They did well considering how difficult this song is. They even lowered the pitch because SHINee's original version is high. The choreo is hard to pull off as well because it needs all members to be really tight and well-coordinated. If they had more time they would have won. I wish the show chose a less intense SHINee song because Sherlock is really a high caliber song even for veterans.
I may have to disagree because from other shows like produce 101 or The Unit, the contestants don't do really well with SHINee's Juliette and Replay too. Idk why but contestants always feel the weight despite any of SHINee's songs and i feel so sad. They just want to perform popular song that is considered 'easy' to them without taking the challange to perform better. I mean, i know they are working hard but are they taking up enough challange?
I think they still couldn't win cause they didn't lost for their performance they lost because they didn't have popular trainees in their team. These boys are the average group even other trainees laughed at them and felt like it's easy to win against them. Despite all of this they showed an incredible performance. If the judging system be more objective they'd surely win this stage
though it's hard they still put up a fight which makes me really proud. Youngwon did his best leading his team and efforts weren't wasted, they did very well. sadly, this team lack supporters :(
I've seen several groups cover Shinees songs with the choreography included it and they either take them down in pitch, the rap instead, some just don't sing it or they do this and have a kid cover it, lol
Shinee's song is hard to cover as ever, especially Sherlock .. But, this Nineteen try their best and make this song feel fresher... Bring back memories, Shawol.. Thankyu for this performance
People these days only look up on recent popular songs specially from Bts and Exo hence people careless about the unit's performance although it's clear that the lost teams deserves better. I thought Mirotic would've won )':
I agree. growl and fake love had advantage because of the popularity of the song and even visited by the members of bts and exo. I am both exol and army btw
You know, I can accept Growl team winning because both teams were close in terms of performance and vocals, but that blowout seemed unfair. MBC surely knew with Growl having more popular trainees and being a more popular song (it's the song that made EXO blow up exponentially) that voters were already biased. They should have requested one of the SHINee members to act as a special director. It would have at least made more fans show their support, because so far with all the special directors that have appeared, their teams have won (VIXX, BTS, EXO, we can even count Yunho for the performance team). Of course, these teams all had popular trainees too with strong performances. It just seems ludicrous that Sherlock team got 174 votes and were the lowest in overall voting, when Fiction team, though vocally amazing, made a mistake and the other rap break was lacking, and still earned over 300 votes.
All I can say is, let the international fans vote too. I have watch different survivals both Korea and China and for the first time I can't sleep because of dissapointment.. This team deserve more than this..
The audience just didn’t like the performance I guess, nothing to cry about. It happens and it’s a Korean survival show, y’all cannot expect much more lol. Some votes surprise me but others don’t now. Plus as soon as I saw the teams that were together in each one, I already knew the results unless a trainee had a miracle moment that made netizens fall in love with em...Fake Love had nothing but popular trainees because the audience wanted it that way ( they still did great tho), same with Growl, although Fiction had popular ones too. It’s always up in the air with there shows 😑 plus I hated the pairing for each live versus stage.. Sherlock vs Growl? Be Mine vs Fiction? mirotic vs FL? It was basically still vocal vs dance to me.
When they lost by SO MUCH, I flew into a rage. They put so much work into it and I felt like the two performances weren't so far apart in quality-- they were both so good. To lose 147 to like 400 made me angry.
No matter how good this team is ,in the end its a popularity show and most of the trainees of this group is underrated and less popular. They had no chance against a team who cover a bts and exo song.
What do you expect from a popularity show. This group actually did really good but on the other teams the team mates are grouped from the more popular trainees and was singing bts and exo song. They had no chance even with a very good performance
In the end it still a popularity show... It's not about the song or who originally sung it nor the performance but it's about the high ranking trainees... so sad... but here I am still gonna watch it because I know everyone has a chance to shine because they are all talented it is just that the time is not for all the trainees...
Yassss... absolutely correct... to be honest I'm really bitter bacause I'm rooting for the Mirotic Team.. and in MY OPINION.. for the record "MY OPINION" they have the best performance, vocal wise, dance wise, rap wise with the addition of visual and fanchant... unfortunately most of the on site voters have different opinion than mine...
@@jhoelf9315 plus why on earth MBC uploaded the other performances days ahead than this performance. Atleast they could give this team same exposure online for the fans to vote for Sherlock team but nah, they choose to upload Bts song and even uploaded teaser about Suga and Suga training the already popular trainees and all. I just gave up . First they remove Jay Chang because foreigner, used Eddie for ratings and controversy but throw him aside after that and now theyre on the way eliminating Christian.
You have a point on that matter... but I don't know why I still want to continue watching the show... I think because everyone deserves it... They are all talented, it just that some are still lacking compare to other and some are more handsome than other and for some... it is not just their time... but I think being more fair for the part of MBC is also a factor... let me just correct you... It's JHope who trained the Fake Love trainees 😀
I just stop watching this show. Its very unfair that they obviously team up the higher ranked trainees on the other teams ,plus those teams are singing ultra popular songs from bts and exo. Shinee is popular but nowadays everyone is all about exo and bts and Sherlock is way harder to perform in comparison to other groups. In the end this is all about popularity. The other team would still win even doing mediocrity because theyre more popular.
To be honest the overall vibe and performance of this was better than Growl. This deserved to win in my opinion. Popularity always wins though, how sad.
