Shoshana Zuboff: Surveillance capitalism and democracy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
- The collection and analysis of data is changing the way economies operate. Are these changes so fundamental that they can be said to have led to the emergence of a new form of capitalism - surveillance capitalism? If people’s behaviour is made increasingly transparent, do we become a society in which trust is no longer necessary? Are individuals a mere appendage to the digital machine, objects of new mechanisms which reward and punish according to the determinations of private capital? How is social cohesion affected when people become dispensable as a labour force, while their data continues to provide function as a source of value in lucrative new markets that trade in predictions of human behaviour? How should we understand the new quality of power that arises from these unprecedented conditions? What kind of society does it aim to create? And what ramifications will these developments have for the principles of liberal democracy? Will privacy law and anti-trust law be enough? How can we tame what we do not yet understand?
Shoshana Zuboff is a social scientist and author of three books, each of which has been recognised as the definitive signal of a new epoch in technological society. Her latest book, The Age of Surveillance Capitalism reveals a world in which technology users are no longer customers but the raw material for an entirely new economic system. Zuboff is the Charles Edward Wilson Professor Emerita at Harvard Business School and was a Faculty Associate at the Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society at Harvard Law School from 2014 until 2016.
Making Sense of the Digital Society
The current rapid pace of technological change creates enormous uncertainties - and thus the need for explanations that help us better understand our situation and shape the future. The Alexander von Humboldt Institute for Internet and Society (HIIG) and the Federal Agency for Civic Education (bpb) are therefore continuing the Lecture Series Making Sense of the Digital Society that was launched in 2017. The aim of the format is to develop a European perspective on the current processes of transformation and its societal impact. The first speaker of this year’s series was sociologist Eva Illouz, followed by Dirk Baecker, José van Dijck and Louise Amoore. The event with Shoshana Zuboff on 6 November is part of the Berlin Science Week 2019 and the keynote of the DigiKomm conference 2019.
More information about the event and the lecture series: www.hiig.de/en...
Photo credit: Falling Walls Foundation
#digitalsociety
#ShoshanaZuboff
#ZuboffBerlin
one of the few intellectuals that isn't impossible to understand and is quite the delight to listen to. what a cool lady!
You should definitely read her book her writing is pretty funny at times! And yet still intellectual in its manner
@Azhag Dark the fact that you are a ball of negative energy is something to be embarrassed of
Nah, another democrat numbskull.
Totally. Her latest book is fascinating.
I love her
Shoshana Zuboff's speech begins at 13:30
Qrayon Thanks.
Thank you :)
@@christinetheresa7416 At your service.
@@michellebitter4494 You're welcome. :)
Lecture starts at 13:30.
Thank You!👐
Shoshanna has a beautiful mind. Thank you for fighting for humanity.
Thank you for fighting for my future, like all of the others previous her had done for me. To give me rights. You have to understand that this lady is almost a retired grandma, with alot of life experience, much more then the average person/you or me.
@Alfonso Jesse why would you do that?
I enjoyed listening to this but I don't feel like there's a beautiful mind, or any kind of revelation in this. There's comfortable, easily understood truism, a lapping-back of waters that were already pushed out by greater force.
@@krustysurfer dude...
'Alfonso' and 'Gianni' are bots programmed to spam tards who think this shit is insightful
BTW, this I hacked my girlfriend's Instagram comment is by a bot.
