It’s honestly adorable just how incredibly afraid he is of ever saying something that would hurt people’s feelings or make them feel unwelcome. It’s not to a fault, but whenever he gets a little more uncomfortable than he needs to be it gives the same energy as “werk” from the gay rights and wrongs Reddit react lol
Yeah that wasnt fear and panic, that was supressed laughter and humor because he knew it was gonna be funny due to the hopefully well known fact that it's not actually them who came up with the lines. Like wtf lighten up
Tommy: towering over Shayne Shayne: avoiding eye-contact Tommy: bends down to Shayne's level Shayne: makes eye-contact It's good that the father knows how to talk to his child
Spencer running up there, telling shayne to “Courtney shut up.” Then Shayne getting a DM that says “WHOS ASS IS THAT!” And Chanse following it up with “Yeah because it’s…it’s..its…GAY!!!” Is a smosh moment I will never forget
Amazingly he missed the "show us the shaft" opportunity, with an arrow shaft sticking out of his neck - can't blame him though, he had just been arrow'd in the neck.
3:20 - Hi, Slut 6:15 - Best one liner 10:48 - Insane roast 13:45 - Inspiration 😊 17:30 - Courtney, shut up! 18:42 - Cpt. One Ball 20:30 - Cpt. continued 22:00 - Supporting lgbtq? Loser. 26:04 - Add the flag 28:30 - Closing statements This video was absolute GOLD, I love Smosh Pit Theatre!
I loved it so much when Spencer ran up, read the card that said "Courtney, shut up", and then you could hear Courtney behind the camera laughing their ass off! (edit: it's around 17:38)
Shayne pulling the homophobic DM and just panicking internally about saying it out loud while Tommy and Chanse (the gays [non-derogatory]) looking at each other was so funny.
I love seeing Antony having fun but also being a little confused, like at the end after Spencer says " may I get you pregnant." He's like "I think it's a good thing"
When Tommy started reading all the ways to say "Goldberg" and Shayne said "How do you know everyone at school calls me that?" It felt like drama therapy
@@CuidightheachODuinn Ok, so, since you never got an answer on this, I can help - in the bible, angels are actually described as being non-human and terrifying/incomprehensible, even though we usually imagine them as looking like people. Awhile back, people started posting images they made of "biblically accurate angels" for fun, making them look like many-eyed, many-winged, lovecraft-esque beings, to highlight how terrifying some stuff in the bible actually is. Then, in meme-like evolution of the phrase, people started calling anything that looks like a more horrifying, abstract, and otherworldly version of itself "biblically accurate" as a call back to that idea. So, they're saying Chanse's eyes are "biblically accurate" to imply they are otherworldly, surprisingly scary, and not what you'd expect.
It makes me so unbelievably happy to see Anthony so happy and laughing so hard at everything in everybody else he's in. I think he is genuinely at peace being back at Smosh. This is where he belongs and it's just so great to see him here. I absolutely love seeing him and Ian back together, and don't get me wrong, I would have loved to see Ian in this video, but seeing Anthony alone in this video with the cast members really makes it feel like he's actually back as a member of the team because this is his first video back without Ian in it. So excited for the future of everyone. So happy for Ian and Anthony
@@ChrissaToddshayne mentioned a comment he saw regarding anthony ‘speed running shows’ in a Reddit stories video pretty soon after anthony rejoined- the jokes been overused/dead ever since
Can we mention how good Spencer was? He's the only one in the room who isn't an actor, but he was pretty good at callbacks in his scenes and sticking to the given setting. The others were obvs great too, but Spencer was surprising
Spencer is def the most underrated person in the cast (yes cast, he and Tommy ARE part of the cast 😤) and crew tbh, yes he's very loved for how attractive and cute he is but his deliveries are absolutely HILARIOUS dude, his humor should be way more appreciated than it is
this is why i absolutely love improv, they had people walking in and out of scene so casually, its like they belonged there or had actually walked up to them out of no where
22:45 "Its true." Haha. Tommy and Chanse are always amazing sports with this kind of stuff. Also, calling Anthony a shattered box of ink pens is a potential diss for his funeral roast. 💀
Forgive me if calling someone a "shattered box of ink pens" is a common phrase that's just lost on me, but I can only assume they're talking about his tattoos? Every time a short pops up involving Anthony I see at least one comment talking about how his tattoos look like marker ink lines.
