@@nobody2021 man i know what you mean here but a big part of the reason he killed her is becuz he canonically was pissed he couldnt have sex with her cuz she didnt want to be touched and he didnt want to cheat on her. thats why theres all the sexual imagery in the game with the enemies, since theyre reflections of james psyche/guilt and all that junk. thats also why pyramid head is found the first two times in sexual situations w/ other monsters. its also why maria is extremely sexual towards him.
Yeah, it's... kind of hard to think of a video game that comes up with more colorful and varied ways to represent "thinking with his hog" than _Silent Hill 2._ It's the theme underlying, like, what, 75-80% of the game's memorable scenes? At the very least?
@@darrelsam419 He's using humor to deal with the fact that the game does its job in making him uncomfortable. "Why Jamie?" actually seems on point for how he'd react.
Real talk, the only bad part about this playthrough was Vin constantly having to placate whiners in chat who would *_REEEE_* at his every minor comment, criticism or joke about the game, even though he assured them he was enjoying it immensely overall. Towards the half-way point of the game I got the distinct feeling he was actively self-censoring as to not trigger chat. Why do people insist that others absolutely need to experience a game exactly as they did the first time, rather than letting others just experience it in their _own_ way? As huge of a fan as I am of this game and the Silent Hill franchise in general, I couldn't disagree more with this obsessive fanboy mentality and I can only imagine how Vin's overall enjoyment of the experience might have been diminished by having to walk on eggshells the whole time.
Everyone who whined on this stream sat down to watch it already extremely agitated, basically deciding beforehand that this guy who got big by cracking jokes on video games was either going to treat playing this game like a Puritan at 1600s Massachusetts church, or those viewers were going to have miniature mental breakdowns over it. Bark bark bark, bark bark bark, etc.
Same reason why Vinny put off Dark Souls 1, and nearly Bloodborne. Chat is shit, and kept giving him shit whenever he fucked up. Ironically enough, the only reason he enjoyed streaming BB was because the BB community wasn't shit to him in chat, and gave him tips and help.
I have to agree that. Even if you immensely enjoy something you can still have criticisms of it. I personally think enjoying something in spite of its faults makes the experience better overall.
@@moonkingdomify I never heard him criticize the game? I don’t think people get upset about him doing that. I think people get upset because in this type of a game, making jokes about the cut scenes, voice acting, and joking around, ruins the experience of watching someone play it. It’s such a serious game with serious themes. I mean imagine showing your friend your favorite scary movie and they just sit there and make jokes about it and constantly joke about how shitty it is, maybe you wouldn’t feel annoyed but a lot of other people in the world would. That’s how they feel when they watch someone play their favorite horror game. Which is why I think this game should never be steamed with a live chat. It should be played alone. Like we did back in the day.
The letter from Mary at the end kills me literally every time I've played though this game/watched someone else play it. I can't help it, hearing someone who genuinely sounds like they're in such unimaginable pain just does something to me.
Blurredborderlines Too bad that letter you received never existed and this is reflected the further you are in your play through as the writing disappears along with the note.
Rewatching this stream made me realize how talented Mary's voice actress was in this game. Her pain feels so relatable and genuine during the last act of the game, the hallway, the bed scene, the epilogue with the letter... Goddammit, I cried like a bitch at the ending.
Monica Taylor Horgan is the indisputable standout in this game and extremely talented; she has many good things to say about making SH2. Unfortunately, after Team Silent separated, Horgan and the others doing voice/mocap for this game were treated like dogshit in the traditional manner of their industry, and Horgan pretty much left voice acting. Hard to blame her, but it's too bad.
if i recall correctly, this game is a really coincidental masterpiece with Jame's voice actor having a divorce around Silent Hill 2's development, which helped him act out his pain more with the character losing his girlfriend, and Mary's voice actor lost a close relative, so they both had a LOT of heart pain to bring into their characters on set. this game really is a beautiful trainwreck
Vinny is definitely a mentally stronger man than me if someone came into my chat and said "please don't joke too much during the cutscenes" I would have lost it
@@INeverWanted2010 Not really. The fandom was always like this. People who get into silent hill, but especially silent hill 2, get far too worked up making sure a experience is delivered and don't want it ruined. It comes from a good place, but it's annoying as hell and always was. But this was true for the game even when it first came out. and it's a odd trait only in silent hill, especially toward 2. It's perhaps the SH fandom worst trait....but in the grand scheme of fandoms, it's a mild and understandable one. As opposed to say...like furry or sonic fandoms.
I mean its the same with me. Only a select few games have ever scared me. SH1-4 all being part of that exception. And Silent Hill 2 and 4 were the ones that did it best. Soma however, isn't scary.
@@Trakesh I feel the same about Soma and many other horror games. SH2 was always one of the creepiest ones for me but 4 actually didn't do anything for me. 1-3 were the only ones that scared me at all. Though I barely remember SH4, anyway. I should probably replay that and see how I feel about it today. But man, 1 and 2 are easily among my all-time favorites.
@@Pandsu 4 was definitely the black sheep when it came out... but now that we've seen how bad it got after then... 4 really isn't really that bad at all.
35:04 OMG. The unintentional genius of that moment. Really seeing the static in the TV as a "monster noise" and considering what the model in the chair actually is...? Damn... I thought I knew this game...
Akira Yamaoka - the man who can orchestrate horrific metallic noises yet also likely make a James Bond theme. One of the best composers alive if not ever, no doubt.
