The Visual Storytelling of Pentiment | Cannot be Tamed
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 фев 2025
- I recently played Pentiment, the newest game by Obsidian. It tells the tale of Andreas Maler, a journeyman artist in 16th century Bavaria, who gets caught up in a murder mystery. I thought the game was great but what really stood out was how amazing its visuals contributed to the storytelling. So I wanted to talk about it.
#pentiment #obsidian #gamepass
Video footage is all my own, recorded on an Xbox Series X. All music is from the game. Thanks to Dylan for reviewing and adding to the script.
Want to see me on other social media?
Twitter - / jasyla_
Instagram - / cannot_be_tamed
Patreon - / pamd
My makeup channel (Cosmetic DLC) - / @cosmeticdlc
Intro artwork, logo and banner by: @theMagdalenRose
"Cantina Blues" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0
creativecommons....
![NOOB TO PRO GYM STARS [FULL SERIES] ROBLOX](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HW6g9pD8VU8/mqdefault.jpg)
I can honestly say this is the best game I have worked on.
Even after over 2 years of working on this project, I still get all teared up when we get to the final mural.
Thank you for this review.
Good work! This game is fabulous!
thank you so much for making this game, the most illuminating game of my life, i just wish more popular
It is one of the best games I've ever played. Thank you!
Wow! I didn't see all of these replies. Thank you so much, guys. Past the first anniversary of the game and I can't believe its been over a year now. I hope you guys give your love to the rest of the team especially the great women who lead both the narrative as well as the art and sound team, not going to name the fine people here but credits are public! Haha. Incredibly proud to have been a part of it and let's hope we get to do a project like this again in the future!
@@sunderarkI just finished the game and I want to thank you and everyone else who has worked on the project at Obsidian. This game is going to stay with me for a long, long time.
4:02 It's a really cool detail how Sebhat is drawn in a different style (more closely resembling the Ethiopian tradition of illumination) to convey how foreign he looks. Also, I'm glad the art team took a bit of liberty when designing the child characters and cutefied them a bit - those children from late medieval / early modern art looked TERRIFYING
I just rolled credits on this and it is best game of 2022. Amazing work of history and storytelling.
All i can say is im totally inmersed in this game. Its starts somewhat slow but as the story unfolds is a joyride
I really hope so. I'm about 2 hours in and found it to be slow. I like the art style though.
Love that you covered this. Just finished it today and I’m very emotional about how it all wrapped up
Great video, and a good game. Did anyone else feel they were completely immersed in the Tassing community by the end of the game? I felt like I was at home and belonged in that community, by the time the Winter festival arrived.
It's a shame that this game isn't that recognized in Mainstream.. People (self proclaimed critics) saying God of War Ragnarok a masterpiece when it's just another game that does same thing 100 other similar game does when this game doea something very unique in 2022.. And I blame such thing alot on reviews cause I seen many reviews that say the same "not for everyone" BS.. Your review is something that actually tells where the game excels, what to expect while still keeping lot of things for us to explore on our own while playing.. Good work..
Yeah the broadness of an audience shouldn't dictate the quality of the work. Pentiment isn't a game I constantly replay like some of my top games of all time, but I still rank it up there, because it achieves exactly what it sets out to do and it does it masturfully.
I just happened to have picked this game up recently. It's a very unique game with a lot of depth to it. I've been drawn in to all the little details of every scene as it seems like everything is there on screen with a purpose to tell you something even if it doesn't spell it out for you.
Also kudos for defining pentimento for us at the beginning of the video! It really helps setup the concept behind this game!
I thought it was important, I didn't know what it meant before I played the game.
Well done going full video essay analysis mode on this one Pam
Really enjoyed this as trying to get my best friend to play this as he loved murder mysteries
Thanks for creating & sharing your review of this. I’ve been curious about it, and you helped “illuminate” some aspects of the game that I found helpful. Great work, as usual!
Coming to this video a year late, but so happy to see more content talking about this masterpiece. I grew up really involved in a fundamentalist Christian church, and despite all the absolutely awful parts of that upbringing, I cherish the knowledge I gained about the history of how the Bible, and subsequently, most books were written/copied/printed throughout time. In my adult life, that knowledge hardly has reason to be recalled, but this game brought all those memories back. Pentiment was such a a fun experience, and a wonderful story.
This game needs a physical release. Because a library like us can definitely use it.
This is probably going to end up being my favorite game I played all year, loved seeing your thoughts on it!
Really dug the opening animation in the style of Pentiment.
Thank you, it only took me 2 hours.