We became a human commodity in 1913 when the federal reserve began. In the 1930's (Look on your birth certificate, the number given to each person from the federal reserve is there to keep count for money to be printed, debt based money for perpetual slavery) to begin printing more money, the govt. began the scheme to print money based on the equivalent of the citizen born, it's earnings and tax revenue, would regulate how much money could be printed. Then Immigration began as a profit, for each one they could print even more money. Then they began printing money on future citizens before they were even born yet. Now our national debt has been laid at the feet of those yet to exist, which is our debt creates slavery, and slavery of 3 or 4 generations to yet come to be. We are slaves who are brainwashed that we are free, and vote in what we think is a democracy when the choices are not choices at all, but just whom ever they present as candidates, who regardless of party, are controlled by the banksters/federal reserve. We are so screwed. FYI, I for one, left FB the day that I realized that serveillance was their profits, and the hot mic quote by Zuckerberg of "Our customers are fucking stupid"! I quit that day, from daily use, to completely vanishing from that world. I came back for 2 or 3 visits at the 2016 election, to see what the sheeple were thinking, and my page was covered with liberal crap, adds from the democratic party (I'm independent) and when I made a comment I was barraged by libtards I never met, and was amazed at the manipulation, the name calling and berrating for not marching to the tune of the brainwashed democrats, and calling me racist, a Nazi etc. was bizzare, so I came back once or twice to laugh when Trump won, and never clicked back.
At the end, they discuss removing hate speech and monitoring and just know, one persons hate is another's love, just ask my x wife lol. But removing and controlling content and speech is wrong at it's core and without free speech, which creates debate. Now denying free speech, we are controlled 100% and that control, like money etc. is it will be abused and that kills us and freedom.
Ralph Stgermain where did you research this, would love to know more 👍🏻
I to am just FLOORED by how this once great place is just walking into the flames of FUTURE Babylon! Fuck WakING up....More like "Run for the hills!" TIME!
FB dies control what you put on there. I have had a few things censored / blocked by FB. Not racist or vulgar things. Actual historic facts they did not like. If you cannot put up historic facts, then you know they have an agenda and want to keep people ignorant. FB totally wants people to Not Know Historical Facts about things they want to promote. …. Like Socialism / Communism.
Agreed Jekyll Island changed everything!
All propaganda needs to do is to make you BELIEVE that something is debatable to win. They don’t have to prove it wrong, they have to make you believe it’s debatable, and then refuse to ever resolve the question. So we do need better media process
Is my big brother watching me watching this video? How surveillance tortures me 24/7 is painful. Great lecture Ms. Zuboff.
Lol. I love how this vid also has a Google geotag as well. Its too perfect
When Surveillance Capitalism becomes Physical Torture,
Chng.it/PgsdqrRyW2 (FEB 2021)
Targeted Individuals (TI) Demand Formal (ODNI) Probe Into Radio Frequency (RF) Terrorism
ATTN TARGETED INDIVIDUALS AND THEIR ALLIES (EMF Refugees too!): THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION WANTS NO GAPS IN ITS ‘COMPREHENSIVE THREAT ASSESSMENT’ OF DOMESTIC VIOLENT EXTREMISM. NO GAPS.
Petition ‘Snapshot’:
Tell Director of National Intelligence Avril Danica Haines she must not omit ‘Radio Frequency (RF) Terrorism’ from the “comprehensive threat assessment” of Domestic Violent Extremism the White House appointed her-we learn Jan. 22 from Psaki-to oversee (and tell SHSA you need a PIN).
Petition Demand:
We the undersigned, the cybertortured and their allies, together call on The Honorable Avril Danica Haines, Director of National Intelligence, to ensure-with a written assurance-the “comprehensive threat assessment” of Domestic Violent Extremism President Joe Biden on January 22, 2021, asked her to launch will include a “robust” (see Polymeropoulos) and rigorous analysis of terroristic tactics and terroristic techniques that target now, or have in the past targeted, civilians for microwave radiation poisoning and torture by focused beaming with concentrated, “directed, pulsed radio frequency (RF) energy” (see Relman) or by “directed-energy assaults and associated crimes” (see Arnegard).
Chng.it/PgsdqrRyW2
Very refreshing indeed to listen to a female who is equally efficient in leading us in this intellectual discourse. Bravo Shoshana! thank you for lighting the path
Doesn't matter it's a male or female. Both are equal in intelligence.