Angela's breakdown after you defeat Abstract Daddy is absolutely fantastic. I am a very unempathetic person, but that scene gets my eyes nice and watery every time. Same for the hallway flashback conversation between Mary and James. And for the letter during the Leave ending. God dammit, this game is SO GOOD.
The thing about Mary's talk with James and letter at the end that really stuck with me is throughout the whole game the weight of the horrible things done or done to the characters just weighs on you so heavily. When Mary and James talk it's like you can breathe again. Hearing Mary sound so sympathetic to James despite what he did to her truly shows she understood and still loved him. Yknow it's like... I can kinda relate. I mean I've never murdered someone but I know when you love someone and you feel anxious and confused and like you are a horrible person, just talking with that person you love can really clear your mind and make you feel better. Even under the worst conditions. I think this game illustrates that wonderfully. At the same time it's so bittersweet but... By the end of the game there's a genuine sense of closure. At least to me.
Vinny got the "Leave" ending on his first run? I was sure he'd get "In Water" - good job, Binyot. And that final line - "You made me happy." Jesus Christ. That's a fucking Whammy Line, if any.
It's pretty hard to get anything but "Leave" on your first time through this game, at least without planning to do otherwise, if you start on normal or easy difficulty, as nearly everyone playing the game would, and it's exactly what Vinny did here. I know people who got endings other than "Leave" their first time through, but it's unusual. In a way, that means the endings are doing their jobs.
man... it's so powerful that vinny kills "Mary" with the great knife, the symbol of jame's need to punish himself for his sins... and then gets the leave ending. i know the leave ending is the most common, but... there's something there
But the voice acting wasn't really "intentionally weird" in many cases. It's just that the way those parts turn out works for _this_ game where it wouldn't in many others. Spielberg didn't shoot Roy Scheider in _Jaws_ until he caught a shooting star in the frame, it just happened. People online have a hard time dealing with meaning outside of planning and intent.
took a nap while listening to this (i’ve done it before) but this time the dialogue and stuff was put in my dream. woke up to maria getting killed while james was in the elevator. how great
As much as I do love watching him play this, it does suck whenever streamers play games like this and read the chat, which is just people dumping misinformation and weird fan-theories on to them. It's really obnoxious.
Not to mention all the butthurt people in chat screeching at him to "TAEK TEH GAEM SRSLY DAMMIT" for the grave crime of making a small joke here and there...you know, something Vinny's _always been known to do,_ and is in fact kinda popular _for_ doing...
People who managed to get through this video game and still think on the garbage-water level of "canon" and "lore" and "fan theory" are beyond help. This game doesn't cure cancer but at the very least, as this medium's _The Turn of the Screw,_ it should cure the player of all three of those mental diseases by the time the end credits roll.
@@thethrashyone I have to imagine those people sat down to watch Vinny play this game just filled with anxiety and stress and carefully prepped frustration for when he inevitably cracked a joke. They had to be just gripping their Care Bear pillows to their chests. And, like... the people who made this game put in an ending where it turns out a cute dog did it.
i cant help it, i keep looking up peoples playthrough of this game. im so happy binyot got to enjoy it spoiler free, god i wish that were me. but even though i knew the twist, seeing it was still a punch in the gut, thats how amazing this game is.
I mean... Donna Burke sings the theme song of the entire game, around which MGSV's promotional campaign and thus record-breaking early sales were built, but uh yeah she also recorded like 10 seconds of heavily processed single-word lines for the robot
@@digital_fairy actually she just did a cover of it, I don't blame you getting for confused tho since Cynthia Harrell and her sound similar, oh btw Cynthia Harrell also sang the credits song to symphony of the night!
the fact i never truly got to appreciate everything this game had to offer when it first came out disappoints me. But man vinny, you gave me the nostalgic feeling to revisit this game. I love it, and after events in my life that truly made me feel shit at its bleakest I can truly appreciate this game at its core. Thanks for the memories man, it just makes me look back and smile more!
This has become one of my favourite videos of all time for the following reason: I tried to keep it short but I just couldn't cut any more out. Hope you give it a read since I just had to let this go. At least it's something that stuck with me. Spoiler Warning: Vinny reacting to the dog ending, shown immediately after the "leave" ending is something to live by. The real ending was incredibly depressing and it hits really hard. Vinny's silence throughout Mary's letter is kind of devastating and hearing him talk about experiences over the course of the credits is just plain disheartening. A lot of people can find themselves in James' situation and hearing Vinny kind of give in and admit that eventually this is mostly what there might be to life just didn't leave me cold. Maybe some of you who watched even remembered personal experiences and shed a tear or two. Right after, the editor cuts in the scene that Binyot missed in his playthrough and it´s a scenario that is way too real, even for the rest of the game. It's that you're still trying to comprehend what you saw and what you're feeling and all of a sudden the dog ending comes up and you hear Vinny laugh. I'm not sure if it's just me but in that first laugh you can hear so much relief on his side. His contageous laugh kinda cheers you up. It feels like someone who's close to you makes you laugh while wiping the tears off your cheek. It's just going back to some good old lighthearted sillyness with our favourite italian boi that simply exists because of how the video has been cut (intentional or not). This moment feels really wholesome considering the impact it had on me personally and that's why it stuck with me. Life might really suck and you will miss people along the way. But there's always the ones around you. If it's a relative, a friend, or someone like the binyot that you watch online... It's more than ok to mourn and grief but it'll never be what the person who's been lost would have wanted for you long term. Cherish, enjoy and hold on to the moments you have with the one's you enjoy to be with. As small and silly as they might be. I hope I could make clear what I love about the montage at the end. It´s hard to get the feelings this conveys to me into words, especially when english is not your native language. But I just had to thank the editor for editing it together the way they did. The entire stream was incredibly enjoyable and for the mentioned reason alone this Best-of supercut has become one of my favourite videos/scenes of all time. A huge and honest thank you to the creator.
