Hadith speaks for itself really, it is clearly Bida. Sahih Bukhari - Book 78, Hadith 140 Narrated Zaid bin Thabit: Allah's Messenger made a small room (with a palm leaf mat). Allah's Messenger came out (of his house) and prayed in it. Some men came and joined him in his prayer. Then again the next night they came for the prayer, but Allah's Messenger delayed and did not come out to them. So they raised their voices and knocked the door with small stones (to draw his attention). He came out to them in a state of anger, saying, "You are still insisting (on your deed, i.e. Tarawih prayer in the mosque) that I thought that this prayer (Tarawih) might become obligatory on you. So you people, offer this prayer at your homes, for the best prayer of a person is the one which he offers at home, except the compulsory (congregational) prayer."
SubhanAllah Dr Zaik Naik is sooooo knowledgable. I am assuming that people didnt actually play the video although the title of the video is deciving and had me confused. After playing the video and listening to him feel so proud of brother Dr Zakir Naik... we need more people like him insha Alllah my children obtain half the knowledge he has i would be so happy
Uncle Johnson Islam is simple , belief in One Great God. Dont listen to fools and stooges. Read the Quran , Allah speaks to u through it and will give you the wisdom of faith. Allah is a loving and forgiving God
To all the people here criticizing Dr. Zakir Naik, I ask you: have you no shame? This is a man who loves Allah(SWT) and his Prophet(S) and proves that by frequently engaging in dawah and public acts of worship. He is someone who has been the cause of MANY being guided to the faith. He has memorized the entire Qur'an and probably all the ahadith as well. What have you done? Who are you to criticize him? Seek refuge in Allah and repent for what you have said. BACKBITING IS HARAM and now you are backbiting about someone who is likely very beloved to our Lord(And Allah(SWT) knows best). If you have nothing nice to say then say nothing at all. Zakir Naik is not going to read these comments so what is the point? Who are you benefiting? Have some respect. Islam is not being mean and judgmental, so set your priorities straight.
pwnslash123 wow! He loves allah and prophet then why does he follow sahih bukhari and factitious things like taraweeh .... wow at that time prophet said he is leaving two big weighty things Quran and AHLEBEYATS then why do u and zakir naik dont follow that. we will follow umair but we cant follow lion of allah(Ali)(also called abu turab) we will follow abu bakr but we cant follow the imam who sacrificed himself and his family for islam...wow u guys r such a true blivers.....thumbs up to u guys and mr.zakir naik.👏👏👏
mohammed jawad sahih bukhari was authentic hadith that what u guys say but u guys dont blive in imams, wow! u guys blive manly created things not things that allah has ordered. respect to u guys n pls dont reply me coz fools always follow a wrong path.
Imagine taking time out of your day and typing hate comments on a Muslim scholar who's only trying to spread Islam and peace in the world by speaking only from Quran and the Hadeeth and rarely ever brings his own opinion. Sad is the state of some so-called 'Muslims'.
❓Question : How many rakaats are there in Taraweeh? 🔷Answer : There are two opinions in this regard The first group deals with the opinions of present-day scholars : ●Zakir Naik - 8 rakaats ●Shiekh Yasir Qadhi - 8 rakaats ●Shiekh Musleh Khan- 8 rakaats ●Shiekh Albaani - 8 rakaats The second group deals with the verdicts of the _Caliphs and the Sahabah_ who learnt from Rasoolallah (saw) directly and actually prayed with him. ●Umar (ra) - 20 rakaats ●Uthmaan (ra)- 20 rakaats ●Ali (ra)-20 rakaats ➡ Both groups claim to be correct, but only *ONE* was endorsed by the Prophet Muhammad (saw) himself - "Follow my way *_and the way of the rightly guided Caliphs!!_* Adhere to it and cling onto it strongly!" -Muhammad (ص) (Saheeh Abu Dawood) #revivethesunnah
To be honest there's no number of rakats since Tarawih is tahajjud you can pray 2 or 100 lol if you WANT to follow how prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) did it he used to pray 8 + 3 for witr as Aisha reported in an authentic hadith & Allah knows best
Abu Dawud also reported from al-’Irbaad ibn Saariyah, may Allaah be pleased with him, that “the Messenger of Allaah (peace be upon him) led us in prayer one day, then he turned to us and exhorted us strongly . . . (he said), ‘Pay attention to my sunnah (way) and the way of the Rightly-guided Khaleefahs after me, adhere to it and hold fast to it.’” (Saheeh Abi Dawud, Kitaab al-Sunnah).
The title of this video is misleading All of time he is saying that travih is sunnah of Muhammad PBUH and it is NOT bidaaah. Watch full video with open ears
taraweeh is not a bidaah bcoz it was done by prophet(saw) the things which were never done by the prophet are known as bidaah the inventions made by today's muslims r all bidaah for eg.eid-e-milad, taaziyat or 40wala after someone dies r all included in bidaah its not a part of islam
Lol... Be it Eid E milaad,taaziyat or something else is additions not innovations moron.Bidah is when u change something and replace it with something totally different.think before u type.
“Verily, my companions are like stars, whichever of them you use as a guide, you will be rightly guided.” prophet Muhammad peace be upon gave permission to follow his companions(sahaba) so on the base of this hadith you can follow the sunnah of hazrat Umar.
By claiming that they abounded sunna and umar revived dont you insulting Abu bakr and all sahabas? Dont you blame them to abandoning sunnah of muhammad saaw. Just after his death immediately. Is this not insulting
where is the fear of Allah when Muslims posts their comments on religious matters? I see no difference between secular people's comments & that of the so called Muslims'comments!
It is in this context, it is prescribed to blow the nose and clean it with water to dissipate the effect of the Evil one attached to every human. In regards to the Unseen, we totally rely on the message of the Prophets, who include a long line of all the Biblical Prophets including Abraham, Moses and Jesus and then the last and final Prophet - the Blessed Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon them all).
"Uthman ibn Affan had fled with two others to a great distance, and returned on the third day. The Prophet (P) remarked to 'Uthman that the distance he had fled was great'? (6) (6) At-Tabarl: Vol. 3, p. 21,Tarikh Al-Kamil, Vol. 3, p. 60.
3:48 it was a biddah linguistically , what Umar rz did was the following of the Prophet that he lead the sahaba in Taraweeh prayers...... Critics always perish listen first completely and the typeeee....
Sahih Bukari Volume 7, Book 70, Number 573: Narrated Ibn 'Abbas: When Allah's Apostle was on his death-bed and in the house there were some people among whom was 'Umar bin Al-Khattab, the Prophet said, "Come, let me write for you a statement after which you will not go astray." 'Umar said, "The Prophet is seriously ill and you have the Qur'an; so the Book of Allah is enough for us." The people present in the house differed and quarrelled. Some said "Go near so that the Prophet may write for you a statement after which you will not go astray," while the others said as Umar said. When they caused a hue and cry before the Prophet, Allah's Apostle said, "Go away!" Narrated 'Ubaidullah: Ibn 'Abbas used to say, "It was very unfortunate that Allah's Apostle was prevented from writing that statement for them because of their disagreement and noise."
I never took Dr. Zakir to be a liar or ignorant. The same verse he mentions in Vol.3 2010 in Bukhari includes how Umar said that it was an innovation not just an innovation but a great one too! Go read your books, you can't trust anyone anymore.
Your spiritual journey goes hand in hand with physical cleanliness. Islam always prescribes that you stay in a state of purity. For every prayer five times a day, perform ablution and cleanse yourself. Refresh your soul. Experience the calm and serenity which follows it. If you had a wet dream or an intercourse with your spouse, take a shower and wear clean clothes. The Prophet said that if it was not hard for his nation, he would have prescribed for them brushing of teeth before every prayer.
As the Prophet had said - "May God bless the man who gets up during the night to pray and wakes up his wife and who, if she refuses to get up, sprinkles water on her face. And may God bless the woman who gets up during the night to pray and wakes up her husband and who, if he refuses sprinkles water on his face."He said - If a man wakes his wife and prays during the night or they pray two rak'at together, they will be recorded among those (men and women) who (constantly) make remembrance of God.
Abu Bakr says that the people began to return to the Prophet (P), that he was the first to come back to him, and that after him came Abu 'Ubaida ibn AI.Jarra (5) (5) Al-Hakim: "AI-Mustadrak", Vol. 3, pp. 26, 27.,Tarikh.al-Khamis, Vol. I, p. 485.
In this message Dr. Naik is not saying that Tarahwee is called bidah by Hazrat Umer R.A, what he is saying is that Hazrat Umer revived the Sunnah of the Prophet. please refrain from spreading misunderstanding. May ASWT have mercy on all of us. Ameen
My brother Zakir you telling me 3 years after our prophet everyone forgot his sunnat? People can you check when the prophet went to Allah swt and when the man that he is talking about came in charge? Only 3 years space not even that. Make dua for all of the Muslims inshallah
Siraj Mohamad Momin Allaah revealed in the Qur'an what means "There is nothing like Allaah in any way whatsoever." The Prophet, peace be upon him, said what means, "Allaah existed eternally and nothing else existed", and our Master ^Aliyy, the Companion and cousin of the Prophet said what means, "Allaah existed and there was no place, [and after place was created], Allaah now still exists without a place." Allaah exists without a place. Saying can you check when the Prophet went to the place that Allaah was in, is kufr. The one who said that needs to become a Muslim by saying the Shahaadah while believing in it.
