@@justsuzy321because she's young and the idol industry is harmful. it would be cruel to stop her now since she's worked so hard and she clearly had the talent to back it up. but she is very young and its super scary watching her not have a normal childhood. but she really wants this so, i think we should support her
There has been some criticism, but only by people who are saying there has been criticism, and by some worried fans, most of us live Kaylee, and wouldn’t want her to be in a different group
When we first saw her on A2K everyone was like hell no not a 12 year old! But she captured everyone's hearts with her talent and dedication so most of us have accepted it at this point lol
Ah yeah let's enable this toxic and wrong behavior bc "she is actually so talented and sweet and deserves to debut" go ahead and keep enabling companies to profit of these young children what the actual hell is wrong with people. There is SO MUCH wrong with this.
It's not her they're criticizing. Any 12-16 year old would sell their soul to be famous and loved and potentially wealthy. It's the company they're criticizing because adults are supposed to be really careful when it comes to child stars
Honestly the problem I have with debuting minors aren't the minors themselves, it's the fact that there are so many creepy "fans" so we as consumers and fans just need to protect them as much as we can
the fans are like the least of your worries. in a patriarchal society, industries are run by men seeking profit and you know the lengths people go through to make as big a profit as they could. not only them, but the girls could grow up in an environment that normalize or even encourage sexualization in order to succeed
She's 14 and she's a teenager. It's not the same as saying she's 12 when that's the age of a kid. Many idols debuted at that age just like Hyein, Jungkook and so on
@@heesqnwon So? Why do should kids under 18 even debut?! They should at least finish high school first. Just because other idols debut young, doesn’t mean we should continue that trend
Being 14 or 15 does not make any difference, the company could wait and train her until she's old enough to debut, the world isn't ending tomorrow, and it wasn't her decision to debut asap, no child or teen is ready for everything that comes with fame and mostly in the kpop industry, sometimes not even adults are, so it isn't a good decision for the companies to make to debut a kid, they only do for profit for themselves.
@@Ndoeliciousthe only name in this comment section that actually debuted at 13. For more: boA, Haeun of lapillus, April’s maknae, Marcus of Hori7on, and many members of Busters. Still don’t make it right though
Being 14 does not make any difference, she's still a minor, and yes, she wanted, it's her dream, but the company could wait and train her until she's old enough to debut, the world isn't ending tomorrow, and it wasn't her decision to debut asap, no child or teen is ready for everything that comes with fame and mostly in the kpop industry, sometimes not even adults are, so it isn't a good decision for the companies to make to debut a kid, they only do for profit for themselves.
@@forer1906 I see where you’re coming from and all, but SHE was the one who wanted to audition for A2K. Besides, she’s on hiatus and she will probably be attending a k pop idol school or at least A school if she’s in America or any other country. The company could’ve waited, but she did get picked, she’s turning 15 soon and she’ll be a little older and will be able to handle this pressure. She has managers and things like that, so they will guide her as well as the other members and idols, and the company.
I’ve never been a fan of debuting minors. Kaylee is so talented but I still think she’s too young. Boa debuted around her age and she said she didn’t wish for other kids to do that and she wished for a normal childhood.
@@wonyoungoveryou exactly why this industry should not debut minors as often as it’s happing today. It gets more and more common and it’s disgusting because these companies KNOW how dangerous it is for minors. They just like to exploit children
Not Camilla. Plus I bet they debut sometime after kaylee’s birthday and Lexus will be 18 by then. But yeah I wish they held off even the predebut until later. There’s already been a 13 year old (Marcus of hori7on that debuted this year) but he’s born in august and is at least 14 now so yay? Still feel horrid about that. Plus there’s yet another 13 year old debuting (she’s like a few weeks older than Kaylee but still Nov born) in October, plus choco which is comprised of all 2008-2010s is actively promoting rn and there was a November 09 who debuted in a Thai group about a month ago. And Indonesian grouo is about to debut rn and all members are born May 2009-almost May 2010. Everyone’s 13-14. We need a law to raise the minimum age cause pls 13 is such a little kid (as someone who was crazy immature at 13)
Kaylee is 14 turning 15 in 2024, kg is 16 turning 17, savanna is 17 turning 18 (so is kendall), lexi is 18 turning 19, and camila is 18 tunring 19 too.
Doesn't make any difference, I don't think any minors should debut, this industry is not safe for anyone, much less for a kid or teen who is not ready.
