Her album, is i-fact doing well - debuted at #3 during the Christmas season, and is still in the top album charts. APT is a generational hit because of the catchy melody -- and not just about Bruno. The reason it's still getting a lot of airplay now is not so much about Rose fans or Bruno fans; but about parents playing it over and over again because toddlers and babies want to dance to it. So that is hard to beat with her other songs. Her album is selling. Her songs are good. Her fans love her songs, and her fans are not known to power-stream. Other chart obssessed people are the ones who care, not necessarily her fans. And these people are still upset over the fact that APT beat a lot of records that their idols now have to chase. And they're spitting really hateful and mean words towards Rose. I am not sure it was a good idea for Rosie to release the album on December (November may have been a better release date), but she wanted to do it on her mom's bday as a sentimental reason, so let's give her that. Although I do agree, I have yet to see Atlantic promote her other solos as much as they promoted APT in terms of playlisting, ads and even billboards-- but it is possible they took a break over the Christmas season and I am hoping they will come back with promoting her songs soon.
i think its mainly because APT. was the type of song that was a bit fast beat and energetic but songs like toxic till the end is more of a sadder and slower song with more meaningful lyrics. *imo*
Another blink that has stereotyped that sad ,ballad or jazz songs don't do well the point is literally about not much improvement in her streams and sales compared to last album 🙂
The reason of her other songs flopping is bc she doesn’t have real demand. Apt success is because of Bruno and Atlantic push that song only. She has 70 million ml and nowhere to be found.
People were crazy about sad songs for over idk already 3 years? Or even more. Tiktok made sad songs trending once again so no excuses for "sadder, slower songs" c'mon
I don't care tbh it is daily drama i enjoyed the song that's matter most for me just enjoyed the damm songs why kpop fans always make everything about charts and all
I'm not sure what the debate is all about. It's obvious just from chart metrics alone that Rosé's solo album and songs are doing well. Here are the FACTS : * Rosé's debut solo album "Rosie" is performing exceptionally well on various charts as of January 2025 : 1) On the Billboard 200, it debuted at No. 3 with 102,000 album-equivalent units 2) The album is currently at No. 16 on the Billboard 200 chart in its sixth week, making it the highest-charting K-pop soloist album in history at this point in its chart run 3) First female K-pop soloist album to remain in the top 50 of the Billboard 200 for three weeks 4) The album has surpassed 1.2 billion streams on Spotify, becoming the fastest album by a female K-pop act in history to reach this milestone 5) "Rosie" has become the K-pop act album with the most weeks earning over 100 million streams in history on Spotify, achieving this feat in just 6 weeks 6) The album's success has contributed to Rosé setting a new record for the highest monthly listeners peak ever achieved by a K-pop soloist on Spotify 7)Rosé's success with "Rosie" has earned her a Guinness World Record for the highest-charting female K-pop artist on the US albums chart 8) Other milestones which I won't mention here. * "Toxic Till the End" : 1) It has held the No. 1 position on Soompi's K-Pop Music Chart for three consecutive weeks as of the second week of January 2025. So I'm not sure where this so-called info of her 'not doing well in Korea' is coming from. 2) The song reached No. 14 on the Billboard Global Excl. U.S. chart and No. 23 on the Global 200 chart 3) It debuted at No. 90 on the Billboard Hot 100 and entered the Billboard Pop Airplay chart at No. 40 with a 50% increase in plays 4) Other milestones which I won't mention here. * "Number One Girl" : 1) It reached No. 1 on the iTunes Top Songs Chart in 34 countries upon its release in November 2024 2) As of early January 2025, it climbed to No. 76 on the Billboard Global Excl. U.S. chart and No. 105 on the Global 200 chart 3) The song has surpassed 100 million streams on Spotify as of January 12, 2025 4) Other milestones which I won't mention here. * Of course, we all know about APT's astronomical success, so I won't elaborate here. However, note the following : 1) Rosé OWNS 100% of the recording master to APT - NOT Bruno, her label or her other collaborators. This means she owns ALL the copyrights and has FULL control of licensing, royalties, revenue streams and the distribution of APT. The same applies to ALL the other songs on the album. So guess who's laughing all the way to the bank ? Irrefutable FACTS don't lie. So what's the fuss about her so-called 'not doing well' again ???
