Building a Warhammer Army Smarter

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 фев 2025

Комментарии • 104

  • @TheOuterCircle
    @TheOuterCircle  Год назад +28

    Technically I should title it "Building a Warhammer army more smartly" but it doesn't look as good on the silly title card you have to engage people with in the 3 seconds they look at your video.... so come after me grammar Yahtzee!

  • @TheCub78
    @TheCub78 Год назад +5

    Nicely done Mr Circle.
    This very much reminds me of the lessons I learned from White Dwarf back in the mid 90’s, and articles from Nigel Stillman (Stillmania). Make a solid core, learn to play with it, learn it’s strengths and weaknesses, then add a new special unit or two to experiment, but always maintain that core.
    And I still do to this very day.

  • @Deredeo13
    @Deredeo13 Год назад +7

    As a former dismounted Army dude, f**k those over-priced tanks. Save your wallet folks, foot sloggers win wars

  • @nightingale4632
    @nightingale4632 Год назад +45

    I wanted to play Word Bearers.
    Bought a single box of the new possessed then tried my colour scheme. Had an awful time, now looking at other legions.
    Seriously, cannot stress enough, start with one model or unit first. Something may look cool and awesome, but you might not enjoy it yourself. Just think of how many people like watching sport but not playing it (or vice versa) our hobby is no different.

    • @Kawanakajima
      @Kawanakajima Год назад

      I agree with everything you said, but turn back to the true Word, Brother! The new CSM possessed suffer from having way too much trim! HH Word Bearers have better sculpts in my opinion.

    • @nightingale4632
      @nightingale4632 Год назад +1

      @@Kawanakajima it isn't the models, it was moreso painting their shade of red that bothered me.
      I might strip them and give it a go again, but atm i'm thinking it might be night lords for my heresy army

    • @sonicwingnut
      @sonicwingnut Год назад

      @@nightingale4632 I found mephiston red on my blood angels guys plus an absolute shitload of agrax earthshade over the top ends up looking like word bearers in terms of colour. Easy win and worth a shot.

    • @nightingale4632
      @nightingale4632 Год назад

      @@sonicwingnut i like my space marines metallic. Might try army painter'a metallic red

    • @sonicwingnut
      @sonicwingnut Год назад

      @@nightingale4632 You could try a metallic paint with red contrast over the top. I think someone told me retributor armour + blood angels red contrast looks amazing.

  • @casualleviathan5926
    @casualleviathan5926 Год назад +11

    A suggestion for a video idea. Do a video about people who do not play the game, but only collect to paint/build an army? Would love to hear your thoughts.

    • @blodugvargar1491
      @blodugvargar1491 Год назад +1

      That's what I'm doing, also because I'm an expat(from Italy to Germany) and it take a lot of time to integrate yourself with the language on a level on wich it's enjoyable to play. At least in the area where I work and live

  • @regularbear
    @regularbear Год назад +5

    As a spin off to this video, something about building a force usable in both HH and 40k would be a great idea

  • @andydogdad4349
    @andydogdad4349 Год назад +2

    I always tell people starting an army to first buy 3 things.... the basic troop and if it's 40k something that has kill team rules. Secondly an hq that works for the start of an army. Third buy an elites choice that you're super excited to paint or have cuz it'll be fun to build and paint and get you hyped for your new army

  • @maxmagnus3793
    @maxmagnus3793 Год назад +21

    I wonder why exactly Heavy Weapons have been made so cheap this edition. Feels like all of them need to be made more expensive, Volkite culverins and lascannons most of all

    • @wormss
      @wormss Год назад

      Yolo that's why

  • @oliverp3545
    @oliverp3545 Год назад +9

    I do get a chuckle out of how obviously bad alot of boxsets are that newer people wouldn't realise because of the marketing of 'more minis for less'.
    Best example is boxsets with named characters, like as a Craftworlds player I already have a Jain Zar so I'm not going to grab the new Boarding Actions kit because even if I want Corsairs and Banshees, I don't win on having a named character that I already have, selling off is annoying, and is quite literally designed to not be kitbashable.

