evolution of jack white playing fell in love with a girl live (2001-2018)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 июн 2021
  • he doesn't play this song as much as I thought he did, also he likes to mess around with this song's structure live a lot which made this a lot harder to make
    Twitter / clancularius9
    Twitch / orbisclancularius
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 178

  • @djfibonacci
    @djfibonacci 2 года назад +523

    Only took 17 years to come full circle

    • @johnnysunshine5007
      @johnnysunshine5007 2 года назад

      Stop being a wannabe Jew. Seriously. Full circle does not make you cool.

    • @Death6701
      @Death6701 2 года назад +14

      @@johnnysunshine5007 yikes man, didn’t need to say that.

    • @austin5944
      @austin5944 2 года назад +7

      @@johnnysunshine5007 bye bye nazi

    • @Zolbat
      @Zolbat 2 года назад +4

      Well, you're in your little room
      And you're working on something good
      But if it's really good
      You're gonna need a bigger room
      And when you're in the bigger room
      You might not know what to do
      You might have to think of how you got started
      Sitting in your little room

    • @redlaserfox3988
      @redlaserfox3988 2 года назад

      Only took SevenTeen years for a crowd to sing half ass??
      bares repeating now

  • @nestycb6702
    @nestycb6702 2 года назад +220

    At some point in his life he went: okay, but make it jazzier

    • @NicoNicoNOOO
      @NicoNicoNOOO 2 года назад +10

      Everyone in their lifetime will at some point look at something they've made and think "okay but make it jazzier"

    • @jimdeadlock
      @jimdeadlock 2 года назад

      too jazzy? ruclips.net/video/SSmNn0wYinQ/видео.html

    • @wilsonsilva2918
      @wilsonsilva2918 2 года назад +2

      That point is called 2012

  • @CIRCLEOFTONE
    @CIRCLEOFTONE 2 года назад +204

    Funny seeing him fall into the Sting/Roxanne trap near the end where Sting plays it slower with a lute with a damn jazz band behind him.

    • @ricardojmestre
      @ricardojmestre 2 года назад +3

      Best comment

    • @CIRCLEOFTONE
      @CIRCLEOFTONE 2 года назад

      @@ricardojmestre Cheers! You Jack White fans may like this video I did on his guitar sound ruclips.net/video/LCVZmvxESYc/видео.html

    • @walley2637
      @walley2637 2 года назад +3

      I think its because after playing it half a million times artist want to reinvent it. he played as a 2 piece so much its a wonder he hasn't gone out with an orchestra behind him at least once.

  • @C0ltrane
    @C0ltrane 2 года назад +261

    It’s good slow but def way better at its original tempo

  • @ryansim7818
    @ryansim7818 2 года назад +540

    Its the evolution of the guy that says "I can change and mature" to his wife, years go by..the kids grow and one day BOOM he's back in the garage with his buddies just rocking out drinking beer.

  • @Bloodray19
    @Bloodray19 2 года назад +880

    He tries to add comlexity to a song that was meant to be simple. It's not bad and it's not a problem, but it will lack that raw energy from the original record

    • @zechs5079
      @zechs5079 2 года назад +156

      You play the same song every night for 20 years straight and tell me that you don't want to switch it up occasionally.

    • @littledaddi3
      @littledaddi3 2 года назад +22

      He changes a song he wrote to how he wants to play it* Ftfy

    • @Bloodray19
      @Bloodray19 2 года назад +28

      @@zechs5079 I understand your point and considered it as well before commenting. It's his song, so he can do whatever he wants, I just say that the beauty of this song was the rawness

    • @s-dew
      @s-dew 2 года назад +8

      @@Bloodray19 in 2018 he played it the same, he only sometimes switched it up.