Sherief Elsayad You say say Sahih Al Bukhari is the most authentic book after the Quran. That is quite a bold statement you make. Do you honestly believe it is???
He didn't said that people forgot. He said Muhammad S.A.W didn't came for the prayer on the fourth night so that it doesn't becomes obligatory for them. Umar R.A remembered. When he saw people praying separately, he once again asked them to become a group and lead the prayer. So it didn't became a Farz but it was a sunnah which Umar R.A revived. He said people stopped praying Taraweeh in Usman's R.A time. Open your ears and mind so you understand correctly.
If you are talking about religious books, then yes, Sahih Bukhari is the most authentic book after Quran. But don't ever try to compare them. Quran is the official word of Allah. Sahih Bukhari is the contribution of a Muslim who collected ahadith from thousands of Muslims and only written those whose chain of narration could not be doubted even 1%. Like if he heard the hadith from one person, and that person heard from this person, and she heard from that man, and he heard from this sahabi, and he heard from that sahabia, if anyone of them had bad memory, or were found to be less truthful in their matters, or any of that, Imam Bukhari would not write that hadith in his Book. His book's name is Sahih Bukhari. Imam Bukhari memorised about 3 lac hadiths. He wrote only about 7275 of them and excluding those which are repeated, the number is 2230. So he wrote 2230 unique ahadith and didn't wrote any which he could even doubt the slightest from the chain of narrators. This is why Sahih Bukhari is considered the most authentic hadith book by all scholars and the most authentic book after Quran because of the scientific method used by Imam Bukhari to keep it free from doubts by keeping it free from doubtful ahadith, even if the doubt was 1% or 10%.
Marriage is bliss. It is an act of virtue. We as Muslims celebrate this gift of God. It is not a taboo in Islam, like in Christian and Hindu traditions which see marriage as something lowly. A man and a woman come together to build a family and be companions for life. Marriage is not all about sex. It is an intellectual partnership too.
NO miss understanding, NO MISS CONCEPTION, PROPHET OF ISLAM MUHAMMAD SAAW, NEVER LEAD A TARAWIH PRAYER IN HIS LIFE, POINT IS NOT TARAWIH ITSELF POINT IS PRAYING TARAHIH al together,with jamaa, is bidah,
It is all about the attitude that you possess - whether you have made God the only Master of your life or have taken your desires as your god. It trickles down to one thing - the love that you have for God so that you lose your identity completely.
This is exactly opposite of what the Divine Law demands from us. Criminal minds of every nation want to dissociate man with God and as they say “The Law is nailed to the Cross”.
I would disagree, if the prophet (saw) stopped the congregation on the 4th night then it means it was stop not that it was a sunnah and hazrat umar (ra) revived the sunnah of prophet (pbuh) then prophet (saw) would have clearly said to pray it in congregation he said i fear it should not be made compulsory for Muslims. Please answer
Brother it's because he was afraid that it will become compulsory but After the death of Muhammad(S.A.W) things can't be compulsory because the addition of message of Allah ends after the death of Muhammad(S.A.W)
After the Prophet’s death, she turned out to be an excellent teacher and a source of knowledge for this nation. The scholars of Islam are agreed that a girl’s marriage cannot be consummated unless she crosses the age of puberty although the marriage contract can be written earlier.
Liar. When people came praying behind the Prophet, he then prayed at home. This is called Salat Al-Layl. Even Umar exclamed " what a wonderful innovation " when he saw people gathering for taraweeh.
his explanation of biddah contradicts his own statements. The concept of biddah is that there must be no biddah in 'usool(principles)' of religion and every biddah in it is bad. However, in 'aamal(acts)' there are both good and bad biddah. Good biddah are such as compilation of Quran, translation and using symbols in Quran, building areas of wuzu in mosques, reciting Quran on special days specifically, creating new trusts and societies for dawah and public welfare, meelad un Nabi saw, reciting Fatiha over food for Barakah and much more. Zakir Naik lacks proper understanding of Islamic Jurisprudence
Dear Sir Johnson,pl donot be confused with differences.Basic tenets of Islam are same in every sect ,so follow the basics only and whenever you need suggestion/clarification on a particular querry ,go to your sect aalim.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم if umar r.a has done tharaweeh 20 raka'ath is proved ...then no need to think for a 2nd time bcoz rasool s.a has told:umar is truth,what ever talk that comes from the mouth of umar, its definitely true...dont doubt it..and one more thing prophets told about umar was..if there will be a prophet after me it would be umar. ..we don't only want that the proof rasool s.a has done for anything..bcoz iam telling this..if umar is doing something (or khulafaau rashideen) it is the true path of prophet s.a ..kk...
Prophet started QIYAM E LAL....YOU SAID BUT OMAR STARTED TARAVEEH....WHO HAD GIVEN OMAR THIS RIGHT was OMAR is Nabi....who GAVE RIGHT to OMAR add ANY THING IN ISLAM....WRONG EXPLANATION...
On a side note, you are not cracking a joke but you are sealing your Fate(unless you repent). It is not God who oppresses by putting the disbeliever in Hell but it is the faithless man himself who earns the Fire of Hell by his disbelief and misdeeds.
Water is the best purifying agent. It refreshes the mind and the body and elevates the soul. Just as water is essential for our physical being, so too in the Divine Law, it plays an important role in the spiritual well being of a person. Just try not to take a shower for a week and see the effect on your inner being. If your heart is still alive, you would feel it. This is all experiential knowledge. The Blessed Prophet has said - “Cleanliness is half the faith”.
While in Mecca, he was heavily persecuted and at the time of the marriage, his tribe was under Abu Lahab, his avowed enemy - so there was no protection from the tribe too. Aaisha’s parents were more than happy with her marriage. In Medina, while he was the ruler there, he did not marry any other virgin lady. If he was so corrupt (may God forbid), we would have narrations of him marrying many more young girls.
It is from the teachings of the Prophets that every man has an evil entity attached to him which provokes him to commit foul acts. A man is prone to two way attack - one from his base desire or the evil inclination of his soul and the other from the Satan who is attached with every man. This Satan is not to be confused with Lucifer/Iblees; of course Lucifer is the head of them all.
It appears that after some time, he and his companions sat down to take rest. From At-Tabari we learn that 'Umar and Talha together ,with some of the Muhiijirin and Ansar, ran away from the field and were sitting on a rock, when someone called out that Muhammad had been killed. Anas ibn Al-Nadr went up to these persons and asked them why they were sitting there. The men on the rock replied that Muhammad (P) had been killed, and expressed their wish that there had been somone who would go to 'Abdallah ibn 'Ubbai, a Munafiq at Medina, and request him to intercede with Abu Sufyan and get an amnesty for them (4) (4) At-Tabarl: Vol. 3, p. 20; p. 19.
You live in accordance with the Will of God and the Law that He has revealed. All these trivial actions like - using your right hand for certain things and left hand for mundane things shows to demonstrate, that you are willing to sacrifice your personal will for the Pleasure of God. In your life, not a single action would be taken unless you make a choice if it pleases God or not. Basically, your entire life is dictated by God.
So Umar called the Sunnah a bid^ah, though he knows that all bid^ah is bad? Instead of saying, this is a nice revival of the sunnah, he called the sunnah a bid^ah? That's pretty ridiculous!
More so, it is for the Prophets of God. Criticism based on unbiased facts is always appreciated and it must be employed to seek the truth. Whereas cursing the greatest benefactors of humanity with a foul language reveals the true color and character of the person who is swearing. We feel the same pain and grief if anyone swears at the Prophets of God, whether he be Moses, Jesus or Muhammad (may God‘s peace and blessings be upon them all)
Also quote that hadith when Hazrat Umer(ra) started it, Abu Bakr(ra) said to him dont u think its biddah? Hazrat Umer replied so what its a good thing to do. Coz he knew that hadith when Prophet(pbuh) said if u start a new thing in islam nd its good then u will get reward for it. Thatswht its called biddat ul hasna
Where's the source to "good bidah"?? Umar wasn't talking about bidah in religion but literal definition of this Arabic word so basically it's a new thing for them thus nothing to do with bidah of the deen & Allah knows best
Narrated 'Urwa: That he was informed by `Aisha, "Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) went out in the middle of the night and prayed in the mosque and some men prayed behind him. In the morning, the people spoke about it and then a large number of them gathered and prayed behind him (on the second night). In the next morning the people again talked about it and on the third night the mosque was full with a large number of people. Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) came out and the people prayed behind him. On the fourth night the Mosque was overwhelmed with people and could not accommodate them, but the Prophet (ﷺ) came out (only) for the morning prayer. When the morning prayer was finished he recited Tashah-hud and (addressing the people) said, "Amma ba'du, your presence was not hidden from me but I was afraid lest the night prayer (Qiyam) should be enjoined on you and you might not be able to carry it on." So, Allah's Apostle died and the situation remained like that (i.e. people prayed individually). " Sahih al-Bukhari 2012 who has misconception ? In PROPHET SAAW life span 1 time 3 nights people (sahaba r.a) did stand behind him, and 4 day prophet of Allah did not come to mosque and did not let them to continue.
Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) stopped praying Tarawih publicly in fear of allah making it obligatory & after his death then all umar did was revive the sunnah for the people (he meant when he said what an excellent bidah that is as the literal meaning of that Arabic word as new thing for them to do nothing to do with innovation in religion) alhamdulillah you can do it at home or in masjid as jamaat it's not complusory salat as it's just tahajjud but in Ramadan & Allah knows best
Ali (as) when he was elected as a khalif,he prevented people praying tarawih as jamaa, he dis not lead in the mosque and he stopped being practicing this innovation(bidaah)
@@recepeksi where's the source to this?? If this is true then it's strange Ali abandoned this sunnah You don't get it...this is not bidah rather it's revived sunnah prophet Muhammad did what umar meant was the LITERAL definition of bidah since prophet Muhammad didn't do this publicly anymore Umar just revived this sunnah so it's new to them as nobody else done this since prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) passed away thus this is nothing to do with bidah in religion Allah knows best & I ain't bothered debating this lol nor have long conversation on this
@@maganhassan2627 first, do not contradict with truth,do not call it sunna, it is sunna of umar bin Khattab. As dr zakir claims,umar started this not Muhammad saaw or abu bakr. Abu bakr is the first khalif and after him umar started praying tarawif with jamaa. Do not ignore that point we are not talking about the tarawih itself, we are talking praying tarawih prayer with jamaa( congregational prayer) When you claim it is sunna, you need to bring an evidence of being sunna. Surely I did not follow any innovation, he followed purely sunna of muhammad saaw.
To conclude, the Blessed Muhammad was the utmost paragon of chastity and purity. Millions and millions of men and women live lives of sexual abstinence based on his guidance and teachings. Muslim men and women are always encouraged to lower their gaze and guard their chastity. In Muslim societies, women are modestly clad. They do not wear revealing clothes and do not indulge in nudity just to follow the commandments of God. Contrast this with the West and how the women are marketed there
Is it Sunnah to read 20 rakat or 8 rakat taraweeh in congregation the whole month? And do you know that Umar himself did not read that. Go read the commentary of that hadith of Bukhari in Fath ul Bari Sharh Sahi Bukhari.
Nauzubillah mr zakir is correcting Umer raz regarding meaning of BIDDAH.he quotes a hadees from Muslim that innovation in religion is wrong but he forget to quote from the same Muslim sharif Hadees no 6800 in book of knowledge which say good innovation in islam is allowed though for that one be rewarded.
he is lying, the Prophet did not start it, the people saw Prophet Praying and joined him in the mosque, no where in the hadith it can be proven that congregational prayers were offered by the Prophet, also Prophet did not invite the people to such prayers, that is why the prophet did not joing them on day 3
Mohammad Khorramshahgol how about salat of eid? how about other voluntary prayers like salat hajaat done in congregation. all of those are proven sunnah in hadith tht its done in congregation. theres no harm to do some sunnat prayer in congregation
Zul Dysesion these prayers were done in congregation by the prophet himself, whereas taraweeh is a bidah from umar never done in the time of the prophet
The Blessed Muhammad had a perfect marriage with all his wives. He did not cheat anyone or coerce anyone. He married our mother Aaisha when she was six. This marriage was consummated when she was nine. When she was six years old, the marriage contract was written up and she stayed with her parents until she became an adult. If, may God forbid, he had been a child molester, he would not have waited for her to turn nine. He proposed for his marriage to her parents in Mecca.
He is such a lier. He didn’t mention why the Prophet (pbuh) didn’t come out the fourth night. Coz he (pbuh) didn’t like people following it and forbid it Secondly he himself belongs to a sect which performs MISYAAR a temporary marriage. But he didn’t mention about it too.
Asalaam alaikum all... is praying 5 hours a day better than 6? is doing shine 5 hours a day better than 6? is 1 hour during of night of power better than the whole night? I'm no sheikh far from it but any form of ibbadah is better than non. Our Nabi saww may Allah be pleased with him corrected the ummah of that time and as time goes by things do change but god is all powerful and has corrected man in this seen as time has gone by. So please do not argue amongst yourselves and do good. May Allah guide is to be better Muslim's.
Doing biddah is worse than doing no ibadah. I am not saying Taraweeh is biddah. Because Nabi S.A.W said that as long as we follow him or his companions, we would be okay. So following his companions is okay.
You do not have to worry about soiling your clothes with urine while you were an infant. As an infant, you were pure and blameless, without any sin (not even the Original Sin). But now as an adult, you are responsible for your actions. It is the same attitude again. God has no say in my life. I want to do whatever my filthy soul desires. I want to be as dirty as I can.
Zakir Naik is also talking the same. First watch video. Don't just comment after reading the title. You know how these youtubers make us click their videos. There is no good biddah and he never said that.
Say for example some women in USA do not wear abaya, and suddenly after hidaya they start wearing so shall we say what an excellent bida'h? Sorry Mr zakir Naik you failed to support this argument because truth shall triumph! Tarawi is bida'h and it's for sure. Prophet Muhammad s.a.w never started tarawi, its even their in that hadith and he scolded those people and said tahajjud should be prayed at home not in congregation. Mr Naik you also supported hadith which is in favour of tarawi which is saying that prophet Muhammad s.a.w used to pray tarawi, so that hadith and this hadith contradict with each other. Both are going in opposite direction. This means that bukhari itself isn't 100% sahi. There is only Qur'an which is 100% original and no one can change it but Allah has not taken any guarantee of bukhari or Muslim. Do you know that bukhari was compiled after 300 years of demise of prophet Muhammad s.a.w? Do you know how much is 300 years? When someone speak something or record something it changes after just one day, so how is it possible to collect 100% sahih details of hadith? Can't there be any fabrication? But no one use their mind as they have been taught to not to ask questions, but Allah says ask questions and try to find out the truth. We should try to go for truth, but not be blindfolded to believe anything except Qur'an.
These trivial actions are just little tests for you whether you are willing to subdue your desire to demonstrate your Love for God or you have made your desire a deity that you worship day and night. All this comes under the grand Plan of God to extract His faithful and beloved servants from mankind and reward them with His Gracious Bounty.
Imaam Muslim related that the Prophet said what means: “The one who innovates a good innovation in Islaam has its reward and the reward of those who practise it until the Day of Judgment, without lessening the rewards of those who practise it. The one who innovates an innovation of misguidance carries this sin and the sins of those who practise it until the Day of Judgement, without lessening the sins of those who practise it.”
Yahya Rodbari the Hadees doesn't say that "the one who Innovates a good innovation in Islam will have a reward but rather it says one who revive the sunnah will have a reward. "Sunnathu Hasanah" is the term in hadees not "Bidath Hasanah".The hadees is directing to anyone who brings back a Sunnah forgotten by the society,Those will have the reward.
Ashhad Kalam Sorry akhi but you misunderstand the hadith. It's not talking about anyone who "revives a sunnah (of the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم), rather "sunnah" here refers to general practice. We know this because later in the hadith it also talks about "bad sunnah" and no sunnah of our Nabi صلى الله عليه وسلم is a bad sunnah. Therfore the word "sunnah" here is used in the linguistical sense, meaning "practice/act"
Zoro Roronoa This is the exact topic under discussion: Jareer ibn 'Abdullaah al-Bajali (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: "The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: 'Whoever starts a good thing and is followed by others, will have his own reward and a reward equal to that of those who follow him, without it detracting from their reward in any way. Whoever starts a bad thing and is followed by others, will bear the burden of his own sin and a burden equal to that of those who follow him, without it detracting from their burden in any way.'" (Reported by al-Tirmidhi, no. 2675. He said, This is a saheeh hasan hadeeth) There is a story behind this hadeeth, which will explain what "whoever starts a good thing" means. Imaam Muslim reported this story from Jareer ibn 'Abdullaah, who also narrated the hadeeth itself. He said: "Some people from the Bedouin came to the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him), wearing woollen garments. He saw that they were in bad shape and in desperate need, so he urged the people to give them charity. They people were very slow to respond, and it could be seen in his face (that he was upset). Then a man of the Ansaar brought a package of silver, then another came, and another and another, and his face was filled with joy. The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: 'Whoever starts a good thing in Islam, and others do likewise after him, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who followed him, without it detracting in the least from their reward. Whoever starts a bad thing in Islam, and others do likewise after him, there will be written for him a burden of sin like that of those who followed him, without it detracting in the least from their burden.'" (Reported by Muslim, no. 1017) so its clear its all about Starting something good initially to inspire others to do so.Just like the context of hadith.
