Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
South Rejects Government's Hindi Push?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 апр 2017
- The government today has completely denied any imposition of the Hindi language and says that it is promoting it. This comes days after DMK's MK Stalin came out strongly against what he calls the centre's Hindi imposition and an attempt to make non-Hindi speaking people feel like second rate citizens. From compulsory Hindi till class 10 in CBSE schools to speeches in Hindi by ministers, is the stage set for a new language war?
Watch full video: www.ndtv.com/video/shows/agend...
NDTV is one of the leaders in the production and broadcasting of un-biased and comprehensive news and entertainment programmes in India and abroad. NDTV delivers reliable information across all platforms: TV, Internet and Mobile.
Subscribe for more videos: ruclips.net/user/ndtv?sub...
Like us on Facebook: / ndtv
Follow us on Twitter: / ndtv
Download the NDTV Apps: www.ndtv.com/page/apps
Watch more videos: www.ndtv.com/video?yt
These North hindi speakers migrate to other parts of India and try to impose their language on others
Hindi speaker privilege reminds me the english speakers privilege habitude in French Canada .
Kick out Hindi language from all southern states
Hyderabad mostly Hindi but it's telungu State
@@csePraveenKumarB it's Urdu not Hindi
@@world_conquerer ohh sry...I think both r similar...am I r8
When they need votes they'll speak in Tamil, Telugu,Kannada and Malayalam but after getting votes they'll impose Hindi in South Indian states
In dravida nadu😢
All the south Indian languages are classical languages... Hindi not even considered as classical language... It has the influence of arabic , persian and urudu.... which is absolute foreign... Being a Malayali I respect all the Indian Languages... But Malayalam is my mother... If I wish to learn Hindi in future, I will , but you cannot force me... I think all Southees will agree with me.... We don giv a Damn... Nee poda mone Dinesha...
We love south Indian languages. But why you people prefer English over Hindi. While Hindi being our own language and English Being foreign language
CHIRAG BHAT we prefer English for some reasons:
1. Learning English is far more easy compared to learning Hindi for South Indians
2. The Hindi language portion in CBSE is very disgusting. Many South Indians go to tuitions after School just because of Hindi. Any language except Hindi is a scoring subject in CBSE. So many prefer a foreign language.
3. We South Indians have huge IT industries. So it's mandatory for us to learn English and it is Internationally linked.
The Country Travelogue hindi is as much a foreign language to us as english is
CHIRAG BHAT Hindi is a alien language to us the south Indians
Nomadic Traveller Hindi is not even a language
I use hindi only to buy Pani poori in chennai :D :D :P ..Ek panipoori bhaai :P
I support you Bro.
Tanumoy Mandal
Me too.
SuccinctDirector 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂👌👌👌👌
don't cry when someone mocke your colour and language
Dude I use the word PAN also😂
I am a proud Tamilian and I know Hindi ....Just understand India is not a single culture like china, Japan,etc...India itself is a continent ...Never impose any culture or language on others..It questions the idea of India
kritika singh rightly said sis... I LL know a bit Hindi... But can't be forced to kill all native languages
NA gud u Googled... For describing south Asia means??? Wers India??? Is it in Antarctica??? Go and support Ur mother language... If Hindi is urs... Don't spoil the beauty of Hindi with English in it... Give respect earn respect....
NA every North Indian languages was mixed and form Hindi but no North Eastern language and south Indian languages can't mixed.pIease mix all Indian languages and make new one then we are accept.china is like this only all from Chinese partiality will never work out brother.this only way for Hindi solution and English down.
You hit the nail on the head man.
India is by its very nature a multi lingual nation. Imposing a language on any section of people is counter productive.
Well ur pride will be ur downfall. Just letting you know that.
Stop Hindi imposition ✊🏼
I would add - stop using tax payers' money in promoting one particular language. This is shameful and cheating !
Somin Mukherji
No body has pushed Hindi...!
Even Modi has said in his speech we should learn different Indian languages so we can communicate with each other's, know each other and it can create a new industry in itself. It will unite the Bharat.
Don't diving people here.
Ravi: You are not getting the correct picture. Nehru was smart and during his regime the 3 language formula was adopted. The Hindi belt cheated on this one. Modi is extremely smart to know the danger of promoting a language that is mother tongue of only about 25% of Indians. But Rajnath Singh and Sushma Swaraj had to open their mouth and state how much they are fond of Hindi Bhasha - What? Who the hell cares about these public servants (salaries and benefits paid by tax payers) love affair with a particular language? - the likes of such people are only there to divide the nation and not unite. In 2015, the UP Govt issued a Fatwa that the official website will be only in Hindi - this was taken to court by the Govt of TN and they stopped. Why is it that all embassies have a budget for promotion of Hindi language alone 0- whose money do they think they are blowing up anyway ? My point of view was in response to someone who thought we all should have one language and that is Hindi - No this can not happen, our strength is in our diversity and we can not let a few Hindi-wallahs destroy our country the way we know it - Can we?..
Somin Mukherji absolutely agree bro .We bengalis fought against urdu , so that we can have bengali .We will fight against hindi haegemony.
Somin Mukherji
nicely said .
Why should I learn the language that you are comfortable with? Respect the local language... Respect unity in diversity....
Exactly!!! We are known for our strength in unity in diversity! We respect hindi but when it comes to imposition the hell no....
@Vimal k Chaubey !which national language are you talking about????? From my knowledge there is no national language for India....
@Vimal k Chaubey every indian language is beautiful not only hindi. even we have more beautiful languages than hindi then why only hindi??
You surely are going to loose your languages by supporting hindi . See even schedule 8 does not include your language . At least English did not interfere with your language and allowed it to exist but hindi will surely construct samadhi for these languages . reducing them as home and kitchen languages . Bro, have some self respect as a bhojpurian ." AWAKE , ARISE AND STOP NOT TILL THE GOAL IS REACHED ." Thus spake Vivekananda .
Bro hindi is not our national language .
Hindi is not required. Make English compulsory in all states. Stop Hindi imposition.
Nilesh Mali -- Yes, that's good idea.
North India 's plight is bcoz of rejecting English. Now every North Indian students of upper middle class and lower middle class learning English. Today Every corner of North India, "English specking course institute" is lucrative market.
Because poor and lower income people cannot afford English education schools. And number of poor people is very high in all over India and not only in north India.