@@-VoDkAsVengeance- Its not a common phrase but it just looks like it since the lines are "splattered" in every direction. Idk I think someone mentioned it first in a video and it sticked since then...a reoccuring joke.
This is the best one of these ever. Some of these were so contextually appropriate, like the date one kept progressing. And then some of them were absolutely nuts. I love how Shayne had to gather strength, apologise to the camera and then read his line
So I guess all the "Where's Anthony?" DMs have turned into "Anthony hire me?" DMs lol
1.1k likes with no comment?
Real
Arasha turning a random crumb tray fact into a motivational speech was next level
And they all went “yeah” to rev her up. It was amazing.
Made me tear up honestly
Fer real dough
24:00 btw
Definity plus withs Shayne's response was amazing
Arasha's toaster tray inspirational speech followed by Shayne's "NOBODY IS REAL" SLAYS ME, dude.
ESPECIALLY THAT MAN BACK THERE! 😭😭
The bit where Shayne pulls "who ass is that?" And Chanse pulling "yeah yeah because it's...GAY" is a top tier Smosh moment
I made the mistake of taking a drink of water at that exact moment...such a big mistake
@@clarisaxpianist classic mistake...
17:54
Yeah, but the “Courtney shut up” definitely added to it! 🤣
@@clarisaxpianist instant try not to laugh for you lol HAHAHAHAH
Ok but why did Arasha and Anthony’s DM conversation make PERFECT sense
Why does Anthony laughs like a goat tho?
because it does!! 😆
I kind of think the slapping your ass with my thighs thing is this iteration's winepepper.
@@FriedSheep69Anthony and Ian both do 😂
@@FriedSheep69fr tho. Him and Ian both do it😂😂😂
"Are you and Courtney dating?" Hits different after that marriage announcement
Yoooo right😂
YOOOOO
was just about to comment thid
Bet you feel embarrassed for those DMs you sent now
Can u tell me why?
Shayne looking directly at camera with fear and panic in his eyes as he is about to deliver the most hateful line.
It’s honestly adorable just how incredibly afraid he is of ever saying something that would hurt people’s feelings or make them feel unwelcome. It’s not to a fault, but whenever he gets a little more uncomfortable than he needs to be it gives the same energy as “werk” from the gay rights and wrongs Reddit react lol
Yeah that wasnt fear and panic, that was supressed laughter and humor because he knew it was gonna be funny due to the hopefully well known fact that it's not actually them who came up with the lines. Like wtf lighten up
@@thedudefromrobloxxsurely you know what a jovial/joking/non-literal comment is. People are allowed to speak hyperbolically without being upset.
Tommy: towering over Shayne
Shayne: avoiding eye-contact
Tommy: bends down to Shayne's level
Shayne: makes eye-contact
It's good that the father knows how to talk to his child
Fee fi fo fum when will you add me in the Smosh main cast 😂
Shayne pulling the homophobic DM as the straightest one in the room and instantly panicking was golden
Has a straight white male the internal panic on his face left me dying 💀😭🤣
Time stamp?
@@rowanadixon9099 22:20
made my day lmao
straightest?
Spencer running up there, telling shayne to “Courtney shut up.” Then Shayne getting a DM that says “WHOS ASS IS THAT!” And Chanse following it up with “Yeah because it’s…it’s..its…GAY!!!” Is a smosh moment I will never forget
just perfection, gotta love those improv moments
Yes it's the best part of the video I can't wait to see it used in compilations
Starts at 17:33 for anyone who wants the timestamp
Even better being Courtney laughing at it
It works so well
Anthony and Shayne laughing is 10 times louder than anyone else. Shayne especially.
Shayne's laugh is a full cast member at this point
As someone who also has a ridiculous cackle I appreciate the representation
when doesn’t shayne laugh harder than everybody else 💀💀
I enjoy that Shayne has another background laugh to out laugh 😆
Is it time for a Who’s Loudest rematch on Pit?
