Netanagri में सावरकर की माफी पर भिड़ंत, JNU प्रोफेसर और इतिहासकार विक्रम संपत में हुई खूब बहस
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 31 июл 2024
- In today’s episode of The Lallantop’s Netanagri, editor Saurabh Dwivedi joined by Vikram Sampath, author of Savarkar: Echoes of a forgotten past, and Prof. Aditya Mukherjee, formerly with JNU. They are discussing the ongoing debate around Mahatma Gandhi's persuasion, a reason behind Savarvar writing a mercy petition. This debate is a result of Union Defence Minister Rajnath Singh's statement claiming that Savarkar had written the mercy petition on Gandhi's instructions. Follow the threadbare discussion for more details.
In the second segment of Netanagri, Saurabh Dwivedi digs into the debate with Rahul Shrivastava, political editor, India Today TV, and Himanshu Mishra, deputy editor, India Today TV around disgruntled BJP MP Varun Gandhi. Recently, both Varun and his mother, Maneka Gandhi, were dropped from BJP's national council. Varun has been public about his criticisms about the handling of the farmers' protest, especially about the Lakhimpur incident.
In the third, Saurabh Dwivedi is in conversation with Shams Tahir Khan, senior executive editor at India Today group, and Sahil Joshi, senior executive editor at India Today group, regarding the arrest and then denial of bail to Aryan Khan, son of Bollywood superstar Shahrukh Khan, in the drugs-on-cruise case of Mumbai. Aryan Khan was arrested on October 3, in connection with the seizure of banned drugs on-board a cruise ship. The Narcotics Control Bureau has accused Aryan of procuring drugs, however, Aryan's counsel has maintained that he was in possession of any drugs during the raid.
And in the last segment, host Nikhil is in conversation with Saurabh, known as Sawal Jawab session, along with some recommendations. Watch this latest episode of The Lallantop’s Netanagri to get unparalleled political ground insights.
आप शहीद भगत सिंह द्वारा लिखा गया 'बम का दर्शन' यहां पढ़ सकते हैं- www.thelallantop.com/bherant/...
आप नेतानगरी के पिछले एपिसोड्स यहां देख सकते हैं: • Neta Nagri | नेता नगर...
Timecodes:
00:00- Opening
02:29-Politics over History Segment
01:19:00-UP(Varun Gandhi) Segment
01:51:11-Mumbai(Aryan Khan) Segment
02:20:22- Fursat ki salah
02:23:25-Ending Note
हमारे नए चैनल Lallantop UP को यहां जाकर सब्सक्राइब करें-
/ @lallantopup
Lallantop UP के फेसबुक पेज को भी लाइक करें: / lallantopup
Install The Lallantop Android App: thelallantop.app.link/zCSsHooQSU
Follow us on: / thelallantop
Like The Lallantop on Facebook: / thelallantop
Follow The Lallantop on Twitter: / thelallantop
For advertisements e-mail us at: Ads@thelallantop.com
Watch Lallantop Documentaries: bit.ly/3dSu8tj
Produced By: The Lallantop
Edited By: Maneesh Negi
I greatly admire Mr Sampat for his honesty and knowledge. Salute Sir
I am totally agreed with Dr. Vikram.
from Jharkhand.
Dr Vikram Sampath ji completely owned this debate. I feel historians like Mukherjee are opposing these ideas just because they've written books on history only through the lens of one narrative and admitting that will lead to complete disregard of their business, but what they don't realize is that their history books will be read less and less as people of the country realize the truth.
They have written history on the basis of patronage
They are not historian but Congressi Pet !!
विक्रम सम्पत चोर है
We should put out the clemency petitions then discuss. I have read them, so poor in taste. Bhagat Singh who is just 23 yrs old, refused to file any such petition, whereas deceitful Sarvarkar by lying and prostrating to English law. Shameful!
@@suchmooch603 Did you not hear the explanation given with examples by Vikram and Mukherjee?
Mr Mukherjee is telling the same narrative we were taught in schools, which was hard to believe to many even at a young age. Hats off to Mr Vikram Sampat’s broader views.
Hats off to young energetic dynamic historian Vikram ji...
Bang on factual no nonsense talks...
We need more scholar like u, unbiased and true to the history, not whitewash it or politically correct...
Keep it on Sir ☺️☺️
He is 43 .
