Mufti Menk's "New Qur'an"?!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 авг 2024
- Mufti Menk's "New Qur'an"?!
Join the Dawah Team by Contributing to one of the following, jazakumAllahukhairan 🤝:
Patreon: / ilmstitute
PayPal: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
GoFundMe: www.gofundme.com/f/ilmstitute...
CashApp: cash.app/$BrotherSaajid
RUclips Membership: / @saajidlipham
📚 Islamic Classes: courses.ilmstitute.com
👕 Merch! (shirts, hoodies, etc.): teespring.com/stores/ilmstitute
🔗 Social Media:
📱 Facebook: / brothersaajid
📱 Twitter: / saajidlipham
📷 Instagram: / brothersaajid
💻 Website: www.ilmstitute.com
🔈 Soundcloud: / user-1260072
🔈 Podcast: itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/i...
God guarantee that Qur'an will remain pure til the end of time. Nobody, nothing can change it. Qur'an will forever be original til the end of time.
That doesn't mean we keep sitting and do nothing if someone tries to play with the holy Quran. It's just like the followers of Prophet Moses who said, "You and your Lord go fight for us."
@@mmkr0000 If it's not in عربية, then it's not القران
@@alfatir14yes but we should not go easy whit this things akhi , and the brother was polite speaking about the subject
@babahadjimohamed9339 It seems most people who are commenting have no idea what they are talking about. It is a 3 volume series. They grouped all Meccan suraat and all Medina suraat. Nothing was left out. Although I don't like this concept, I looked into it before addressing it.
@@alfatir14 To be honest, I thought what would be the point of this, but I couldn't find anything
And this is why the Quran is preserved in its original language AND via memorisation. Something that'll last till the hour comes. May Allah guide us all. Ameen
How many different qirats did your prophet reveal because there isn't one original preserved Quran? Seems like u just fell for the dawah script and didn't fact check or research anything... Well done. 🤙
qirats are dialects but because you don't study arabic you wouldn't know. all the dialects where revealed at the same time. and there is only 1 quran@@emmytones8311
@@emmytones8311 You are the one who did not research well and did not verify the facts. The number of readings is 7, and they do not affect the Qur’an at all, and the Qur’an has been memorized frequently.
@@jarmcar6144 you and no other Muslim can prove that 7 qirats, or any amount, were revealed. It's just another part of the dawah script you fell for... So which readings/recitations of the Quran is the original, preserved one? 🤔
No it won’t last until the day of judgement as the Quran will be taken off earth and their will come a time where the old people will say I remember my
Grandparents use to say their is no god but Allah and the prophet Muhammad may peace be upon him said this alone will give them jannah
The only issue with this is: It's being advertised as Qur'an. It shouldn't. It should be advertised as an independent book simply explaining/teaching which Surahs came first and why, what times, etc.
Exactly. This is my thought exactly.
True
Theyll try to normalize it..the key word is try..cuz all they can do is try
But it is the Holy Qur’an since it contains all the verses from it. It should be called something else of course. The Quran in Chronological order, or something along those lines.
Well spoken my brother well spoken. that's the issue
May Allah guide us all to the straight path 🤲
@@Mark-pb4dnso when someone advice you when you do something wrong, warn you so you stick to the truth is negative? I called that sensitivity. Emotions have no place in islam when it come to correcting others
اللهم آمين آمين
@@Mark-pb4dn I am confused on what make you think that brother Sajid acted with arrogance? Anyway I am not here to debate.
Just say that you are here to back bite those who follow the salafs I get it you don't like them. Leave the rest to Allah.
Shaby Ali please... The man who think that is more knowlegable THAN Allah..
I prefer sticking to the Quran my family got *for free* in Makkah. It has all the Surah in the order established by the companions of the Prophet (Peace and Blessings be upon him) 1400+ years ago.
Bro how to get free Qur'an frm mecca
As my parents are going to Umrah and I want to get one with English translation from there
@@muhammad_al_ayyubi people are giving away qur'an as sadaqah, sometimes they will ask you to confirm that you're going to use it. I’ve been there thats how I know.
@@muhammad_al_ayyubi I have never been here myself yet, but when members of my family went for Hajj or 'Umrah they came back with the Quran, it is fully in Arabic, I don't know if they also give Quran with translation. I believe it is a project funded and started by King Faysal (the previous king of Sa'udi Arabia) as a Sadaqah. Maybe when your parents go there they can ask people working there where to get a copy of the Quran. You can also look online maybe they have a website or maybe someone who has already gone there explains what to do. I hope these infos helps.
May Allah forgive them and accept their 'Umrah.
Bro just say you get the quran we all use, you gave me a lil uneasiness 😭
@@kennethwilliams4371 I wanted to point out the superiority and advantages of the Quran we all use compared to the Quran they are trying to sell.
The Quran needs to maintained as it was revealed to the Prophet (PBUH). Must have the same order, preferably in arabic and english. None of us are authorized to change this.
The Quran isn't in chronological order. Mufti Menk's book seems to intend to present the Meccan surahs in chronological order
@@1001011011010 we don't want any new order, neither Meccan surahs in chronological order nor Madni. Nothing needs to be changed.