When the thread puller is revealed. I was shocked, their hand writing changing to the handwriting of the notes that the murderers received throughout the game as you figure out who it is made my jaw drop honestly
One of the first times in a LONG time I was genuinely shocked by a narrative twist, I didn’t see it coming at all
Me too! What a masterwork
I am playing Pentiment for the second time and I am now digesting all the video essay like content about it on RUclips. Love your video and your style!
Thanks!
Thanks! Been Entertained by your videos for a while now
Awesome, thank you!
Fantastic! Loving this game, and so happy you made a video on it.
Thanks for the time and energy you put into this video. I had little interest in this title but your video is makeing me rethink checking it out.
Glad you liked it, thanks for watching.
I was about to ask you to make a video of this game! This is 1000% he perfect game for a Cannot be tamed review! I was on the fence about this title, I'm definitely getting it now.
Excellent, I hope you like it as much as I did.
Great video as always! Thank you for shining a spotlight on indie titles. I tend to ignore ads and be stupid busy and miss out on a lot of releases.
Always liked the paint chipping off characters as they got closer to death
Great to see this notification. RUclips has been terrible at putting your content on my home page. Time to catch up on some recent uploads!
Yeah, you really have to go to subscription pages to make sure you see videos from people you're subscribed to, unfortunately.
@@Cannotbetamed1 Oh definitely. I just noticed that a lot of the channels I watch most consistently and within 24 hours of a new upload are positioned there on the RUclips app. It seems the algorithm isn't serving me your content the same, so I appreciate the extra notification. Better solution... going to go click the bell icon now!
Playing this phenomenal game now. So unique.
That was interesting. I've heard a lot of good things about this game, but it's been a hard sell without an introduction to its setting and mechanics, since those are hard to make out by reading a simple review. But they certainly fell into place now.
I can't help but drawing parallels to Kingdom Come: Deliverance. Although a very different type of game, it's too built around some of the same mechanics (passing of time, social dynamics, language skills etc), and a few similar themes. Anyhow, it seems like the kind of game for a history buff like me so I'll be checking it out. Thank you so much for making this video.
Thank you for this great video, Pam. I love this video essay format. I hope you play other games that make you want to create more videos like this. I think it will compliment your game reviews nicely. It feels liberating and especially well suited to the indie space where a lot of fresh ideas are tested and deserve to be praised for their merits, even if the game as a whole may come up short against AAA games with high production values in all areas. But to say games like Pentiment are recommendable at their lower price point also sells their achievements short. Kudos for not adding a recommendation or score. I watched several professional reviews of Pentiment in anticipation of your video. Effusive as they are, yours convinced me more I should check out Pentiment.
Indie games are generally much better than AAA games, which all kinda blend together.
@@Cannotbetamed1 TL; DR: Better for you, or better for me, is likely not better for most gamers. That's OK. The majority doesn't need to be corrected. You can encourage even small improvements on the tried and true and tired formula while giving more people what they want.
---
I disagree with your first part but agree with your second part. Indie games are more willing to try something new or focus on elevating one part to art or masterpiece quality. They add a lot of vibrancy to the video game industry. However, sales figures alone prove that the vast majority of gamers still prefer the AAA experience. That's how I define "better." It's better for me if I like it more. If most people like it more, it's objectively better. There is a professional take on games done by people who are educated in the technical aspects of their creation, and I respect their opinion. I respect the creator of Angry Centaur Gaming reviews for that reason. Other times, I put my trust in the majority who came before.
This is why I agree with your second point, that AAA games blend together, but also think it's OK. The formula stays the same because it works. Some people can whine and hate on COD all they want. The games will still be made. I like COD, especially the original Modern Warfare series. But not all AAA games are like that. Some do try to make incremental changes, a timid new step. I am sorry, but I am blanking out on good examples. You probably know better examples of what I am talking about than I do. You can do your part to help encourage change by spotlighting these improvements, without sacrificing your platform by either shunning them entirely or pandering to the least common denominator.
---
The rest goes off on a tangent. I am not even convinced Persona 5 on Xbox is that big of a deal; it's new on Xbox but still a 2016 game. But I've heard it asked of you more than once, and if I wait, I'll probably forget what I want to say when it matters.
Our sharing our views on what is "better" aside, I think it would benefit you more to accommodate the masses. Like playing Persona 5. 😄People love it. I share your fear of the time commitment to that. I had a trying experience with P3 and P4. I don't have to create content though. Just, if you ever play to create content, try to get help when it comes to the persona fusion, or whatever the equivalent mechanic is in P5. That easily consumed more than half of my time in P3 and P4. Also, if you are not used to simulation of Japanese high school life or have had bad experience with that, prepare yourself. Is it going to be more edifying for you or your audience than this video essay? Probably not. But I expect it will entertain more people.