@@krishnashrivastava8364rahul is still a young netaji after crossing the age of 50
Why people of North apply their logic of rajputs and tej bahadur ji' seer kata denge par jhukayenge nahi ' saab app hare the jyada idealism ko manke 😂
Shivaji maharaj ne khud ko choota batane ko strategy banaya tha called as hide your strength to fool enemy.
Wo realistic the isliye mughlo ko marathe kadmo par lane me safal hue.
For shivaji maharaj and savarkar ultimate result was priority rather then compromise in way to archive it. 😅
पहले तो लल्लनटॉप को साधुवाद।
मैं सावरकर जी को जानता नही था, मतलब सिर्फ नाम सुना था। लेकिन इस बहस में दोनों ने दमदार बातें कहीं लेकिन फिर भी विक्रम जी की बाते कहीं न कहीं अधिक उचित रही । मैं विक्रम जी से सहमत हो पाया हुँ।
I am 73 years old ,they teach us how to write applications and we are told to use ,faithfully , obedient and these kind of words in independent Indian schools
Thousand kudos to the podcast and Mr Sampat for the truth and the total animical stance of the Commies and Congress to our Bharat
Vikram is making me realize that we the younger generation can also create change . Thanks Vikram
What change you want? Everything is great under Modi and Shah ? Sampath is also right wing and like many minor bhakts ready to display his ignorance.
@@ladusingh2141 aa gaye leftist libtards to spread hate. Bachpan ka pyaar for leftist is hate.
He is giving reference of so called politician private secret chats, was he gone there with Time machine. Typical whatsapp chutiyapa
@@AvinashKumar-xl2vv he is a historian - only if you understand that
@@ladusingh2141 so what you want we should only read pigfan habib? that third rated lier?
Bikram Sampath rocks . History should be unbiased
After 57:30 professor ji didn't throw in facts to counter Sampath Ji.... He felt shattered and got emotional and kept flooding emotions over facts or to say he tried to keep alive his narrative driven by emotions, Vikram on the other hand kept correcting him...
Debate was awesome...
Vikram is Treasure. Not because of the narrative but the honest efforts in bringing out the truth backed by facts
Another one bites the dust.. Kudos to Vikram 😀😀
One of the finest Discussion on very important topic.. thanks Dr Vikram Sampath for throwing brighter light on Veer Sawarkar and the truth behind his ple. Also you put forth rightly the contribution of many movements in freedom struggle. The Leftist history and biasing of Muslim rulers and fading the real History of Indian subcontinent...
It's apparent that Vikram Sampath's presentation of arguments and facts was incredibly compelling. While Professor Mukherjee from JNU appeared to struggle, relying more on emotional appeal rather than factual evidence. It's intriguing to note the prevalence of left-leaning intellectuals from JNU, a phenomenon that prompts further exploration.
Witnessing Prof. Mukherjee's thorough dismantling by Vikram through logical arguments and factual evidence brought a sense of satisfaction.
वीर सावरकर जी ने 11वर्ष काला पानी की सजा भोगी हे अत्यंत कठीन परिस्थिती मे जीवित रहे सिर्फ अपने देश भक्ति को समर्पित किया. नमन शत शत नमन
I am totally sold by Vikram Sampath's logical arguments.
What a great man!
The problem for old historian is that young people are started questioning and we believe in facts 😊 great debate Dr Vikram you have gained a new fan today 🙏💪
I second u
Me too
Why are u fan of a historian?
@@ahan106 because we are not fan of ganjediyans
ए जो विद्वता का बखान कर रहे हैं ए महोदय एक दिन भी सेलुलर जेल में नहीं रहे हैं किन्तु फिर भी सावरकर को पूर्ण रूप से गलत साबित कर रहा है । यह मूर्ख मुखर्जी उनकी लाइफ के संघर्स को कमतर करके बता रहा है ये लोग बड़े कृतघ्नता में डूबे हुए हैं इनका फ्रीडम में कोई सहयोग नहीं है । किन्तु फिर भी सावरकर जैसे वीरों को गाली देते हैं । मेरे विचार से इनका मुह नोच लेना चाहिए । दोनो भाई 18से52 साल तक जेल में रहे इतना बड़ा दुख उठाया फिर भी उन्हें कायर बताते हैं इससे बड़े वेदनपूरन दूसरी बात नहीं हो सकता है
Mr.Dwivedi ,It is expected that at least you will address Mr. SAVARKAR with due respect.
