Marking Remembrance with 98 year old veteran Colonel Blum and Cub Scout Emily

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 дек 2024

Комментарии • 795

  • @flippafloppa2961
    @flippafloppa2961 3 года назад +1665

    I love how Catherine makes every event about the people, not about herself. She listens. She connects with people. She is brilliant!

    • @Valencetheshireman927
      @Valencetheshireman927 3 года назад +149

      The exact opposite of Meghan

    • @lisarm100
      @lisarm100 3 года назад +112

      Catherine‘s amazing! I love her heart!

    • @cindyleastorch194
      @cindyleastorch194 3 года назад +118

      I'm part way thru and haven't heard her say "I" once. No 'me me me'. Wonderful interviewer.

    • @ginnypurdey1
      @ginnypurdey1 3 года назад +117

      Catherine is a TREASURE for our Nation. Thank you for ALL your HARD work Catherine.

    • @maggieedward3951
      @maggieedward3951 3 года назад +82

      Great ambassador

  • @jennydrake491
    @jennydrake491 3 года назад +799

    Isn't Kate amazing. So masterful at guiding the conversation. Thoughtful, respectful, warm and genuine.

  • @rachaelandrews6618
    @rachaelandrews6618 3 года назад +589

    I love how Emily is so respectful of the past, what a lovely girl

    • @marthaross6301
      @marthaross6301 3 года назад +33

      And to receive her badge from the Duchess❣️
      How incredibly extra special

    • @queenmum698
      @queenmum698 3 года назад +14

      We need to remember the past in order to have a successful and bright future. God Bless.

  • @christinejoy3030
    @christinejoy3030 3 года назад +739

    What a wonderful lady Catherine is. She makes it all about the other people and the cause.

  • @janettehutton8634
    @janettehutton8634 3 года назад +885

    The Royal families secret weapon, as I’ve heard her called. An absolute crown jewel ❤️

    • @onlygirl1635
      @onlygirl1635 3 года назад +23

      I don't think it's a secret

    • @girlcriedwolf9174
      @girlcriedwolf9174 3 года назад +9

      Not a secret cause everyone knows...☺️

    • @renegaytan908
      @renegaytan908 3 года назад +3

      She is indeed!

    • @soniaperez4526
      @soniaperez4526 3 года назад

      Huh, don't wanna be rude, folk, but when we say "secret weapon" referring to a woman, we are making her an object. See why: in the armed forces since long time ago, there's the tradition of name your assigned weapon after a woman's name. Kate is not a weapon. She is an amazing woman.

    • @janettehutton8634
      @janettehutton8634 3 года назад +1

      @@soniaperez4526 I prefer crown jewel too

  • @raccoonruby86
    @raccoonruby86 3 года назад +650

    This was wonderful. I have three young daughters and I would be so thrilled if they turned out to be like Emily. What a polite, intelligent, and friendly young lady. She will go far in life, I'm sure!

    • @Smartychase
      @Smartychase 3 года назад +19

      And eventually like Catherine ?

    • @dlcalbaugh
      @dlcalbaugh 3 года назад +5

      @@Smartychase That would be wonderful!

    • @andrewharald88
      @andrewharald88 3 года назад

      Hello Fiona

  • @crashhard4578
    @crashhard4578 3 года назад +460

    It's not ever about Catherine, it's about the folks she's talking to. Sincere and caring, a perfect fit for the RF.

  • @wendycoombes5223
    @wendycoombes5223 3 года назад +263

    The Duchess of Cambridge shows respect to everyone she meets,and with such compassion and poise.The Queen and Prince William(and the whole Royal Family) must be proud of how she has just continued to grow into her role.

  • @georgiefarr1094
    @georgiefarr1094 3 года назад +522

    I cried hearing about the colonel's story when his friend died before the war ended. But thank you sir for everything you've done for the country.
    Lest We Forget 🌹🌹🌹

  • @K.Lovelace1968
    @K.Lovelace1968 3 года назад +257

    Kate is amazing, she is without a doubt, the most beautiful person, inside and out, and will one day make an extraordinary Queen... Well done Duchess...

  • @deb53
    @deb53 3 года назад +243

    She has grown so much into her role. I really respect her ability to interview and/or authentically speak to people. Catherine doesn't make it about her. She doesn't take the oxygen out of the room with tales about herself or her cause. She asks others about themselves, what they think and what they want. Well done Duchess!