2:22 AND THEY WERE ALREADY ENGAGED AT THE TIME YALL
E
And they were roommates
Tommy and Chanse nodding to each other after the homophobic dm had me crying
THIS. Died.
What's the time stamp?
@@Melkweg722:07 for context, 22:43 for nod
Just want to say Tommy's archery acting was top tier
Right made me think he could actually be one
Tommy’s and Arasha’s siege my favorite bit, I was just waiting on Arusha to shoot one darn arrow!!! Tommy did amazing!
Amazingly he missed the "show us the shaft" opportunity, with an arrow shaft sticking out of his neck - can't blame him though, he had just been arrow'd in the neck.
Tommy asking Shayne if he and Courtney are dating hits a lot different now
FRFR
I came back to see if anybody commented on this lol
someone was really onto it.
@@aquarianlove1787 Same
@@aquarianlove1787 Same
I love how Anthony immediately fell to the floor after reading “can I spank your ass with my front thighs and not my hand”
I’m laughing so much 😭😭
That broke me
Ashamed to admit how long it took me to understand
feels like a hr violation to listen to it lol hahahah
@@rodo1252 I still don't understand
So who’s gonna tell ‘em?
Chanse and Tommy looking at each other and mouthing "true" when Shayne read the homophobic DM is the most relatable thing DSFHJNKFDSGKJN
What is the last thing after thing?
@@jaimereupert4247 It's the thing
@@jaimereupert4247 as yes this thing is very thing
IS THAT BOTTOM SPAM DETECTED
@@VraskaTheNoodle BOTTOM SPAM LMFAOOOOO
the fact shayne and courtney were, in fact, dating is CRAZY
Seeing Anthony's pure joy at participating in these post-Defy bits is life.
For sureeee
It's unfair how good all of them look with turtle necks
fr 😭
yr not even fucking lyin
It’s just an attractive bunch!
Agreed
Tommy, Anthony, Shayne, Chanse, Arasha and Steve Jobs all look fantastic
2:22 - Well that was some big brain foreshadowing
Yess
Chanse's random vocal riff at 19:15 is SENDING me 😭👌 so good but so fucking funny
It was giving Hannah Montana transitions and I loved it
I'm glad that the editor made sure it didn't go unnoticed
How did I literally not notice that even a little bit???
so it's definitely christina aguilera's riff from burlesque??? which is HILARIOUS
I need Anthony to always sit on the couch, because watching him literally roll around with laughter was the best part
Real and true
He’s got quite a laugh
3:20 - Hi, Slut
6:15 - Best one liner
10:48 - Insane roast
13:45 - Inspiration 😊
17:30 - Courtney, shut up!
18:42 - Cpt. One Ball
20:30 - Cpt. continued
22:00 - Supporting lgbtq? Loser.
26:04 - Add the flag
28:30 - Closing statements
This video was absolute GOLD, I love Smosh Pit Theatre!
Tysm
@@gracewrites720why? This didnt really do anything
Nevermind.
@@IMH4NS0L0 I wanted to go back to a scene I liked and this helped quite a bit.
@@IMH4NS0L0 Yeah it did
@@Emmaem111 Immediately after writing that I started using it lol
I love how “Can I your ball” sounds like a double typo, and then the reveal comes that it’s to Spencer and you realize no, they did mean just “ball”
i haven't watched smosh in a while and i genuinely was so confused and it took me WAY too many ball references and the captain ball dm to remember LOL
I loved it so much when Spencer ran up, read the card that said "Courtney, shut up", and then you could hear Courtney behind the camera laughing their ass off! (edit: it's around 17:38)
Time stamp?
@@christopherdriscoll8672 added it 👍
Oh my god thank you so much for pointing that out, that’s hilarious 🤣
Lmao I didn’t notice them in the background !
loved it 😭
20:44 Anthony saying "with lots of rizz" verbally had me dying 😂
E
Shayne pulling the homophobic DM and just panicking internally about saying it out loud while Tommy and Chanse (the gays [non-derogatory]) looking at each other was so funny.
