Indias China Strategy has Changed I Indias Bold Moves against China I Lt Gen Syed Ata Hasnain I Aadi
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
- Indias China Strategy has Changed, How? Indias Bold Moves against China in Taiwan and Xinjang. Is India fighting alone?
#india #china #modi #deftalks
DEF Talks is a space for clear cut discussions on important subjects of current affairs of the world with a prime focus to the Indian Subcontinent. I cover issues related to conflicts, Geopolitics, Military Strategy and Foreign Affairs.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @deftalksbyaadi
Do support me by clicking "Thanks'.
Connect With me and Interact
EMAIL: aadiachint@gmail.com
TELEGRAM: t.me/deftalksaadi
LINKEDIN: DEF TALKS BY AADI ACHINT
TWITTER: / aadiachint
Copyrights owned.
It's always a good source of knowledge by hearing Lt. Gen Ata Hasnain Sir.
Always a pleasure to listen to Hasnain Sir 👏🏽
Oh my god the knowldege Lt Gen Syed At Hasanain sir brings is paramount.
He has a good modulation in his voice but still so non dramatic about even the most shocking thing. Love to listen to him. Thanks aadi for bringing him
My dear. Aadi did not bring me to public speaking. The Indian Army did, and I have done this for years and years with different organizations.
However, yours was a kind comment. Thank you. Need to, however, know backgrounds of people you comment on.
Lt. Gen Ata Hasnain sir is always a treat to listen to…what a personality! Truly impressive! You can hear him for hours…So knowledgeable and patriotic!
Retd Army Personnel of the caliber of Lt Gen Syed are also the big assets of our nation. Their ideas and suggestions are of extreme importance especially in shaping world opinion. Hope GOI is taking full advantage of this. Great video.
Thanks!
Thank you so much
One of the best - Lt .Gen Hasnain
Jai Hind General Hasnain Saheb
blunders made since our independence cost us heavily both in term of terriotery1962 and economically, now there is correction mode under present govt with strong political wil, which is vital for the security and safety of our nation.
Feel proud of listening this Gen of our Regiment.
Lt Gen Abhay Krishna, former Army Commander of Eastern Command (also of SW and Central Command) is an expert on China. Would like to listen to his views on India's future relation dynamics. Aadi may consider inviting him to your channel.
Just Brilliant.
It's always a Great pleasure to listen to Lt. General Syed Atta Hasnain. His intensity and depth of knowledge is very infectious.
We're proud of you Sir.
One of the best episodes of Adi. Thanks.
General Atta Hasnain speaks brilliant analysis. Great respect.
Very nicely put forth a sound and logical road map ... 🎉🎉
Jai Hind 🙏🏻
Jai Bharat 🙏🏻
Great strategic analysis
General sir jai hind u r such a pro at communication, its great to hear you. Thank u.sir
Lt gen sir namaskar
due to having turbulent times, i couldnt attend your discussions. missed them. slowly catching up. keep up the good work, please. thank you for your hard work. makes my like little easier knowning there were people who have same interests. most of my peers find topics such as this boring.
Thanks for sharing and discussing about such things and subject, looking forward to such valuable information and discussion.
Gen Hasnain sir is a majestic speaker
1. It is amusing to watch the General talking eloquently about the economic difficulties of China!! It is well known that economic conditions move cyclically and can be managed. China remains a strong country despite all these difficulties and is making life miserable for the USA and its allies like Japan and Australia. 2 But India has responded strongly after 2020 Galwan and in another 5 to 10 years, we will be fully matching the Chinese, thanks our political leadership and capable Armed Forces. The USA helping us will hasten this progress. 3. Thanks Aadi for inviting the General to discuss topics like the Taiwan conference, 3Ts etc.
Excellent discussion
Lt.Gen Hasnain Sir is an asset to Indians. Youngster from all realm can learn a lot from him.
Gen Hasnain, my deep regards as an ex soldier!
How well has India done in Psy, cyber and Star wars? Do we have formal org to plan n execute it !
I agree that this is a domain in which efforts are on but not in a very optimum way, yet
Great discussion, 👍 guys, very creative, informative
Awesome disscustion 👍👍❤️🙏🏼
Great salute to Lt Gen Syed Atta Hussain Ji❤❤❤
Namaste to Syad Sir
When I see or listen to Lt Gen Syed Atta Hussain ji, I became full of energy
I hope with China accomodating the desire of India will put an end to their dispute and focus on cooperation... Lets remember this century belong to Asia.... and India and China will be the cornerstone of the regions stabilitya and prosperity...
Nice to hear this Indian General again.
It's an impolite usage if you address anyone only by rank and by use of the word 'this'.
Instead it could have been put as- " Nice to hear General Hasnain".
It would have won you brownie points with any superior too.
True, sir ❣️👍❣️😊
🙏 Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳😊
Thanks
People come up with all kinds of questions, but nobody asks about what the Indian strategists think about Chinese presence in coco island right to the north of what he calls “effective theatre “ in Nicobar Islands.
