This is why in *SCANDALS,* we always should stay *NEUTRAL!* This is a reminder that your actions towards people will always have a result, and judging someone so easily is apart of this. It’s all going down like the Woojin situation where he was viciously bullied into his career despite being innocent. I am not saying Garam is 100% innocent, but people should stop harassing her because they think it’s okay when in reality it’s *NOT*
i told those ppl that cyberbullying garam wasnt a solution but they didn't listen, they were all like 'she deserves it' 'this is her karma' 'ur defending her just cuz shes pretty' i was just staying neutral at that point and told ppl to do the same 'wym neutral, its confirmed' 'hybe alr kicked her prob bc shes guilty' 'theres no proof she isn't a bully lmao'. even if she really is a bully and deserves all this, ur being a bully urself, now ur gonna get ur own karma for ruining ones career and mental health.
Die hard K-pop fans and Korean media hold idols and entertainers to a higher standard, and that’s the problem. If these celebs do something less than perfect, it’s a whole controversy blown out of proportion for years. Meanwhile a music artist who grew up drug dealing in project housing wouldn’t get that same scrutiny. Their lives are less than perfect, but they aren’t held to that high standard that Korean entertainers are.
She was also 12 so it was like 4 or 5 years ago. Even if she had been a bully, there was no evidence she continued to do so, so shouldn't have been flogged online for something that happened ages ago.
You guys see now? How do you feel now after cyberbullying, harassing, and ruining a 16 year olds career now that she is proven innocent? We told y'all stop sending hate to her we don't know if she's innocent or not yet but since you guys wanted to act like detectives and control everything the situation got out of control. She deserves an apology from Hybe and everyone else who kept cyberbullying her on the internet, I hope Garam ends up achieving her dream again and debuting in another group! We love you Garam!💖
I'm a Mamamoo stan and I feel so lucky for being their fans - Wheein, even after leaving the company, is still part of the group and they (Moonbyul, Solar and Hwasa) all make efforts to continue as one. I love how they respect and love us fans just as much as we love them. I hope Monta X fans will have the same treatment as us moomoos.
The fact that Garam's ex teammates are not saying anything is just disappointing. I know they're instructed by the higher ups one way or another but its just sad.
I wish the best for I.M cuz im not forgetting what starship did to Wonho. Im so glad Mamamoo is still slaying as a group eventho not every one of them r under the same company and i hope the same goes for Monsta X. The trust in Starship isn't there so i am slightly worried.
THIS IS WHY SOMEONE IS INNOCENT UNTIL PROVENT GUILTY. we are NOT them or anyone who is related to them so we have no right to speculate or say anything abt any situation.
@@bryce1616 there was infact a lot of proof lmao..y'all just didn't decide to pay attention to it bc y'all were busy bullying her w/out knowing if she was guilty or innocent.
@@bryce1616 why can't you research the case for yourself? The first thing I found fishy was the alleged victim claimed she was bullied physically and online by Garam but she never showed proof of this and online bullying is extremely easy to prove since we leave cyber footprints everywhere. That's why they say once it's out there, it's out there. Then she claimed that Garam had a squad of friends who bullied her as well. But she never named any of these alleged bullies. If she was seeking retribution or wanted justice for her alleged bullying, why just hand the alleged bully who was in the spotlight and not the others she claimed harassed her?? Nobody ever came out to say anything similar to what Eunseo was alleging, including the girl who had her picture taken by Eunseo and was the source of the disciplinary hearing, as the actual victim in that, you'd think she'd have something to say. Eunseo, after being expelled, ended up in a school that was right across from Garam and yet this girl allegedly afraid of her bully never tried to switch schools again? And why did she wait until Garam debuted as an idol? She had smoke opportunity while Garam was just a trainee and if she'd done that she would've kept herself anonymous because who is going to care about if a HYBE trainee gets fired??! There were so many signs. But common sense ain't common in everybody, I suppose.
Ever since Source Music disbanded Gfriend (the group that saved them from bankruptcy), I knew it was going to get worse but I didn’t think it would get THIS worse. Poor Garam. I wish her a bright future and I hope she will stay strong enough to never give up on her dreams.
Gfriend saved bighit? Really? Edit: GUYS I AM SORRY I MISREAD IT. I KNOW SOURCE MUSIC IS UNDER HYBE. I ACTUALLY WROTE THIS COMMENT IN A RUSH SO I DIDN’T PROOF READ IT. I AM SO SORRY IF I OFFENDED ANYONE AND I HOPE YOU CAN FORGIVE ME. TYVM!
@@Streamidentity_misamo nobody said that. Op said that gfriend save source music, the label that gfriend was originally under, that was aquired by hybe
I hope she’s doing well, she’s so young and the two weeks she was active in must’ve felt magical to her. the people who bullied her have to be sorry for hurting you garam, u deserve better.
don't say we. You people yeah, some of us decided to use our brains and stayed neutral. I really hope karma gets you and everyone else that BULLIED Garam. Edit: The person that made the comment basically first said they were one of the people that bullied Garam, they changed their comment to look innocent
@@kchill6925 exactly I always stay neutral and it's really funny how they advocate for bullying and literally bullied her told her awful things it was really sick to see this happen so often
@@kchill6925 we as for the people that bullied her, i just didn’t know how to word it. if u didn’t understand me then u can ask for an explanation, not throwing words without understanding what i meant 😗
You also forgot to mention that Garam released the full SVC report on her friend's instagram which pretty much confirms Hybe's statement and Yoo Eunseo as the real perpetrator. The molka incident did happened and Garam was framed this whole time.
I think at this point it's valid to leave it for the court.. If eunsoo or Garam whoever is guilty you won't be able to help them.. What happened has happened .. Garam is no more an idol so just let her live.. By nagging y'all just make it worse leave it for the court
Exactly. The book was literally announced WAY before SNSD announced the comeback. Jessica even announced a possible new solo album WAY before the SNSD announcement
Girls' Generation's last comeback before 'FOREVER 1' was in 2017 with the album 'Holiday Night', which was released for the group's 10th anniversary, not 2015. Just wanted to clear that up cuz it was only 5 years between comebacks not 7, and I don't want inaccurate information to be given out even if it is minor.
@@paulambs that’s what I first thought, but sometimes when groups talk about anniversaries or how long the couple has been together, it’s always plus 1 or something when they speak in Korean.
@@jewljuju i think it's just a matter of speech, like instead of saying "we've been together for 1 year" they say "this is our second year together" in the sense that when 1 year passes another already begins
So upsetting to see this Garam's dreams crushed so fast and at such a young age. I feel the better move would've been just to put her on hiatus until the air was cleared (and HYBE had the evidence to do so). It's very sad to see but I wish her the best. There's no chance she would ever join the group back, but I would love if she could.
actually there is still a chance, with Garam proven innocent .. i hope that SouMu isn't going to turn a blind eye towards the obvious statements and proof of innocence
All this stuff was said early on, weeks ago, why are people acting like it's new info. They simply could have chosen not to harass a child online for actions done when she was 12.
@@GopherCakeStuff didn't garam just release this statement....... yeah, there was evidence early on but people chose not to listen. I don't get what you're saying here
@@sowonbuddy I literally read about most of this info weeks ago, that's what I'm saying. The info was always out there, plus it said the school punished them, so if the school already punished her I don't know why people thought it was up to them to bring out pitchforks for a 4 year old incident.
@@GopherCakeStuff because the point was to ruin her. I mean the alleged victim accused not just Garam but who she called Garam's squad and yet she never named any member of this alleged squad of bullies. She never tried to seek "justice" until after Garam debuted. It was fishy to me from the beginning, but these childish netizens today will look for any reason to hate on somebody.
people just never learn do they? After seeing many idols being accused of bullying, out of which 90% of the time turns out to be false and all lies, still continue to believe them and jump on the hate train for the accused idol. You guys just want excuses to hate and spread hate on idols don’t ya? I feel bad for the poor idols. They are the real victims
@@GopherCakeStuff exactly it’s crazy how random people can just end an idols career off of baseless facts because they know fans won’t do their own research.
Just been watching True Beauty where this topic is a main theme, and how it ends up with the suicide of a idol. The girl is very young and should of been better supported and given a chance, not kicked out. I feel sad for her :-(
The moral of this entire video: Please refrain from taking accusations and speculation of mistreatment and bullying as fact, and remain neutral. The amount of damage the "Fans" can cause to Idols by running away with hate and negativity based on hearsay and unproven assumptions, can be massive. Once that hate train starts, it's really hard to stop it. And then if Fans ended up being wrong, apologies mean nothing, the damage is almost irreversible. So before you judge Idols, please think if your actions actually helps the situation, or makes it worse.
0:10: I'm really hyped for this comeback and I'm sure they won't disappoint 0:48: At first I didn't really like cookie that much but now the song is playing in my head 24/7. I loved all their pre debuts as well and hope for them the best of luck 1:41: I'm happy that Monsta x renewed contract and I hope I.M good luck in the future. Also, I think it's too early to decide how their group activities are gonna go, let's just wait and see 2:41: I'm going neutral on this one. And I don't think the timing is sus cuz a novel takes 2-3 years to publish and her novel was released after their comeback so I think she added that line in her book before then. But again, I'm going neutral 5:11: I do believe that hybe debuting this many groups is chaotic but I wouldn't worry about it too much 7:19: I think Garam is innocent and it's like that whole Soojin scandal again. I kinda feel bad for her since that was only when she was young and that I'm sure she knows her wrongdoings
Garam is now starting to remind me of Mina and Jimin situation where they went back and forth playing the “ my words against yours” game until someone came out with hard evidence against Mina which caused the situation to go 180
Okay but saying she’s 16 so she doesn’t know what she’s doing is stupid. Im younger than her and i’m more mature. I know what’s wrong and what’s not and if i’m wrong in a huge argument i’m gonna apologize instead of making it even worse.
for some reason I hated ta-ki for the whole show, I’m sorry ta-ki I was envious (also K deserved to be in Enhypen, I loved him so much on the show and he was so good)
Monsta X are one of my ults and seeing Wonho leaving the group was so painful. If it's gonna be the same with I.M I'm ready to fight Starship. How come most companies are too incompetent at managing their groups? Isn't that their job?
I agree. I.M is an essential member of the group, how come I can see that clearly and the professional agency don't? Starship has proven to be a sh*tty company before but this is just beyond words. I got the feeling they want to destroy Monsta X.
I don't think he'll be gone. I mean, there's other groups now that have members in other agencies but they are still a group. Every Got7 member is in a different agency but they have made a comeback. It took longer since they were all in different agencies, but since Changkyun is the only one going elsewhere, it might be different for Monsta X.