    • @ln2675
      @ln2675 3 года назад +9

      It's a new format and it suits her because she has a lot of empathy. I hope it will allow her to show us yet other sides of her in her public personna. She, along with her faithful team, is doing a great job. Inspiring.

  • @beverlypra3224
    @beverlypra3224 3 года назад +148

    The fact that she always let others stories shine is what I appreciate the most: it’s not just kind and respectful but also a sign of great maturity. She understood what her job is about.

  • @cezz789
    @cezz789 3 года назад +428

    Catherine is such a wonderful asset to our Royal Family, so kind, calm, respectful and empathic with everyone that she meets. ❤️

    • @aprilskies9149
      @aprilskies9149 3 года назад +13

      We love her here . ♥️🇺🇸

    • @serenityinside1
      @serenityinside1 2 года назад +1

      Good to hear- she’s special isn’t she 😊🇬🇧🇬🇧

  • @anniewhitmore7627
    @anniewhitmore7627 3 года назад +171

    We're in safe hands with HRH Duchess Catherine. Charm personified. Our respect, love and gratitude to Colonel Blum and all who served. And Emily, what a delight and lovely young girl you are - so articulate and an absolute gem. All of you are assets to our country and the world. Wonderful to watch you mark Remembrance, thank you all.

  • @yashu1750
    @yashu1750 3 года назад +440

    Catherine is really an absolutely most valuable gem in crown 😍😍😍😍

  • @lilyof-the-valley7324
    @lilyof-the-valley7324 3 года назад +150

    What a charming 10yo Emily is!?! Beautiful and confident; an absolute delight!
    Colonel Blum! Just love that name! God bless you Sir for your Contributions.
    The Duchess of Cambridge is just everything that's right with the Royal Family. She is a shining star. God bless the Cambridges and their families.

  • @audreyfforbes1444
    @audreyfforbes1444 3 года назад +112

    I love the quiet calmness of this interview. Catherine is such an asset to the royal family.

  • @phrtao
    @phrtao 3 года назад +123

    Thank you Colonel Blum
    The duchess is incredible - she manages to be both royal and a wonderfully genuine and approachable woman as well.
    We are so lucky to have all 3 of these people♥

  • @vidhyaraghavan2614
    @vidhyaraghavan2614 3 года назад +65

    How Beautiful! As a wife of a veteran,, feel so happy to see the Duchess of Cambridge do such wonderful work to highlight the Rememberance day!

  • @deedeegreen8338
    @deedeegreen8338 3 года назад +79

    I love Catherine. She has a way of making everyone feel at ease and she really listens when people speak. She is a class act.

  • @tisa6193
    @tisa6193 3 года назад +65

    Duchess Catherine is just so genuine and sincere. Such an asset to RF. She does Prince William proud!

  • @kittycatlyn
    @kittycatlyn 3 года назад +168

    May God bless you Colonel Blum and all those who fought (and those who continue to fight, protect and defend) for the freedoms we enjoy every day. Emily is a wonderful girl and a credit to her family. The Duchess of Cambridge is class personified as always. This was lovely to watch.

  • @chiedzacaroline9647
    @chiedzacaroline9647 3 года назад +279

    This was just so wonderful, watching three different generations talking about Remembrance and what it means to them. And I have to add that Catherine is a balm for the soul. I love the work she does and the consideration she shows while doing it.

  • @Minaish11
    @Minaish11 3 года назад +238

    What a beautiful video. We should all remember the sacrifices that our armed forces (Army Navy Airforce and homeguards or their equivalents) have made and are still making for us no matter in which country we live. A huge shout out to the Boy scouts and Girl Guides (that's the way they're known here in India). God Bless them all . ❤️From Bombay 🇮🇳

  • @twistedsister2568
    @twistedsister2568 3 года назад +91

    I have tears running down my cheeks listening them, that child knows so much and appreciates what was sacrificed for us to be free. It’s a pity a few others don’t understand as she does. We must never forget what sacrifices were made and never forget the horrors they went through. We must continue to teach our children and grandchildren and attend Remembrance Day services. This makes me proud

  • @barbaram5214
    @barbaram5214 3 года назад +39

    How lovely! Doesn’t Colonel Blum look and sound wonderful at 98. You can tell that Catherine has a love of Scouts herself and enjoys talking about its connection to Remembrance.

