Keypoints and results from the video: 1. The blue one claims to remove waterproof makeup while the pink one doesn't 2. The blue one leaves her face oily 3. Neither one removes every sign of makeup 4. The pink one is better for fixing mistakes while doing makeup 5. All in all, she chose the pink one! Hope was helpful :)
It actually says on the back to remove eye makeup: hold pad over closed eyes for a few seconds THEN gently wipe. Maybe that will help you get more of the mascara off
The pink one is my favorite. I'm on my 7th bottle now, it works so well. I like using this first to take off my face and eye makeup, then I'll go in with exfoliators or cleansers to get deep into the skin and to get off whatever is left. Also the value of the product is amazing for the price you pay. Funny story actually, I'm in Atlantic City now and I literally brought everything with me except this micellar water😭 My face feels so incomplete.
yes it's amazing for the price. I'll buy this over and over before bioderma.. if only it had the pump that bioderma has (kinda like the makeup remover pumps in sephora) and ahhhh that's crazy.. they sell it all over the place, just be careful where you go. hope you have fun!! maybe one of the times your here in AC we'll run into each other!
I'm I the only one in pain by seeing her rubbing her skin in wrong directions? Ladies please, gentle movements in and out from chin to forehead in upward motion!
So I asked my mom to buy the one with the pink one and I thought the only difference is that the pink one is for gentle but still removed but I didn’t know it wasn’t for WATERPROOF mascara and I always wear waterproof mascara
Great comparison video! I've used the blue top one for years and never knew exactly what would make the pink top one any different. Now we know! I haven't used any soaps and haven't washed my face with anything except this micellar water/regular warm water from the tap + my fingers. The blue-capped bottle removes my thick, dark eye makeup effortlessly and without rubbing--so for that kinda action I am willing to put up with that strange oily feeling. Protip: To get rid of the oily feeling the blue capped one leaves just grab another 100% cotton pad and swoop it over the "oily" areas to blot it off. I'll then put fresh moisturizers/makeup on right away. :D
jump scare foxy im not sure whether this helps or not, but if u read the ingrediets, the blue one has alcohol denat which can cause dryness. However, the pink one suits for every type of skin actually.. It doesnt apply to sensitive skin only. Hope that helps 😄
im using the blue one.in my place pink is for sensitive skin and blue is for oily skin.my skin is oily skin so i pick blue. so far i love it😍it doesnt make my skin more oily and it remove my make up really well
I've only used the blue one and it doesn't even take off regular mascara. I soak a cotton pad, let it sit against my eye for 10 seconds and then wipe. The cotton pad is still white after I use it. Only gets off mascara and SOME liquid matte lipsticks. It sucks.
I personal like the blue bottle because it removes waterproof mascara (which I wear every time I go out) And I have a mixture of oily and prone skin. The cleanser is the first thing I use for my face, then I use a different facial cleanser, and then a skin brighting daily scrub with moisturizer. And I’ve noticed a big difference in my face... my skin in almost clear now:)
Got that Garnier Pink Micellar water and it really helps my sensitive skin. I suggest that pink one if you have an acne- prone skin. It leaves your skin so soft and smooth after every use. The other good thing about it is, its very affordable price. Thank you for the review about the difference between the two. Now I am not so curious about the use of the blue one. More power! =)
I’m so glad you did this video! I originally tried the green one for sensitive skin. I just ran out , so I bought the blue. I do not like the oil either . !!!! And I didn’t notice the oil at first.
I find the pink one dries my face out. My skin immediately turns red and looks like I have Rosacea. I don't have that problem with the blue one. I do have dry skin, so I guess the oil is not a problem for dry skin. My sister bought blue and doesn't like it, so we'll trade bottles. She has oily skin. So pink would be better for her. Thanks for the info.
Wait why does it matter if it's oily or not. You're gonna wash your face afterwards.??? Plus where you wearing waterproof mascara or just regular mascara???