@@1001011011010yet he has no right to do that. The Quraan is in the order it was intended to be in and not the order it was revealed.
@@lnoorplaylist
It's not a "new Qur'an", it's a work that presents the results of much study. There is much work out there about the order of revelation. It's not a change to anything, just presenting the results in a practical way for an English-speaking audience.
Maybe you have no interest in the chronological order of revelation, but it is of much scholarly interest.
The idea that this is some "new Qur'an" seems to me to be simply wrong, and this idea is the only thing that people take issue with. If they didn't have this idea (that they hold for some reason), there's nothing objectionable to reading surahs out of published order. How many children learn the last surah long before the second? Etc.
@@abdullahinoor3972
The only objectionable thing here is the concept that it is a "new Qur'an". But this concept is false, as it is not meant to be a "new Qur'an". People read the surahs out of order all the time (ie how many children can recite by heart the last 3 surahs before ever reading the first three?), and the order of revelation is of great value. There are a lot of works concerning the order of revelation as a matter of study, and it can be complicated and difficult for non-Arabic speakers to know which order is correct or appropriate. So publishing what research shows to be the correct chronological order in English is of value, especially being that it is formatted in this way as opposed to just saying, "Chapter such and such was revealed at so and so time".
The only really bad thing is this idea that he is trying to publish a "new Qur'an", but this concept is just not true as to what's happening. As if to push against this idea, it doesn't even contain the Medinan surahs!
Tbh the one who is making problem is the one who promoting and saying "new Quran".. Marketing team in every business is always bunch people who need to be taught the limit of making statement.. This clearly crossed those limit.
Getting viral in marketing isnt always necessary brother & sister, if you product is good & beneficial, insha'Allah it will sell good.
"Do not sell your faith for a paltry price."
Perhaps you didn't watch the video, but it was not promoted as "new". The person addressing the supposed issues used the word "new".
Mufti Menk is a UAE agent to corrupt Islam and Muslims PERIOD.......
@@alfatir14yeah i think people using the word new makes it seem like they’re inventing a new quran. Although they are not . I think the problem is exactly what our brother was explaining in the video . About how they make it seem like a quran but it is actually a translation.But Allah knows Best. May Allah forgive those who are talking bad about these scholars. Ameen
"Do not follow that of which you have no knowledge. Surely the hearing, the sight, the heart - each of these shall be called to account." [17:36]
Walahi, we're truly living in akhira zaman.
I think so too
That's what people used to say in the 70s or so just because people weren't as modest. Subhanallah the world today is alot worse with sexual deviance, lies everywhere, and murder so common. We should mentally prepare ourselves for worse as it could always be worse. However if we stick to the Islam of the early generations we will fine and will be rewarded just like them
You dont i dont know Allah swt knows
Yes, Allah knows, and Allah who knows has given you signs to look for, not just a few signs like 200 years ago, or more signs like in the 70s.
May Allah guide us and give us understanding from and of the Qur'an and his prophet's life and Sunnah.
@@Jdjdjdjjdj1997 when river Euphrates and tigris are empty you still wait akhiruzamaan
I have a book of tafsir that only includes the 30th juz surahs. It's marketed as a short tafsir book, not Qur'an. I think it helped me memorize and have better understanding of the short surahs.
Maybe it would be better if they marketed and titled the book as tafsir of Makkan surahs in historical order, since it only consists of Makkan surahs. I think that would work just fine!
What’s that book called? I’m interested in buying it
A book of Tafseer of the 30th Juz is much different than someone marketing something as the new Quran which has no explanation in it and includes only Makki surahs.
Mufti menk is so tuned with the youth he should know better to not add confusion to the young minds unless there is an another agenda!!
Mufti Menk is a UAE agent to corrupt Islam and Muslims PERIOD.
Some Muslim countries always wanted to take out some Surats of the Quran. This is their first step!
@@eurekacomment5719really? Can u explain?
Watch his reply. What is wrong with some of us muslims?? Why are you so quick to judge?? You should apologise to him. This is disgusting.@@eurekacomment5719
@@eurekacomment5719which surah is removed? If u have proof then u can speak
It's just wrong. And your totally right I was just thinking "bro we have tafsir". People are saying oh it's good for reverts. What?? The sahabas were reverts and later they didn't need to give mekkan surahs only Qurans to the new peoples who were non Arabs who became Muslims. Millions of reverts are fine today with just a normal Quran in their own language, and learning tafaseer. This just feels wrong and only people who look at mufti menk like a celebrity are for this.
How about us " born Muslim" that never learned the deen because our family were ignorant or never practiced
@@noneofyourbuiznessread the original Quran and the tafsir of it I would say. And talk to your parents about Islam, so they learn from you.
@@noneofyourbuizness you can start now
as a revert i learned how shaytan was so patient in misguiding people, it waits generations to establish his misguidance, may Allah guide us,
Brother Sajid you said the truth bro here. jazak Allahu khyr .