  • @annbaillie9098
    @annbaillie9098 3 года назад +132

    What a well mannered and respectful and also delightful young lady Kate is, her parents must be so proud. xoxoxox

  • @TK-xh1xc
    @TK-xh1xc 3 года назад +215

    What a class act. So heartwarming. Such a gift to the Royal family.

  • @raccoonruby86
    @raccoonruby86 3 года назад +49

    Thank you for your service and sharing your memories, Colonel Blum. We will never forget what you and your brothers-in-arms did for us!

  • @PamelaWildheart
    @PamelaWildheart 3 года назад +22

    Catherine, she's a lady...what a great tribute. Her attire too---it's about Remembrance...nothing red, loud and revealing. Catherine is an icon and a blessing to the Royals...

  • @demoneoseavery4074
    @demoneoseavery4074 3 года назад +40

    I love how she highlights this kind of event, talking with the survivors, not only during remembrance week, but even during random days

  • @jahnavisingh6118
    @jahnavisingh6118 3 года назад +65

    it's important to remember all those who died for their countries but also understand and respect their sacrifice. Love the duchess of cambridge, such a beautiful soul

  • @kismet2354
    @kismet2354 3 года назад +78

    There is something just so comforting about listening to HRH Duchess of Cambridge speaking. She will one day make for an amazing & truly compassionate Queen Consort to her husband, when he eventually ascends the Throne after his Father Charles.

  • @barbaracarol485
    @barbaracarol485 3 года назад +45

    I really love Catherine's caring voice, she speaks so well

  • @philippapay4352
    @philippapay4352 3 года назад +45

    What a delightful conversation and such a gentle way for a youngster to be introduced to our warriors from long ago and realize how young they were when called up to serve in the war.

  • @margaretmax-community
    @margaretmax-community 3 года назад +94

    I love seeing and hearing from Duchess Catherine, and her dashing Prince William

  • @danielwallace8668
    @danielwallace8668 3 года назад +45

    These types of conversations are how we make sure that we never forget. 🖤

  • @heathermotta8544
    @heathermotta8544 3 года назад +131

    So special hearing the stories of the Colonel and Emily, especially how the Scouts help them. Oh, stirring porridge! 😂 Loved seeing them make theor own poppies, and the look of pride on rhe Colonel's face when young Emily knew their significance. What an amazing legacy the poppies and Rememberance Day has, especially as those who served will no longer be with us. Well done.

  • @charlie1banks
    @charlie1banks 3 года назад +22

    Our Duchess Catherine's passion, compassion and genuiness is absolutely tangible!! Her character and person is flawless! An inspirational woman without any boundaries!

  • @katiesutton3448
    @katiesutton3448 3 года назад +52

    Brought me to tears. Emily is so thoughtful and brilliant. Colonel, you are a treasure to your nation. Thank you, Duchess.

    • @karenkratzer7036
      @karenkratzer7036 3 года назад +1

      Emily's parents must be so proud of her. She is an example for all young people to follow. Thank you for your service Colonel. The Duchess has a wonderful way about her in asking questions and really listening to what is said. Hope to see more videos of this nature.

  • @amab576
    @amab576 3 года назад +33

    Duchess of Cambridge did a great job in this lovely and warm interview. How amazing is Colonel Blum and Congratulations to Emily you should be proud.👍

  • @jennywilliams9594
    @jennywilliams9594 3 года назад +88

    This is wonderful! The Duchess is an amazing woman concentrating on what these people have to say and not on herself.

  • @abbymills7416
    @abbymills7416 3 года назад +530

    I feel like Kate would make an amazing teacher if she wasn’t a royal

  • @elainebines6803
    @elainebines6803 3 года назад +134

    Interesting fact, a poppy will pop up anywhere. Look at construction sites and coming through the concrete boulders is a poppy growing. Another reason that through adversity a poppy will grow under any conditions and survive. Another reason why the poppy is such an important symbol of our brave veterans 🥀

    • @paulaemartin674
      @paulaemartin674 3 года назад +14

      I believe after the allied solders had fought their way through fields in Flanders the next year due to the ground being turned over by the boots of the soldiers The fields Had thousands of poppies flowering ..