I keep coming back to this, I just love how much he likes the game. Also, Vinny dreaming about forgetting a locker combination so often means that he's unsure about how you feel in a situation. Just something interesting to add.
@@duroorud527 dreaming gory stuff doesn't automatically mean you like gore. it could mean something else. Dreaming about locker combinations doesn't mean you like lockers
@@duroorud527 Dreams don't always have "meaning", but they do always have a reason. It could be something in passing through the day, something you've been thinking or worried about, or even something from deeper in the subconscious. It doesn't have to be some greater truth, but there is a reason for your dreams. As for analyzing them, you know your mind better than anyone else ever can. You just need to start thinking about how you think, and asking where your thoughts come from. As you start tracing things back, you'll begin to understand who you are underneath your impulses. That's the Jungian approach to analysis.
@@MegaZeta It's pretty easy to, actually. It's a game _about_ depression (among other things), so naturally you tell yourself 'this game is depressing'. Thinking that and _feeling_ it are two very different experiences.
@@MegaZeta Yeah, I'm glad it fell through. I didn't feel they could do it any justice, and PT just felt like Resident Evil 7 with some mind-screw. That isn't what Silent Hill is to me.
@@CosmicWaltz7 I’m sorry… did you seriously just compare a goofy and campy resident evil to the terrifying mind-bending and intense pt gameplay? Did you actually claim the best writers and artists in the genre wanting to recreate this games energy was a bad thing??? In compared to what? Losing the franchise forever? Congrats. Your the only shills on the planet who are happy we lost this masterpiece of a series. Glad people like you can shill a company that corrupt, so easily.
@@vinhighlights5456 I was also just about to comment here and say how great this compilation is. I've played the full video a couple times now as background & haven't gotten tired of it; you did a really great job on it!!
2:18:30 I find it fucking hilarious that James' enters a room of bugs, and instead of just stepping on them, he fucking swings his bat around then starts shooting them. Imagine if pest control handled all their cases like this.
Spoilers for the end but... "I will Always Love You." Fucking hell that hit me deep. That ending alone is a fantastic piece of media, but to be included in such an extraordinarily atmospheric and psychologically engrossing game is a wonder in and of itself.
@@lasarousi bitch one time I got it while I was extremely hangover *that* was my personal silent hill alright I almost died this game is sentient I swear to god
You're wondering why playing this game that's only a few hours long at hardest difficulty, or watching an even more condensed highlight reel of it, has you running across the same scene every single time?
@@lasarousi yeah, its acually a rape scene of Angela and her father/brother and the whole room is themed around. Its stil a mystery what the 21 holes mean but thinking thats how many times she experience this makes sense.
@@YuubiTimberwolf I think it's not necessarily the amount of times, but the act repeating itself so many times in her head, just the act of penetration in and of itself is what represents the neatly ordered pistons on a higher point of the walls. The room is her own mind suffocating her daily. Or what I used to think, it's the amount of years it took to overcome her fear of her dad when she finally kills it with the tv and kicks it. But I think she is younger than 21 in the game, but who knows she is already dead for many years before James arrived. Game's great tho.
Probably someone very passionate about the game and well inversed in the game's lore. But let's just say, that passion is worded poorly, so just tone it back a little, eh?
The end fucking hurts me, considering the fact that the protagonists name is James coupled with the conversation that he and Mary had while she was in the hospital dying of most likely cancer, was very similar to how conversations started to go between me and my mother as she deteriorated day by day before she eventually died, love your parents everyone.
Technically it's the creation of A Pyramid Head (i.e. one particular, singular PH) -and its the result of a Bad Ending. Who knows where the O.G. Pyramid Heads (the at least 2 separate ones we see in this one) came from.
Isn't the whole idea of silent hill that it's some sort of personalized hell? How would something born from a guy's psyche have an origin? Or have I completely misunderstood what the series is?
@@329link You got it right. But Pyramid Head is too famous. He was in at least one of the movies too. Don't remember them too well. Because brand recognition
This game freaks me out in a good way. I love the dark atmosphere, Also, I’d like to point out that most of the samples in in the music are from a sample CD called “Distorted Reality” By Spectrasonics.
love that pyramid head fight in the flooded room. *scraping of weapon and taps of footsteps* *CLANG* followed by one or two *soft clunks* rinse and repeat
The year is 2021. The world is a chaotic mess. And I am sitting here, laughing until I cannot breathe, tears streaming down my face, at Vinny bonking Pyramid Head over the back of the helmet with a wooden plank like he was trying to shoo a raccoon with a broom.