Her streams and sales are also less compared to the last album chart rankings are declining too ,she left bb hot within a week ,still charting on radio but chart ranking is not increasing atleast could've shown more improvement bcz of the hype her fans were showing so which excuse this time?
@@Sigma420-d7bgo check for all the records. Her album Rosie is the highest charting kpop female act on billboard and also Rosie first , second ,third week streams on Spotify is highest in both male and female kpop acts even surpassed Jungkook 's Golden which was at first before Rosie dropped. We numberones keep track of everything and about sales these are low (not that low tho)on melon because her website was the main site for purchasing it .
It's actually has 11 writers including bruno and rosé. But 2 of the other writers were included as APT interpolated a song they wrote. Bruno is also one of the producers and arrangers of the song aside from being a writer. So yep, he also needs to be credited.
Apt success is bc of Bruno. Simple. Her other songs are not getting the streams and she has 70 monthly listeners (from Bruno not popularity) where are her listeners to support her? Also noticed how her American label Atlantic only push apt and not her solo songs? Simply that label was actually pushing Bruno not her.
APT is like Gangnam Style. A great catchy song and would have dont great because of that alone. I mean, if her fsms were psycho streamers then i can see her doing the same with every song and album. I literally see people cry to stream sings they don't even like. And some admitted to having songs on mute and just repeatedly streaming it for the views and listens. Its easy to think someones the best when their fandoms do things like that. At least Rosés song is listened to and loved around the world and not just within her fandom
Her album was 3rd most sold in December right after Taylor Swift, Kendrick Lamar. She's doing well lol. Also, most of the songs on her album are slow paced and K-pop in general leans towards more upbeat songs.
@Aryanbankar-p5t so brave to compare a hiatus group with an active one that is still doing better on charts why don't u compare bp this way then are they even on the charts ? and also why don't u compare her other songs chart rankings then
@Aryanbankar-p5t i can name u more than 20 songs without collabs of bts can u name 1 of her in top50 on bbhot100 without collab? Or even top 10 bp as a group and even members? Life goes on first korean song to enter bbhot #1, 1# dynamite,#1 ptd ,first song of them was also dna ,jk #5 snty ,jimin lc# 1, their first album was also love yourself her to enter bb 200 did collab made it ? And have u seen any person saying that it's a feature's song not of bts or jk's but we have 🙋♀️
@@Shinshien-cg5jbyeah Rosie album is the highest charting album amongst all kpop acts . Someone tell them the difference that record held by Bts is broken . Let's see who breaks it this year
Lol APT become a #CURSED for rosé. She gave all credit to Bruno..not just her but her fans also.. she never said that she want her Album to become hit or she wants become no. 1 Soloist. ""She just wants to make good music"" Its kchart or other big social media platforms give her no. 1 Asian female Soloist title. She deserves it. Her other songs also Charted well. Do you guys except 12 songs to chart in top 10. Most of Soloist Album contain 4 songs. People only know main song. Fans don't even know rest of the songs. idk why people are jealous.
It's amazing how some netizens comment negatively on an artist's popularity and performances as if they could do any better. She's happy with her music and there are plenty of fans who have been enjoying her album. At the end of the day, that's the most important thing.
Most idols just buy catchy english songs for chart success, she came up with the idea for APT. And rest of the album is about herself and it's full of slower songs. Try making a dance reel on number one girl lol. Not every song is made for streaming. She owns copyright to all her songs and APT is her song. The best song on the album is number one girl but it's not for repeat listening, And kpop fans need to buy dictionary to understand the accused lol. Always using the word 'accused' and 'fact' in a wrong way.
May or may not, bcz 1. Grammy's are r@cist... Psy deserved it bts as well,none received🙂 2. Many such songs are released like cupid not all get a Grammy for trending on tiktok
She is doing so well than other kpop groups like stray kides, twice, seventeen and more. All of them left the charts and rose still charting inside the top 20 at billboard 200 and it's been months now she is inside the top 10 on world wide iTunes and Apple music's album chart. Meanwhile stray kides left the chart after one week.