Not that it matters but she’ll be 14 by the time they debut. Which is still too young imo but every large company that i know of has debuted a 14 yr old so i hope we can spread out the criticism. Also, we should be talking about child actors too
KAYLEE ISNT 14 YET WHEN HYEIN WAS 14 HAERIN WAS 15 SO SHE EASILY FIT IN AS THERE WAS ONLY 1 YEAR GAP HERE KG IS 3 YEARS OLD THAN KENDALL JUST IMAGINE BEING IN THE SAME GROUP WITH 4 PEOPLE OF YOUR AGE AND A 13 YEAR OLD CHILD SAME WITH CHIQUITA SHE IS 14 AND RORA IS 15 ONLY 1 YEAR GAP SO SHE EASILY FIT IN + CHIQUITA IS MATURE ENOUGH TO BECOME KPOP IDOL + HYEIN HAS EXPERIENCE IN THIS INDUSTRY AS SHE WAS FAMOUS BEFORE DEBUT KAYLEE IS LITERALLY A LITTLE GIRL SHE CAN'T COPE UP IN THIS TOXIC INDUSTRY WHEN YOURE AND IDOL YOU GET HATE NO MATTER WHAT YOU DO IM NOT HATING ANYONE BUT SHE LITERALLY WOULD START CRYING ANYTIME SHE DOESN'T FIT IN THE GROUP AND LOOKS LIKE A LOST CHILD EVEN THE GROUP BOND WON'T BE STRONG WITH SUCH A BIG GAP PROBLEM ISNT HER AGE IT IS THE AGE GAP EVEN IF ONE MEMBER WAS 13-14 SHE WOULD FIT IN
They literally told Natty she couldn’t be in Twice because she was too young (11) and then 8 years later he goes and debuts a 13 year old Edit: I looked them up because I wanted to know more and after learning of her age I’m not supporting them until she is 16. And yes I’m serious I’m not even supporting NJ. I’m ok with supporting a group where the youngest is 16 but 13-14 is WAAAAY to young for such an intense industry. Way too many groups are losing members and too many idols are developing severe anxiety
13 is too young but you dont criticize the girl, you criticize the company and the industry. Giving hate to the girl that has already debuted is unproductive and harmful
bro she was 12 during auditions, now shes 1month away from being 14... are people ok do they not know the whole process was 1.5 yrs about there and in one of the episodes jyp lietrally said smt along the lines of "you're officially 13 now right?" then kaylee said yes like gurl that means shes at least 13 people need to watch the show
Although she’s the youngest of the group she’s the most stable vocalist and I could literally feel the idol sparkles from her when she was in A2k They really need to take care of them as they should. I hope nothing bad will happen to them
@@oscaraguayo8065her bday is Nov 22, 2009. She'll be 14 in 2 months. They won't be debuting until 2024. So She'll be around Hyein age in NewJeans. 14 is still young, but if you'd followed her. She's smarter and more mature than most 19 yo Americans.
The concern for her age at the time was understandable, but you also have to considering she willingly went through the audition process and was selected due to her talent and potential. If JYP had chosen not to select her solely due to her age, it could be seen as ageist. So there's drawbacks on either side of the coin. Regardless, I'm really proud of Kaylee and all of the members and i'm so happy to see how far they've come in such a short time already.
KAYLEE ISNT 14 YET WHEN HYEIN WAS 14 HAERIN WAS 15 SO SHE EASILY FIT IN AS THERE WAS ONLY 1 YEAR GAP HERE KG IS 3 YEARS OLD THAN KENDALL JUST IMAGINE BEING IN THE SAME GROUP WITH 4 PEOPLE OF YOUR AGE AND A 13 YEAR OLD CHILD SAME WITH CHIQUITA SHE IS 14 AND RORA IS 15 ONLY 1 YEAR GAP SO SHE EASILY FIT IN + CHIQUITA IS MATURE ENOUGH TO BECOME KPOP IDOL + HYEIN HAS EXPERIENCE IN THIS INDUSTRY AS SHE WAS FAMOUS BEFORE DEBUT KAYLEE IS LITERALLY A LITTLE GIRL SHE CAN'T COPE UP IN THIS TOXIC INDUSTRY WHEN YOURE AND IDOL YOU GET HATE NO MATTER WHAT YOU DO IM NOT HATING ANYONE BUT SHE LITERALLY WOULD START CRYING ANYTIME SHE DOESN'T FIT IN THE GROUP AND LOOKS LIKE A LOST CHILD EVEN THE GROUP BOND WON'T BE STRONG WITH SUCH A BIG GAP PROBLEM ISNT HER AGE IT IS THE AGE GAP EVEN IF ONE MEMBER WAS 13-14 SHE WOULD FIT IN
Because 12-14 is not a good age to debut when you are that age you are not mentally strong enough to be an idol especially cause 12+ hours of training+ school and the constant hate body shaming and sometimes even hyper sexualization that is not good for anyone under the age of 18 that isn’t even good for people over 18
She’s 14 now. And she worked hard to be where she is. Minor or not, her dedication shows her maturity. Unlike most 12 years old these days. Or even millennials these days.