1:17:05 - Vikram Sampath completely demolished Mukherjee's argument in roughly 35 secs 👍
Absolutely
विक्रम जी की जानकारी अद्भुत है , कई सवालों के जवाब मिले । धन्यवाद
Nice debate. Young historian Vikram Sampat was so much factual. Hats off. We need this type of scholars in every field in India🇮🇳.
Leftist destroyed..they are intellectual till no one question them.. the moment they are questioned they start rhetoric.
He is a closet sanghi...but with a charming smile
He is not a historian
Please dont display ignorance. History is not about facts. It is about the relationships between fact and interpretation. Read E.H. Carr and tells you why Sampat is off key and has a long way to go before he calls himself a historian.
@@ladusingh2141 historians should display the findings not to interp...
Most civilised and fact based debate of this century I would say👏👏
No JNU professors 👨🏫 will face Vikram Sampath! You nailed him
If there had to be a nutshell version of how left in India operates, Mr. Mukherjee right here in this debate is a testament to it. Thank you Dr. Sampath.
rightly said
And also how the right operates Sampath chap is a testament to that!!!!!
very good discussions &argument a treat to the brain .
@@truth7653 why your ass Is burning, bawasir ho gya hai to dawa le lo
shubham tiwari, here comes an RSS bajrang dal Godse wala thug. Kala topi, half pant, stick in hand Mohan Bhagwat stooge!!
Hats off to Vikram Sampat ji.. The amount of research that would have gone into offering an alternative narration of history which is missing from our mainstream history is just inspiring. 🙏
Sampat means ghandh
Is not hero of India independent.sawaker is the hero of our country
@@mahboobahmad4060 n vikram sampath ji jo hua h vo usko hi to bata re h....agr tum samajhte ho ki vo galat keh re h to counter kro....democracy h ...daro ni.mobile se bahar ni ayega koi
@@mahboobahmad4060 Abdul sometimes think rationally beyond ur religion
@@mahboobahmad4060 where he called Gandhiji was not a hero....he just pointed out what is wrong is to brush aside full interpretation of other heroes like subhas Chandra Bose and Bhagat Singh in order just to make Gandhi and congress even bigger than it really was ......
Point is Gandhiji was undoubtedly great but equally or even more was the role of Netaji in freeing india......
And also gandhi was hero does not mean Savarkar was villain
Shubham Trivedi:: prayer for
Climency was right or wrong, is endless debate. so let us stop it.
A big question is what was the contribution of sawarkar in freedom
What did he do extraordinary or sacrificed for the nation for which He shuold be honourned with "Bharat Ratna."?
थैंक्स विक्रम संपत सर, आपने सावरकर की इज्जत पर बहुत शानदार बात कही है, वामपंथियों को तगड़ा जबाब दिया है.
I am totally agreed with Dr. Vikram
from Jharkhand.
JNU Leftist Professor so poor with facts.
Well done Vikram Sampath 👍
Bhagat singh & Netaji leftist thhe woh bhi poor 🥹?
@@kritagya.Rajawat are bhai tab right wing matlab Congress gandhi ka sath tab. to leftist ka alag hi defination tha
@@kritagya.Rajawat Left has the monopoly of revolution against the State, no doubt about that, therefore all revolutionists aka "krantikaris" were leftists. The question is, what is INDn left revolting against now? against whom? the INDn State?
@@kritagya.Rajawat who said wo log leftist the
@@kritagya.Rajawat yha sentence m noun professor hain, or adjective leftist h....so don't mix bhagat singh (the Legend) with these rascals
What a debate! Vikram and Sai, these guys are changing the discourse of our history. Watch Sai discussion with Shashi Tharoor, the way he is destroying Shashi is worth watching.
Sanjeev Sanyal is also worth listening.
@@anuragmishra6691 👌
@Vidhi ....very true
Very nicely hostly debate Saurabh on such a contested topic. I am from Mumbai so I have heard about Vir Savarkar since my school days and I never knew that he was so misunderstood. Vikram Sampath did such a fine job to explain Vir Savarkar and highlight very important point that all different ideas which worked during freedom movement and Congress/MK Gandhi was not the only freedom movement. If this was a trial then my vote is for Vikram Sampat's argument.
Vikram, please keep up the good work. I have just bought your book after listening to this as I am sure I will learn a lot from your book.