Great to see this stuff rising in discussion. The fear and dread here is that after Surveillance Capitalism comes Surveillance State.
It is already here. In 1960 former president Richard Nixon tried to exploit the use of television for his political campaign against JFK. It backfired on him because of his always showing "5:00 o clock" shadow" that some voters did not like. JFK barely won. in 2008 former president Obama used social media the first time and won 2009-2017. In 2016 Former first lady Hillary Clinton hired the 50 top US research psychologists to direct her campaign, she also received millions of dollars worth of consulting FREE from the CEO of Google to find out what activated people to vote. She developed the Clinton Foundation to provide "soft" money for her campaign. Hillary used a three prong approach and lost ( Google research led by Dr. Cialdini who wrote the book on subliminal "Influence". She used the Clinton Foundation "soft" donor money machine . She spent twice as much money as Trump and lost. In 2016 to present Democrats alleged the Trump won because of "Facebook ads" ( $7,000 worth of them) from Russia and this was debunked. The future is unknown.
@Robert Gardea I agree! the most effective mottos are short such as " Drain the Swamp, Build the Wall and Lock Her Up".
I'm pretty sure none of us thought it would be out in the open quite this soon!
~LB, May 2020~
How is capitalism the problem? Do you all suggest we go into socialism or communism where everyone is equally as poor?
Humans are inherently imperfect, corruptible, greedy, and power hungry! So who will make sure we are all being fair? Humans?
@@POLITICALSTALEMATE Ultimately, the key is to decentralize power. I think laws should be in place to limit Capitalism -put a cap on the amount of money someone can have. Nobody needs more than a few billion(max). The rise of Bitcoin can be a great model for this. It takes power away from government so they can't simply print money for wars as they wish. We can also use Blockchain technology to decentralize voting and changes to laws generally, where people vote for everything and congress is eroded. The old system is completely corrupt and dysfunctional. What does not work gets done away with. Millions of people voting on a law is far more democratic that 200 corrupt politicians. Look at the way Congress is doing nothing except holding up an illusion of democracy.
Absolutely Brilliant. ...People wake up ..
There's been people saying similar stuff to what Shoshana says in this video for decades now. This isn't new, revolutionary information. The vast majority of people out there don't care. Most people probably watched this video on their smartphones and will continue using smartphones even with the knowledge that they're spying devices. They value convenience and 24/7 access to the internet over their privacy and they will look at you funny when you tell them you don't own any smart devices. In today's society, you're the weird one for not wanting to be tracked and spied on 24/7.
@@plottwist1733 Exactly why there is no coming back from this, or at least it would be extremely hard to do so. There aren't many people like Shoshana Zuboff. Most people don't think about privacy and surveillance like Shoshana does.. and even if they watch her talks, they won't change a thing in their life. Hell, they will even share it on facebook with others and happily continue using it, giving data to FB about their lives.
So far it looks like this will get only worse, not better. I wonder how the world will look like in 10-20 years from now.
In the end up giving up data by watching a video about the theft of data. We are stuck in a loop.
She mentions how much we rely on whistle blowers. Vox has a video on how badly we fail our whistle blowers, to point their lives are destroyed, even despite it improving from being even worse. We need to fight to improve this.
Agreed,
When Surveillance Capitalism becomes Physical Torture,
Chng.it/PgsdqrRyW2 (FEB 2021)
Targeted Individuals (TI) Demand Formal (ODNI) Probe Into Radio Frequency (RF) Terrorism
ATTN TARGETED INDIVIDUALS AND THEIR ALLIES (EMF Refugees too!): THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION WANTS NO GAPS IN ITS ‘COMPREHENSIVE THREAT ASSESSMENT’ OF DOMESTIC VIOLENT EXTREMISM. NO GAPS.
Petition ‘Snapshot’:
Tell Director of National Intelligence Avril Danica Haines she must not omit ‘Radio Frequency (RF) Terrorism’ from the “comprehensive threat assessment” of Domestic Violent Extremism the White House appointed her-we learn Jan. 22 from Psaki-to oversee (and tell SHSA you need a PIN).