I really want that shirt (Gay [non-derogatory])
As a gay myself (derogatory) i lost my shit at that part
@helenaEFFERVESCENC3 I thinking it's on the Smosh Amazon store!
the fact that Chanse literally went “it’s true” to Tommy killed me
It’s awful that people don’t support the LGBQ
The dms that randomly cut off without meaning are the ones that really push the casts improv skills 😭
Can I your ball?
I hope you know hoe amazing you ate
Dragons don’t actually lay eggs but actually…..
Aren't them thought?
Hey
Hey respectfully
I love seeing Antony having fun but also being a little confused, like at the end after Spencer says " may I get you pregnant." He's like "I think it's a good thing"
Spencer's sigh while he's debating whether or not to say "Mami" has me crying
He knew it would be clipped or can cammed
arasha and shayne have such an ability together to just turn the stupidest shit into oscar level performances
I think their ship name should Shaysha 😂
arashayne?
a- rosh ha- shayne- a?
Shayne's life flashed before his eyes before he read that dm
I hope they can act out the bad or rejected scripts they've written like the ones that Shayne, Angela, and Amanda did on Smosh Mouth.
I NEED them to do that Alcatraz escape room one
A full length Ham Cakes is not a want but a Need
@@zoesommer6710an actual necessity
how dare you Ham Cake is genius like on a monty python level.
My favorite show is yellow stone but I haven’t seen it
Smosh found someone that laughs at Shayne's jokes more than Shayne, and it's Anthony ❤
Exactly what I thought 😂
20:37 shayne roasting spencer in this scene gets me every time
Same im shocked no one else is talking about it 😂
When Tommy started reading all the ways to say "Goldberg" and Shayne said "How do you know everyone at school calls me that?" It felt like drama therapy
14:16 the “show us ur shaft, quick” line is crazy 🤣🤣🤣 like I’m shocked one of them got texted that 🤭😂
It works so well with arrows also
Like it's an emergency
it was probably to Anthony, back when they read the journal
25:14 “you alright buddy?” Tommy: “🥺 ‘No, but thanks for asking…’
Chanse staring intensely with his biblically accurate eyes while serving vocals is sending me!
19:20
his biblically accurate eyes lol!!!!
Wtf are Biblically accurate eyes? I'm so confused.
@@CuidightheachODuinnlook it up
@@CuidightheachODuinnI dunno, I'm not caught up on the lore. 😂
@@CuidightheachODuinn Ok, so, since you never got an answer on this, I can help - in the bible, angels are actually described as being non-human and terrifying/incomprehensible, even though we usually imagine them as looking like people. Awhile back, people started posting images they made of "biblically accurate angels" for fun, making them look like many-eyed, many-winged, lovecraft-esque beings, to highlight how terrifying some stuff in the bible actually is. Then, in meme-like evolution of the phrase, people started calling anything that looks like a more horrifying, abstract, and otherworldly version of itself "biblically accurate" as a call back to that idea. So, they're saying Chanse's eyes are "biblically accurate" to imply they are otherworldly, surprisingly scary, and not what you'd expect.
need to share some appreciation for their amazing delivery at 17:54
"You can't say that, this is a SAFEWAY!"
"Tell me it's not, look at it!"
13:37 Chanse absolutely freaking out over the “Debbie” name was amazing
This was so CHAOTIC. A few thoughts:
1. That improv where the cast joined Shayne and Chanse was GREAT
2. Chanse can sing????
The TNTL musical episode features Chanse, he also sings there!
yes! he and angela are great at musical improv
Yes! I'm hoping Angela eventually drags him into Starkid with her
chanse talks in a stereotypical gay man.