No,growl is better. Im not being unfair. But their voice sucks. The dance performance is also lacking. They need to be sharp a bit. That's what i see in these group.
@@ladygee4659 No. Sherlock team has a more stable vocals compared to Exo. Dancing wise, only Christian is a standout in this one. Not that Exo team is any better. The winner was determined by who has the most fans, not by how they performed.
@@ladygee4659 Sherlock team was most definitely better in terms of vocals and for dancing both seemed equal. Both teams lacked a bit of presence and sharpness for dancing. But overall Sherlock was better.
It would be great if Taemin coached these boys like Kai coached the Growl Team..... It's like Kai Vs Taemin... Exo Vs SHINee ... Both my absolute favourite groups and I feel both the groups performed equally well ❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️
THIS GROUP GREAT, I MEAN THE SONG IS REALLY HARD ITSELF LIKE JONGHYUN PART, THE WHOLE DANCE IS FREAKING DIFFICULT. AND THIS GRUP JUST DOING, THUMBS UP 👍🏻
The fact that they lost was so unfair. I was MAD mad. This perfomance was super good in every way and they executed it amazingly even though it’s a super hard song to perform. When everyone found them as the easy target I was boiling. They really all deserved better.
In other survival shows (beside The Unit/Mix Nine maybe) they almost never give trainees perform difficult songs by e.g. SHINee, BEAST, INFINITE or TVXQ (not counting the early/debiut songs like in P101) as if they were afraid the trainees will suck and the songs won't bring a lot of people to watch it (which is BS). Yet this show was ballsy enough to give these boys Fiction (which demands a lot of vocal control and harmonies) and Sherlock (which is ridiculously high and has hard choreo) and Mirotic (hard vocals and that freakin' high note). It's like they are saying: "Hey, you want to be singers? Then this is the level you should be to succeed in this industry" and that's how it supposed to be. Don't get me wrong, it's not like songs by other artists are bad, it's just in my opinion these shows should at least teach trainees something and the best way is to learn difficult things so they can get better in the future :)
SHINee songs aren't easy to cover, especially Sherlock! It's a very high leveled performance and needs sharp movements and quite some energy behind their dance moves. They did very well for such a difficult dance and song. I was missing a bit of the raw energy but it is a song that is even hard for veterans to accomplish. They really did their best here, continue fighting! :D
They did really well plus that boy who wear red blazer was so good because he still did his best even his mic fall off. Dude respect. Both group are so good. Growl and Sherlock
the fact that they pulled it off soo well even tho Sherlock is soo difficult just proves that they are really great. And Youngwon performed so well even with that incident of his mic, no lies they should've won!!
Hats down the best performance put of all 6!!!! Sherlock and Mirotic teams are like debuted groups already. They both don’t deserve that low number of votes, esp Sherlock Team. They were sooo good
1:20 HIS NAME IS LIM YOUNSEO. Do you know he is very good at singing?! he is adorable and handsome at once❤️ You can check the performance of Exo 'Love Me Right' song on this 'under nineteen' show too. the sound is very good! he really shines there! Trust me. please support him! don't let his talents be wasted😭😭😭💗
This 10-year shawol noona approves of these kids' perf. They did a good job of covering the song that 90% of the other trainees don't want to pick due to its difficulty. Good job kids!!
Its okay even though they did not win this round. They delivered a good performance and Im satisfied with it. What is not okay is the GAP between their SCORES. I really felt sorry for Sherlock team :(. They didnt deserved the score that they got. They deserve higher than a hunded plus.
marvioxious1989 not yet. I didn't see the rank. Omo! Why? I feel bad for the Sherlock team. I'm worried what if they will eliminate? :'( If I could vote, I will vote and help them.
@@elleanypost Christian is like rank #40 from 40 contestants. If you dont realize this team has the lower rank boys. Even they did better, they had no chance to win against the Exo Growl team with more popular members plus its an Exo song. Exo is like the talk of the nation this days because of kai*Jennie. Sherlock is i mean was famous but yeah . Ma boi Christian is in danger😭. By the way search for the scores, its a heart breaker.
marvioxious1989 I'm scared to find out. I'm a Christian fan cause I see and feel his passion. Why? If this team will do EXO song or BTS song maybe their rank will go higher. MBC is a snake. I feel bad! 😭😭😭 I hope for a miracle. Maybe Koreans doesn't like Christian or the foreigner members except Wumuti. Wumuti is popular.
I'm so disappointed, they did so well and worked so hard (ik the other groups did too) I really wanted them to win or at least have a little more votes because they really deserved it.
SHINee's quality songs are no jokes. Jonghyun's highnote too! No one can beat him. Anw the one who did Jonghyun's highnote with grey suit looks super adorable 😂
I'm sorry this was kinda hard to watch... Technical difficulties and the inconsistency in singing :/ But Younseo's voice was really really good and he's still my vocal pick! ❤️ Oh and Christian did so well omg I love his parts!
@@arlyncabz6578 I obviously know SHINee lol and what your saying is true. Im not hating on the group tho Sherlock is a hard song but this wasnt as good as people are making it seem its very inconsistent with the singing and the dance could have been alot stronger. I feel like people are sugar coating all of this which they shouldnt people should say the truth.