I am happy that I never hated kim garam, and I'm also glad she is proved innocent, y'all call her a bully while y'all yourselves were cyberbullying and harrassing a 16 year old teen girl and ruined her whole career, ngl but she had perfect vocals and voice, I'm feeling awful for her. Poor garam😣
I am thankful and feel good about how i was neutral all along...i never hated her or brought her down... But i was attacked by ppl just coz i asked them to be neutral. She was heck of a performer, prolly the best after Yunjin and Chaewon honestly..she did so well in their debut song and screw those so called OT5 fans who hated Garam.
@@iwasthebugatsowoozoomuster2021 like i love chaeyeon(ex-izone) with all my heart but saying how hybe shld kick garam out and put chaeyeon in is sickening-
Same, glad i was staying neutral the whole time 😭 i feel so bad for her tho, she deserves to be in the group. She worked so hard to debut and then some bish just felt the need to ruin her future and life
@@Marksbsfong The are some chats of eunseo planning to destroy garam's career, this is also reforced with the pictures in Garam insta stories when they where really friendly and even resolved everything after the picture incident
I honestly can't imagine how crushing garam feels rn. Like reaching your dream after so much hard work then just gettinh it taken away from not even when your 2 steps in, is so sad. I hope for the best for her
@@bryce1616 Hey troll, if you don't do anything important in your life and just be here on social media spreading hate, I suggest you don't go online and ask senseless questions. You're a capable human being that can use the internet. Research for yourself if you are actually looking for answers. The truth always comes out and in Garam's case, it already has, with enough proof by the way. So do everyone a favor and get away from social media before karma comes at you.
No matter how much we need Garam back, there's no chances of getting her back, Hybe ended their contract with her. HYBE and Source music were so stupid to not let her talk. #KimGaramIsInnocent
Hybe and SouMu don't have the authorities to "let her talk".. Garam is still a minor.. Whether she takes this to court or not rests entirely on her parents..
0:10 nct 127 cb!! 0:49 new jeans new achievement 1:41 monsta X 2:40 girls generation + Jessica 5:12 hybe's new grps 7:18 garam Have a nice day/night...bye! 🧡
First of all, it's the first comeback of SNSD in 5 years and not 7(the last one was in 2017). Second I won't consider SNSD'S comeback as a mess.. it's their most successful comeback to date in terms of sales, RUclips, Spotify, iTunes and more platforms. Yes covid is a b**ch but unfortunately it's effected a lot of groups before too, and as I understood it sm didn't cancel the music shows attended just moved it to the following week. Get well soon our precious maknae Seohyun, we love you 💗💗💗
Yea thats how I understood it as well, that they will continue next week when Seohyun is out of quarantine! Its not like theyre canceling everything since theyve already done so many shows and want to show us the best!!!
SNSD was supposed to be on Music Bank this friday 20220812 and they cancelled that however every other schedule is still on hold.. Seohyun herself posted on insta story that they will probably perform next weeks friday 20220819 since she can test herself free after 7days which would be on monday or tuesday.
Poor Garam, I feel so bad for her. She had to survive in this crucial world. Hope she’s doing her best. I’ll support her either way, she apologized and got kicked out already. Fighting Garam! 💗
Garam has went through *_A LOT_* . She is just 16 and faced a lot of difficulties after her debut. I hope she comes back as a soloist or as a part of the group.
i REALLY wish she comes back, but the thing is, the chances are EXTREMELY low. I've never heard of a group member who leaves coming back. especially when they faced a bullying case
@@ryujinswig3253 that is also a fact. Hybe should have taken time in solving the case rather than putting the fans through a frenzy. As soon as she was kicked out of the group many fans were happy but on the other side many were devastated.
@@anjanaathularavindakshan8076 Girll don't blame hybe at all, blame those crazy netizens who pressured hybe to kick her out. Yall gott stop blaming company's for everything that happens.
@@Valentina_Bae but Hybe should not listen to any hater (they can make their own decisions), all they have to do is to find out the truth, and then do what is good for Garam and the company. it's so braindead to kick out someone bc ppl tell you to do it. so Hybe deserves to get blamed aswell.
@@oliviyasss I think what they meant is to draw lines but hold accountable mean to make someone take the responsibility for their actions... That's what I know
I have never felt so bad for anyone, but Garam, she is just 16 and going through so much, she is so talented and I so badly wanted her to go on with her career, she was my bias and I literally love her so much, but now nothing can be changed so I wish her good luck. She will always be in my heart.
Correction: SNSD came back after 5 years not 7! They had their comeback for their 10th year in 2017, solo activities for 5 years and now back for their 15th year! #SONE
I.M isn't leaving Monsta X and they are still together as a group, and I'm happy for him having more career opportunities out there. It isn't always something bad but positive if we look from both sides of thing and ask what's truly matter. I'm wishing them the best and can't wait to see what they'll bring in the future 💜
Hybe has many other entertainment companies under it so we can really expect them 5o debut 4 groups a year but it really needs to start treating them well anyway i am really excited for pledis new group as it will be first group after seventeen since 2015 and offcourse trainee A i have been waiting for their debut since last year
Come on now Jessica has started a new career and she will also be participating in her new survival group. I hope both SNSD and Jessica have a smooth career. The proof that SNSD exists is not from the sales but how they got together again after 15 years of their career.
This is so crazy. If HYBE held out a little longer, she would have been proven innocent and then Le Sserafim could have continued as a 6-member group. I wonder what all the netizens who insisted on her getting kicked out have to say for themselves now...
Oh they still think she’s a bully just because she cursed at eunsoo (the real bully). They don’t care if garam’s friends and family comes forward and tell the truth cuz all they care about is how bad her image/actions were at the age of 12 🙄
The problem is Garam's friends sent this information to HYBE, however they ignored them. This made people speculate they used her as noise marketing. Garam clearly has the official documents to prove her innocence but i guess HYBE stopped her from releasing them under her contract. So sad, a young girls dreams crushed based solely on speculation.
As long as she was with hybe, all the proof we have now wouldnt be public and shed still be known as a bully. Hybe was probably noise marketing or couldnt do much with the proofs they recieved as everyone involved were and still are minors. Either way garam couldnt have continued as a lesserafim member
@@yanc4237 i agree, sadly even though its not what people made it out to be, she would have still had the image of the bully if HYBE couldnt release documents. Therefore people would be more likely to avoid the group.
Even though Jessica isn’t in Girls’ Generation anymore, she will always be involved with the group one way or another whether it’s controversially or just remembering her time with GG. SNSD started as 9 and it was like for 7 years, it’s just something you can’t erase from the groups history.
@@russjordan6039 what? She's not nice? She's too nice that's why sm tried everything to ruin her career. Did you even know how sm banned her from any south korean radio and tv shows?
@@russjordan6039 are you a psycho? You’re acting like you know her personally or know what actually happened. Even if the truth is somewhere in the middle you have no reason to say those nasty things.
The worst thing to me is that it doesn’t seem like the people that bullied Garam off of the internet are satisfied with getting her kicked out of the group. People are still saying malicious and unnecessary things to her and it honestly makes me sad. I hope that of being an idol is still her passion that she can debut in another group or as a soloist (how cool would that be) but also I’d 100% respect it if she decided to do something else. I hope she’s doing okay
Please watch the video by Doyouram Everday K-Culture ruclips.net/video/1wIL-u9N2vQ/видео.html It has the full account of the school violence committee uploaded by Garam herself. It states that Garam and Eunseo were both at fault. Garam even apologized saying that she admits she was wrong and that she was immature back then. So technically Garam is not innocent. But people should stop attacking her since she now apologized.
@@kraye5908 I know she's not fully innocent, but a lot of the "evidence" and claims people used against her were not real. Guilty or not, she's still a minor, and her mental health isn't being valued. Thanks for the video :)
@@beaqi_ Yes, there were a lot of claims from both sides that were not true. That is why I said people should stop sending hate towards her. She can still move forward since she is young. And I really appreciate that she posted the full report even if it shows that she did cyber bully Eunseo. that was a very commendable act on her side. Then she apologized and realize that she was wrong and immature back then. I really hope people would leave her alone now. I wish her well.
Y'all are so fast to accuse someone Then go bully them and act like you know a lot yet walk around saying "innocent until proven guilty"...that's why it's always good to mind your business and that's what I'll do from now on just leave it where it's .. what do you think you can for her now she already got kicked
Don't count me in that. You can look up my comments, I defended her from the beginning because it never made sense to me. I think part of it is because I did believe Mina over Jimin and I didn't want to ever get that wrong again.
@your dad who left anyone who believed eunsoo are sheep who don’t know how to think for themself. i knew it was clear as day that eunsoo’s side was suspicious and had many holes from the start and i guess i was right
@sanawebs why were u searching for proof that looked believable? u should be searching for proof that is real. the proof released that made me the most sus was the svr because there wasn’t any context and eunsoo’s lawfirm never lived up to their promise. auto red flag. also, i was neutral but leaning a bit toward garam
@sanawebs lmao it’s not hybe’s fault y’all were accusing them of lying. look now, garam turns out not be a bully but yet ur still calling her a bully? so u agree that there’s nothing wrong with hacking someone’s facebook to post innapropriate pics of a minor and attempting to get people framed but then act like a victim that didn’t start all of this crap?! eunsoo is the real bully here, and looks like ur the bully too
Why do people suddenly blame Hybe for Garam's case. They tried to protect her, published statement about her situation, but noobody believed them, their employee turned on them, their stocks went down, still they tried. The ones at fault are the netizens, the haters, the RUclipsrs, and all the ones who bullied her out of her group, in the name of anti-bullying. Even this channel accused her of having a relationship with a Hybe executive, just because Hybe tried to protect her. What goes around comes around, when you lost your job or dream, it's probably because of the bad deeds you sow.
HYBE released a complete detailed statement about this issue two months ago to prove her innocence but i totally ignored it cause a lot of kpop stans said it was full of shit 😭. I’m so dumb to believe them. Kpop fans are toxic af.
Hybe caved-in to the netizens calling for Garam to be kicked out. I thought since HYBE released the report about Garam's friend being bullied by Yoo Eunseo, that would mean HYBE would ignore anything Yoo Eunseo had to say. That would be like allowing the wolf to cry "wolf" (Bully complaining about being bullied). The announcement that Garam was being kicked out was a surprise. The long delay and rumors about Garam making a comeback, led me to believe HYBE was going to tell haters to "take a hike" (shut up and ignore them). Hope Garam can recover from this and make a debut again somewhere else.
I won't lie, Garam was my bias from the get go.. Then all of these happened and I was sad, her dream was crushed...and now see. I mean this is not fair
This is why it is important to know every side of a story. I admit myself I jumped to a conclusion without knowing all details (I'm personally sorry Garam). Seems like it was just two girls who had a tiff with each other during school. Something that most of us can relate to. I think it shows a lot of maturity and humbleness to apologize for a past mistake and honestly makes me quite frustrated that Hybe/Source didn't let her release the report and a full statement/apology in the first place. Garam had the information and willingness all along and could have set the record straight. Source/Hybe let her down from the start. I know its pretty much impossible now but I'd love to see Garam back in Le Sserafim, even though a part of me would also love to see her excell with a different group and company. Too little, too late I suppose. Regardless, I truly wish the best for her and hope to see her debut again soon.