We know that other people also debuted young, but that was years ago, now this is happening again, but its even worse because of the industry THIS TIME and how they are so toxic..
Bro, kaylee is literly a kid, as much as a like these groups songs, I just hope they don’t do ‘sexy concepts’ ANYTIME SOON! Also, I hope none of the memebrs wear super revealing outfits without consent!
i was so happy when i saw Kaylee tho bc in that one part when she was so sad and cried in front of everyone and besides her age im glad she made it and if i stan her group shell most likely be my bias
I think if something happens to her it's his fault honestly, whether she's aged since it's started they shouldn't put fame on a 2 year old. I mean have y'all seen clips of groups at airports, it's not safe for a 12 year old or 16 year old
honestly the members of vcha chose this opportunity and jyp saw that they were talented individuals so they chose them, and it would be stupid for the, to choose older but less talented members so the mebers did choose this path so no need for unnecessary hate.
Many other groups had like younger girls and boys she's 14 now even if she's a child she loves dancing and singing if she loves to do it she well work hard for it and she did she probably had thought about the creeps and she's very strong so I don't even know why people would be that worried like she already has debut so she can't just leave bc of some people
“Mature” the same thing creepy adult men say to teenagers? A teenager should be able to have moments where they don’t have to be mature and have the pressure of millions of people on their shoulders.
She is not mature at all. She is very childish and naive! You could see it through the whole show. Gina for example was around the same age but was mentally much further than Kaylee! Kaylee even cried after minor criticism on her voice... she is still a child and just started hitting puberty let's not forget that..
Most 13 yo kids in America are lazy and don't want to do anything except sit home and play games all day. Their parents encourage this and then complain that their kids are 20 and still living at home. If my 13 yo tells me they want to be an idol and are willing to dedicate 12 hrs a day training to fulfill that dream, I'd be so proud I'd cry.
I dont agree with you. The reasons most 13 yo stay home because their parents didnt put them in activities and not willing to pay for extra curricular activities. If the American parent are willing to pay extra curricular classes after school like Machester soccer which cost USD$500 per month, then the child have activities to participate in.
I love Kaylee! I think she’s extremely talented and one of the most vocally strong members of their group tbh. It’s funny because people will criticize this when Unis current day has a 12 year old member and nobody gives a shit, meanwhile Kaylee was 12 when the show was filmed but she’s older now
Alot of people didnt know that KG what already a artist in the singer industry so idk why she debut with vcha if she had alot of fame already bc cause of her ex asher
Guys, she's like 13/14 she was 12 only when the show started . It's really annoying when ur don't really think abt how the show was filmed a year ago 🙂
Most popular singers started out at the same age, in america as well like Chris Brown, Michael Jackson, if this is her dream, i say she takes this opportunity
I Love Kaylee and so does most of the general public I’m pretty sure, but I think it would’ve been smarter for the company to keep her as a trainee and debut her in a future group, especially since she is fluent in Korean and English.
She debut at 14 and also Lim Seowon debuted at 13 and just turned 13 a few day before debut but no one is bothered ik she is known by many Koreans and stuff but I mean
Im not hating on the group or nothing but i hope shes okay and can handle all the stress... i think people are just worried about her but others just use it as a way to hate on the group, im older than her and even i cant imagine being in such a tough industry, and its so weird to me how people are saying that since shes 14 its okay or that they shouldn't be worried when thats still so young? 🥲 and overall i think people should be concerned because so many minors are debuting (especially ggs), i just wish people could see that by saying stuff like "shes too young" were not trying to slander the girls or undermining their dedication, they are simply too young, its a tough industry no 12,13,14 year old should be in.
To be honest, this show was filmed long ago so kaylee is now 14 if I’m right
No bc the year they went to Korea was 2023 and she said she turned 13 so she’s 13 right now
@@ASA._.BABYMONS7ER_STAN.she'll turn 14 in November though and they'll be debuting next year officially
🤷🏼♀️Why does it matter so fkn much??