    • @nestycb6702
      @nestycb6702 2 года назад +2

      It is quite literally his song

  • @Daplin1
    @Daplin1 2 года назад +89

    Damn people let the man have fun with his song lol

    • @KevinSmith-ys9sw
      @KevinSmith-ys9sw 2 года назад +2

      Right? Honestly...
      "Every time I'm doin' what I want to
      Somebody comes and tells me it's wrong
      Whenever I'm doin' just as I please
      Somebody cuts me down to my knees
      Yeah, somebody cuts me down to my knees"

    • @bahnadumitru.5864
      @bahnadumitru.5864 Год назад +1

      @@KevinSmith-ys9sw where is this from?

    • @TheSASUKENerds
      @TheSASUKENerds Год назад +1

      @@bahnadumitru.5864 Entitlement off of Lazaretto

  • @kettch42
    @kettch42 2 года назад +113

    Seems like they got better at micing his amp over the years.

    • @williamblank2213
      @williamblank2213 2 года назад +3

      The guitars he used in the beginning were pretty rough guys. He liked to play cheapo ones that sounded different. More expensive guitars towards the end. Cool note; pretty sure he's playing St. Vincent's guitar line that she designed in last clip

  • @sam_i_am6410
    @sam_i_am6410 2 года назад +80

    Miss Meg. I could watch her drum forever

    • @DeFiSiYT
      @DeFiSiYT 2 года назад +18

      Yep, I miss her too... I hope she's happy doing whatever she's doing wherever she is...

    • @beauxba_ti
      @beauxba_ti 10 месяцев назад

      @@DeFiSiYT some friends visited her last christmas she's just kinda chilling rn

  • @chriscms3399
    @chriscms3399 2 года назад +176

    My favorite part is “bobby said its fine he don’t consider it cheating now” i like its accent

    • @s-dew
      @s-dew 2 года назад +2

      It's?

    • @chriscms3399
      @chriscms3399 2 года назад +21

      @@s-dew I have no respect for this language

    • @Ojos_TV__
      @Ojos_TV__ 2 года назад +1

      Aguante fugitivo pancho

    • @chriscms3399
      @chriscms3399 2 года назад +1

      @@Ojos_TV__ ánimo Chris! Soy tu fans, FUGITIVO PANCHO ES LA LUUUZ!

    • @s-dew
      @s-dew 2 года назад

      @@chriscms3399 lol ok, but hes a dude.

  • @torugolago
    @torugolago 2 года назад +51

    So basically he started breathing between words

  • @RaphaelBriand
    @RaphaelBriand 2 года назад +184

    "I hope Jack plays a quiet, expansive jazz version of FILWAG" said fucking nobody

  • @MrBrodman98
    @MrBrodman98 3 года назад +27

    Love the video! Good work!

  • @thomashooper2649
    @thomashooper2649 2 года назад +5

    Can’t wait to see him live again

  • @waveemann8857
    @waveemann8857 2 года назад +8

    Truly don't even know why I clicked on this but seeing Carla Azar on drums at the end made it worth it

  • @FreddieFirth
    @FreddieFirth 2 года назад +2

    This is a video that needed to be made!

  • @linebeck1381
    @linebeck1381 2 года назад +25

    I’m sure a reason for him changing it is that you get sick of playing it after all these years

  • @aidensaroka7268
    @aidensaroka7268 2 года назад +11

    Love that so much

  • @corwinwickersham1860
    @corwinwickersham1860 3 года назад +3

    Well done!

  • @alwaysxnever
    @alwaysxnever Год назад +2

    I love these variations. Take into account his maturity and other factors.

  • @ryanashby2481
    @ryanashby2481 2 года назад +24

    Fell in love with the white stripes when I wad 10, in 2011, turns out they were playing my favourite songs the year I was born. Feels so weird but I guess that's life, wish I could've seen them live

    • @sojirokaidoh2
      @sojirokaidoh2 2 года назад +1

      It's a beautiful thing to connect with people before your time through their art. As the great Vladimir Horowitz once wrote: "Styles change, forms change, but feelings never change."

