Not necessarily. Engineers immediately have their minds jump to working on how to actually make this. One possibility would be for the metal to be a large belt instead of a cylinder.
Funny thing is - Rush-E was specifically intended to be unplayable by single pianist , but people still manage to do it 😂 BTW (my engineer brain speaking) I think it’s technically possible to develop and manufacture such device, but people won’t buy enough of them to justify development and manufacturing costs
@@lightsnmore6253 the fabric would not create the right sound. but you could do some electromechanical dohickey to make it play whatever. But it would require speciality tools and a lot of ingenunity.
@@GeirEivindMork small two state mechanism, similar to how braille practice boards work, for the pegs. Then use ramps to set the pegs, one set to reset them and another, controlled with servos or electromagnetic actuators, to set the correct ones to play.
Then you observe that, in order to fit all these notes, this cylinder must exist in non-euclidean space and come to the realisation that means, on a scale of 1-10 of how screwed you are, you have just hit at least a 14.
I can conceive of only one scenario in which this could exist in physical space: the cylinder is actually a really long belt that extends waaaay down, and this music box is actually like four stories tall. That's the only possible way Edit: I said this mainly as a joke but I appreciate the people smarter than me replying with actual possibilities
@@blockybeanz9924 or there could be something underneath the roll thingy popping little holes into the rod, adding new bumps to the cylinder, and flattening them out when it gets to the bottom.
Like a funfair organ. With the book it uses to play the notes (that is either driven by an engine or hand cranked) EDIT..... It exists on such an organ!!! ON 2 DIFFERENT SUCH ORGANS EVEN!!! ruclips.net/video/TY3BxZvS9bE/видео.html&ab_channel=ThijsHaenen (if the link doesn't work: search for "rush e belgian dance organ") ruclips.net/video/30Q-LWXdPDk/видео.html&ab_channel=%E3%80%90%E6%89%8B%E5%9B%9E%E3%81%97%E3%82%AA%E3%83%AB%E3%82%AC%E3%83%B3%E3%80%91YukiKojima-KojiKojiMoheji- (if this link doesn't work: search for "rush e streetorgan flute type")
OK this is so well rendered I thought it was an actual music box with an HD camera filming it for a solid 2 seconds and was wondering how they would pull off the song. (until you realise there is something off about the cylinder)
@@Wormwank I thought that for a second too because that's how "player Pianos" work but this has pegs and not holes like the player piano has. Also if you look to the right side of the cylinder you can see underneath it.
My late grandparents had a Regina Music Box. It stood about 4 feet tall and played disks like this one. My Great Grandpa Schrop bought it for his wife in 1907 when they got married. It cost him around $90 in 1907 which was a huge amount of money back then. When my great grandfather died in 1967 the music box was moved to my grandparents house. They used to play it for me. I was only 3 years old in 1967 so I wasn't even tall enough to see the top on it yet. But I just loved the sound. These are great memories that I have now that all my grandparents and parents have died.
At first I thought it was a real music box, then I realised the notes don't fit on the cylinder, thought it was some kind of band mechanism. Turns out it's just a 3D animation - the box looks too pristine (no scratches, dust, fingerprints) and the pins are not vibrating while they play the note.
This video shows Rush E being played on an instrument that few would have thought of, and while he came up with a variety of ideas himself, it also conveys his deep dedication to the instrument. I did it! I got 110 likes for the first time in my life! Thank you everyone!
Very, very clever. The only thing that gives it away, apart from the repeating pattern of imperfections in the drum surface, is the lack of vibration in the tines as they are released. Beautiful modelling.
It could be possible to have lots of popular songs on such devices! Just find a good so g, and CGI it like this! Deep Purple "Highway Star" would be an excellent choice!!
well, won't you tell us how you made this? did you use some kind of existing music box simulation, or did you actually model and animate this by yourself? is the sound simulated or just synchronized over it? i mean it's cool seeing it, but it'd be even more interesting to see how it works!
I was fooled for a good part of the video that this was somehow real, and then I saw the comments that said it was a render. Those are some major 3d modeling skills, keep it up.