My friend don't you listen the songs of Telugu Hindi Tamil please respect all language
True..Hindi is an Indian language and this will make India more unified and strong in a long run..We must not accept Hindi. More and more English should be imposed so that we may serve Britain and America in a better way as we did before 1947. They used to treat us so well..Missing that.
Regards
@@kaushikmishra2167 I do speak Hindi but if English is discarded because it is not an Indian language then stop wearing jeans. Wear Khadi and adopt the Swadesi way of life.
Iam a south Indian 😎 and i love Dravidian languages and i learned all of them
Do you know Tulu ❤....
Jai Telugu States..!
Jai Southern States..!
Jai South India..!
Oppose Hindi imposition..!
Tony C jai telugu thalli
Tony C jai costal andhra
jai telangana
jai rayalseema
jai jai telugu talli💪💪💪
kai karnatandra
ಜೈ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕಂದ್ರ
ready to one south Indian Contry
aseem misra Even we say jai hind, but we can't give up our mother tongue replaced with hindi. Jai Karnataka jai hind
really then why kannada people are against Tamilians ???
Urdu was imposed on Bengalis of East Bengal. ,,,,The result Bangladesh. Those who do not learn from history, are condemned to repeat it.
So true.
we are as south korea..and northern are like north korea..beggar
@@rayhanahmed6875 somewhat its true but there are some states which is keeping north together otherwise all the bimaru states are surely north Korea.
Exactly 👍👍
@@rayhanahmed6875
Who are you to divide India converted mullah 🤣🤣. Live and let live no one will impose Hindi on you, we very much respect south’s culture and language
Jai Hind
I am against this compulsory learning of Hindi in CBSE and Kendriya Vidyalaya schools.
This issue has been debated and discussed a number times, but people who are imposing the will of the majority on others are not understanding the issue.
It was decided that we will adopt three language formula, where One would be your mother tongue and other two would be any other languages of your choice.
This was supposed to followed by all states.
What this led to in states like Karnataka is that we had kannada and english as the two languages and had hindi as the third language.
But what I realised is that this is three language formula is not used in most of the north Indian states. And even if they are studying a "third" language, they are studying sanskrit in devanagri script. They are not making an effort to know the other languages of this country.
I am fine with it, if that is the people's choice, but tell me how many govt institutions are actually giving the option to students to study other indian languages? the whole three language works on quid pro quo.
So if you are not learning other indian languages as the third language, I am not forcing it on you but I also expect you to not force hindi on us.
we can use english as link language, as it has more advantage as being the worlds link language, and let the students learn their respective mother tongue.
sorry its not will of majority, hindi is mother tongue of barely 30% ppl. It is just use of brutal force by a foolish n crude large group... will be resisted.
steelnerve yes
Bro CBSE schools all around India doesn't have any regional language . I studied in a CBSE school throughout my life ( ARMY PUBLIC SCHOOL indeed) even in Hyderabad. They did not oppose this decision why you guys are? If a person is learning hindi that does not mean that he/she does not know his/her mother tongue . Also the students who are studying in CBSE schools in chennai does not want tamil as a subject . Your state ministry opposed this decision so that more and more people come in State Boarded school by paying a hefty price.
Nobody asked you to go to these schools or send your children there. You can always send your children to non-CBSE schools.
I am a Tamilian but you are using a wrong argument.
Kendriya Vidhyalaya are run by central govt. Hindi is going to be there whether you like it or not.
However everyone has a choice whether to send their children there or to some other school.
Also this debate has gone on for too long. It is not even funny now.
Hindi is a language spoken by 40% or more Indians. It is extremely useful in commerce, business and when you step out of Tamil Nadu. So, just learn that damn language and stop this stupid debate, will you?
👌👌👌
Only solution is let those 5 or 6 Hindi speaking states go away from India (a beautiful conglomeration of Indian languages from Kashmiri to Assamese to Gujarati to Malayalam). And these Hindi speaking states can then make Hindi their national language, and celebrate their formation of new country like Pakistan and Bangladesh.
you are perfectly correct
how will kashmir be a part of this conglomeration of different languages as kashmir and punjab will have no geographic link with rest of the country (becuase hindi belt which physically joins them will be gone)
You have hit the nail on its head
We don't want hindi . As a south indian we are happy with our mother language Kannada.
Why you imposing hindi? Hindi may be good for you. Not for us. It is direct threat to south indians as whole.
Not only for south india..but it is threat for all regional languages..
🚩🚩jai maharashtra 🚩🚩
🚩🚩Jai marathi 🚩🚩
Oppose hindi imposition.
We don't want hindi .
Maratis themselves call hindi, marati has hindi script, it's a joke u supporting south.
@XDOX XD Boss don't try to fool urself, in maharastra ppl associate themselves to hindi as National language while to South indians they say marathi is different from hindi. Double standards for survival techniques. Marati will not survive too long that too post bala saheb Thackeray demise. Thackarey too was confused whom to support, he had called a slogan to kick oout South indians in maharastra which is 'pungi bajaoo lungi bagaoo'. Soon hindi ppl will outnumber maratis in MH
@XDOX XD Just move out, no problem a muslim world will be created in ur each states. Don't think language binds all but when country is created again they will be division on religion & caste
@@anil01kumar2000 that's y Siva Sena roasted you guys years back in the era of BAL Thackeray
@@international_fraud Bal Thackeray himself was against South Indians, then Biharis,up walaa,,gujratis in mumbai.
The Majority of Non-Hindi Speakers is greater than the Majority of Hindi Speakers ! Then how can Hindi be considered as a National Language ?! Hindu-Hindi-India policy should be dropped... We're such a diversified country, we as a Indian needs to celebrate this beauty. Placing ones Language or culture over others will bring nothing !!!
Well said
I agree with you mostly apart from the fact that we do need to speak a set of Indian languages so that we can communicate with each other. If we can only communicate with each other in English then what is exactly the point of such India. Now if we decide to select other languages in the curriculum, let's say one from south and one from the east then their will be people fighting for which language should be represented. Fighting is not the way. We need to find a fair solution but by having a discussion. Peace out.
Tamizh Mozhi -- Rightly said. kudos. But Chai wala & pan wala running the country. result is chaos. apart from this , these aggressors Election chori is happening every corner of North India.
I support to go for English as national language rather than hindi ..
I am from Maharashtra, india
I know hindi very well. But it is unnecessary to learn
Mother tongue and english is enough to communicate.
There should not be third wheel.