Petition Demand:
We the undersigned, the cybertortured and their allies, together call on The Honorable Avril Danica Haines, Director of National Intelligence, to ensure-with a written assurance-the “comprehensive threat assessment” of Domestic Violent Extremism President Joe Biden on January 22, 2021, asked her to launch will include a “robust” (see Polymeropoulos) and rigorous analysis of terroristic tactics and terroristic techniques that target now, or have in the past targeted, civilians for microwave radiation poisoning and torture by focused beaming with concentrated, “directed, pulsed radio frequency (RF) energy” (see Relman) or by “directed-energy assaults and associated crimes” (see Arnegard).
Chng.it/PgsdqrRyW2
Sometimes when watching/listening to programs like this , the language is in Chinese to me. Shoshana is brilliant and puts things in ways that makes it very understandable to all !
don't worry, as is english is a rather poor language. She wrote a great book however.
What a waste of technology when designed to keep us shopping. Too bad consumerism is killing the planet. That is how stupid these systems have made us.
PS--- we were already plenty stupid... ;)
Just keep public busy.
Work, work and spend.
Spend all your life for things.
At the end of life there are only regrets and sorrow about wasted life.
if you think that is the ultimate end game for this then you are really stupid
@@therealtoni We are learning from our stupid upbringing. And now we are searching to flee.
Yeah, heard bill Mahn say “I’ve never seen a logical argument ever sway any of them”
thks to shoshana Zuboff ;) really clever human
What are the names, familiy connections, beliefs, religions and national loyalties of the people who control digital surveillance?
Shoshana Zuboff starts her lecture at 13:14
Hahahaha she has to refeer to Greta Thumberg to engage the young audience hahahaha
You could have simply cut the three introductory speakers.
Welcome to RUclips comments. Thank you for the lecture.
The sad paranoia here is that the lack of will power in younger people currently, may cause them in that 'numbing state' for god knows how many years or decades to come. She seems like such a great human.. I hope we get our shit together for her to witness some light.
1:11:30 - "We essentially need to outlaw the surveillance dividend." Done. IAMCC/IYA ... Interactive (i.e. - what you can do!): 1) Interrupt supply 2) Interrupt demand.
People who are taking selfie shots don't know they are holding a gun.
@@fallenangel2123 aiming it at their face! pulling the trigger...
It's very easy to understand, in the same way it's easy to understand that a mirror shows what is behind you: the same insight is gained with the effort of turning your head ninety degrees.
interupting surveillance capitalism on an individual basis seems like a mountain of a task, an entire lifestyle change for very many. Law change seems the only adequate response. The collective action Zuboff describes ( 1:45:40 - 1:48:00 ) in the Q&A is mandatory
Just READ her book "The Age of Surveillance Capitalism" - 750 pages includes 250 pages of detailed references. She has not discussed the secret Intel IME computer hidden in most desktop and laptop computers since 2009 which uses Minux 3.0 at security level -3 Ring.
There are FREE alternatives to Microsoft Windows. Their are hundreds of FREE and Open Source Linux distributions. Google search can be replaced with NON SPYING www.duckduckgo.com The Google provided insecure Android operating system can be replaced with three new Linux touch based smartphones in Second Quarter 2020. I see no rational reason to use Facebook, or most online video games. Apple laptops and desktops also use the secret Intel IME chips. I do not recommend these products. If you use the Chrome browser , be careful. Chrome is made by Google and is Proprietary and does not like anti malware and Anti adware addons. The Free CHROMIUM browser although made by Google, is Open Source and no secret back doors have been found...YET! on the Linux platforms. If you use Webmail by Windows, Yahoo, Google you are NOT secure or private. Try www.Protonmail.com in Switzerland which has serious regulations about SPYING on your private email messages. Also try a VPN Virtual Private Network to provide one more level of privacy. Read as much as you can about YOUR privacy. Nest thermostats? They include a secret microphone---why do you need a microphone to measure your temperature? Fitbit. NO way! The US Army training was spied on by these devices that provided confidential information to Third parties. There is MORE. Smart Tv's? NO! Many of these models have secret cameras and microphones that WATCH YOU, your family AND children! Be cautious of your comments on RUclips. RUclips uses Artificial Intelligence to monitor ALL comments.