Yeah it doesn’t really matter and she’s practically a teen so 🤷♀️ and it was her own choice
@@justsuzy321because she's young and the idol industry is harmful. it would be cruel to stop her now since she's worked so hard and she clearly had the talent to back it up. but she is very young and its super scary watching her not have a normal childhood. but she really wants this so, i think we should support her
I don’t think they have gotten that much backlash… most of the public loves kaylee so let’s not try to start problems 😅
There has been some criticism, but only by people who are saying there has been criticism, and by some worried fans, most of us live Kaylee, and wouldn’t want her to be in a different group
When we first saw her on A2K everyone was like hell no not a 12 year old! But she captured everyone's hearts with her talent and dedication so most of us have accepted it at this point lol
Ah yeah let's enable this toxic and wrong behavior bc
"she is actually so talented and sweet and deserves to debut"
go ahead and keep enabling companies to profit of these young children
what the actual hell is wrong with people. There is SO MUCH wrong with this.
"not to start". No need to. Debuting a 14 year old already is.
It's not her they're criticizing. Any 12-16 year old would sell their soul to be famous and loved and potentially wealthy. It's the company they're criticizing because adults are supposed to be really careful when it comes to child stars
Honestly the problem I have with debuting minors aren't the minors themselves, it's the fact that there are so many creepy "fans" so we as consumers and fans just need to protect them as much as we can
the fans are like the least of your worries. in a patriarchal society, industries are run by men seeking profit and you know the lengths people go through to make as big a profit as they could. not only them, but the girls could grow up in an environment that normalize or even encourage sexualization in order to succeed
at least vcha seems it for a kids based audience and the outfits and songs are not too mature for them
Guys it actually happened to Kaylee recently today she doesn’t deserve this 😢.
@@XxNatureFairyxX what happened??
I totally agree with you
She'll be 14 in November.
No she Turned 13 This august
@@itzyxxxmidzy8864 Her birthday is November 24, 2009 so she'll be 14.
@@itzyxxxmidzy8864the programm was pre recorded so when she said that she turnes 13 was a year ago her birthday is in novemeber
I thought she just turned 13???
Nvm I forgot this was filmed a year ago she will be turning 14 this year
This show was filmed LAST YEAR so that means kaylee is nearly 14
She was was 12 at the time which is very clearly said in one of the a2k episodes
@@Ipromiseyounobodyismadyeah? 12 last year in October and her birthday is in November, so she's turning 14 this year
14 isn't any better. That is TOO young.
Thats still young tjo
@@raiinzyylike at all
"oh she's close to 14" AND?! ☠️
Fr 💀
ATLEAST THATS A TEENAGER UNLIKE ENA WHO WAS A CHILD
@@Miraculous_sooyaabugstill so young tho
She's 14 and she's a teenager. It's not the same as saying she's 12 when that's the age of a kid. Many idols debuted at that age just like Hyein, Jungkook and so on
@@heesqnwon So? Why do should kids under 18 even debut?! They should at least finish high school first. Just because other idols debut young, doesn’t mean we should continue that trend
The show was filmed in advance. On the show she was 12 but when the episodes came out she was 13 and by the time she debuted she already turned 14.
she isn’t twelve guys she was fucking 14 and now she’s 15. she just went on the show at 12
shes not 15 she will turn 15 november 24th
In Korea age she’s considered 14-15
Being 14 or 15 does not make any difference, the company could wait and train her until she's old enough to debut, the world isn't ending tomorrow, and it wasn't her decision to debut asap, no child or teen is ready for everything that comes with fame and mostly in the kpop industry, sometimes not even adults are, so it isn't a good decision for the companies to make to debut a kid, they only do for profit for themselves.
Literally wonyoung debuted at 13 years old
Sakura...
Hyein
No she was 14 even on the finale of pd48
@@chqq80Hyein was 14 and 3 months
@@Ndoeliciousthe only name in this comment section that actually debuted at 13. For more: boA, Haeun of lapillus, April’s maknae, Marcus of Hori7on, and many members of Busters. Still don’t make it right though
y’all saying she’s almost fourteen like that makes it better- that’s a CHILD
Fr bro
Fr like it’s not that my of a difference
K-pop has always debuted kids that age
Nobody has a problem when its NewJeans
@@Blue777Dragon ppl actually did have a problem with that...
She’s 14, and she was the one who wanted to be an idol.
