Are Mystery Ranch & Hill People Gear In Trouble!? 5.11 Skyweight Chest Packs & Backpacks

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024

Комментарии • 123

  • @SlasherSociety09
    @SlasherSociety09 Год назад +3

    Man you are one of the few people that ,first of all are able but also that can be so super thorough and not come off like a complete goof...great job you always cover alot of ground, awesome!

  • @reallyhappenings5597
    @reallyhappenings5597 9 месяцев назад +3

    Thanks, your channel delivers the details again

  • @robertengel8342
    @robertengel8342 Год назад +2

    I like that the survival chest rig being thin for your firearm and you pick molle pouches for customization to your needs. I wish they put molle on the front of the utility chest rig like the survival model. It would also be nice if they made that molle flap some what rigid to help support the pouches that will be added on.

  • @TimothyLipinski
    @TimothyLipinski 26 дней назад

    Great Video ! Like the Water Bottle set-up ! Maybe add a mod to connect to a Gas Mask... The Hydration Bladder set-up is great for Level 3A Body Armor ! Have too many 5.11 back packs already. Like the Utility Chest Pack, but wish it was a little bit larger. In the large front pocket put the Land Nav Kit ! tjl

  • @bkdesignr
    @bkdesignr Год назад +1

    thats' one thing i always loved about (pre mystery ranch) dana design backpacks. the pack lids on some larger models had removable lid that turned into a fanny/hip pack.

  • @Ashton.everydaycarry
    @Ashton.everydaycarry Год назад +3

    I recently got a 5.11 rush 24 which I've been using lots, so I'll be sticking with that for now. Definitely a cool new direction for 5.11. A few odd layout/design choices like you mentioned, but seems like a good pack overall.

  • @roybailey7911
    @roybailey7911 Год назад +2

    It’s kinda like 5.11 is going back to their roots. Royal Robbin made outdoor pants that LEOs liked.

  • @mikeh692
    @mikeh692 Год назад +1

    I use the Survival pack to carry a camera plus a few small items (folding knife, mini first aid kit, lighter, etc). It works well for me, comfortable and useful. I’m not sold on the backpacks.

  • @thatchanguy
    @thatchanguy Год назад +1

    Great reviews, as always. I like the Hardside Hydration option. I would love it if they had a built-in filter (like Sawyer or Grayl).

  • @denvercyclist
    @denvercyclist Год назад +2

    I know this is out of the context of your use case scenario. But this would work great as a cycling bag being slick and with the tops snches might even make it a little aro. You could definitely use those Thompson just as well in conjunction with the water bottle pocket to put poles or a tripod in . Thanks for the great review!

  • @Scarywoody
    @Scarywoody Год назад +1

    Great review. I wasn't aware of this new stuff.

  • @JonathanCrane82
    @JonathanCrane82 5 месяцев назад

    For someone like myself who lives in a wheelchair, the skyweight system has been amazing to see from 5.11

  • @coultin
    @coultin 11 месяцев назад

    Went backpacking with my skyweight utility pack and absolutely loved it. Charger. Phone. Cords, sun screen, Candy.

  • @chrismonsen
    @chrismonsen 6 месяцев назад +2

    Thanks so much for this review. Hey do you think it would be too heavy if I strap on a 32oz Nalgene on the front of the survival molle version?

  • @redout1000
    @redout1000 11 месяцев назад +1

    Just got both chest rigs. Utility pack all the way for weapons and other gear

  • @ghost762
    @ghost762 Год назад +1

    You forget about Helikon-Tex. Currently running the Numbat chest pack.

  • @johnsimmons3160
    @johnsimmons3160 Год назад +2

    I like HPG because it looks less military .