I totally relate! I Love Love Love Sherlock, but SHINee does so well in owning their songs that I can't be entirely satisfied with other group's covers. Though what makes me really really sad about this performance is their lack of supporters. Obviously it can affect how a performer does on stage. If probably there more popular members in the group, they'd have much chance since they're opponent is dancing an already 'overused' song. (Just in case this becomes an issue, I love growl but with so many covers, it's difficult for them to be unique)
@donna lim yes exactly like did sherlock team even get a mentor? Will we ever know? Like they really edited so much out I don't think it was fair and that. 12yr old really doing his best to hold his own too. I feel like a lot of fans just voted for Kai, not purely the teams. Like I'm sure they love people on the team too but kai sealed the deal for them
I just cant when Kim YoungWon keep blaming his self for his team's lost 😭 everybody, he manage that mic problem like a pro! He keep smiling and hit that notes and yes.. SLAY US GOOD!! please save KIM YOUNG WON !! And this team! Who performance this song like a pro with stable voices and amazing dance! 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤❤❤
tbh i don’t think its the “famous song” that made the other group win. its the MEMBERS lots of high rankings ones are there :/ and the lower ranking ones are in this... they had a good performance here so its really sad that they’re not recognized for it
The dance formation is really difficult. But i love the can perfome so well. And their voice stabil. But i'm sorry to say they didn't have the power that this song have. Just my opinion. Can i know who is the little one cutie and how old he is? I'm uwuing over him
I quite agree with you but still looking at it positively cuz some of them aren't trainees or trained for a long time. Shinee did this with charisma, hard work, skills and talent and there'll be the time for this boys to come to that level. The fact that they did this stage is already an achievement. I believe this group did the best along with Mirotic team. They're the most formidable of all stages presented.
I feel bad for the kids in this team. Everyone is openly looking down on them, they wanted Team Sherlock as their opponent coz this team seems "easy" in their eyes (especially when team Growl shouting in glee when they knew they were up against Sherlock). Youngwoon has every right to get mad at them. He's right when he said "they're looking down on us just because we have many trainees at the bottom of the charts". My heart is aching when he said that, coz there's exactly where Dahan & Christian position was ㅠㅠ My TakTakTak Duo ㅠㅠ But im proud the manage to prove to the others that they're not someone that people can easily look down upon :') Kudos to Youngwoon, handling his mic drop like a pro..
Honestly he's been proving everyone in each mission on how good and well balanced he is! Such a shame how underrated he is (this coming from a non-fan of christian) 😣
Considering them covering one of SHINee's high vocal and dance beat song, we should applaud these boys for covering it. Honestly when the group was divided itself I knew the ones who would win. The grouping of trainees was such that the popular ones were in fake love team and growl team. The grouping was bad, in addition to it, the songs are of the group which are popular as of now. So I would say it was unfair from the beginning. Looks like the channel already decided whom they wanted to debut. Anyways, hatsoff to the boys for trying extremely a difficult song (this was one of the most difficult one out of those whole bunch). Yes Armys I understand fake love choreography is very intricate but you can't deny the vocals and the dance beat are tiring in this song. And that guy with red suit handling his mic had a very professional mindset.
@@Written_in_the_Starss yeah exactly. It was a marketing tactics used for more online votes. The channel at least should have been fair in that aspect. With those two guys visiting automatically the votes would be to the BTS and EXO team. It was such a dirty play by the channel...
I wasn’t expecting much from this team Because Shinee’ s songs are very high pitched and also the choreo is really hard but they managed to do a good job. Also the guy in red first caught my eyes during love me right he has very good expressions in both performances. 0:25 His mic dropped but he handled it professionally, I am impressed boy 👏
There's no my biases here, but they're the BEST tbh like, damn. Perfect vocals, perfect dances, there're so many points that people can remember, like dahan's back flip(?), yechan's scream, the dances, yechan's jump, etc etc etc, this is like SO UNFAIR
Ellos debieron haber ganado, realmente es muy frustrante el no poder votar también, ellos se esforzaron demasiado, interpretaron correctamente la canción, el sentimiento fue increíble, de verdad es decepcionante ver que no fueron ellos los ganadores. Dejaron atrás y por mucho a la otra unidad.
i think everyone is misunderstanding tbh. this group performance is GREAT no doubt about that. the members in the other group however are high in the ranks. just because they have a “famous song” doesn’t mean they’ll automatically win. from what i learned from produce 101, its the members’ ranks that make the votes, no matter what song they pick.
@@Written_in_the_Starss lol. Its not that 'singing bts and exo songs' they won because the members of that unit are popular and already have their own fanbase. ARMY and EXOL are nothing to do with those votes.
@@Written_in_the_Starss they become a group because fans give votes to "people with songs that suit them. are they wrong when they become a group? if they have to choose themselves, most of them will definitely choose bts songs
i think not only me who cant move on with this program. but watch it for see what that nowdays people judge the others. dont use populority but look for quality. Merotic n Sherlock it flawless performance (hard to cover up), must know that is LEGEND . until know i dont know which part that make Growl n Fake Love more point? its because handsome guys? think it nitizen
i just wish they would've just shown the performance properly instead of focusing on his bloody mic falling off.. i mean, they did so well! the editing pausing and slowing down the performance was so distracting they could've added it in after the performance like they did for growl.. tsk!