Being 14 does not make any difference, she's still a minor, and yes, she wanted, it's her dream, but the company could wait and train her until she's old enough to debut, the world isn't ending tomorrow, and it wasn't her decision to debut asap, no child or teen is ready for everything that comes with fame and mostly in the kpop industry, sometimes not even adults are, so it isn't a good decision for the companies to make to debut a kid, they only do for profit for themselves.
@@forer1906 I see where you’re coming from and all, but SHE was the one who wanted to audition for A2K. Besides, she’s on hiatus and she will probably be attending a k pop idol school or at least A school if she’s in America or any other country. The company could’ve waited, but she did get picked, she’s turning 15 soon and she’ll be a little older and will be able to handle this pressure. She has managers and things like that, so they will guide her as well as the other members and idols, and the company.
I’ve never been a fan of debuting minors. Kaylee is so talented but I still think she’s too young. Boa debuted around her age and she said she didn’t wish for other kids to do that and she wished for a normal childhood.
Oh... I actually didn't know she said that... That's sad...
BoA also said she has PTSD (or anxiety disorder, I forget) from all the s*xualisation she received from a young age.
@@wonyoungoveryou exactly why this industry should not debut minors as often as it’s happing today. It gets more and more common and it’s disgusting because these companies KNOW how dangerous it is for minors. They just like to exploit children
And many ppl with normal childhoods wish they’re famous and rich
@@bash547 thank you for saying exactly what I just said
almost* every single member is a minor 💀
i forgot i made this comment ☠️
No camila is 18 so she’s legally an adult
yes like haerin from new jeans
Just like felix when he debuted.
Not Camilla. Plus I bet they debut sometime after kaylee’s birthday and Lexus will be 18 by then. But yeah I wish they held off even the predebut until later. There’s already been a 13 year old (Marcus of hori7on that debuted this year) but he’s born in august and is at least 14 now so yay? Still feel horrid about that. Plus there’s yet another 13 year old debuting (she’s like a few weeks older than Kaylee but still Nov born) in October, plus choco which is comprised of all 2008-2010s is actively promoting rn and there was a November 09 who debuted in a Thai group about a month ago. And Indonesian grouo is about to debut rn and all members are born May 2009-almost May 2010. Everyone’s 13-14. We need a law to raise the minimum age cause pls 13 is such a little kid (as someone who was crazy immature at 13)
@@HongJiah_Soloistnot in Korea the age of majority is 19
Kaylee is 14 now so that should be fine bc those same netizens supported hyein when she was 14
she isn't 14 yet
@@xoxoaliyahz but she's close
@@ancii2541 it doesn't matter currently shes still 13
@@xoxoaliyahz bro it dosen't matter if shes 14 or close to 14
@@ancii2541 it does because your spreading the wrong info
Kaylee is 14 turning 15 in 2024, kg is 16 turning 17, savanna is 17 turning 18 (so is kendall), lexi is 18 turning 19, and camila is 18 tunring 19 too.
Doesn't make any difference, I don't think any minors should debut, this industry is not safe for anyone, much less for a kid or teen who is not ready.
Not that it matters but she’ll be 14 by the time they debut. Which is still too young imo but every large company that i know of has debuted a 14 yr old so i hope we can spread out the criticism. Also, we should be talking about child actors too
KAYLEE ISNT 14 YET WHEN HYEIN WAS 14 HAERIN WAS 15 SO SHE EASILY FIT IN AS THERE WAS ONLY 1 YEAR GAP HERE KG IS 3 YEARS OLD THAN KENDALL JUST IMAGINE BEING IN THE SAME GROUP WITH 4 PEOPLE OF YOUR AGE AND A 13 YEAR OLD CHILD SAME WITH CHIQUITA SHE IS 14 AND RORA IS 15 ONLY 1 YEAR GAP SO SHE EASILY FIT IN
+ CHIQUITA IS MATURE ENOUGH TO BECOME KPOP IDOL
+ HYEIN HAS EXPERIENCE IN THIS INDUSTRY AS SHE WAS FAMOUS BEFORE DEBUT
KAYLEE IS LITERALLY A LITTLE GIRL SHE CAN'T COPE UP IN THIS TOXIC INDUSTRY WHEN YOURE AND IDOL YOU GET HATE NO MATTER WHAT YOU DO IM NOT HATING ANYONE BUT SHE LITERALLY WOULD START CRYING ANYTIME
SHE DOESN'T FIT IN THE GROUP AND LOOKS LIKE A LOST CHILD
EVEN THE GROUP BOND WON'T BE STRONG WITH SUCH A BIG GAP PROBLEM ISNT HER AGE
IT IS THE AGE GAP EVEN IF ONE MEMBER WAS 13-14 SHE WOULD FIT IN
They literally told Natty she couldn’t be in Twice because she was too young (11) and then 8 years later he goes and debuts a 13 year old
Edit: I looked them up because I wanted to know more and after learning of her age I’m not supporting them until she is 16. And yes I’m serious I’m not even supporting NJ. I’m ok with supporting a group where the youngest is 16 but 13-14 is WAAAAY to young for such an intense industry. Way too many groups are losing members and too many idols are developing severe anxiety
This!! Kaylee is barely entering her teen years. She's not old enough to deal with everything that happens to K-pop groups like hate and solo stans.