    • @11jerans
      @11jerans Год назад +1

      So your complaint is that the box set marketed for people new to the faction have characters you, a person not new to the faction, already have?

    • @oliverp3545
      @oliverp3545 Год назад +3

      @11jerans literally every box is marketed as 'great for beginners' so don't know what to tell you.

  • @MKHousel
    @MKHousel Год назад

    Love these types of videos! Your honest opinion is why I watch you channel all the time!

  • @sharkbait3644
    @sharkbait3644 Год назад +1

    I have found a good use of 3d printing is as a way to get sample models to test out paint schems before buying into an army

  • @sagacity1071
    @sagacity1071 Год назад +6

    I want to build a militia force... GW thinks I don't deserve rules sadly.

    • @casualleviathan5926
      @casualleviathan5926 Год назад +1

      I have played militia, LOTD, and renegades for years. GW does not like us anymore, that's why I got a 3d printer.

  • @ero9841
    @ero9841 Год назад

    I agree with alot your saying. Some advice that has helped me is setting spending limits and buying used.

  • @HauntedCorpseGaming
    @HauntedCorpseGaming Год назад +1

    Good video.
    Bought two patrol boxes, Trajann Valoris, 2 boxes of Wardens and tracked down the Black Library release for Aleya and Valerian for Custodes then I got some nice proxies off Cults 3D for the Telemon and Calladius to give them a shot; should I feel they perform well I'll eventually replace them with the real models from Forgeworld for store tournaments.

  • @jamesthelamenter5464
    @jamesthelamenter5464 Год назад +3

    It should definitely be encouraging for people to have a test miniature or a few so long as it's a cheap or spare mini.
    If you are straped for money or low on space then you can get a troop choice for a faction that you like then play kill team.
    In my experience it perfectly fine to play kill team especially for first time players.

  • @davefogle7747
    @davefogle7747 Год назад +1

    I've always tested paint schemes on the generic plastic army men that you can get in the dollar store

  • @sonicwingnut
    @sonicwingnut Год назад +2

    Some good advice here - although I'd say if you're happy with a lot of MKVI bodies, what I did is actually bought multiple AoD boxes, and and split them for profit. This was more lucrative just after launch but still do-able now. You can either keep some free units or use the profits to buy more useful ones - Right now buying AoD for £140 at a 20% off retailer would net you £55-60 profit after postage/fees - just list everything on an 80% off fees weekend on Ebay, there's usually a couple every month. Alternatively you could break even but keep a free contemptor and 20x MK VI marines.
    Where I'd kinda differ here from the advice is that having a ton of marines is a bit like the whole thing with colour schemes - they're cheap as shit (or free) so if you get those weapon upgrade kits you can kit a few squads out with different weapons and be able to experiment or play different units. I'd agree the lascannon/autocannon/volkite heavy weapons kit is a great shout, but the special weapons kit is alright too. Pick some weapons you want to try out or think are decent for your legion. Then again, split the weapons upgrades you don't need and chuck em on ebay for a few quid, this makes the cost of making heavy and special weapons squads negligible.
    Another thing is despite what the die-hard grognards say, 40k is still a great source of minis for 30k, so since the vast majority of people getting into 30k right now are coming over from 40k, research what units you already have you could have some fun with while you build your army. Arbiter Ian did a pretty great breakdown of this stuff on his channel. Not sure if Mac has done one too but wouldn't surprise me. Obviously don't go putting Primaris intercessors in your 30k army, but do research what units would fit in 30k. For instance I bought a massive joblot of Blood Angels on ebay for like £45 which included a complete BA tactical squad - if you look at this kit there's actually 5-6 heresy-era armours in there and a ton of fluffy upgrade bits. Sanguinary guard while annoyingly not yet in HH 2.0 are basically a bunch of guys in heresy-era artificer armour. Most people will let you run those guys as dawnbreakers or a command squad.
    Also remember TOC is well-informed, but also mega-opinionated - that's not to say don't listen to his advice, but also get MULTIPLE opinions from various sources when building your army. For instance Hearesy is a great podcast on here for info on various units, legions, tactics etc. Absolutely research what you actually need before hitting that buy button, but if you love a model and wanna paint it, don't let hard opinions on the matter prevent you from enjoying them.