I too jumped to a conclusion extremely fast and I personally think that the report shows that it was equal on both sides with Yoon Eunseo majorly acting like a victim when she also did wrong. It seems like arguments that got out of hand and a person with a will to end someone's career. I hope she can move forward and find happiness.
@@simsimah exactly. Netizens acted like garam wrung the neck of their mamas and supported an actual bully! Eunseo received lvl 6 punishment, the one where serious punishment actually starts….. but people just wanted more drama and ruined garam’s life. They literally don’t realise that a bit of drama is enjoyment to THEM but for others it can be living HELL
@@simsimah I personally don't have any vitriol against Garam. As you said I dont know her. More so I'm very sensitive to the subject of bullying in general, from my own past experiences, and sometimes that can unfairly cloud my judgment about certain situations. I will say it was more so I was favoring Eunseu's side of the story because at the time it was the only one providing evidence (I say that loosely now) to support her claim while Garam was sadly forced to remain quite. Definitely one of those "There are three sides to every story: your side, my side, and the truth" moments. I hope that helps clarify a bit.
Bright came out months ago, this drama also came out also months ago. Sooyoung, Taeyeon, Yoona got most of the blame because readers predicted it was them who were the “mean” characters or something. You’d think there’d be a disclaimer in the book considering it IS fiction. She knew what she was doing when she released the book, she knew her fans would go and predict who was who and take every little thing in the book seriously.
The book is literally presented as fiction, that's the disclaimer. She never said it was a biography but people are taking it as such. You can't blame Jessica for people being stupid lmao
@itsnaralyn other members started businesses or were acting and doing all sorts of other things. It's literally no different. Why do yall keep blaming Jessica for what fans believed loool Plus yall always do this where you paint one member as an angel and another as a devil when you know neither of them. They both could have been a problem with moving forward as a group.
im disappointed with Jessica. SNSD is still the group that make her popular. its not like she debut solo or something. still throwing shade after all these years are disappointing. i love u jessica and love all the members too. please stop 😢
Garams career cannot be saved, her reputation has been ruined. I don't know what she will do next, wish her all the best but the idol life is not for her
Hybe is very different to other companys.. Hybe is just the "Name" and under them are so many different companys like bighit pledis source music.. its like every company is debuting 1 group which isnt a bad thing. its like if jyp yg and sm were put together and each of them would debut a group -
How can you blame Jessica for releasing her book, Bright, during the promotion of SNSD's new song? Jessica's book was released on May 10, 2022. You guys should fact-check before you believe what Knetizens.
This is literally the same channel which highlighted all the negative rumour about garam , a 16 yo minor and people were bashing her in comment section with all those vague evidence ruining her career before it even started ...................... At this point kpop stans should never throw their regards without even knowing the case deeply. I really hope she gets all the love she needs for healing. ( not guilty until proven ). When this channel wanted her kicked out of the group , hybe did it's best to protect their artists. PS : this channel works for pure attention seeking .
I kinda miss the promotions that monsta x had in the first comebacks in the agency and the legendary comebacks, i hope that this will be a new fresh start. Also I want u to remember that actually mamamoo are doing the same thing, they did the Kpop flex as 4 members soo yeah, let's hope that
it’s weird how you said monsta x’s future is uncertain when starship themselves already included in their statement that *changkyun will continue promoting with the group*, he’s literally included in monbebe 7th generation announcement. if starship was planning to remove him after he left the agency, starship won’t release the 7th generation recruitment with him 5 days into being a free agent. anyways monsta x are set to do a 3-day seoul concert this september, perform in thailand, headline nickfest, and are preparing for new music (solo and group) WITH CHANGKYUN.
Jessica lost her longtime friends in a blink of an eye she deserves to be happy and successful stop the hate I mean the girls will not think of her if they want to release something why would she
@kookielit you should also apologize you have been spreading misinformation about her. You have contributed to the reason why many people hate her. Have some shame.
But when hybe first said she was innocent y'all denied it and demanded further investigation. Hybe once defended her but the world was so mad. Now hybe is blamed bcz they let garam out 🤨🧐
Let's be honest the Garam situation is actually a good example of hypocrisy, hybe tried to keep her and defend her but everyone questioned this decision, her new statement is literally the same that hybe posted but now suddenly everyone believes her just because they already fire her
I.M didnt leave Monsta x, he just only left company and will continue being in monsta x, as 6 members. we dont need any drama around it and we trust and believe in Monsta x, they know better what is good for them and im also gonna support I.M no matter what his desicions in the future will be. lets just wait and see how things will go!!!
I never believed that Garam was a bully, there’s always bullying allegations to every idol. Also, kicking an idol out because she “bullied” somebody when she was a CHILD makes no sense. People can’t grow and change? I’ve always thought Garam was innocent *edit: guys I didn’t think people would fight over this. I was saying that people can grow and change and reflect as they grow older. Forgiveness is not a thing? I don’t think she was a bully. Almost every idol was accused of being a bully. For example, Nam Joo-hyuk, Karina, Garam, Jimin (AOA), etc. This is just the media trying to make idols look bad when they debut. I respect your opinions tho.*
Korea has a very strict law against bullying so when idols/ actors or models are rumored to be bullies they usually go to court. When it comes to idols they either be on hiatus for a few months to years until it dies down or get kicked out the group to save face of the group. Which is why I think HYBE kicked her out to save face of the group.
The timing of Jessica's book and girls' generation's comback is close to each other bc they all just decided to release their things in their debut month. I know Jessica isn't a part of snsd but still she debuted in August too.
@@JustMe-qd6er kookielit is always spreading lie n making something small big. jessicas book was announced like a year ago then it keeps on getting pushed back n was finally published in may.
Good for newjeans! They are so talented and there music is just so good! Like arguably the best debut music I’ve ever heard, literally all 4 songs on repeat the last week. I really hope they don’t get cursed by Hybe controversy and continue in this trajectory because I am really excited to see how they grow.
1. SNSD came back after 5 not 7 years 2. They sold 100,000+ on their 1st day, first week. 3. They topped 1 in 31 countries for iTunes and top 1 worldwide 4. Better talk about Jessica what her real motive is because for us SONES, we just want to enjoy this success and comeback. All negativities and bitterness from the "protagonist" is unwelcomed. Jessica can write her book whatsoever, involve SNSD there or what, if that's what makes people read her book, then it's fine. Jessica, is Jessica, kicked out from the industry because of her own desires. SNSD is SNSD with or without Jessica, SNSD is happier and successful without even bringing up her name. SNSD is still legendary and the nation's Girl Group, even without her. Yes, she was popular, but now, even Taeyeon herself can be 10 times more successful than her. Stop bringing jealousy because all SNSD members are doing their whole damn thing. Actresses, Soloists, DJ, Variety Hosts, MCs, Chefs, Song Writers, and etc. With all those success they got as a group and individually, I think the one should be Jeaoulus is THAT WOMAN herself. Period.
And ppl still believe she's speaking the whole truth bcos she's the only one speaking lmao 😂, Anyways I'm also a SONE and enjoying SNSD's comeback, I'm not craving for her to comeback to the group because there was a lot of damage done already and they've strived well for the past 8 years but I wish the blacklistment be removed 🥲
Jessica from being my second bias to nothing now. After Bright and all her sabotaging against her former members, I cannot stan her anymore. What a cheap way to sell books. Day by day I’m losing respect with all her drama and gimmicks. Admit it or not, until now she cannot forgive herself for messing up her priorities that lead up to the 2014 events. With all the mishaps and lawsuits that her so-called “fashion company” faced. Thanks to her ugly and scammer of a boyfriend, Tyler. What she does nowadays, releasing bright the same period as GG’s comeback, and joining a cheap china show is purely pathetic tbh. She’s nowhere now while GG are thriving in their own fields, and still can comeback as a whole group despite different agencies. Sorry J, if you never met Tyler, you’d still probably be in GG making a comeback now. Regret is always in the end, Girls’ Generation all the way. #OT8 Haters be hatin’, GG always slayin’.
why the heck is SNSD comeback a mess? nope. it wasnt, its even successful! and we dont care about the public opinion because the comeback is for the fans, SONEs so its okay to think otherwise. as for their music show performances it was not cancelled it was just moved for next week, Seohyun isnt to blame,healthy or not you can be hit by Covid. And they are all free and can compromise so they wont perform with just 7 they will wait for Seohyun and knowing her she can recover quickly. All of their schedules are just moved for next week. They will ecen attend SMtown as a whole group and I am so excited for it❤️❤️❤️❤️🥰🥰 get well soon Seohyun!!!
There is alot more posted about the Garam situation the full transcripts for the SVC has been posted and translated. Her being removed from Lesserafim was unjust and she deserved better,.
I feel like when all such bullying allegations come up, the idol should be allowed to speak in front of cameras instead of letting the company handle it behind the scenes and letting people just be oblivious to the real situation. People never get to hear both sides. So if the alleged victim is telling their end of the story, the idol should be given a chance to tell theirs too.
Jessica released Bright in early May, at least in the US. Maybe the July release was Asia/Korea? I really don't think that's intentional to sabotage GG's comeback.
-i’m too hyped for 127’s comeback, i miss them so much 🥹 -i wasn’t into monsta x ever but i wish them the best, maybe i’ll listen to them in the future -i think what happened with jessica wasn’t fair but also she could’ve postponed the release of her book. -hybe is going bonkers with its plans to debut new groups. learn to manage your existing groups first and then debut more smh. -garam is too young to be going through all of this backlash and hatred and i hope she can do something good for herself in the future.
Kim garam is innocent because she defended her friend. everyone keeps saying garam is a stalker and they keep defending a person who photographs an underage girl in her underwear. do you think defending a friend from this type of person who has no respect for personal privacy is stalking? you are wrong, not her.
I feel really bad for Garam omg,imagine she trained for months and hours and she would just get kicked out of the group? Come on now she alr confirmed it herself that she's innocent and all she did is to protect her friend,I would never forgive those people who ruined Garam's dream and career she even said on the letter (?) "Even though I only got the dream of mine for 2 weeks,I would cherish those moments forever" something like that I think? I feel so bad for her esp her mental health and she's just 16 years old,idk I'm so annoyed at Hybe rn why didn't they even TRY to protect Garam:(
Please watch the video by Doyouram Everday K-Culture ruclips.net/video/1wIL-u9N2vQ/видео.html It has the full account of the school violence committee uploaded by Garam herself. It states that Garam and Eunseo were both at fault. Garam even apologized saying that she admits she was wrong and that she was immature back then. So technically Garam is not innocent. But people should stop attacking her since she now apologized.
