And remember you can not judge if someone is healthy or not just by looking at her/his body. Being fat, skinny or average does not determine nothing, you need to know their habits and metabolism (:
In a lot cases, yes, we can see it from their body. When someone used to be average sized and is now extra skinny, that's not healthy. That's extreme diet. Nobody's metabolism can cause them to go from being average size to extra skinny.
@@abcdefoff3307 when they grow tall even the average size they used to be in seems thinner for us. Everyone in my family told me I am getting underweight when I grew taller but when I checked I was in my right weight. Taller people has more bone weight than muscles. This could be the case with Yuna and wonyoung coz they were minors when they debuted and grew taller
@@aaa-9399 I totally get your point. But loosing weight could also be a result of emotional or biological factors, yes, maybe most of them are not healthy for our eyes (remember that sizes and weight are different in Asia caused by biological and geographical differences) but we really need to know what’s going on in their lives
@disappointment3090Thing is, less so for those with elaborate dance choreography, many women in general have very little muscle mass along with genetically they store their fat in the hips, thighs and bust. So even if they're a healthy 20% body fat it looks really skinny and you can see the upper ab lines. This is simply what skinny fat is. There's no muscle displacement and its all internal organs, bones and fat and if you have the right genetics for fat distribution and bone structure, can look really skinny and be considered attractive.
Yeah, that's why they showed skinny girls in the healthy examples. The girls shown in the unhealthy examples aren't "skinny", they're pretty underweight, and them being "naturally"/effortlessly like that doesn't make it any less unhealthy
Yea but this much skinny and yes skinny doesn't mean unhealthy, I am skinny too . If you have a skinny body doesn't mean to leave it like that ( I am not body shaming) coz it can lead to osteoporosis , anaemia , or pregnancy problems Ngl but nowadays people consider anything as body shaming , yea they can't gain a lot of weight but atleast can try to gain somewhat 1,1.5 kgs or that much as they can , If someone is saying something about your body doesn't always means it shaming or insulting but Max time it is but not always
being THIN doesn't mean they are "UNHEALTHY" . they are KPOP IDOL they know how to take care of their own body and its one of their "beauty standard" i don't know why people always curious about it 😅
You must be dumb on purpose. These ppl have no idea what health is if their diet consist of starving themselves. Anyone who knows nutrition knows it's not about restricting food but about balancing food with a healthy amount of excise. These ppl are doing that. They barely eat and look insanely thin. That's not healthy.
I bet you most people talking sh*t in this video are overweight, clearly this video was created spawn hatred and controversy for the sake of views cause there's no way to tell if someone is healthy or unhealthy just by watching an image.
Ok well guess what. Wonyoung is 19 years old. The average weight of a 19 year old is 156. However, wonyoung weighs 102. Do you know the average weight of a 13 year old? It is 102 meaning, wonyoung weights the same as a 13 year old clearly proving she is unhealthy.
@@Favoritefruitisblackberries you’re just skinny shaming. Some people are naturally skinny, and some people have a hard time gaining weight. Even though I eat a lot, I only gain a little bit of weight. It’s probably the same for Wonyoung where she just has a hard time gaining weight
It makes me very sad that people are focused on their bodies rather than their mental health. They are aware of their bodies more than anyone else. Whether they’re ‘healthy’ or ‘unhealthy’ they have support systems around them to be there for them. You never know what someone is going through until you’re in their shoes.
@@riyannugraha9547 I’m aware of that but don’t forget that the narrative would change if it’s in our control. They have friends, lovers and family members to support them through this. If they didn’t they would have indicated such, they would have asked for support in indirect manners. There are many idols out there who have told their fans to stop treating them like children, they are aware of the things we only just notice after it’s focused upon Also, most of the time idols suffer bcs of our focus on these things. A lot of examples are out there and it’s too heartbreaking to mention. Whether it’s one of the reasons or not, it still makes it a reason that someone decided they weren’t worthy enough.
@@antaequeJ Yeah but everyone praise their beauty and their body proportion, and idol happy about that. Do they just want to be praised? they work in entertainment as idol and you can't deny that their bodies are one of their selling points then we can't talk about that?