While there’s no lore reason to why pyramid head wears that helmet, the monster designer said he made it that way because he wanted to make it look painful to wear. Sorry for making you find out Vinny
i fell asleep with youtube running on my laptop and woke up in the middle of the night to the radio blaring static.I then passed out again, and woke up to the ending note from Mary
@@terranaes1270 Yeah, "Angel's Thanatos", one of the goofiest tracks in the entire series. Those first few seconds when it starts to play are maybe this game's weakest overall... at least you can finish the whole game without ever experiencing it
It hits harder, cause Silent Hill is supposed to be like rehab and make someone stronger and finally accept. But like the other 3 that were brought to the town, they just ended up dead...
the graphics were very cutting edge for their time. if you run the game on high enough computer power youll actually have a game that matches some modern consoles.
![[Vinesauce] Vinny - Resident Evil 4 Remake Compilation](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/38QdR-gCD1A/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Vinesauce] Vinny - Resident Evil 4 Remake Compilation](/img/tr.png)
![[Vinesauce] Vinny - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Compilation (Part 1 of 2)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/958e4LmXIzg/mqdefault.jpg)
All the minor details that Vinny missed were revindicated by him killing the final boss with pyramid heads huge knife, in his first and only run.
I normally don't like spoilers for things but I'm actively looking forward to watching that now.
The poetry...it's marvlous.
"do you think james is thinking with his hog" funnily enough this whole game and situation is because james was thinking with his hog
Follow your hog
Yep. When James put his terminally ill wife out of her misery, he did it for his hog
@@nobody2021 man i know what you mean here but a big part of the reason he killed her is becuz he canonically was pissed he couldnt have sex with her cuz she didnt want to be touched and he didnt want to cheat on her. thats why theres all the sexual imagery in the game with the enemies, since theyre reflections of james psyche/guilt and all that junk. thats also why pyramid head is found the first two times in sexual situations w/ other monsters. its also why maria is extremely sexual towards him.
Yeah, it's... kind of hard to think of a video game that comes up with more colorful and varied ways to represent "thinking with his hog" than _Silent Hill 2._ It's the theme underlying, like, what, 75-80% of the game's memorable scenes? At the very least?
well, in two endings jame fights his hog and wins, so it's all good in the end.
There's few things more satisfying than watching someone truly enjoy a game you love so much
ragnrx :think: this and his play through of mother 3 give me that same satisfaction
*most plot critical moment of the game is going on*
Vinny: y jame
pserafi time stamp?
@@GREEDEX12345 3:19:55
I like to believe that was how Vinny tried to cope with the reveal. Using humor to elevate the sadness.
@@darrelsam419 He's using humor to deal with the fact that the game does its job in making him uncomfortable.
"Why Jamie?" actually seems on point for how he'd react.
Why Jamie
Where's the "How can you sit there and eat pizza" scene? That's a classic.
yes
To be fair, Vinny didn't really react to it that much. He only chuckled a bit.
I love how this game has bits pf humor in it despite the horror.
peetZUH
Real talk, the only bad part about this playthrough was Vin constantly having to placate whiners in chat who would *_REEEE_* at his every minor comment, criticism or joke about the game, even though he assured them he was enjoying it immensely overall. Towards the half-way point of the game I got the distinct feeling he was actively self-censoring as to not trigger chat. Why do people insist that others absolutely need to experience a game exactly as they did the first time, rather than letting others just experience it in their _own_ way? As huge of a fan as I am of this game and the Silent Hill franchise in general, I couldn't disagree more with this obsessive fanboy mentality and I can only imagine how Vin's overall enjoyment of the experience might have been diminished by having to walk on eggshells the whole time.
Everyone who whined on this stream sat down to watch it already extremely agitated, basically deciding beforehand that this guy who got big by cracking jokes on video games was either going to treat playing this game like a Puritan at 1600s Massachusetts church, or those viewers were going to have miniature mental breakdowns over it. Bark bark bark, bark bark bark, etc.
Same reason why Vinny put off Dark Souls 1, and nearly Bloodborne. Chat is shit, and kept giving him shit whenever he fucked up. Ironically enough, the only reason he enjoyed streaming BB was because the BB community wasn't shit to him in chat, and gave him tips and help.
I have to agree that. Even if you immensely enjoy something you can still have criticisms of it. I personally think enjoying something in spite of its faults makes the experience better overall.
I think that's why vinny never streamed undertale, isn't it? Because that fanbase is the worst when it comes to that.
@@moonkingdomify I never heard him criticize the game? I don’t think people get upset about him doing that. I think people get upset because in this type of a game, making jokes about the cut scenes, voice acting, and joking around, ruins the experience of watching someone play it. It’s such a serious game with serious themes. I mean imagine showing your friend your favorite scary movie and they just sit there and make jokes about it and constantly joke about how shitty it is, maybe you wouldn’t feel annoyed but a lot of other people in the world would. That’s how they feel when they watch someone play their favorite horror game. Which is why I think this game should never be steamed with a live chat. It should be played alone. Like we did back in the day.
The letter from Mary at the end kills me literally every time I've played though this game/watched someone else play it. I can't help it, hearing someone who genuinely sounds like they're in such unimaginable pain just does something to me.
Blurredborderlines Too bad that letter you received never existed and this is reflected the further you are in your play through as the writing disappears along with the note.
@@NeonChrome_ The one during the credits, dumb dumb
"You made me happy" gets me every time
yes
@@NGRevenant Yep, that mark makes me weep.
On that very first stream when he said "Cool music" I knew this was gonna be a great playthrough.
the PT wound hurts more when you realize Junji Ito was gonna design some monsters.