I somehow hadn't heard of this, but your video totally sold me on it. Adding it to my wishlist now.
this looks interesting, i like it when people sneak history into my gaming
This game looks very cool. Seems to be one of those experiences only videogames can provide.
I love this subject. Perspectives on storytelling is fascinating to me, and you hit this out of the park. Wonderful video, Pam. (Also, the changing writing style based on the player character's perception is just subtly brilliant -- it tells you something not only about the NPC but about your character as well.)
Really well done. I had to quit partway through because you’ve convinced me to pick the game back up and I don’t want to spoil things for myself.
Have fun with it!
Phenomenal video, Pam. I will definitely be checking this one out.
Thanks!
Great video! The best one on this game that I have seen.
Thank you!
Nice job. No video on RUclips has covered this material as well as this.
Glad you liked it!
Great video Pam gonna play this as soon as I wrap up God of War!
Thanks for this amazing video Pam!
Hello Pam, sorry I don’t have any service. Hope you’re doing well! Looking forward to this week!
This is a very well done review.
Thank you
Such a great video essay, rare on RUclips these days.
Thanks so much!
I was hoping you would do a video on this game. Now to watch while at work
Whew - somehow missed that this actually released! Just grabbed it, can't wait to play (after I finish Alpha Protocol, how timely!)
Have fun!
10:40 it's like they read The Name of the Rose and made a game of all the things they didn't address in the original movie adaptation.
The developers have explicitly cited name of the rose as an influence on the game, and there are direct references made to it therein
Good to know I'm not the only one who remain to canal those buttons start and select 😅
i will try this game, looks very promising, thank you
Hope you enjoy it!
Great video, as always, Pamelot.
Thanks!
Sharing this to the art appreciative
I kept hearing good things about this game, but WOW it looks like I'll need to play it sooner then later as it could be GotY material !
Great video, Pam! Looks like a very interesting game. I hope it comes to the Switch! :)
Prolly not, xbox owns the creators of the game
@@SharkWithASuit229 Ori did, so it’s not completely out of the question.
I love your reviews ❤️
Thanks!
What a really really great video. Loved it!
Thank you so much!
I got some art history from this one, thanks😎👍🏽
Interesting game and great review Pam, you had enough charisma to keep me engaged through the entire review but I still won't do that one because it's too text heavy and I'll be thinking "skip!" too much 😜
Have a great day and the same to Lilly Dog.
I know i am asking too much but imagine this game with voice and accent of that time.
Looks beautiful, reminds me of Monty python😉
Fascinating! I want to play! The subtle expressions of class has me intrigued…no SWITCH RELEASE??? Sigh. Well, maybe there are some alternatives out there? Anyway, thanks for the review.
As of February 2024, Pentiment is now available on the Nintendo Switch
@@emmarodgers4599 WOO HOO!
I love inventive concepts like these. Having Gods name in red is a feature in the King James bible so it's cool how they focus on the most minor of details.
And interestingly, paintings were often painted over because the artists were so poor they couldn't afford another canvas to paint on.
I'll need to give this game a try if I get the chance.
Thanks for the video.
Please recommend games like pentiment with deep story.
Great video!
Thanks!
Great video! I like this critical analysis.
Thanks!
Great video, I hope more find this great game soon.
Great game, I've completed it just about when it was released to the xgp.
Only thing I didn't like, is that I don't think it's possible to lose in any way, other than accusing a less likely suspect.
I can't believe this didn't get nominated.
Yess
Super interesting!
Awesome one Pam
Thank you!
This looks fantastic. No doubt they drew some kind of inspiration from Eco's The Name of the Rose. (In fact, these developers ought to get the game rights for the novel; they would hit it out the park. I would love to see the labyrinthine abbey library done in a clever game like this.)
It's absolutely inspired by the Name of The Rose. The book you erase at the beginning of the game is literally the beginning of that novel, and you can find a book when you break into the library that literally has the exact maps of the un-named Abbey and the labyrinthian library that you can find in the novel
I love your content!
Ótimo vídeo. É perceptível o quanto gostou do jogo.
I really need a better PC to play this. I really do want to!
Love your content, but I gotta keep it real for a moment here. The best parts are whenever your dog makes an unexpected appearance
It's true.
2:34 drawing horses is hard okay...
Let's disco
This type of game is way over my paygrade and Intelligence. LOL
While I like the idea, I miss Eora :(
Great 🍒
I had to watch it twice 👍. Do not waste your time - *promosm* .
The game looks wonderful! I hope MS get Bethesda to do a Switch port 🫶
where can i found your email