No! English cannot be the national language. Neither can any one of the twenty-two official languages of India. Solution to this conundrum? Englis should be designated as the only link language of the nation. It has a neutral flavour as seen in the context of all the states in India.
more like a uniting language. In Bangalore and parts of Mumbai, English is the lingua franca.
🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕
बंद कर बे अपनी चोंच को अंग्रेज की औलाद 😡
💯💯💯
yuck man, this upadhyay guy cant even speak english properly and such chutiyas are batting for a pan hindi india. i am a north indian, hindi speaker and know kannada since i lived in ktaka for 6 odd years and i oppose this move. every language should be given respect, all these cultures date back to thousands of years. why dont we northies pick up various languages instead of imposing it on the rest like this chutiya upadhyays logic. everyone in THE japan speaks jaapaaniss , lol
iamgama Yeah. Hindi "sud" be the national language. Hindi what? 😂
iamgama formoola for formula he told😂😂😂ride for write,pine for fine😂😂😂
Subramanian Natarajan bihari are not filthy. They are mostly innocent people. I am from bihar and I believe every person should have freedom to choose the language they will use to communicate. I also believe that Hindi is very shallow language, not suitable for national statur
Lol I just read first line of your comment and laughed ... If someone is advocating for hindi , why should well english knowledge be the qualification ? Such chutiyas are giving lectures? 😂😂
Subramanian Natarajan Chal chutiye , I used to make fun of my south indian cook, who only likes sambhar to eat. 😂😂
Condition is worse in Mahrashtra. 3 language formula, with preference to state language slowly turning to Hindi first.
To the upadhyay: They are not opposing Hindi but it's imposition.
Suyog Parab very true!
the reason for that is not hindi education but the reason for that is bollywood and absence of marathi media till now , and becos of that hindi became popular and it became normalcy language ,
situation is changing now becos now there is hugh marathi media and people are switching to it but gonna some time to push back hindi language .
Suyog Parab yes, i too feel it
Suyog Parab yes its true
Yamraaj usse dominate nahi kehte.. atikraman kehte he.. isliye maar khate he..
don,t kill our mother tongues,go back hindi.
Mr Sharm are u really south indian?
Imposing HINDI is deplorable only 40% of entire INDIA & 60% majority INDIA is NON-HINDI. HINDI is not nationalism, HINDI is not INDIA, HINDI is not everything. So don't impose & force HINDI.
I would like to say implement Kannada compulsory in all CBSC syllabus, Kannada is one of the oldest living languages in the world and a classical language.
Kannada English saku Hindi Yake!!!!! jai Karnataka!!! stop Hindi imposition
GIRISH L G you are a konga.. don't lie saale..
GIRISH L G ಹೌದು ಸ್ಯಾರ್ ಸರಿಯಾಗೆ ಹೇಳಿದ್ರಿ
Suuuuuuuper anna
Nitesh Hegde kannada is the identity of kannadiggas. What do you mean by only english? It would lead to loss of identity. So it must be kannada + English.
Nitesh Hegde ok then have your mother tongue + English that’s better. But only english is not acceptable.
no...Hindi.. , only Oriya... or own mother language.
bibekananda moharana Well said brother. love thy mother tongue
bibekananda moharana Yes true we don't need to talk to each other. Let us make a pledge that we won't learn/speak/understand any common tongue. We must make sure that our own native becomes the National Language to be learnt by everyone else. :D :D
Regards
bibekananda moharana we in odisa speak more than 5 languages... odia n sambalpuri is majority n other tribal language (kui,ho,santali etc.) ... no three language rule here... we're the first state formed in preindependent India on linguistic basis.... try as much as you want... we are resisting Hindi with more force now
bibek moharana
Hey, I support you.
xD
i from uttarakhand . i support to all southies,They have their right to speak their mother tongue . even all the south Indian languages have different literature... tamil is my favourite ... and now days i am try to understanding tamil .அனைவருக்கும் வணக்கம்
உங்கள் அனைவரையும் மிகவும் நேசிக்கிறேன்
Good, good, Best of luck.
His English says it all why he don't want English
😂
When is one language in the Japan 😂😂😂
😂
@abhishekray Shut up you think so that knowing english is a talent....if you know english and think so i have a talent...plzzz get a life
Lol 🤣🤣
Stop Hindi Imposition
Naren Reddy yes
Teach Hindi in South Indian schools by all means... but also make teaching one non-Hindi language mandatory in every school in North India - be it Tamil, Telugu, Assamese, Naga, Bengali, Malayalam etc.
sailordoc2007 we are humans not robots.not everyone can learn 4languages in school.i can speak 4 languages but i can write only 2 properly.
Seriously you can only write in 2 language? ;P You people are so proud of being white aryan, race & look upon south as inferior compared to north because of colour!! Since you people consider yourself as superior in every way then learning 10 languages, in school should be a child's play:P
Korea one language but two country, arabic one language 26 countries saudi,uae,yeman,oman,bahrain,quator and kuwait all these countries are bordering countries then why they are separate nations
Couple of points to the Upadhyay fellow:
1 Hindi has to be taught compulsorily to all children - then do it in the Hindi states. Hindi states have the least levels of literacy in India.
2 Hindi is needed for development- Then why are the Hindi speaking states the least developed in all of India? Some are grouped together and called BIMARU.
Prasanth Valsan -- Sharp question. congratulations.
Read history..You'll learn how those states turned bimaru.
Regards
@@rajanbabu3448 foolish question... highly unsharp question.... Most of non-South Indian regions do not have coastline and that plays one of the most major role in development of a region when calculated historically.
Also, whole S.India is a peninsular pleateu while N.India is prone to earthquakes and floods.
Learn to appreciate the good things available in your country. Don't be a frog living in its own ignorence.
Regards
dude, are you the guy on quora.
@@kaushikmishra2167 c'mon what is the use of coast areas when we are not literate much and concentrate in IT services,manufacturing, agriculture. Then punjab, haryana took a decent place in HDI rank like southern states are they having any sea? We are just using our resources
Illiterate northern people just grow up . Most of we south indians don't speak hindi. But still we are are far more developed than any of the northern states. You can find nearly 60% hindi speakers in bangalore, 70% hindi speakers in hydrabad, 50% in cochin and 2% in chennai, Rest of southern cities and districts india don't speak hindi. Do you think we are fools? First learn to speak english as its an international language, It will link your jitichenz to the world.., India is one, Learn to respect other state people's culture, Their tradition and their language if you don't then just sit idle don't create sense less topic. Do you know? India's cleanest city is in tamil nadu. India's high literacy state is tamil nadu. India's highly industrial economy is in Andhra Paradesh/ telangana. India's largest IT economy boom in Karanata. Except Maharashtra and Gujarat rest of north states still live under poverty line and the unemployment rate is much higher than the south. #INDIA_IS_ONE
Why don't you Indians focus on eradicating English first.