-Omar ran away from the battlefield in Uhud -Omar killed the Prophet Muhammad’s daughter and usurped her land -Omar refused to let the Prophet write his will, because he knew in it he would select ali for the caliphate so he said the prophet was going insane and that he was hallucinating -Omar buried his daughter and was worshipping idol (even in the prophets time he was a munafik) - Omar, during his caliphate judged unjustly, when his friend and a women called um um jameel (abu lahab’s wife) where publicly fornicating, 4 people say they saw them and beard witness but Omar told one of them not so say that he saw them in the act so the witnesses would get punished not the fornicatiors. - Omar also invented Taraweeh😂 -Omar was responsible for poverty due to unfair spread of money during his caliphate -Omar was responsible for the uprising od Banu Ummayed And yes, I am Shia just being truthful and objective here and I know I will be cursed by sunni’s but I will get their good deeds and they will get my bad deeds( Inshallah if they do).
Here are some things i have to say about this hadith: That taraweh salah was already there at the time of Rasulullah (Salalahu Alayhi wa Ala Alihi wa Sahbihi wa Barak wa Salum), where .he (Salalahu Alayhi wa Sallam) prayed in jamaat at night in the mosque, and then he repeated this, having a greater number of people in jamaat after every day until the fourth where the mosque was more than filled with companions ready for jamaat with Rasulullah (Salalahu Alayhi wa Sallam), but he did not come. He told the people that day after Fajr jamaat salah that the reason he did not come for taraweh is because he was worried that taraweh might become fard and his ummah cannot handle it consistently, i.e. might miss some and cause themselves sin due to missing fard ibadah. Sahih al-Bukhari 2012 In-book reference : Book 31, Hadith 5 USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 3, Book 32, Hadith 229 So here, from the hadith, which is a shorter version of the full hadtih, that taraweh was already in the religion from Rasulullah (Salalahu Alayhi wa Sallam), but then it was left/ not practiced. But then, from the hadith that the video is based on, you see that it is simple revived from a companion (radyallah hu'anhu) who knew about this sunnah. There is nothing newly invented, simply that the sunnah is revived by a companion (radyallah hu'anhu) of Rasulullah (Salalahu Alayhi wa Sallam) who gains all the reward for this and those who take from it. Here is a hadith which talks about the revival of a sunnah/ good act: The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: 'Whoever starts a good thing and is followed by others, will have his own reward and a reward equal to that of those who follow him, without it detracting from their reward in any way. Whoever starts a bad thing and is followed by others, will bear the burden of his own sin and a burden equal to that of those who follow him, without it detracting from their burden in any way.' Here, the mentioning of 'starts a good thing' not a bid'ah, because bid'ah is a bad thing and starts, from the context, shows that it is just the first good deed from a chain of good deeds. And: “Know that whoever revives my practice when it has died out after me will have a reward similar to those who act upon it without detracting from his reward in the slightest, and whoever innovates misguidance displeasing to Allah and His messenger will have a sin similar to those who act upon it without detracting from their sins in the slightest.” Umar (radyallah hu'anhu) simply revived the sunnah and 'started' a good thing, no bid'ah, a goodly accepted deed from a dead act within the sunnah. Also, Umar (radyallah hu'anhu) did not say simply and only say that this is a good bid'ah, rather that is some falsehood which people say out of context. He was told that this is bid'ah, and responed by saing that if this is bid'ah then this is an excellent bid'ah. This clearly shows that there is no bid'ah but sunnah because he clearly said 'if this is bid'ah' implying that this is not, but if it were. Also, he was speaking literally, it was just an expression of speech, saying that this is a good act that is basically new,, since it was dead, but knowing that it is not actually new but was just dead.
If Nabi SAW said stop ,it becomes haram Nabi SAW said dont eat the flesh of donkey so it becomes haram So when some eat the meat of donkey ,it means sunnat is revived
@@danishwar8216 if he said don't do it usually that means haraam but he doesn't do it without implying it's haraam & we do it then it's sunnah that is revived that's what happened to Tarawih
@@maganhassan2627 Bukhari Hadith no.7290 Perform your prayers at your homes, for the best prayer of a person is what is performed at his home except the compulsory congregational prayer
You criticism is just based on cultural background and no objective morality. Muhammad’s time was almost 1500 years back. Even in today’s day and age, there is so much disparity in the age of consent. In China, the age of consent is just 14 whereas in India, it is 18. In your country Cyprus, it is 17. In Germany it is 14. Whereas in Bahrain and Tunisia, it is 21 and 20 - so by their standard, many in your country could be charged.
can someone answer me? is it bid'ah for a muslim or even an ulama to wear western clothing especially which our prophet pbuh did not wear western clothing?
Like the natural laws which are immutable, God’s Design of the World is such that people who have recognized God and lived their lives in accordance with His Will shall earn His Company, Favor and an immense reward for eternity. On the other hand, people who have made their base desire as their lord are damned for Hell. This is the immutable Law of God.
The Blessed Prophet had given his wives the choice to stay with him or seek a separation and not a single one wanted to leave him. That was the love they had for him. Aaisha was the one who underwent a rigorous spiritual training under him. She is the one who reported hundreds of narrations mentioning his personal life. She watched with amazement the extensive worship of Muhammad of his Lord and reported to us how he used to extol and praise God in the dark recesses of night.
This man is the real celebrity of Islam | A True Hero. May Allah accept his effort and May Allah guide us all. Ameen
Hadith speaks for itself really, it is clearly Bida.
Sahih Bukhari - Book 78, Hadith 140
Narrated Zaid bin Thabit:
Allah's Messenger made a small room (with a palm leaf mat). Allah's Messenger came out (of his house) and prayed in it. Some men came and joined him in his prayer. Then again the next night they came for the prayer, but Allah's Messenger delayed and did not come out to them. So they raised their voices and knocked the door with small stones (to draw his attention). He came out to them in a state of anger, saying, "You are still insisting (on your deed, i.e. Tarawih prayer in the mosque) that I thought that this prayer (Tarawih) might become obligatory on you. So you people, offer this prayer at your homes, for the best prayer of a person is the one which he offers at home, except the compulsory (congregational) prayer."
@@gujarchaudhry3 can u give me the source? I mean where did u get this ahadith from
SubhanAllah Dr Zaik Naik is sooooo knowledgable. I am assuming that people didnt actually play the video although the title of the video is deciving and had me confused. After playing the video and listening to him feel so proud of brother Dr Zakir Naik... we need more people like him insha Alllah my children obtain half the knowledge he has i would be so happy
Brothers and sisters, I am a convert Muslim , I could not imagine becoming Muslim after reading these comment. Yooz need to chill.
Uncle Johnson we will keep fighting on these issues rather than follow sunnat bcoz fighting and arguing is easy following properly is tough
Dear brother dnt read all these comments just read quran n hadit n hv faith in u n Allah
Uncle Johnson I know what you mean but not everyone commenting is a muslim nor a scholar but don't forget Sunday is not a must but it's good to do it
Uncle Johnson Islam is simple , belief in One Great God. Dont listen to fools and stooges. Read the Quran , Allah speaks to u through it and will give you the wisdom of faith. Allah is a loving and forgiving God
Uncle johnoson if you want to understand and to become a good muslim..so you Understand Quran and read the life of prophet Muhammad (SAW)
To all the people here criticizing Dr. Zakir Naik, I ask you: have you no shame? This is a man who loves Allah(SWT) and his Prophet(S) and proves that by frequently engaging in dawah and public acts of worship. He is someone who has been the cause of MANY being guided to the faith. He has memorized the entire Qur'an and probably all the ahadith as well. What have you done? Who are you to criticize him? Seek refuge in Allah and repent for what you have said. BACKBITING IS HARAM and now you are backbiting about someone who is likely very beloved to our Lord(And Allah(SWT) knows best). If you have nothing nice to say then say nothing at all. Zakir Naik is not going to read these comments so what is the point? Who are you benefiting? Have some respect. Islam is not being mean and judgmental, so set your priorities straight.
pwnslash123 wow! He loves allah and prophet then why does he follow sahih bukhari and factitious things like taraweeh .... wow at that time prophet said he is leaving two big weighty things Quran and AHLEBEYATS then why do u and zakir naik dont follow that.
we will follow umair but we cant follow lion of allah(Ali)(also called abu turab)
we will follow abu bakr but we cant follow the imam who sacrificed himself and his family for islam...wow u guys r such a true blivers.....thumbs up to u guys and mr.zakir naik.👏👏👏
Muskan Sharma@... Could you tell me where is he wrong?
Ashèr Velázquez respect sahih bukhari it is the book with most authentic hadith.and tarweh was a practise of Prophet ,dont think its something useless
mohammed jawad sahih bukhari was authentic hadith that what u guys say but u guys dont blive in imams, wow! u guys blive manly created things not things that allah has ordered.
respect to u guys n pls dont reply me coz fools always follow a wrong path.