  • @valorant846
    @valorant846 9 месяцев назад +1

    hope they make chest pack 2.0 with all harness point resalable, tried them at store such a pain to put on and off

  • @butchhill5656
    @butchhill5656 Год назад +1

    I like the survival. Going to look into getting one. Great way to carry a handgun

  • @francoisroussel1
    @francoisroussel1 Год назад +1

    Personally, i don't think there is new feature. this is just inspire from a '' night hawk'' style of a bag. We use to modified our navy bag to have the opening at the top, instead of along the bag body, and clipped a haversack bag on the top. The compression strap were from the top to the bottom. Alice strap were clipped for the '' back packing '' mode.

  • @bigchief4044
    @bigchief4044 Год назад +1

    Great direction 5.11 is going with series of gear.
    It’s also not overly expensive like the other brands.

    • @CptBlkBrd
      @CptBlkBrd Год назад

      I'd prefer to pay more to support other Americans making solid gear.

  • @thumperthumper5322
    @thumperthumper5322 Год назад

    I agree it could use a upgrade for the water bottle.

  • @sorearm
    @sorearm Год назад +1

    Nice review thank you

  • @gladius1275
    @gladius1275 Год назад +1

    What is being ripped off that most hiking packs don’t offer? Modularity, chest rigs? Military gear around the world have had this for some time. It’s good to see expansion in 5.11’s lineup.

  • @louissinon6868
    @louissinon6868 Год назад

    I have a couple rush pacs and a pair of boots, the Molle chest pack as a helpful edition to my filming gear to hold my phone in a mount while able to carry other gear with my hand free. 511 is expensive but I trust it with my life.

  • @Kobalta
    @Kobalta Год назад +1

    For me it seems that the 5.11 tries to expand this lighter lineup with cheaper variants of more expensive (and globally less available/harder to get) products already on the market, like this backpack slightly reminds me the SHADO 24L from Prometheus Design Werx and the chest packs were probably inspired by the ones from the Hill People Gear (the few years old Helikon-Tex Numbat is other good and cheaper one, but without the front PALS straps and they also have fanny packs with removable belts, can be used directly with the internal belt or even with a backpack's sternum strap).

  • @RockyMountainEDC
    @RockyMountainEDC Год назад

    Love this !!! Thanks so much for this video !

  • @EnigmaticAnomaly
    @EnigmaticAnomaly Год назад +1

    I have the same setup -- the backpack and chest rig. Haven't had the opportunity to use the backpack yet, but I love the chest pack. And also, that Hardside Swig Rig is something I've been needing and never new existed -- but $30-$40 for a freaking flexible straw? Come on!

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад +2

      It’s a little more than that, and it’s a USA based company, and with a $10 nalgene it’s the combined same cost as a bladder but more versatile. That’s just me.

  • @davidleonard1813
    @davidleonard1813 Год назад +1

    It'd be nice if it these type of packs rand a really nice well padded 3 or 4 row PAL Molle fixtures. 36lt a tad small it'd be nice if you could put a 1lt bottle pouch on each side of the belt.
    Karimore do an option you can put a full Molle belt UNDER the pack so you could put 5 British water bottle pouches around it.
    At 35l6 litres I'd prefer an option like that 40lt seems to be bare minimum for me

  • @trikelife4960
    @trikelife4960 Год назад +1

    I want to love this pack but the compression system is odd. I really like the toned down laser cut molle and the good suspension. Weight is good, the color is great (except that horrific hi viz rain cover...why do they...nvm lol) and the organization is about perfect (too many pockets is a hindrance rather than an asset). Once these become available in Canada I may try the 24.

  • @allenclawson6638
    @allenclawson6638 Год назад +1

    I see you’re not using the grayl titanium any reason why?

  • @kichwatembo6551
    @kichwatembo6551 Год назад +3

    First!
    Love my hpg sar kit bag
    Tried other brands but always come back
    Add a recon harness to it and you have a lot of options

    • @johnsimmons3160
      @johnsimmons3160 Год назад

      Add a Prairie Belt with pouches and 2016 buttpack and you'll be all set.