The difference listed on the bottle is so subtle you can't even see it! I bought the blue originally...HATED IT! Had to use a facial cleanser and astrigent afterward to get that slimy feeling off my face... The pink leaves my skin feeling clean...love it! #TeamMicellarPink
I NEED HELP. From what i know the pink one is for sensitive skin. My skin is not sensitive and I'm currently using the blue one. A lot of ppl recommended the pink one. Should i change into the pink one? 😭
But....it's not oil. It's a moisturizing agent. I get what what you're saying though. It does feel different than the pink one...it feels like you've moisturized your skin after the blue one but with the pink it feels just like after you've cleansed your skin. Ya feel me?? It's definatly not oil though. Js
In the UK the pink one is for sensitive skin and the blue bottle is for dry skin Pink: £5 Blue: £6 There are so many different ones there are: Anti blemish Sensitive Oily Combination Charcoal range as well
Love the blue for winter time I need that extra hydration cause I get super dry skin cause of the weather and I do lotion and butter masks as well to keep my skin sane if I don't do a mask before I go to sleep I will regret it the next morning! But will switch over to pink in the summer time due to the fact I sweat a lot cause of the crazy humidity in VA, VA as extreme climate changes and I hate it! I wake up with an oily face and oil thru out the day sucks even light lotions trigger oil I basicly have to use nothing I hated using sunblock for that same oily reason but suck it up now cause Im treating my complexion and don't want the sun to reverse all the hard work and money I spent, I have to change my lotions, body wash, face cleansers and some of my make up with the weather, I don't mind cause I love trying different stuff tho
Thank you. You answered my question re: the pink and the blue bottles. Was going to by the blue because of being water proof but you saved me from making that mistake. Well done!!
The pink on only kinda smears my eye makeup, it wont take it off :(. Im not about to scrub my skin raw Also, you should be washing your face after u “cleanse” it with the micellar water or any makeup remover.... so i prefer the blue one for everyday tho the pink cap is better for fixing mistakes while putting on makeup
you may like it better.. it's not too oily if you shake it. It leaves your face feeling very smooth and moisturized.. but just a TAD more moisturized than I personally like lol
Thank you for this video I've been debating between these two bottles for so long and I trust your review (for both this video and the Garnier vs Bioderma) so again thank you for the review and helping me with solidifying my choice to get the pink bottle. I also saw that Garnier came out with makeup removal wipes by any chance have you tried them yet?
No problem.. So glad I can help people with my videos!! I had no idea they were coming out with wipes.. I'm going to the drugstore tomorrow to find them.
just a random question cause i am freaking out lol i ordered this online: Does it come with a seal or its just like that with a cap? I am worried its used or something. lol
Everyone has different skin types. If you have dry skin use the one that will moisturize your skin.. If you have oily skin use the one that is not oily on your skin. I use the micellar wipes along with the water and it comes off quick. Pads suck. Try the wipes instead of the pads. It will clean your skin
It says that the blue bottle, have alcohol content so I stick to the pink one because my mom said that avoid using cleanser that have alcohol in it. Great review!
The pink one has alcohol in the ingredients and the blue one does not. The blue one is also oil free. Which is why I purchased the blue one. The RUclipsr should have compared them by ingredients.
It’s did at first for me too. I just use a face cloth to gently wipe the excess oil away and my skins feels so soft after. After using it for about two weeks it’s been better. I wonder if it’s pulling oil out because my pores seem smaller and I have way less sebaceous filament. Sorry that’s gross but true haha
I have the blue lid and it dries my skin out terribly. I already have dry skin so I thought the blue one would be ok since it says for all skin types, even sensitive. I think I’m going to try the pink one.
The blue one has "Denat Alcohol" :( I should have purchased the pink one. Your face may feel oily after using the blue because your face secretes more oil after the alcohol wipes out your skin's natural moisture.
😎Yes pink one I say thanks to my Daughter I brought my first own bottle today Thank You 😘Daughter & Thanks For your review I just finish washing my face for tonight with it TBH Lol! 😎💯
Probably maybe because you didn’t press you have to press then slide it off when your takin off your mascara I use the blue one and I don’t wear waterproof but it does a good job of taking Matte lipsticks off as well
i hate the blue one i was so mad when i realized it wasn’t the same as the pink lol i just thought the tops were different colors 🙄 i got another pink one as well the blue one is just sitting
+Patricia San Jose nah, just a quick make up remover. If you use a toner right after using the micellar cleansing water, you'll still see makeup come off. It doesn't give the same benefits a toner does
@@feliciarivera4297 yes use toner after the micellar water ladies and gents. And it is not solely a makeup remover. You can use it as a cleanser or a cleanser booster. It will get rid of every last bit of dirt and oil on the skin if you use it properly. I've yet to see anyone use it properly on youtube!! 😂 It's a "CLEANSING WATER" that is also great at removing makeup.