  • @jonathankilby6636
    @jonathankilby6636 Год назад +1

    I'd be intrigued to know your thought on proxies and decent examples of proxies

  • @MrKoalaburger
    @MrKoalaburger Год назад

    That's what I did back when I started playing. I bought a box of cultists to see if I enjoyed painting / could actually invest the time. I enjoyed it, so bought a second box of em to practice (this was 6th Ed, cultists were 50 cents a model on ebay lol).

  • @Sam-vs2es
    @Sam-vs2es Год назад +1

    I wont need my games workshop starter set anymore! I am so smart! S-M-A-T! S-M-A-T! I mean S-M-A-R-T

  • @cloaker2829
    @cloaker2829 Год назад

    "Don't let perfection be the enemy of good"

  • @dariostabletopminatures
    @dariostabletopminatures 2 месяца назад

    Great Great Video!

  • @fogdragon5566
    @fogdragon5566 Год назад

    I’m half tempted to get a second aod box for my sons of Horus allied force

  • @Balevolt
    @Balevolt Год назад +1

    My entire 1.0 army isn't fun to play anymore. Waiting for Blackshields now.

  • @demonic_myst4503
    @demonic_myst4503 Год назад

    I designed my color scheme based on sections shoulders and chest Purple right shoulder and arm grey body black left shoulder helmet purple with silver face plate
    I soend alot time when i get a new style tank looking what areas should be color matched what should be a section and then which to do purple which to do black and grey needs be the main color

  • @cerohero1
    @cerohero1 Год назад

    I would add onto the painting tips, pick 1 thing to put the most effort and time into. So for marines the main armor color. If that 1 thing is done well you can half ass everything else and it'll look nearly as good as someone's marines that they spent a million hours on each marine, especially on table top. For example do the zenithal highlight, contrast to color in, then do a highlight and a wash on the armor. Paint your weapon casings and random other accessories black (don't even bother to highlight or wash it, just get a solid coating), pick a brown for your leather, and so on. You'll finish up way faster and it'll still look great because the majority of the model had more effort put in.

  • @paulgreinke2586
    @paulgreinke2586 Год назад

    Just do you know macca I found this video very useful.
    I've been working on a dread waaaah for 40k and have started with multiple deff dreads. After this video I've realised I probably need some troops before continuing. Thank you for pointing that out.

  • @morgymomo8535
    @morgymomo8535 Год назад +1

    love ur videos

  • @JDSG360
    @JDSG360 Год назад +1

    I don’t know much about the game I’m more of a collector but are HH tank armies a thing?

  • @john12644
    @john12644 Год назад

    Idk how to do a narrative list but would the AOD box work for alpha legion one 20 man, one 10 man tacticals 2 squads of 5 of lernean and one 10 man squad of Cataphractii, a 10 or two 5 man squads of volkite culverins heavy support, Contemptor Dreadnought with two dual volkite, and armillus dynat. I wanna do mostly volkite to kind of theme them all together and I like the paint project aspect of volkite also. But i would prefer to do a narrative list from a book.

  • @RazielLordOfSecrets
    @RazielLordOfSecrets Год назад

    Another thing i do to save money is to look at the force organisation and go what do i need. i have x amount of troops/heavy support/elites but no fast attack. So instead of buying another tank id get some bikes (its an example). then go what would help me next

  • @RSBurgener
    @RSBurgener Год назад

    It took me forever to get my Iron Warriors paint scheme right. I thought "it's silver and brass, easy". No, it's gunmetal and bronze and it's very difficult to get just right. I've stripped a lot of models in alcohol, so many that I think of it as just part of the hobby. If you're playing sports you're gonna have to get x-rays and physical therapy. If you paint models, you're gonna have to dunk em in the alcohol and paint em again.