    • @kichwatembo6551
      @kichwatembo6551 Год назад

      @John Simmons
      I almost did years ago but I've never used a buttpack and wasn't sure I'd like the set up
      Functionality for sure

  • @ROE1300
    @ROE1300 Год назад +1

    👍 Excellent review of an interesting new design. Thank you for sharing. Can either chest pack connect to the backpack shoulder straps or must you use the harness that comes with the chest pack?

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад +1

      You need to use the harness 👍

    • @ROE1300
      @ROE1300 Год назад +1

      @@gideonstactical Thank you for the reply. Not sure I like that aspect.

  • @PrestonGladd
    @PrestonGladd Год назад +3

    This pack is a pick-pockets dream, huge fail on the zippers to access the main compartment on the bottom back. Don't wear this pack in an urban area.

    • @mikeh692
      @mikeh692 Год назад +1

      Agree 100%. Also a problem if the zip fails or you don’t fully close it out in the wild and gear starts to fall,out the pack as you hike.

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад

      For sure!!

  • @Heresay2
    @Heresay2 Год назад +2

    Good review. I’ve used the utility chest pack.
    Pros
    -not as tactical looking
    -I like the rounded edges
    -good organization
    Cons
    -big issue I have is the adjustment system. HPG is much easier to adjust the right fit. 5.11 Utility I have to take it off to set up the right fit whereas the HPG I can do it on the go.

    • @Tacticooldorkdad
      @Tacticooldorkdad Год назад

      I agree with the adjustment being terrible. HPG got that part right

    • @Kobalta
      @Kobalta Год назад

      Anybody can compare it to the Helikon-Tex Numbat maybe?

  • @Shooter11B
    @Shooter11B Год назад

    I regularly run a Hill People Gear chest rig about the same size as the utility version and I have to say I like the layout of the 5.11 better than the HPG version. On the HPG they have the same number of compartments, BUT they utilize two sets of heavy-duty zippers with 550 cord on the zipper pulls to open the compartments (annoying) and the pistol compartment is really just another pouch that I use for that purpose. So, I am definitely going to get one of the 5.11 versions to run in the near future. Thanks for the great review and heads up on this new line from 5.11.

  • @kurtgellert9166
    @kurtgellert9166 Год назад +2

    5.11 is heading in a good direction with this line. Agree with almost all critique points... it needs a mesh pocket on the back, the insert pockets with the lower zippers, better tension straps, etc all would make this an elite pack. I'd also like to see them add big zip pockets on the waist straps...there's certain enough room for them...for easy access to phone, wallet, keys, etc.

  • @jvzabala98
    @jvzabala98 Год назад +2

    Wow that water bottle ad is great, I’m picking one up for sure!!! Never been a fan of bladders!

  • @roypaulcarter4654
    @roypaulcarter4654 Год назад +1

    Nice good information

  • @Kalaharijack69
    @Kalaharijack69 Год назад +1

    Love your reviews! I wish you would do a review of the new Becker Patrol Pack!

  • @xqlusive
    @xqlusive Год назад

    Awesome. Been trying to get both the rig and pack in Australia here. But it's not available over here. 😔

  • @tap42al
    @tap42al 4 месяца назад +1

    The 36liter looks better

  • @surviveanything4765
    @surviveanything4765 Год назад +3

    For about a pound more, I'll take my Mystery Ranch Raid LT 32 over foreign made 5.11's. Much better design and features.

    • @edrader746
      @edrader746 Год назад +1

      not me. 1lb is huge for me

    • @surviveanything4765
      @surviveanything4765 Год назад +1

      @@edrader746 My get home bag weighs 22lbs and will sustain me for a minimum of 96 hours.

    • @bigchief4044
      @bigchief4044 Год назад +1

      Who cares where it’s made as long as it works and checks the boxes that you’re looking for.