*⚠️Okay so I'm just stating what's on my mind ⚠️:* Rosé is seriously so desperate for western attention, she literally thinks she's a big pop star or something, she just comes to Korea every 2-3 months to make sure her korean fans are with her and that too for only 6-7 days hardly and she sets off to LA swiftly like a ninja. I swear if she wasn't a Blackpink member, she would've been settled down in the US ages ago. Her songs only charted well because of Bruno Mars, otherwise her whole album didn't perform well. And just recently she became the ambassador for Skims (if ykyk 💀) which is a kardashians brand. Like girl how much are you gonna sell yourself for some western attention, I mean she could've done for any other brand. Nowadays, she just pretends to Miss her family and everything but herself hardly comes to Korea, maybe 1 round in 3-4 months.and she's in US that too for just spending time in there, Even her promotions are over now.Even in the lie detector test, the host asked to choose between a different group (of which they showed the picture) and Blackpink, she said Blackpink but it turned out to be lie, can a lie detector test lie tho? 🤷🏻♀️And the host himself said it's super accurate. You guys might hate me for my opinion, but it's true y'all ☕
First you say it's your opinion and second you say it's true! It's very true in your head ! And she has always wanted to be a singer, her dad saw and audition to become a kpop idol and she said why not ? She just wants to do music no matter where she is ! What the problem with that?
Her fans souldn't push her on our face as the biggest kpop soloist because this is such a blatant lie... When you have the hit maker Bruno Mars as your first pre release collab of course you are going to rock it. To me her success as a soloist can be judget on her solo songs only, it's a big joke to attribute APT success to her and act like her name made the song famous. Bruno name did it.
She's the most underaprreciated in the whole blackpink Least biased Least popular Most discredited And when she blew up with apt y'all have the nerve to discredit her She made the songs and album herself . Apt was created by her, bruno was only feature she was most consumed " no 1 artist globally " near the end of 2024 and bruno was top 3 ... Only after releasing apt bruno went from 60 ml to 148 ml monthly listeners Apt gave bruno and rosé their biggest debut with 6 + millions streams Even in 2021 she held the record with 4 + million stream debut with on the ground ....... Despite being the least popular least biased she broke many recordes even with her album Even in 2021 she was the first of blackpink memebers to reach top 1 with "on the ground" in global 200 and 70 with her song "on the ground" in billboard hot 100 breaking the record for the highest topping song by female kpop soloist She gained over 12 million monthly listeners that year alone And she is now breaking record again but Y'all are bunch of hyppocrites discrediting her when she was just making history again Even no 1 girl topped many korean charts As well as the toxic till the end but y'all don't wanna accept it Y'all want kpop idols to be real artists and when someone comes up with album like this y'all won't even support instead you want her to fail Y'all are bunch of hyppocrites and snakes I will always support a real artist no matter what y'all cry salty tears
They only say that because it’s Rosé, lol. This happens with almost every artist, when just one song goes viral from an entire album. Also, Rosé already had a massive fan base before that collab, thanks to BLACKPINK.
Rosé is obviously a blackpink member, so she is famous on her own, but the dude is BRUNO MARS. He's a legend. I don't think any of his songs has ever flopped. Plus since he's usually low profile compared to most western celebs he stands out even more. So of course the success was because of him being there. He did a lot of promo for her, even went to perform at Mama. He's basically a pop culture legend. Not only that but his song with Gaga was already out and loved so people were expecting even more good stuff from him. Even if her solo songs aren't charting as well, I'm pretty sure that the APT wave will run her carreer for a long time. Now all she needs is do another "APT" on her own without any features. She's the only member I see securing a long carreer in music, she doesn't need any brand deals or modeling gigs, if she gets on her thing she'll make it big.
Yes apt is rose's concept and burno make it amazing 🤩 actually comparing apt and Rosie is meaningless because apt ia loved and streamed by all over the world 🌍 here problem is not Rosie album real problem is number ones,blinks (streaming)
Well of course since bruno mars was part of the song , it was going to blow up . BUT i believe that the stong could have blown up either way ,maybe not as much as how it did with bruno but it would have had it's sucess either way. It was a fun , catchy song. Every kpop group or soloist songs that have features with big pop artist , will blow up anyways so i dont get the hate.
Well in my understanding, APT. is more fun and fast beat while toxic till the end and number one girl is more meaningful and slower. The song drinks or coffee is pretty good and could become rlly popular.
Atleast her album was good . Not everything is about charts. Plus bp will comeback solo wise and as a group too mext yr. Than the blinks will be most active and it will pick up.