Keypoints and results from the video:
1. The blue one claims to remove waterproof makeup while the pink one doesn't
2. The blue one leaves her face oily
3. Neither one removes every sign of makeup
4. The pink one is better for fixing mistakes while doing makeup
5. All in all, she chose the pink one!
Hope was helpful :)
In Australia the pink lid is for sensitive skin, the blue lid is for acne prone combo skin and the green lid is for oily skin :)
Belinda Kelly same in the philippines, that is why i got the blue cap one
Belinda Kelly thanks ur commant
What if you have all 3?
In the US my blue bottle says all skin types and sensitive. Haven't tried pink one.
I have all three 😭
When I tried the blue one, I instantly loved the oil. I can have a pretty dry face so it’s helped soften it and removes my makeup fantastically.
Girl u barely wiped your eye once with the blue one😂 that’s why there was no difference
It actually says on the back to remove eye makeup: hold pad over closed eyes for a few seconds THEN gently wipe. Maybe that will help you get more of the mascara off
The pink one is my favorite. I'm on my 7th bottle now, it works so well. I like using this first to take off my face and eye makeup, then I'll go in with exfoliators or cleansers to get deep into the skin and to get off whatever is left. Also the value of the product is amazing for the price you pay. Funny story actually, I'm in Atlantic City now and I literally brought everything with me except this micellar water😭 My face feels so incomplete.
yes it's amazing for the price. I'll buy this over and over before bioderma.. if only it had the pump that bioderma has (kinda like the makeup remover pumps in sephora) and ahhhh that's crazy.. they sell it all over the place, just be careful where you go. hope you have fun!! maybe one of the times your here in AC we'll run into each other!
Farzana F. Does it takes mascara?
I'm I the only one in pain by seeing her rubbing her skin in wrong directions? Ladies please, gentle movements in and out from chin to forehead in upward motion!
ENIA 😱
Kai Stiles no! That will cause faster aging
"I apply so much mascara" um hunny no you dont, I didnt even know you were wearing mascara.
I know 😭💀
😂😂right
Why be rude though?
So I asked my mom to buy the one with the pink one and I thought the only difference is that the pink one is for gentle but still removed but I didn’t know it wasn’t for WATERPROOF mascara and I always wear waterproof mascara
Great comparison video! I've used the blue top one for years and never knew exactly what would make the pink top one any different. Now we know! I haven't used any soaps and haven't washed my face with anything except this micellar water/regular warm water from the tap + my fingers. The blue-capped bottle removes my thick, dark eye makeup effortlessly and without rubbing--so for that kinda action I am willing to put up with that strange oily feeling. Protip: To get rid of the oily feeling the blue capped one leaves just grab another 100% cotton pad and swoop it over the "oily" areas to blot it off. I'll then put fresh moisturizers/makeup on right away. :D
I have the blue one and it works really well it helps my skin too cause it is dry af
jump scare foxy im not sure whether this helps or not, but if u read the ingrediets, the blue one has alcohol denat which can cause dryness. However, the pink one suits for every type of skin actually.. It doesnt apply to sensitive skin only. Hope that helps 😄
True, i mistakenly bought the blue one, it makes my skin became dried.
im using the blue one.in my place pink is for sensitive skin and blue is for oily skin.my skin is oily skin so i pick blue. so far i love it😍it doesnt make my skin more oily and it remove my make up really well
The blue ones my favorite it cleared up my skin
I use the Blue one cause, I have dry & oily skin. It really helps balance out my skin texture.
I use the pink one because it works for me but i have the same skin type
Would be nice to see how the blue one works on "waterproof makeup" as that is what it is labeled for?
+poepoejankins good idea! I️ can def do video on that
Pink one doesn’t take off waterproof mascara well and blue one takes it off right away !