    • @edrader746
      @edrader746 Год назад

      @@bigchief4044 i hear you. i'm a capitalist

    • @surviveanything4765
      @surviveanything4765 Год назад

      @@bigchief4044 To me quality matters. 5.11 are not a high quality bag. I had issues with stitching and I had a strap fail.

  • @ek8652
    @ek8652 Год назад +1

    What chest pack would be best for either a sig p239 or p229? I’m wondering if the thinner of the two chest rigs would be less bulky and heavy?

  • @jonathancamps9853
    @jonathancamps9853 Год назад +1

    Ive been using the utility chest pack for yardwork, house work, camping, hiking, and I leave it loaded out with my edc pistol when I get home as a nighttime pack. The pull tab makes getting the pistol out quicker than any other ccw option.
    The day I bought it, my first thought was, “I cant wait for the GT review.” You never disappoint Aaron

  • @Wyo_Wyld
    @Wyo_Wyld Год назад

    5-11 should offer the pack belt as a separate item. It looks sturdy and would be a great addition to my kit.

  • @nutthrower4415
    @nutthrower4415 11 месяцев назад +1

    I Have a chest pack and do like the idea of it but just having the bulk sitting out in front of me seems awkward, for me anyway. I probably pack to much in it. But why have all the pockets and such if your not going to use them. So that slimmer one might be a better fit , again For Me. Love/ hate relationship , I really wanted to like mine 🤷‍♂️

  • @eyeofthetiger4184
    @eyeofthetiger4184 Год назад +1

    G'day Aaron, I do dig the direction, but a bit of a .......... mixed bag.
    Like the hip belt and the inclusion of a rain cover; incidentally, I wish that belt was compatible with the Rush 12, .... out of the box anyway, ..... I'm sure it could be done with modification..
    Chest rigs do make sense with regard to easy access and weight distribution, though the nuisance value in that position, together with another harness is ...... too much to bear ; )
    And seems to me, this pack design almost assumes you're gonna have a chest rig to go with it, and if you dont, you're stuck with a funny hat for those items.
    Bottom line, with more refinement, I reckon there's an outstanding design just waiting to emerge.
    Cheers Duke.

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад +1

      💯 percent my friend. Good take and I always appreciate your input.

  • @Jhenry55677
    @Jhenry55677 Год назад +1

    Mushroom tip. 😂

  • @larrysioxson2567
    @larrysioxson2567 Год назад

    Can you please review the 5.11 Tactical CFK7 Camp Knife? There’s not very many reviews on that knife.

  • @mschroeder17
    @mschroeder17 Год назад +1

    Maybe we should move to Vanquest backpacks? What do you guys think.?

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад

      I have reviewed most of their packs over the years great quality

  • @renegadearms
    @renegadearms Год назад

    I don’t know besides maybe clothing I feel like with gear they have been behind the power curve, seems like they don’t innovate and just come out with stuff after others.

  • @adventuredave9461
    @adventuredave9461 10 месяцев назад +1

    What molle knife you carrying?

  • @ThorSkin69
    @ThorSkin69 Год назад

    bag looks very narrow, no good for camera cubes etc. I dont like the molle on the rush series but they are a fantastic bag. I might have to get an amp24 before they go.

  • @DanDannyDanielleBob
    @DanDannyDanielleBob Год назад +1

    Is the molle robust enough to handle the weight of a holster, canteen, or rifle mag pouches?

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад

      They seam to be well stitched. The year will tell.

  • @Swearengen1980
    @Swearengen1980 10 месяцев назад

    Actually looks like a good attempt. 5.11 makes some quality stuff, but their obsession with tactical and heavy weights was always a turn off for gear. Just not a over-MOLLE'd look. For my preference, still falls short of Kuiu gear. My Kuiu Pro 60L is less than a pound heavier than this 5.11 and is built to haul out a deer. Overbuilt hip belt and shoulder straps are insanely comfortable (and visibly thicker than the 5.11). The Divide series from Kuiu is more comparable and in this price range to the 24-36L, but still has superior padding/comfort level (also removable). Really, it looks like the backpacks are copying Kuiu's design quite a bit. I actually do like the chest rig though. It's a much cheaper (and diverse) option over a chest holster, which is my ideal location to carry the 10mm when wearing a pack. As a more budget friendly option though, well done by 5.11

  • @michaelpatton8427
    @michaelpatton8427 Год назад +1

    I am still pissed that they shut down the amp series.