@@riyannugraha9547 respect where you’re coming from. About that tho; nah, I didn’t say anything about them wanting just praise. Let’s say, you’re willing to work hard for your dreams right? Whether it be for the fame, the satisfaction, a long-awaited endeavour, accomplishment, wealth (which in this industry is very unlikely if you don’t make it big) etc, you’re already aware of the highs and lows to come (for an idol specifically, the trainee period indicates to the harsh life they are about to endure, but they’re also aware of the advantages; the long-awaited rewards) You do not however realise how much it will affect you until you’re facing such trials. If you’re working hard you want to be acknowledged for it, and the praise, everyone wants praise but for idols they always receive compliments on their appearances (and backlash Ofc, lots of that. But in person ppl can’t really say a bad thing to them :/ the hypocrisy lol) so it means much more to them when people praise their passion, their artistry, their ability to perform etc. we as viewers look to these people to find the ideal picture, the ideal vision. We find it hard to accept that even they have their flaws bcs we are so desperate to escape our own. I went off track, sorry, to keep it simplified; at the end of the day, we don’t know these people in person no matter how desperately we want to connect to them. It’s sad but true. They wouldn’t take our advice seriously unless they don’t have anyone else to give them such. They don’t owe us an explanation. Especially idols who are grown adults, they probably find it very ridiculous that we are referring to their struggles as if we will solve them. I hope they can work through their stuff. But bringing awareness to something so vulnerable and constantly putting emphasis on it will only make them ‘prove’ and ‘defy’ the facts with their actions, and that does not solve it at all. Again, the unspoken thing about ED that should be mentioned; if it’s noticeable, the person experiencing it can clearly see what’s going on. The first thing they hope for when they step out to face the world is for people NOT to mention it
@@riyannugraha9547 also I really respect that you care enough to defend your point. Not everyone cares for these idols the way you seem to. Just remember that if the care they want from us is the kind that is congruent and non-judgemental, I think we owe that much for the respect they show us despite the toxicity amongst such fandoms. Respect of boundaries and such ❤️
It's not our business whether the idol has a very skinny body, infact, it isn't our business how the idols body looks at all. It's between them and their doctor. Also let's not talk abt their bodies, but their talent
Them and their doctor? You can't be that stupid on purpose. These ppl don't know proper nutrition if their lives depended on it. You have momo literally only eating ice to stay thin. Is that healthy? Dieting is not about restricting food it's about balancing calories with healthy excerise. These people aren't doing that. Literally look at them, no healthy person looks like that. It's all skin and bones no muscles. They all look like that one RUclipsr eugenia cooney. They aren't toned whatsoever. They are all headed in her direction if ppl don't intervene. You fans propergate unhealthy lifestyle then get mad and gaslight others when people call it out. Y'all are the problem as well as the industry that is so hell-bent on looks and "visual". Y'all are just as bad as Korean netizens. I guess you get to live your Koreaboo fantasy. 😅🥴
I am skinny and people always think I am unhealthy when I am perfectly one of the most healthy person ,so it differs to each person . Your health and unhealthy is very different from many people health and unhealthy
this is getting ridiculous!! i was extremely unhealthy but looked very healthy for a few years. i was a bit on the chubby side and i hated it so for 2 years i would barely eat and put my body through hell and back. i still didn't lose much weight because i had an undiagnosed conditioned so i was literally praised left and right for having a healthy body and not being a stick while i was on "a banana a day" type of diets... like... i would literally eat NOTHING all day except a single banana in the morning. i looked great for everyone with "meat on my bones". now i'm 48kgs (5ft4) and i've never felt better. i eat 3 base meals a day and 3 snacks. i work out a lot as well. you can see my ribs and hip bones and it annoys the hell out of me but i'm the most healthy i've ever been. i've been doing blood work and checkups every 2 months for the past 2 years and all the doctors are very impressed how well i take care of myself now and told me 1 million times to stop worrying about my ribs and hip bones. they're very important body parts and acting like someone is dying if you can see them is very stupid.
imagine if someone put a far idol as unhealthy. comments would talk about how you can't say someone is unhealthy by looks but its okay when it's a skinny person ig. just SHUT UP about ppl's bodies.
Im Gen X in Australia my heart goes out to these young girls 😢.I know the beauty standards are very unrealistic .As someone who is curvy but loves K-pop I rarely watch girl group performances or videos because I know it can be triggering . But was also shocked when male idols admitted the pressure they were under 🙁.I have an active job , eat healthy & go to the gym but Im not slim . Our lives should not be dictated by the number on the scale . I spent many having a unhealthy relationship with food & exercise & finally stopped comparing myself . I hope someday idols are not so harshly judged . A lot of people end up with health & joint issues after years of strict dieting & over exercising. Also there is injuries . When we're young we feel invisible. When you get older you realise the body is the temple that houses your soul & should be appreciated.🙏🕊️
Some people have naturally skinny bodies because of genetics (or other things). I mean no hate in this comment btw, but I don't like this talk about haters/fans comparing idols/people's bodies to other when in reality we all look different and have different genetics.
Plenty of people with actual diagnosed anorexia who are severely underweight manage to exercise several hours a day - activity level is literally irrelevant here.
People who intentionally get too skinny following the trends, looking at the idols. Let me tell you a unhealthy body under extreme conditions has never been attractive or not for too long. And that type of skinny has its own repercussions. Stop inviting illness. Aim for a healthy, fit body. That is whats attractive
It's nobody's business if someone is underweight and skinny. And they are naturally skinny. They may lose confidence if y'all keep calling them skinny. And just because they are skinny doesn't mean they are unhealthy. There's no need to compare unhealthy and healthy idols, what even is this it could kill their confidence if you keep comparing them to others
Some idols may be too skinny, some idols may be chubby, but in my eyes all kpop idols are beautiful/handsome. ( just because someone looks skinny or chubby doesn't mean their unhealthy)
Girls, this is not body shaming, some of them have risked their health for that thinness, it is not genetic or good to follow trends for it, or are you going to tell me that Woonyoung is healthy with those skeletal proportions but we have seen her with more muscle mass previously? What about Wendy? or maybe Yuna with marked ribs and not by stretching while dancing. If you want to lose weight, be realistic, because Jisoo is not safe either with her inexorable way of losing weight for her comeback.