I am a revert and until this video I thought it was an “English Quran”. I would have bought it and NOT known there were missing Surahs or that it was out of order. (Unless I had researched the website and read all the “warnings”). I listen to Mufti Menks lectures and seeing him promote this had me excited for something “new”. It is strange to me that 1. It says “Quran” on the cover and in promotion when, in fact, it is NOT a Quran and 2. That anything promoted by a Sheikh, Mufti, etc. needs to come with warnings and further explanation as to why it is not something false or haram. This could have been another beautifully translated Quran, OR could have been another book explaining the Meccan surahs and NOT been promoted as a Quran.
Suppose they have good intention (be it for a complementary reading to learn the context and history chronologically or what not), considering the content, they could go with a title like "The Makkan Surahs in Order of Revelation" or if it's not just the Makkan, "Surahs from Qur'an in Order of Revelation", NOT calling it Qur'an in any way so it wouldn't mislead people to think it as the holy Qur'an.
May Allah protect the ummah and grant them and us all taufeeq.
Welcome to Islam sister. May Allah continue to guide you and of all of us! My sincere advice to you would be to avoid listening to speakers like menk, nouman khan, yasir qadi and those who associate with these kind of guys because they are known to water down Islam and promote only the aspects of Islam that will be accepted by the non Muslims. They will not talk or teach about the most important aspects of Islam like Tawheed, Aqida, The 5 daily prayers (how to perform them and the importance of them), importance Sunnah and staying away from innovations, etc. I know this may be a lot to take in and understand as a revert but try reflect on this. May Allah guide us all and admit us into Paradise on the day of Judgement! Ameen
As a native Arabic who has a very high interest in this subject, I believe the translation of Dr. Mohammad Mahoud Ghali is the most accurate one. He spent about 13 years to finish the translation. You can find it with many others on the site of islamawakened. Dr. Ghali translation is used by many new translators as a reference. He was born in 1920 and past away may Allah reward him Jenna. You can see him here: ruclips.net/video/JMtSRq9WcB8/видео.html
Mufti Menk is not an Islamic scholar. I'm even reluctant to call him Sheikh at the very least. He is a Motivational Speaker. Don't take Serious Islamic Knowledge from Him unless he's telling you the obvious things, like Belief in Only Allah, 5 prayers. Him and his group of Westernized sheikhs are out to please the Disbelievers and misguide many. The prophet ( Peace Be Upon Him) said in. Hadith that what He Feared for Us more than the Trial of Dajjal is Speakers who will speak about Islam without knowledge and misguide many. ( Callers to the Hellfire) There is an organization of Islamic scholars and Menk is not one of them.
@@Zaitoon55😮 I didn't know this. Thanks
Yeaaaah this is all far too much alteration in my view, thank you for the video and information as always brother Saajid.
Guess what Mufti Menk fans are gonna say about this refutation. Something like 'You're just jealous' or 'Give him naseeha in private if you are sincere'. :) I wonder how far we can go with the truth when misguidance is promoted and spread widely in public while naseeha is forced to be given in private.
This is the danger of becoming attached to people on the basis of personality rather than Quran and Sunnah
Who is misguiding anyone ?
This wasn't a refutation
Never have i heard mufti menk giving dawah about tawheed or aqidah just Fluffy Duffy sugar coated stuff
@@Jdjdjdjjdj1997 Are you ready to die on those words? Are there elements of Islam that are fluffy Duffy? Are you insulting الله and His messenger?
MAY Allah bless you me and all Muslims FOREVER AMEEN
Correct me if I'm wrong,
The madani surahs (you know the ones that are omitted from Mufti Menk's book) are the surahs that address people of the book i.e Jews and Christians. In those surahs we find out how jews killed prophets, how they were blasphemous again and again, and especially how madina's jews were dishonest and deceitful, how they tried to poison, murder prophet Muhammad صلى اللّه عليه و سلم
So are we ought to think it's just a coincidence and that the book is just an honest mistake made with pure intentions? Along with its title and marketing?! 🧐
Yes this is exactly why he did this. He is a people pleaser. I'm not saying this just for no reasons but as time passed on his views started to change just to please people
I don't understand Mufti menk really. But his yk speeches and stuff are helpful ig.
But like showing his lifestyle and stuff ( not exactly sure) but many sheikhs say not to share your lifestyle.. so idk. May Allah guide us all
💯…. Also the Madani Surahs are the ones that have the Aayaat of Jihaad…. Which liberals want to change and give their own interpretation to
You've got it. 100%. Now add the salafi part, and you'd have hit the trifecta
@@Mohazz88if menk is a Salafi then I'm the Pope 😂
Jazakallah Khairan Katsiran. May Allah always grant us guidance.
Ameen
I made an exact point like this on my tiktok regarding this. New muslims can purchase this book believing it is a quranic translation and therefore making more people confused because of it.
Thanks for sharing Brother Saajid🇵🇸❤️
The strongest opinion in the order of the surahs and ayaahs in Qur'an is that all of them has been directed by Rasulullah shallallahu alaihi wassalam, like which ayaah included in which surah. I'm not sure the intention of this order of the Qur'an but I'm extremely skeptical on any other order of the Qur'an.