  • @richardhenry1969
    @richardhenry1969 Год назад +1

    Only someone that’s never served would put their knife on their pack. Something happens and you are forced to drop your pack you have no knife. Next to water a knife is very important.

    • @diomedes39
      @diomedes39 Год назад +1

      It depends on what you are doing. A combat patrol isn’t camping.

    • @bigchief4044
      @bigchief4044 Год назад

      lol

  • @bigcat99100
    @bigcat99100 Год назад

    6'2"?? i been watching you since I was a kid I never knew you were that tall.

  • @user-cx7cv1qf8y
    @user-cx7cv1qf8y Год назад

    Will the hip belt from the 511 fit on your mystery ranch coulee 25??? (At first glance it looks like it might) I tried the mystery ranch with my hill people gear chest rig the other day…loved the mystery ranch pack except the flimsy belt doesn’t carry much load.

  • @GotYarbles
    @GotYarbles Год назад +16

    Because 5.11 is ripping them off?

    • @chriscrawford3809
      @chriscrawford3809 Год назад

      Wow complete ripoff!

    • @scottjohnson360
      @scottjohnson360 Год назад

      No surprise there

    • @Owl566
      @Owl566 Год назад +1

      Capitalism- free market. Makes products better

    • @RJxMacReady
      @RJxMacReady 10 месяцев назад +1

      @@Owl566lol. HPG has theirs made in the US with a solid warranty. Seriously doubt you are getting that from 5.11.

    • @Owl566
      @Owl566 10 месяцев назад

      @@RJxMacReadyif 5.11 get enough of the market share watch HPG offer more for less… see what I mean?

  • @khomatech6428
    @khomatech6428 Год назад +1

    no

  • @user-fp6cj2ju2v
    @user-fp6cj2ju2v Год назад +1

    How did you attach the bear spray holster to the chest pack?

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад +1

      Ranger bands!! Great little items

    • @user-fp6cj2ju2v
      @user-fp6cj2ju2v Год назад

      Ok one more dumb question. This vs the LA pack for use with back pack, using Sbiner to attach to shoulder straps?

  • @TheOutdoorFile
    @TheOutdoorFile 6 месяцев назад

    I do not personally care for the materials used and construction of most 511 products

  • @chriscrawford3809
    @chriscrawford3809 Год назад +1

    511’s products are decent quality, but not up to the standards of HPG. IMO I’ll stick with my HPG because of this and the fact it’s a small business with A++ customer service!

  • @KellenQuinn-ls2iv
    @KellenQuinn-ls2iv Год назад +1

    Out of curiosity - I really like that the weight of this setup seems to be quite a bit lower than the the weight of the Hill People Gear system. I currently own an Umlindi v2. I agree with your criticisms about the awkward compression system on this pack, but do you think the 36L Skyweight pack would be worth ditching the Umlindi? I'm 6'3, so I can definitely relate to being tall. I love the versatility of HPG - but the fabric is so heavy.

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад

      That’s a great question. I am not sure since I don’t on that one currently. 36 L is a pretty large pack so unless you have a lot of equipment and may seem like a lot of access space wasted?

  • @JohnDoe-zb7dz
    @JohnDoe-zb7dz Год назад

    I like the chest pack but I'm a lefty so no deal.

    • @wavemakersdj
      @wavemakersdj 4 месяца назад

      Why does lefty matter? It has zippers on both sides.....