This kind of videos are so stupid, the comments too. You can't determine if a person is unhealthy or healthy based on assumptions or your beauty standars. If the person is too fat or extremely skinny, for example Wonyoung in some moments, I kinda get the worry. But yall need to stop thinking that every skinny person is unhealthy, thats just not true and it's extremely offensive 💀 And honestly their weight is none of our business, but i'm sick of this kind of trend of criticizing bodies, so I had to give my perspective :/
Literally hop they make a mandatory rule where all kpop idols nd trainees must be in the gym working out and eating healthy that fits their bmi. Cause honestly their work schedule plus training and dieting is horrendous to the body
I agree that the idols shown as unhealthy were a bit on the thin side. Unfortunately, they work in an industry where they need to be super thin. It's hard to live a healthy lifestyle as an idol. I look chubby even when I am thin because my bone structure is not petite and having big boobs doesn't make me look thin either. The "unhealthy" girls probably have a more petite frame therefore look too thin but are probably healthy.
Being skinny doesn't mean unhealthy, same as being not this skinny, doesn't mean healthy. I thought it was obvious but it seams kpop fans need a drawing.
But no... She gained weight due to health problems So... Why do yall think Im a Jeongyeon hater? i do NOT consider her body "ugly", I really love her as an artist in twice. I was happy to see her at a new concert after such a long time. But there are facts - she experienced a severe form of a hernia + struggled with mental problems, because of which she had to take antidepressants (I dont know exactly what medications she took). These problems are what caused her weight gain, and those reasons are unhealthy, as much as you all would like to believe that she gained weight of her own accord.
@@hoshinohh girly has been always skinny. And she has gained some weight for their new comeback. Some of these picture were also edited to make her more skinny
@@strawberri_rush I said it doesn't ALWAYS mean. There are a lot of idols who eat fine, but they are still really skinny. I'm not saying that applies to everyone. Yes some idols are malnourished and underweight
my version of healthy is being underweight and sick. i have issues with my image so my family help me with their standards , in some ways it’s helpful.
Can people wake up and learn that some people are born extremely skinny. I love food, yet you can see 99% of my bones on my stomach, like it looks bad, but I'm not unhealthy.
U can’t just claim that skinnier bodies are less healthy, while “thicker” ones are healthy. Both can be healthy and unhealthy, so pls stop categorizing. It just creates unnecessary shaming and eating disorders. Edit: The point of my comment flew over most of yall's heads💀. I never claimed that most idols don't have eating disorders....my point is that you can't judge health solely by appearance. Some ppl have rly fast metabolisms (finds it extremely difficult to gain weight) such as Lisa, but they get skinny shamed all the time, while others such as Jeongyeon (Twice) have health problems that make them fuller, but it doesn't make them healthy either.
Who tf said Karina's body is "thick"? Is not about that, is about the fact that beauty standards are almost killing young girls out there and people like you be like "sToP dOiNg ThAt THeY ArE HeAlThY 😭😭😭you're a hateeeer" grew up and stop normalizing people being almost anorexic
That’s not true. If you see bones that means there’s not enough fat which women need more than men to have their periods and have regular hormone levels
@@michaelscottspapercompany6373 that’s not necessarily true, there’s a lot of people that are super skinny and you can see their bones some but they have an extremely hard time gaining weight
@@londonbuehler8712 yes but thats not the case for some of these idols, i cant speak for the other idols but wonyoung did not look THIS thin in iz*one nor was she unbelievably thin when she was a child so we can safely assume she's either unhealthy or just barely healthy
healthy ones are the skinny little kiddo. others are unhealthy skeletons. there is nothing wrong with obese shaming too 😂 if you re influencing people with your unhealhty ss you deserve the drag
@@Am_._they’re not just “skinny”, they’re borderline underweight. nobody is shaming them, it’s just alarming how slim these idols are in comparison to their height.
my body looks like Jisoo’s and we’re even the same height and yet I have an eating disorder so you can’t really tell whether someone’s body is healthy just by looking at them
@@funniestcomment7305 that’s their point. The video is saying jisoo has a healthy body based off of her appearance. But this commenter is saying they look like Jisoo and they have an eating disorder and therefore aren’t healthy. They’re saying that you can’t say someone (like jisoo in this example) is healthy just based off of their appearance. So jisoo may have one too or she may not, but you can’t just claim she’s healthy by the fact that she’s slim and has defined muscle. There’s a lot more to it than that
It's hard to stay healthy in that industry especially when you have to stay skinny , So much so that it's really common for Kpop idols to faint from so much pressure Edit: This is not ok , Don't body shame them because it's something most can't control ( This is not a message directed to the creator of the channel but to others) And I think that this all needs to stop the Company's need to treat them like human beings
please do not judge someone’s health just looking at their body. even doctors tests blood and do lots of checks to know your health. if you want to be healthy go to doctor and don’t stress too much🥰
@b No it doesn't? I just have a fast metabolism. I eat the most in my whole family and yet stay skinny. I have gone to many doctors and they all say that I'm healthy
@@mr00p37It also depends on height. Also, bmi scales are outdated and really only works for men. It doesn’t take account of factors such as breast size which could add extra weight
@@Hia.97 SAME! I have fast metabolism, and it's from my genes, I have Yuna's body but a little bit thicker, and everyone says I look a little unhealthy, I turned 14 last month, and I'm still growing up, that's what makes it upsetting, And I'm going through puberty, They know I'm not unhealthy, and they also know I have fast metabolism, and its from my genes, that what makes it even more upsetting.