Thanks for the video sir
A very well covered and conducted podcast and Ata as always is good
Our three forces chiefs went their is good . But we can't stop for watching the reactions of the aggressors. We must continue till they went in our like situations which they have gifted us bro. Go with greater passion 🎉 don't have second opinion in ur mind till u achieve ur interest which may be against ur ethics. It their choice. U r bound to perform bethout.
Jai Hind 🙏🏻
Jai Bharat 🙏🏻
Jai Hind ❤
Always great to hear from Gen Syed Ata Hasnain. India is slowly but surely realizing its own strength as a world power and responding to Chinese posturing with its own posturing by sending the three army chiefs to Taiwan. The message will have rung loud and clear within the CPC walls. This time when Xi Jinping comes to India for the G20 meeting, he will have his tail firmly between his legs. India will get bolder in posturing under a strong political leadership to play the Chinese in their own territory backed by a strong military - well said Gen Hasnain. Jai Hind Sir!
Yes
Great info
Amit Shah g k parliament mein bhashan se bhi china agye ayia k usko threat laga jab kaha tha k , Amit Shah g 'mera matlab j&k se pura jammu Kashmir including with pok and aksai chin bhi hai', tab china darr giya
Awesome content sir
Very interesting and informative discussion
Giving our Armed Forces with new technology, funds and kind of free hand to secure borders and deal with Pak & China and other countries around...❤
sir, I salute you. Thank you for your service
Namaskar Aadi Bhai
Suggestion to Aadi. Bunch questions so that there is no overlap
India is playing a game of chess a parallel thrust for trust, an economic and the other a pragmatic hanging sword over China.
Both beneficial in India's intrest and both detrimental to China which is admired by USA who wants an ally, an ally unlike Ukraine.
This admiration says a lot politically.
Ata sir in past we had faced great refugee intake 1972. If Pakistan is in economics doldrum in future.Why don't we build innovative boundary wall .That bill boost our economy.
For me, the single most important point made by Lt Gen Hasnain was to be very skeptical about the economic weakness in China. A few indirect pointers in that direction:
1. German companies continue to announce expansion plans in China. Clearly, European businesses are neither decoupling from nor are bearish about China
2. American consumer spending thus far has remained robust. Even if one allocates an increased share of that spending towards services; spending on goods has not cratered. And if manufacturing activities have not moved completely out of China; clearly China continues to remain a beneficiary of American spending, even if it is at a slightly reduced level
3.The recent decision by Indian government to ban imports of laptops drew a howl of protest from US companies, notably the chip manufacturers. Could there be a clearer indication of US companies continuing to be beneficiaries of manufacturing activity in China, serving the global market?
It does not matter how the Western media reports on anything; we need to always take these reports with lumps of salt!
Excellent analysis about China’s future plan.
1:00:58
Whether any nation is capable of altering the climatic conditions , which can be used as a weapon ?
👌👌👍👍🙏🙏
Sir, why does India not issue a new map in which Kailas Mansarovar, Tibbat, and a few other parts presently under China are shown as a part of new India ?
People im JNU may think the PLA is 10 feet tall. Nobody else does. Also, its noteworthy that the Indian Navy is DEFINITELY a bluewater Navy and is well positioned to be a dominant force by 2030 in the IOR. The Indian Navy is the least sung, but the most strategic minded of the three services. Overall. Not infividually.
Blue water navy. No one in the Indian Navy even says that. India will eventually have one but till then hold your horses
Not unconsciously but sub consiciously
Have we accepted Tibet is part of China (unlike anywhere before 1950 ever, when Tibet was part of Chinese Empire on & off, but preserved her language, culture & distinctive religion)? If so (we accepted it) not under duress or circumstances, PRC scored a very big victory. It reduces us to a position where we quibble for border solution. PRC is very happy as long as India considers it as "border" issue and engaged with it.
Tibet has always been a nation but that complexion gradually changed after 1950. How does the "World" (don't bring in India) view this?
High time we got over the China phobia and resort to direct 1 to 1 dealings instead of beating about the bush. Creating irritation will not help us in any manner, instead will only harm our cause.
Sir, I am interested in such talks. Your analysis and presentation is excellent. I think if I was in place of Xi , I will make China-India relationship much stronger. It will help balance the west & US. For this I will support India on POK , leave Axai Chin and take help of India for one belt project. Stabilize boarder issue. It will make China-India relationship at a different levels.
U mean, Bharat should be subservient to China!
- One China can also mean Mainland China belongs to Taiwan
- Great idea that veteran Indian diplomats and servicemen attend at least 100 conferences a year. Should not be left as a suggestion but pushed with more zeal and action
- Demographics is bad for US and Europe also, but immigration has solved that to some extent. This is not available to China as it hasn’t to closed societies like Japan
- Why are US/India not creating the Strategic Ambiguity in Tibet
Mao used to say. Thrash India in a way to subdue the will to fight for at least next forty years so as not to be able to pose any threat or completion in Asia.
Please do it in English also
Wasn't it mixed well. English and Hindi
In 20/20 china kept on saying 1962 yaad dila dengae.recently it has stopped it.