When hybe was not canceling her contract, you guys blamed hybe. When hybe made garam debut, you guys blamed hybe saying that how can one company take trainees without background check. Now you gus are hating hybe for not letting her tell her side story. Always blaming someone for own fault.
They literally covered the members solo parts in the japanese version of boomerang with Jessica's voice when they remade it. You have to listen hard to hear the other members on that song. Imagine getting woke up at 6 am to record music, to sing 8 words and then you cant even be heard because the producers favorite is over you and all you add is texture. Was she the most popular no but she was favored musically especially in Japan. The dancers barely sang on that first album. The Great Escape is one of their best tracks period. Best by a kpop group period but it was basically Taeyeon, Jessica and Seohyun with some Tiffany
IKR! they were even making assumptions of her having connections and her family being rich. And remember they were saying that hybe used taehyung and jennie to back up garam's scandal? Really- kpop stans believe and assume anything that justifies what they believe in in a very unhealthy amount
@@OldDannyDevito the thing is… they’re still not on her side. Most of the kpop stans aren’t really mad at the bullying issue. They just want an excuse to hate on someone. And now that she’s trying to clear her name, they either don’t care or switch and put the blame on the company (I’m not even a hybe bootlicker but some people really need to stop using Garam’s case to justify their hate on a company. For me that’s tactless)
@@ya.02 I was thinking the same. Like weeks or month ago the way this channel talking against about Garam and fueling the uncomfirmed rumors and now they are like showing the innocence of her....
I think NewJeans is BOP, i am really their big fan ! I am impatiently waiting for HYBE Japan group to debut! I really wanna see K, Nicholas, EJ and Taki finally accomplish their dreams! I have been their fan since I-land! Also I am highly anticipating Trainee A's debute too , we all know they are gonna be totally amazing! JJ is actually so far my favourite member! And about Kim Garam's matter, I have always been saying this and I'll say this once again... Lesserafim will never be same without her, she was actually my favourite member in the group! She was really talented, pretty and fought hard for her dreams to debut! But in the end her career and mental health just got ruined due to these psycho cyberbullys who have nothing better job to do other than throwing hate online at people. I just wish her bright future. Many people are thinking that Source Music may take her back in the group since the air has cleared out now, but I don't think this is gonna happen! I just hope she will at some point make debut again under some agency... I'll be rooting for her until then 💜
So sad how people were like imagine being an idol for two weeks and garam still cherish those two weeks as part of her dream. She is honestly such a sweet girl and didn’t even bash her haters!!Garam come back when you’re ready and we’ll give you all the power and support you need.
Am I crazy to think that a certain comeback was moved up to line up with a certain book launch, so the controversy helps with sales. I am a soshi fan, but also well aware of what SM is like, nothing is ever what is seems
I feel bad for Garam. She got so much unnecessary hate for nothing. I'm glad I always stayed neutral. It feels like the history repeated itself. Remember the Soojin scandal? Stupid haters, what do you have to say now? After knowing about so many K-pop bullying scandals and how most of the idols accused of bullying were proven to be innocent, I decided to stay neutral. After all, nothing was confirmed by Garam herself so why haters had to send hate for her? It's not like she harmed you. I really appreciated her singing skills and stage presence. She could have achieved her dreams and become a great idol but see, what have you done. We first lost Soojin, and now Garam. I just wish Garam could again become a K-pop idol. It is her dream and I know she would do a excellent job as an idol. HYBE and everyone out there, #ApologizeToGaram .
So true. Me personally i am so sad about Garam's situations because it's like Soojin's case is repeating itself. As a Soojin stan i still tear up sometimes thinking about how a bunch of lies ruined her life and career. Now the same thing happened with Garam it's so heartbreaking.
Please watch the video by Doyouram Everday K-Culture ruclips.net/video/1wIL-u9N2vQ/видео.html It has the full account of the school violence committee uploaded by Garam herself. It states that Garam and Eunseo were both at fault. Garam even apologized saying that she admits she was wrong and that she was immature back then. So technically Garam is not innocent. But people should stop attacking her since she now apologized.
People mentioning the timing being suspicious is absolutely ridiculous. A book release is often set MONTHS before they are released, sometimes its even set when its still being edited. Its likely her book date was set before the comeback even received a date. Its the publishing company that has a say in her deadline and release date. Are you all suggesting her publishing company knew of SM's plans for a GG comeback and released the book in the timeframe SM had in mind for the comeback? Please, this ain't Spy X Family.
Both I.M and Starship Entertainment made it VERY clear that they were still staying together as a 6 member group and he would be participating in all group promotions. I don't know why people are not understanding that. They couldn't have made it any clearer.
For everyone continuing to hate on garam are bully’s, yall say u hate garam bc she’s a bully but ur guys are cyber bullying her. Stop being such a hypocrite.
That's the reason why I don't speak until everything is over and done with.... But I do think hybe is only debuting all these groups to fill in the hole that's going to be left by bts and their solos/vacas/enlistment futures
2022 being a gg year ✨ Got the beat debut , IVE debut , Ke1per debut , NMIXX debut , Le serrefim debut , new jeans debut . Wonderful comebacks from ITZY, Ke1per, IVE , MANY MORE the most awaited comebacks of blackpink and girls generation
Garam deserves justice, she explained her side of the story and whether or not she was a bully (she is not but I'm not saying she is completely innocent), she still worked very hard to achieve her dream, to debut. Everyone that disregarded her in the group was also wrong, you listened to other peoples accusations without even bothering to hear her own side. She said in the message that she acknowledged she was wrong. I was always neutral and believed she was not a bully and not just because of looks. But because it all didn't make sense. She really deserves better and maybe even to be put back in the group, you never know.
This is why in *SCANDALS,* we always should stay *NEUTRAL!* This is a reminder that your actions towards people will always have a result, and judging someone so easily is apart of this. It’s all going down like the Woojin situation where he was viciously bullied into his career despite being innocent. I am not saying Garam is 100% innocent, but people should stop harassing her because they think it’s okay when in reality it’s *NOT*
EXACTLY
spat nothing but FACTS!
i told those ppl that cyberbullying garam wasnt a solution but they didn't listen, they were all like 'she deserves it' 'this is her karma' 'ur defending her just cuz shes pretty' i was just staying neutral at that point and told ppl to do the same 'wym neutral, its confirmed' 'hybe alr kicked her prob bc shes guilty' 'theres no proof she isn't a bully lmao'. even if she really is a bully and deserves all this, ur being a bully urself, now ur gonna get ur own karma for ruining ones career and mental health.
Die hard K-pop fans and Korean media hold idols and entertainers to a higher standard, and that’s the problem. If these celebs do something less than perfect, it’s a whole controversy blown out of proportion for years. Meanwhile a music artist who grew up drug dealing in project housing wouldn’t get that same scrutiny. Their lives are less than perfect, but they aren’t held to that high standard that Korean entertainers are.
She was also 12 so it was like 4 or 5 years ago. Even if she had been a bully, there was no evidence she continued to do so, so shouldn't have been flogged online for something that happened ages ago.
You guys see now? How do you feel now after cyberbullying, harassing, and ruining a 16 year olds career now that she is proven innocent? We told y'all stop sending hate to her we don't know if she's innocent or not yet but since you guys wanted to act like detectives and control everything the situation got out of control. She deserves an apology from Hybe and everyone else who kept cyberbullying her on the internet, I hope Garam ends up achieving her dream again and debuting in another group! We love you Garam!💖
Pls, innocent where?
@@atinydeobij1024 Whether she is innocent or not that doesn’t give people permission to bully someone else
@@cozwhynot2day didn't say it did. But saying she's "innocent" is wrong
@@atinydeobij1024 You just want to harass a 16 year old don't you?
@@atinydeobij1024 Because she IS really innocent, thats why we have the reason to call her "innocent"
I'm a Mamamoo stan and I feel so lucky for being their fans - Wheein, even after leaving the company, is still part of the group and they (Moonbyul, Solar and Hwasa) all make efforts to continue as one. I love how they respect and love us fans just as much as we love them. I hope Monta X fans will have the same treatment as us moomoos.
The fact that Garam's ex teammates are not saying anything is just disappointing. I know they're instructed by the higher ups one way or another but its just sad.
I wish the best for I.M cuz im not forgetting what starship did to Wonho. Im so glad Mamamoo is still slaying as a group eventho not every one of them r under the same company and i hope the same goes for Monsta X. The trust in Starship isn't there so i am slightly worried.
THIS IS WHY SOMEONE IS INNOCENT UNTIL PROVENT GUILTY. we are NOT them or anyone who is related to them so we have no right to speculate or say anything abt any situation.
Is she innocent? Hoe it was proven?
Lol,,was there any proves 😴
@@bryce1616 there was infact a lot of proof lmao..y'all just didn't decide to pay attention to it bc y'all were busy bullying her w/out knowing if she was guilty or innocent.
@@kpopistic6143 lol...you did ,right ,,then link please 😴😴😴
@@bryce1616 why can't you research the case for yourself? The first thing I found fishy was the alleged victim claimed she was bullied physically and online by Garam but she never showed proof of this and online bullying is extremely easy to prove since we leave cyber footprints everywhere. That's why they say once it's out there, it's out there.
Then she claimed that Garam had a squad of friends who bullied her as well. But she never named any of these alleged bullies. If she was seeking retribution or wanted justice for her alleged bullying, why just hand the alleged bully who was in the spotlight and not the others she claimed harassed her??
Nobody ever came out to say anything similar to what Eunseo was alleging, including the girl who had her picture taken by Eunseo and was the source of the disciplinary hearing, as the actual victim in that, you'd think she'd have something to say.
Eunseo, after being expelled, ended up in a school that was right across from Garam and yet this girl allegedly afraid of her bully never tried to switch schools again?
And why did she wait until Garam debuted as an idol? She had smoke opportunity while Garam was just a trainee and if she'd done that she would've kept herself anonymous because who is going to care about if a HYBE trainee gets fired??!
There were so many signs. But common sense ain't common in everybody, I suppose.
Ever since Source Music disbanded Gfriend (the group that saved them from bankruptcy), I knew it was going to get worse but I didn’t think it would get THIS worse. Poor Garam. I wish her a bright future and I hope she will stay strong enough to never give up on her dreams.
Remember these K-pop companies main focus is making money, if somebody will threaten that they won't think twice about dropping them.
Gfriend saved bighit? Really?
Edit: GUYS I AM SORRY I MISREAD IT. I KNOW SOURCE MUSIC IS UNDER HYBE. I ACTUALLY WROTE THIS COMMENT IN A RUSH SO I DIDN’T PROOF READ IT. I AM SO SORRY IF I OFFENDED ANYONE AND I HOPE YOU CAN FORGIVE ME. TYVM!