Declan Newton-Maharaj Bengali is superior to hindi .If any indian language is worthy then it is bengali .Your hindi is 50% muslim influenced , arabic , farsi all are amalgamated . We hindus don't accept muslims .Go fuck .#Fuckhindi.
Agreed with Ajay Nadar. If Southern Indians moves to Northern Indian states: most of them learn to speak in Hindi in less than 3 months ; their basic command of Dravidian languages helps them to learn other languages faster. If the need rises: they adapt themselves in a new environment of their choice due to their basic mastery of Southern Indian languages. The scenario is not the same and almost all Northern Indians have difficulty mastering Southern Indian languages when they move to Southern Indian states: THIS DOES NOT GIVE YOU RIGHT TO IMPOSE HINDI ON SOUTHERN INDIAN STATES. If you are not intelligent enough to adapt to a new culture for economic benefit: THAT IS YOUR OWN PROBLEM AND YOU SHOULD STAY IN NORTHERN INDIA.
Less thab 40% People know Hindi in Hyderabad. Even though it is a Urdu City, After being capital of Andhra in 1956, most tepugu people settled in Hyderabad and imposed Telugu on Urdu Muslims......
I always want to learn Hindi. But this is why hate Hindi
why we need hindi?😂😂😂😂
does you hindi get us jobs outside India?
If you learn to stop butchering Urdu maybe yes. Hindi is Urdu. They just don't know how to pronounce their Zs as proven by the guys in this video.
Yes...huge number of high paying jobs are available. Check for yourself. It is the third largest spoken language of the world and a pride of every Indian.
Regards
@PRAISE KEK Brother you've every right to think of anything as a non-sense and live in ignorence. Additionally, English is not the only thing that can give you a job. Learn to appreciate and recognize the good native things available around you.
English mein to job hai hi... so that we can serve Britishers/Americans through their call centres as we did for last 200 yrs.
Regards
@PRAISE KEK Also, pls read the kind of English the guy has written to whom you've responded. But , I don't mind that as I believe English is nobody's language in India so I'll accept everybody's mistake with love and respect.
Also, You can check language census 2011( published in 2018) where there's noone speaking English as native language as I said it is nobody's language, We must learn to appreciate our own things and be aatmnirbhar.
Regards
@@kaushikmishra2167 bhai i found atleast one in favour of hindi...
Is Hindi is language of India ? It's created by Mughal emperors and imposed on north indians.....just not doing family planning... doesn't mean largest speaking language.
This India is created by British so only English should be the common and official Language in India not Useless Hindi,very state Should have Mother tongue and English as a official Language
nobody is preventing anybody from learning hindi but implementation is bad. if a student has interest then let him or her learn.
Samanth Bharadwaj exactly what you will feel when you get an ATM withdrawal alert SMS in Tamil. we exactly feel the same when its in Hindi.
@@jayeshmonlbs bro it's just divide and rule politics of politicians we are all Indians and we are one let them do their idiotic work they just want to ruine the beauty of our country btw I am from uttar pradesh and o speak hindi but as an Indian it's responsibility to protect the integrity of Tamil language because it's part of my beautiful country
@@sankalptiwari2828 are you able to use an atm served in malayalam or tamil instead of hindi.. if you resist may I call it politically motivated??
That's really not the beauty of the country..
@@sankalptiwari2828 sankalp tiwari where is divide and rule here?
It's not politically motivated.. resistance is just natural if someone force some alien language in my own motherland .. it's my right to get served in my mothertongue in my own place ...
@@sankalptiwari2828 if you call it politically motivated or divide and rule .. you are the one destroying the beauty of the country. And you're an anti national...
I strongly support Telugu as a compulsary language in all the CBSE schools. Telugu is more an international language than Hindi.
Sarath Krishna true. But Tamil is more international than Telugu itself.
Sarath Krishna aunu kaani tamil undhi..... aalochinchandi
Sarath Krishna don't fight between Tamil or telungu. Fight between Hindi and South Indian language.
Karthikeyan Mahalingam Believe me in future you are going to have this fight as well in case Tamil is chosen. This is a vicious circle.
lets speak bangla or lets develop a new common language using all the main language speak in india
crows = Hindi , non Hindi = tigers
Gowda bhen ka lowda
sahil 8181 nin Aman Gandu nan magane, sule magane,
i am tamilian learning kannada living in bangalore ..... good reply this fellow as a Vēśyeya maga ...
hindi tum hara baap hai
Molten Lava where do you stay brother...chennai or maharastra
If u say Hindi is great,I can say Tamil is the great of all languages as its the first and oldest language in the world.Y can't u make tamil as national language???
Which is much better than **** hindi.
according to Indian article 343 there is no national language in India and India is divided on only basics of language.
Language is an identity for us and why do central government trying to destory our identity.
India-"Unity in diversity" it's not a statement.and i hardly believe in that.then what's the need of common language?????
Ajay Karthik but you see tamil is the most difficult language to learn for a nation
Reflection Stillz
May be... But most interesting language according to me.
Ajay Karthik yes because you are a tamilian... but for others its not.
Reflection Stillz yeah the same thing goes with the southern State people who don't know hindi my friend.
Reflection Stillz for us Hindi is most difficult language
Learn tamil North Indian people it's the pure Indian language.
Vishal Murali
Hindi is the true language descended from the oldest of languages: Sanakrit.
Declan Newton-Maharaj even Sanskrit is not an pure language which borrows heavily from European and dravidan language, Tamil too borrowed some words. If you remove the borrowed words Tamil can survive but Sanskrit can't.
Vishal Murali
Sanskrit did not borrow much words. If you removed all the borrowed words from Sanskrit. Basically nothing gas happened. It is a different story for Tamil.