    • @annavannoni
      @annavannoni 3 года назад +3

      @@paulaemartin674 interesting fact. I never knew that.

    • @nancywilson2314
      @nancywilson2314 3 года назад +3

      What a lovely message you have shared Elaine. Thank you.

    • @andrewharald88
      @andrewharald88 3 года назад

      @@paulaemartin674 hi Paula

  • @marielfalk4537
    @marielfalk4537 3 года назад +19

    Oh my, Catherine is truly a noble lady. So grateful that she brought these two wonderful people's stories to light. Very inspiring!

  • @ritabroils6190
    @ritabroils6190 3 года назад +69

    I like the many observations of Remembrance Day leading up to Sunday's laying of wreaths. I like the multi generational look at the day and the place scouting has in the past and today.

  • @samiasultana44
    @samiasultana44 3 года назад +84

    This is so wonderful. I always enjoy the work William and Catherine do and get inspired by them

  • @anabellklopfer1885
    @anabellklopfer1885 3 года назад +10

    She is just such a fantastic woman. Authentic, caring, interested in people and their stories. You can feel that she loves her job and she is very dedicated to it.

  • @Jan-xg8rd
    @Jan-xg8rd 3 года назад +31

    Tears streaming down my face watching this. Catherine is such a naturally lovely lady and makes everyone feel relaxed. What a lovely gentleman and young lady too ❤️😊

  • @Emma-yi5mf
    @Emma-yi5mf 3 года назад +122

    Such a lovely video. It's so important to make sure that their stories and memories are preserved for future generations.

    • @carmelitajones7779
      @carmelitajones7779 3 года назад +12

      For sure. Notice what Colonel Blum said (paraphrasing), at his age, there's not many people to share memories with. Then he looks over at Emily. Prior to that, Colon Blum talks about the importance of the younger generations not forgetting. The sacrifice of our vets should not be forgotten; neither should the reason their sacrifice was asked to be made.

  • @jeanward7640
    @jeanward7640 3 года назад +19

    What a wonderful person Catherine is . She makes us want to puff out our chests and say “ I’m British “ . I do home HMQ. sees this . It wouldn’t hurt for another person to learn the proper way a REAL PRINCESS acts . It’s all about others with Catherine . She, together with William are doing a wonderful job with their children 🌹🇨🇦

  • @bonniefuller858
    @bonniefuller858 3 года назад +42

    What a beautiful video, what beautiful people...you are so lucky to have these three representatives to share generations of remembrance, and show why you are still such a beautiful Country, and beautiful Commonwealth...God Bless you all, God Bless Queen Elizabeth II🙏🏻🌹🙏🏻🇬🇧🇺🇸

  • @deborah85728
    @deborah85728 3 года назад +43

    Must confess I shed a tear or two remembering my Dad but am so glad I got to see the video what an inspiration it was !

  • @romaengholm
    @romaengholm 3 года назад +9

    Catherine makes a wonderful interviewer. She is emphatic, warmth and genuinely interested in people.

  • @verchip8
    @verchip8 3 года назад +28

    What a great initiative Princess Catherine hosted. It shows simpathy, honoring the heroes of the past, but also educate the young to follow their footsteps in a whole different battle ❤️

  • @mariahewes4723
    @mariahewes4723 3 года назад +9

    Catherine is so engaged with both of them. It's clear she has done her research for the organization and is interested in what they have to say. It's not about her. I love that about her.

  • @deanerdean58
    @deanerdean58 3 года назад +21

    That was very nice, seeing this young girl sitting and talking with this sweet man about remembering this part of history. They're both on the same page, just 80 years apart. Kate does a wonderful job at sewing it all together, to bring both their stories into one, and without needing to be in the story herself. She is a Natural at this, that's why she is so loved. She is very kind hearted .💕

  • @bendecidamyersoriordan9545
    @bendecidamyersoriordan9545 3 года назад +80

    Hermosa, elegante, toda una reina!