![[C.C.] Check out their pilates routine! #IVE #YUJIN #WONYOUNG](/img/1.gif)
Diii plzz pin me plzzzzzzxzz
Coming from kerala??
@@night_sky_ samee
what will get get if u get pin.. smhh
@@peekaboov809ATTENTION
@@purple__dreams3059 it's not always attention
every else's photos: 🧍♀️
karina: 🤸♀️
1.2k likes and no comments let me fix that ❤
Fr frr!! 😭
Jisoo
😂
i like that picture a lot now 😂
And remember you can not judge if someone is healthy or not just by looking at her/his body. Being fat, skinny or average does not determine nothing, you need to know their habits and metabolism (:
In a lot cases, yes, we can see it from their body. When someone used to be average sized and is now extra skinny, that's not healthy. That's extreme diet. Nobody's metabolism can cause them to go from being average size to extra skinny.
you can easily tell in k-pop tho. most of the idols in here lost weight very drastically = unhealthy. the healthy part is arguable tho.
@@abcdefoff3307 when they grow tall even the average size they used to be in seems thinner for us. Everyone in my family told me I am getting underweight when I grew taller but when I checked I was in my right weight. Taller people has more bone weight than muscles. This could be the case with Yuna and wonyoung coz they were minors when they debuted and grew taller
Actually no
@@aaa-9399 I totally get your point. But loosing weight could also be a result of emotional or biological factors, yes, maybe most of them are not healthy for our eyes (remember that sizes and weight are different in Asia caused by biological and geographical differences) but we really need to know what’s going on in their lives
Don't care about anything else
Tzuyu straight up be slaying that introooooooooo❤❤❤❤
can you tell me that song name ?
@@user-ei72hhs8 Gael stone - left right
@@user-ei72hhs8left and right by gael stone
@@user-ei72hhs8Left and right song
Ok this is straight up body shaming let's please stop it 😭✋🏻
Actually, this is pretty accurate. All idols that they've claimed to have an unhealthy body have lost weight very quickly.
Not directly. So many signs Wonyoungs body was incredibly unhealthy, and especially in Jype diets are real, and they‘re not okay at all
Generally the kpop industry is top visual focused, and it‘s very very unhealthy
It isn't stop being apologetic
@@shenayahoffmann701
Lmao are you stupid? Wony recently got a 5kg weight gain and a healthy body post on Instagram where she turned MUCH healthier
being skinny doesn’t mean your automatically unhealthy wtf 💀
Fr and having no dad doesn’t mean your healrhy
@disappointment3090Thing is, less so for those with elaborate dance choreography, many women in general have very little muscle mass along with genetically they store their fat in the hips, thighs and bust. So even if they're a healthy 20% body fat it looks really skinny and you can see the upper ab lines. This is simply what skinny fat is. There's no muscle displacement and its all internal organs, bones and fat and if you have the right genetics for fat distribution and bone structure, can look really skinny and be considered attractive.
being skinny and being underweight are two very different things
Being able to see bones everywhere means a person is likely underweight=> unhealthy. Bad for your health and heart
It doesn't mean you're unhealthy no. But it's an unhealthy body type if they're just standing still and you can see the outline of their bones.
Some people are just naturally skinny. Skinny is not equal to unhealthy.!
Yeah, that's why they showed skinny girls in the healthy examples. The girls shown in the unhealthy examples aren't "skinny", they're pretty underweight, and them being "naturally"/effortlessly like that doesn't make it any less unhealthy
Yea but this much skinny and yes skinny doesn't mean unhealthy, I am skinny too .
If you have a skinny body doesn't mean to leave it like that ( I am not body shaming) coz it can lead to osteoporosis , anaemia , or pregnancy problems
Ngl but nowadays people consider anything as body shaming , yea they can't gain a lot of weight but atleast can try to gain somewhat 1,1.5 kgs or that much as they can ,
If someone is saying something about your body doesn't always means it shaming or insulting but Max time it is but not always
being THIN doesn't mean they are "UNHEALTHY" . they are KPOP IDOL they know how to take care of their own body and its one of their "beauty standard" i don't know why people always curious about it 😅
You must be dumb on purpose. These ppl have no idea what health is if their diet consist of starving themselves. Anyone who knows nutrition knows it's not about restricting food but about balancing food with a healthy amount of excise. These ppl are doing that. They barely eat and look insanely thin. That's not healthy.
Some of them are borderline anorexic...that definitely cant be healthy!
Jisoo my bias ❤
Skinny is not unhealthy. My body looks a lot like Wonyoung but I’m healthy and completely fine. Skinny is usually perfectly healthy
I bet you most people talking sh*t in this video are overweight, clearly this video was created spawn hatred and controversy for the sake of views cause there's no way to tell if someone is healthy or unhealthy just by watching an image.