@@Streamidentity_misamo nobody said that. Op said that gfriend save source music, the label that gfriend was originally under, that was aquired by hybe
@@Streamidentity_misamo source music more rather
@@Streamidentity_misamo lmaooo 😭😭😭 u made urself looks funny
I hope she’s doing well, she’s so young and the two weeks she was active in must’ve felt magical to her. the people who bullied her have to be sorry for hurting you garam, u deserve better.
@@leggo3213 thats how shitty and toxic the industry is
don't say we. You people yeah, some of us decided to use our brains and stayed neutral. I really hope karma gets you and everyone else that BULLIED Garam.
Edit: The person that made the comment basically first said they were one of the people that bullied Garam, they changed their comment to look innocent
@@kchill6925 exactly I always stay neutral and it's really funny how they advocate for bullying and literally bullied her told her awful things it was really sick to see this happen so often
@@kchill6925 we as for the people that bullied her, i just didn’t know how to word it. if u didn’t understand me then u can ask for an explanation, not throwing words without understanding what i meant 😗
@@alittihad3amak still you were one of the people bullying her and you could've been worded what you said better .
You also forgot to mention that Garam released the full SVC report on her friend's instagram which pretty much confirms Hybe's statement and Yoo Eunseo as the real perpetrator. The molka incident did happened and Garam was framed this whole time.
I think at this point it's valid to leave it for the court.. If eunsoo or Garam whoever is guilty you won't be able to help them.. What happened has happened .. Garam is no more an idol so just let her live.. By nagging y'all just make it worse leave it for the court
@@AnzzCheatedOnMarkWithHaechan I made this comment because the creator of this channel left out a vital piece of information. That's literally it.
@@AnzzCheatedOnMarkWithHaechan she’s not nagging she is telling creator she left a important partbout
@@AnzzCheatedOnMarkWithHaechan she still can be an idol tho
@@AnzzCheatedOnMarkWithHaechan dumass
Jessica's book was released in May, you could have preordered it last year. Snsd's comeback was a week ago... what are you talking about?
Exactly. The book was literally announced WAY before SNSD announced the comeback. Jessica even announced a possible new solo album WAY before the SNSD announcement
because the korean version of the book was just recently released.
Girls' Generation's last comeback before 'FOREVER 1' was in 2017 with the album 'Holiday Night', which was released for the group's 10th anniversary, not 2015. Just wanted to clear that up cuz it was only 5 years between comebacks not 7, and I don't want inaccurate information to be given out even if it is minor.
Right. I was confused if she was talking in Korean years Which i never know how that works
@@jewljuju korean years is only for age, not for actual years lol
@@paulambs that’s what I first thought, but sometimes when groups talk about anniversaries or how long the couple has been together, it’s always plus 1 or something when they speak in Korean.
@@jewljuju i think it's just a matter of speech, like instead of saying "we've been together for 1 year" they say "this is our second year together" in the sense that when 1 year passes another already begins
Nah really and she’s such an ass kisser to all of the idols and the way she was talking down about Hybe’s girl groups just threw me off.
So upsetting to see this Garam's dreams crushed so fast and at such a young age. I feel the better move would've been just to put her on hiatus until the air was cleared (and HYBE had the evidence to do so). It's very sad to see but I wish her the best. There's no chance she would ever join the group back, but I would love if she could.
actually there is still a chance, with Garam proven innocent .. i hope that SouMu isn't going to turn a blind eye towards the obvious statements and proof of innocence
All this stuff was said early on, weeks ago, why are people acting like it's new info. They simply could have chosen not to harass a child online for actions done when she was 12.
@@GopherCakeStuff didn't garam just release this statement....... yeah, there was evidence early on but people chose not to listen. I don't get what you're saying here
@@sowonbuddy I literally read about most of this info weeks ago, that's what I'm saying. The info was always out there, plus it said the school punished them, so if the school already punished her I don't know why people thought it was up to them to bring out pitchforks for a 4 year old incident.
@@GopherCakeStuff because the point was to ruin her. I mean the alleged victim accused not just Garam but who she called Garam's squad and yet she never named any member of this alleged squad of bullies. She never tried to seek "justice" until after Garam debuted. It was fishy to me from the beginning, but these childish netizens today will look for any reason to hate on somebody.
people just never learn do they? After seeing many idols being accused of bullying, out of which 90% of the time turns out to be false and all lies, still continue to believe them and jump on the hate train for the accused idol. You guys just want excuses to hate and spread hate on idols don’t ya? I feel bad for the poor idols. They are the real victims
Or most of them were equal arguments where another person decided to play victim
@@GopherCakeStuff yep
@@GopherCakeStuff exactly it’s crazy how random people can just end an idols career off of baseless facts because they know fans won’t do their own research.
Just been watching True Beauty where this topic is a main theme, and how it ends up with the suicide of a idol. The girl is very young and should of been better supported and given a chance, not kicked out. I feel sad for her :-(
I said the same it’s goofy and old people gotta pay attention
The moral of this entire video: Please refrain from taking accusations and speculation of mistreatment and bullying as fact, and remain neutral. The amount of damage the "Fans" can cause to Idols by running away with hate and negativity based on hearsay and unproven assumptions, can be massive. Once that hate train starts, it's really hard to stop it. And then if Fans ended up being wrong, apologies mean nothing, the damage is almost irreversible. So before you judge Idols, please think if your actions actually helps the situation, or makes it worse.
0:10: I'm really hyped for this comeback and I'm sure they won't disappoint
0:48: At first I didn't really like cookie that much but now the song is playing in my head 24/7. I loved all their pre debuts as well and hope for them the best of luck
1:41: I'm happy that Monsta x renewed contract and I hope I.M good luck in the future. Also, I think it's too early to decide how their group activities are gonna go, let's just wait and see
2:41: I'm going neutral on this one. And I don't think the timing is sus cuz a novel takes 2-3 years to publish and her novel was released after their comeback so I think she added that line in her book before then. But again, I'm going neutral
5:11: I do believe that hybe debuting this many groups is chaotic but I wouldn't worry about it too much
7:19: I think Garam is innocent and it's like that whole Soojin scandal again. I kinda feel bad for her since that was only when she was young and that I'm sure she knows her wrongdoings
I always knew there was something off when they hated on her. I feel so sorry for her.
Garam is now starting to remind me of Mina and Jimin situation where they went back and forth playing the “ my words against yours” game until someone came out with hard evidence against Mina which caused the situation to go 180
Okay but saying she’s 16 so she doesn’t know what she’s doing is stupid. Im younger than her and i’m more mature. I know what’s wrong and what’s not and if i’m wrong in a huge argument i’m gonna apologize instead of making it even worse.
@@-.no. if someone took a nude picture of your friend and you don't fight for her you are not mature, you are coward...
@@-.no. she was 12 when it happened. she's 16 now
I really hope to see the iland boys in their Japan boy group.. I miss every member of them.. Can't wait to see Taki, K Nicholas and all the others 😭😭🔥
Also I hope iland 2 will be as strong as 1.. I really got attached to all the boys.. Miss Daniel and Ej :(
Ej is also in the debut lineup :)
@@crazykookie2339 yesssss that's why I can't wait their line up is fire 😭🔥🔥🔥
Daniellll 😭😭😭
for some reason I hated ta-ki for the whole show, I’m sorry ta-ki I was envious
(also K deserved to be in Enhypen, I loved him so much on the show and he was so good)
Monsta X are one of my ults and seeing Wonho leaving the group was so painful. If it's gonna be the same with I.M I'm ready to fight Starship. How come most companies are too incompetent at managing their groups? Isn't that their job?
I agree. I.M is an essential member of the group, how come I can see that clearly and the professional agency don't?
Starship has proven to be a sh*tty company before but this is just beyond words. I got the feeling they want to destroy Monsta X.
He didn't leave the group, just starship
I don't think he'll be gone. I mean, there's other groups now that have members in other agencies but they are still a group. Every Got7 member is in a different agency but they have made a comeback. It took longer since they were all in different agencies, but since Changkyun is the only one going elsewhere, it might be different for Monsta X.
did he leave the group and company or just company
@@DdanbinU he just left Starship but stayed with MX. In his handwritten letter, he stated he’ll continue to be a MX member and that MX is ot6
I am happy that I never hated kim garam, and I'm also glad she is proved innocent, y'all call her a bully while y'all yourselves were cyberbullying and harrassing a 16 year old teen girl and ruined her whole career, ngl but she had perfect vocals and voice, I'm feeling awful for her. Poor garam😣
HER VISUALS AND HER AURA OMG, she has the potential to be one of the it girls of 4th gen... wasted😭😭
I am thankful and feel good about how i was neutral all along...i never hated her or brought her down... But i was attacked by ppl just coz i asked them to be neutral. She was heck of a performer, prolly the best after Yunjin and Chaewon honestly..she did so well in their debut song and screw those so called OT5 fans who hated Garam.
@@iwasthebugatsowoozoomuster2021 like i love chaeyeon(ex-izone) with all my heart but saying how hybe shld kick garam out and put chaeyeon in is sickening-
Same, glad i was staying neutral the whole time 😭 i feel so bad for her tho, she deserves to be in the group. She worked so hard to debut and then some bish just felt the need to ruin her future and life
@@Marksbsfong The are some chats of eunseo planning to destroy garam's career, this is also reforced with the pictures in Garam insta stories when they where really friendly and even resolved everything after the picture incident
I honestly can't imagine how crushing garam feels rn. Like reaching your dream after so much hard work then just gettinh it taken away from not even when your 2 steps in, is so sad. I hope for the best for her
Lol,, people are now believing a twitter user without any evidence lol....It could be dumb delulu fans act 😌😌😌
Kim garam The bully with her delulu cult 😂😂😂
@@bryce1616 she released a whole document for evidence 🙄.at this point you are reaching.also its not from twitter.
@@heenadhurwe_ce325 link 🖇️
@@bryce1616 Hey troll, if you don't do anything important in your life and just be here on social media spreading hate, I suggest you don't go online and ask senseless questions. You're a capable human being that can use the internet. Research for yourself if you are actually looking for answers. The truth always comes out and in Garam's case, it already has, with enough proof by the way. So do everyone a favor and get away from social media before karma comes at you.
No matter how much we need Garam back, there's no chances of getting her back, Hybe ended their contract with her. HYBE and Source music were so stupid to not let her talk. #KimGaramIsInnocent
Ikr
She won't come back
@@izzyy_249 💀💀 bro really didn't read the comment
@@izzyy_249 I know but I wish she could
Hybe and SouMu don't have the authorities to "let her talk".. Garam is still a minor.. Whether she takes this to court or not rests entirely on her parents..
0:10 nct 127 cb!!