i believe Natty was 13 during sixteen
Also Kaylee was 12 when a2k was filmed...
@@anarecinos1590and Kaylee is now on hiatus, so we have won for now!
Don't idols get a choice to debut? Let's just be happy for her and not spread any form of hate (I know this isn't a hate video)
Been a vlight since far before debut ❤
Love u vcha 🥹🤩🥳
First of all Kaylee is 15 yrs old not 12 you've must've watched one episode when she was 12 the key word is WHEN SHE WAS ok miss
13 is too young but you dont criticize the girl, you criticize the company and the industry. Giving hate to the girl that has already debuted is unproductive and harmful
They are all so beautiful I love them ❤❤❤
JYPAPI TO NATTI: YOU ARE TOO YOUNG TO DEBUT
JYPEE TO KAYLEE: PACK YOUR BAGS, YOU'RE GOING TO KOREA
She's 14 now tho
bro she was 12 during auditions, now shes 1month away from being 14... are people ok do they not know the whole process was 1.5 yrs about there and in one of the episodes jyp lietrally said smt along the lines of "you're officially 13 now right?" then kaylee said yes like gurl that means shes at least 13 people need to watch the show
Kaylee is the most popular one her fancam has the most views
So what? This doesn't justify her being just too young for this industry
Although she’s the youngest of the group she’s the most stable vocalist and I could literally feel the idol sparkles from her when she was in A2k
They really need to take care of them as they should. I hope nothing bad will happen to them
Bro the ages are wrong everyone is atleast a year older Kaylee 13 camila 18 kg 16 Kendall 16 lexi 17 savanna 17
kaylee is 14
@@niyatiyen no she’s 13 in the teen vogue interview they have her age as 13
@@niyatiyen and the interview is from September 21 of this year
@@oscaraguayo8065her bday is Nov 22, 2009. She'll be 14 in 2 months. They won't be debuting until 2024. So She'll be around Hyein age in NewJeans.
14 is still young, but if you'd followed her. She's smarter and more mature than most 19 yo Americans.
@@tuanv5418 I’m not talking about when they debut in talking about now with Y.O.Universe promotions bc people keep saying she’s 12 when she’s 13
The concern for her age at the time was understandable, but you also have to considering she willingly went through the audition process and was selected due to her talent and potential. If JYP had chosen not to select her solely due to her age, it could be seen as ageist. So there's drawbacks on either side of the coin. Regardless, I'm really proud of Kaylee and all of the members and i'm so happy to see how far they've come in such a short time already.
So they will not grow up? I’m confused by the hate!
They should have debuted when they were adults, or at least 17.
KAYLEE ISNT 14 YET WHEN HYEIN WAS 14 HAERIN WAS 15 SO SHE EASILY FIT IN AS THERE WAS ONLY 1 YEAR GAP HERE KG IS 3 YEARS OLD THAN KENDALL JUST IMAGINE BEING IN THE SAME GROUP WITH 4 PEOPLE OF YOUR AGE AND A 13 YEAR OLD CHILD SAME WITH CHIQUITA SHE IS 14 AND RORA IS 15 ONLY 1 YEAR GAP SO SHE EASILY FIT IN
+ CHIQUITA IS MATURE ENOUGH TO BECOME KPOP IDOL
+ HYEIN HAS EXPERIENCE IN THIS INDUSTRY AS SHE WAS FAMOUS BEFORE DEBUT
KAYLEE IS LITERALLY A LITTLE GIRL SHE CAN'T COPE UP IN THIS TOXIC INDUSTRY WHEN YOURE AND IDOL YOU GET HATE NO MATTER WHAT YOU DO IM NOT HATING ANYONE BUT SHE LITERALLY WOULD START CRYING ANYTIME
SHE DOESN'T FIT IN THE GROUP AND LOOKS LIKE A LOST CHILD
EVEN THE GROUP BOND WON'T BE STRONG WITH SUCH A BIG GAP PROBLEM ISNT HER AGE
IT IS THE AGE GAP EVEN IF ONE MEMBER WAS 13-14 SHE WOULD FIT IN
It's about what age they are when they debut... 12 year olds are just not able to deal with the hate and responsibility.