Ok well guess what. Wonyoung is 19 years old. The average weight of a 19 year old is 156. However, wonyoung weighs 102. Do you know the average weight of a 13 year old? It is 102 meaning, wonyoung weights the same as a 13 year old clearly proving she is unhealthy.
@@Favoritefruitisblackberries you’re just skinny shaming. Some people are naturally skinny, and some people have a hard time gaining weight. Even though I eat a lot, I only gain a little bit of weight. It’s probably the same for Wonyoung where she just has a hard time gaining weight
It makes me very sad that people are focused on their bodies rather than their mental health. They are aware of their bodies more than anyone else. Whether they’re ‘healthy’ or ‘unhealthy’ they have support systems around them to be there for them. You never know what someone is going through until you’re in their shoes.
The process how idol body is formed might be affect heir mental health. Maybe they forced to do heavy diet.
@@riyannugraha9547 I’m aware of that but don’t forget that the narrative would change if it’s in our control. They have friends, lovers and family members to support them through this. If they didn’t they would have indicated such, they would have asked for support in indirect manners. There are many idols out there who have told their fans to stop treating them like children, they are aware of the things we only just notice after it’s focused upon
Also, most of the time idols suffer bcs of our focus on these things. A lot of examples are out there and it’s too heartbreaking to mention. Whether it’s one of the reasons or not, it still makes it a reason that someone decided they weren’t worthy enough.
@@antaequeJ Yeah but everyone praise their beauty and their body proportion, and idol happy about that. Do they just want to be praised? they work in entertainment as idol and you can't deny that their bodies are one of their selling points then we can't talk about that?
@@riyannugraha9547 respect where you’re coming from. About that tho; nah, I didn’t say anything about them wanting just praise. Let’s say, you’re willing to work hard for your dreams right? Whether it be for the fame, the satisfaction, a long-awaited endeavour, accomplishment, wealth (which in this industry is very unlikely if you don’t make it big) etc, you’re already aware of the highs and lows to come (for an idol specifically, the trainee period indicates to the harsh life they are about to endure, but they’re also aware of the advantages; the long-awaited rewards) You do not however realise how much it will affect you until you’re facing such trials. If you’re working hard you want to be acknowledged for it, and the praise, everyone wants praise but for idols they always receive compliments on their appearances (and backlash Ofc, lots of that. But in person ppl can’t really say a bad thing to them :/ the hypocrisy lol) so it means much more to them when people praise their passion, their artistry, their ability to perform etc. we as viewers look to these people to find the ideal picture, the ideal vision. We find it hard to accept that even they have their flaws bcs we are so desperate to escape our own.
I went off track, sorry, to keep it simplified; at the end of the day, we don’t know these people in person no matter how desperately we want to connect to them. It’s sad but true. They wouldn’t take our advice seriously unless they don’t have anyone else to give them such. They don’t owe us an explanation. Especially idols who are grown adults, they probably find it very ridiculous that we are referring to their struggles as if we will solve them. I hope they can work through their stuff. But bringing awareness to something so vulnerable and constantly putting emphasis on it will only make them ‘prove’ and ‘defy’ the facts with their actions, and that does not solve it at all.
Again, the unspoken thing about ED that should be mentioned; if it’s noticeable, the person experiencing it can clearly see what’s going on. The first thing they hope for when they step out to face the world is for people NOT to mention it
@@riyannugraha9547 also I really respect that you care enough to defend your point. Not everyone cares for these idols the way you seem to. Just remember that if the care they want from us is the kind that is congruent and non-judgemental, I think we owe that much for the respect they show us despite the toxicity amongst such fandoms. Respect of boundaries and such ❤️
*Karina has the best body proportions*
Jisoo's abs have their own fandom ✨
It's not our business whether the idol has a very skinny body, infact, it isn't our business how the idols body looks at all. It's between them and their doctor. Also let's not talk abt their bodies, but their talent
Them and their doctor? You can't be that stupid on purpose. These ppl don't know proper nutrition if their lives depended on it. You have momo literally only eating ice to stay thin. Is that healthy? Dieting is not about restricting food it's about balancing calories with healthy excerise. These people aren't doing that. Literally look at them, no healthy person looks like that. It's all skin and bones no muscles. They all look like that one RUclipsr eugenia cooney. They aren't toned whatsoever. They are all headed in her direction if ppl don't intervene. You fans propergate unhealthy lifestyle then get mad and gaslight others when people call it out. Y'all are the problem as well as the industry that is so hell-bent on looks and "visual". Y'all are just as bad as Korean netizens. I guess you get to live your Koreaboo fantasy. 😅🥴
They forced to be unhealthy for us.. didn't u know?
@@Me-gj9dmOkay, but they are strangers to us and we are not doctors. Their health is not our business. There’s rules for a reason.
@@neb.9489 you don't need to be a doctor to know the basic BMI... It's to know if you're healthy or not
I am skinny and people always think I am unhealthy when I am perfectly one of the most healthy person ,so it differs to each person . Your health and unhealthy is very different from many people health and unhealthy
Karina has the healthiest body ❤ of all I've seen
YUNA does Karina is ugly
She is underweight tho
@@JihyosPark wdym?