Edit: "The new Quran as revealed"...
Even so it doesn't sit well, that "as" is so tiny the least they could've done was make "AS" in bold caps which might have made it seem just a little less misleading.
Intial comment:
In these times we really don't need something referred to as "the new Qur-an" new testament astaghfirullaah
They could've called it something related to what they did instead of calling it the new Qur-an 🤦♀️ example "the surahs as they were revealed..." or something!
this book isnt called the new Quran tho...it's called "the Quran as revealed mekkan edition". Everyone is saying it should be titled in the way that it already is titled..
@@jadengabban8370
I saw yes but it's still misleading & just weird that's why my suggestion was "the surah as revealed" so it's clearly distingushable from the Quran so it does not become a source of even more confusion amongst an already disunited ummah 😔
@@logicalconspiracist7741 i understand your point, i think some people might buy it thinking its a Quran when it isnt so i understand wanting to avoid confusion and i agree on that. But it think that people are making it a bigger deal than it really is in the sense that im hearing a lot of people criticizing them for calling it "new Quran" when to be honest I've never heard the people who worked on this call it that, which is pretty unfair, people are criticizing Mufti Menk for making a book called new Quran when the people doing the criticism are the only ones calling it that. And theres already collections of surahs in chronological order, I think a fairer criticism is that i saw on some covers it doesnt say its only the makkan surahs, im guessing they might have changed the title tho. I agree with having a more unambiguous title as to not divide the ummah but i do disagree with the drama itself and I think that it's being fuelled by misinformation
@@logicalconspiracist7741 and I do agree that they could have avoided putting "Quran" im the title since its only makkan surahs so its incomplete. I think people would be a lot more lenient on this if it included the medinan surahs as well. I guess the upside of putting Quran in the name is that non muslims can understand what it is as they arent familiar with terms like surah, but again the downside with that is it may cause confusion
Ikhwan before you listen to a public speaker find out where he learnt from, if he has a title next to his name find out where he got it from. Lastly and most importantly learn your Aqeedah and by the permission of Allah you will be able to distinguish who to listen to and who you shouldn’t.
Be cautious of a person who doesn’t make his Aqeedah clear
BarakAllahu feek akhi Saajid for this vid
Before i listen to Somebody i do research who is his Sheikh etc what is his manhaj if i see he is not revealing his aqeedah like mufti menk then i know enough and will not follow him that a sign that he is defiant if i see a duat or Sheikh is following the salaf then i will listen to him
Alhamdulillah for the aqeeda content on salafi publications
I don’t ’think it’s about aqeedah here ! I am worried the the christians on tiktok live will make a big deal out of it and claiming muslims have a new Quran ! They do make shubuhaat in the heart of new muslims and also born muslims who are not well-versed
@@Jdjdjdjjdj1997AMAU
At the end of the day nothing should be omitted.
The title of the book should be "Quranic surah as revealed" or "Quranic Ayat as revealed"
Once more, well said, brother. Jazakallahu kheiran for the beneficial clarifications to enlighten common Muslims over these deviant trends that are trying to water down the Deen or create confusion.
How can a "mufti" be so short sighted?
Things happen. We all try our best
@@alphauno6614Were the people around him short sighted as well? I hope not,
@@alphauno6614 u realise brand promos like this take weeks if not months to sort out. Not to mention coming up with the idea, taking it to the manufacturers, actually making it etc....
@@Madmarkhor I can see how this could've been seen as a good idea in the moment. The content of the book, I'm sure you don't object to, right? The only objection is the title and the branding this book got. To castigate Mufti Menk over a possibly inappropriate branding campaign and try to reject him altogether like many of the commenters here are doing, in my opinion is short sighted.
We all make mistakes - Mufti, you and me. No one can see the future except Allah (and who builds a Time Machine). Best we can do is try out best and make dua.
@@alphauno6614 the context of the book where its a 95% rip off of a national geographic spread with maybe 10 lines on each page? Yes,akh i object to that massively.
i understand youve come to this particualr party late: rejection of Menk is not based solely on this issue. People in the comments understand its his aqidah in which we primarily reject him. Any scandals that come from him is ultimately a result of such a deviated aqidah.
I think understand what Mufti Menk is trying to do. Basically if someone wants to learn when the surahs were revealed in chronological order. It's good for studying but I would not call it a Quran
I'm fine chronological order, but incomplete and calling it new Quran? It shouldn't be called a Quran.
Totally agree with you brother, it shouldn't be given this title. No such thing as new Quran. May Allah, The Most Merciful guide us on the straight path. Jazaak Allaahu khayran for letting us know.
Thank you brother for pointing it out so politely. You have articulated the problem really well. I'm glad i didn't go to his gatherings in UK when invited by peers. some of the stuff he says seems detached to the long standing islamic tradition which is quite critical.
Wassalam
I’ve had issues with this same brother regarding him promoting the inshallah app.