Logical, can’t deny we were living in world of our own, my grandparents and parents were influenced by some of westerners methods… such as organising ability , systematic education system, example all catholic convent schools had same syllabus If I went from , Amritsar convent to Dalhousie convent in summer I’ll be admitted in the same class and continue my studies as if there has not been any break. This system was easier for children to follow. Our education system is still in such a big mess, it changes with every change of one single individual. Wordy sorry.
You gentlemen are talking in Hindglish !
Can't understand a word..
I have a question. How does India propose to replace its losses in the event it fights China?
Will Russia supply India with enough SU 37, T90s and related equipment in the middle of an intense war and with enough weapons to replace losses at the Divisional level?
Given the many external factors--drop in Chinese exports to U.S., the negative environmental impacts, drop it its internal consumption, drop in favourable image of China all over the world and expecially in Asean countries, and too much dependence on exports which aren't growing, the diminishing returns of its infra structure investments and loans--do you think China may recover fast. If so why?
What about Tibet!
I saw in a video that they are letting Maui burn so that the Property developers to come in and make money through redevelopment projects.
There economy will recover soon as festival season is approaching and we are idiot enough and not able to boycott their products.
Shouldn't we grab opportunity to start confrontation soonest possible.
We should stop being obsessed with both China & Pakistan.
In the event of Taiwan flare we must open Northern borders.
Ardi either Hindi or English.
Ask govt. totrain lacs near China border. only few days training in case of war they can be pushed in war.See how Russia is facing shortage of personnel in war.
If we not getting information, then what our hacker are doing 😭
Put some of India combating.forces in countries around vicinity of China boundaries and close to Tiwan as this will.correct Chinise military arrogance towards India and fortify Indian image
Russia will.slme day have to.fight Chinese as these have eye on Baldibostas state of Russia. Chinese claim it as their own teritorry
We can recognize Taiwan as true and one China.
It would been better if had spoken in English.
Why was my comment withdrawn
Which comment. do keep it clear so that YT sensors don’t pick it up. I don’t delete comments
It’s very much there as a reply to someone
Is this English?
Tajikistan cpec belt
We are naive enough to give respote to our strategic adversaries and they take advantage of this foolishness, rather India should rachet up the heat a few notch when they are engaged else where, this will give them taste of their own medicine.
This discussion was all about that. Hope you actually listen in
कृपया हिंदी में बोले
I DONT THINK CHINA GROWTH WILL BE 5%
Sorry no time to spare from politcs 24/7
Gen Husnain is wrong about Indian army being weak vs china in 1962. At that time Indian army was comparatively better equipped and trained in comprison to china. The only reason army lost was because of nepotism indulged in by Nehru in directly over ruling army chief and putting his own cousin in charge of a fake corps created overnight. Today the situation is diff. China has way more economic and military power vs india.
😅😅 thoda padh lo Bhai.....WhatsApp University se bhi alag duniya hai, general sahab is absolute right ....
AND GADDAR IN MILITARY TOO WHO KILLED 3-4 GEMS WAS IN OWN MILTARY GAVE LEAKED ALL TO TAKE LIVES
#AskAadi China asked that Buffer zone be inside Indian controlled territory and none in China controlled territory and rumours are that India agreed!! Does that mean that despite our jingoism, we are actually afraid/too cautious?
your info in question is totally fake .....just like your thoughts----research more and then come back with references of what ur saying.
Why waste time talking about guesses.
Subscribed to your channel halfway through my first ever video of yours but you know what.. you need to learn time management.. these days whenever I get a notification from tour channel I look at the length of the video first..its scary man.. honestly.. every single video is in excess of one hour including this one that I am now commenting on.. nah baba.. please cut down.. your content is very good but the duration.. please....you seem to have all the time on earth but defo not your subscribers however much good and patriotic your content is.. those who agree ..show it with your 👍
I watch it in 1.5X speed. You can also try.
I agree that such videos should be under 30 minutes
I invite you to not watch !!!
@@DEFTALKSbyAadi yes that's what I did..
@@DEFTALKSbyAadi absolutely! What do you think most of subscribers do then?! Sit through this one hour+ long torture or what?? never watched any of your videos fully... and I bet you will get this from more of us.. 😂😂😂😂.. such arrogance won't help dude.. that was an honest feedback I gave..
Murkh ko murkh ki bhasa mein samjhana padta hai.
Sir, what are the chances of freeing Tibet, East Turkistan(xinziang), Inner Manngolia etc. Don’t you think this is best time to act. Added to neighbours of China being against China, Environment also acting against,Covid also raising it’s ugly head apart from all this Collapse of banking, failure of infrastructure industry etc on top of all this unrest in China, shifting of international Cos, so on so far.
The US bonds sale is the last tranch of cash China will have. After that, China will not have any forex except gold (6920 tons and going).
Which is why China might be even more anxious to take Taiwan, of late. Taiwan’s exports are supposed to fix its cash position thereafter, and it might probably use the gold to finance the aggression.
FISHY FISHY ALWAYS ON FACE IS ONLY WRONG TO DISTRACT U OK FROM UR GOAL AND TO BE STRICT