@@Julianahfamador she is underweight her bmi is 15.3
karina is literally my body goals oh my god she’s just perfection
this is getting ridiculous!! i was extremely unhealthy but looked very healthy for a few years. i was a bit on the chubby side and i hated it so for 2 years i would barely eat and put my body through hell and back. i still didn't lose much weight because i had an undiagnosed conditioned so i was literally praised left and right for having a healthy body and not being a stick while i was on "a banana a day" type of diets... like... i would literally eat NOTHING all day except a single banana in the morning. i looked great for everyone with "meat on my bones".
now i'm 48kgs (5ft4) and i've never felt better. i eat 3 base meals a day and 3 snacks. i work out a lot as well. you can see my ribs and hip bones and it annoys the hell out of me but i'm the most healthy i've ever been. i've been doing blood work and checkups every 2 months for the past 2 years and all the doctors are very impressed how well i take care of myself now and told me 1 million times to stop worrying about my ribs and hip bones. they're very important body parts and acting like someone is dying if you can see them is very stupid.
okay but that tzuyu edit slayed so hard!!??
THE INTRO OMG😭😭😭
Bro the intro has me dead so good💀❤
I thought I was the only one 😂😂
Omg the edit of tzuyu ateee ✝️💟
that intro edit tho was soo good
this is such a mean video lol
just imagine someone posting something like this about your body
fr
Jisoo ❤️
imagine if someone put a far idol as unhealthy. comments would talk about how you can't say someone is unhealthy by looks but its okay when it's a skinny person ig. just SHUT UP about ppl's bodies.
Karina is the definition of PERFECTION
Karina's body is like a chef kiss
Tzuyu has the most beautiful healthily hourglass body in my view
Why do people care so much about idol's bodies? It's not up to us to decide whether someone's body healthy or not, none of our business literally
Im Gen X in Australia my heart goes out to these young girls 😢.I know the beauty standards are very unrealistic .As someone who is curvy but loves K-pop I rarely watch girl group performances or videos because I know it can be triggering . But was also shocked when male idols admitted the pressure they were under 🙁.I have an active job , eat healthy & go to the gym but Im not slim . Our lives should not be dictated by the number on the scale . I spent many having a unhealthy relationship with food & exercise & finally stopped comparing myself . I hope someday idols are not so harshly judged . A lot of people end up with health & joint issues after years of strict dieting & over exercising. Also there is injuries . When we're young we feel invisible. When you get older you realise the body is the temple that houses your soul & should be appreciated.🙏🕊️
Some people have naturally skinny bodies because of genetics (or other things). I mean no hate in this comment btw, but I don't like this talk about haters/fans comparing idols/people's bodies to other when in reality we all look different and have different genetics.
Healthy - jisoo❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
People, in the unhealthy ones I can literally see their ribs protruding more than they should.
Jisoo 💪💪
I’m sorry if they’re able to dance and sing 5+ hours everyday, none of them are unhealthy. I’d like to see OP try
Plenty of people with actual diagnosed anorexia who are severely underweight manage to exercise several hours a day - activity level is literally irrelevant here.
The way I immediately recognized the building karina was be hinde
Kpop Boy group be like :
Before : Normal weight with little bit muscle
After : Shredded Sixpack
People who intentionally get too skinny following the trends, looking at the idols. Let me tell you a unhealthy body under extreme conditions has never been attractive or not for too long. And that type of skinny has its own repercussions. Stop inviting illness. Aim for a healthy, fit body. That is whats attractive
It's nobody's business if someone is underweight and skinny. And they are naturally skinny. They may lose confidence if y'all keep calling them skinny. And just because they are skinny doesn't mean they are unhealthy.
There's no need to compare unhealthy and healthy idols, what even is this it could kill their confidence if you keep comparing them to others
Me ignoring the context of the video and twerking to the music at past midnight on my bed lmao.
Oh my god who's that idol in the into? So pretty ❤
Tzuyu from twice
Being not as skinny as others doesn't meqn a healthy body!
My mom is naturally so skinny and she eats a lot. She’s been skinny shamed her whole life. Stop assuming skinny ppl are unhealthy.
Not gonna lie I thought I was gonna get sunghooned like "why are you still here" I don't know why🤔
yall really have to realize that body size doesn’t determine if you are healthy or not 💀
GOD DAMN I CAN'T STOP REPLAYING THE INTRO
minji is so body goals
Lmao the logic of this video:
Big boobs✅
Small boobs: MY GOD UR STARVING!
Also Jiwoo from nmixx has a healthy body 🤩 she recently slimmed but I still say she looks great
u cant tell how healthy they are bc of their bodies bro
Some idols may be too skinny, some idols may be chubby, but in my eyes all kpop idols are beautiful/handsome. ( just because someone looks skinny or chubby doesn't mean their unhealthy)
Jisoo is perfect woman❤❤
Girls, this is not body shaming, some of them have risked their health for that thinness, it is not genetic or good to follow trends for it, or are you going to tell me that Woonyoung is healthy with those skeletal proportions but we have seen her with more muscle mass previously? What about Wendy? or maybe Yuna with marked ribs and not by stretching while dancing. If you want to lose weight, be realistic, because Jisoo is not safe either with her inexorable way of losing weight for her comeback.