0:49 new jeans new achievement
1:41 monsta X
2:40 girls generation + Jessica
5:12 hybe's new grps
7:18 garam
Have a nice day/night...bye! 🧡
I hope both sides of your pillow is cold when you go to sleep tonight. Thank you 💗
thank you so much!!
Thankusm !!!
@@Marieeaftersunset ahaha thanks I love my pillows cold 😄
First of all, it's the first comeback of SNSD in 5 years and not 7(the last one was in 2017). Second I won't consider SNSD'S comeback as a mess.. it's their most successful comeback to date in terms of sales, RUclips, Spotify, iTunes and more platforms. Yes covid is a b**ch but unfortunately it's effected a lot of groups before too, and as I understood it sm didn't cancel the music shows attended just moved it to the following week.
Get well soon our precious maknae Seohyun, we love you 💗💗💗
yup, they slayed and the covid situation cannot be helped and jessica’s book isn’t really affecting them either, “a mess” is a stretch
@Kanbaru no holiday and all night were released 5 years ago
@@sibelde8944 yep..I'm sooo happy for this comeback..I even cry. Hope our little maknae recover and get well soon 💜
Yea thats how I understood it as well, that they will continue next week when Seohyun is out of quarantine! Its not like theyre canceling everything since theyve already done so many shows and want to show us the best!!!
@Kanbaru no it's not, snsd released their last album (holiday night) together as full 8 members in 2017 and that was 5 years ago not 7,
SNSD was supposed to be on Music Bank this friday 20220812 and they cancelled that however every other schedule is still on hold.. Seohyun herself posted on insta story that they will probably perform next weeks friday 20220819 since she can test herself free after 7days which would be on monday or tuesday.
Poor Garam, I feel so bad for her. She had to survive in this crucial world. Hope she’s doing her best. I’ll support her either way, she apologized and got kicked out already. Fighting Garam! 💗
Garam has went through *_A LOT_* . She is just 16 and faced a lot of difficulties after her debut. I hope she comes back as a soloist or as a part of the group.
i REALLY wish she comes back, but the thing is, the chances are EXTREMELY low. I've never heard of a group member who leaves coming back. especially when they faced a bullying case
@@ryujinswig3253 that is also a fact. Hybe should have taken time in solving the case rather than putting the fans through a frenzy. As soon as she was kicked out of the group many fans were happy but on the other side many were devastated.
@@anjanaathularavindakshan8076 Girll don't blame hybe at all, blame those crazy netizens who pressured hybe to kick her out. Yall gott stop blaming company's for everything that happens.
@@Valentina_Bae but Hybe should not listen to any hater (they can make their own decisions), all they have to do is to find out the truth, and then do what is good for Garam and the company. it's so braindead to kick out someone bc ppl tell you to do it. so Hybe deserves to get blamed aswell.
Lol,, people are now believing a twitter user without any evidence lol....It could be dumb delulu fans act 😌😌😌
Hybe should be held accountable for this.
Facts
what does held accuntable mean?
@@oliviyasss held to be responsible for their actions.
@@oliviyasss I think what they meant is to draw lines but hold accountable mean to make someone take the responsibility for their actions... That's what I know
Hybe and the haters
Jessica Jung book came out May 10, 2022 on Amazon. Way before we knew about Girls Generation Comeback.
I have never felt so bad for anyone, but Garam, she is just 16 and going through so much, she is so talented and I so badly wanted her to go on with her career, she was my bias and I literally love her so much, but now nothing can be changed so I wish her good luck. She will always be in my heart.
Correction: SNSD came back after 5 years not 7! They had their comeback for their 10th year in 2017, solo activities for 5 years and now back for their 15th year! #SONE
I.M isn't leaving Monsta X and they are still together as a group, and I'm happy for him having more career opportunities out there. It isn't always something bad but positive if we look from both sides of thing and ask what's truly matter. I'm wishing them the best and can't wait to see what they'll bring in the future 💜
Hybe has many other entertainment companies under it so we can really expect them 5o debut 4 groups a year but it really needs to start treating them well anyway i am really excited for pledis new group as it will be first group after seventeen since 2015 and offcourse trainee A i have been waiting for their debut since last year
They better not start abandoning SEVENTEEN
@cookies and cream they will i guess
Come on now Jessica has started a new career and she will also be participating in her new survival group. I hope both SNSD and Jessica have a smooth career. The proof that SNSD exists is not from the sales but how they got together again after 15 years of their career.
This is so crazy. If HYBE held out a little longer, she would have been proven innocent and then Le Sserafim could have continued as a 6-member group. I wonder what all the netizens who insisted on her getting kicked out have to say for themselves now...
Oh they still think she’s a bully just because she cursed at eunsoo (the real bully). They don’t care if garam’s friends and family comes forward and tell the truth cuz all they care about is how bad her image/actions were at the age of 12 🙄
The problem is Garam's friends sent this information to HYBE, however they ignored them. This made people speculate they used her as noise marketing. Garam clearly has the official documents to prove her innocence but i guess HYBE stopped her from releasing them under her contract. So sad, a young girls dreams crushed based solely on speculation.
literally everyone was saying to remove her from Le sserafim, I'm happy that I stayed neutral..
As long as she was with hybe, all the proof we have now wouldnt be public and shed still be known as a bully. Hybe was probably noise marketing or couldnt do much with the proofs they recieved as everyone involved were and still are minors. Either way garam couldnt have continued as a lesserafim member
@@yanc4237 i agree, sadly even though its not what people made it out to be, she would have still had the image of the bully if HYBE couldnt release documents. Therefore people would be more likely to avoid the group.
seohyun is/ has been my favorite from the beginning i hope her health and hope she’s resting well
Same
Manifesting a happy life for Kim Garam and to her having the opportunity to come back like Jimin 💕 🕯️
Jessica's book Bright was published in 2021, it just got a lot of wind bc of the comeback
HYBE bring back Garam I literally have enough of her getting hated, I always knew something was up with this scandal
I am sick of all these attacks on Garam who is only 16 and just started her career. I just want her to return to Le Sserafim.
I prefer she's not going back at least she's finally free from all of this bs. kpop fans and netizens don't deserve her at all
Even though Jessica isn’t in Girls’ Generation anymore, she will always be involved with the group one way or another whether it’s controversially or just remembering her time with GG. SNSD started as 9 and it was like for 7 years, it’s just something you can’t erase from the groups history.
True sis
@@russjordan6039 ...wat?
To Jessica from SNSD: "Call me the Villain cause I'm busy killin' it!"
@@russjordan6039 what?
She's not nice? She's too nice that's why sm tried everything to ruin her career. Did you even know how sm banned her from any south korean radio and tv shows?
@@russjordan6039 are you a psycho? You’re acting like you know her personally or know what actually happened. Even if the truth is somewhere in the middle you have no reason to say those nasty things.
The worst thing to me is that it doesn’t seem like the people that bullied Garam off of the internet are satisfied with getting her kicked out of the group. People are still saying malicious and unnecessary things to her and it honestly makes me sad. I hope that of being an idol is still her passion that she can debut in another group or as a soloist (how cool would that be) but also I’d 100% respect it if she decided to do something else. I hope she’s doing okay
Please watch the video by Doyouram Everday K-Culture ruclips.net/video/1wIL-u9N2vQ/видео.html
It has the full account of the school violence committee uploaded by Garam herself. It states that Garam and Eunseo were both at fault. Garam even apologized saying that she admits she was wrong and that she was immature back then. So technically Garam is not innocent. But people should stop attacking her since she now apologized.
@@kraye5908 I know she's not fully innocent, but a lot of the "evidence" and claims people used against her were not real. Guilty or not, she's still a minor, and her mental health isn't being valued. Thanks for the video :)
@@beaqi_ Yes, there were a lot of claims from both sides that were not true. That is why I said people should stop sending hate towards her. She can still move forward since she is young. And I really appreciate that she posted the full report even if it shows that she did cyber bully Eunseo. that was a very commendable act on her side. Then she apologized and realize that she was wrong and immature back then. I really hope people would leave her alone now. I wish her well.
Y'all are so fast to accuse someone Then go bully them and act like you know a lot yet walk around saying "innocent until proven guilty"...that's why it's always good to mind your business and that's what I'll do from now on just leave it where it's .. what do you think you can for her now she already got kicked
And now people are gonna go with the "I knew she was innocent we shouldn't harrass someone" after sending that hate wagon for her
Don't count me in that. You can look up my comments, I defended her from the beginning because it never made sense to me. I think part of it is because I did believe Mina over Jimin and I didn't want to ever get that wrong again.
@your dad who left anyone who believed eunsoo are sheep who don’t know how to think for themself. i knew it was clear as day that eunsoo’s side was suspicious and had many holes from the start and i guess i was right
@sanawebs why were u searching for proof that looked believable? u should be searching for proof that is real. the proof released that made me the most sus was the svr because there wasn’t any context and eunsoo’s lawfirm never lived up to their promise. auto red flag. also, i was neutral but leaning a bit toward garam
@sanawebs lmao it’s not hybe’s fault y’all were accusing them of lying. look now, garam turns out not be a bully but yet ur still calling her a bully? so u agree that there’s nothing wrong with hacking someone’s facebook to post innapropriate pics of a minor and attempting to get people framed but then act like a victim that didn’t start all of this crap?! eunsoo is the real bully here, and looks like ur the bully too
Why do people suddenly blame Hybe for Garam's case. They tried to protect her, published statement about her situation, but noobody believed them, their employee turned on them, their stocks went down, still they tried. The ones at fault are the netizens, the haters, the RUclipsrs, and all the ones who bullied her out of her group, in the name of anti-bullying. Even this channel accused her of having a relationship with a Hybe executive, just because Hybe tried to protect her. What goes around comes around, when you lost your job or dream, it's probably because of the bad deeds you sow.
This channel is freakin toxic, thats for sure.
HYBE released a complete detailed statement about this issue two months ago to prove her innocence but i totally ignored it cause a lot of kpop stans said it was full of shit 😭. I’m so dumb to believe them. Kpop fans are toxic af.
Hybe caved-in to the netizens calling for Garam to be kicked out. I thought since HYBE released the report about Garam's friend being bullied by Yoo Eunseo, that would mean HYBE would ignore anything Yoo Eunseo had to say. That would be like allowing the wolf to cry "wolf" (Bully complaining about being bullied). The announcement that Garam was being kicked out was a surprise. The long delay and rumors about Garam making a comeback, led me to believe HYBE was going to tell haters to "take a hike" (shut up and ignore them).
Hope Garam can recover from this and make a debut again somewhere else.
Cause everybody is a double face. They are now feeling guilty for bulling garam and that's why they are blaming hybe.
@@armoaeongene5163 facts
I Feel sad for her cause she got alot of hate eventhought she was innocent
She was not innocent
Innocent where?
Was she proved innocent?!