  • @joekimberlin264
    @joekimberlin264 2 года назад +12

    Sometimes you just nail it on the first go ;) nice edit 👍

  • @jonathansteadman7935
    @jonathansteadman7935 2 года назад +35

    I know that playing the same song night after night, year after year can get tiresome, but that's just the nature of being a successful musician. The Stones seem to manage it, while still sounding contemporary. Personally I associate the Airline guitar with the sound of this song, it's more quirky.

  • @MrKaden1217
    @MrKaden1217 3 года назад +4

    From reddit great video

  • @carlwhissel7557
    @carlwhissel7557 3 года назад +12

    2002 ftw

  • @fredhasopinions
    @fredhasopinions 2 года назад +23

    Shhh the “jazzy” version slaps, it’s just not really the same song and I see why OG rock fans wouldn’t like it.

  • @izzy1349
    @izzy1349 2 года назад

    Whats the 2018 one from

  • @teleman2157
    @teleman2157 2 года назад

    Love the guitar tone in the above video from 2007

  • @abandonalex1846
    @abandonalex1846 2 года назад +41

    Can we all agree that Meg is a better drummer then Lars

    • @bauhaund7935
      @bauhaund7935 2 года назад +8

      I love meg but I think that's definitely debatable

    • @JoMan2909
      @JoMan2909 2 года назад +3

      definitely not... XD

    • @clappingpig
      @clappingpig 2 года назад +1

      *than not then...

    • @abandonalex1846
      @abandonalex1846 2 года назад +2

      @@bauhaund7935 i mean hes the richest drummer in the world but can't even keep a steady beat even after like over 30 years of playing

    • @bornamovafaghi6075
      @bornamovafaghi6075 2 года назад +9

      Lars is my hero, he's the reason I chose to learn the guitar.

  • @sergiocardozo2875
    @sergiocardozo2875 3 года назад

    How I love

  • @Xyz-zu8wp
    @Xyz-zu8wp 2 года назад +1

    2018, Really the most peak performance in his journey..!!

  • @markperrine501
    @markperrine501 2 года назад +2

    Should have named the video “a few times Jack White played Fell In Love With a Girl differently”

  • @chrisjeffries367
    @chrisjeffries367 2 года назад +7

    I miss the white stripes :(

  • @christovrea4273
    @christovrea4273 2 года назад +1

    Think about how boring it would be to play that song the same way for 20+ years. True artist here

  • @michaelmarrs958
    @michaelmarrs958 2 года назад +12

    Is it just me or have me gotten pretty bad at recording live performance in past few years?

    • @crackermuncher3869
      @crackermuncher3869 2 года назад +1

      I think he is doing great right now imo at least he is finding passion for it again but for a while it kinda seemed like he was losing the spirit

    • @SixteenJacobsCreams
      @SixteenJacobsCreams 2 года назад +1

      I think it's just that the first few are professionally filmed and the last one is on somebody's phone. Obviously back in 2002 Fell in Love With a Girl was their biggest hit, these days he has a much bigger catalog of songs to pick from. There just aren't so many pro recordings of that song now.

  • @lukeedwardson7527
    @lukeedwardson7527 2 года назад

    anyone know the 2012 performance

  • @thisguy916
    @thisguy916 2 года назад +1

    2018: the year jack white turned into jack black

  • @krissgerhardt4815
    @krissgerhardt4815 2 года назад +53

    The longer he goes on for, the more of that edge he loses. Maybe that’s all part of getting older, but I swear the more simplistic he was, the better the art was

    • @The890venom
      @The890venom 2 года назад +5

      He can always come back to it, but that’s why the white stripes was simple. Because Meg was an okay drummer and the man knew how to play guitar so he worked simplicity into his writing. Jack White is a blues rock man who takes blues rock and hard rock, it’s maybe not as good. But that’s what he pushed himself towards cause as he has said he feels like a preacher when he makes music spreading his gospel. He’s done with alt rock but it’s never lost. There is only so much to write after 20 years heh but I think boarding house reach was great personally. The white stripes stays as is and is engrained forever but as an artist that’s limiting.