Holy crap. For real? I'm gonna cry...
the grief the pain
Rewatching this stream made me realize how talented Mary's voice actress was in this game. Her pain feels so relatable and genuine during the last act of the game, the hallway, the bed scene, the epilogue with the letter...
Goddammit, I cried like a bitch at the ending.
Monica Taylor Horgan is the indisputable standout in this game and extremely talented; she has many good things to say about making SH2. Unfortunately, after Team Silent separated, Horgan and the others doing voice/mocap for this game were treated like dogshit in the traditional manner of their industry, and Horgan pretty much left voice acting. Hard to blame her, but it's too bad.
Don’t worry bro, we ALL cried at Mary reading the letter.
From what I know, Mrs. Horgan started crying herself when reading out the last letter.
if i recall correctly, this game is a really coincidental masterpiece with Jame's voice actor having a divorce around Silent Hill 2's development, which helped him act out his pain more with the character losing his girlfriend, and Mary's voice actor lost a close relative, so they both had a LOT of heart pain to bring into their characters on set. this game really is a beautiful trainwreck
I fucking love how much he's enjoying this game. From the atmosphere to the dialogue to the gameplay he really gets it and i love that.
-*sees fog in Silent Hill*
-*I T S L I K E S I L E N T H I L L*
Vinny is definitely a mentally stronger man than me if someone came into my chat and said "please don't joke too much during the cutscenes" I would have lost it
wouldn't be so bad if he was legit funny
Too many Silent Hill fans are insufferable crybabies these days.
@@INeverWanted2010
Not really. The fandom was always like this. People who get into silent hill, but especially silent hill 2, get far too worked up making sure a experience is delivered and don't want it ruined. It comes from a good place, but it's annoying as hell and always was. But this was true for the game even when it first came out.
and it's a odd trait only in silent hill, especially toward 2. It's perhaps the SH fandom worst trait....but in the grand scheme of fandoms, it's a mild and understandable one. As opposed to say...like furry or sonic fandoms.
Silent hill was the friends we made along the way
finally a horror game that managed to break throught Vinny's "horrorr games dont scare me" mentality
Naturally! Its the best for a reason.
Ever see him play Soma?
I mean its the same with me. Only a select few games have ever scared me. SH1-4 all being part of that exception. And Silent Hill 2 and 4 were the ones that did it best.
Soma however, isn't scary.
@@Trakesh I feel the same about Soma and many other horror games. SH2 was always one of the creepiest ones for me but 4 actually didn't do anything for me. 1-3 were the only ones that scared me at all.
Though I barely remember SH4, anyway. I should probably replay that and see how I feel about it today. But man, 1 and 2 are easily among my all-time favorites.
@@Pandsu 4 was definitely the black sheep when it came out... but now that we've seen how bad it got after then... 4 really isn't really that bad at all.
He was so afraid, he used a big medpack in advance.
hearing Vinny’s voice getting somber and choked up gave me feelings I did not know I signed up for
I can't believe it took me over a decade to put together that Eddie is vomiting because he just killed a person.
35:04 OMG.
The unintentional genius of that moment. Really seeing the static in the TV as a "monster noise" and considering what the model in the chair actually is...? Damn... I thought I knew this game...
Akira Yamaoka - the man who can orchestrate horrific metallic noises yet also likely make a James Bond theme.
One of the best composers alive if not ever, no doubt.
I mean... he's pretty good in terms of downbeat and ambient, I own all his albums but he's not fucking Mozart
@@MegaZeta I hope not. Mozart has been dead for a long time.
Mega Zeta You don’t need complextro to be regarded a talented composer.
@@ksheely With the wonders of DAWs, you don't necessarily need to read sheet music to make music.
@@siefer117 fuck dude you deserved more credit for this
Vinny getting the first aid kit in the intro and then immediately using it up may be my favorite Vinesauce moment of the past year
Angela's breakdown after you defeat Abstract Daddy is absolutely fantastic.
I am a very unempathetic person, but that scene gets my eyes nice and watery every time.
Same for the hallway flashback conversation between Mary and James.
And for the letter during the Leave ending.
God dammit, this game is SO GOOD.
Holy shit that was gut wrenching
I was considering playing this on my own, but this'll do it for me
You really should do it for yourself - you can get a [[[legal copy]]] on the internet.
"gut wrenching"
Hello demented fanboy
Allow me to tell you that this game is overrated. I’d rather pirate it than spend my money on this.
The thing about Mary's talk with James and letter at the end that really stuck with me is throughout the whole game the weight of the horrible things done or done to the characters just weighs on you so heavily.
When Mary and James talk it's like you can breathe again. Hearing Mary sound so sympathetic to James despite what he did to her truly shows she understood and still loved him.
Yknow it's like... I can kinda relate. I mean I've never murdered someone but I know when you love someone and you feel anxious and confused and like you are a horrible person, just talking with that person you love can really clear your mind and make you feel better. Even under the worst conditions. I think this game illustrates that wonderfully.
At the same time it's so bittersweet but... By the end of the game there's a genuine sense of closure. At least to me.
we might never know though... Mary's corpse is still on the backseat, in a car with James' license plate... it's a really bittersweet closure for sure
Vinny got the "Leave" ending on his first run?
I was sure he'd get "In Water" - good job, Binyot.
And that final line - "You made me happy."
Jesus Christ.
That's a fucking Whammy Line, if any.