@Ailynbungal well I would rather have her know for good songs. Lisa got the most streams but still gets hate for meaningless lyrics,etc by jobless people. Rosie got good lyrics but is still getting hated by intelligent people like you. Nothing the girls do satisfies people, so I would rather like them to do whatever the hell type of music they want.
You know what... APT is tik tok kind of song but as a blink myself i rank APT in 3 or 4th position of her album bec...i beleive toxic till the end and number one girl are far better than APT... APT was a fresh music for genz....rosie was more about a sight into rosé personal life and her beautiful vocals...so as blinks those numbers doesn't matter to us
Jennie and Lisa are the only from that group who can survive as Soloist... Jisoo haven't released the album yet but still she is only female Soloist in Top 10 biggest album debut by k-pop soloist on Hanteo , rest are from BTS,One from Exo and LYW....
He certainly helped there are many Bruno fans who don't necessary hate K-pop just don't listen to it and they must have liked it as the amount of new followers Rose has after Apt released is almost 15Million on Instagram alone. Also lets not act Like Rose didn't Help Bruno either he won his First Korean Award and even multiple Music show wins in Korea so it was a Win Win for both artist. And it not like the same can be said for every Single Idol who collaborates every single one of them Lisa, Jungkook, Monsta X, Stray Kids and Wendy to name a Few its not a crime and doesn't take away the Fact that these Idols Including Rosie are so Talented that they were Able to Collaborate with These Large Western Artist's who have their own Large Fandoms some of them have probably barely if Never listened to K-Pop
I mean wasn't that what we expected, apt was something different and catchy and also i still remembered when her own fans where dragging jennie and lisa just because rose (the least popular member of the group) where making bigger numbers than (jennie and lisa) now look both mantra and new woman had bigger numbers than number one girl.
Also for me the members who has the potential to become something bigger on their own is Jennie and Lisa. Jennie because (she seems to have so much more potential than rose) and for Lisa (she does have potential put she needs to focus on upgrading her vocals and maybe her rap and releasing song like new woman and not song about fame and money)
She is getting whacked here and there,all thanks to her fans who setup her....One collaboration with Western A-list artist makes them think like that she ended Sabrina, Tyla, BTS, Ariana, Olivia.... Tierd of seeing those delusional comment under multiple posts but once you asked them where is her solo song then they will explain how Apt is her song but can't able to explain where is her own songs
All fake chart the chart just for hype 😂😂😂 if rose super hit song like this what about any other idols rose and sm idols also 😂😂😂 in world new just waiting for chart 😅😅😅.
Like isn't it obvious in the broad daylight that it's all about Bruno and heavy Atlantic payola! I'd like to introduce "payola" to kpop stans since they've been twisting the meaning of the word using it against organic artists in every way, "This is pure payola" 🫴🏼
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Her album, is i-fact doing well - debuted at #3 during the Christmas season, and is still in the top album charts. APT is a generational hit because of the catchy melody -- and not just about Bruno. The reason it's still getting a lot of airplay now is not so much about Rose fans or Bruno fans; but about parents playing it over and over again because toddlers and babies want to dance to it. So that is hard to beat with her other songs. Her album is selling. Her songs are good. Her fans love her songs, and her fans are not known to power-stream. Other chart obssessed people are the ones who care, not necessarily her fans. And these people are still upset over the fact that APT beat a lot of records that their idols now have to chase. And they're spitting really hateful and mean words towards Rose. I am not sure it was a good idea for Rosie to release the album on December (November may have been a better release date), but she wanted to do it on her mom's bday as a sentimental reason, so let's give her that. Although I do agree, I have yet to see Atlantic promote her other solos as much as they promoted APT in terms of playlisting, ads and even billboards-- but it is possible they took a break over the Christmas season and I am hoping they will come back with promoting her songs soon.
i think its mainly because APT. was the type of song that was a bit fast beat and energetic but songs like toxic till the end is more of a sadder and slower song with more meaningful lyrics. *imo*
Another blink that has stereotyped that sad ,ballad or jazz songs don't do well the point is literally about not much improvement in her streams and sales compared to last album 🙂
The reason of her other songs flopping is bc she doesn’t have real demand. Apt success is because of Bruno and Atlantic push that song only. She has 70 million ml and nowhere to be found.
People were crazy about sad songs for over idk already 3 years? Or even more. Tiktok made sad songs trending once again so no excuses for "sadder, slower songs" c'mon
@betxengi5388kpop stan really don’t like sad song
@ im not a blink..