@@love.251 Wait where can I find more details
@@WhippedForJeonJungkook she is innocent yall just dont want to be wrong cause yall conscious are bothering yoi😀😍
it’s actually only been 5 years since the last gg comeback. They released Holiday in 2017 alongside two music videos
I won't lie, Garam was my bias from the get go.. Then all of these happened and I was sad, her dream was crushed...and now see. I mean this is not fair
This is why it is important to know every side of a story. I admit myself I jumped to a conclusion without knowing all details (I'm personally sorry Garam). Seems like it was just two girls who had a tiff with each other during school. Something that most of us can relate to. I think it shows a lot of maturity and humbleness to apologize for a past mistake and honestly makes me quite frustrated that Hybe/Source didn't let her release the report and a full statement/apology in the first place. Garam had the information and willingness all along and could have set the record straight. Source/Hybe let her down from the start. I know its pretty much impossible now but I'd love to see Garam back in Le Sserafim, even though a part of me would also love to see her excell with a different group and company. Too little, too late I suppose. Regardless, I truly wish the best for her and hope to see her debut again soon.
I too jumped to a conclusion extremely fast and I personally think that the report shows that it was equal on both sides with Yoon Eunseo majorly acting like a victim when she also did wrong. It seems like arguments that got out of hand and a person with a will to end someone's career. I hope she can move forward and find happiness.
Why take the side of people you don’t know? Not hate just a question.
@@simsimah exactly. Netizens acted like garam wrung the neck of their mamas and supported an actual bully! Eunseo received lvl 6 punishment, the one where serious punishment actually starts….. but people just wanted more drama and ruined garam’s life. They literally don’t realise that a bit of drama is enjoyment to THEM but for others it can be living HELL
@@simsimah I personally don't have any vitriol against Garam. As you said I dont know her. More so I'm very sensitive to the subject of bullying in general, from my own past experiences, and sometimes that can unfairly cloud my judgment about certain situations. I will say it was more so I was favoring Eunseu's side of the story because at the time it was the only one providing evidence (I say that loosely now) to support her claim while Garam was sadly forced to remain quite. Definitely one of those "There are three sides to every story: your side, my side, and the truth" moments. I hope that helps clarify a bit.
Uhh, please blame the writer who decided to publish a book review during SNSD comeback. Bright was released months ago.
Bright came out months ago, this drama also came out also months ago. Sooyoung, Taeyeon, Yoona got most of the blame because readers predicted it was them who were the “mean” characters or something. You’d think there’d be a disclaimer in the book considering it IS fiction. She knew what she was doing when she released the book, she knew her fans would go and predict who was who and take every little thing in the book seriously.
The book is literally presented as fiction, that's the disclaimer. She never said it was a biography but people are taking it as such. You can't blame Jessica for people being stupid lmao
And they were the most popular members too 😭
@itsnaralyn omg even exo ls coming after her when she was dating Baekhyun. 😔
@itsnaralyn other members started businesses or were acting and doing all sorts of other things. It's literally no different. Why do yall keep blaming Jessica for what fans believed loool
Plus yall always do this where you paint one member as an angel and another as a devil when you know neither of them. They both could have been a problem with moving forward as a group.
im disappointed with Jessica. SNSD is still the group that make her popular. its not like she debut solo or something. still throwing shade after all these years are disappointing. i love u jessica and love all the members too. please stop 😢
Garams career cannot be saved, her reputation has been ruined. I don't know what she will do next, wish her all the best but the idol life is not for her
This is sad but truew
True.
Again, we don't know what the future holds. Hopefully she is happy now. I hope nothing but the best for her
i’m hoping she returns! she’s INNOCENT
the idol life was somewhat for her, but bc of what happened, now it isn’t :’)
I miss her so much ❤️and I am glad that she told her side of the story with EVIDENCE
Hybe is very different to other companys.. Hybe is just the "Name" and under them are so many different companys like bighit pledis source music..
its like every company is debuting 1 group which isnt a bad thing.
its like if jyp yg and sm were put together and each of them would debut a group -
How can you blame Jessica for releasing her book, Bright, during the promotion of SNSD's new song? Jessica's book was released on May 10, 2022. You guys should fact-check before you believe what Knetizens.
This is literally the same channel which highlighted all the negative rumour about garam , a 16 yo minor and people were bashing her in comment section with all those vague evidence ruining her career before it even started ......................
At this point kpop stans should never throw their regards without even knowing the case deeply.
I really hope she gets all the love she needs for healing. ( not guilty until proven ).
When this channel wanted her kicked out of the group , hybe did it's best to protect their artists.
PS : this channel works for pure attention seeking .
How do u feel after ruining a 16 year old girl's career and bullied her ??? Happy now u weirdos??
This channel is also responsible
justice for garam!
I kinda miss the promotions that monsta x had in the first comebacks in the agency and the legendary comebacks, i hope that this will be a new fresh start. Also I want u to remember that actually mamamoo are doing the same thing, they did the Kpop flex as 4 members soo yeah, let's hope that
it’s weird how you said monsta x’s future is uncertain when starship themselves already included in their statement that *changkyun will continue promoting with the group*, he’s literally included in monbebe 7th generation announcement. if starship was planning to remove him after he left the agency, starship won’t release the 7th generation recruitment with him 5 days into being a free agent.
anyways monsta x are set to do a 3-day seoul concert this september, perform in thailand, headline nickfest, and are preparing for new music (solo and group) WITH CHANGKYUN.
Jessica lost her longtime friends in a blink of an eye she deserves to be happy and successful stop the hate I mean the girls will not think of her if they want to release something why would she
What sucks too is that Garam no longer has the resources of a record company to pursue legal action
@kookielit you should also apologize you have been spreading misinformation about her. You have contributed to the reason why many people hate her. Have some shame.
Yeah,this channel is totally shameless,spreading the hate.hope this channel also gets its karma
Comment number 6 was obviously not a SONE because they would know that Jessica was really popular in SNSD lol
But when hybe first said she was innocent y'all denied it and demanded further investigation. Hybe once defended her but the world was so mad. Now hybe is blamed bcz they let garam out 🤨🧐
Let's be honest the Garam situation is actually a good example of hypocrisy, hybe tried to keep her and defend her but everyone questioned this decision, her new statement is literally the same that hybe posted but now suddenly everyone believes her just because they already fire her
i thought of this too. people started to believe her after her contract got terminated but then again Garam released the full SVC report
Girls'Generation slayed and that's the tea sis
I.M didnt leave Monsta x, he just only left company and will continue being in monsta x, as 6 members. we dont need any drama around it and we trust and believe in Monsta x, they know better what is good for them and im also gonna support I.M no matter what his desicions in the future will be. lets just wait and see how things will go!!!
I never believed that Garam was a bully, there’s always bullying allegations to every idol. Also, kicking an idol out because she “bullied” somebody when she was a CHILD makes no sense. People can’t grow and change? I’ve always thought Garam was innocent
*edit: guys I didn’t think people would fight over this. I was saying that people can grow and change and reflect as they grow older. Forgiveness is not a thing? I don’t think she was a bully. Almost every idol was accused of being a bully. For example, Nam Joo-hyuk, Karina, Garam, Jimin (AOA), etc. This is just the media trying to make idols look bad when they debut. I respect your opinions tho.*
No hybe should have kept her and ruin the group's name, thats what u wanted. Wait which court declare her as innocent, i didnt see any.
Same people are just crazy nowdays what's wrong with them is it fun to cyber bully people leading them to hurt themselves? Is it really worth it..
@@safz15 And you didn't see any which said she was guilty...
Korea has a very strict law against bullying so when idols/ actors or models are rumored to be bullies they usually go to court. When it comes to idols they either be on hiatus for a few months to years until it dies down or get kicked out the group to save face of the group. Which is why I think HYBE kicked her out to save face of the group.
@@safz15 do you see or hear the korea court called her guilty and eunseo is innocent? I don't think so
The timing of Jessica's book and girls' generation's comback is close to each other bc they all just decided to release their things in their debut month. I know Jessica isn't a part of snsd but still she debuted in August too.
bright wasnt published in august.
@@LJ-qy4cs oh then why do they say in the video that she published it same time as snsd's comeback? I didn't know the publish date
@@JustMe-qd6er kookielit is always spreading lie n making something small big. jessicas book was announced like a year ago then it keeps on getting pushed back n was finally published in may.
@@LJ-qy4cs oh ok, thanks for clarification ♡♡
@@LJ-qy4cs yes the Korean version was
Good for newjeans! They are so talented and there music is just so good! Like arguably the best debut music I’ve ever heard, literally all 4 songs on repeat the last week. I really hope they don’t get cursed by Hybe controversy and continue in this trajectory because I am really excited to see how they grow.
And i am excitedfor their CEO to be kicked out of the company!!!
1. SNSD came back after 5 not 7 years
2. They sold 100,000+ on their 1st day, first week.
3. They topped 1 in 31 countries for iTunes and top 1 worldwide
4. Better talk about Jessica what her real motive is because for us SONES, we just want to enjoy this success and comeback. All negativities and bitterness from the "protagonist" is unwelcomed. Jessica can write her book whatsoever, involve SNSD there or what, if that's what makes people read her book, then it's fine. Jessica, is Jessica, kicked out from the industry because of her own desires. SNSD is SNSD with or without Jessica, SNSD is happier and successful without even bringing up her name. SNSD is still legendary and the nation's Girl Group, even without her. Yes, she was popular, but now, even Taeyeon herself can be 10 times more successful than her. Stop bringing jealousy because all SNSD members are doing their whole damn thing. Actresses, Soloists, DJ, Variety Hosts, MCs, Chefs, Song Writers, and etc. With all those success they got as a group and individually, I think the one should be Jeaoulus is THAT WOMAN herself. Period.
And ppl still believe she's speaking the whole truth bcos she's the only one speaking lmao 😂, Anyways I'm also a SONE and enjoying SNSD's comeback, I'm not craving for her to comeback to the group because there was a lot of damage done already and they've strived well for the past 8 years but I wish the blacklistment be removed 🥲
Jessica from being my second bias to nothing now. After Bright and all her sabotaging against her former members, I cannot stan her anymore. What a cheap way to sell books. Day by day I’m losing respect with all her drama and gimmicks. Admit it or not, until now she cannot forgive herself for messing up her priorities that lead up to the 2014 events. With all the mishaps and lawsuits that her so-called “fashion company” faced. Thanks to her ugly and scammer of a boyfriend, Tyler.
What she does nowadays, releasing bright the same period as GG’s comeback, and joining a cheap china show is purely pathetic tbh. She’s nowhere now while GG are thriving in their own fields, and still can comeback as a whole group despite different agencies.
Sorry J, if you never met Tyler, you’d still probably be in GG making a comeback now. Regret is always in the end,
Girls’ Generation all the way. #OT8
Haters be hatin’, GG always slayin’.