*The show should've understand that giving them SHINee's Sherlock out of ALL their legendary songs is so hard to perform and only gods can do such high powerful vocals and choreo* I mean I believe in their team but even they had a hard time practicing it bcuz the song was too difficult :'( good thing it went well
![[HOT] Growl's stage, 언더 나인틴 20190112](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AAxb3phv9Vk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HOT] Growl's stage, 언더 나인틴 20190112](/img/tr.png)
![SHINee - "Sherlock" Dance Cover [UNDER NINETEEN Ep 11]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/j05pPeJiiR0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[통한의 통편집] 언더나인틴 - 이예찬 디렉터 진로상담](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/M2ez_ZU717c/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Stage mix] 아스트로 (ASTRO) - All Night (전화해) 교차편집](/img/1.gif)
They did well considering how difficult this song is. They even lowered the pitch because SHINee's original version is high. The choreo is hard to pull off as well because it needs all members to be really tight and well-coordinated. If they had more time they would have won. I wish the show chose a less intense SHINee song because Sherlock is really a high caliber song even for veterans.
Yess, because the original one it's too high but they did it well
I may have to disagree because from other shows like produce 101 or The Unit, the contestants don't do really well with SHINee's Juliette and Replay too. Idk why but contestants always feel the weight despite any of SHINee's songs and i feel so sad. They just want to perform popular song that is considered 'easy' to them without taking the challange to perform better. I mean, i know they are working hard but are they taking up enough challange?
Even minho is asking if they can sing on lower key 🤣🤣🤣
Stan SHINee Stan Talent
@@suryanasalomimatakupan7476 I laughed too
hard at this.....I mean if Minho is asking to bring the key down lol
I think they still couldn't win cause they didn't lost for their performance they lost because they didn't have popular trainees in their team. These boys are the average group even other trainees laughed at them and felt like it's easy to win against them. Despite all of this they showed an incredible performance. If the judging system be more objective they'd surely win this stage
I love how youngwon is very professional with his mic pack falling off, please debutt
Splitting Banana 👍👍👍
U’re doing well young won, I’ll always support u 👏👏
YEAH!!! I was so impressed with how he kept it together omg
Yess!!
👍👍👍👍👏👏👏👏
though it's hard they still put up a fight which makes me really proud. Youngwon did his best leading his team and efforts weren't wasted, they did very well. sadly, this team lack supporters :(
true
Go... Sherlock Team... You did a great job...
Kim Kun vocal get better :) i'am so proud
Agree.. its a shame when the score pop up.. i just cant 😭
i feel really hurt about their scores, i just feel very sad about them 😭😭😢
Its so funnily cute that nobody could hit Jonghyuns notes so they made the youngest one did it cause his voice hasnt cracked 😂😂
Kye Huann 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Thats actually really clever since a child voice is really high pitch
Yeah, he's looks so cute when sing jonghyun part... 😂
He’s a kid! But he has so much talent! 😫😫
I've seen several groups cover Shinees songs with the choreography included it and they either take them down in pitch, the rap instead, some just don't sing it or they do this and have a kid cover it, lol
Shinee's song is hard to cover as ever, especially Sherlock .. But, this Nineteen try their best and make this song feel fresher... Bring back memories, Shawol.. Thankyu for this performance
Team Sherlock and Mirotic both deserved better. Those votes they both got ain't fückin it and no one can tell me otherwise 👑✨
People these days only look up on recent popular songs specially from Bts and Exo hence people careless about the unit's performance although it's clear that the lost teams deserves better. I thought Mirotic would've won )':
@@minty2642 same! For me Mirotic was the most flawless out of all the performances. It was perfect to say the least 👑✨👏
I agree!! I love all the songs and performances, but Sherlock and Mirotic were two of the best performances in my opinion.
literally mirotic and sherlock are my top two performances for this mission :(( anD FFS THEYRE IN THE BOTTOM TWO?¿
I agree. growl and fake love had advantage because of the popularity of the song and even visited by the members of bts and exo. I am both exol and army btw
You know, I can accept Growl team winning because both teams were close in terms of performance and vocals, but that blowout seemed unfair. MBC surely knew with Growl having more popular trainees and being a more popular song (it's the song that made EXO blow up exponentially) that voters were already biased. They should have requested one of the SHINee members to act as a special director. It would have at least made more fans show their support, because so far with all the special directors that have appeared, their teams have won (VIXX, BTS, EXO, we can even count Yunho for the performance team). Of course, these teams all had popular trainees too with strong performances. It just seems ludicrous that Sherlock team got 174 votes and were the lowest in overall voting, when Fiction team, though vocally amazing, made a mistake and the other rap break was lacking, and still earned over 300 votes.
WWLD rt :/
You're absolutely right.
This show is a joke.
All I can say is, let the international fans vote too. I have watch different survivals both Korea and China and for the first time I can't sleep because of dissapointment.. This team deserve more than this..
The audience just didn’t like the performance I guess, nothing to cry about. It happens and it’s a Korean survival show, y’all cannot expect much more lol. Some votes surprise me but others don’t now. Plus as soon as I saw the teams that were together in each one, I already knew the results unless a trainee had a miracle moment that made netizens fall in love with em...Fake Love had nothing but popular trainees because the audience wanted it that way ( they still did great tho), same with Growl, although Fiction had popular ones too. It’s always up in the air with there shows 😑 plus I hated the pairing for each live versus stage.. Sherlock vs Growl? Be Mine vs Fiction? mirotic vs FL? It was basically still vocal vs dance to me.