    • @brandonmcgraw1873
      @brandonmcgraw1873 2 года назад +2

      @@The890venom Done with alternative rock? What do you think help us stranger was?

    • @The890venom
      @The890venom 2 года назад +1

      @@brandonmcgraw1873 okay he’s not done with it but it’s also not his main focus musically. That is clearly evident with his solo career, plus uh that album was okay…so it’s clear to see that his simplicity of the alternative genre has done better in the past. The dead weather is also alternative so I guess I’m just half wrong. Oh well I still think he has mostly wanted to make more complex arrangements rather than your basic 4 chord shimmy.

    • @daveshif2514
      @daveshif2514 2 года назад +1

      He IS more experimental but id say in a good way despite any setbacks. Could be worse, he could be billie cordon

    • @The890venom
      @The890venom 2 года назад

      @@daveshif2514 you are right there good sir.

  • @johnpomeroy6931
    @johnpomeroy6931 2 года назад +5

    interesting how the rhythm change gave the whole thing a whole new feel. then it turned like all jazzy/folky? idk but the phrasing of the lyrics changed in a really cool and interesting way

  • @thraft
    @thraft 2 года назад +139

    Jack shouldve stayed with the two piece, keep the energy raw; just my opinion

    • @dubnessIII
      @dubnessIII 2 года назад +9

      I hope he at least sticks with a three piece he played with on SNL in 2020

    • @AA-rc8sm
      @AA-rc8sm 2 года назад +23

      Meg probably didn't wanna keep playing with him.

    • @battousai12
      @battousai12 2 года назад +1

      @@AA-rc8sm yep, she is shy and lacks interest in music

    • @brianmcawesome
      @brianmcawesome 2 года назад +21

      That's what he wants. He's said multiple times he wants to do the Stripes but Meg doesn't.

    • @AA-rc8sm
      @AA-rc8sm 2 года назад +5

      @@battousai12 Yeah it seems like that. If she ever played music in public again, that'd be without him.

  • @barryfreed6868
    @barryfreed6868 2 года назад +3

    give me meg or give me deatj

  • @VTRDC27
    @VTRDC27 2 года назад +42

    God forbid an artist try something new.

  • @TheMNeko
    @TheMNeko 2 года назад +1

    2003 is very Zeppelin-esque and I love it!

    • @dansaunders1655
      @dansaunders1655 2 года назад

      His voice is definitely more Plantish than usual

  • @edwardssistershands
    @edwardssistershands 2 года назад

    How does the quality get worse as the years go on? Blame cell phones.

  • @viaplaysguitar
    @viaplaysguitar 2 года назад

    Meg

  • @Codemarla
    @Codemarla 2 года назад +1

    Loving that jazz version. So smooth.

  • @SummerRainBand
    @SummerRainBand 2 года назад

    That voice

  • @screenheads3812
    @screenheads3812 2 года назад +2

    Jeeeze, he special editions harder than George Lucas

  • @duvan-solis
    @duvan-solis 3 года назад

    2003... Even properly.

  • @jeffrunge1608
    @jeffrunge1608 2 года назад +1

    Back in 2012, Jack was unaware that Metallica would make a very simular mistake with an orchestra 😂

  • @MrBrodman98
    @MrBrodman98 3 года назад +10

    2005 from Brazil could have been included but amazing work!

  • @wolfgangfalck1250
    @wolfgangfalck1250 2 года назад

    since 2012 something has changed for the better, if I only could point my finge.... ah wait there is a drummer who can actually hold the timing, take away a bit of the rawness adds sophistication I like it.

  • @mateusbez2669
    @mateusbez2669 2 года назад +2

    Love it how he brings back the Stripes era guitar to play the Stripes era version in 2018.