Jabardast Vikram sampath ji... Pranam🙏🕉🚩
Nikhil is the most disappointed person here because today he got some knowledge about the *History*
Love You Sampath, Sir!!! Killed it❤️
El bar ko lga nikhil bhai apna screen pause markar chale gye
निखिल जी समझदार हैं उनको यह अच्छे से मालूम है कि कहां मुँह बिल्कुल नहीं खोलना है।
@@dushyantks haha .. vaise uska contribution bhi etana hi hai 🤣
He is always like that because he is that kind of journalists who don't have .0001% of knowledge about history ...he is just good example of progressive person who achieve his position by doing "chatukarita"
@@amitsingh-si8vd true 😂
Vikram Bhaiya, you are a shining light in appropriating Indian History in the very correct way🙏🏻
India will always indebted by the sacrifices of Veer Savarkar.
Sadar Naman
🙏🙏🙏🙏
Being so young Dr, Vikram can be way more sarcastic than the professor yet he choose to be on point, no laughing chuckling about anyone just facts and views of many person, and so polite that itself nailed the debate on the other hand the professor knowledge and points are so weaker that it looks like did he even the right person to debate on this with Dr. Sampath. I read you Vikram and your writings with so many quoted facts gives a very large knowledge base if someone goes by each quoted facts.
Amazing debate! Vikram is amazing, and well informed historian.
The debate continues no doubt for ever because east cannot meet west! How shrewd and shameless when you are always dragging Baba Saheb Ambedkar in so many instances!! Unfortunately this is how you people were the champions of Casteism in India!!!
@@udaymarndi139 No, it's totally opposite.
Bringing Dr Ambedkar here with his views was right as he took different take than Gandhi and congress almost always but no historian will dare to take his name in bad light due to his unchallenged position in India today.........but bcz Savarkar has no following like Baba Saheb he will be abused just bcz he took congress and gandhiji head on..and this is double standard our great historians have been showing since independence.
@@udaymarndi139 and please i will like to know from you why Dr Ambedkar should not be bring??
He had written and spoken on every major issue concern to us as collective indians that is still haunting us...
@@udaymarndi139 baba saheb vi anrej o ka chusta tha. 😂. Unka khuda writings paro , fir ana bak bak karne.
Mr. sampat was absolutely bang on!!! What a lovely discussion by him. That man was factually so strong to the point.
बहुत ही सुंदर... ऐसी इतिहास विषयक सभ्य बहस देख के मन प्रफुल्लित हो गया। दिमाग को ज्ञान का खुराक मिल गया... ऐसी तथ्यपूर्ण बातें करने वाले महमानो को लाते रहिए। सौरभ जी आपका और आपके संपूर्ण सहयोगी दल का बहुत बहुत शुक्रिया, अभिनंदन!
Inspite of true sincere historian, mr sampat has a great sense of patriotism!!thanks!! Hats off.
विक्रम सम्पत जी, जे॰एन॰यू॰ गैंग को आज आपने अक़ेले ही धो डाला।
वाह लाजवाब।
“सत्य प्रताड़ित हो सकता है लैकिन परास्त नहीं हो सकता।”
🙏🙏🙏🙏
So JNU se to saurabh dewedi bhi h kya unko bhi bol rhe and second JNU is best collage of India
Sampath Dalal Jo mafi mange Veer nahin ho sakta Vada Lal aur Gaddar angrejon ka Dalal angrejon ka
Sampat saral sabko pata hai Veer kabhi mafi nahin manta
Sab log mafi mangte to Desh Azad Ho Gaya hota
Tum jaise angrejo ke Dalal
ऐसी तर्क संगत बहस हमेशा होते रहनी चाहिये संपत जी के तर्क बहुत शानदार थे |आशा करती हूँ कि आप फिर से किसी विषय को लेकर संपत जी से बात करें |
What logic he gave instead of being emotional partial ???
@@aakashsharma920 listen 👂
@@aakashsharma920 other guy was being emotional partial not Vikram
😱😱😱@@aakashsharma920
Hats off to you Vikram bhai... Love u alot.
Vikram sir. RESPECT.
Agar hme ap jaise teacher and professors mile hote to aj Hamara future bhi kuch aur hota.
Apke jaise teacher and professors har school and college me hone chahiye. Love from me sir.
Humble people with great knowledge.
First time ,I am seeing emerging scholars from other side. Sampath totally slayed the so called left intellectual.