Ashèr Velázquez who says we dont belive in imams.we belive in imam shafi imam abu hanifa imam malik imam hambal
Imagine taking time out of your day and typing hate comments on a Muslim scholar who's only trying to spread Islam and peace in the world by speaking only from Quran and the Hadeeth and rarely ever brings his own opinion. Sad is the state of some so-called 'Muslims'.
True
Very sad.
💔
❓Question : How many rakaats are there in Taraweeh?
🔷Answer : There are two opinions in this regard
The first group deals with the opinions of present-day scholars :
●Zakir Naik - 8 rakaats
●Shiekh Yasir Qadhi - 8 rakaats
●Shiekh Musleh Khan- 8 rakaats
●Shiekh Albaani - 8 rakaats
The second group deals with the verdicts of the _Caliphs and the Sahabah_ who learnt from Rasoolallah (saw) directly and actually prayed with him.
●Umar (ra) - 20 rakaats
●Uthmaan (ra)- 20 rakaats
●Ali (ra)-20 rakaats
➡ Both groups claim to be correct, but only *ONE* was endorsed by the Prophet Muhammad (saw) himself -
"Follow my way *_and the way of the rightly guided Caliphs!!_* Adhere to it and cling onto it strongly!"
-Muhammad (ص)
(Saheeh Abu Dawood)
#revivethesunnah
Zahir Sookoor brilliant analysis Bro
zakir naik may claim to follow sunnah better than the rightly guided Khalifs
Madan Mohan Prince Prince stop this chapter verse nonsense...
is not enough that khulfa e rashdeen did it
Madan Mohan Prince Prince The khulafa rashidun acting upon it is the reference/daleel. That's enough for me and should be enough for you.
Zahir Sookoor spot on m8👍
To be honest there's no number of rakats since Tarawih is tahajjud you can pray 2 or 100 lol if you WANT to follow how prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) did it he used to pray 8 + 3 for witr as Aisha reported in an authentic hadith & Allah knows best
Abu Dawud also reported from al-’Irbaad ibn Saariyah, may Allaah be pleased with him, that “the Messenger of Allaah (peace be upon him) led us in prayer one day, then he turned to us and exhorted us strongly . . . (he said), ‘Pay attention to my sunnah (way) and the way of the Rightly-guided Khaleefahs after me, adhere to it and hold fast to it.’” (Saheeh Abi Dawud, Kitaab al-Sunnah).
Then why did Fatima Zahra get angry with Abu bakrs decision regarding baag e fadak and did not talk to him till she died. Ref : Sahi Bukhari.
Beautifully explained Jazak Allah!
Jazakallah Dr. .Literally Dr.you are gem for the Ummah who understand.I am proud of you as an Indian ,bcz Allah produced you from the land of India❤.
SubhanAllah how clearly Dr Zakir Naik removed this misconception of(Innovation) means at that particular time
Alhamdulillah
JazakAllahu Khaira
The title of this video is misleading All of time he is saying that travih is sunnah of Muhammad PBUH and it is NOT bidaaah. Watch full video with open ears
taraweeh is not a bidaah bcoz it was done by prophet(saw) the things which were never done by the prophet are known as bidaah the inventions made by today's muslims r all bidaah for eg.eid-e-milad, taaziyat or 40wala after someone dies r all included in bidaah its not a part of islam
doing it in congregation is . have u forget umar RA said what a good biddah this is ?
in regards to mawlid it is not a biddah
MIke Zandi it is a biddah Hasanah
Lol... Be it Eid E milaad,taaziyat or something else is additions not innovations moron.Bidah is when u change something and replace it with something totally different.think before u type.
“Verily, my companions are like stars, whichever of them you use as a guide, you will be rightly guided.”
prophet Muhammad peace be upon gave permission to follow his companions(sahaba) so on the base of this hadith you can follow the sunnah of hazrat Umar.
Correct. What a point (y)
What is its reference though? I would not use this hadith if it is a weak narration.
I heard it is fabricated, wallahu 'alm.
By claiming that they abounded sunna and umar revived dont you insulting Abu bakr and all sahabas?
Dont you blame them to abandoning sunnah of muhammad saaw. Just after his death immediately. Is this not insulting
where is the fear of Allah when Muslims posts their comments on religious matters? I see no difference between secular people's comments & that of the so called Muslims'comments!
It is in this context, it is prescribed to blow the nose and clean it with water to dissipate the effect of the Evil one attached to every human. In regards to the Unseen, we totally rely on the message of the Prophets, who include a long line of all the Biblical Prophets including Abraham, Moses and Jesus and then the last and final Prophet - the Blessed Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon them all).
"Uthman ibn Affan had fled with two others to a great distance, and returned on the third day. The Prophet (P) remarked to 'Uthman that the distance he had fled was great'? (6)
(6) At-Tabarl: Vol. 3, p. 21,Tarikh Al-Kamil, Vol. 3, p. 60.
3:48 it was a biddah linguistically , what Umar rz did was the following of the Prophet that he lead the sahaba in Taraweeh prayers...... Critics always perish listen first completely and the typeeee....
Sahih Bukari
Volume 7, Book 70, Number 573:
Narrated Ibn 'Abbas:
When Allah's Apostle was on his death-bed and in the house there were some people among whom was 'Umar bin Al-Khattab, the Prophet said, "Come, let me write for you a statement after which you will not go astray." 'Umar said, "The Prophet is seriously ill and you have the Qur'an; so the Book of Allah is enough for us." The people present in the house differed and quarrelled. Some said "Go near so that the Prophet may write for you a statement after which you will not go astray," while the others said as Umar said. When they caused a hue and cry before the Prophet, Allah's Apostle said, "Go away!" Narrated 'Ubaidullah: Ibn 'Abbas used to say, "It was very unfortunate that Allah's Apostle was prevented from writing that statement for them because of their disagreement and noise."
I never took Dr. Zakir to be a liar or ignorant. The same verse he mentions in Vol.3 2010 in Bukhari includes how Umar said that it was an innovation not just an innovation but a great one too! Go read your books, you can't trust anyone anymore.
Your spiritual journey goes hand in hand with physical cleanliness. Islam always prescribes that you stay in a state of purity. For every prayer five times a day, perform ablution and cleanse yourself. Refresh your soul. Experience the calm and serenity which follows it. If you had a wet dream or an intercourse with your spouse, take a shower and wear clean clothes. The Prophet said that if it was not hard for his nation, he would have prescribed for them brushing of teeth before every prayer.
Iltimos shu sozlari ozbekchaga tarjimasi bolsa kanalga qoyilar
Terrible explaining because where is the evidence in the Hadith or Quran that prophet prayed taraweeh????
Sahih Bukhari 272
As the Prophet had said - "May God bless the man who gets up during the night to pray and wakes up his wife and who, if she refuses to get up, sprinkles water on her face. And may God bless the woman who gets up during the night to pray and wakes up her husband and who, if he refuses sprinkles water on his face."He said - If a man wakes his wife and prays during the night or they pray two rak'at together, they will be recorded among those (men and women) who (constantly) make remembrance of God.
Abu Bakr says that the people began to return to the Prophet (P), that he was the first to come back to him, and that after him came Abu 'Ubaida ibn AI.Jarra (5)
(5) Al-Hakim: "AI-Mustadrak", Vol. 3, pp. 26, 27.,Tarikh.al-Khamis, Vol. I, p. 485.
In this message Dr. Naik is not saying that Tarahwee is called bidah by Hazrat Umer R.A, what he is saying is that Hazrat Umer revived the Sunnah of the Prophet. please refrain from spreading misunderstanding. May ASWT have mercy on all of us. Ameen
My brother Zakir you telling me 3 years after our prophet everyone forgot his sunnat? People can you check when the prophet went to Allah swt and when the man that he is talking about came in charge? Only 3 years space not even that. Make dua for all of the Muslims inshallah
Siraj Mohamad Momin Allaah revealed in the Qur'an what means "There is nothing like Allaah in any way whatsoever." The Prophet, peace be upon him, said what means, "Allaah existed eternally and nothing else existed", and our Master ^Aliyy, the Companion and cousin of the Prophet said what means, "Allaah existed and there was no place, [and after place was created], Allaah now still exists without a place." Allaah exists without a place. Saying can you check when the Prophet went to the place that Allaah was in, is kufr. The one who said that needs to become a Muslim by saying the Shahaadah while believing in it.
Sherief Elsayad
You say say Sahih Al Bukhari is the most authentic book after the Quran. That is quite a bold statement you make. Do you honestly believe it is???
He didn't said that people forgot. He said Muhammad S.A.W didn't came for the prayer on the fourth night so that it doesn't becomes obligatory for them. Umar R.A remembered. When he saw people praying separately, he once again asked them to become a group and lead the prayer. So it didn't became a Farz but it was a sunnah which Umar R.A revived. He said people stopped praying Taraweeh in Usman's R.A time.
Open your ears and mind so you understand correctly.