Declan Newton-Maharaj From a post in 1997 by George.L.Hart, Professor of Tamil, University of California, Berkeley
on Tamil, Brahmins, & Sanskrit:
More Info about George.L.Hart: Institute for South Asia Studies
Sanskrit has borrowed quite as much from Dravidian as Dravidian has from Sanskrit. But none of the four Dravidian languages I have read has borrowed anything from Sanskrit syntax that I can identify. Much of the syntax of Sanskrit is Dravidian, and it has a large Dravidian vocabulary. Its system of phonetics is profoundly influenced by Dravidian -- Indo-
Aryan is the only IE family with retroflexes.
Sanskrit also lacks some sounds that are available in Tamil. Tamil has short e and o, zh, R, n, and many permutations of stops -- e.g. k in akam -- which are not found in Skt. Actually both languages have about the same number of phonemes.
Both languages are carriers of wonderful and rich intellectual and literary traditions. The only way to appreciate either language is to read these literatures and spend a lot of time pondering them.
I will say Sanskrit words, which is same as Hindi, coz Hindi is nothing but kind of conglomeration of several languages with base as Sanskrit. Hindi is like English, heavy dependencies on other language words.
1. The roots of few Sanskrit words to Tamil are like just changing the hard Vallina Tamil words(ka, ca, ta, tha, pa, ra) into the Sanskrit "Sha"(ष ).
Example:
Kashta(कष्ट) - Kattam (கட்டம் )
கட்டமே காதல் (திவ். திருவாய். 7,2,4).
Nashta(नष्ट) - Nattam (நட்டம்)
நட்டாமாமுலகம் (உத்தாரா. திக்குவி. 67).
Ishta(इष्ट) - Ittam(இட்டம் )
இட்டமான வியற்புக ரோனிடங் கிட்டினான் (கந்தபு.சுக்கிரனுப.15).
2. Other than above mentioned words with sha, ha, replacements, few direct words will be like:
Log(लोग् ) /Lok(Hindi)- Ulagu(உலகு) or Ulagam corrupted into LOGAMU(ಲೋಗಮು) in Telugu and LOG(लोग् )in Sanskrit and LOK in Hindi from Sanskrit.
Krishaan(कृषाण)/ Kisaan(Hindi) - from the word Kizhaan(கிழான்), who means the owner, example "nila kizaan" (நிலக் கிழான் - representing Male owner) means land owner, Kaadhal Kizhathi(காதல் கிழத்தி ) means a lady who owns one's love. This even comes into as Kizhavan(கிழவன்), Aged and elderly Male owner of the land, Kizhavi(கிழவி), Female aged elderly owner of the land.
As per தேவநேயப் பாவாணர் ( Devaneya Pavanar ), Sanskrit word "देवम् "(Deivam), is said to be sharing roots with Tamil word "தீ ", he gives explanation as:
The word "theivam" (also spelled in English as "deivam")(தெய்வம்) is common to both Tamil and Sanskrit, and commonly considered a Sanskrit word borrowed into Tamil centuries ago. In an article published a few decades ago Devaneyan (popularly known as Pavanar or Devaneya Pavanar) points to the Tamil word "thee" (தீ) (means fire) as the root for "theivam". Worship of nature, especially those natural phenomena that benefited them or scared them, is common among ancient people. Rain was worshiped as something that benefited human kind, and fire was worshiped because they were afraid of it. Ancient Tamils, and even today aborigines in many countries, worship fire. Initially the "fire-god" must have been called "theivam" ("deivam"). With time the word came to refer to god in general. (For example, the word "thanneer" referred to cold water. Now it refers to water in general.)
English words "deity", "theology" and "theism" are all derivatives of the Tamil word "theivam" (deivam).
By the way, what is the origin of the Tamil word "thee". Deveneyan points to the Tamil word "thaei" (meaning "rub"). In ancient times fire was made by rubbing dry sticks. Brush fires in old Tamil Nadu were caused by the accidental rubbing of dry bamboo stems as they moved and swayed in wind. Thus the word "thee" originated from "thaei" (தேய்).
There are many words still to mention, I am lazy enough to mention all others, Coz it is like writing one frigging book.
For more details have a look at this etymological dictionary:
::தமிழ் இணையக் கல்விக்கழகம் - Tamil Virtual Academy::
Page : 121.
I do not what sources you get this from but all I know is that you are saying bullcrap.
Hindi is descended from the holy Sanskit, saying hindi is descended from Persian languages is saying Tamil is descended from Bali language.
We have our Classy south Indian Languages with huge history and literature. We don't need a duplicate language 😂😂
Sir, India is not a country like other nations having only one language. Only 30 percent people speak Hindi and it is not majority. We are a United States of India not one India.
Why you are promoting Hindi as unified language only as India is united based on "multilingual states" as one?? It is totally against equality. I am not living in another country where I should learn their own language in order to get citizenship there. It is better to have one non Indian language which is popular and useful for us to learn and develop more skills and notably make us equal. For example, I speak Hindi and English and other person who speaks Telugu and English makes both are even in terms of having same learning load in schools punches the center of equality. Just imagine all non native speakers of Hindi should learn Hindi but Hindi speakers are not having any compulsion such that to learn any other languages of India. I live in democratic country. If someone comes and say Tamil is the oldest and finest language of India and why not everyone should learn that language? Would you agree? No. everyone should learn their native language first followed by any languages they like.
Ashok Kumar I agree. We need to have a set of Indian languages which should be part of our curriculum and everyone should learn. The only trouble is how to choose this set as this will also lead to unnecessary fighting. Why cannot we all have a discussion with cool heads rather than fighting like goons. Secondly, there is no way that we live in India and have to communicate with each other in English. There has to be another solution.
Ashok Kumar -- Rightly said.
We can't accept everything from Gandhi ji.. he was also a normal human being and had his own emotions and opinions.. and don't put stress on school students into learning 3 languages.. if we learn our mother tongue and English. Then English can be used as a connecting language with in India and abroad as well.. students will not be stressed out.
Jahir Abbas,
100% correct
He also condemned the RSS for being extremist. Yet, the Prime Minister is shamelessly a part of it. This criticism was far more important.
Tamil is the oldest language in this world still living and growing.
Nitesh Hegde tholkappium is the proof
No it's Sanskrit
@@akhillover6745 give us the proof
@@santhosh9868 idli guy the main proof is your Dravidian languages have come from sanskrit...sanskrit was from the time of bhagwan ram nd it was thousands of years back..your Tamil is just 3000 or 4000 years back nd the rest of the Dravidian languages is influenced by Sanskrit...your stupid periyar has fooled you people to think that arya Dravidian story is true...fraud periyar fraud dmk is looting you people...Hindi is a must learn for you to eradicate all the problems in south thts when we all will be united...