I really need a "making-of" video for this. This is way more realistic than it has any business being while simultaneously being intuitively impossible.
imagine if we didn't invent ear pods and instead we carried a backpack with like automated instruments inside, and popular music artists would have to make their own tapes instead of like records n stuff
Many real musical boxes have accidentals left out of the scale intentionally, in order to provide as wide of a bass-to-treble note range as possible, while still working within the confines of a relatively few notes / teeth on the comb for a given small sized musical box. Obviously, the music arrangers who work for the musical box companies, have to modify all but the simplest or most diatonic tunes, to fit the available notes, to the point where sometimes they sound 'funny' or 'wrong'. Also, see my other comment reply (somewhere in here!) about larger musical boxes having multiple teeth tuned to the SAME NOTE to facilitate normal speed repetition, since the plucking action is actually a bit slow (unlike this computer generated video). So that is why serious musical boxes often have large combs with many teeth, is to: 1. make them more chromatic; and 2. enable them to repeat more notes more quickly.
The creep in my room in 2am: EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
This is physically impossible for a music box to play more than a few seconds of a melody but this is amazing. I want to hear more songs this way. Since you did Rush can you do tom sawyer and spirit of radio on it?
Theoretically, it would be possibly to have retractable pins in the drum, either electrically or pneumatically controlled, and run a microcontroller to extend and retract the pins at the correct time to have the music box play this, or any song. Though 3D animation was probably the easier and cheaper choice.
Rush E is a played out black-midi meme, but this is actually the first time I've seen it played, and it's not even by a real person, where it's really interesting to me. The original is black-midi so it's obviously just a jumble of notes that makes it impossible to humanly play, but this is the simplified very easily played version of the tune that everyone and their mom has played, but it's still very much impossible at face value. I don't know and don't care how it was done, it's the first time I've ever actually been entertained by Rush E.
I know this is 3D rendered, but if this can be physically possible, one way I can think of is that the bump would hold together via electromagnetic that can be released at will and some insertion taking place behind it.
I love how RUSH E is still alive, was alive and always be alive
my phone ringtone is RUSH E. just saying 😅
Some day it'll die
@@turuu Mine is Rush E 2
@@raulalves1887 no it wont LOL
@cameraproductions-en5fe Yes, it will.
Dude had me convinced for a few seconds that this was real and then I realized this would defy the laws of physics. Fantastic render.
Not necessarily. Engineers immediately have their minds jump to working on how to actually make this. One possibility would be for the metal to be a large belt instead of a cylinder.
@@ThatBoomerDude56 or a series of individual rods under a soft fabric on the cylinder that extend in a programmed fashion
Funny thing is - Rush-E was specifically intended to be unplayable by single pianist , but people still manage to do it 😂
BTW (my engineer brain speaking) I think it’s technically possible to develop and manufacture such device, but people won’t buy enough of them to justify development and manufacturing costs
@@lightsnmore6253 the fabric would not create the right sound. but you could do some electromechanical dohickey to make it play whatever. But it would require speciality tools and a lot of ingenunity.
@@GeirEivindMork small two state mechanism, similar to how braille practice boards work, for the pegs. Then use ramps to set the pegs, one set to reset them and another, controlled with servos or electromagnetic actuators, to set the correct ones to play.
Imagine that you're in a haunted house then you see a music box. Suddenly it starts playing by itself, but it plays rush e
Gotta be giant with how manny notes
Well, then your vocabulary will turn into Rush F real quick.
I would stay, the ghosts are probably super cool to hang with tbh, like casper and friends
Boss music
Then you observe that, in order to fit all these notes, this cylinder must exist in non-euclidean space and come to the realisation that means, on a scale of 1-10 of how screwed you are, you have just hit at least a 14.
I hope music boss sees this
Yea
Ya and nont
Yes😅
Yeah this is really good
E
I can conceive of only one scenario in which this could exist in physical space: the cylinder is actually a really long belt that extends waaaay down, and this music box is actually like four stories tall. That's the only possible way
Edit: I said this mainly as a joke but I appreciate the people smarter than me replying with actual possibilities
It’s a convEyEr bElt
That or it’s being 3D printed instantly and cutting off the notes that come in to reuse them
@@blockybeanz9924 or there could be something underneath the roll thingy popping little holes into the rod, adding new bumps to the cylinder, and flattening them out when it gets to the bottom.
True
It's likely a roll at the bottom that gets fed into the things as it goes, like a VHS tape
Dude amazing 3d modelling skills! It looks so realistic!
I know right?!
Wait, its fake?
Wait… it’s fake?????.