If you are talking about religious books, then yes, Sahih Bukhari is the most authentic book after Quran. But don't ever try to compare them. Quran is the official word of Allah. Sahih Bukhari is the contribution of a Muslim who collected ahadith from thousands of Muslims and only written those whose chain of narration could not be doubted even 1%. Like if he heard the hadith from one person, and that person heard from this person, and she heard from that man, and he heard from this sahabi, and he heard from that sahabia, if anyone of them had bad memory, or were found to be less truthful in their matters, or any of that, Imam Bukhari would not write that hadith in his Book. His book's name is Sahih Bukhari. Imam Bukhari memorised about 3 lac hadiths. He wrote only about 7275 of them and excluding those which are repeated, the number is 2230. So he wrote 2230 unique ahadith and didn't wrote any which he could even doubt the slightest from the chain of narrators. This is why Sahih Bukhari is considered the most authentic hadith book by all scholars and the most authentic book after Quran because of the scientific method used by Imam Bukhari to keep it free from doubts by keeping it free from doubtful ahadith, even if the doubt was 1% or 10%.
Dear admin of the channel...Kindly change the title of the video.... Its name can mislead people who can't understand english properly.
Marriage is bliss. It is an act of virtue. We as Muslims celebrate this gift of God. It is not a taboo in Islam, like in Christian and Hindu traditions which see marriage as something lowly. A man and a woman come together to build a family and be companions for life. Marriage is not all about sex. It is an intellectual partnership too.
Umar said it was a bidah lol so how are u saying he didn't mean that.
Listen properly wht zakir naik saying
@uzairzara9894 I'm sorry but it's against the Sunnah. No matter if Zakir or if Umar ibn khattab says it.
The very same Umar who said the Prophet was deliriously
Refrence
@@arbazsheikh1864 Sahih al-Bukhari 3053
Read about the calamity of Thursday
@@arbazsheikh1864 Sahih Bukari 3053
Refered to as the Thursday calamity
@@arbazsheikh1864 Search it yourself calamity of Thursday Sahih Bukari
@@arbazsheikh1864 sahih bukhari 3053
NO miss understanding, NO MISS CONCEPTION, PROPHET OF ISLAM MUHAMMAD SAAW, NEVER LEAD A TARAWIH PRAYER IN HIS LIFE, POINT IS NOT TARAWIH ITSELF POINT IS PRAYING TARAHIH al together,with jamaa, is bidah,
Excellent research,may Allah strengthen his mind n bones
who is the reciter at the beginning?
It is all about the attitude that you possess - whether you have made God the only Master of your life or have taken your desires as your god. It trickles down to one thing - the love that you have for God so that you lose your identity completely.
This is exactly opposite of what the Divine Law demands from us. Criminal minds of every nation want to dissociate man with God and as they say “The Law is nailed to the Cross”.
Prophit never did this learned person like should not manipulate Hades's so sad....
I would disagree, if the prophet (saw) stopped the congregation on the 4th night then it means it was stop not that it was a sunnah and hazrat umar (ra) revived the sunnah of prophet (pbuh) then prophet (saw) would have clearly said to pray it in congregation he said i fear it should not be made compulsory for Muslims.
Please answer
Brother it's because he was afraid that it will become compulsory but After the death of Muhammad(S.A.W) things can't be compulsory because the addition of message of Allah ends after the death of Muhammad(S.A.W)
After the Prophet’s death, she turned out to be an excellent teacher and a source of knowledge for this nation. The scholars of Islam are agreed that a girl’s marriage cannot be consummated unless she crosses the age of puberty although the marriage contract can be written earlier.
abbadabbajabba 15 age is adult age in islam nd when hzrat Ayesha married .she is 19 yrs old
Abdul Muqeet , ki hadice bukhari sa saheeh sa ?
Liar. When people came praying behind the Prophet, he then prayed at home. This is called Salat Al-Layl.
Even Umar exclamed " what a wonderful innovation " when he saw people gathering for taraweeh.
Does anyone know the name of the imam that was making dua at the intro of the video?
NO
his explanation of biddah contradicts his own statements. The concept of biddah is that there must be no biddah in 'usool(principles)' of religion and every biddah in it is bad. However, in 'aamal(acts)' there are both good and bad biddah. Good biddah are such as compilation of Quran, translation and using symbols in Quran, building areas of wuzu in mosques, reciting Quran on special days specifically, creating new trusts and societies for dawah and public welfare, meelad un Nabi saw, reciting Fatiha over food for Barakah and much more.
Zakir Naik lacks proper understanding of Islamic Jurisprudence
Dear Sir Johnson,pl donot be confused with differences.Basic tenets of Islam are same in every sect ,so follow the basics only and whenever you need suggestion/clarification on a particular querry ,go to your sect aalim.
Why hazrat umar didnt read himself taraweeh.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
if umar r.a has done tharaweeh 20 raka'ath is proved ...then no need to think for a 2nd time bcoz rasool s.a has told:umar is truth,what ever talk that comes from the mouth of umar, its definitely true...dont doubt it..and one more thing prophets told about umar was..if there will be a prophet after me it would be umar. ..we don't only want that the proof rasool s.a has done for anything..bcoz iam telling this..if umar is doing something (or khulafaau rashideen) it is the true path of prophet s.a ..kk...
shukkoor miyanath hadees you are referring is about abbu bakkar siddeque R. A
shukkoor miyanath fake hadiths liar
You’re getting confused between umar ali Ali (AS), umar was actually a munafik he ust wanted power and money.
Madara Who only wanted peace idiot... Jews... fuckkk u
This hadith is Zaeef/Wrong No one can be a Prophet after Muhammad SAWW....Uqayb was a narrator of this hadith which is not credible
Prophet started QIYAM E LAL....YOU SAID BUT OMAR STARTED TARAVEEH....WHO HAD GIVEN OMAR THIS RIGHT was OMAR is Nabi....who GAVE RIGHT to OMAR add ANY THING IN ISLAM....WRONG EXPLANATION...
On a side note, you are not cracking a joke but you are sealing your Fate(unless you repent). It is not God who oppresses by putting the disbeliever in Hell but it is the faithless man himself who earns the Fire of Hell by his disbelief and misdeeds.
Water is the best purifying agent. It refreshes the mind and the body and elevates the soul. Just as water is essential for our physical being, so too in the Divine Law, it plays an important role in the spiritual well being of a person. Just try not to take a shower for a week and see the effect on your inner being. If your heart is still alive, you would feel it. This is all experiential knowledge. The Blessed Prophet has said - “Cleanliness is half the faith”.
While in Mecca, he was heavily persecuted and at the time of the marriage, his tribe was under Abu Lahab, his avowed enemy - so there was no protection from the tribe too. Aaisha’s parents were more than happy with her marriage. In Medina, while he was the ruler there, he did not marry any other virgin lady. If he was so corrupt (may God forbid), we would have narrations of him marrying many more young girls.
Alhamdulillah very easy to understand
It is from the teachings of the Prophets that every man has an evil entity attached to him which provokes him to commit foul acts. A man is prone to two way attack - one from his base desire or the evil inclination of his soul and the other from the Satan who is attached with every man. This Satan is not to be confused with Lucifer/Iblees; of course Lucifer is the head of them all.
Iltimos shu sozlari ozbekchaga tarjima qilingani bolsa kanalga qoyilar
It appears that after some time, he and his companions sat down to take rest. From At-Tabari we learn that 'Umar and Talha together ,with some of the Muhiijirin and Ansar, ran away from the field and were sitting on a rock, when someone called out that Muhammad had been killed. Anas ibn Al-Nadr went up to these persons and asked them why they were sitting there. The men on the rock replied that Muhammad (P) had been killed, and expressed their wish that there had been somone who would go to 'Abdallah ibn 'Ubbai, a Munafiq at Medina, and request him to intercede with Abu Sufyan and get an amnesty for them (4)
(4) At-Tabarl: Vol. 3, p. 20; p. 19.
if you want to learn somthing about islam its better to listen to Mufti Ismael Menk.
You live in accordance with the Will of God and the Law that He has revealed. All these trivial actions like - using your right hand for certain things and left hand for mundane things shows to demonstrate, that you are willing to sacrifice your personal will for the Pleasure of God. In your life, not a single action would be taken unless you make a choice if it pleases God or not. Basically, your entire life is dictated by God.
So Umar called the Sunnah a bid^ah, though he knows that all bid^ah is bad? Instead of saying, this is a nice revival of the sunnah, he called the sunnah a bid^ah?
That's pretty ridiculous!
Zakir Naik Find out y omar ibn kattab said "Nihmatul hazihil biddah"
More so, it is for the Prophets of God. Criticism based on unbiased facts is always appreciated and it must be employed to seek the truth. Whereas cursing the greatest benefactors of humanity with a foul language reveals the true color and character of the person who is swearing. We feel the same pain and grief if anyone swears at the Prophets of God, whether he be Moses, Jesus or Muhammad (may God‘s peace and blessings be upon them all)
Also quote that hadith when Hazrat Umer(ra) started it, Abu Bakr(ra) said to him dont u think its biddah? Hazrat Umer replied so what its a good thing to do.