It's pretty hard to get anything but "Leave" on your first time through this game, at least without planning to do otherwise, if you start on normal or easy difficulty, as nearly everyone playing the game would, and it's exactly what Vinny did here. I know people who got endings other than "Leave" their first time through, but it's unusual. In a way, that means the endings are doing their jobs.
man... it's so powerful that vinny kills "Mary" with the great knife, the symbol of jame's need to punish himself for his sins... and then gets the leave ending. i know the leave ending is the most common, but... there's something there
vinny's been healing left and right, i'm 100% sure this was on accident
I think the thing that shows that the voice acting is intentionally weird is stuff like 2:06:00 - it gets good when things get really serious.
But the voice acting wasn't really "intentionally weird" in many cases. It's just that the way those parts turn out works for _this_ game where it wouldn't in many others. Spielberg didn't shoot Roy Scheider in _Jaws_ until he caught a shooting star in the frame, it just happened. People online have a hard time dealing with meaning outside of planning and intent.
@@MegaZeta no but it was though, it was literally supposed to sound hazy and dreamlike
@@nataliecameron guy cihi said it aswell
took a nap while listening to this (i’ve done it before) but this time the dialogue and stuff was put in my dream. woke up to maria getting killed while james was in the elevator. how great
I actually fell asleep with this. And I woke up when James was in the room with the piano that Laura was playing.
"lusty for that crusty" 10/10
Eddie is ready.
As much as I do love watching him play this, it does suck whenever streamers play games like this and read the chat, which is just people dumping misinformation and weird fan-theories on to them. It's really obnoxious.
Not to mention all the butthurt people in chat screeching at him to "TAEK TEH GAEM SRSLY DAMMIT" for the grave crime of making a small joke here and there...you know, something Vinny's _always been known to do,_ and is in fact kinda popular _for_ doing...
good thingo he hadnt playo undertail
People who managed to get through this video game and still think on the garbage-water level of "canon" and "lore" and "fan theory" are beyond help. This game doesn't cure cancer but at the very least, as this medium's _The Turn of the Screw,_ it should cure the player of all three of those mental diseases by the time the end credits roll.
@@thethrashyone I have to imagine those people sat down to watch Vinny play this game just filled with anxiety and stress and carefully prepped frustration for when he inevitably cracked a joke. They had to be just gripping their Care Bear pillows to their chests. And, like... the people who made this game put in an ending where it turns out a cute dog did it.
i cant help it, i keep looking up peoples playthrough of this game. im so happy binyot got to enjoy it spoiler free, god i wish that were me. but even though i knew the twist, seeing it was still a punch in the gut, thats how amazing this game is.
Vinny has such amazing timing with the Pyramid Head encounters.
fun fact: the voice of Angela (Donna Burke) voices the iDroid in MGSV
I mean... Donna Burke sings the theme song of the entire game, around which MGSV's promotional campaign and thus record-breaking early sales were built, but uh yeah she also recorded like 10 seconds of heavily processed single-word lines for the robot
She also sings Snaker Eater!
@@digital_fairy actually she just did a cover of it, I don't blame you getting for confused tho since Cynthia Harrell and her sound similar, oh btw Cynthia Harrell also sang the credits song to symphony of the night!
I hope someone told Vinny to go look up Akira Yamaoka after he was through all this. Guy is a freaking genius
the fact i never truly got to appreciate everything this game had to offer when it first came out disappoints me. But man vinny, you gave me the nostalgic feeling to revisit this game. I love it, and after events in my life that truly made me feel shit at its bleakest I can truly appreciate this game at its core. Thanks for the memories man, it just makes me look back and smile more!
This has become one of my favourite videos of all time for the following reason:
I tried to keep it short but I just couldn't cut any more out. Hope you give it a read since I just had to let this go. At least it's something that stuck with me.
Spoiler Warning:
Vinny reacting to the dog ending, shown immediately after the "leave" ending is something to live by.
The real ending was incredibly depressing and it hits really hard. Vinny's silence throughout Mary's letter is kind of devastating and hearing him talk about experiences over the course of the credits is just plain disheartening. A lot of people can find themselves in James' situation and hearing Vinny kind of give in and admit that eventually this is mostly what there might be to life just didn't leave me cold. Maybe some of you who watched even remembered personal experiences and shed a tear or two. Right after, the editor cuts in the scene that Binyot missed in his playthrough and it´s a scenario that is way too real, even for the rest of the game.
It's that you're still trying to comprehend what you saw and what you're feeling and all of a sudden the dog ending comes up and you hear Vinny laugh.
I'm not sure if it's just me but in that first laugh you can hear so much relief on his side. His contageous laugh kinda cheers you up. It feels like someone who's close to you makes you laugh while wiping the tears off your cheek. It's just going back to some good old lighthearted sillyness with our favourite italian boi that simply exists because of how the video has been cut (intentional or not).
This moment feels really wholesome considering the impact it had on me personally and that's why it stuck with me.
Life might really suck and you will miss people along the way. But there's always the ones around you. If it's a relative, a friend, or someone like the binyot that you watch online...
It's more than ok to mourn and grief but it'll never be what the person who's been lost would have wanted for you long term.
Cherish, enjoy and hold on to the moments you have with the one's you enjoy to be with. As small and silly as they might be.
I hope I could make clear what I love about the montage at the end. It´s hard to get the feelings this conveys to me into words, especially when english is not your native language. But I just had to thank the editor for editing it together the way they did.