Her fans shouldn't have set her up this way
I don't care tbh it is daily drama i enjoyed the song that's matter most for me just enjoyed the damm songs why kpop fans always make everything about charts and all
Exactly!
Got out of my bed today the sunlight was hitting my face
and two little bird's came and sat on the edge and they ask
If I am doing okay and we talk for a while sat for a while
And one of them asked me if there's anything I would change
I'm not sure what the debate is all about. It's obvious just from chart metrics alone that Rosé's solo album and songs are doing well. Here are the FACTS :
* Rosé's debut solo album "Rosie" is performing exceptionally well on various charts as of January 2025 :
1) On the Billboard 200, it debuted at No. 3 with 102,000 album-equivalent units
2) The album is currently at No. 16 on the Billboard 200 chart in its sixth week, making it the highest-charting K-pop soloist album in history at this point in its chart run
3) First female K-pop soloist album to remain in the top 50 of the Billboard 200 for three weeks
4) The album has surpassed 1.2 billion streams on Spotify, becoming the fastest album by a female K-pop act in history to reach this milestone
5) "Rosie" has become the K-pop act album with the most weeks earning over 100 million streams in history on Spotify, achieving this feat in just 6 weeks
6) The album's success has contributed to Rosé setting a new record for the highest monthly listeners peak ever achieved by a K-pop soloist on Spotify
7)Rosé's success with "Rosie" has earned her a Guinness World Record for the highest-charting female K-pop artist on the US albums chart
8) Other milestones which I won't mention here.
* "Toxic Till the End" :
1) It has held the No. 1 position on Soompi's K-Pop Music Chart for three consecutive weeks as of the second week of January 2025. So I'm not sure where this so-called info of her 'not doing well in Korea' is coming from.
2) The song reached No. 14 on the Billboard Global Excl. U.S. chart and No. 23 on the Global 200 chart
3) It debuted at No. 90 on the Billboard Hot 100 and entered the Billboard Pop Airplay chart at No. 40 with a 50% increase in plays
4) Other milestones which I won't mention here.
* "Number One Girl" :
1) It reached No. 1 on the iTunes Top Songs Chart in 34 countries upon its release in November 2024
2) As of early January 2025, it climbed to No. 76 on the Billboard Global Excl. U.S. chart and No. 105 on the Global 200 chart
3) The song has surpassed 100 million streams on Spotify as of January 12, 2025
4) Other milestones which I won't mention here.
* Of course, we all know about APT's astronomical success, so I won't elaborate here. However, note the following :
1) Rosé OWNS 100% of the recording master to APT - NOT Bruno, her label or her other collaborators. This means she owns ALL the copyrights and has FULL control of licensing, royalties, revenue streams and the distribution of APT. The same applies to ALL the other songs on the album. So guess who's laughing all the way to the bank ?
Irrefutable FACTS don't lie. So what's the fuss about her so-called 'not doing well' again ???
thats not true... its not low after APT, its just Apt was ahuge hit anything after that would be lower than Apt.
Her streams and sales are also less compared to the last album chart rankings are declining too ,she left bb hot within a week ,still charting on radio but chart ranking is not increasing atleast could've shown more improvement bcz of the hype her fans were showing so which excuse this time?
She did worse than even Jennie and Lisa .
Hahahaha @@Sigma420-d7b
@@Sigma420-d7bgo check for all the records. Her album Rosie is the highest charting kpop female act on billboard and also Rosie first , second ,third week streams on Spotify is highest in both male and female kpop acts even surpassed Jungkook 's Golden which was at first before Rosie dropped. We numberones keep track of everything and about sales these are low (not that low tho)on melon because her website was the main site for purchasing it .
It's not about Bruno. APT is an amazing song. And it's written by Rose. So of course Rose has credits.
Not being rude but she is one of the 6 members who wrote that song
It's actually has 11 writers including bruno and rosé. But 2 of the other writers were included as APT interpolated a song they wrote. Bruno is also one of the producers and arrangers of the song aside from being a writer. So yep, he also needs to be credited.
11 song writer Apt has in which half of the song lyrics are just Apt Apt with Catchy beat...