When they lost by SO MUCH, I flew into a rage. They put so much work into it and I felt like the two performances weren't so far apart in quality-- they were both so good. To lose 147 to like 400 made me angry.
i’m still pissed tbh
Team Sherlock is still the BEST! 💖
Sherlock is very hard song but they're did it well ❤good job guys ini know this song is really high note and the dance was so strong
I feel like Christian was the best foreigner that was able to adapt to this show despite not knowing the language ❤️
true but i think its more likely.. Suren who adapted best
cmpotato i also love suren hes also doing great!
cmpotato wait what's the nationality of suren?
elleee hes chinese
Christian and Oh Dahan made the formation by saying "tak tak tak" lolll
No matter how good this team is ,in the end its a popularity show and most of the trainees of this group is underrated and less popular. They had no chance against a team who cover a bts and exo song.
The number of votes they recieved got me like :'((((
ikr. it's almost feel like the audiences were mocking them :(
What do you expect from a popularity show. This group actually did really good but on the other teams the team mates are grouped from the more popular trainees and was singing bts and exo song. They had no chance even with a very good performance
Same
In the end it still a popularity show... It's not about the song or who originally sung it nor the performance but it's about the high ranking trainees... so sad... but here I am still gonna watch it because I know everyone has a chance to shine because they are all talented it is just that the time is not for all the trainees...
Specially when the more popular trainees are group in one team and are covering popular songs from ultra popular groups like bts and exo.
Yassss... absolutely correct... to be honest I'm really bitter bacause I'm rooting for the Mirotic Team.. and in MY OPINION.. for the record "MY OPINION" they have the best performance, vocal wise, dance wise, rap wise with the addition of visual and fanchant... unfortunately most of the on site voters have different opinion than mine...
@@jhoelf9315 plus why on earth MBC uploaded the other performances days ahead than this performance. Atleast they could give this team same exposure online for the fans to vote for Sherlock team but nah, they choose to upload Bts song and even uploaded teaser about Suga and Suga training the already popular trainees and all. I just gave up . First they remove Jay Chang because foreigner, used Eddie for ratings and controversy but throw him aside after that and now theyre on the way eliminating Christian.
You have a point on that matter... but I don't know why I still want to continue watching the show... I think because everyone deserves it... They are all talented, it just that some are still lacking compare to other and some are more handsome than other and for some... it is not just their time... but I think being more fair for the part of MBC is also a factor... let me just correct you... It's JHope who trained the Fake Love trainees 😀
@@jhoelf9315 aw sorry .hehe I only knew Suga😂
This group is full of underrated talented member
Please support them 😘💕
Yess 💜
Yeah mbc is dumb
I just stop watching this show. Its very unfair that they obviously team up the higher ranked trainees on the other teams ,plus those teams are singing ultra popular songs from bts and exo. Shinee is popular but nowadays everyone is all about exo and bts and Sherlock is way harder to perform in comparison to other groups. In the end this is all about popularity. The other team would still win even doing mediocrity because theyre more popular.
This is how korean survival work :)
E X A C T L Y
agree :( other groups are great but SHINee is on another level honestly :(
The one that had the accident, he handled it well
To be honest the overall vibe and performance of this was better than Growl. This deserved to win in my opinion. Popularity always wins though, how sad.
No,growl is better. Im not being unfair. But their voice sucks. The dance performance is also lacking. They need to be sharp a bit. That's what i see in these group.
@@ladygee4659 No. Sherlock team has a more stable vocals compared to Exo. Dancing wise, only Christian is a standout in this one. Not that Exo team is any better. The winner was determined by who has the most fans, not by how they performed.
@@ladygee4659 Sherlock team was most definitely better in terms of vocals and for dancing both seemed equal. Both teams lacked a bit of presence and sharpness for dancing. But overall Sherlock was better.
Both are stable for me but the rap in growl is a little off
It would be great if Taemin coached these boys like Kai coached the Growl Team..... It's like Kai Vs Taemin... Exo Vs SHINee ... Both my absolute favourite groups and I feel both the groups performed equally well ❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️
EXACTLY I WAS WAITING FOR TJ(I call him Taemin Jackson) TO SHOW UP. If he had coached them they would've won no doubt
THIS GROUP GREAT, I MEAN THE SONG IS REALLY HARD ITSELF LIKE JONGHYUN PART, THE WHOLE DANCE IS FREAKING DIFFICULT. AND THIS GRUP JUST DOING, THUMBS UP 👍🏻
The fact that this song is such a difficult song to perform and yet they still didn’t get recognition is sad. They all did an amazing job
The fact that they lost was so unfair. I was MAD mad. This perfomance was super good in every way and they executed it amazingly even though it’s a super hard song to perform. When everyone found them as the easy target I was boiling. They really all deserved better.