  • @maxmagnus377
    @maxmagnus377 Год назад

    I honestly don't mind too much that my silver basecoat + akhelian green Alpha Legion does not look completely uniform. It was my first foray into contrast paints and I learned along the way. Especially the Spartan Tank needed a LOT of trial and error to get to a result that was "close enough" to the rest of my army. Yeah it's not perfect, the tank is a bit uneven in its basecoat, the first 2 squads of tacticals were done in a much more heavy handed way than the later units I painted, but I can look at my army and see the progress I made along the way of painting them.
    I do agree with the overall sentiment of the video, but I will say this. The idea of "build your army smarter by buying way more than what's in the base box", while a good tips for more experienced (and affluent) players, the starter box does genuinely make for a decent starting point to build on over time.
    When I do get a cataphractii praetor, the 2 in the box can technically be used as certain consuls. I did add 2 contemptors (one is on the way from the far east after GW discontinued the AL contemptor, but don't tell them that). I was able to convert a squad of taccies into a recon squad by repurposing some old Warhammer Fantasy spears into longer barrels and silencers. And yeah, in the end some of what I have may be shoved off to the side to never be put on the table again, but honestly, as a beginner in Horus Heresy, I prefer that happening organically than buying even more upfront.

  • @rryannn1
    @rryannn1 11 месяцев назад

    I've avoided the astartes battle group box for so many months..I dont need it; but i want it.

  • @thespookymage
    @thespookymage Год назад

    I am curious, what legion or army do you play in Horus Heresy?

  • @titobenito43
    @titobenito43 Год назад +1

    Oh boy a new OC video for me to ignore watching and just comment about how macca is a negative nancy! It must be my birthday!

  • @jahlaniwilliams2468
    @jahlaniwilliams2468 Год назад +1

    Would you recommend adding predators to an army list?

    • @combatwombat2134
      @combatwombat2134 Год назад +2

      I've had some success with them, for sure. That being said, I must say I play Iron Hands - so I've already got an inherent bonuses. I've also got Battlesmith everywhere.
      They have great weapon options, but just take care - if anyone wants one destroyed, it'll be destroyed.

    • @silver9809
      @silver9809 Год назад

      Get 3 of them

    • @TheAlterspark
      @TheAlterspark Год назад +1

      For their points cost they are a workhorse. Varied weapons, low cost to field, etc. I'd say if you need tanks but aren't committed to a RoW or legion that makes them better they are perfectly passable.

    • @jahlaniwilliams2468
      @jahlaniwilliams2468 Год назад

      What kind of load out you guys recommend?

    • @combatwombat2134
      @combatwombat2134 Год назад

      @@jahlaniwilliams2468 melta, las maybe grav. 👍

  • @DrManspread
    @DrManspread Год назад

    Out of curiosity (as someone new to HH): any thoughts on a very tank heavy & infantry light Solar Auxilia force? Just for fun more and having a laugh than any serious expectation of winning anything

  • @markwilliams1892
    @markwilliams1892 Год назад

    Given the new units and so forth do you think it’s worth revisiting your guides on building each legion from the starting box?

  • @chrislevitt4929
    @chrislevitt4929 Год назад

    Macca the hero heresy needs

  • @Lordvader1212
    @Lordvader1212 Год назад +2

    Good video... I would say if you are playing narrative or themed then how good the units are doesn’t matter as much. This kind of play style IMO is more fun, sociable and avoids the meta chasing

    • @TheOuterCircle
      @TheOuterCircle  Год назад

      It shouldn't matter, but I think it kinda does if your favourite unit you've lavished attention on always dies without doing anything... it gets old, you just want them to pull off their ability one time, just one time!

  • @jmt5626
    @jmt5626 Год назад

    MR. Circle quick question i have recently gotten the hours heresy rules books and it seems that game seems simpler the are not a ton of reactions in the different phases i was wondering if you would recommend just using the first edition . the army's I'm interested in Iron Warriors/World Beares and militia any recommendations if a should just wait or use the old rules. Most of the game are narrative and do you have old vides on the imperil militia. please and thank you. PS please don't hang me for the bad grammar.

    • @TheOuterCircle
      @TheOuterCircle  Год назад

      Both have their strengths and weaknesses, 1.0 is the better game, by far, but 2.0 has redeeming qualities.