APT had many writers
They way yall discredits other 11 song writer's lmao
Apt success is bc of Bruno. Simple. Her other songs are not getting the streams and she has 70 monthly listeners (from Bruno not popularity) where are her listeners to support her? Also noticed how her American label Atlantic only push apt and not her solo songs? Simply that label was actually pushing Bruno not her.
70 million ml**
No
@@Gibberish-c9xyup
True
Bruno went from 60 million to 148 million with just APT and Dwm.
APT is like Gangnam Style. A great catchy song and would have dont great because of that alone. I mean, if her fsms were psycho streamers then i can see her doing the same with every song and album. I literally see people cry to stream sings they don't even like. And some admitted to having songs on mute and just repeatedly streaming it for the views and listens. Its easy to think someones the best when their fandoms do things like that.
At least Rosés song is listened to and loved around the world and not just within her fandom
Her album was 3rd most sold in December right after Taylor Swift, Kendrick Lamar. She's doing well lol. Also, most of the songs on her album are slow paced and K-pop in general leans towards more upbeat songs.
Rosie is charting #17 on billboard 200 it is the highest charting album by a kpop act during 6th week surpassing bts #21
@Aryanbankar-p5t so brave to compare a hiatus group with an active one that is still doing better on charts why don't u compare bp this way then are they even on the charts ? and also why don't u compare her other songs chart rankings then
@Shinshien-cg5jb I am talking about a album not a song
@Shinshien-cg5jb and song bts has released 32 collaborations rosé is released only one
@Aryanbankar-p5t i can name u more than 20 songs without collabs of bts can u name 1 of her in top50 on bbhot100 without collab? Or even top 10 bp as a group and even members? Life goes on first korean song to enter bbhot #1, 1# dynamite,#1 ptd ,first song of them was also dna ,jk #5 snty ,jimin lc# 1, their first album was also love yourself her to enter bb 200 did collab made it ? And have u seen any person saying that it's a feature's song not of bts or jk's but we have 🙋♀️
@@Shinshien-cg5jbyeah Rosie album is the highest charting album amongst all kpop acts . Someone tell them the difference that record held by Bts is broken . Let's see who breaks it this year
Lol APT become a #CURSED for rosé.
She gave all credit to Bruno..not just her but her fans also.. she never said that she want her Album to become hit or she wants become no. 1 Soloist.
""She just wants to make good music""
Its kchart or other big social media platforms give her no. 1 Asian female Soloist title. She deserves it. Her other songs also Charted well. Do you guys except 12 songs to chart in top 10. Most of Soloist Album contain 4 songs. People only know main song. Fans don't even know rest of the songs.
idk why people are jealous.
She has 70M monthly listeners how did the charts go down??!
Because the 70M isn't just number one's that are streaming apt but also Bruno Mars fans and blinks
Only one song apt is being streamed by the million the rest is 1 million or less
It's amazing how some netizens comment negatively on an artist's popularity and performances as if they could do any better.
She's happy with her music and there are plenty of fans who have been enjoying her album. At the end of the day, that's the most important thing.
It's not because of Bruno it's because of the song was good.
What if the song wasn't good? what we would do with Bruno??
Most idols just buy catchy english songs for chart success, she came up with the idea for APT. And rest of the album is about herself and it's full of slower songs. Try making a dance reel on number one girl lol. Not every song is made for streaming. She owns copyright to all her songs and APT is her song.
The best song on the album is number one girl but it's not for repeat listening,
And kpop fans need to buy dictionary to understand the accused lol. Always using the word 'accused' and 'fact' in a wrong way.
Whatever she is gonna win Grammy for sure although i am not a fan of apt or rosie
I truly hope and pray
May or may not, bcz 1. Grammy's are r@cist... Psy deserved it bts as well,none received🙂
2. Many such songs are released like cupid not all get a Grammy for trending on tiktok
She is doing so well than other kpop groups like stray kides, twice, seventeen and more. All of them left the charts and rose still charting inside the top 20 at billboard 200 and it's been months now she is inside the top 10 on world wide iTunes and Apple music's album chart. Meanwhile stray kides left the chart after one week.