They did a great job! I’ve got goosebumps all over my body. Sherlock is a hard song, and I, as a Shawol, is impressed 👏🏻
In other survival shows (beside The Unit/Mix Nine maybe) they almost never give trainees perform difficult songs by e.g. SHINee, BEAST, INFINITE or TVXQ (not counting the early/debiut songs like in P101) as if they were afraid the trainees will suck and the songs won't bring a lot of people to watch it (which is BS). Yet this show was ballsy enough to give these boys Fiction (which demands a lot of vocal control and harmonies) and Sherlock (which is ridiculously high and has hard choreo) and Mirotic (hard vocals and that freakin' high note). It's like they are saying: "Hey, you want to be singers? Then this is the level you should be to succeed in this industry" and that's how it supposed to be. Don't get me wrong, it's not like songs by other artists are bad, it's just in my opinion these shows should at least teach trainees something and the best way is to learn difficult things so they can get better in the future :)
SHINee songs aren't easy to cover, especially Sherlock! It's a very high leveled performance and needs sharp movements and quite some energy behind their dance moves. They did very well for such a difficult dance and song. I was missing a bit of the raw energy but it is a song that is even hard for veterans to accomplish. They really did their best here, continue fighting! :D
Glad to see they’re trying to reach SHINee level in terms of performance. That’s the caliber trainees should be aiming for
Tbh christian is the best in dancing in this team. Hes so underrated tho.
Rank 40 out of 40 contestants😭
+marvioxious1989 lets still hope for a miracle. hes rank 38 last time i heard. but voting ended already
@@jaeaaah he needs to be atleast #25 to survive and #40 to #25 is like impossible😭😭😭.
+marvioxious1989 yeah i know. thats why i said miracle😔
They did really well plus that boy who wear red blazer was so good because he still did his best even his mic fall off. Dude respect.
Both group are so good. Growl and Sherlock
KIM YOUNGWON DID WELL TILL THE END. OH MAN IM IN TEARS. GREAT JOB BOYS!❤️🧡💛💚💙💜
Christian's hair style, outfit, and dance is all on point. Its just that his moments are so limited but I notice his good performance.
the fact that they pulled it off soo well even tho Sherlock is soo difficult just proves that they are really great. And Youngwon performed so well even with that incident of his mic, no lies they should've won!!
He handled it really well!!💜
Hats down the best performance put of all 6!!!! Sherlock and Mirotic teams are like debuted groups already. They both don’t deserve that low number of votes, esp Sherlock
Team. They were sooo good
They did not get recognized for how difficult this was to perform - they did amazing!
Growl did well. But i love sherlock mooorreeeeee! I mean the song itself is soooo hard to pull off yet these boys did it awesomely!
Same, I honestly like them more
1:20 HIS NAME IS LIM YOUNSEO. Do you know he is very good at singing?! he is adorable and handsome at once❤️ You can check the performance of Exo 'Love Me Right' song on this 'under nineteen' show too. the sound is very good! he really shines there! Trust me. please support him! don't let his talents be wasted😭😭😭💗
lavieona __ I like his voice too.
finally someone support him~
that talent cant be wasted ㅠㅠ
lim yunseo deserve to debut.. I really hope ppl dont sleep on his talent.. he really good in singing and his voice.. 😍😍..
omg he caught my eyes. i love his voice so much
IM SO PROUD OF CHRISTIAN!!! and the whole sherlock team 😌❤️
Same💜
you would be prouder for him now because he already debuted as a ppop idol in the Philippines, you might check his group VXON they are so good. :)
That was great. Those mic problems is just heightens my admiration for this performance. It was really well put together. I'm happy to see this today
This 10-year shawol noona approves of these kids' perf. They did a good job of covering the song that 90% of the other trainees don't want to pick due to its difficulty. Good job kids!!
Its okay even though they did not win this round. They delivered a good performance and Im satisfied with it. What is not okay is the GAP between their SCORES. I really felt sorry for Sherlock team :(. They didnt deserved the score that they got. They deserve higher than a hunded plus.
I don’t even watch this show. Just came up on my feed and DAMN these kids did amazing!!! Every single one held their own. Well done!
Christian and Dahan are always together. I wish they will debut together too. Our Sherlock team hope win. God bless you guys! ❤️
Mbc group the struggling boys on the rankings while grouping the higher rank boys on the other group. Have you seen the score gap? Heartbreaking.
marvioxious1989 not yet. I didn't see the rank. Omo! Why? I feel bad for the Sherlock team. I'm worried what if they will eliminate? :'( If I could vote, I will vote and help them.
@@elleanypost Christian is like rank #40 from 40 contestants. If you dont realize this team has the lower rank boys. Even they did better, they had no chance to win against the Exo Growl team with more popular members plus its an Exo song. Exo is like the talk of the nation this days because of kai*Jennie. Sherlock is i mean was famous but yeah . Ma boi Christian is in danger😭. By the way search for the scores, its a heart breaker.
marvioxious1989 I'm scared to find out. I'm a Christian fan cause I see and feel his passion. Why? If this team will do EXO song or BTS song maybe their rank will go higher. MBC is a snake. I feel bad! 😭😭😭 I hope for a miracle. Maybe Koreans doesn't like Christian or the foreigner members except Wumuti. Wumuti is popular.
they did really well tbh. the song, the choreo is difficult and they performed it nicely. they put a different feel then the one i am used to seeing
I cant understand why they only got around 170 votes ;__;
I cant understand too. I really think Netizens are discrediting their hardwork just because these trainees are all from lower ranks :(
yeah me too
i'm sad for them :((((((
I'm so disappointed, they did so well and worked so hard (ik the other groups did too) I really wanted them to win or at least have a little more votes because they really deserved it.
great job guys! sherlock is such a difficult song with a great choreography, SHINee would be proud of your efforts ♥ hope the best for you!!!