I've only used the blue one and it doesn't even take off regular mascara. I soak a cotton pad, let it sit against my eye for 10 seconds and then wipe. The cotton pad is still white after I use it. Only gets off mascara and SOME liquid matte lipsticks. It sucks.
I personal like the blue bottle because it removes waterproof mascara (which I wear every time I go out) And I have a mixture of oily and prone skin. The cleanser is the first thing I use for my face, then I use a different facial cleanser, and then a skin brighting daily scrub with moisturizer. And I’ve noticed a big difference in my face... my skin in almost clear now:)
Got that Garnier Pink Micellar water and it really helps my sensitive skin. I suggest that pink one if you have an acne- prone skin. It leaves your skin so soft and smooth after every use. The other good thing about it is, its very affordable price. Thank you for the review about the difference between the two. Now I am not so curious about the use of the blue one. More power! =)
yes you are not missing anything with the blue one!!! Stick to the pink one =)
I’m so glad you did this video! I originally tried the green one for sensitive skin. I just ran out , so I bought the blue. I do not like the oil either . !!!! And I didn’t notice the oil at first.
I find the pink one dries my face out. My skin immediately turns red and looks like I have Rosacea. I don't have that problem with the blue one. I do have dry skin, so I guess the oil is not a problem for dry skin. My sister bought blue and doesn't like it, so we'll trade bottles. She has oily skin. So pink would be better for her. Thanks for the info.
The pink is for sensitive skin
Wait why does it matter if it's oily or not. You're gonna wash your face afterwards.??? Plus where you wearing waterproof mascara or just regular mascara???
Martha Perez in the video she said she was wearing normal mascara
It said on the bottle that you don’t have to rinse your face afterwards
FreakishPlumLB thats gross. U should wash your face regardless. Thats just a marketing tactic
XIIxMysticxIIX right cause i exfoliate and stuff afterwards to get off whatever is left that i can’t see.
The difference listed on the bottle is so subtle you can't even see it! I bought the blue originally...HATED IT! Had to use a facial cleanser and astrigent afterward to get that slimy feeling off my face...
The pink leaves my skin feeling clean...love it!
#TeamMicellarPink
I NEED HELP. From what i know the pink one is for sensitive skin. My skin is not sensitive and I'm currently using the blue one. A lot of ppl recommended the pink one. Should i change into the pink one? 😭
Christina Sciblo thank you!! Ily😂❤
+DahlyaQistina your welcome😘😘 love you too!
Drama queen
@@kayburutsa8739 what hahaha
Thank you I’m returning the blue one tomorrow
It’s my first time to use the pink one. Is it really soapy?
Do i have to wash my face after using?
no, it says no rinse off
I'd still rinse, then add moisturizer.
But....it's not oil. It's a moisturizing agent. I get what what you're saying though. It does feel different than the pink one...it feels like you've moisturized your skin after the blue one but with the pink it feels just like after you've cleansed your skin. Ya feel me?? It's definatly not oil though. Js
In the UK the pink one is for sensitive skin and the blue bottle is for dry skin
Pink: £5
Blue: £6
There are so many different ones there are:
Anti blemish
Sensitive
Oily
Combination
Charcoal range as well
Kay Burutsa hello, could u tell me what color for anti blemish?
Love the blue for winter time I need that extra hydration cause I get super dry skin cause of the weather and I do lotion and butter masks as well to keep my skin sane if I don't do a mask before I go to sleep I will regret it the next morning! But will switch over to pink in the summer time due to the fact I sweat a lot cause of the crazy humidity in VA, VA as extreme climate changes and I hate it! I wake up with an oily face and oil thru out the day sucks even light lotions trigger oil I basicly have to use nothing I hated using sunblock for that same oily reason but suck it up now cause Im treating my complexion and don't want the sun to reverse all the hard work and money I spent, I have to change my lotions, body wash, face cleansers and some of my make up with the weather, I don't mind cause I love trying different stuff tho
Thank you. You answered my question re: the pink and the blue bottles. Was going to by the blue because of being water proof but you saved me from making that mistake. Well done!!