The entire stream was incredibly enjoyable and for the mentioned reason alone this Best-of supercut has become one of my favourite videos/scenes of all time.
A huge and honest thank you to the creator.
I'm so glad Vinny played this game. My favorite horror game of all time.
I keep coming back to this, I just love how much he likes the game.
Also, Vinny dreaming about forgetting a locker combination so often means that he's unsure about how you feel in a situation. Just something interesting to add.
no.
dreams don't always have a meaning.
i dream very gory stuff but i don't like extreme gore.
@@duroorud527 dreaming gory stuff doesn't automatically mean you like gore. it could mean something else. Dreaming about locker combinations doesn't mean you like lockers
@@deffdefying4803 like what?
@@duroorud527 Sorry, I'm not a psychoanalyst or a psychiatrist. I have no idea.
@@duroorud527 Dreams don't always have "meaning", but they do always have a reason. It could be something in passing through the day, something you've been thinking or worried about, or even something from deeper in the subconscious. It doesn't have to be some greater truth, but there is a reason for your dreams. As for analyzing them, you know your mind better than anyone else ever can. You just need to start thinking about how you think, and asking where your thoughts come from. As you start tracing things back, you'll begin to understand who you are underneath your impulses. That's the Jungian approach to analysis.
video tends to get dysynced in the last third. around 2:40:12 onwards.
Yeah I noticed that after it rendered :// i have no FUCking idea why that happened,
@@vinhighlights5456 will you be able to ever fix that?
or are you willing to?
I always love coming back to this comp. It captures all of the good moments, and then some.
I forgot how depressing this game was
Did you
@@MegaZeta
It's pretty easy to, actually.
It's a game _about_ depression (among other things), so naturally you tell yourself 'this game is depressing'.
Thinking that and _feeling_ it are two very different experiences.
was?
I'll forever wonder what Kojima's crazy writing and Del Toro's amazing character design would have brought us. I love this damn game so much.
Would have been a complete master piece if yamaoka was in charge of the soundtrack
IMO those guys were both bad picks for Silent Hill as a series; whatever else they have going for them, they're both pretty immature
They had Junji Ito and some OG Team Sioent members aswell. Truly a damn shame.
@@MegaZeta Yeah, I'm glad it fell through. I didn't feel they could do it any justice, and PT just felt like Resident Evil 7 with some mind-screw. That isn't what Silent Hill is to me.
@@CosmicWaltz7 I’m sorry… did you seriously just compare a goofy and campy resident evil to the terrifying mind-bending and intense pt gameplay? Did you actually claim the best writers and artists in the genre wanting to recreate this games energy was a bad thing??? In compared to what? Losing the franchise forever? Congrats. Your the only shills on the planet who are happy we lost this masterpiece of a series. Glad people like you can shill a company that corrupt, so easily.
Every time I hear James say "Mary died of that damn disease" I make the most disgusted face
death disorder
(a fatal case)
Pillow overdose
Was it tuberculosis?
Or Lumbago?
or
a *PLAN*
James., the damned disease~ Poor guy.
Who the fuck chose to watch Vinny play this game and start whining that he's cracking jokes? Why are they still there? Just to suffer?
Thank you *so much,* I was literally about to sit down and make a compilation tonight until I found this. Awesome work, loved this playthrough 👍
thank YOU!! that was a very nice comment to read :>
@@vinhighlights5456 I was also just about to comment here and say how great this compilation is. I've played the full video a couple times now as background & haven't gotten tired of it; you did a really great job on it!!
Highly underrated hightlight
That intro he watches at the beginning of the last part gives me the chills.I love Laura's theme.
I did not expect to watch this whole stream, but I'm glad I did.
2:18:30 I find it fucking hilarious that James' enters a room of bugs, and instead of just stepping on them, he fucking swings his bat around then starts shooting them. Imagine if pest control handled all their cases like this.
sielnt hi ll
it sure is man
Silent he'll
penis
Just me, or is James's shadow Harry Mason @ 2:45:05?
It does look like they used Harry's model
Who REALLY died that day? And who came back?
It depends
give him some sauce scoot
Norm's moth joke is absolutely amazing
Spoilers for the end but...
"I will Always Love You." Fucking hell that hit me deep. That ending alone is a fantastic piece of media, but to be included in such an extraordinarily atmospheric and psychologically engrossing game is a wonder in and of itself.
why do I get the puking scene every goddamn time I eat wtf silent hill
That's your personal silent Hill.
@@lasarousi bitch one time I got it while I was extremely hangover *that* was my personal silent hill alright I almost died
this game is sentient I swear to god
i know,right? i was heating up a slice _just_ as that scene came up
You're wondering why playing this game that's only a few hours long at hardest difficulty, or watching an even more condensed highlight reel of it, has you running across the same scene every single time?
@@MegaZeta The point was that the puking scene always seems to come up *while OP is eating*
Don't be an ass.
James will for ever be Jamie.
Jame
beginning music sounds like Zelda TP as Vinny said. The Twilight realm theme from TP sounds very similar.
It took me years to understand what that table monster and the room meant, mostly what that table was.
Maybe because that's not a table, at least in my eyes.
@@lasarousi yeah, its acually a rape scene of Angela and her father/brother and the whole room is themed around.
Its stil a mystery what the 21 holes mean but thinking thats how many times she experience this makes sense.