Coz he knew that hadith when Prophet(pbuh) said if u start a new thing in islam nd its good then u will get reward for it. Thatswht its called biddat ul hasna
Where's the source to "good bidah"?? Umar wasn't talking about bidah in religion but literal definition of this Arabic word so basically it's a new thing for them thus nothing to do with bidah of the deen & Allah knows best
Taraweeh is a big sunni Umari Bidah
Narrated 'Urwa:
That he was informed by `Aisha, "Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) went out in the middle of the night and prayed in the mosque and some men prayed behind him. In the morning, the people spoke about it and then a large number of them gathered and prayed behind him (on the second night). In the next morning the people again talked about it and on the third night the mosque was full with a large number of people. Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) came out and the people prayed behind him. On the fourth night the Mosque was overwhelmed with people and could not accommodate them, but the Prophet (ﷺ) came out (only) for the morning prayer. When the morning prayer was finished he recited Tashah-hud and (addressing the people) said, "Amma ba'du, your presence was not hidden from me but I was afraid lest the night prayer (Qiyam) should be enjoined on you and you might not be able to carry it on." So, Allah's Apostle died and the situation remained like that (i.e. people prayed individually). " Sahih al-Bukhari 2012
who has misconception ? In PROPHET SAAW life span 1 time 3 nights people (sahaba r.a) did stand behind him, and 4 day prophet of Allah did not come to mosque and did not let them to continue.
Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) stopped praying Tarawih publicly in fear of allah making it obligatory & after his death then all umar did was revive the sunnah for the people (he meant when he said what an excellent bidah that is as the literal meaning of that Arabic word as new thing for them to do nothing to do with innovation in religion) alhamdulillah you can do it at home or in masjid as jamaat it's not complusory salat as it's just tahajjud but in Ramadan & Allah knows best
Ali (as) when he was elected as a khalif,he prevented people praying tarawih as jamaa, he dis not lead in the mosque and he stopped being practicing this innovation(bidaah)
@@recepeksi where's the source to this?? If this is true then it's strange Ali abandoned this sunnah
You don't get it...this is not bidah rather it's revived sunnah prophet Muhammad did what umar meant was the LITERAL definition of bidah since prophet Muhammad didn't do this publicly anymore Umar just revived this sunnah so it's new to them as nobody else done this since prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) passed away thus this is nothing to do with bidah in religion
Allah knows best & I ain't bothered debating this lol nor have long conversation on this
@@maganhassan2627 first, do not contradict with truth,do not call it sunna, it is sunna of umar bin Khattab. As dr zakir claims,umar started this not Muhammad saaw or abu bakr.
Abu bakr is the first khalif and after him umar started praying tarawif with jamaa.
Do not ignore that point we are not talking about the tarawih itself, we are talking praying tarawih prayer with jamaa( congregational prayer)
When you claim it is sunna, you need to bring an evidence of being sunna.
Surely I did not follow any innovation, he followed purely sunna of muhammad saaw.
You need to make a wider research and find out the fatcs,truths not assumptions.
To conclude, the Blessed Muhammad was the utmost paragon of chastity and purity. Millions and millions of men and women live lives of sexual abstinence based on his guidance and teachings. Muslim men and women are always encouraged to lower their gaze and guard their chastity. In Muslim societies, women are modestly clad. They do not wear revealing clothes and do not indulge in nudity just to follow the commandments of God. Contrast this with the West and how the women are marketed there
Is it Sunnah to read 20 rakat or 8 rakat taraweeh in congregation the whole month? And do you know that Umar himself did not read that. Go read the commentary of that hadith of Bukhari in Fath ul Bari Sharh Sahi Bukhari.
Nauzubillah mr zakir is correcting Umer raz regarding meaning of BIDDAH.he quotes a hadees from Muslim that innovation in religion is wrong but he forget to quote from the same Muslim sharif Hadees no 6800 in book of knowledge which say good innovation in islam is allowed though for that one be rewarded.
he is lying, the Prophet did not start it, the people saw Prophet Praying and joined him in the mosque, no where in the hadith it can be proven that congregational prayers were offered by the Prophet,
also Prophet did not invite the people to such prayers, that is why the prophet did not joing them on day 3
if Tarawahi is Sunna of prophet than why Umar says says Its a great innovation ? did second caliph of Omri didn't know it's Sunna of prophet .
He didn't say that. It's a lie. He said something else.
Even if it is something made up by omar. Its still just people getting together i and praying. Whats wrong with that?
That the Prophet himself openly said that the prayers that should be prayed in congregation are the compulsory prayers, not extra prayers.
Mohammad Khorramshahgol how about salat of eid? how about other voluntary prayers like salat hajaat done in congregation. all of those are proven sunnah in hadith tht its done in congregation. theres no harm to do some sunnat prayer in congregation
Zul Dysesion these prayers were done in congregation by the prophet himself, whereas taraweeh is a bidah from umar never done in the time of the prophet
The biggest bedat is making or believing sects in islam.its islam,quran,last prophet's hadit,muslim and nothing.
True. Taraweeh is not in the Quran.
The Blessed Muhammad had a perfect marriage with all his wives. He did not cheat anyone or coerce anyone. He married our mother Aaisha when she was six. This marriage was consummated when she was nine. When she was six years old, the marriage contract was written up and she stayed with her parents until she became an adult. If, may God forbid, he had been a child molester, he would not have waited for her to turn nine. He proposed for his marriage to her parents in Mecca.
He is such a lier. He didn’t mention why the Prophet (pbuh) didn’t come out the fourth night.
Coz he (pbuh) didn’t like people following it and forbid it
Secondly he himself belongs to a sect which performs MISYAAR a temporary marriage. But he didn’t mention about it too.
Asalaam alaikum all... is praying 5 hours a day better than 6? is doing shine 5 hours a day better than 6? is 1 hour during of night of power better than the whole night? I'm no sheikh far from it but any form of ibbadah is better than non. Our Nabi saww may Allah be pleased with him corrected the ummah of that time and as time goes by things do change but god is all powerful and has corrected man in this seen as time has gone by. So please do not argue amongst yourselves and do good. May Allah guide is to be better Muslim's.
shine = dhikr
Doing biddah is worse than doing no ibadah. I am not saying Taraweeh is biddah. Because Nabi S.A.W said that as long as we follow him or his companions, we would be okay. So following his companions is okay.
prophet s.a.w never offer tarawweh in congregation
hence it is bidah ....
You do not have to worry about soiling your clothes with urine while you were an infant. As an infant, you were pure and blameless, without any sin (not even the Original Sin). But now as an adult, you are responsible for your actions. It is the same attitude again. God has no say in my life. I want to do whatever my filthy soul desires. I want to be as dirty as I can.
Zakir Naik knows Arabic better than hazrat Umar? if sahaba used to pray Taraweeh than how was it bidah(innovation)?
Kashif Khan there are good bidah
Zakir Naik is also talking the same. First watch video. Don't just comment after reading the title. You know how these youtubers make us click their videos. There is no good biddah and he never said that.
no there are not, and no one said there were
zakir naik sometime goes beyond to limits.
Say for example some women in USA do not wear abaya, and suddenly after hidaya they start wearing so shall we say what an excellent bida'h? Sorry Mr zakir Naik you failed to support this argument because truth shall triumph! Tarawi is bida'h and it's for sure. Prophet Muhammad s.a.w never started tarawi, its even their in that hadith and he scolded those people and said tahajjud should be prayed at home not in congregation. Mr Naik you also supported hadith which is in favour of tarawi which is saying that prophet Muhammad s.a.w used to pray tarawi, so that hadith and this hadith contradict with each other. Both are going in opposite direction. This means that bukhari itself isn't 100% sahi. There is only Qur'an which is 100% original and no one can change it but Allah has not taken any guarantee of bukhari or Muslim. Do you know that bukhari was compiled after 300 years of demise of prophet Muhammad s.a.w? Do you know how much is 300 years? When someone speak something or record something it changes after just one day, so how is it possible to collect 100% sahih details of hadith? Can't there be any fabrication? But no one use their mind as they have been taught to not to ask questions, but Allah says ask questions and try to find out the truth. We should try to go for truth, but not be blindfolded to believe anything except Qur'an.
These trivial actions are just little tests for you whether you are willing to subdue your desire to demonstrate your Love for God or you have made your desire a deity that you worship day and night. All this comes under the grand Plan of God to extract His faithful and beloved servants from mankind and reward them with His Gracious Bounty.
He says hazrat umar revived the sunnat
“It was a bid’a in linguistic terms”😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
What's here to laugh devieted cult🤔
Imaam Muslim related that the Prophet said what means: “The one who innovates a good innovation in Islaam has its reward and the reward of those who practise it until the Day of Judgment, without lessening the rewards of those who practise it. The one who innovates an innovation of misguidance carries this sin and the sins of those who practise it until the Day of Judgement, without lessening the sins of those who practise it.”