@@akhillover6745 pffffffttt.....HAHAHAHAHA
I don't understand the logic behind the Cow-Belt Hyper-Patriotic Hindi World argument that a Nation should have a National Language to keep us unified, when there are many countries exist without a National Language,
due to the fact Language is often a factor in political rivalry between competing communities living in a single nation state...
India is Federal System and it's Union of States and the Regional Sentiments should be respected...
India got it's freedom in 1947... When Central Government is imposing something on it's Citizens and States... Our Freedoms are slowly slipping away...
English is not my Native Language, Hindi is not my Native Language, both are not related to my Dravidian sub-race,
but I choose English over Hindi is 'cause I choose it and I prefer to keep my preference that way and Indian Government should respect my Freedom Of Choice...
Ruru Koshy Varghese,
I agree with U. This India is created by British so only English should be the common and official Language in India
Then they would say that the cow is our national animal..🤦🏻♂️must be lack of education..🤷🏻♂️
It is called the hindi speaker privilege attitude !
If some one says we should learn Hindi let them learn Tamil becoz it is pure and very older than Hindi
Why we accept Hindi as a national language if south and north India separate we will follow our language
Constitution was imposed upon the people without taking their opinion.
Hindi is a regional language, it cannot be imposed upon others.
Gandhi was not a very educated person; he knew very little; he was a dictator. Gujarati is not a developed language, so Gujaratis accepted Hindi.
We have wasted 70 years because of the Bihari Babu Rajendra Prasad. opposition to Hindi does not come from the South alone but also from east as well.
Instead of Hindi accept sanskrit as the national language.
we should amend our constitutuion, it is against people's fundamental rights.
Dipak Basu Hindi stems directly from Sanskrit and literally a modern form of Sanskrit and hence easy to learn and understand.There were reasons why our founding fathers dreamt that Hindi could be a common tongue among Indian mass and in reality it actually is.
Regards.
Abc Xyz Congratulations you fucked a native language of your own country and a common tongue of a huge section of your countrymen who help build the nation along with you. Enjoy :)
Regards
Hindi is actually mainly composed of farsi and urdu contaminated by Sanskrit...farsi is a middle East language...Hindi is a slave language...these clowns let their real language Sanskrit die
Avishu Baberwal Up per capita income 40000 rs only 40% of indian avg .lol 😂 .
Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, Haryana, Rajasthan, Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh.. let all these hindi official language states form new country and enjoy your language...
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Then other states can live in peace.
True brother... 😂👍
Hindi belt states are obsessed with calling hindi as nationalist language 😂..
dont know how.?
Hindi is just regional language...
Even in countries like China Russia they started to use English as their connection language if u travel these countries you can feel the difference
You cannot survive on English in China. The link language there is Mandarin which has been imposed on every Chinese student for the past 40 years. Now, you can travel to the most remote areas and you can still find people fluent in Mandarin.
First of all, our aim should not be to transform ourselves into China and Russia. These are authoritarian autocracies which are against the spirit of our sacred Constitution.
Hindi is not national language. Period. When all Indians are sharing similar sentiments on almost all issues these days, some assholes in BJP are hell bent of pushing Hindi, only issue which can break this country !
absolutely NOT period. that half urdu half from our samskrutam, sanskrit, napunsak baasha h woh,hindi shindi jai hind.
well would not go far to insult any language. But Hindi imperialism not accepted.
unfortunately its required, look at the audacity. hindi, shindi must never be encouraged..too much jai hindustan.
yeah agreed. Its only Jai & Cow. Hindi people need to be tackled; they have a habit of behaving like Aurangzeb unnecessarily...bullying others.
good observation yours is. and you used right words...
anil Reddy pulimi
Hindi, The Panipoori Language.
European Union and United Nations does not have single language as compulsory....India is not monolith country like China,US,Germany,Japan etc. as its a subcontinent and made up of union of states....stop that absurd comparison
we in odisa speak more than 5 languages... odia n sambalpuri is majority n other tribal language (kui,ho,santali etc.) ... no three language rule here... we're the first state formed in preindependent India on linguistic basis.... try as much as you want... we are resisting Hindi with more force now
Bhruguraj Pradhan I would like to know more about your state and language.
More power to you. So many northern states had become submissive and prefer to use Hindi over their own native language. This should stop. Hindi is eating our culture slowly by sitting at our own houses.
Stop talking bullshit!!!😒
im a proud tamiliyan
nothing can be imposed on me.i will be an indian as long as my mother language has equally right.
Mr Not to intelligent petitioner who has a terrible accent.. doesn't know that chinese isnt a single language.. there is Cantonese and Mandarin and 100s of other forms..
Exactly, even I commented the same.
do not say stupid. . . You are all racist. . first of all you know India is not a country it is a combination of many countries. . . your mother can not be my mother. . . yes in German china japan is just one official language because in that country their people are all one race and one language but India is different from all aspects
Absolutely correct. Plus, these North Indians are on majority illiterates and can't speak or follow English. That's why they try to dominate South India by way of imposing Hindi and treat South Indians as second grade citizens.
Drive out all North Indians who are settled in தமிழ் நாடு.. 👍👍
Where Hindi is a few hundred years old and Tamil is several thousand years old.
Tamil is the official language of the Indian state of Tamil Nadu and the union territory of Puducherry (Pondicherry).
It is also an official language in Sri Lanka and Singapore and has significant numbers of speakers in Malaysia, Mauritius, Fiji, and South Africa.
Hindi depends on the Sanskrit way(Hindi is Sanskrit Avatar). so Sanskrit will come to life in it as Hindi grows.
The gates of hell will be opened when Sanskrit is resurrected.
This development of Hindi and Sanskrit will devastate the people at a time when they are free from the catastrophes caused by castes.
Tamil is Indian Old language give me respect
I don't like Gandhi
How cruel his thought was
"Every student should know hindi👿👿"and they are imposing it in South india
Hindi cannot be accepted as National Language nd as a Tamilian I totally disagree to include Hindi language in schools nd or anywhere in Tamil Nadu . We don't need Hindi in our state today or ever . I myself studied in kedriya vidyalaya nd learned Hindi from the day I joined schools but I don't insist or cumpul my children's to learn Hindi . Why we need to learn Hindi what's so important learn Hindi , no never I will never insist any girl child or boy to learn Hindi .no no no no no we don't need Hindi for any use
Stop hindhi in southern states
These Pani Puri guys don't to speak English so they are demanding us to speak hindhi
ജയ് മലയാളം ஜய் தமிழ்
We are enjoying travelling around the world, with English.