  • @volcano3493
    @volcano3493 Год назад

    Use training painting schemes with metal marines and never plastic ones. That way you can strip paint without damaging models.

  • @danielkochis5133
    @danielkochis5133 Год назад

    What’s your opinion on buying someone’s mistake army and using that as a base to build from?

    • @TheOuterCircle
      @TheOuterCircle  Год назад

      Nothing wrong with that, if the price is right.

  • @KameradArktis
    @KameradArktis Год назад

    wanted to play alpha legion csm as first army got burned out on painting trim got a chaos knight as a gift now going full chaos knights as i sit here debating iron hand or alpha legion for a 30k army as i got burned on csm your videos are great love the content really helps not buying into the FOMO

  • @falsehero2001
    @falsehero2001 Год назад

    Let’s look at this in reverse: if you got the Age of Darkness box set, what is the legion that is most playable out of the box, o extras needed. My gut says Dark Angels, Imperial Fists, Ultramarines, or Sons of Horus.

  • @colinmack8655
    @colinmack8655 Год назад +1

    I build mine by playing Mantics Firefighr

  • @notnubilous3804
    @notnubilous3804 Год назад

    Macca, with your old group, have ya'll still be trying to get a few games of 1.0 going? Have they all moved to 2.0? I'm curious what some of the older HH playgroups have been doing with this edition and some of the unpleasant rules/rites/datasheets

    • @TheOuterCircle
      @TheOuterCircle  Год назад +1

      We've moved to 2.0, but with issues.

    • @notnubilous3804
      @notnubilous3804 Год назад

      @@TheOuterCircle did you guys agree on any "house rules" to compensate or are you rigorously sticking to the current plates?

  • @TheAlterspark
    @TheAlterspark Год назад

    For me the AoD bundle needs Cataphractii swapped for Tartaros and the Spartan for a Proteus. The two HQs I take or leave because they are surprisingly easy to convert (I made the axe one a librarian and the sword one a chaplain without much trouble).

    • @Kawanakajima
      @Kawanakajima Год назад

      I guess Cataphractii were more iconic for the Heresy and the Tartaros look really small next to the Mk VI.

    • @sonicwingnut
      @sonicwingnut Год назад +1

      I was gonna say the Praetors get a lot of hate on here but even a week after release I saw TONS of amazing conversions of these models. Saw a Dark Angels one of the sword praetor the other day that actually made the stupid giant sword look badass.
      On the Spartan that's pretty much what I did with my second box - got a free Spartan out of selling the bits then realised the Proteus was a better buy, sold the Spartan and bought the Proteus with the money instead.

  • @hironagamaki9744
    @hironagamaki9744 Год назад

    Another great video that hits me where it hurts. And that's fine.
    I bought my army for Death Guard and fair enough I overdid it.
    Fortunately it wasn't much.
    10x mk3 breachers
    20x beanies
    10 deathshrouds ( this I over did. I should have just bought 5 and use 2 40k deathshroud for hq)
    Typhon.
    2 x contemptor dreadnought ( should have held on one and wait for the 2nd)
    And Mortarion for flex ( this I really want for collection so maybe?)
    Still i was tempted to add grave wardens but fortunately I heard off for now. But yeah start small is great advise

    • @djangofett4879
      @djangofett4879 Год назад

      Beanies 😂 im imaging a bunch of helmetless astartes who sudden became self conscious about their hairline

  • @01oo011
    @01oo011 Год назад +1

    Black shields still have nothing. That is all.

  • @wiggy5209
    @wiggy5209 Год назад

    A lot of people i think do look at your videos for more than three seconds. I think you think they only watch three seconds and are not informed as it would hurt your bias.
    Im 1:41 in and already agree -with your first statement for those who are building armies for playing with, to not be enticed by what GW puts out as bundles, that they are usually filled with units noone wanted in the first place and ones with rules that are dire.....for those who collect the models for painting or building/converting however they can sometimes provide a good deal and a good amount of hobby time.
    Its quite difficult justifying "buying models based on game performance" as GW will most likely weaken those units at a later date, making them just as obsolete anyways.....
    You do become a greater painter if you're able to mix colours on the fly, understand how they interact with other colours and surfaces intrinsically and provide consistency on the model throughout, there are gradients of colours that you cant buy. However you dont need to be able to do so to provide a good result, limited ability to buy paint at the time or lack of funds also make it a good idea to at least dabble in mixing yourself ...its just another aspect of the hobby under your belt and one that showcases your experience.