  • @ElizabethF2222
    @ElizabethF2222 3 года назад +11

    The Duchess of Cambridge has a remarkable ability to connect with people of all ages, young, old and in between. I'm so impressed with her and the Duke as well. She's about as perfect a representative of the Royal Family as you can get. Thank you Colonel Blum and Emily for sharing your stories! ❤️❤️

  • @leae2731
    @leae2731 3 года назад +26

    I cant imagine how hard it must been to fight in a war and loose a friend 😭😭😭

  • @christiekas
    @christiekas 3 года назад +11

    Beautiful. Anyone who lost family or a loved one fighting in the War knows their bravery are to be remembered forever. Well done to the Duchess of Cambridge, impeccable skills.

  • @sheilasinghal2922
    @sheilasinghal2922 3 года назад +25

    What a lovely video for Remembrance Day. The Colonel is amazing, and Emily is so poised and sweet. It's also clear that the Duchess of Cambridge genuinely likes talking to people and making actual connections. It all makes me proud to be a member of the Commonwealth. 😊

  • @kristinhall8435
    @kristinhall8435 3 года назад +2

    Simply class. The Royal family is so lucky to have this wonderful woman. She brings nothing but class and grace to the monarchy. God Bless you Catherine.

  • @heatherdeavalon
    @heatherdeavalon 3 года назад +34

    Never forget! I think I am better prepared for the situation we find ourselves in because of the generation that raised me. My grandparents were born in the 1890s and my parents were born during WWI. I can do anything!

  • @sandyschneider5175
    @sandyschneider5175 3 года назад +13

    What an absolute treasure you have in the Duchess! Such a genuine kind and caring woman.

  • @bonniewugsie5950
    @bonniewugsie5950 3 года назад +6

    A breath of fresh air. Very natural and I love how she connects with everyone she talks to.

  • @toniswift6058
    @toniswift6058 3 года назад +7

    Catherine was wonderful with Colonel Blum and Emily, she was so attentive to both of them whilst talking about Remembrance day and the scouts. What a real gem she is.

  • @jy3781
    @jy3781 3 года назад +3

    Didn’t say a thing about herself , made it all about them , that’s so nice and refreshing to see .

  • @nandinisharma3849
    @nandinisharma3849 3 года назад +45

    First of all i’d like to salute the Colonel and Emily, huge respect to them. Absolutely beautiful! And, love to see Duchess Catherine having meaningful conversations with such magnificent people, everything in this video is about them!

  • @molgau4218
    @molgau4218 3 года назад +15

    It's wonderful how the Duchess of Cambridge connected with people, and learned about them...she's good listener definitely.

  • @evacsarhaku464
    @evacsarhaku464 3 года назад +6

    I will have my grandson watch your episodes so he will learn history and get to know you Duchess and your family. We love you.

  • @corgilove8783
    @corgilove8783 3 года назад +11

    How lovely to bring the old and young together in remembrance. Catherine is so special as she gently brings out the best in people while she listens carefully and never invades their space🌹🌹

  • @lynnbarclay4241
    @lynnbarclay4241 3 года назад +45

    So wonderful and interesting to watch and be reminded how important our service members and volunteers are & their sacrifices. The sense of duty and community, stronger together than apart, is a lesson we should never forget as nations & families.

  • @nbmhelena
    @nbmhelena 3 года назад +8

    Remembrance is so important, respect for the legacy, respect for the ancestors. Well done Duchesse Catherine, may you live happily and harmoniously.

  • @lelleithmurray235
    @lelleithmurray235 3 года назад +14

    Duchess Katherine will make a kind and compassionate Queen one day. Love to hear those wartime stories!

  • @JJLaufeyson
    @JJLaufeyson 3 года назад +21

    Thank you for sharing your story Colonel Blum!
    Emily gives me hope for the young generation 😊

  • @rmb6550
    @rmb6550 3 года назад +32

    This will keep reminding the new generations that you should be thankful of the freedom that you have now to those people who risks their life for us. They never get to live long becoz they have to fight for ur freedom. 😥😥😥😥.. This is sooo amazing duchess.
    This reminds me of my grandparents. You will always be remember and u r such a great inspiration to our young people.

  • @willowjune24
    @willowjune24 3 года назад +10

    My eyes welled up with tears.. What I enjoy the most are the stories that Katherine and William bring out from people to share with the planet who wouldn’t otherwise hear them.
    Lest We Forget all those who sacrificed. Thank you Katherine.