Do you want to enjoy only few north Indian backward states?
Join us. Learn mother tongue and English to enjoy the neighbourhood and the whole world! Be rational!
You are all try to push hindi, but actually all of us promoting English.
Hindi is just another language for me.I don't know Hindi and I haven't had any problems till date.
if we have our own language.. then what's ur. problem..
bibek moharana they started sending sensitive info in Hindi like ATM withdrawal alerts. we don't know that fucking language. then what we can do?
The 3-language policy was recommended by the Kothari Commission in 1968. They recommended that Hindi should be taught in southern states and southern languages should be taught in Hindi states. While all southern states are teaching Hindi (except TN and PY perhaps, I am not sure), not a single Hindi speaking state out of 12 odd has complied. Why??
P.Chidambaram has already clarified that he was only ex-officio chairman of the committee and 28 out of 30 members on the panel were from Hindi/northern states. He did not have a veto to overrule them.
Why is NaMo/BJP/RSS keen on putting this panel recommendation into practice while Kothari Commission recommendation is still catching dust??
Why are there different yardsticks for "nationalism"? If a southerner is expected to learn Hindi for the sake of unity, the northerner should also learn southern languages for the same reason.
If a southerner has to speak Hindi when he goes North and still speak Hindi when a northerner comes South, then our languages will certainly die, given the massive south bound migration in recent times. This is a recipe for harakiri.
All Central Govt schemes are in Hindi now. All parliamentary debates are in Hindi now. All minsters and dignitaries are being asked to speak in Hindi. It is expected that Hindi students should be allowed to take interviews in Hindi in any part of this country. I am a Kannadiga and I love my language. I also want to spoken to only in Kannada no matter where I go in this country and similarly other language speakers. Can the President please give his nod?
Modi/BJP/RSS are actually trying to kill English in this country and give that slot to Hindi. Everyone today knows how important English is. If NaMo kills English, we will end up selling tea at VadNagar railway station like our honourable PM once did.
We southerners will never give up our language and culture for Hindi.
We are Indians but we are not Hindi and Modi cannot convert us into Hindi. We will never succumb to becoming 2nd class citizens in our own country and play 2nd fiddle to someone else.
NaMo/BJP/RSS are giving a spur to communal hatred and ultimately division of this country. Sincere advice to Modi...please quit the chauvinism and zealotry and focus on development because you asked us for votes on that basis. Stop trying to implement hidden agendas.
Krishna R you R 100% correct
Everything u uttered is ok except the fact that u r targeting modi for modi.Dont forget that even,the erstwhile congress govt's were zealots of hindi imposition
@@trueindian887 Congress did it too, nobody is denying. My comment is relevant to what is happening since 2014 since Modi took over. No need to bring Congress into this now. It is plainly clear that Modi is Congress's grandfather in this Hindi imposition matter.
IS OTHER INDIAN LANGUGES ARE NOT LANGUAGE ONLY NORTH INDIAN LANGUAGES ARE LANGUAGE
Kuntal Kalit😂😂😂😂
B Sridhar
1 second ago
I am fluent in Hindi and like the language. I love singing Hindi bhajans, dohas, and film songs. I speak Kannada, Telugu, Marathi, and can read and understand Samskrit. My grandfather was a board member of the Dakshina Bharat Hindi Prachar Sabha and a cousin of mine edited Navneet, the Hindi digest. That should prove that I have a favorable view of the language.
Having said that , one has to show the Hindi-zealots their place. Let us try facts and logic for a change instead of playing on emotions.
First, most Hindi speakers believe that Hindi is a national language. That betrays their lack of knowledge of the Indian Constitution. No it is not.
Second, one third of all illiterates in India reside in the Hindi-belt (UP, Bihar, MP, Rajasthan etc). So, logically, it makes much more sense for Hindi-proponents to teach Hindi to their fellow citizens in the Hindi belt first, before trying to convince people fro other states that it is their patriotic duty to accept Hindi as the national language.
Third, the Three Language Formula that was agreed upon in 1968 required the study : "Hindi, English and modern Indian language (preferably one of the southern languages) in the Hindi speaking states and Hindi, English and the Regional language in the non-Hindi speaking States. The South kept their obligation. Hindi was and is being taught as an additional language for 50 years. Can you point to one state in the Hind- belt where this formula has been implemented? How many in the Hindi belt speak, read or write a single South India language? Instead, with huge population increases, and with that huge increase in illiterate population, these states have become a drain on the national economy.
Our national security is threatened not because Hindi is not treated as national language. The number one likely reason for national insecurity is illiteracy and run away population growth.
Let us focus on substantive issues that can bring people together than trying to gain political advantage by inciting through divisive issues.
Iam daily speaking hindi in chennai.... 'Ek plate pani puri'
Ha ha 😂😋😂
If Hindi is imposed in TN we need to be separated from India it is the fact Southern States contribute to the development of the Nation except Gujarat and Maharastra it is southern states contribute in fact Bihar, Rajasthan, UP contribute less but South is neglected be it relief or central funds shame on you you treat southern States as beggars you take more and give us less
Majority of india speaks English
Only 10 percent of population and look at Germany. They speak their native language and English and communicate with one another in German.
@@bobbymidha3901 we south indians also doing the same. we also speaking our native language(mother tongue) and english
We are not China we are not USA we are not Japan. Our country has history of thousands of years. India is a union of different people of languages, races, regions etc. Just talk your mother tongue if required learn any language of your choice. Making hindi is ridiculous.
Government should make all the 22 languages as compulsory in educational system. Because, these languages are Indian languages only so that whole Indian population can speak all languages and no linguistic state is denied of its importance. In a course of time, all languages will become majority speaking. If anyone feels it is absurd, then imposing Hindi or Sanskrit is also equally absurd. Democracy means that its policy should ensure protection of minorities interest also. All the time majoritrarian rule will not apply. And if it fails, it is not democracy but, is dictatorship. India is a secular, federal and multi-linguistic country. India was formed with that objective. Languages can be promoted by voluntary organisation rather than by government.
gandhi for convenience ....for hindi ...and for all other subjects follow godse not mahatma gandhi
Mu Man wow !