I know you didn't just drag my girl Wonyoung like that-
Tzuyu in the intro tho
She's simply saying fat idols vs skinny idols 😂😂😂
omg BODY SHAMING!?? So quirky keep going sis you slayed and ate 😍😍
okay yuna is very much healthy and you can tell from her muscle tone, bffr
Bro that intro tho
This kind of videos are so stupid, the comments too. You can't determine if a person is unhealthy or healthy based on assumptions or your beauty standars. If the person is too fat or extremely skinny, for example Wonyoung in some moments, I kinda get the worry. But yall need to stop thinking that every skinny person is unhealthy, thats just not true and it's extremely offensive 💀
And honestly their weight is none of our business, but i'm sick of this kind of trend of criticizing bodies, so I had to give my perspective :/
Lmao the first person shown in the intro is unhealthy too😭
Literally hop they make a mandatory rule where all kpop idols nd trainees must be in the gym working out and eating healthy that fits their bmi. Cause honestly their work schedule plus training and dieting is horrendous to the body
They are all beautiful.
You can look healthy but actually be the most unhealthy we shouldn't just assume whos healthy or not
Wait...
Tzuyu's edit in starting ❤❤
Just bcuz ppl are a tiny bit skinny doesn't mean they r unhealthy
The worst part is people call the healthy bodies fat 😒
Very healthy body- "Twice"
I agree that the idols shown as unhealthy were a bit on the thin side. Unfortunately, they work in an industry where they need to be super thin. It's hard to live a healthy lifestyle as an idol. I look chubby even when I am thin because my bone structure is not petite and having big boobs doesn't make me look thin either. The "unhealthy" girls probably have a more petite frame therefore look too thin but are probably healthy.
ppl: skinny is unhealthy
also ppl: I am not fat i am plus size
Love the beginning❤😊
Being skinny doesn't mean unhealthy, same as being not this skinny, doesn't mean healthy. I thought it was obvious but it seams kpop fans need a drawing.
i dont think thats how it works.. im literally at a healthy weight and looks normal but my body is soo unhealthy 😭
This comment section passed the vibe check
Jisoo is perfect! And jeongyeon also got perfect health!
Everyone in new jeans looks healthy
Lol people have other shapes
For example, me. I’m skinny like Wonyoung. I eat a lot. It’s genetic. My dad also skinny
I just LOVED Tzuyu intro
Jisoo❤️❤️
Healthy- Jeongyeon
frfr
But no... She gained weight due to health problems
So... Why do yall think Im a Jeongyeon hater? i do NOT consider her body "ugly", I really love her as an artist in twice. I was happy to see her at a new concert after such a long time. But there are facts - she experienced a severe form of a hernia + struggled with mental problems, because of which she had to take antidepressants (I dont know exactly what medications she took). These problems are what caused her weight gain, and those reasons are unhealthy, as much as you all would like to believe that she gained weight of her own accord.
@@vnrs yeah but she's at a healthy weight for her height
Fr i was waiting for her
@@chuuips yes she is neither fat nor Slim it's the perfect body
Jisoo's abs:
🙇♀️
👇
Edit: OMG I FEEL LIKE CINDERELLA NAENGA PYGONA 😼✨
*Translate to English*
😃😃
having abs doesnt mean you're healthy? what sort of logic is that?
🖐️
@@lunalovegood3650 They didn't say that.. tho? They were just mesmerized by Jisoo's abs.
*NOT INTENDED TO BE RUDE AT ALL* Just a bit of clarification.
@@dantheaqua6596 okay, maybe i interpreted it incorrectly. However, i do believe my point still stands.
Not me falling in love with the intro 😂
do you know the name of the song?
@@lilacforyouleft and right
Are you sure? I searched but there no sound like that
@@Bubblesss07 click on the sound and on the top next to the sound there is a song called left & right
Same here😂❤
GURL THE TZUYU EDIT GOT ME FALLING.
Just a reminder, just because someone leans toward the more skinnier side, it doesn't always mean that they have a unhealthy body
Literally take a look eugenia cooney.
What about Wonyoung we all know she’s severely underweight..
@@hoshinohh girly has been always skinny. And she has gained some weight for their new comeback. Some of these picture were also edited to make her more skinny
They literally have their bones showing with the heavy beauty standards in kpop they are to 100% underweight
@@strawberri_rush I said it doesn't ALWAYS mean. There are a lot of idols who eat fine, but they are still really skinny. I'm not saying that applies to everyone. Yes some idols are malnourished and underweight
Like Ariana said: Your healthy/unhealthy isn't the person's healthy/unhealthy!
Culture vulture Ariana is the last person you should take any advice from.
my version of healthy is being underweight and sick. i have issues with my image so my family help me with their standards , in some ways it’s helpful.
@@kaayleelynnn wtf?
Okay but being 173 and weighing 45 pounds is never healthy doesnt matter what you gaslight yoursekf
@@kaayleelynnnwhat are you even talking about?