"Call me a villian, cuz im busy killin it" - SNSD
@@sethanxxd9611 YAS!!
Now jessica fans are laughing saying Seohyun got karma. Tsk
why the heck is SNSD comeback a mess? nope. it wasnt, its even successful! and we dont care about the public opinion because the comeback is for the fans, SONEs so its okay to think otherwise. as for their music show performances it was not cancelled it was just moved for next week, Seohyun isnt to blame,healthy or not you can be hit by Covid.
And they are all free and can compromise so they wont perform with just 7 they will wait for Seohyun and knowing her she can recover quickly. All of their schedules are just moved for next week. They will ecen attend SMtown as a whole group and I am so excited for it❤️❤️❤️❤️🥰🥰
get well soon Seohyun!!!
Can't wait for NCT's comeback!!! It's my first comeback for them as a new nctzen! EXITED! TT
Me too!! Its actually my first 127 comeback so im really excited
NCT is always getting better and better in every comeback
New nctzen welcome to the fandom 💚
@@hanad.d.d127 thank you ;3
There is alot more posted about the Garam situation the full transcripts for the SVC has been posted and translated. Her being removed from Lesserafim was unjust and she deserved better,.
I’m sorry to Kim garam for the hatred. She deserves more. Hopefully she’s doing okay.
Finally NCT 127 !
It's always something unique ✨️
Can't wait
I feel like when all such bullying allegations come up, the idol should be allowed to speak in front of cameras instead of letting the company handle it behind the scenes and letting people just be oblivious to the real situation. People never get to hear both sides. So if the alleged victim is telling their end of the story, the idol should be given a chance to tell theirs too.
Hybe had already put out Garam's side of the story. Kpopies were too illiterate to read that.
@@Orion22810 😭
Jessica released Bright in early May, at least in the US. Maybe the July release was Asia/Korea? I really don't think that's intentional to sabotage GG's comeback.
-i’m too hyped for 127’s comeback, i miss them so much 🥹
-i wasn’t into monsta x ever but i wish them the best, maybe i’ll listen to them in the future
-i think what happened with jessica wasn’t fair but also she could’ve postponed the release of her book.
-hybe is going bonkers with its plans to debut new groups. learn to manage your existing groups first and then debut more smh.
-garam is too young to be going through all of this backlash and hatred and i hope she can do something good for herself in the future.
Kim garam is innocent because she defended her friend.
everyone keeps saying garam is a stalker and they keep defending a person who photographs an underage girl in her underwear.
do you think defending a friend from this type of person who has no respect for personal privacy is stalking? you are wrong, not her.
Yesss Garam finally got some bit of closure when she’s the one who spoke up, Hoping the best care for her mental health 🥰
I feel really bad for Garam omg,imagine she trained for months and hours and she would just get kicked out of the group? Come on now she alr confirmed it herself that she's innocent and all she did is to protect her friend,I would never forgive those people who ruined Garam's dream and career she even said on the letter (?) "Even though I only got the dream of mine for 2 weeks,I would cherish those moments forever" something like that I think? I feel so bad for her esp her mental health and she's just 16 years old,idk I'm so annoyed at Hybe rn why didn't they even TRY to protect Garam:(
Please watch the video by Doyouram Everday K-Culture ruclips.net/video/1wIL-u9N2vQ/видео.html
It has the full account of the school violence committee uploaded by Garam herself. It states that Garam and Eunseo were both at fault. Garam even apologized saying that she admits she was wrong and that she was immature back then. So technically Garam is not innocent. But people should stop attacking her since she now apologized.
She trained for years
@@tintin8682 yeahh sorry I don't really know that much abt it,Thank you!
When hybe was not canceling her contract, you guys blamed hybe. When hybe made garam debut, you guys blamed hybe saying that how can one company take trainees without background check. Now you gus are hating hybe for not letting her tell her side story. Always blaming someone for own fault.
@@armoaeongene5163 tbh,I did not spoke up abt the issue even in the first place this is just the first time I'm speaking up abt the issue :)
They literally covered the members solo parts in the japanese version of boomerang with Jessica's voice when they remade it. You have to listen hard to hear the other members on that song. Imagine getting woke up at 6 am to record music, to sing 8 words and then you cant even be heard because the producers favorite is over you and all you add is texture. Was she the most popular no but she was favored musically especially in Japan. The dancers barely sang on that first album. The Great Escape is one of their best tracks period. Best by a kpop group period but it was basically Taeyeon, Jessica and Seohyun with some Tiffany
The great escape was like 2014 , now it's 2022
Didn't Hybe said most of the same thing as what she said? But like no one believed and thought the company was making lies to save her??
This is one of the channels who put fuel to the garam hate train. Kpop stans switch easily.
IKR! they were even making assumptions of her having connections and her family being rich. And remember they were saying that hybe used taehyung and jennie to back up garam's scandal?
Really- kpop stans believe and assume anything that justifies what they believe in in a very unhealthy amount
@@OldDannyDevito the thing is… they’re still not on her side. Most of the kpop stans aren’t really mad at the bullying issue. They just want an excuse to hate on someone. And now that she’s trying to clear her name, they either don’t care or switch and put the blame on the company (I’m not even a hybe bootlicker but some people really need to stop using Garam’s case to justify their hate on a company. For me that’s tactless)
@@ya.02 I was thinking the same. Like weeks or month ago the way this channel talking against about Garam and fueling the uncomfirmed rumors and now they are like showing the innocence of her....
Don’t forget they still will perform at SM concert can’t wait to see them live GG
I think NewJeans is BOP, i am really their big fan ! I am impatiently waiting for HYBE Japan group to debut! I really wanna see K, Nicholas, EJ and Taki finally accomplish their dreams! I have been their fan since I-land! Also I am highly anticipating Trainee A's debute too , we all know they are gonna be totally amazing! JJ is actually so far my favourite member! And about Kim Garam's matter, I have always been saying this and I'll say this once again... Lesserafim will never be same without her, she was actually my favourite member in the group! She was really talented, pretty and fought hard for her dreams to debut! But in the end her career and mental health just got ruined due to these psycho cyberbullys who have nothing better job to do other than throwing hate online at people. I just wish her bright future. Many people are thinking that Source Music may take her back in the group since the air has cleared out now, but I don't think this is gonna happen! I just hope she will at some point make debut again under some agency... I'll be rooting for her until then 💜
So sad how people were like imagine being an idol for two weeks and garam still cherish those two weeks as part of her dream. She is honestly such a sweet girl and didn’t even bash her haters!!Garam come back when you’re ready and we’ll give you all the power and support you need.
That Jessica thing was not suspicious as you said. Reviews typically take that long and it just so happens to land at the time of SNSD's comeback.
To Jessica from SNSD: "Call me the Villain cause I'm busy killin' it!"
People should stop dragging jessica with snsd. She left years ago. Her books are fiction. Leave her alone for goodness sake.
Hope Garam comes back she doesn't deserve this much hate
She won't
As much as I want her to comeback I don't think she will
@@misty7645 rumours she may sign with yg😆🥺
She's pretty much just Soojin all over again and its sad
@@zimbalabimm9020 i hope she does she was my bias
Kim Garam was a kid when it happened
We all makes mistakes when we are young
Am I crazy to think that a certain comeback was moved up to line up with a certain book launch, so the controversy helps with sales.
I am a soshi fan, but also well aware of what SM is like, nothing is ever what is seems
I feel bad for Garam. She got so much unnecessary hate for nothing. I'm glad I always stayed neutral. It feels like the history repeated itself. Remember the Soojin scandal?
Stupid haters, what do you have to say now? After knowing about so many K-pop bullying scandals and how most of the idols accused of bullying were proven to be innocent, I decided to stay neutral. After all, nothing was confirmed by Garam herself so why haters had to send hate for her? It's not like she harmed you.
I really appreciated her singing skills and stage presence. She could have achieved her dreams and become a great idol but see, what have you done. We first lost Soojin, and now Garam.
I just wish Garam could again become a K-pop idol. It is her dream and I know she would do a excellent job as an idol.
HYBE and everyone out there, #ApologizeToGaram .
So true. Me personally i am so sad about Garam's situations because it's like Soojin's case is repeating itself. As a Soojin stan i still tear up sometimes thinking about how a bunch of lies ruined her life and career. Now the same thing happened with Garam it's so heartbreaking.
Its good that she levaed hybe
Hybe used her so badly
u didn’t talk about how she showed the actual documents of 2018 she’s the victim, everyone owes her the biggest apology ever
Please watch the video by Doyouram Everday K-Culture ruclips.net/video/1wIL-u9N2vQ/видео.html
It has the full account of the school violence committee uploaded by Garam herself. It states that Garam and Eunseo were both at fault. Garam even apologized saying that she admits she was wrong and that she was immature back then. So technically Garam is not innocent. But people should stop attacking her since she now apologized.
Just one correction: SNSD came back after 5 years, not 7. They had the holiday one for their 10th anniversary:)
People mentioning the timing being suspicious is absolutely ridiculous. A book release is often set MONTHS before they are released, sometimes its even set when its still being edited. Its likely her book date was set before the comeback even received a date. Its the publishing company that has a say in her deadline and release date. Are you all suggesting her publishing company knew of SM's plans for a GG comeback and released the book in the timeframe SM had in mind for the comeback? Please, this ain't Spy X Family.
Lmao ppl love to witch-hunt XD😆
Both I.M and Starship Entertainment made it VERY clear that they were still staying together as a 6 member group and he would be participating in all group promotions. I don't know why people are not understanding that. They couldn't have made it any clearer.
History repeats itself. After Jimin and Mina scandal people still haven't learned. How disappointing..
For everyone continuing to hate on garam are bully’s, yall say u hate garam bc she’s a bully but ur guys are cyber bullying her. Stop being such a hypocrite.
That's the reason why I don't speak until everything is over and done with....
But I do think hybe is only debuting all these groups to fill in the hole that's going to be left by bts and their solos/vacas/enlistment futures
2022 being a gg year ✨
Got the beat debut , IVE debut , Ke1per debut , NMIXX debut , Le serrefim debut , new jeans debut .
Wonderful comebacks from ITZY, Ke1per, IVE , MANY MORE
the most awaited comebacks of blackpink and girls generation
This is why I stay away from bullying scandals because in the end of the day there’s always gonna be turn around
Garam deserves justice, she explained her side of the story and whether or not she was a bully (she is not but I'm not saying she is completely innocent), she still worked very hard to achieve her dream, to debut. Everyone that disregarded her in the group was also wrong, you listened to other peoples accusations without even bothering to hear her own side. She said in the message that she acknowledged she was wrong. I was always neutral and believed she was not a bully and not just because of looks. But because it all didn't make sense. She really deserves better and maybe even to be put back in the group, you never know.