May god be with you
Your content is always insightful. Jazak Allah khair for sharing
Subhaan Allaah! This is actually what ive been looking for!
What are the surahs that's been omitted and what are the reason behind it? If it doesn't include all of the surahs of the Qur'an, then it shouldn't be called the Qur'an.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Brother Saajid great video and Allah bless you. I have a request one small student to another proper student, is it possible for you to cover the adilla on the order of the mushaf as it is so the people can realize how much of an alteration and a deviance this “New Quran” is. I feel like many people wouldn’t understand the gravity of this act because their distance from correct knowledge. Once they understand that the order of the mushaf is from Allah I think some will start understanding not only the deviance of this but many other deviances as well.
جزاك الله خير
No one or mufti menk claimed it was ‘The new Quran’. Who are they to challenge the Quran revealed only and only by Allah first? Before criticizing allow yourselves to accept other information from people and look upon it as well. It’s these problem stirrers who are claiming it to be a New Quran or the marketing team, which I agree is wrong to do . But mufti menk didn’t have any likewise intentions or claimed so.
@@raheelaijaz7973 the name isn’t the only problem here. It’s the order the suwar, this is what I was saying most people don’t understand how bad this is. The way the mushaf is compiled today was revealed by Allah to the Prophet and for a reason. I really hope Brother Sajid makes a video on it explaining the evidences and the wisdom of the mushaf’s order
@@arhumshamim7753 look, by your logic, some curriculum teach Islamic studies and some reserve a special book aside for students in which surahs, their important verses and explanations are contained just like a tafseer e Quran. Just like here, these books may have order of surahs not matching that as of the noble Quran’s divine arrangement. Refer to this example of tafseer e Quran, mufti menk also arranged not all but some surahs in a way that its ease for readers to understand or whenever a surah reference came in his mind he thought has lots of advices for the ummah he listed it down and worked on its translation and then transferred it to a final version with the same order. If he were to do it for all 313 surahs, he would’ve followed the proper divine arrangement and respected rules of the noble Quran.
Thank you for clarifying this issue. Please review Shaykh Nuh Ha Mim Keller's translation "The Quran Beheld", 2022.
جزاك الله خيرا على ما تقدمه لنا. نحبك في الله تعالى
Thanks brothet Saajid.
Salam from Indonesia
@@hariaatukemjey4512the bottom line, menk is a wahabi. Cannot trust learn ur religion from wahabis.
Its well known, all scholars wahabi is not amongst sunnah wal jamaah.
Indonesian and Malaysian brothers are always so respectful, InshaAllah I will get to visit both places one day
Audubillah. This is why one needs to be on the correct manhaj. The manhaj of salaf us salih and not be a muqallid of mufti fulaan.
هذا الحق
Well spoken and toned rebuttal. My compliments.
I am a native arab and been studying arabic and quran in depth, and honestly i am impressed by how well you understood the core of this religion as a non arab, also if any non arab needs help understanding something i will be more than happy to help.
May allah guide you all
Abubakr (RA) was afraid of compiling the Quran into a book form and was against it because it was not done during the life of the prophet (SAW), until he was advised by major companions like Umar and finally agreed to do it. Now we have people even going further and changing what those companions decided without any fear?
The Quran was compiled into a book during the life time of our prophet s.a.w. don't spread lies abu bakr never compiled the Quran mufti Menk will go to hellfire for this if he doesn't repent reprinting the Quran with missing surah this whole ummah are unbelievers because you follow sects
i think people are making a fuss over nothing.
this man tried to publish another educational book about the quran. but it seems like , people were very quick to jump conclusions. and thought " oh it has quran in the title.... is this man promoting a "new quran" ".....bruh...
No dude, its not just as simple as that. Whether we think that or not hes calling it the holy book, period. No add ons to make anything clear. and its not even complete or in the right order that its always been. New muslims will be confused and this'll make way for other people to think to do the same. This is the exact way how the bible was lost excluding losing the first book bc we still have it.
Jazakallaah khair
سلامٌ عليكم
Some information is best conveyed via indexing and hyperlinks or other similar references and citations. In my view, a publication of any sort is promoted or let down by its indexing/ table of conents/references etc.
It would have been quite adequate to include the original text and use referencing and citation to provide the historical order of revelation.
Do not rely on a human, Islam & Muslims are a different things, Islam is perfect but Muslims are not don't care who you are specially in this era, even if you are an Imam. Just don't messed up with Quran.
Salam brothers and sisters. Correct me if I am wrong here but this book is being marketed as “Surahs as delivered chronologically to our Prophet (PBUH).”
This is not The Qur’an (Divine Speech compiled and relayed to the Ummah as intended by our Prophet PBUH). This is just Surahs how they were chronologically delivered and can be considered of educational/supplementary value. It is by no means a standard and no one has claimed as such. It does have educational value and the intension of the Mufti to educate and not to profit. Allah (SWT) knows best. We are not the judges. Being critical and skeptical is alright and demanding that this book be named “Surahs of the Qur’an as delivered chronologically,” makes sense and should be arbitrated. Do not call this book the Qur’an though. Prophet Muhammad’s (PBUH) intent is the standard Qur’an we have and it is absolutely unchanging because Divine Speech survives the time and tide (what we humans call evolution/change).