Because 12-14 is not a good age to debut when you are that age you are not mentally strong enough to be an idol especially cause 12+ hours of training+ school and the constant hate body shaming and sometimes even hyper sexualization that is not good for anyone under the age of 18 that isn’t even good for people over 18
There has been a lot of companies who actually debuted younger girls in girl groups!
She’s 13 now the show was filmed last year she was born November 24th 2009
She’s 14 now. And she worked hard to be where she is. Minor or not, her dedication shows her maturity. Unlike most 12 years old these days. Or even millennials these days.
she's still 13
“These days” 😭😭😭
@@niyahjohnson8643she'll turn 14 this november
No shes 13 it was filmed last year when she was 12 which was CLEARLY stated in one of the episodes
her birthday is in november 2009 so basically she is 14 this year
@@Ipromiseyounobodyismad
She worked so hard to get where she is she shouldn't get thrown out because she's too young
We know that other people also debuted young, but that was years ago, now this is happening again, but its even worse because of the industry THIS TIME and how they are so toxic..
and so have many other idols debuted at such a young age. people just find ANYTHING to complain ab.
Dude this is what she wanted she chose to do this...
They are bashing Kaylee of debuting young not knowing that unis maknae is younger than Kaylee and she is the youngest kpop idol
NO SHE İS 14
she is 13 and turning 14 November 24
They need to listen to her vocals because Kaylee (in my opinion) is one of the best singers in the group!
She is 2009 like chiquita from babymonster
Imo the idols who debuted in a young age chose to debut it’s their choice
First of all it was her choice to join the addition and in her journey you can see how hard she was working just so she can get debuted
She was 12 when they were getting ready for the real day of when they become kpop superstars and now she's 14
Why is everyone commenting other young idols who debuted at 13/14 like that makes this any better 💀 stop normalising this it's depressing
Real like she’s one month younger than me plus she is capable of a lot of things just because ppl r young doesn’t mean that they r not prepared
Bro, kaylee is literly a kid, as much as a like these groups songs, I just hope they don’t do ‘sexy concepts’ ANYTIME SOON!
Also, I hope none of the memebrs wear super revealing outfits without consent!
i was so happy when i saw Kaylee tho bc in that one part when she was so sad and cried in front of everyone and besides her age im glad she made it and if i stan her group shell most likely be my bias
No she turned 15 in the lastyear now she will be 16 in 2024❤
"vee-chaah"
I think if something happens to her it's his fault honestly, whether she's aged since it's started they shouldn't put fame on a 2 year old. I mean have y'all seen clips of groups at airports, it's not safe for a 12 year old or 16 year old
Tbh they worked hard so if they debut they know they could handle it although they are young they work hard so just support them or ignore them
It’s not JYPs fault tho- it’s her parents that let her sign up, so why is that JYPs fault?💀…
honestly the members of vcha chose this opportunity and jyp saw that they were talented individuals so they chose them, and it would be stupid for the, to choose older but less talented members so the mebers did choose this path so no need for unnecessary hate.
Kaylee was selected because of her outstanding cuteness, performance and mostly her vocal ,JYP told her that she was BORN to be a K-pop star ❤
People will forget about this within 2 weeks. That's why companies keep on doing this
Many other groups had like younger girls and boys she's 14 now even if she's a child she loves dancing and singing if she loves to do it she well work hard for it and she did she probably had thought about the creeps and she's very strong so I don't even know why people would be that worried like she already has debut so she can't just leave bc of some people
She didn't debut at 12 she was 12 at the a2k in one episode she turned 13 she debuted at 13
Well you know f*ck the haters
I’m sure that not many care
There have been many many talented debuts of a similar age
Some are big stars
If the girl wants to follow her dream let her follow her dream
She’s not 12 she’s 13
14 now, I think...
Okay
She's turning 15 this year
Oh okay
케일리 너무귀엽고 예뻐요 😍👍👍✌️✌️👍✌️😍❤️🙏🙏
People act like JYP forced her to join and held her hostage. She auditioned for it, she wanted to join.
She is there because she is focused, mature and her parents support her. Get over it and wish the group well!