    • @Viper-dz2kw
      @Viper-dz2kw 2 года назад +3

      That’s St. Vincent’s signature, it didn’t even exist when the white stripes were a thing

  • @stevenburgett8828
    @stevenburgett8828 2 года назад

    He still trys to give signals to the new drummers QQ D,:

  • @chljurado
    @chljurado 4 месяца назад

    I miss Meg

  • @supercloud6643
    @supercloud6643 2 года назад

    I think 2003 is my favorite

  • @pedrodaguiar5865
    @pedrodaguiar5865 2 года назад

    Things spoil with time.

  • @jmongmon1100
    @jmongmon1100 Год назад

    Devolution

  • @richb3326
    @richb3326 2 года назад +10

    loses its charm year by year. man he needs meg.

  • @Spaghettaboutit
    @Spaghettaboutit 2 года назад +3

    So it got worst and lost the spirit of the song? Got it!

  • @fireman5419
    @fireman5419 2 года назад

    It his song. He can play it any fucking way he wants to…. Doesn’t mean I have to like it! Hahahhaaa

  • @deadleg6
    @deadleg6 2 года назад +3

    How many dudes do you think came on Jack White's face for him to become so pale?

    • @buffluffstuff
      @buffluffstuff 2 года назад +10

      You tell us, you seem to be the expert

  • @Slavik__Kot
    @Slavik__Kot 2 года назад

    Коло замкнулося

  • @876r876rf
    @876r876rf 2 года назад

    02' was best

  • @colettecolette4292
    @colettecolette4292 2 года назад +1

    Jack do whatever it takes! Bring Meg back! White Stripes Forever!!

  • @geoschilling
    @geoschilling Год назад +1

    Not much of an evolution, that would be him playing every 2-3 years: you went all the way to 2012 then 2018

  • @XleofmelloX
    @XleofmelloX 3 месяца назад

    onde está a evolução ? so vi piorar!

  • @dynaboyjl.4220
    @dynaboyjl.4220 2 года назад

    I'm not saying I have any problems with Jack White, but that little fake-blues shimmy he does at 1:08 while looking like a freaking KISS member made me understand why people think Jack White is a dipshit.

  • @PlaguePriest88
    @PlaguePriest88 2 года назад

    Why does everyobody keep saying 2012 version is jazz. It sounds nothing like jazz, its more like something rootsy/folkish

  • @bkkurls1666
    @bkkurls1666 2 года назад

    I thought it was cool that he was playing a st Vincent music man.

  • @choosmusic9676
    @choosmusic9676 2 года назад +2

    Nice genetics

  • @angusmcnay5449
    @angusmcnay5449 2 года назад +1

    *degradation and restoration

  • @HBMediaFilms
    @HBMediaFilms 2 года назад +1

    The last great rock genius

  • @seregarus4638
    @seregarus4638 2 года назад +1

    просто постарел как и мы :( но играть хуже не стал!!!!:)

  • @notenoughpancakes6149
    @notenoughpancakes6149 2 года назад

    I mean it must get boring playing 5 chords in repeat

  • @artonion420
    @artonion420 2 года назад +1

    Yet another great example of that Jack White peaked in 2002

    • @artonion420
      @artonion420 6 месяцев назад

      Took the words right out of my mouth

  • @MIKEPOZISVLOGS
    @MIKEPOZISVLOGS 2 года назад

    Can we go back to the early 2000s

  • @francisslam1457
    @francisslam1457 2 года назад

    0:44 that Robert Plant voice is on point

  • @bananagumboot87
    @bananagumboot87 2 года назад +1

    If there's one thing I can't stand it's when bands slow down and add jazz elements to their songs live.
    Bowie did this in the 70s and I'm not a fan of it. Play the songs as they're meant to be heard and if you are going to reinvent it make sure its got some energy at least!

  • @theleftysmokes9977
    @theleftysmokes9977 2 года назад +6

    This video should be retitled "How hyperbolical praise inflates the ego"

    • @justaamateur6533
      @justaamateur6533 2 года назад

      What? Why?

