'Beijing is making inroads, Delhi is building fences, but India shouldn’t give up on Myanmar'
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
- For centuries, Indian traders and merchants successfully competed for influence in the great cities of east Asia, like Ayutthya. Even in the midst of wars, insurgencies and drug-running, Indian communities sustained their trade interests. But as India panics in the face of growing violence in Manipur, its at risk of giving up hopes of growing those gains through its Look East policy.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Praveen Swami's column here : theprint.in/op...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Europe also has free borders but that doesn't mean they leave their borders unfenced. Free movement can be through specific checkpoints based on biometrics otherwise how do they expect to control illegal immigration. The border between Myanmar and China or between China and any other country is well fenced.
They don't know anything about it. Neither they care. This media group is anti India. They will do anything to destroy peace inside this country with their evil narratives. Just take care of such a people. Know them, don't ignore. They are the enemy of progress.
Actually it is without fence sanghi andhbhakat
@@manjotsingh7238don't lie
@@manjotsingh7238blatant lie speaking as northeast citizens most want border to be fenced because the militants also operate from myanmar whenever military drives them out from their base in northeast because army has no ligetamacy in foreign country they can curve this using proper fencing
We have doors and walls, but it doesn't necessarily mean we dont want any relationship with our neighbors.
Building fences across a region that is volatile only makes sense.
And China has also build fences along china Myanmar border, nevertheless the title of the video says, china is making in roads whereas indian building fences.
We have fences with Bangladesh but then we have excellent relationship and very high people to people contact with it.
Fences is to stop illegal movements and not the legal one.
The one who suffers only knows the pain.
Who started this ruckus in manipur and how is still debatable as information coming in from such chaos are vague, non verifiable, biased.
It will be unwise for any agency to declare someone as the reason for it, unless that agency is the judiciary.
Print is paid to have anti national slant.
Rapist meitei spotted
I recommend that you study the history of Manipur and why this current communal crisis is occurring. You must understand that this is just a facade to hide from the world, and that a much deeper and more complicated Indian geopolitical plan exists, with Manipur serving as a parking spot for that plan. You must also understand why ending the free movement regime and fencing all borders is necessary not only for Manipur, but for India as a whole. If not, don't speak with your half-ass understanding of Manipur; you are not qualified, sir.
Report twwo brodr. Eidi twkhre
When will these newspeople stop buying colonial ideas. It is time start looking things in Indian way. #Indiafirst
this is not the 15th century, Every thing is globalized.We dont the necessary natural resources like US that we can do tat crap!
Which is what?
I had nearly given up on Jyothi Malhotra's ThePrint until Praveen Swami salvaged it with his primetime journalistic mettle.
same shaaker gupta is the only reason, other than him, print only has biased propaganda
Jyothi lies too
@@indian9632 Jyothi lies, Freedom dies.
How can you criticise manipur's CM by saying he nurtured the ethenic class? How much did kuki paid you to take their side. Why blamed meitei indian and take side of kuki who are fro Myanmar. You got paid for broadcasting news and also got paid for selling kuki bias news. Shame on you even though you report falsely the genuine things remain unchanged. You dont control government by reporting make up imformations.
Bravo. Now this is a journalist I'd follow. Thank you for understanding and explaining the complexity of North Eastern states and the politics behind it so well👏👏
Realistically speaking, the terrain and geography will be impossible to fence, even if you could how will you send patrol along clif and unexplored jungle for hundreds of kilometer
If there is a will, there is a way.
LOC is tougher and it's fenced too. Govt spent 6 years building it.
Not that hard i am an native manipuri have travelled in Myanmar from tamu to yangon the the travel time is long and terrain is harsh but not impossible to fence just need lot of manpower the moment of civilians will not be relinquished but will be done under military radar because of the crisis happening in Myanmar
Thanks!
Dear Arko,
Thank you for constantly supporting ThePrint.
Very vast knowledge about our land....thank you so much
Europe is different...they don't have terrorist neighbours unlike Asia
Fencing will affect fringe Economics of Inter border cities and towns.
R.Udaybasker.Adv Madras High Court.
Praveen Swami ji Firstly u try to understand is Manipur was an independent kingdom before India independent .....after indepent byforcefuly Manipur merge in India ...in this current issue ..i want to say if Manipur has own kingdom means not in India ...there will be no longer time to end this war ...
Defend first, attack later. The time interval need not be long, perhaps should not be, as defense power is a high purpose power, and necessity dictates.
Always insightful, truthful and hard hitting facts from you Sir. In a sea of Godi media like NEWS 9,TIMES NOW and others , the print is a gem. Voice for the voiceless and journalism in it's true sense. Hats off.
😮 mullla media
Indias geopolitics burned Manipur. Save Manipur. Save India🇮🇳. Seityamev jayate. Jai hind.
This print doesn't know anything about Manipur in ground tumara bhaab bhi nahin janta ....china has big wall over myanmar...and control drugs very strictly but they play upper hand without disturbing his country boundary in Myanmar...but india govt think whole NE as a boundary and war zone ...and dont think NE indian as first hand citizen ...so this print only play game what they want....what is giving up...is already lost in geopolitics of Myanmar...if you want to build strong relationships with myanmar...first understand who is meitei and what it play before Manipur joint india...india support chin/kuki which is not regarded as citizen of Myanmar till today...kuki are not respectable people in Myanmar also by Bamah which real majority people of Myanmar...but they know very well about meitei and its military might and hold respectable position in Myanmar givt till today and also bonafide citizen ...so before you trying gain upper hand in Myanmar better understand the relationship with Myanmar and Manipur Kingdom
Yes he and his team including his old fellow doesn't know who is real Manipuri people...if you read fake kuki history and believe it...india will fail 1000 times in geopolitics of Myanmar and south east asain country's...even the Britisher have written many time not to trust kuki many time even they help in their war as coolei/kuki...again now india geopolitics is fail and now HM has promised to finished FMR and now want to fence border...I have requested to all indian if india want make strong geopolitics with myanmar and southeast country better study well about Manipur/Kangleipak kingdom and it's people. as manipur is only strong kingdom in NE which hold strong power for more than 4000-5000 years old written record.So better have good relationship with Meitei people not with kuki/Chin people' which was baught by Britisher from malay paninsula to control Myanmar and Manipur kindom...