SHINee's quality songs are no jokes. Jonghyun's highnote too! No one can beat him. Anw the one who did Jonghyun's highnote with grey suit looks super adorable 😂
Team Sherlock is good
Sherlock is a very hard song both for the choreo and vocal part .. I'm so proud they pulled this off .. 👏👏👏❤️❤️
I'm sorry this was kinda hard to watch... Technical difficulties and the inconsistency in singing :/
But Younseo's voice was really really good and he's still my vocal pick! ❤️
Oh and Christian did so well omg I love his parts!
exactly. if you know shinee then you know that this group is lacking but still fans are complaining that this is the best.
@@arlyncabz6578 I obviously know SHINee lol and what your saying is true. Im not hating on the group tho Sherlock is a hard song but this wasnt as good as people are making it seem its very inconsistent with the singing and the dance could have been alot stronger. I feel like people are sugar coating all of this which they shouldnt people should say the truth.
I totally relate! I Love Love Love Sherlock, but SHINee does so well in owning their songs that I can't be entirely satisfied with other group's covers.
Though what makes me really really sad about this performance is their lack of supporters. Obviously it can affect how a performer does on stage. If probably there more popular members in the group, they'd have much chance since they're opponent is dancing an already 'overused' song.
(Just in case this becomes an issue, I love growl but with so many covers, it's difficult for them to be unique)
@donna lim yes exactly like did sherlock team even get a mentor? Will we ever know? Like they really edited so much out I don't think it was fair and that. 12yr old really doing his best to hold his own too. I feel like a lot of fans just voted for Kai, not purely the teams. Like I'm sure they love people on the team too but kai sealed the deal for them
I just cant when Kim YoungWon keep blaming his self for his team's lost 😭 everybody, he manage that mic problem like a pro! He keep smiling and hit that notes and yes.. SLAY US GOOD!! please save KIM YOUNG WON !! And this team! Who performance this song like a pro with stable voices and amazing dance! 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤❤❤
He handled it really well
I wish them all good luck, I hope he doesn't get eliminated💜
When just bcoz its a famous song, even the greatest performance can't win.
Yes . Just because that song from famous group .
shinee is famous too
@@jennycal9871 yes shinee famous too ..
tbh i don’t think its the “famous song” that made the other group win. its the MEMBERS lots of high rankings ones are there :/ and the lower ranking ones are in this... they had a good performance here so its really sad that they’re not recognized for it
Lol its not because of the *famous song* *Growl team DID WELL* each member really did well
The dance formation is really difficult. But i love the can perfome so well. And their voice stabil.
But i'm sorry to say they didn't have the power that this song have. Just my opinion.
Can i know who is the little one cutie and how old he is? I'm uwuing over him
He is lee yechan, 13th
@@newzenazidni9581 thank you. And now i feel old. Kkkk
12 international
I quite agree with you but still looking at it positively cuz some of them aren't trainees or trained for a long time. Shinee did this with charisma, hard work, skills and talent and there'll be the time for this boys to come to that level.
The fact that they did this stage is already an achievement.
I believe this group did the best along with Mirotic team. They're the most formidable of all stages presented.
This team really did well, better than the others. they are so eye catching
Right??💜😭
The red suit boy really doing well😭😭😭😭😭😭
His Youngwon :)
I feel bad for the kids in this team. Everyone is openly looking down on them, they wanted Team Sherlock as their opponent coz this team seems "easy" in their eyes (especially when team Growl shouting in glee when they knew they were up against Sherlock). Youngwoon has every right to get mad at them. He's right when he said "they're looking down on us just because we have many trainees at the bottom of the charts". My heart is aching when he said that, coz there's exactly where Dahan & Christian position was ㅠㅠ My TakTakTak Duo ㅠㅠ
But im proud the manage to prove to the others that they're not someone that people can easily look down upon :')
Kudos to Youngwoon, handling his mic drop like a pro..
LadyELF♥SuJu they lost but they actually did the best out of all teams. The performance is super clean
Christian!!!!!! 💞💕❤
My name is Christian too kkkkkkkkk
Nobody scream when christian sang tho 🙁
mhd ash sadly he's not popular in korea because of lack of screen time 😢
Honestly he's been proving everyone in each mission on how good and well balanced he is! Such a shame how underrated he is (this coming from a non-fan of christian) 😣
That's the guy that slides at 3:09 right? I was wondering who he was throughout the performance. I follow the show, but couldn't place him.
It's a strong competition btw sherlock and growl. Both did well!! I love both!!! ❤️❤️❤️ Good job 💕💕
This is so unfair, they did great and were very professional... :(
Shinee's song and especially their choreo always hard and not easy but this team did a good job 👍
Considering them covering one of SHINee's high vocal and dance beat song, we should applaud these boys for covering it. Honestly when the group was divided itself I knew the ones who would win. The grouping of trainees was such that the popular ones were in fake love team and growl team. The grouping was bad, in addition to it, the songs are of the group which are popular as of now. So I would say it was unfair from the beginning. Looks like the channel already decided whom they wanted to debut. Anyways, hatsoff to the boys for trying extremely a difficult song (this was one of the most difficult one out of those whole bunch). Yes Armys I understand fake love choreography is very intricate but you can't deny the vocals and the dance beat are tiring in this song. And that guy with red suit handling his mic had a very professional mindset.