Then it's marketed wrongly including the name.
You said a lot of stuff but the fact that they used that specific title proves you wrong. Not from our point of view. But from their own actions.
Also, if it was for chronological order, where are the madani surats? Or they going to make a part 2? Or did they purposefully omit the madani surats?
And the wording “as it was meant to be revealed”. According to who? We have tafasir that have been peer reviewed and have been used day in and day out and we have some, will all due respect, a nobody, coming to give us something we missed?
May Allah عزّ وجلّ guide us all
@@hilmyakatsuki1665 How is it being marketed, and what is the name?
@@alfatir14 you can see in the video including the website
@@hilmyakatsuki1665 Most people are only addressing things based on this video, so again, how is it being marketed?
Thanks for your analysis and insightful review
As a student, I appreciate the organization of the book and its value for knowledge seekers. I acknowledge it may pose challenges for some, yet I find the exaggeration about it being an innovation perplexing. The sheikh presented the book as a tool to comprehend Makki Surahs more simply. In my Arabic translation studies, focusing on Makki/Madani Surahs initially facilitated understanding. I fail to see how this could be mistaken for the Holy Quran; it serves as a supplementary resource and Allah knows best.
❤
This is insane.
Also, we need to read this translation properly.
A lot of the translations even the ones that have the correct order sometimes soffen some of the words e.g. surah nisa verse 34.
English language speakers are missing out if they haven’t read the translation by the people behind that book. Absolutely superb beautiful and points in one direction only !
What direction exactly? Care to explain more?
Selaam aljkum I will always go to the original Quran but I am for helping people understand Islam and the Quran I see no problem here. This is not replacing the Quran it’s to help non speaking Arabic brothers and sisters.
You don't see the problem, but when people get the problem, and there are many of us who complained, don't you think there's something wrong with this "NEW QUR'AN"?
can you imagine the audacity to rearrange Qur'an with human limited knowledge, then call it as "NEW QUR'AN"? can you imagine what kind of mentality people who have the arrogance to change Qur'an then name the change as "NEW QUR'AN"??? who will do this? The audacity. God please keep us all in straight path and avoid us all from hypocrites.
This people can make tafsir or whatever and title it as tafsir of the Qur'an... Nobody in their right mind and loving Qur'an will say, this is NEW QUR'AN. Qur'an is Qur'an. There's no old Qur'an and new Qur'an. NOT A CHANCE. QUR'AN IS QURAN. that's it til the end of time. It will be forever pure and original.
@@bluewhite0202 it’s not a Quran it for the new comer to the deen. Non Muslim and people who claim tobe Muslim have done worse and said worse about our deen and prophets be mindful some people need a lil help understanding our deen.
@@bluewhite0202 stop and think for just for a sec what does Allah say he protects the deen Allah knows best remember there is nothing to fear my brother Allah is the best of planners if (Allah) willed this would of never happened but (Allah) is testing us always brother have some iman in (Allah) may continue to guide us, and show mercy upon us. Remember, (Allah) is the best of planners..(Allah) I think the key here is patience (Allah)loves those who are patient.
It is concerning that they translated only the Mekkan surah, they left the Madinah surahs which have most of the laws and Shari'a.
It's a 3 volume set.
@@alfatir14 so three volumes and yet they still skipped the Madinah surahs? Thats against them btw
@@tumbakits because Menk doesn't want to upset the Yahud, he's a sellout
@tumbak No. 😂😂🤦🏿 Volumes 2 and 3 will be the Medina period. You might want to research things before you speak on them. Although I dislike this means of learning, I at least looked into it to have an opinion.
@@alfatir14 when the other volumes are published then you have a point, until then your point is mute الفاطر
Thank you brother for brining this issue to our kmoeledge. We agree. We are happy with the quran we hv not Any new quram. Jazakuallah
In my place there is a "Yasin book" for us to read surah yasin, some short surah and some prayer (dhua) bc in my place we usually pray for someone that passed away with that book (not read a full quran), but i dont understand why the title for the book in the video is "new quran" maybe changing the title will solve the confusion
If there is no arabic and only translation than its not Quran it's a translation of Quran. I don't pray salah in English even i am not a person whi speaks Arabic
Thanks a lot... I have always wanted a to read an English translation of Quran which is arranged in chronological order....I want to know how it was revealed.....
Translation Qur'an in English are everywhere, and it already in proper order, it already PERFECT just how it is, because Qur'an is God's revelations, it is PERFECT. Human's brain won't reach the perfection of Qur'an.
a lot of the chapters are left out in menks book, don’t read it!
@@anonymuser95is it multiple part series?
A'ouzhou bil Lahi min sharrill munafiqoon.
It would be almost impossible to have it in chronological order for a number of reasons, partly because parts of suwar were revealed at different times. As you know the beginning of Surat al’Alaq was the first revelation but then the rest of the surah was revealed much later after other revelation. So you would have to chop up the surah to keep it chronological. Also because many parts of the Quran it’s not sure when they were exactly revealed. And some surah there is khilaf (difference of opinion ) about when they were revealed.