Thank you for a great mind who is able to research and decipher all this information and being able to interpret and lay it out in front of us.❤
They'll never make it illegal there's too much money behind it
Great talk. Thank you for maintaining this format and inviting such interesting speakers. Unfortunately, the important part on alternatives came too short. The services that Google enables us are simply amazing. Just take RUclips as an example. Wherever I am, I can watch this talk by a renown academic in exchange for some of my personal data (that Google harvests). There is no alternative business model on which Google, Facebook, etc. could function. A person in the audience addressed this issue but unfortunately, prof. Zuboff didn't answer it and instead led the discussion somewhere else.
TheSupernerd97 She's just one person. She did her part, exposing this and authoring a book we can all read. It's time for others to take up the sword. One person cannot do it all by themself. Sadly, we have a whole lot of very stupid young people all over the world. They walk around with all these worthless college degrees, spend all their time on social media and gaming, and have never learned how to formulate an independent thought, and think it's someone else's job to fix all their problems. Let them look for and implement the answers. Let them pull themselves away from their addictions to gaming and tweeting and figure out the answers. If the generations that will be most severely affected by this issue don't care enough to do anything, why should someone from her or my generation worry about it? Furthermore, your assertion that there is no other business model blah blah blah, is complete garbage. This is not a business model, it's surveillance. They are not doing this to run a business, pay bills, pay employees, etc. They are doing this to get FILTHY RICH and create herd mentalities and hive minds. The fact that you made such a stupid misinterpretation of what this is really about is just, well, pathetic. Ms. Zuboff may have hope for the future generations, but I don't. Your comment shows how mindless you are. You think it's a "business model". You think it's someone else's responsibility to provide you the answer (And supply you with everything you need to do it), and make it convenient for you, and make sure all your wants are instantly fulfilled, and on and on. Google knows you (and they have nothing to fear).
@@christinetheresa7416 Thank you for your comment.
Thank you for sharing this video and I hope you are able to continue vital reports !
“We ‘understand’ that privacy is a collection action problem...”No, it goes way beyond a “collection action problem”, Privacy IS one of our basic RIGHTS under the constitution of the UNITED STATES! Invasion of privacy IS a CRIME. Our rights are being trampled upon! People need to learn to UNDERSTAND the CONSTITUTION! We already have the LAW!
1:10:35-1:12:30
It IS already LAW! It is being IGNORED and trampled upon!
THEY belong to the WORLD therefor they speak as the inspired by the world and the world listens to them : we belong to God- -he who knows God listens to us, he who does not belong to God does not listen to us. THIS IS HOW we recognize the spirit of truth and the spirit of error 1 John 4:4-7
This is why CASH never must be banned.
RIGHT!!!
better yet nations should have the right to control/print and regulate the value of their money. If that's done international banks lose their stranglehold on your nation.
59:00
Isn't this like the difference between 1984 and Brave New World?
George Orwell vs Aldous Huxley?
In a way I think 1984 is more at the tip of the tongue of most people.
But 1984 is about surveillance and oppression whereas in BNW,
people are embracing their circumstances.
We are now in a state where we embrace our phone.
The nine year old gets a phone, embraces her mom and says she
is the best mom in the world (from personal experience).
And I am typing away in virtual reality.
Yeah. 1984 is death by torture. BNW is death by entertainment.
Both ways we lose our freedom
The Circle by Dave Eggers.