@@AceOfSpades13542 yes, you would need a giant cylinder to store that many notes
@@AceOfSpades13542of course! Did you really think that such a small roller can store so many notes?
most people: cool
me: WHAT IS THIS WITCHCRAFT
Aanimationbro
^
|. O. SPACE IT OUT
This is literally on my mind, ITS NOT ROTATING PROPERLY
GTAG GANG RISE UP!
Seriously though
You know, this actualy seems possibile to play with an actual music box.
A different type of music box sure, but still
Or just a regular one and a really really big drum
or change the drum into a conveyer that has bumps
Like a funfair organ. With the book it uses to play the notes (that is either driven by an engine or hand cranked)
EDIT..... It exists on such an organ!!! ON 2 DIFFERENT SUCH ORGANS EVEN!!!
ruclips.net/video/TY3BxZvS9bE/видео.html&ab_channel=ThijsHaenen (if the link doesn't work: search for "rush e belgian dance organ")
ruclips.net/video/30Q-LWXdPDk/видео.html&ab_channel=%E3%80%90%E6%89%8B%E5%9B%9E%E3%81%97%E3%82%AA%E3%83%AB%E3%82%AC%E3%83%B3%E3%80%91YukiKojima-KojiKojiMoheji- (if this link doesn't work: search for "rush e streetorgan flute type")
Marble machine next
Let's get Wintergaten on this
I feel like in 10 years the RUclips algorithm is going to bring us together again...
I'll try to remember that
;)
Me too, maybe we'll be part of history XD@@genialergandalf7044
Please reply to this comment in 10 years time. This is my time capsule. I just met Raquel, I’m a year into working at the vets home.
Uhh, i like doritos
ye see yall in 10 years
Other people’s music boxes: peaceful tranquility
My music box: *_A N X I E T Y_*
😂
OK this is so well rendered I thought it was an actual music box with an HD camera filming it for a solid 2 seconds and was wondering how they would pull off the song. (until you realise there is something off about the cylinder)
Same
Couldn't the film around the roll just go down instead of around? Like a vertical conveyer belt
@@Wormwank I thought that for a second too because that's how "player Pianos" work but this has pegs and not holes like the player piano has. Also if you look to the right side of the cylinder you can see underneath it.
It doesn't need to be rendered. He also could have alot of those zylinders, swapped them out and cut all videos together.
@@fenrillratz9890 Then that is some very smooth cutting.
The lighting, texture mapping, bump mapping, and shaders used on this are really impressive. It looks super realistic
So this is actually an animation!
I was wondering how pegs would even pop up
I thought it was a really long metal paper thing that was spinning inside the music box
@@XizyMSMsame
@xizy_real, theoretically, it would be possible to design a system with an extremely long sheet that goes in one end out the other
@@Finn_the_Cat I think you can do one with paper sheets?
It's very refreshing seeing the notes sliding upwards as the music plays.
A music box never fails to make songs beautiful, nostalgic, and hypnotic with a touch of haunting. Even if it's something like Rush E. Beautiful work!
Martin from Wintergatan even made an actual digital VST instrument from a music box - it's called Speldosa, published by Klevgrand :)
That's very beautiful ! The most beautiful version of Rush E I've ever listened to.
0:23 sounds like a teror song
That is exactly what I was thinking too 😂
Ikr😂😂😂
I was thinking playing this at my brothers door to wake him up in the morning LOL
Fr bro
It sounds like the start to This is Halloween!
This display for sheet music is ingenious. I'm glad it's not just a still image like other channels do!
That's a pretty clean render, and/or composite. I'm impressed.
My late grandparents had a Regina Music Box. It stood about 4 feet tall and played disks like this one. My Great Grandpa Schrop bought it for his wife in 1907 when they got married. It cost him around $90 in 1907 which was a huge amount of money back then. When my great grandfather died in 1967 the music box was moved to my grandparents house. They used to play it for me. I was only 3 years old in 1967 so I wasn't even tall enough to see the top on it yet. But I just loved the sound. These are great memories that I have now that all my grandparents and parents have died.
Where is sheet music boss.he needs to see this
Edit:thank you guys for the likes!
Why does every song that has a music box cover sound sad?
minor overtones I think
oh ok
I disagree
This one ironically doesn't sound sad to me
guys let’s not start world war 3 in here ok?
So a music box is basically an automated kalimba? Cool.
A kalimba a manually operated music box. :D
0:53 -ears here :(
the entire time I was waiting for a little E to show up, the ending warmed my soul
0:39 hits a G major Chord instead of an E major Chord which is wrong 😮
I don’t think the music box is capable of handling sharps and flats.