बोहोत है लेकिन कोई सुनता नहीं. thanks lallantop ये लोग ने atleqst बुलाया
So called? Leftists are para site
Vikram Sampath rocks man…!! This is how we do peer reviewing in medicine..!! The JNU prof was looking clueless and was trying his level best to sound credible.. god save JNU if it had such low iq profs..!! If the JNU prof had to defend his thesis in front of examiners he would have failed miserably..!! Thoroughly disappointed with the JNU “History” prof…
Which peer-reviewed Paper (or Thesis) is in favour of Vikram Sampath's sayings?
Which peer-reviewed Paper {or Thesis} is against Professor Aaditya Mukherjee?
You can't say about JNU they also have graduates like saurabh ❤
Sampat has agreed on almost all the count of what the prof said but in another tone.
Leftists are lo w IQ
Awesome Mr Sampath you nailed it, actually professor had nothing to say.
Nice presentation Vikram Sampat Sir. 🙏
No word for Vikram . what a historien and knowleage he has .One of the best netanagri épisode
Vikram sir seems quite rational.... I was shocked listening to him.
विक्रम पक्का अंधभक्त है,
@@CH-ng8ei और तुम पक्के वामपंथी देश के 40 टुकड़े करने वाले चीन और भारत के युद्ध में अपने जवानों को खून नहीं देने का अभियान चलाने वाले वामपंथी कम्युनिस्ट कांग्रेस के चमचे तुम लोगों को हकीकत बताओ तो तुम लोगों को पक्का मिर्ची लग जाती है बाद में तुम्हें कुछ रहने को नहीं रहता तो तुम लोग अंधभक्त कह देते हो🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@CH-ng8ei Prof. Mukherjee real account se aao 🙄
I am now 55 yrs old from Marathi family and die hard supporter of Savarkar as was Lata Mangeshkar and her entire family. But I am happy to see now that younger generation throughout Bharat has changed completely. Blessed you all, enough of Gandhi and Chacha support.
Sir how do you see support for savarkar during your time and now?
@@NoVideo2024 In Maharashtra or to be precise in Mumbai where I was born and brought. Everybody in Marathi community may it be schedule caste, Brahmins, Maratha etc. Everybody had tremendous respect. There used to be frequent lectures, sabhas on Savarkar and his thoughts. I distinctively remember in our school 8th std i think one of my female colleague gave such a brilliant speech and won prize(where she also criticized MK Gandhi and his non-violence teachings). Even on all India radio Savarkars poem "ne maza she ne parat matru bhumila..." was played zillion times sung by Mangeshkar family with lead singer as Latabai (Latabai was very nasty when somebody use to say ill on Savarkar. She and her father Dinanath were best friends).
On political virtually all the political parties in Maharashtra use to respected him. I guess when crooks like Sharad Pawar, 3rd rated backward class leaders like Prakash Ambedkar started this anti-Savarkar speeches. But luckily no one takes them seriously.
But the big surprise is from Northern India and also from W.Bengal after 2014 and thanks to people like Vikram Sampath and others the support for Savarkar and his thoughts have reached at such a level that Maharashtra pales in comparison. But I am super happy that people especially youngster like you are thinking independently and in right manner keep it up our Bharat has bright future. As B. R. Ambedkar said "Gandhi will soon be memory of distant past".
One of the best debates and discussions.
Respect to both the participants. Saurabh rightly summed up that we felt being in a history class, being taught by two experts. Thanks for this episode.🙏🙏
Mr.Mukherjee is struggling to present his version of history😀😀😀 and mr. Sampat just nailed it throughout the debate👍👍👍
He is maharashtrian and knows and read Savarkars and babasaheb ambedkar s books and profesor sahab toh marathi jante nahi unko sirf congress ne likha hua history pata hai 😂
Prof. Aditya Mukherjee lost his hold on Rationality and started making emotional comments, is a Testimony of his defeat in the debate.. I think, Mr Vikram Sampath made very cogent arguments without loosing his cool. He has won this debate..👍
That's the problem with leftist
agree with you
Yes, he also made a few personal comments, while saying that ‘Vikarm bhi What’sapp jaisa narrative ki side ja rehe hain’ and fer aak politician k opinion k basis pe Savarkar ko bolna k wo Gandhi ji k murder mai involved the jab supreme court tak ne kuch ni paya….ajeeb historian h🤷🏻♂️
Aditya mukarjee jaise log, apne under kisi neural opinion wale student ko PHD karne dete honge? Never. Yahi issue h leftist historians ka, wo apne side ki hi story endorse karte hain, politician ban jate hain
Now one can Safely say that ANDH BHAKTS are everywhere in every ideology. No matter how one label themselves as Leftist, Historian , Liberal, Secular, Progressive.