  • @-nope3030
    @-nope3030 Год назад +1

    I actually justified doing SoH originally just simply because Death Guard SHOULD NOT be in MKVI, I dont care what anyone says, and the AoD box set was good value.
    Finished the set and decided I just wasn't interested.
    Started my DG now and I am happy.

  • @ristanraw9321
    @ristanraw9321 Год назад

    Great video, thank you for doing this. Could you possibly do more videos on how to make the best use of the box set for those of us new to heresy who bought one or two box sets before we realized what we were getting into ? Like which legions uses it best, what rites of war etc. Again thanks for all you do !

  • @tabletoptyrant9573
    @tabletoptyrant9573 Год назад

    What’s the fastest anyone here has painted an army?

    • @TheOuterCircle
      @TheOuterCircle  Год назад +2

      Well, on this channel I got the Age of Darkness boxed set on release day, and built, converted with parts and green stuff, painted and based the entire boxed set of 2 praetors, a contemptor, 10 cataphractii, 40 tactical marines, spartan tank PLUS an additional unit, within 3 weeks, whilst working full time, showing off updates on Instagram as I went. I then posted the army on this channel. I feel like that's a really good speed for the level I achieved.

    • @tabletoptyrant9573
      @tabletoptyrant9573 Год назад

      @@TheOuterCircle I followed that what’s more impressive was you customized the army too and green stuffed detail. I’m currently doing the AOD set to see if I can do it in a similar time. Have you played any games with the salamanders?

  • @DeusMachina71
    @DeusMachina71 Год назад +40

    How to build a Warhammer army smarter? Don't buy into GWs ridiculously unfun pay to play mass combat games and just play skirmish.. or 3d print your own and don't buy GW products. I haven't bought anything except 2 Necromunda books over the past 2 years and I feel great..

    • @myrddraalhalfmen9524
      @myrddraalhalfmen9524 Год назад +8

      Pdf rulebooks, wahapedia, 3d printer and recasters made this hobby more comfortable and enjoyable for me. Literally better experience than what I had buying gw only at the start of the hobby

    • @DeusMachina71
      @DeusMachina71 Год назад +3

      @@myrddraalhalfmen9524 I've pretty much moved on from playing GW games except Necromunda and some old school stuff like Mordheim.. I just can't with GW anymore they are just too greedy and the game cool lore aside kinda sucks anyway. I'd rather just play Warhammer Armies fan creation or One Page Rules for large grim dark future games or even mantics games these days even I can't stand the official models are more fun lol. I've been collecting for on and off 35 years I don't need GW toxic greed and bs anymore lol

    • @myrddraalhalfmen9524
      @myrddraalhalfmen9524 Год назад +3

      @@DeusMachina71 Yeah, I can relate. 9th edition was very boring. The only enjoyment from it for me come from the feeling of visiting local wargame clubs and casually moving minis with some guys. But for example Infinity or SW Legion have a fun gameplay that you can actually enjoy. And also could have great narrative, as I discovered with Infinity. (No need to mention Star Wars)

    • @casualleviathan5926
      @casualleviathan5926 Год назад +2

      Also onepage rules are so simple and fun to play.

    • @colinmack8655
      @colinmack8655 Год назад +1

      Mantic games my friends

  • @andrewbakescakes9684
    @andrewbakescakes9684 Год назад

    Sky Hunters not good at all? You are just bad at the game if you think that. They are a high skill ceiling unit.

  • @Kosmajcher
    @Kosmajcher Год назад

    Buiolding Warhammer army smarter... Don't buy warhammer!

  • @Kombereloni
    @Kombereloni Год назад +2

    Step 1:
    Dont.
    Step 2:
    Battletech

  • @digitalcommunist6335
    @digitalcommunist6335 Год назад

    Excellent whine! G W should up prices another 5%!