*⚠️Okay so I'm just stating what's on my mind ⚠️:*
Rosé is seriously so desperate for western attention, she literally thinks she's a big pop star or something, she just comes to Korea every 2-3 months to make sure her korean fans are with her and that too for only 6-7 days hardly and she sets off to LA swiftly like a ninja. I swear if she wasn't a Blackpink member, she would've been settled down in the US ages ago. Her songs only charted well because of Bruno Mars, otherwise her whole album didn't perform well. And just recently she became the ambassador for Skims (if ykyk 💀) which is a kardashians brand. Like girl how much are you gonna sell yourself for some western attention, I mean she could've done for any other brand. Nowadays, she just pretends to Miss her family and everything but herself hardly comes to Korea, maybe 1 round in 3-4 months.and she's in US that too for just spending time in there, Even her promotions are over now.Even in the lie detector test, the host asked to choose between a different group (of which they showed the picture) and Blackpink, she said Blackpink but it turned out to be lie, can a lie detector test lie tho? 🤷🏻♀️And the host himself said it's super accurate.
You guys might hate me for my opinion, but it's true y'all ☕
All I have to say is..... Baby girl, do you know spice girls???? It's spice girls for crying out loud!!!!!! 😂😂😂😂
Nah, I don't and what's the problem if I don't?
True ..that girl is pathological liar ..she stay in the LA to be with her drug addict boyfriend evan
First you say it's your opinion and second you say it's true! It's very true in your head ! And she has always wanted to be a singer, her dad saw and audition to become a kpop idol and she said why not ? She just wants to do music no matter where she is ! What the problem with that?
The more successful an artist is, the more haters there are 😊 АРТ. - 1 Billion soon 🎉 Rosé the best ❤ haters will go cry somewhere else 😂
Thanks to bruno oppa
Her fans souldn't push her on our face as the biggest kpop soloist because this is such a blatant lie... When you have the hit maker Bruno Mars as your first pre release collab of course you are going to rock it.
To me her success as a soloist can be judget on her solo songs only, it's a big joke to attribute APT success to her and act like her name made the song famous. Bruno name did it.
She's the most underaprreciated in the whole blackpink
Least biased
Least popular
Most discredited
And when she blew up with apt y'all have the nerve to discredit her
She made the songs and album herself . Apt was created by her, bruno was only feature she was most consumed " no 1 artist globally " near the end of 2024 and bruno was top 3 ...
Only after releasing apt bruno went from 60 ml to 148 ml monthly listeners
Apt gave bruno and rosé their biggest debut with 6 + millions streams
Even in 2021 she held the record with 4 + million stream debut with on the ground .......
Despite being the least popular least biased she broke many recordes even with her album
Even in 2021 she was the first of blackpink memebers to reach top 1 with "on the ground" in global 200 and 70 with her song "on the ground" in billboard hot 100 breaking the record for the highest topping song by female kpop soloist
She gained over 12 million monthly listeners that year alone
And she is now breaking record again but
Y'all are bunch of hyppocrites discrediting her when she was just making history again
Even no 1 girl topped many korean charts
As well as the toxic till the end but y'all don't wanna accept it
Y'all want kpop idols to be real artists and when someone comes up with album like this y'all won't even support instead you want her to fail
Y'all are bunch of hyppocrites and snakes
I will always support a real artist no matter what y'all cry salty tears
Idk what you guys were expecting, this was obviously going to happen
@Hy_unjin_ ikr no one would've criticized her if her fans wouldn't have set her up this high its like 50 -50 cupid
@Shinshien-cg5jb exactly and it's not even like it didn't do well ):
They only say that because it’s Rosé, lol. This happens with almost every artist, when just one song goes viral from an entire album. Also, Rosé already had a massive fan base before that collab, thanks to BLACKPINK.
Rosé is obviously a blackpink member, so she is famous on her own, but the dude is BRUNO MARS. He's a legend. I don't think any of his songs has ever flopped. Plus since he's usually low profile compared to most western celebs he stands out even more.
So of course the success was because of him being there. He did a lot of promo for her, even went to perform at Mama. He's basically a pop culture legend. Not only that but his song with Gaga was already out and loved so people were expecting even more good stuff from him.
Even if her solo songs aren't charting as well, I'm pretty sure that the APT wave will run her carreer for a long time. Now all she needs is do another "APT" on her own without any features. She's the only member I see securing a long carreer in music, she doesn't need any brand deals or modeling gigs, if she gets on her thing she'll make it big.