I noticed that too it added a creepy effect
for anyone confused: This is a 3D render, like all the other videos on the channel also.
At first I thought it was a real music box, then I realised the notes don't fit on the cylinder, thought it was some kind of band mechanism. Turns out it's just a 3D animation - the box looks too pristine (no scratches, dust, fingerprints) and the pins are not vibrating while they play the note.
This video shows Rush E being played on an instrument that few would have thought of, and while he came up with a variety of ideas himself, it also conveys his deep dedication to the instrument.
I did it! I got 110 likes for the first time in my life! Thank you everyone!
Who let ChatGPT online 💀
blud talks like an AI 💀
@@AkramsChannel 'so many positive reviews'
This thing can be played on anything BUT a piano xd
This is a 3D render dimwit
This has just added to my belief that anything played on a music box instantly sound more creepy
0:19 why does this sound like a samsung phone ringtone
Lol
Lol
Lol
Lol
Lol
Shouldn’t the barrel loop back? How there are more pegs popping up?
magic
I assume it's been made by blender animations
Magic of 3D animation
Ghost be like: what is this music?!? 💀🥶
Very, very clever. The only thing that gives it away, apart from the repeating pattern of imperfections in the drum surface, is the lack of vibration in the tines as they are released. Beautiful modelling.
Wow i love this 3d animation
It could be possible to have lots of popular songs on such devices! Just find a good so g, and CGI it like this! Deep Purple "Highway Star" would be an excellent choice!!
Man the song lacks the 5 black keys, you know that?
ofc he does
It’s an animation
@@TheBellowfishGuy its missing some accidentals though
@@Flappy09 yeah
Music boxes don’t use accidentals most of the time.
The "Rush E" at the end was the cherry on top
me: my music box plays twinkle twinkle
Beeano: my music plays rush E
me: i have met a true giga chad
When it said "E", I really felt that.
The most beautiful form of my anxiety!😊
2:07 one solution is to bring fully developed Sukukna in yuji itadori and sukuna and 4 other sukunas to play this
well, won't you tell us how you made this?
did you use some kind of existing music box simulation, or did you actually model and animate this by yourself? is the sound simulated or just synchronized over it?
i mean it's cool seeing it, but it'd be even more interesting to see how it works!
Is it Animated ?!!
So realistic and accurate..
Great work !!
how?
impressed me
animation but still very cool indeed
The perfect song to help fall asleep to.
1:05 does anyone else hear Minecraft doors
No
I was fooled for a good part of the video that this was somehow real, and then I saw the comments that said it was a render.
Those are some major 3d modeling skills, keep it up.
Me thinking that this was a real music box: 💀
This is such a nice render that I didn't even realize it wasn't a real music box.
*me sleeping calmly at night and hears this* “ WHO’S THERE?” *screams louder than anything in the world *
This is the sort of thing that is gonna pop up in everyone’s recommendations in a decade
how?
impressive!!
Imagine walking into a haunted house and a music box starts playing rush e. And every time it hits an e you hear a footstep.
this video deserves more likes
Nah, it's no real music box
Fr
Its new
@@markus1351 that's ok. takes time to do an animation like that.
@@markus1351 That doesn't mean he doesn't deserve the likes...
I really need a "making-of" video for this.
This is way more realistic than it has any business being while simultaneously being intuitively impossible.
Tbh, I was waiting for the music box to explode
bro for a sec I thought it was real😂 but nice
imagine if we didn't invent ear pods and instead we carried a backpack with like automated instruments inside, and popular music artists would have to make their own tapes instead of like records n stuff
When the fairground organ never died out and it surpassed the record player, I guess
Is any other pitch-perfect person cringing at the lack of half notes this is playing? Love this song. Keep up the good work!
Many real musical boxes have accidentals left out of the scale intentionally, in order to provide as wide of a bass-to-treble note range as possible, while still working within the confines of a relatively few notes / teeth on the comb for a given small sized musical box. Obviously, the music arrangers who work for the musical box companies, have to modify all but the simplest or most diatonic tunes, to fit the available notes, to the point where sometimes they sound 'funny' or 'wrong'.
Also, see my other comment reply (somewhere in here!) about larger musical boxes having multiple teeth tuned to the SAME NOTE to facilitate normal speed repetition, since the plucking action is actually a bit slow (unlike this computer generated video).