It makes me so unbelievably happy to see Anthony so happy and laughing so hard at everything in everybody else he's in. I think he is genuinely at peace being back at Smosh. This is where he belongs and it's just so great to see him here. I absolutely love seeing him and Ian back together, and don't get me wrong, I would have loved to see Ian in this video, but seeing Anthony alone in this video with the cast members really makes it feel like he's actually back as a member of the team because this is his first video back without Ian in it. So excited for the future of everyone. So happy for Ian and Anthony
The first video without Ian was "1-2 switch got better" on smosh games. Anthony does seem more comfortable now which is a good thing ;)
@@cameronwarren8865 That's true man, but I meant on smosh pit. But I probably should have specified
❤❤❤
What happened to make him leave in the first place?
AT 3:30 YOU CAN SEE TOMMY MOUTHING ALONG WHICH PROBABLY MEANS SPENCER HAS SHOWED THIS DM TO HIM LOL😭
Anthony’s speed run of every Smosh stuff ever continues
And it will never end, that's the best part
@@R15-99 well ian always does shows so idk why commenters are still commenting about Anthony on shows.
@@ChrissaTodd at this point its more like an ongoing joke. Take it with a grain of salt
@@ChrissaToddshayne mentioned a comment he saw regarding anthony ‘speed running shows’ in a Reddit stories video pretty soon after anthony rejoined- the jokes been overused/dead ever since
Can we mention how good Spencer was? He's the only one in the room who isn't an actor, but he was pretty good at callbacks in his scenes and sticking to the given setting. The others were obvs great too, but Spencer was surprising
I love Spencer’s quiet, subtle humor.
Spencer is def the most underrated person in the cast (yes cast, he and Tommy ARE part of the cast 😤) and crew tbh, yes he's very loved for how attractive and cute he is but his deliveries are absolutely HILARIOUS dude, his humor should be way more appreciated than it is
Editors understand timing
@@SaberRexZealottrue! Still takes confidence to execute and deliver in camera though. You gotta trust yourself in the moment
It's cuz he's the chosen
Are we all just gonna ignore the glorious harmony Chanse did at 19:16?
Dunno who chanse is, but I hope we don't ignore that, lol.
I legit think he just pulled out a Christina Aguilera riff because I’ve done the same one for practice 😂
That wasn’t harmony, it was just singing, but it was so beautiful!
The cast didn’t even clock it, he deserved way more hype for that
24:08 Okay but Arasha’s transition there was SMOOTH AF
I love how much Anthony is enjoying being there you can fr hear the man laughing even when he’s not on screen😭
this is why i absolutely love improv, they had people walking in and out of scene so casually, its like they belonged there or had actually walked up to them out of no where
Tommy saying "oooooh, he's long" genuinely made me cackling out loud 🤣
The Arasha and Shayne combo is insane.
Arasha in improv is insane tbh. She's so good no matter what they throw at her
They have great chemistry together.
They work so well off eachother
2:22 it hits different now
6:09 , Anthony getting progressively more red in the face having to read those set of dms LMFAOOOO
Off -camera laughing: Courtney is the new Shayne
"Are you dating Courtney"
It was right fucking there 💀
Them bringing back these rarer gem shows just to get Anthony on as many shows that he missed as possible has been so fun.
Courtney laughing in the background after being told to shut up is so funny
2:22 aged so well
love that anthony is laughing so much in this. shows that he's happy to be back, and it really rivals shayne's emphatic laughter lol
That courtroom scene just evolved and wrapped perfectly. I was crying😂😂
It’s proof that Smosh And Order never truly died - it is simply dormant, waiting for its return foretold in the prophecies…
26:03 this is my favorite line delivery from Spencer 😭😭😭😭
Some of those Anthony-Arasha scene dms worked TOO well lol
Right? Like if you closed your eyes it felt like they were reading a proper scene.
Arasha in improv is insane tbh. She's so good no matter what they throw at her
@@Fluff_Noodlesfor real, the way she incorporated the toast crumb tray as a metaphor was perfect
“Kiss?”
“You like kids?”
“We got kids?”
“You simping?”
Living in my head rent free for the rest of my life
17:38 You could hear Courtney laughing from another room 💀
She’s directing so she’s just behind the cameras
22:45 "Its true." Haha. Tommy and Chanse are always amazing sports with this kind of stuff. Also, calling Anthony a shattered box of ink pens is a potential diss for his funeral roast. 💀
Forgive me if calling someone a "shattered box of ink pens" is a common phrase that's just lost on me, but I can only assume they're talking about his tattoos? Every time a short pops up involving Anthony I see at least one comment talking about how his tattoos look like marker ink lines.