I love the oil because it feels moisturizing
The pink on only kinda smears my eye makeup, it wont take it off :(. Im not about to scrub my skin raw
Also, you should be washing your face after u “cleanse” it with the micellar water or any makeup remover.... so i prefer the blue one for everyday tho the pink cap is better for fixing mistakes while putting on makeup
Love this video, you went straight to the point.
Hmm I wonder if I would like the blue one better just because I have really dry skin
you may like it better.. it's not too oily if you shake it. It leaves your face feeling very smooth and moisturized.. but just a TAD more moisturized than I personally like lol
I have dry skin and I love to use the blue one because it makes my face so smooth
Thank you for this video I've been debating between these two bottles for so long and I trust your review (for both this video and the Garnier vs Bioderma) so again thank you for the review and helping me with solidifying my choice to get the pink bottle. I also saw that Garnier came out with makeup removal wipes by any chance have you tried them yet?
No problem.. So glad I can help people with my videos!!
I had no idea they were coming out with wipes.. I'm going to the drugstore tomorrow to find them.
definitely the pink bottle!!
100%
I love the blue one so far
Blue ones my fave, and it'd more "oily" bc its meant to take off waterproof mascara to break it down..so yeah..
I just bought this and now I’m second guessing if I should keep it
+RUclips Account which one did you get?
I just bought the pink one so im searching for review. Thanks 🙏🏻😊
Pink- sensitive skin
Blue- oily skin and acne prone skin
And I have a sensitive, oily and acne prone skin
Help me
jack Espinosa you should use the green one!!
HaHAHAHAHHAHA
just a random question cause i am freaking out lol i ordered this online: Does it come with a seal or its just like that with a cap? I am worried its used or something. lol
It had a plastic seal around the top
thanks
wait mine didn’t have a seal...
Damn I wish I watched this before I bought the blue one
I purchased the pink one yay! ❤
Everyone has different skin types. If you have dry skin use the one that will moisturize your skin.. If you have oily skin use the one that is not oily on your skin. I use the micellar wipes along with the water and it comes off quick. Pads suck. Try the wipes instead of the pads. It will clean your skin
In the UK pink is for sensitive skin, blue is acne prone or combo skin (I think) and green is oily skin
yes!! this is the kinda review I need!!
It says that the blue bottle, have alcohol content so I stick to the pink one because my mom said that avoid using cleanser that have alcohol in it.
Great review!
The blue one says directly on the front no alcohol fragrance or oil
The pink one has alcohol in the ingredients and the blue one does not. The blue one is also oil free. Which is why I purchased the blue one. The RUclipsr should have compared them by ingredients.
Does pink work with waterproof makeup
I just tried the blue because my store was out of simple. I hate the feeling of oil :( threw the whole bottle away
anyone else cringe when she scrubbed around her eye?
I recently purchased the blue one, makes my face super oily.
It’s did at first for me too. I just use a face cloth to gently wipe the excess oil away and my skins feels so soft after. After using it for about two weeks it’s been better. I wonder if it’s pulling oil out because my pores seem smaller and I have way less sebaceous filament. Sorry that’s gross but true haha
I have the one with the green lid., I think they are all the same
hey if you still use this green lid one, it contains alcohol which is very harsh on the skin
Rachel Montiel But other commenters have been saying the different lid covers either mean sensitive skin, acne prone skin, oily skin, dry skin etc
They're definatly NOT all the same!! There's that little thing on the back of the bottle called an "Ingredient List"...You should try reading it. Js ✌
I have the green one too
I’ve tried all of the different ones. My favorite is the blue top. I have drier skin,that’s why I prefer the blue top.
I have the blue lid and it dries my skin out terribly. I already have dry skin so I thought the blue one would be ok since it says for all skin types, even sensitive. I think I’m going to try the pink one.
really?! wow the blue one I thought was so oily. definitely don't try the green one then lol. pink one seems pretty generic
Christina Sciblo well fudge. Lol. Thanks girl. I will try & let ya know how it goes. 😝
pink one is for sensitive skin. at the bottom of the bottle it says sensitive skin. :)
They both say for sensitive skin actually...lol
The blue one has "Denat Alcohol" :(
I should have purchased the pink one. Your face may feel oily after using the blue because your face secretes more oil after the alcohol wipes out your skin's natural moisture.