Brother you have hit the nail on the head perfectly! May Allah عز و جل reward you for highlighting this new INNOVATION. It may not be Mr Menk's intention🤔 but this book backs a very dangerous mindset nowadays which MANY moderate muslims have fallen into, and are influencing new reverts with. The mindset is that "well when the quran was being revealed in makkah, for 13 years, salah, fasting etc wasn't enjoined instantly nor was alcohol etc prohibited immediately so we can take our time 'leisurely' to apply Islam and all its actions." This is the mindset of moderate deviants who wish to live a life of disobedience to Allah yet still want all the "goodies" of what's promised to a true Muslim who strives all his life.
Thats why this "new book" focuses on the Makkan period specifically, to basically eradicate practical Islam resulting in hollow, empty "Muslims" who look the part but actually aren't.
And this mindset is being pushed by the leaders of Arab/Gulf countries who want to be "seen" as the protectors of Islam yet dont want REAL muslims in their countries because they know that true muslims would bring down such deviant leaders to begin with. These leaders imprison the TRUE SCHOLARS who actually call to the true Islam which obviously starts from the "rulings" of Islam to be applied. So beware of such "riff-raff scholars" who are being promoted by these countries because they are just to make the leaders look Islamic so their people don't disobey them and in return, these scholars get to fill their pockets.
Suppose they have good intention (be it for a complementary reading to learn the context and history chronologically or what not), considering the content, they could go with a title like "The Makkan Surahs in Order of Revelation" or if it's not just the Makkan, "Surahs from Qur'an in Order of Revelation", NOT calling it Qur'an in any way so it wouldn't mislead people to think it as the holy Qur'an.
May Allah protect the ummah and grant them and us all taufeeq.
The last point is very important.
The reward for an incorrect ruling is for the scholar. It is not an excuse for us to follow incorrect rulings. Nor a discouragement against criticizing incorrect rulings.
And I really don’t think Mufti Menk is qualified to give fatwa.
Yes, but for scholars and "mufti" menk is not a scholar .
@@ahmadfared1204 well, I agree that Mufti Menk is not a scholar but that’s beside the point.
Who qualified mufti menk as a classified mufti though?
Is the versus changed. Is there a new added on or deleted surahs. If it's stated that this is not the Quran then why is it said new Quran.
Does anyone needs to be reminded of menks danish radio interview?
Mufti Menk with another big blunder... How about sticking to the sunnah??
Assalamu alaykum
I lost it when Mufti Menk was promoting a dating app recently
The issue is how they marketed, promoted and titled the book.
Lack of wisdom and or experience is a trait of the times on the dawah scene. Daily i have to correct someone who shows me some silly video a muslim made on tiktok. Music being in almost all of them. Or deviant sects making videos.
Let's try to understand, mufti Menk wants to explain the order in which surahs were revealed, he has an intention... I think people are creating problems for nothing. There are many books with only specific surahs in them. Let's not cause problems for nothing.
Why call it a new Quran? What’s the intention behind that?
@@shokzz1532Did they claim it be New Quran?? No they didnt. But they should've clarified in the title it was just the Makkan Surahs that was short sighted.
@@adilkhan3584 what is the title???
@@shokzz1532 NOT the New Quran, what are you talking about? Or you a Troll or simply Hating?
@@adilkhan3584 nothing wrong with the book itself, rather the marketing
The fact that anybody could possibly be confused by this just goes to show how uneducated we have become...
It clearly says it's a book to learn about the mekkan surahs in the order they were revealed.
Were the salaf confused because Allah revealed the Quran to them in this way? I know we are not the Salaf, but everyone knows the Quran was revealed out of order and if this book strives to educate us on that history and the way in which Allah subahanahu wa ta'ala revealed the Quran, then why not benefit from the book or just move on without having to refute the Sheikh for trying to educate the ummah just because you don't like the title or marketing of the book.
In a couple of years, nobody will remember the marketing and it will just be a book to reference and anyone who has a brain and opens it will know it isn't a translation of the whole Quran or an official re-structuring of the Quran, but rather a tool to better understand the way in which the Quran was revealed before the Hijrah.
Wa Allahu Alam.
They clearly made some mistakes. They should have listed the number of volumes. They also have another book for "The cow" surah. So it looks like they are trying to make it a series of books in chronological order. But there are no volume numbers. They should've done that, then most of the controversy won't start. Looks like each was made as separate volumes. Likely 3/4 of books but still no reference between books, naming it Quran as Revealed but not mentioned which books hold which surahs or number of the book on cover page(even inside of the book) is the issue.
I feel like Mufti Menk isn’t the problem here, the people promoting it differently are the ones causing this issue. The book is clearly called the Quran as revealed ….
why did it ommit the madinah surahs?
Mufti Menk is 100% part of the problem. As a supposed learned indicueal he knows he shudnt be introducing it to his audience (of which there r many). His deviation in aqeedah is the root of this.