So that is why serious musical boxes often have large combs with many teeth, is to: 1. make them more chromatic; and 2. enable them to repeat more notes more quickly.
The creep in my room in 2am:
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EE
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
and the alarm in my room at 6:00 a.m.
. Eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee f e d e a c
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
E
E
E
E
E
E
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Fun fact, fast repeated notes on a music box will either skip, sound flat or fail to resonate.
Thats why slow songs are commonly used.
I assume this is a simulation? Cause I love it
Well... our entire reality is a simulation... so... we love it anyway :D
@@WalterLoggetti no it isn't. Get over yourself. Fun thought experiment, but ultimately a nothing burger.
@@t_c5266 Well... i know...
But sometimes I enjoy nothing burgers :P
It sounds so beautiful and tender
Rush e: 😰
Crush e: 💀
If you watch closely the nubs pop out, you can see little rings on the nice looking smooth surface
Bro, how did the little dots on the Golden Cylinder change spot I bet it’s fake 1:27
It's video editing.
It might be animated
No shit sherlock
Yes, it is.
@@BricksAndBots47it is cuz music boxes can’t be that long. Because it would just repeat
SO LOVELY
Tại sao không có bài doraemon? 😮
Супер получилось, однозначно лайк за колосальную заморочку,
Ah yes, finally, what I have been looking for, the forbidden music box that will haunt me for the rest of my life.
Honestly this is the best version of rush E I’ve ever heard
Where did you get it
I think that it's an animation. You can see that the notes don't cycle/loop even though the cylinder keeps rotating.
@@SMT_NVS good idea
It could be true if that cylinder is turning a stripe with all the notes on it
@@ScratcherReal22it’s not real
Likely it’s an animation or a website that lets you play custom music
This is physically impossible for a music box to play more than a few seconds of a melody but this is amazing. I want to hear more songs this way. Since you did Rush can you do tom sawyer and spirit of radio on it?
I'd rather this than some slow creepy music playing
Yeag
Great quality animation 😀😁👍
Wow
Theoretically, it would be possibly to have retractable pins in the drum, either electrically or pneumatically controlled, and run a microcontroller to extend and retract the pins at the correct time to have the music box play this, or any song. Though 3D animation was probably the easier and cheaper choice.
What AI did you use to make this
It’s not AI? Why would it be AI? It’s video editing.
@@newsuperbowserworldit's an animation, actually.
@@BricksAndBots47 proof?
@@newsuperbowserworldproof its not an animation?
@@ferrarifan1655 no? I just think it’s video editing. I’d take proof for both arguments.
This is my favorite version of this song so far
At 0:22 it sounds like piano horror
I watched this in 2X, it’s hilarious!
Fake, you cant have 60000 notes on something that can only have 30.
no
Clever editing. Perhaps you've heard of it? /lh (lighthearted) /t (teasing)
Oh wow no way man thanks for protecting us from fake news(clever editing)
How about it being just like a long pill shaped strip on like a reel or sumthin
i think its animated
Please some explain to me how is the drum making full rotation and still making new notes how?
This is being 3D animated and not real... obviously...
Beautiful
Most listen-able version I've heard, as a bonus!
I wonder what it would look like if the music box's play speed adjusted to the dynamic tempo of the song, rather than the notes' spacing changing
There's also the programmable music box that you feed with a ream of cards.
Imagine playing this in a dnd horror setting as a monster chases your players
I wonder how much energy would need to be stored in the coil to be able to play this full piece
Rush E is a played out black-midi meme, but this is actually the first time I've seen it played, and it's not even by a real person, where it's really interesting to me. The original is black-midi so it's obviously just a jumble of notes that makes it impossible to humanly play, but this is the simplified very easily played version of the tune that everyone and their mom has played, but it's still very much impossible at face value. I don't know and don't care how it was done, it's the first time I've ever actually been entertained by Rush E.
I theorise that the music box employs a hyper cylinder. It has extra volume in the 4th dimension.
This is a masterpiece
Im going to use this as my new sleeping music😊
Ok
how does that cinlender have so many of those bumps if it’s so small
close your eyes and then here this evergreen musical melody...
You can have a conveyor that pulls a long sheet that plays the music that is hidden from view
I know this is 3D rendered, but if this can be physically possible, one way I can think of is that the bump would hold together via electromagnetic that can be released at will and some insertion taking place behind it.
I wont lie the CGI is great keep it up