    • @theleftysmokes9977
      @theleftysmokes9977 2 года назад

      @@justaamateur6533 because thats what happened to him

    • @SixteenJacobsCreams
      @SixteenJacobsCreams 2 года назад +3

      @@theleftysmokes9977 Eh? He's fucking around with it live pretty early on, and arguably the 2018 one is closest to the original.

    • @theusername2309
      @theusername2309 2 года назад +5

      @@theleftysmokes9977 i don’t think so i think it’s a matter of him having to play this song so much, it gets boring. he probably just wants to mess around with it. don’t think it has anything to do with an ego.

    • @SixteenJacobsCreams
      @SixteenJacobsCreams 2 года назад

      @@theusername2309 Also watching any of their live performances, they were always changing/mashing up their songs even in the early days.

  • @jessewilliams8655
    @jessewilliams8655 2 года назад +13

    1:06 so 2012 is the moment Jack became an insufferable dork

    • @andrewd1788
      @andrewd1788 2 года назад +5

      I'd be raging if I went to that show and he sang it like that

    • @MrEspenFarstad
      @MrEspenFarstad 2 года назад

      @@andrewd1788 Then don't go to gigs.

    • @andrewd1788
      @andrewd1788 2 года назад

      @@MrEspenFarstad 🤔

  • @SuperDukes18
    @SuperDukes18 2 года назад +2

    My favourite part was when he finally stopped singing and playing really badly because the video ended.

  • @undromedariocansado
    @undromedariocansado 2 года назад

    Looks like he just needed a better drummer

  • @LB-tb4st
    @LB-tb4st 2 года назад +2

    Joss Stone ruined this and then he started singing it like her. Kills me.

  • @julianhyde1645
    @julianhyde1645 2 года назад

    Jesus. There was like a whole decade where that song fucking sucked.

  • @alexrtsimpson
    @alexrtsimpson 2 года назад

    As he became a better musician his song became worse. Goes to show. Sometimes with music what comes from the gut is often better than what comes from the head

  • @yummyklown9226
    @yummyklown9226 2 года назад +8

    Got worse as time went on.

  • @fraundakelmbrilpondaprost90
    @fraundakelmbrilpondaprost90 2 года назад

    The studio version is bar none the worst Stripes song and one of the most ear-grating pieces of shit I've ever heard. Thank God he changed it up live.

  • @MrConstant23.
    @MrConstant23. 2 года назад

    The middle was terrible

  • @NarcoticDimension
    @NarcoticDimension 2 года назад

    Took a long time but he never got any talent. Very sad case.

  • @sharonlee4773
    @sharonlee4773 2 года назад

    it aint that great a song

  • @mricardo96
    @mricardo96 2 года назад

    Too many gaps,

  • @noahninetyone
    @noahninetyone 2 года назад

    He’s such a pretentious douche 🙄

  • @johnnysunshine5007
    @johnnysunshine5007 2 года назад

    What is it with the all encompassing full circle dark alley squid hat asses? I'm sorry. Not supposed to say that about girls.... But goddamn if you all don't remind me of a certain toadie from 24 hours of .. whatever.

  • @billymac3638
    @billymac3638 2 года назад +2

    2012 cringe..then again the 10s really were shittest time for music. 20s not looking promising either. Might top myself.

    • @willoverdoseonmusic
      @willoverdoseonmusic 2 года назад +6

      There was wonderful and very great music being put out in the 10s and still being put out now, just have to look deeper.

    • @RepublicOfUs
      @RepublicOfUs 2 года назад +4

      You're either a child, or very old; those are the most common demographics for making dumb statements like that.

  • @guinness1376
    @guinness1376 2 года назад +10

    That song didn't age well

  • @XCenturionX
    @XCenturionX 2 года назад

    Worst "band" ever on planet earth