Can people wake up and learn that some people are born extremely skinny. I love food, yet you can see 99% of my bones on my stomach, like it looks bad, but I'm not unhealthy.
Samee
U can’t just claim that skinnier bodies are less healthy, while “thicker” ones are healthy. Both can be healthy and unhealthy, so pls stop categorizing. It just creates unnecessary shaming and eating disorders.
Edit: The point of my comment flew over most of yall's heads💀. I never claimed that most idols don't have eating disorders....my point is that you can't judge health solely by appearance. Some ppl have rly fast metabolisms (finds it extremely difficult to gain weight) such as Lisa, but they get skinny shamed all the time, while others such as Jeongyeon (Twice) have health problems that make them fuller, but it doesn't make them healthy either.
Who tf said Karina's body is "thick"? Is not about that, is about the fact that beauty standards are almost killing young girls out there and people like you be like "sToP dOiNg ThAt THeY ArE HeAlThY 😭😭😭you're a hateeeer" grew up and stop normalizing people being almost anorexic
That’s not true. If you see bones that means there’s not enough fat which women need more than men to have their periods and have regular hormone levels
@@michaelscottspapercompany6373 that’s not necessarily true, there’s a lot of people that are super skinny and you can see their bones some but they have an extremely hard time gaining weight
So Obesse people could be healthy💀
@@londonbuehler8712 yes but thats not the case for some of these idols, i cant speak for the other idols but wonyoung did not look THIS thin in iz*one nor was she unbelievably thin when she was a child so we can safely assume she's either unhealthy or just barely healthy
The intro was better than the actual video lol
Lol 😂😂😂
righttt
😂 right
Who’s in the intro, can you please tell me?
@@chicitgirl222 She's Tzuyu member of twice a girl group
“Skinny shaming isn’t a thing”
Meanwhile mfs:
healthy ones are the skinny little kiddo. others are unhealthy skeletons. there is nothing wrong with obese shaming too 😂 if you re influencing people with your unhealhty ss you deserve the drag
its not skinny shaming
@@Vballl4lifee445 they literally look at any skinny idol and say they’re unhealthy. That’s skinny shaming.
@@kamshiro then what is it?
@@Am_._they’re not just “skinny”, they’re borderline underweight. nobody is shaming them, it’s just alarming how slim these idols are in comparison to their height.
Okay but tzuyu's edit at the beginning - 😩🤌🏻
bro u seen wendy recently? womans got abs...fine abs too
yes srsly wendyy 🔥
FRR
EXACTLY and she looks so gooodddd
Wendy is super healthy now, perfect abs
Abs don’t mean that you’re healthy
that tzuyu edit at the start 🔥
Jisoo❤❤
my body looks like Jisoo’s and we’re even the same height and yet I have an eating disorder so you can’t really tell whether someone’s body is healthy just by looking at them
You tell ‘em! They have no idea how wrong they are for this! And also I hope you’re able to slowly recover at some point 💚
How do u know she doesn't have one too?
@@funniestcomment7305 that’s their point. The video is saying jisoo has a healthy body based off of her appearance. But this commenter is saying they look like Jisoo and they have an eating disorder and therefore aren’t healthy. They’re saying that you can’t say someone (like jisoo in this example) is healthy just based off of their appearance. So jisoo may have one too or she may not, but you can’t just claim she’s healthy by the fact that she’s slim and has defined muscle. There’s a lot more to it than that
@@stellarae8257 thank you for being so kind 💗💗💗
@@user-3259 ofc! Remember to Be kind to yourself too! 💗💗💗
It's hard to stay healthy in that industry especially when you have to stay skinny , So much so that it's really common for Kpop idols to faint from so much pressure Edit: This is not ok , Don't body shame them because it's something most can't control ( This is not a message directed to the creator of the channel but to others) And I think that this all needs to stop the Company's need to treat them like human beings
I think they have all very healty bidyy
@@purplered7004 stop being stupid. None of these ppl are healthy.
please do not judge someone’s health just looking at their body. even doctors tests blood and do lots of checks to know your health. if you want to be healthy go to doctor and don’t stress too much🥰
I naturally have a body like wonyoung, that doesn't mean that I'm unhealthy.
@b No it doesn't? I just have a fast metabolism. I eat the most in my whole family and yet stay skinny. I have gone to many doctors and they all say that I'm healthy
@@mr00p37It also depends on height. Also, bmi scales are outdated and really only works for men. It doesn’t take account of factors such as breast size which could add extra weight
@@Hia.97 SAME! I have fast metabolism, and it's from my genes, I have Yuna's body but a little bit thicker, and everyone says I look a little unhealthy, I turned 14 last month, and I'm still growing up, that's what makes it upsetting, And I'm going through puberty, They know I'm not unhealthy, and they also know I have fast metabolism, and its from my genes, that what makes it even more upsetting.
Ya but you aren’t under a microscope for millions to see.
@@neb.9489the breast is almost entirely fat it's just some women who have more tissue so for a normal person the BMI scale is fine
Karina is literally our body goals ❤
Fr
Ikr
Fr
Karina is just wow. GOAL
Fr
can we just stop talking about idols weight? gosh this is why there is such a big focus on weight in the kpop industry because if people like this