“Mature” the same thing creepy adult men say to teenagers? A teenager should be able to have moments where they don’t have to be mature and have the pressure of millions of people on their shoulders.
She is not mature at all. She is very childish and naive! You could see it through the whole show. Gina for example was around the same age but was mentally much further than Kaylee! Kaylee even cried after minor criticism on her voice... she is still a child and just started hitting puberty let's not forget that..
Its not about age though its about your TALENT and you are proud to ur self Who u really are,Kaylee as a great talent even though she is 12
she’s nearly 14 a2k was filmed over a year ago
kaylee was 13 by ep 16 of a2k
people be like "BUT IT'S HER DREAM" when her dream should start at 9 pm on weekdays because she has school
Most 13 yo kids in America are lazy and don't want to do anything except sit home and play games all day. Their parents encourage this and then complain that their kids are 20 and still living at home.
If my 13 yo tells me they want to be an idol and are willing to dedicate 12 hrs a day training to fulfill that dream, I'd be so proud I'd cry.
totally agree!!
I hope you arent talking about your own kids😭
Shes 13
I dont agree with you. The reasons most 13 yo stay home because their parents didnt put them in activities and not willing to pay for extra curricular activities. If the American parent are willing to pay extra curricular classes after school like Machester soccer which cost USD$500 per month, then the child have activities to participate in.
They train just to get exploited sexualized online, and bullied by the internet. Wtf...
Kaylee is my bias since a2k until now and we are the same age
I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again, I don’t think anyone understand the age of 16 should start training to be an idol or debut.
I love Kaylee! I think she’s extremely talented and one of the most vocally strong members of their group tbh. It’s funny because people will criticize this when Unis current day has a 12 year old member and nobody gives a shit, meanwhile Kaylee was 12 when the show was filmed but she’s older now
Me watching people my age debating as k pop idols while I am doing nothing with my life 💀💀💀💀👹
BoA debuted when she was 13 under SM entertainment. Tzuyu debuted when she was 13 with Twice. Nothing new
Tzuyu debuted when she was 15(almost 16)
I wonder how they were training since 2 years cuz it was made like at 2022
Tbh they shouldn’t worry bc she’s 14 now 🫶
She is younger than me and has already debuted what am i doing w my life 😢
Alot of people didnt know that KG what already a artist in the singer industry so idk why she debut with vcha if she had alot of fame already bc cause of her ex asher
If she were debut she would be my bias
Ok but the pronounce "kay le le" 😭
Like its her choice she wants to be a k-pop idol at this age rn shes 13 turning 14 in nov like its her choice stop hating on her choice!!
shes not 12 shes 14, turning 15 this year
Guys, she's like 13/14 she was 12 only when the show started . It's really annoying when ur don't really think abt how the show was filmed a year ago 🙂
Most popular singers started out at the same age, in america as well like Chris Brown, Michael Jackson, if this is her dream, i say she takes this opportunity
Tbh she is one of the best and my fav
Why are people mad she wants to be an idole and he is giving her career
Kaylee is 2009 so (even though she’s still young)she’s 14 and will turn 15 in 2024
kaylee is actually 13, turning 14 in 2 days, and they haven't debuted yet too
I Love Kaylee and so does most of the general public I’m pretty sure, but I think it would’ve been smarter for the company to keep her as a trainee and debut her in a future group, especially since she is fluent in Korean and English.
12 DID THAT SYA TEWELVE
So hold up JYP is getting criticized bc half of vcha are minors…. What about the other 90% of grips that are mostly if not fully minors
She's one year older than me
She’s older than me too
I don’t mind her debuting, but I just can’t get over how young she looks. She could pass for a tween.
Kaylee is 15 this year I did my research and she was born in 2009
She debut at 14 and also Lim Seowon debuted at 13 and just turned 13 a few day before debut but no one is bothered ik she is known by many Koreans and stuff but I mean
Kaylee is now14
Im not hating on the group or nothing but i hope shes okay and can handle all the stress... i think people are just worried about her but others just use it as a way to hate on the group, im older than her and even i cant imagine being in such a tough industry, and its so weird to me how people are saying that since shes 14 its okay or that they shouldn't be worried when thats still so young? 🥲 and overall i think people should be concerned because so many minors are debuting (especially ggs), i just wish people could see that by saying stuff like "shes too young" were not trying to slander the girls or undermining their dedication, they are simply too young, its a tough industry no 12,13,14 year old should be in.
Yes kaylee is 14 this coking november this show was long time ago...
SHES 13!!!!!!!!!!!