@@nckimphal8074indian geopolitics will fail again if people don't understand the meitei kingdom and its old history and relationship with neighbouring countries...and act east policy will also fail if india govt undermine Meitei civilization and try to box in small land
@@nckimphal8074yes this print shaker and his son only understand one name in Manipur related history ie PLA leader name only😂😂....Bhai read the real history of Manipur not with the Google mad wikipedia information....is all make up by kuki for more than 30-40 years and article from reputed journal....
Sadly, the meitei community doesn't have money to invest in his channel. That's all mate
@@disanKh rightly mentioned poppy money is what this channel is talking about only shit talk
Border fencing between china and Myanmar done by china
Are u aware that, fault lines are attracted to librandus?
PLA under leadership of CCP, already having strong barbed or walled boundry wall all around China except on Ind0-Tibetan border. So, their walls are strong, now they are open doors in the wall in controlled way. So, if you are saying India is building fences and beijing is maiking inroads because, Beijing's fences are already their and more stronger than ever. No they only building fully-controlled gated pathway in-between fences.
Fencing along border is mandatory
this is his point of view, what about having relation and opened border with militants ruled golden triangle, india will be a good market for them and that time it will be too late to regret
Then Government of India should leave Manipur alone if you don't want to fence international borders because it's affecting indigenous peoples of Manipur. Reminder- Indian people should protect meitei people. And I am proud of meitei. Indian sports is doomed without meitei community. If you don't want to protect meitei people. We meitei will reconsider pre merger status
Very Insightful
Genesis of conflict in Manipur must be understood with demographic politics. If you forget this issue, your analysis is nowhere correct.
They must be stopped or they become another aurangjeb or baabur.
China never made “inroads” into any country.They have only bought the leadership of target countries as they have done in the case of some of our neighbours in the west and south .They have also bought a national political party lead by a lady and her son in India, though I don’t want to name them.
Indian excuses... Always trying yo berate other countries when in fact, India is a weak and poor country. Lol
Party first and Country after could create greater logjam, domestic conflict logjams need way forward with peace for symbiotic gains for India.
We the community have our blood brothers and sisters in Myanmar accordingly if we look back kuki history agreement between India and mizou our brothers and sisters
Look back, look at the present and look at the future. If events that are taking place affects the security and national interest of the country, then policies have to be modified in accordance to the changes.
What blood brothers?
Kuki millitants just have history of illegal refugees
Dismantle all international boundaries of India be it Indo Pak Indo China Indo Bangladesh or Indo Myanmar... That's border drawn by British and their Agents
Did u know manipur is only 700sq km,do u know about....@@MaximusNingthoujam
Yes, Modi-Shah is not doing nearly enough to deal with every domestic problem at the borders. In fact, India ought to fence borders with Sri Lanka as well. Chalo Rameswaram pukaar ke.. 👉🏾 🌊 🤺
One of the very few mainlander who knows and speak about Mr N Biren Singh Politics
Thanks to Pravin Swami
I think protecting cultural identity is much more important than free floating opium trade root and guns. And modi is the one who is felling insecured for the sake of nation. Your narrative looks immature.
Mr. So called Self Styled Expert, Stop Trying To Get Fame By Playing With Fire. And Do Proper Study Of Manipur History and What It Has Lost So Far After Becoming a Part of India. And Stop Supporting Those Savage Groups By Saying Ethnic Population. That Shows Your Ignorance of True History of Manipur While Trying To Get Some Fame. That's Nonesense. Period.
And we the Manipuri People Support The Decision of MHA. 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Why you are having fencing between Tripura and Bangladesh? You paid journalist of The Print don't play a hypocrite.
It's just to please the meiteis,based on the vote-bank.The hill-people 've never & will never recognise the present border;large parts of Myanmar,inhabited by tribes will be anex &become a part of India.
Do more research
Lol itna dimag nahi hain politicians ke pas
U r sitting in Delhi and listening to speak
North East East not part of sanatana india so Modi should part away to it ....Jay shree Ram 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Yes give them independence
@@dinacherput3225 Actually - they don't want to be without India ( All leaders understand that they can always cry victim in democracy ) but the fact is economics, those states are living under "special status" where funds are allocated from India as hill states for development which was denied to Andhra Pradesh despite promise by Center in 2013 during bifurcation. those states will be in tatters and nothing to cover up themselves..with no sea access or economic activity youth land up in mainland India for higher education to jobs. But the locals who live there are generally hostile to main land Indian population ( and vice -versa also. to very less extent ). They have been integrated to main land India by India 's softer approach unlike China's approach where Han population was forced into Xinjiang and Tibet. Their leaders know where they stand in respect to that when they had gone for an insurgent training in early 60s to China. They observed the reality. There are several episodes covered by Shekhar Gupta in Print explaining this well.
Meiteis are Hindu dude...
@@qwertyca Nepali also hindu dude....
@@qwertyca there are meiti Muslim called meiti pangal and there are meiti Christians also.. about 10% of meiti population
Paid journalist stop talking without proper study. You know nothing about Manipur. How do you get from the Kukis? Worse talk ever.
Blaming the kukis for inciting violence in manipur is putting the horse before the cart.
😂
Drug fun chenal