I bought the book. Sadly I find it virtually unreadable. It is far too convoluted and repetitive and the book would have benfitted from a substantial edit.
What a brilliant, engaging and charming woman.
This sounds like bot commentary
Folks that are detail oriented can see the changes throughout the digital world, it's like you are not an individual anymore and the system they have created is dictating your daily moves, if you pay attention to all your digital outputs you will notice suttle changes, that is the system directing your life, it sucks!!!
mikee1422
And that is why we are all working at a desk right now and typing where the laptop did you see ex machina whoa
Move out to the country.
Sell off the TV.
Then trash the computer.
And dump the debris.
Get rid of the cell phone.
And everything "Smart" .
Take up some new hobbies.
Like music or art.
Stop using those store cards
that track what you buy
Use cash and not plastic
On that they can't spy
Buy food from the farmers
Drink from your own well
Let Google and Facebook
fade slowly to hell.
Why one lives as a fugitive on the run. No "smart nothing". Only cash or crypto. Everything through proxies (ie, lawyers)
First we had Communism, ultimately stifling , then Consumerism, unbridled spending snd greed at it's best and worst, I hope we can find a way to humanism and Communalism. Great presentation!
13 minutes of introductions??? There should be a law that holds introductions to one person, introducing a speaker for one minute. Please stow your egos, and just let the speaker, speak.
Go read a book.
Agree with what's happening but not with the conclusions as to solution(s). The solution is in individual awakening at the grass roots level, a deep and true movement wherein those who know find one another and begin to work together voluntarily to effect change. And this depends entirely upon each one, via our inner connection, awakening to his or her own personal sovreignty. A movement of collective action will, as always lead to totalitarianism and continued division in my view. We are already over-regulated and imprisoned by a plethora of laws on top of laws that are hidden within yet more laws. First to change must be the human mind and heart. This cannot be organized, regulated or controlled by a body of laws. But I do believe it is happening. We can learn to use this venue of digital communication in new and better ways. It really IS a matter of tuning in and finding creative ways of dropping out, then quietly sharing our discoveries with one another.
The solution is actually much simpler than that. Get rid of your smartphones and any other smart devices you own. Buy yourself an old Nokia dumbphone. Get used to not having internet access when outdoors. Go out in nature, breathe in the fresh air, enjoy the world around you.
Thank you for teaching the Truth. !!! They use there super minds for personal gains nothing to do with helping humanity!!! Bless you Shoshanna !!
If you live in purity and honesty, you don't NEED a backstage...
Did surveillance capitalism lead me here?
Actually starts at 13:29
Very smart women ....I love her
"RIGHT ON!". A beautiful speaker that is teaching us what we need to know about the covert surveillance capitalists.
I'd say there's a fair bit of latency with the information the masses are getting.. Once it reaches the every man, corporations will have already updated their harvesting procedures and become even better at hiding their agendas
It isn't covert its so overt its unbelievable. Remember its the age of the world wide web.
Introduction ends at minute 13.
Hahahaha, 13 minutes of introduction and not really a good talk, the problem is not that she is old but the ideas that she proposes are.
Gustavo Martinez
“ she “ is another gate-keeper.
Like Chomsky.
What makes me upset is that these companies made us into products and are making billions out of us ... do any of us get a paycheck from them for our data? No we don't, which is bizarre. If they are extracting our data every single person to whom they do that should receive a compensation in a form of a regular living wage monthly or weekly paycheck or be able to opt out this completely.
"We don't need technology (slido) to have a conversation. We're in the room!" 😁💪🏽😁
Strongly recomend her book, it's just mindblowing!
The reason they do not know about it is because they either deny it or they are lazy and too stupid to connect the dots. So it's easier to continue watching netflix and assorted reality tv or "the news". People want to be comfortable they don't want the inconvenience or discomfort of having to revolt.