    • @JohnDoe-zb7dz
      @JohnDoe-zb7dz 4 месяца назад

      @@wavemakersdj Because the zipper on the chest pouch only zips one way, from right to left. As a lefty I want to draw from the left.

  • @weedfiendofthewasteland3616
    @weedfiendofthewasteland3616 Год назад +2

    5.11 is overbuilt? You mean overpriced, don't you?😂

  • @Omar20v
    @Omar20v 6 месяцев назад +1

    Lol.. imagine using 5.11 anything

    • @wavemakersdj
      @wavemakersdj 4 месяца назад

      What's wrong with 5.11? They have lots of great products, it's just fashionable in the space to diss them so people like to do it all the time. They usually make excellent products.

  • @Hayyothhakodesh
    @Hayyothhakodesh Год назад +1

    Hill People Gear I own tons of their stuff. And I find them way more module. The decker frames with decker pockets, bags, upon bags and panels and their prairie belt and recon belt and straps and the list so goes on. It's more technical but if u have just a bit of small skill upl be way happier and much higher quality. 5.11 did that terrible compression strap which just speaks of inexperience and not really thought thru. Hill people gear thinks of everything that works so well. Mystery ranch is also a classic that has unparalleled construction. Kifaru too. And now new companies r springing up and doin great things like cottage companies. I own soooo many packs and I started with 5.11 of which i own 6 packs of theirs. Their a beginner company and cheaper. I think their good for people starting out till they find their actual go to company. 5.11 is McDonald's of tactical and decent bags. But their not Hill People or Mystery ranch or kifaru or eberlestock, tactical tailor or even exo mountain etc etc. 5.11=McDonald's. I use my 5 11 for storage bags now. I even had a sternum strap totally snap off of one of my rush 72s. Bad design to the plastics of how it hooks onto the shoulder straps .

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад

      Thanks for the good feedback and comment! 👍

    • @allenclawson6638
      @allenclawson6638 Год назад

      ⁠@@Hayyothhakodeshit’s obviously a opinion, first and for most I would never I mean ever consider a hill people hear bag over 5.11. Working on a military base where a navy seal compound and where they do sniper training for the spec ops teams, I’ve seen and asked a lot about what bags they use and what works for them in the field actual tactical use. Their go to is
      Kelty
      511
      Not saying everyone uses those but to say 511 is the McDonald’s of tactical bags is hilarious

  • @Hudson4426
    @Hudson4426 11 месяцев назад +1

    Meh… for the price I’ll buy better gear

  • @BOOSTEDLASER
    @BOOSTEDLASER Год назад +2

    WISH HPG LARGE KIT BAG WAS 1/3 LARGER

  • @kene3431
    @kene3431 Год назад +1

    Made in Vietnam, hard pass.

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад +1

      I hear you but I Not sure of two many packs not made in Asia somewhere??

    • @kene3431
      @kene3431 Год назад +2

      @@gideonstactical true, but I will go out of my way and spend more to buy products made with American labor with US owned businesses. Hill People Gear is made right down the road from me in Fenton Missouri at First Spear. Spending my money "local" not only ovoids supporting countries that dislike us, but helps the economy and ultimately myself. Not to mention 99 times out of 100 I am getting a superior product. I don't mind products from Japan or other friendly nations. I think it our moral responsibility to spend money with companies that allign with our values. Your mileage may vary, Unfortunately most people are just thinking about saving a few bucks not looking at the long term ramifications.

  • @Sleepyjackable
    @Sleepyjackable Год назад +1

    5.11 is the harbor freight of tactical gear. HPG and MR are going to be just fine.

    • @gideonstactical
      @gideonstactical  Год назад +1

      Ha ha ha ha I love it

    • @allenclawson6638
      @allenclawson6638 Год назад

      Chest rigs in general you’re correct, as far as bags HPG doesn’t come close to 5.11. And as for mystery ranch just because something costs more doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a better product.
      I would argue the rush bags are way more versatile then anything mystery ranch has to offer just my opinion.