@@-VoDkAsVengeance- Its not a common phrase but it just looks like it since the lines are "splattered" in every direction. Idk I think someone mentioned it first in a video and it sticked since then...a reoccuring joke.
6:20 the way Anthony turned so red after reading that 😂 bless him
the ‘show me the shaft’ was so fitting for a medieval siege 😭😭😭 14:36
Shaynes and Chanse’s skit where everyone was coming up WAS KILLING ME
23:53 Good improv from her for turning that into something relevenat and useful to the bit
Anthony's "Ho" and walk out was perfection
Chance’s facial expressions are UNPARALLELED omg
LMAOO I LOVED HOW THEY BOTH LOOKED BACK AT EACH OTHER AFTER THAT 22:36
Chanse: *waits patiently for Tommy and Arasha's bit to start
Chanse: (3 seconds later) Debbie?! DEBBBBBIIIEE?!!
24:13 Arasha absolutely brought it home, love her. Also Chanse going “yep” so supportively actually made me clap 😅
This is the best one of these ever. Some of these were so contextually appropriate, like the date one kept progressing. And then some of them were absolutely nuts. I love how Shayne had to gather strength, apologise to the camera and then read his line
19:41 WHOEVERS DM IT IS LIKED THE MESSAGE BYE
Spencer's deadpan yet sincere reading of these messages are amazing.
My favorite part was honestly just “Courtney, shut up” 😂😂😂😂
And hearing her laugh in the background immediately after it's said 😂
2:20 this has a whole new context to it now lmao
Love that Chanse picked up the papers from the previous rounds. Respect.
Can we talk about how savage the line "You make him look like a box of shattered ink pens in comparison" was?
10:57
Just brutal😂😂😂😂😂
I want to know who got that dm! It didn't look like it was Shayne so I'm confused lol
@@jannatulshoilee1443I guess it was Tommy, or maybe Chanse
@@jannatulshoilee1443 In my mind, it was Ian or Spencer. 😁😁😁
i’m pretty sure it was ian’s because his ig bio read “2nd cutest smosh boy”
@@vion3009 Ian's DMs weren't even included, it was only DMs of the people there, and Ian wasn't.
24:20 Best reference of the video fight me on it
OMG the samples but with Shayne and Chanse was great 😂 “whose ass is that?!” “Yeah it’s… its…GAY!” “You can’t say that, this is a SAFEway!!” 😭😭😭😂😂😂
The matching turtle necks definitely make it way funnier 🤣🤣🤣🤣😂
THOMAS GOING “Ohh, he’s *long* ” GOT ME HAHAHHA
Time: 26:50
Anthony finally crossing out Smosh Pit Theater in his bucketlist of Smosh shows to appear in 📝
The quiet push in to chance as he disassociates and riffs is EVERYTHING and had me HOWLING
Omg when Chanse said "Tell me it's not! Look at it!" At 18:02 he sounded exactly like Brandon Rogers😂
I really appreciated how chance kept picking up the pieces of paper
Right?
Anthony hangin' out with the smosh step children 😎
And his long lost son Shayne
Shayne is 100% considered an “OG” member lol
We love Shayne so much for the internal panic & immediately direct eye contact with audience 😂❤
Mariah is such a warrior, still firing arrows after their dying words 🥲
17:56 lmao Anthony and Arasha are synced in their laughing 😂
no way
26:55 Spencer's delivery, though!
I cannot stress how much I need to see Ian and Anthony reading a fanfic. Please. Give it me.
There are like four videos of them reading fanfic from years ago
I think we let the fans cook up some more reunion fics and then do an episode of it
@@Lucarioguild7 brooo I looked up some reunion fics. Don't do it!
17:40 Courtney’s cackling in the background kills me
10:13 this is probably the funniest 3 consecutive shots I've seen
I feel like this series is going to make people DM even more wild stuff 😅
Hey, it's free material