@@YuubiTimberwolf I think it's not necessarily the amount of times, but the act repeating itself so many times in her head, just the act of penetration in and of itself is what represents the neatly ordered pistons on a higher point of the walls. The room is her own mind suffocating her daily.
Or what I used to think, it's the amount of years it took to overcome her fear of her dad when she finally kills it with the tv and kicks it. But I think she is younger than 21 in the game, but who knows she is already dead for many years before James arrived.
Game's great tho.
How
lasarousi Yah she was 19 before she burned.
"Video games are fun, Video games are fun, make me want to die, video games are fun."
Well... never gonna get the phrase "hosting logs" out of my head now lol
Yesss! Been looking forward to a megacut for Awhile. Thanks sooooo much!
Vinesauce actually being serious for once like this is pretty nice to see.
Eh
@@MegaZeta jesus christ why are you replying to literally every single comment just to be a negative contrarian prick
Probably someone very passionate about the game and well inversed in the game's lore. But let's just say, that passion is worded poorly, so just tone it back a little, eh?
The end fucking hurts me, considering the fact that the protagonists name is James coupled with the conversation that he and Mary had while she was in the hospital dying of most likely cancer, was very similar to how conversations started to go between me and my mother as she deteriorated day by day before she eventually died, love your parents everyone.
3:49:13 Vinny freak out from random disembodied voice “Who the f are you?!” lol
"In Silent Hill 5..." oh Vinnie... they do actually go into Pyramid Head's origin in that game and it's almost as bad as what he said.
Technically it's the creation of A Pyramid Head (i.e. one particular, singular PH) -and its the result of a Bad Ending. Who knows where the O.G. Pyramid Heads (the at least 2 separate ones we see in this one) came from.
Isn't the whole idea of silent hill that it's some sort of personalized hell? How would something born from a guy's psyche have an origin? Or have I completely misunderstood what the series is?
@@329link You got it right. But Pyramid Head is too famous. He was in at least one of the movies too. Don't remember them too well. Because brand recognition
This game freaks me out in a good way.
I love the dark atmosphere,
Also, I’d like to point out that most of the samples in in the music are from a sample CD called “Distorted Reality” By Spectrasonics.
Why do i keep rewatching this !?
_well that made me really upset_
Wow, that ending letter fucking destroyed me. Glad you edited this together.
it's telling when vinny goes quiet for a long time
gonna enjoy this
Laura is going to get called back to Silent Hill and end up constantly locked in rooms with keys stolen from her.
It’s gonna be the whole Alessa/Cheryl adventure again.
I love this game. It's like if I had a crush on someone but they're a horror game. A gorgeous, tearjerking, wonderful horror game. 😢❤
Oh
1:43:55 Vinny sounds so fucking concerned with that *"UmMMM-"*
2:58:00 this is for me
There's so much wrong with that Captain America picture
Hosting logs and squeezing hogs
love that pyramid head fight in the flooded room.
*scraping of weapon and taps of footsteps*
*CLANG* followed by one or two *soft clunks*
rinse and repeat
*Leon?*
The year is 2021. The world is a chaotic mess. And I am sitting here, laughing until I cannot breathe, tears streaming down my face, at Vinny bonking Pyramid Head over the back of the helmet with a wooden plank like he was trying to shoo a raccoon with a broom.
While there’s no lore reason to why pyramid head wears that helmet, the monster designer said he made it that way because he wanted to make it look painful to wear. Sorry for making you find out Vinny
Never realized it before, but Henry Mildred Scott, Hour Minute Second.
Well, yeah
1:11:20
I thougt my phone was viberating on a hard surface
Sounds nothing like that
1:21:28 I can confirm, Sauce Pizzeria in the East Village is quite legit.
I think you should reupload this video. Awesome video but the audio doesn't match in the last 1/3 of the video.
I hope one day vinny plays bioshock on stream!
You wasted all of our ammo there eh Jamie?
I don't know why but that comment was great
1:21:12 nine inch nails story
Lusty for that crusty
i feel depressed now
I almost died at the jingle all the way impressions
The hallway scene with Mary’s monologue at the end is horrifying. For so many reasons.
i fell asleep with youtube running on my laptop and woke up in the middle of the night to the radio blaring static.I then passed out again, and woke up to the ending note from Mary
Vinny also read On The Beach? Didn't think he'd care about decades-old apocalyptic fict- oh. He's talking about a song of the same name.
3:10:53
swoos
nathan fielder
This game is creepy as fuck, and I *love* it!
Do you
@@MegaZeta yes
I watched the full play through a month ago and here I am already nostalgia
Why don't you fucking play the video game
@@MegaZeta Why don't you fucking stop being an asshole
damn i was hoping for in water, hits much harder than leave
In water always ruined the feel of the end for me, then at the end some loud Korn knock-off plays during the credits and it just catches you off guard
@@terranaes1270 totally agree. I don't know what they were thinking, it's just thematically tone deaf.
@@terranaes1270 Yeah, "Angel's Thanatos", one of the goofiest tracks in the entire series. Those first few seconds when it starts to play are maybe this game's weakest overall... at least you can finish the whole game without ever experiencing it
It hits harder, cause Silent Hill is supposed to be like rehab and make someone stronger and finally accept. But like the other 3 that were brought to the town, they just ended up dead...
Right at 2:30:14 my video went to shit.
the graphics were very cutting edge for their time. if you run the game on high enough computer power youll actually have a game that matches some modern consoles.