😎Yes pink one I say thanks to my Daughter I brought my first own bottle today Thank You 😘Daughter & Thanks For your review I just finish washing my face for tonight with it TBH Lol! 😎💯
Am I the only one who’s tried both and the pink bottle gets very soaping almost?!?!
I have the blue one and it does not work on water proof mascara. Every time I use the blue one it does not work.
Is Garnier good for facewash or ponds
Blue is for waterproof mascara and such.
I love the pink one. I am going back to it soon. Plus the pink one does not make my face ichy like the blue one.
Yes the pink one if the best!
Nice just what I was looking for . Thanks for the recommendation 😋 definitely buying the pink one jeje
yessss the pink bottle!! can't go wrong
Thanks so much for this. Didn't know. I just subscribed. ♡
How well does it takes out the masacara?
I have hem both and the pink removes the mascara better the the blue
Hello yung garnier po ba pang tanggal pimples?
She can't understand tagalog girl
Probably maybe because you didn’t press you have to press then slide it off when your takin off your mascara I use the blue one and I don’t wear waterproof but it does a good job of taking Matte lipsticks off as well
I have the pink one using it as a gentle toner after cleaning face but before moisturizing it
What if my skin is not sensitive and not dry
What should I do?😂
I apply the yellow 💛 one it's vitamin c
i hate the blue one i was so mad when i realized it wasn’t the same as the pink lol i just thought the tops were different colors 🙄 i got another pink one as well the blue one is just sitting
Why do my micellar water smell like alcohol
can i use this as a toner?
nah not a toner.
I've gotta try these! I never have...
It's the best drugstore makeup remover!!
The pink one is so much better. I could tell that your face seemed red and you had mascara still on with the blue one.
Can this be used as a toner?
+Patricia San Jose nah, just a quick make up remover. If you use a toner right after using the micellar cleansing water, you'll still see makeup come off. It doesn't give the same benefits a toner does
Try the Dickinson or Thayers witch hazel toner, it’s natural and doesn’t make your skin dry or irritated. It’s a holy grail product for me.
Crystal Robateau I almost purchased them but they had alcohol in them
Ashley Carriger Dickinsons has a Hydrating Alcohol-Free Witch Hazel. Has hyaluronic acid in it 😊
I hate the pink one but love the oil one ( the gold cap) will be trying the blue one
the blue one didn’t take my mascara off either!! and trust me I TRIED
NIVEA micellar water is the best!!!
My favourite is the yellow one it has vitamin C hard to come by.
I have the yellow one now 🙌🏼 when this video was made there were only two
the blue top is for all types of skin/sensitive.
the pink top is for oily skin.
at least that’s what it says, and yes the blue is for waterproof too!
Pink one doesn’t even touch my mascara 😭
Pink ❤️😍
The blue one is much better
They sell the micellar blue bottle at the 99 cent store for $2.99 get ya product cheaper ladies.
Is it normal for it too separate
Oil and water don't mix. That's why they are separated.
The blue one has alcohol denat lol
If you have a good moisturizer it should be fine.
I like the pink one
I just came here to say you look a bit like Ana de Armas
is it safe for pregnant
I would ask your doctor but I had used when I was pregnant. Again check with your doc
I didn't realize they sold these 😲
Ohhhhh girl, don't run downward on your face like that. Remember gravity is working against you all the time even if you can't see its effects yet!
📝
Ah ngomong naon teu kaharti abi mh😭
can you use this as a toner?
Rebecca Bryant no
+Rebecca Bryant no bc if you apply a toner after this you'll see how much junk still comes off your face. It's just meant for removing makeup.
ahh I used it to remove my powder and foundation and it did amazingly well
Christina Sciblo do you suggest using toner after the micellar water?
@@feliciarivera4297 yes use toner after the micellar water ladies and gents. And it is not solely a makeup remover. You can use it as a cleanser or a cleanser booster. It will get rid of every last bit of dirt and oil on the skin if you use it properly. I've yet to see anyone use it properly on youtube!! 😂 It's a "CLEANSING WATER" that is also great at removing makeup.