Out of almost 5000 comments more than 90% people are impressed by Vikram Sampath it means history should be well supported by facts and not to support a particular narrative.
Vikram sampath is genius. Well researched, eloquent, calmly replying to illogical points.
Sampat Rocks....India needs more historians like Vikram Sampat
Not Dear Like Vikram Sir
Bhai books padiye official journal read kariye phir agar savaarkar or rss ko gaali na do guarantee ha... Sahab inka rss hindu mahasabha, savaarkar ka itihaas rha ha chaakri ka
@@shubham-uc6ih they trust only 5 years old history of what's app. 🤣
@@jalkaura ye flat earth gang.
He is whatsapp 🌟
44th minute onwards is pure gold . Vikram
Sampath completely roasts the JNU professor.
Khud roast hogaya Vikram uske age ka dekho😂
Abe bhang kha k dekh rha hai kya??
baba dhongi hote h aur bhakt gadha hote h? ye h secularism?
India k muslim dekh lo 8cr se 28 cr, aur Bangladesh m hindu dekh lo 28 cr se 8cr pahonch gaye (1947 census). parivarwad desh ka gaan* mar diya h.
desh ko jihadyon se nahin librandon se khatra h.
@@pratham665 age matter nhi krti facts krte h. Narratives bna k history ni chalti.
@@AshishSharma-bj8hh ye yhi krte h victim nd lachari card khelenge
V well done Vikram ji, hats off to you …so well articulated, knowledgeable and yet sober…
Professor sahab ki class ho gayi Vikram sir ke sath 😊
Very impressed with Vikram's knowledge and belief system. And I agree with Saurabh, Rahul S should write a book. I for one will read it for sure
M also fan of sampath g bcz ye neutral hokar fact pe baat karte hain
Go to Pakistan
Vikram Ji ki itihaas ki Jaankari dekh kar bahut khushi hui!!
We should not fight over our Great Revolutionary Politicians,be it Savarkar,Gandhi Ji,Bhagat Singh,Neta Ji,Udham Singh and others!!
Kya baat boli vaah debate dialogue theek h jhagda karoge toh azadi ka balidaan toh vyarth gya
@@ahan106 hmm..
I hope,that politicians should also understand that!!
Dont write savarkar or maafkars name along with them not even before tham
@@dapinderjitsingh did you even watch the whole debate?
@@adichauhan3713 yes i did mere basic two lines that both parties are in-fact enough to say so there is no shortage of revolutionaries new names need to be dug out of history
Really liked the conversation/debate....no tamasha....Vikram Sampath is amazing genuise Historian. He's a epitome of Talented historian.
Last Question asked by anchor about keeping Objectivity & truth...was very important.
Hope to see more debates like this. Very knowledgeable
Vikram sampat ji, seriously n simply u nailed it with awesome n factual elaboration of urs. 👍
Discussing Savarkar without the burden of agreeing or disagreeing, is definitely a welcome change. History has to be unbiased.
@@ziaqazi41 he must be glorified because he has sacrificed his life for this country. The next generation must know about him and his ideology.
You have done nothing so pls don't comment on him. I think you are from santipriya majahab
@@ziaqazi41 As Vikram told ; history is not about "nation building" but knowing truth.
@@lawplanet2818 bhai tu gumnaam hi reh
@@nsitpoison aur tu mallech hi reh
@@lawplanet2818 yeah I agreed I think we should give respect all the freedom fighters chahe vo mangal pandey ho ya tilak sayad hm sabko hi bhul gye h and iska use kisi party k mtlb k liye n ho BJP congress aayenge jayenge but we want to know truth
In my opinion the JNU professor not only exposed himself, but also exposed Communists (SA Dange) & Congress! His anger & hate against current BJP government is clearly visible in face & words! That victorious smile betrays defeat!
No one is happy with the atrocities of the current govt 😒
An average JHOLATARD is a Good for nothingJunk
@@indianjaihind4125 what atrocities ? Atrocity , genocide , fascism , dictatorship are words which have immense meaning. Today you using them & nothing happening to you is itself proof against what you allege the current government for .