  • @omegaknight01
    @omegaknight01 3 года назад +45

    Beautiful Kate!!! ❤️❤️❤️

  • @bfg1127
    @bfg1127 3 года назад +2

    As an American, I'm watching this with tears in my eyes. The past should never be forgotten and the future looks bright if there are more children like Emily. Thank you, Duchess, for bringing this to us.

  • @dicksongoh2496
    @dicksongoh2496 3 года назад +13

    I like the way she focus on others & not herself. She is a great listener. She gave the people she was engaging plenty of opportunities to talk & she listened intently with compassion. All three spoke freely to each other. Duchess of Cambridge has the ability to put those around her at ease. She is a team player & a great asset to the RF.
    Happy to see more of her😃😃😃

  • @clairey6407
    @clairey6407 3 года назад +15

    I'm so impressed by Emily. I can't believe she's only 10! I'm 36 and I remember my Dad (who passed away 9 years ago now) saying we must never forget the wars and just how many people were killed, and the huge efforts and sacrifices that were made that we benefit from to this day.

  • @rahatumaimah4785
    @rahatumaimah4785 3 года назад +72

    This is beautiful and heartwarming! ❤🥀

  • @JMMjamm
    @JMMjamm 3 года назад +11

    Everything about this interview is touching and important to keep those memories alive. Well done, Duchess of Cambridge. Lovely as ever and so compassionate.

  • @napoleon0884
    @napoleon0884 3 года назад +12

    the duchess has done it again 👏🏽👏🏽. thank you very much for colonel blum and his service, and emily, what a lovely little lady 👏🏽

  • @patriciastclair765
    @patriciastclair765 3 года назад +10

    Catherine, I love your confidence and grace, you are a huge asset to the Royal Family👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❤️

  • @artj2657
    @artj2657 3 года назад +5

    Duchess Catherine ALWAYS makes it about others! She is so genuine and caring.

  • @charmaccents6278
    @charmaccents6278 3 года назад +7

    This is so sweet. I have tears in my eyes. Thank you, Duchess Catherine, for being so benevolent and thank you to Colonel Blum and Emily for sharing your lives with us. I can't help but think Colonel Blum and the queen would be able to share many memories together and that talking to each other would do both of them good.

  • @anemicvampyre605
    @anemicvampyre605 3 года назад +7

    Their interaction with each other is so natural and respectful. Thank you!

  • @juliacatlin9576
    @juliacatlin9576 3 года назад +4

    Notice how she makes it about them not her. Pure class

  • @mandyarmitage9181
    @mandyarmitage9181 3 года назад +40

    What a lovely video everyone relaxed and sharing stories fantastic

  • @kathylabers3367
    @kathylabers3367 3 года назад +4

    I love how Catherine is so relatable and friendly with people. Makes people so relaxed and at ease.

  • @SeekingScripture
    @SeekingScripture 3 года назад +24

    This was a beautiful start to my day. Thank you. Lovely, lovely people.

  • @nmcn8347
    @nmcn8347 3 года назад +19

    Catherine you are a national treasure and an inspiration! 👑💐❤️

  • @mindakahn9964
    @mindakahn9964 3 года назад +7

    The genuine and engaging Catherine. Thank you Sir and Young Lady for your service. We used to have Poppy Day I. The US. I don’t know why it ended. The poppies were made by Veterans and supported Veterans.

  • @JumpAndStretch
    @JumpAndStretch 3 года назад +2

    The Duchess of Cambridge is wonderful in her empathy, kindness, sensitivity and in simply being present to the Colonel and Emily. Thank you, Catherine, for honoring them, drawing out their stories, truly listening and allowing the time and space for this to happen. You are truly doing a royals work.

  • @Just-Joyce4009
    @Just-Joyce4009 3 года назад +4

    The Dutchess of Cambridge is stunning....not pretentious...a very warm spirit...good interview❤

  • @anneas8532
    @anneas8532 3 года назад +2

    A day neither Colonel Blum, or Emily will never forget.
    Catherine interacted so naturally and beautifully. She has an inner grace and her kindness comes from within.

  • @alicja5697
    @alicja5697 3 года назад +10

    Brilliant, all three of the participants. And that’s the real Heroes and Royalty of our times.

  • @allexmarieholland9989
    @allexmarieholland9989 3 года назад +4

    I love how selfless our beautiful Duchess of Cambridge is. Catherine has every genuine beautiful attribute needed to be a beautiful Duchess, Queen in the making