The 1968 "3" language formula is implemented by many South States by introducing Hindi as 2nd language but all North Indian States taken advantage of by picking up Sanskrit as their choice, which is a complete dilution of the "3" language formula.
Hindi Lovers like Bihar Model and will turn India to Hindia
I'm from Bangalore I know hindi,english,tamil,telugu,kanada,malayalam...... but I'm fed up of Hindi talking people in Bangalore...
it's become something great that if u speak hindi especially in Bangalore...... they try to dominate everyone here in Bangalore.....
I'm really irritated with hindi talking people....
I'm happy that I'm from South India and love my all four langurges.... though I know hindi I'll stop talking hindi from now on....
Shilpa madam even i m from bengaluru plz don't speak to them in hindi.
Same here in Hyderabad, Hindi everywhere..
@@VidyaSagar-uq1sg no bro Muslim dominated old city & north India migrated places central city people's speak in urdu&hindi and rest of places only Telugu
We have voted for BJP from Karnataka, if you impose Hindi then BJP has to face a serious consequences in Karnataka.
I am not tamil/telgu (other south indian) but how about
make north indians learn tamil, in Russia and other counties to universiry level studies have to learn 3 languages (including English)
We want to talk our own language..not hindi..
Stop discrimination to south Indians...
I don't know why you guys are fighting like this??
Do you know hindi, okay talk in hindi...
you guys do you know tamil, okay talk in tamil...
same as telugu, kannada, malayalam... etc
Because we are not living in china, saudi or whatever country...
we are living in INDIA...
UNITY IN DIVERSITY
So, we all have right to learn, or speak, or breath with their mother tongue...
Don't force them...
Let we use English, our official language of india...
Stay connected with india...
In my state of Telangana we need to any three languages of our choice whatever the languages. No compulsory language when I studied. People have right to study in any language they want. If we don't have such right. It means we haven't got independence yet.
Hey if u say that I'll say something to u in India there are more dogs in India and less tigers in India from this u can't say dog as a national animal same way Hindi can't be a national language😤
Hope india is a democratic county. Why to impose something. Everyone has the freedom of choice. Let people decide what they want to speak. Especially in a country like india, where multiple languages and culture are present, its clearly unfair to force someone to speak Hindi. Also there are other major issues in the country. Saving hindi and cow shouldn't be the major concern now. Farmers are dying, corruption in every nook and corner, girls not safe here etc., Do something for these things first.
so are usa and uk.they speak only english.nobody is forcing you to speak.take it as a subject give exam and pass.that's it.you will tell why not any other language.it's because more than 40% can write hindi, 50-55% can speak and 80% can understand already.
Most of the people know to read and write doesn't mean that everyone should also be forced to learn the same and give an exam on that. You cannot ask a donkey to climb the tree, saying that monkey can climb and why not donkey then. Let people decide what they need to know.
most of the states have a third language in subject curriculum except mother tongue and english.so why not hindi being the third language in place of german or french.nobody is telling you to forget mother tongue and start speaking hindi.
Nothing wrong in learning a new language. Let it be anything like Hindi, Malayalam, Gujarati, or even German or french. Let the third language selection be of students wish based on their comfort. The concern here is, why we need to order them to read Hindi. I am not against Hindi (any other languages too) in any manner. We can promote the benefits of knowing Hindi. But here it appears to be forcing.
killer instinct only 28% can read and write hindi , don't inflate the number.
A gandhi also told villages are our future...but why no one care about that.
We all have right to speak our own language..irrespective of hindi or any other ...I too speak tamil, hindi , english, malayalam and I like to learn more languages...no one has the right to force any one to emphasis more on to a particular language...in sense of majority ....not in country but in world we should speak English..
stop Hindi my state karnataka.Kannada language is Indian oldest language
జీవన్ కుమార్ , is there no migration in Hyderabad..!! support Kannada ppl
Vijay Kumar I support kannadiggaas... yaakandre nanna amma bengaluru.... hagandre tamil is the oldest language in the world, proof idhe. You can only say kannada is older than hindi, adhe sari. தமிழ் !!!
Kannada is older hindi is correct.. But Tamil is the oldest Language in the world..
Nitesh Hegde Hey.. Lol.. Just Google it.. 'oldest Language in the world' that is Tamil...
Nitish Hegde I respect tulu and am learning it too. But...
Sir, just because tulu is your language don't utter nonsense. I would have considered if you had said no.. Sanskrit is the oldest. But tulu... please don't joke.
If you have self-esteem then teach hindi in technical Institutes you don't want to learn hindi first and you're just imposing hindi
EINSTEIN STORY 💯
One day Einstein Makes the large hole in door for mother cat 😺
In few days, next to the large hole, he makes small hole for kitten 🐈
Then only he realised, large hole itself enough for both kitten and cat
That small hole is Hindi
That large hole is English
English is enough to connect peoples All over world
Someone tell Mr Upadhyay that there is no language called 'Chinese' 🤣😂🤣😂
North Indian people depends on south India ,south people not depends on north let kannada should be national language, eg: all states people depends on karnataka, but kannadigas not depends on any other states
y nt promote malayalam, or bengai....they got better movies
Dont force anything on the people of south, or else, things will be different, hope the central govt remembers what we can, remember JALLIKATTU
Vanthu paru, tamizhan da nanga
Why you guys think about Marathi language??
Let the North Indians learn one South Indian or North East Indian language along with Hindi and English, following three language formula.
Asokan Bhaskaran Why should we learn it when we already have Hindi as the link language.
free man filthy?? Says who? Mind your fucking tongue dude
We dont want hindi
Wrong to impose hindi, that result from PM/administration, capital city location and common language all are hindi centric, which is the reason create ego and advantage to hindi natives to bully other Indians. Research shows there are other Indian languages more original, qualified and older compare to hindi. Where is the separation of power and justice? All language Indians fight for independance not to make it as hindi centric. All non hindi speakers should unite against this hindi colonization before they lose their own identity and treated as second class citizen in their own country. India need to kick out the few hindi centric states and politicians if they fail to adapt and respect the India's rich diversity and exploit other states wealth. Boycot all things hindi till International language english is the only link language and all major indian languages are given equal importance in the central administration, for unity, progress and peace. United Nation should help against this injustice. India should have a strong non hindi centric political party to defend against this continuous bullying.
We do not have any problem in learning hindi, but do promote Tamil in UP, Kannada in MP, Telugu in Bihar & Malayalam in Uttarakhand, If you people feel this is silly then we say imposing is very silly.