@@prayagjoshi1179 what ? Check how many time BJP shut down internet, how many they used article 124 , how many people got caught under UAPA just because of they were speaking against BJP .
@@indianjaihind4125 ...
Come with your real name if you are not librandu or commie
It is a debate between emotional Gandhibhakt and a historian 😂
😆😆😆
Mr.vikram sampath ,your presentation was super.Your gentle approach & style of presentation touches a lot.
Vikram Sampath is truly a historian...truthful, honest,unbiased and above all Very very ARTICULATE..Kudos to him🙏👍
Vikram is a veritable intellectual, erudite and very well versed with facts and nuances. He is so articulate and forms his arguments extremely well. He is a gem and I thank Lallantop to bring out such an extraordinary conversation.
Would RSS, BJP and all fringe elements of these feel shame 4 their andhbhakti towards coward savarkar..
@@sujoybiswas7147 Well done bro...your first point is superb...
@@ajazsayed5327 have you read about savarkar Or just got your knowledge from what's app university??
they are all are dancing on Bjp songs ...
1942 movement involved India's p
Savarkar jaisa na koi tha na koi hosakta hai, hamara ahobaghya hai jo unhone is bhumi janam liya koti koti naman 🙏🙏🙏
Bharat Ratna Savarkar 🌹🌹🌹
Thanks Lallantop for holding this debate. Great explanation by Vikramji. Other fellow was clueless at the end on what to talk
Vikram Sampath has nailed this show!!
I am so impressed by dr Vikram ji he is an amazing and well knowledged historian
❤️❤️❤️
Vikram's research in the issue is amazing and reveals a lot of facts not known to us ,he has been clearly prove that the name of saber ker is being slandered by likes of prof mukharji he has nothing new to tell us and has been doing this rhetoric in the past,
@@lalitsingh-hx2ts agree
Worth watching. We need such kind of intellectual debates. Looking forward to have more meaningful discussions which are truly thought provoking. Thanks to Lallantop for bringing such stuffs.
Sampath made Mukherjee sir humble in 15 minutes of interview.
Man Vikram Sampath is such a composed debater!! He completely owned prof. Mukherjee through his factual rebuttals. One can see that Prof. Mukherjee is complete flustered by Vikram's arguments.. I just hope Vikram continues on this path and more power to him as he has now become the prime target of the left ecosystem
वीर सावरकर को नमन 🙏🙏
Great vikram sampat❤❤❤
NCERT should be rewritten.. Vikram Sampath Huge Respect ❤🔥
We need more debates like this.
Mukherjee just putting his interpretation and opinion but Vikram putting Facts.
Maza aa gaya.
Vikram Sampath changed my opinion on Veer Savarkar.He put facts brilliantly. Going to buy his book for sure.
True💯 Agree with you brother
Savarkar become evil for the society after releasing from jail and lived life on British pension.... Like before 1930-1940 jinnah never demanded separate nation and he fought with British and fought cases for Inc members, but it will not wash his Image what he did after.... All it matters what happens in the end. Savarkar is not a Veer
@@sarfarazafzal7038 half truths. Read the book.
@@sarfarazafzal7038 सैयद अहमद खां ने टू नेशन थ्योरी दी थी!
गद्दार, गद्दार ही रहेगे, आखिर अरबों के गुलाम जो है
@@maratha8808.....sukr hai ye ni bola ki Gandhi ji ne two nation theory di th.....maafiveer k kukarmo ko chupana pd rha hai kisi ur ka naam lga kr......
What a debate!!! Such a brilliant analysis by Dr Sampath.
Well Done Mr. Vikram Sampath. Salute to Swatantryaveer Savarkar for his contribution to our Motherland Bharat.
Very impress by Mr Vikram .. respect sir, you have brought so many new dimensions to the over all freedom movement - than what we have been thought in school..
Always hearing Mr Sampat and his Analysis on Veer Savarkar is eye opening.
Absolutely civilised debate
Thank you
Sampat sir is having point seems to be more correct , hope new generation is not deprived of real history
Wow... Vikram sir... I am fan of your... Nice debate between both
It is quite intriguing for me that people like Mr. Mukherjee is a Prof in JNU. He restored to only rhetoric, try to misquote Vikram, and more importantly very close minded for different of opinion. Vikram is just brilliant and crisp and so factual in his presentation.
beacuse of professors like him students of jnu are miaguided and have become antigovt anti indic
Truly agreed brother....and my converation with jnu students....cohort the same mindset as they cannot accept other persons views....how come they are so great
Vikram is giving opinions. Sampath is providing facts.