Plus Jhope and Kai visited the fake love and growl team. While Sherlock doing everything their best ,but they had no chance at all😭
@@Written_in_the_Starss yeah exactly. It was a marketing tactics used for more online votes. The channel at least should have been fair in that aspect. With those two guys visiting automatically the votes would be to the BTS and EXO team. It was such a dirty play by the channel...
I love every unit performances. But sherlock is no kidding. They're GREAT.
Agreed!!
@@arcanelvr 174 votes did broke my heart T.T
I wasn’t expecting much from this team Because Shinee’ s songs are very high pitched and also the choreo is really hard but they managed to do a good job. Also the guy in red first caught my eyes during love me right he has very good expressions in both performances. 0:25 His mic dropped but he handled it professionally, I am impressed boy 👏
They all did amazing jobs but the original is my favourite. SHINee really are legends 💕
200% this song is so hard....thank u for the great performance n dont give up..😊
There's no my biases here, but they're the BEST tbh like, damn. Perfect vocals, perfect dances, there're so many points that people can remember, like dahan's back flip(?), yechan's scream, the dances, yechan's jump, etc etc etc, this is like SO UNFAIR
I love the Sherlock team and Growl team so much!! Such great performances!! 😊❤
Christian and Kun💜💜
Don't be disappointed, the most important of you is the best ... Lee Yechann so manly😙😙😙😙
Thank you for performing this song 😭
okay but I love younseo's suit
The superior performance after mirotic.
The most harder sm entertaiment choreography they did it well!!!!!
eventho the mic pack fell off youngwon still did a great job!!!youngwon ahh lets debut✨✨✨😍😍😍💞💞💞
the performance leave bigger impression 👏👏👏👏
Kim youngwon ❤❤
Christian is very talented rap , sing and dance is amazing ...
WOW JUST WOW IT'S THE MOST WELL DISTRIBUTED PARTS AMONG ALL THE STAGE WOW SHERLOCK TEAM YOU DID GREAT REALLY
Ellos debieron haber ganado, realmente es muy frustrante el no poder votar también, ellos se esforzaron demasiado, interpretaron correctamente la canción, el sentimiento fue increíble, de verdad es decepcionante ver que no fueron ellos los ganadores. Dejaron atrás y por mucho a la otra unidad.
They honestly did amazing with this song. I was highly impressed.
I have to give my respect to these guys!! They did an amazing performance!!! Sherlock is a difficult song, but they were all really amazing!!!
This performance is so underrated... I feel bad for them
Kim Kun singing is improving, wow.
good job guyss, you win my heart
Wow does kid nowdays even know this legend song tbh
I hope and pray that Youngwon will be on Top 25!
i think everyone is misunderstanding tbh. this group performance is GREAT no doubt about that. the members in the other group however are high in the ranks. just because they have a “famous song” doesn’t mean they’ll automatically win. from what i learned from produce 101, its the members’ ranks that make the votes, no matter what song they pick.
both teams did great tho. they have their faults but they both worked hard. congratsss 🎉🎊
Yes. High rank trainees are grouped in the other teams and are singing Bts and exo song. This team had no chance.
@@Written_in_the_Starss lol. Its not that 'singing bts and exo songs' they won because the members of that unit are popular and already have their own fanbase. ARMY and EXOL are nothing to do with those votes.
@@haechkyu how can i belive how unbiased youre with that username.
@@Written_in_the_Starss they become a group because fans give votes to "people with songs that suit them. are they wrong when they become a group? if they have to choose themselves, most of them will definitely choose bts songs
i think not only me who cant move on with this program. but watch it for see what that nowdays people judge the others. dont use populority but look for quality. Merotic n Sherlock it flawless performance (hard to cover up), must know that is LEGEND . until know i dont know which part that make Growl n Fake Love more point? its because handsome guys? think it nitizen
This team rocked so hard, I love it 😍
when they said give it up for 19 i cryed because that was jjongs part.m.o
young won is so charming with that hair style. They had done the best performance actually.
These guys deserve more 😭
Please save youngwon from face elimination
Youngwon did it so well this team is powerfull, please vote for them.
THIS TEAM DESERVE BETTER
i just wish they would've just shown the performance properly instead of focusing on his bloody mic falling off..
i mean, they did so well! the editing pausing and slowing down the performance was so distracting
they could've added it in after the performance like they did for growl.. tsk!
*The show should've understand that giving them SHINee's Sherlock out of ALL their legendary songs is so hard to perform and only gods can do such high powerful vocals and choreo*
I mean I believe in their team but even they had a hard time practicing it bcuz the song was too difficult :'( good thing it went well
Gummy Bear and they didn’t have a coach 😔...
@@veritonvp2034 The show itself is always unfair )': 💔
This was the best team ❤
I really love this performance!!!🔥💜
I like voice youngwon so good and Team Sherlock good job 🔥💜💜👏👍👍😻
Go Christiaannn!!!!! 💪💪💪