Yahya Rodbari the Hadees doesn't say that "the one who Innovates a good innovation in Islam will have a reward but rather it says one who revive the sunnah will have a reward. "Sunnathu Hasanah" is the term in hadees not "Bidath Hasanah".The hadees is directing to anyone who brings back a Sunnah forgotten by the society,Those will have the reward.
Ashhad Kalam Sorry akhi but you misunderstand the hadith. It's not talking about anyone who "revives a sunnah (of the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم), rather "sunnah" here refers to general practice.
We know this because later in the hadith it also talks about "bad sunnah" and no sunnah of our Nabi صلى الله عليه وسلم is a bad sunnah. Therfore the word "sunnah" here is used in the linguistical sense, meaning "practice/act"
Zoro Roronoa This is the exact topic under discussion:
Jareer ibn 'Abdullaah al-Bajali (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: "The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: 'Whoever starts a good thing and is followed by others, will have his own reward and a reward equal to that of those who follow him, without it detracting from their reward in any way. Whoever starts a bad thing and is followed by others, will bear the burden of his own sin and a burden equal to that of those who follow him, without it detracting from their burden in any way.'" (Reported by al-Tirmidhi, no. 2675. He said, This is a saheeh hasan hadeeth)
There is a story behind this hadeeth, which will explain what "whoever starts a good thing" means. Imaam Muslim reported this story from Jareer ibn 'Abdullaah, who also narrated the hadeeth itself. He said: "Some people from the Bedouin came to the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him), wearing woollen garments. He saw that they were in bad shape and in desperate need, so he urged the people to give them charity. They people were very slow to respond, and it could be seen in his face (that he was upset). Then a man of the Ansaar brought a package of silver, then another came, and another and another, and his face was filled with joy. The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: 'Whoever starts a good thing in Islam, and others do likewise after him, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who followed him, without it detracting in the least from their reward. Whoever starts a bad thing in Islam, and others do likewise after him, there will be written for him a burden of sin like that of those who followed him, without it detracting in the least from their burden.'" (Reported by Muslim, no. 1017)
so its clear its all about Starting something good initially to inspire others to do so.Just like the context of hadith.
So it is not about starting a good biddah. No biddah is good. It is about starting something good. Sadqa e Jariyah.
Yahya Rodbari good explanation. He is misleading Muslims
whats the nasheed, subhana rabbika rabbil izzati ammaa yasifoon?
-Omar ran away from the battlefield in Uhud
-Omar killed the Prophet Muhammad’s daughter and usurped her land
-Omar refused to let the Prophet write his will, because he knew in it he would select ali for the caliphate so he said the prophet was going insane and that he was hallucinating
-Omar buried his daughter and was worshipping idol (even in the prophets time he was a munafik)
- Omar, during his caliphate judged unjustly, when his friend and a women called um um jameel (abu lahab’s wife) where publicly fornicating, 4 people say they saw them and beard witness but Omar told one of them not so say that he saw them in the act so the witnesses would get punished not the fornicatiors.
- Omar also invented Taraweeh😂
-Omar was responsible for poverty due to unfair spread of money during his caliphate
-Omar was responsible for the uprising od Banu Ummayed
And yes, I am Shia just being truthful and objective here and I know I will be cursed by sunni’s but I will get their good deeds and they will get my bad deeds( Inshallah if they do).
حضرت عمر رضی اللّٰہ عنہ ایک عظیم شخصیت تھے.. we love him soo much.. 💖💖💖پیارے صحابی رضی اللّٰہ عنہ
Dr. Zakir naik is a great scholar
only true religious scholar zakir naik
Excellent ❤️
Here are some things i have to say about this hadith:
That taraweh salah was already there at the time of Rasulullah (Salalahu Alayhi wa Ala Alihi wa Sahbihi wa Barak wa Salum), where .he (Salalahu Alayhi wa Sallam) prayed in jamaat at night in the mosque, and then he repeated this, having a greater number of people in jamaat after every day until the fourth where the mosque was more than filled with companions ready for jamaat with Rasulullah (Salalahu Alayhi wa Sallam), but he did not come.
He told the people that day after Fajr jamaat salah that the reason he did not come for taraweh is because he was worried that taraweh might become fard and his ummah cannot handle it consistently, i.e. might miss some and cause themselves sin due to missing fard ibadah.
Sahih al-Bukhari 2012
In-book reference : Book 31, Hadith 5
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 3, Book 32, Hadith 229
So here, from the hadith, which is a shorter version of the full hadtih, that taraweh was already in the religion from Rasulullah (Salalahu Alayhi wa Sallam), but then it was left/ not practiced. But then, from the hadith that the video is based on, you see that it is simple revived from a companion (radyallah hu'anhu) who knew about this sunnah.
There is nothing newly invented, simply that the sunnah is revived by a companion (radyallah hu'anhu) of Rasulullah (Salalahu Alayhi wa Sallam) who gains all the reward for this and those who take from it.
Here is a hadith which talks about the revival of a sunnah/ good act:
The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: 'Whoever starts a good thing and is followed by others, will have his own reward and a reward equal to that of those who follow him, without it detracting from their reward in any way. Whoever starts a bad thing and is followed by others, will bear the burden of his own sin and a burden equal to that of those who follow him, without it detracting from their burden in any way.'
Here, the mentioning of 'starts a good thing' not a bid'ah, because bid'ah is a bad thing and starts, from the context, shows that it is just the first good deed from a chain of good deeds.
And:
“Know that whoever revives my practice when it has died out after me will have a reward similar to those who act upon it without detracting from his reward in the slightest, and whoever innovates misguidance displeasing to Allah and His messenger will have a sin similar to those who act upon it without detracting from their sins in the slightest.”
Umar (radyallah hu'anhu) simply revived the sunnah and 'started' a good thing, no bid'ah, a goodly accepted deed from a dead act within the sunnah.
Also, Umar (radyallah hu'anhu) did not say simply and only say that this is a good bid'ah, rather that is some falsehood which people say out of context.
He was told that this is bid'ah, and responed by saing that if this is bid'ah then this is an excellent bid'ah. This clearly shows that there is no bid'ah but sunnah because he clearly said 'if this is bid'ah' implying that this is not, but if it were.
Also, he was speaking literally, it was just an expression of speech, saying that this is a good act that is basically new,, since it was dead, but knowing that it is not actually new but was just dead.
Jazakallah khair for the clarification
If Nabi SAW said stop ,it becomes haram
Nabi SAW said dont eat the flesh of donkey so it becomes haram
So when some eat the meat of donkey ,it means sunnat is revived
@@danishwar8216 if he said don't do it usually that means haraam but he doesn't do it without implying it's haraam & we do it then it's sunnah that is revived that's what happened to Tarawih
@@maganhassan2627
Bukhari Hadith no.7290
Perform your prayers at your homes, for the best prayer of a person is what is performed at his home
except the compulsory congregational prayer
@@maganhassan2627
Bukhari 2012
I was afraid lest the night prayer (Qiyam) should be enjoined on you
You criticism is just based on cultural background and no objective morality. Muhammad’s time was almost 1500 years back. Even in today’s day and age, there is so much disparity in the age of consent. In China, the age of consent is just 14 whereas in India, it is 18. In your country Cyprus, it is 17. In Germany it is 14. Whereas in Bahrain and Tunisia, it is 21 and 20 - so by their standard, many in your country could be charged.
I like Taraweeh sunna or bidah I don't giv a damn....i like it
He is not telling the complete truth and wrong on many things.
Why didn't obu bakar offered it.
can someone answer me? is it bid'ah for a muslim or even an ulama to wear western clothing especially which our prophet pbuh did not wear western clothing?
No, Its not bidah as long as there not going against Islam. As long as you cover your body the way Shariah says then its fine.
I don't think it's bidah, I think it's an evolution of intellect. :)
prana888 Isn't it "BID'AH" for you to use the computer, internet, facebook and youtube when the prophet never used it?
Azhar Eddin that way the Muslims will be left in time ler
Bidaah as in bidaah in worship not worldly things such as clothes, electronics, etc
mustaqim hadi I know that bro. I was sarcastic :)
so taraweeh is a bidah....
He dint anwer d question properly its a diplomatic answer
Qiyam ul layl is different to Taraweeh....Taraweeh is Taraweeh salaah and Qiyam ul Layl is Tahujjud salaah
Nope they mean the same thing really
zakir naik should eating garlic naans too lmao, it's haram to eat according to sahih hadith.
Like the natural laws which are immutable, God’s Design of the World is such that people who have recognized God and lived their lives in accordance with His Will shall earn His Company, Favor and an immense reward for eternity. On the other hand, people who have made their base desire as their lord are damned for Hell. This is the immutable Law of God.
Who recrited that ayya
The Blessed Prophet had given his wives the choice to stay with him or seek a separation and not a single one wanted to leave him. That was the love they had for him. Aaisha was the one who underwent a rigorous spiritual training under him. She is the one who reported hundreds of narrations mentioning his personal life. She watched with amazement the extensive worship of Muhammad of his Lord and reported to us how he used to extol and praise God in the dark recesses of night.