Rose fans need to push her solos song like game boy , 3 am drink or coffee much more . How I do not know
Disappointing 😅 she is literally killing.... This is like saying Magic sucked because he won 5 championships with Kareem 😅
Yes apt is rose's concept and burno make it amazing 🤩 actually comparing apt and Rosie is meaningless because apt ia loved and streamed by all over the world 🌍 here problem is not Rosie album real problem is number ones,blinks (streaming)
Well of course since bruno mars was part of the song , it was going to blow up . BUT i believe that the stong could have blown up either way ,maybe not as much as how it did with bruno but it would have had it's sucess either way. It was a fun , catchy song. Every kpop group or soloist songs that have features with big pop artist , will blow up anyways so i dont get the hate.
I mean it's low-key true. Plus her fans SHOULDN'T have set her up like that
Well in my understanding, APT. is more fun and fast beat while toxic till the end and number one girl is more meaningful and slower. The song drinks or coffee is pretty good and could become rlly popular.
Atleast her album was good . Not everything is about charts. Plus bp will comeback solo wise and as a group too mext yr. Than the blinks will be most active and it will pick up.
Her album is good but the most FLOP
@Ailynbungal well I would rather have her know for good songs. Lisa got the most streams but still gets hate for meaningless lyrics,etc by jobless people. Rosie got good lyrics but is still getting hated by intelligent people like you. Nothing the girls do satisfies people, so I would rather like them to do whatever the hell type of music they want.
You know what... APT is tik tok kind of song but as a blink myself i rank APT in 3 or 4th position of her album bec...i beleive toxic till the end and number one girl are far better than APT... APT was a fresh music for genz....rosie was more about a sight into rosé personal life and her beautiful vocals...so as blinks those numbers doesn't matter to us
Jennie and Lisa are the only from that group who can survive as Soloist... Jisoo haven't released the album yet but still she is only female Soloist in Top 10 biggest album debut by k-pop soloist on Hanteo , rest are from BTS,One from Exo and LYW....
rosé is born to be soloist.
Well if we talk about skills..
@@minjuscookie skills is rose but potential is Jennie and lisa
@jennielubi146 I am talking about Jisoo
Jisoo could've simply gone with acting but she chose to make music so I'm genuinely suprised and curious to see her output
He certainly helped there are many Bruno fans who don't necessary hate K-pop just don't listen to it and they must have liked it as the amount of new followers Rose has after Apt released is almost 15Million on Instagram alone. Also lets not act Like Rose didn't Help Bruno either he won his First Korean Award and even multiple Music show wins in Korea so it was a Win Win for both artist.
And it not like the same can be said for every Single Idol who collaborates every single one of them Lisa, Jungkook, Monsta X, Stray Kids and Wendy to name a Few its not a crime and doesn't take away the Fact that these Idols Including Rosie are so Talented that they were Able to Collaborate with These Large Western Artist's who have their own Large Fandoms some of them have probably barely if Never listened to K-Pop
I mean wasn't that what we expected, apt was something different and catchy and also i still remembered when her own fans where dragging jennie and lisa just because rose (the least popular member of the group) where making bigger numbers than (jennie and lisa) now look both mantra and new woman had bigger numbers than number one girl.
Also for me the members who has the potential to become something bigger on their own is Jennie and Lisa. Jennie because (she seems to have so much more potential than rose) and for Lisa (she does have potential put she needs to focus on upgrading her vocals and maybe her rap and releasing song like new woman and not song about fame and money)
She is getting whacked here and there,all thanks to her fans who setup her....One collaboration with Western A-list artist makes them think like that she ended Sabrina, Tyla, BTS, Ariana, Olivia.... Tierd of seeing those delusional comment under multiple posts but once you asked them where is her solo song then they will explain how Apt is her song but can't able to explain where is her own songs
But her other song streams are slower I thought at least 4 of her song will hit 400 million streams
This a really ignorant analysis
True 💯
Yes true shes nothing without bruno ,all her solo song is flop
All fake chart the chart just for hype 😂😂😂 if rose super hit song like this what about any other idols rose and sm idols also 😂😂😂 in world new just waiting for chart 😅😅😅.
Like isn't it obvious in the broad daylight that it's all about Bruno and heavy Atlantic payola! I'd like to introduce "payola" to kpop stans since they've been twisting the meaning of the word using it against organic artists in every way, "This is pure payola" 🫴🏼
The kids in my neighborhood turned on everyone and they could sing.