I think if you are a man of da'wah and something you done results in confusion and false assumption in the ummah.. He should take the book away just so it wouldnt be used as it meant to be..
Just dont be a moron@@Madmarkhor
@@Prizkov99because the Madinan surahs talk about the Yahud and their characteristics and he doesn't want to upset his yahud friends
How can you crticise someone for something you are doing as well. Why is the title "mufti menks new quran" arent you falsely promoting this as well? You are doing exactly that honestly, i heard about that book before and it was clear to me what it was about from the start. However from this clickbaity title you introduced the very idea to me that you criticise him for sharing. Please dont be a guy who focus on mistakes of others and forgets himself, may allah guide as all.
Spot on !
But I'd it was revealed piecemeal, how does it consolidate printing a surah before the previous one was completed?
I purchased this book, not understanding what I’m actually buying, I loved the look of the pictures and illustration and thought it would be a brilliant way of giving dowah, I’m regretting buying it now
If I had the power, I would burn all prints of this book. What’s this… I doubt he would publish the same for the Medinese Surahs.
Wait do you say this because of the ayat which mention aqeedah?
I hear there is a volume 2 with those missing surah. Sell it in one book, pay 1 price. Divide it into 2, can charge less for each, but make more. That's fairly common. Drama gets more views and audience participation. We expect to know everything immediately and are impatient.
There is no new Quran. Full stop
may Allah omit this menk s book from dunya
Mufti menk himself said it's just a book for studying about Islam it's crazy that a lot of people don't realize that💀
There is a deeper agenda to this then what they tell you. Why could they not done this in a regular book form with explaination if what they say is true
I don't watch Mufti Menk anymore, he is a puppet now.
So Mufti Menk is the Paul within Islam. Great
Surely without all the surahs it's not a quran?
None muslims are going to enjoy this.
Specially former muslims😂
I will not be surprised if that "mufti " menk is trying to hide his aqeedah by not explanation of the verses ( ayah ) that speek about the names and attributes of Allah . Just as he did when escape during a class an verse the quran surah Ta Ha verse 05 " the Most Merciful rose above His throne " .
Be wary of those who fear upsetting the people of misguidance and falsehood as one of the traits of the group upon haqq was they do not have concern whether people abandon or remain with them.
Bro calm down down and stick to the topic. Goodness sake
It's a very common misconception that a mufti is rewarded for being mistaken, there's nothing like that the Hadith they're referring to is strictly talking about a judge arbitrating a case between two parties, he's is encouraged to make a judgement once he studied the case and gathered all of the information he could possibly do he must not abstain from ruling out of fear of making wrong judgment as he'll still be rewarded as long as he was honest, impartial and put the effort needed. Fatwa in the other hand in the contrary to what many (including allot of "scholars") think, should only be given if clear and taken only from Quran and verified Hadith no scholar is authorized to issue a fatwa otherwise the notion of ijtihad is later innovation.
allowing the order of surahs to be changed would snowball effect into the bible 2 (specifically on how it has been edited). freedom causes disorder.
“Mufti” menk, imagine calling him mufti
not sure why people keep complicating things..
May Allah swt protect us all from misguidance ..
thank you brother to bring it to light
Ameen
It's the little change that starts everything.
Shaykh Muḥammad Ibn Ṣāleḥ al-‘Uthaymīn already explained way back that writing the Qur'ān in a different order like this is prohibited because the ordering is restricted توقيفي - He, رحمه الله, made reference to Shaykh Muḥammad Fu’ād ‘Abd ul-Baqī titled تفصيل آيات القرآن الكريم, it is a work in which the verses of the Qur’ān were gathered under 18 different categories such as Tawḥīd, acts of worship, the Sharī‘ah, history, Muḥammad ﷺ, and others.
Mufti Menk has gone too far
I always felt there was something seriously wrong with Mufti Menk
Here we go.... Still doing more for the Din whether it's that he specialises in a certain market or area than most Muslims. May Allah accept his good and forgive him for any error he may have fell into i'm sure you have so many too, maybe Mufti Menk is better than us and you in the Eyes of Allah so we shouldn't wait for one situation to look to get off anything ill we may have in our hearts towards a dear Brother in Islam.
I can see another comment where you have slandered a Muslim which would not benefit you or him on RUclips comments it's not good these are also deeds that are being recorded by Mala'ikah. May Allah guide us.
@@fakeaccount4058 mufti menk who sat with zi0n!sts for lunch in uae is doing more for islam huh ? By distorting islam for western people ?
jazak allah khair. mufti menk has always been weird and not clear cut like scholars may allah guide him and us i dont listen to him anymore
I need more information, I’m sorry. Nothing should be labeled Quran the marketing should be very careful precise and mindful. I’d love to know more details of how the Quran was revealed and organized bc that’s fascinating to me, including what surahs were revealed when during what part of prophets time pbuh. I think scholars fail to relate that to ordinary ppl. There’s not much out there and I think Muslims would be interested. But nothing should be labeled as new Quran. There’s lot missing here I’ll have to look up this story myself.