Looks like planted.
@Abhishek Panigrahi
This should not be intriguing at all. What else do you expect from a JNU prof?
The only criterion to become JNU prof is to peddle leftist agenda and prof Mukherjee is doing what is expected of him.
At one point he mentioned “Discovery of India” as one of the best books on Indian history. That itself is a testimony on his scholarship on Indian history.
One of the reason the discussion in Savarkar is so sensible is there is no Randeep Sardesai. Both guests are learned. I am more impressed by the logical conclusion drawn by Dr. Sampath.
Congratulations Sourabh and Nikhil for your superb work.
Mr. Vikram Sampat Sir you are genius. Super presentation.
Good said shampath ji . Apka bat sahi hai .Abhi ka history par na layak nahi .Pro Indian history .
Prof. Aditya Mukherjee came across as an emotional man with a bias. He should have defended or accepted the "communist leader's" petition letter,, but he chose to ignore it, and give an emotional rhetoric. THIS itself shows that he is selective in his truth . On the other hand, Vikram came across as calm, curious and respectful. Vikram WINS Hands-down.
One is historian, other is history professor in one of the most political college of the nation
@@mandarrane history professor aur historian Abbi isme farak kya hai
@@pratham665 historian will state facts. Professor will bring political angle to cover the fact
Jnu vale pasand is liye nahi hai. Vo mante hum kahe vo sach baki juth. Aur kuch bolte bolte vo has dege jo dekh k hi gussa aata hai. Jab samne vala professionally behave kar rah hai to tum kyu nahi kar rahe. Kuch bi bhonk k chale jate hai ye jnu vale.
It’s opposite Vikram is biased, in fact he is challenging the freedom movement and attempts to demonise Gandhi
57:33 professor reaction 😂😂 Tata bye bye, khel khtam, Well done Vikaram sampat Sir, truly factual analysis 🙏 there are many complex thread in history.
Till now we have read only congress side history,there is strong need to reclaim the history with some other perspective! At last very good conclusion from both fine mind of history,
Sampat You r doing great job 🙏
अंग्रेज़ सावरकर को पेंशन दिया करते थे, साठ रुपए महीना. वो अंग्रेज़ों की कौन सी ऐसी सेवा करते थे, जिसके लिए उनको पेंशन मिलती थी ? वो इस तरह की पेंशन पाने वाले अकेले शख़्स थे। क्योंकि वो अंग्रेजों के लिए मुखबिरी करते थे
@@CH-ng8ei Read books, puncture waley!
This Prof😄 is a joke .. he couldn't stand facts .. he felt like a fish 🐟out of water 💧
😂😂 some people are just follower. All history not mentioned in discovery of India.
@@CH-ng8ei jaake whatsApp pe padhai kr e😁😁😁😁😁
Vikram sampat Ji , Great research , great factual speech ! claps ! You are totally right about NCERT books .I just saw a chapter in my daughters Hindi book , 3rd std CBSE . Bharat ki emaratein . And what are those 1. Taj Mahal , 2. Qutuab Minar , 3)Charminar , 4) Salarjung meuseum and mention of Hussain sagar talav Gibraltor rock with Buddha statue . See the irony , when now some one talking about including facts and balanced content rather than one sided content , people have prb
I become fan of Vikram sir. Great to listen him with such clarity and corroborative facts.
The Debate was very healthy.. Really knowledgeable and factual argument... Both are very knowledgeable person but i really liked sampat sir facts and knowledge... Thankyou team lallantop🙂
👍👍👍
A well organized debate on history. Thanks Saurabh for bringing the historians together and having such a civic debate. Vikram was superb with his clarity.
Thanks Nairjee.,I do agreed with your opinion but Saurabhjee should have taken more initiative to find out other hidden truths which are yet to come.
@@ramanathdash4394 l
A
@@fakhruddinarif6527 njk
History past politics aristotle
Glad to see a very decent and respectful debate. Both the historians were very clear in their conviction.So it is upto us to come to conclusion Thanks to you
Hats off vikram . Joy netaji. Joy revolutionaries ❤❤❤