🗣🗣🗣🗣
2000 also gave birth to Infragard. It has its own website and it’s declaration as a non profit organization and pays no taxes. It’s chaired by energy corporations, the rotary clubs, and the FBI. Each state has one and is listed on their website. With their linked in committee personalities and their ties. It’s mission is to use private civilians in surveillance of infrastructure threats to energy companies. They pay your neighbors to surveille, harass and disrupt any challenge to their energy plans.
blairbushproject
Wow that’s pretty mind blowing geez
Little ms Can’t be wrong do a search and look at their webpage.
...pays no taxes.....just like google. As a matter of fact google made money off of the government last year. The government paid them. Facebook pays no taxes. Most of these large corps cook the books legally while the "normal" person goes to jail if they dont pay their taxes.
Now that's interesting ,, Smart Lady indeed. ❤️🌎❤️
Great material delivered as though by a middle school teacher convinced her class is absolutely not above average.
Edit: I believe that large tech companies use their sponsorships not only to try to muzzle dissent. I believe they also use it to stoke criticism from ideological purists. In this way, they manage to undermine everyone who does not espouse their beliefs.
I hope you mean this as a compliment, as it should be. Zuboff is brilliant, knowledgeable, and has--thankfully--a conscientious morality. I, for one, am grateful that she is measured and careful in her speech. She is speaking to the entire world and hoping they hear her. I hope so too.
Watching this video is arming them with more information about you.
Wow her hair is really thick and healthy. The only reason I got a computer was for college and on libraries.
A guy introduces the guy that introduces her.
Why is the comment section full of nonsensical comments? Its like their brains are melting..
Because people are In denial, the people that are narcissistically addicted to things like facebook, their egos won't allow them to accept how much they have been fooled by these companies.
it's people who do trolling for a living lol. wouldn't say that this section looks free from neonazis or troll-factory trolls, possibly also independent trolls, but unfortunately, i guess most people making strange, unrelated comments, are just immature and stupid. (i guess mostly kids - though mature kids do exist in the world, but also, sometimes age comes without wisdom.)
doesn't this remind you of situation with David Icke when he started speaking out 30+ years ago? except now, for Shoshana, all that she mentions are publicly known facts.
that's why i think most strange comments cone from kinds - those, born after year 2000. most of them never knew life without devices, and do not understand what is she talking about. kind of like people couldn't understand that you don't believe everything that TV is broadcasting because it's widely used tool for propaganda and brainwashing. (not saying black or white - there can be OK stuff on TV too, everything is shades of grey, but trouble is - people lack discernment. people think in contrasts - if someone says this is going on, people understand that "only this is going on", but nope. is it soap operas fault? overdramatizing everything like that... that's happening en masse.)
She's awesome. And who the hell is leaving two cap closed bottles and no glass for a speaker??
What's wrong with drinking straight from the bottle?
I am just glad they are not plastic...
never underestimate the germans
@@bluewaters3100 plastic is a by product. May as well use it.
psychological warfare...
We brought nothing into this world, and we cannot take anything out of the world
,
but those who desire to be rich fall into temptation, into a snare, into many senseless and harmful desires that plunge people into ruin and destruction, for the love of money is a root of all kinds of evils.
people be so easily persuaded out of their 'hard earned income'. grateful i could never afford all this privilege. i never bought into the advertising industry, couldn't afford to.
waste not, want not. I've always believed that life is priceless, and yet there is this global economy and future stocks. "NO" IS AN ACCEPTABLE ANSWER. PRIVACY IS A BASIC RITE FOR EVERY BEING. STOP 'BUYING' ALL THIS S**T!!!! ABSTAIN!
human beings are the only species on this planet that live their lives following a WRITTEN RULE and RACE against TIME. btw, who owns youtube? who's profiting from all these posted videos? call me a cynic.
it use to be 'illegal' to open another's written word which was sealed with wax.
The end of freedom as we know it.
Now in addition with the virus they can usher it in super fast - or at least they will try - it is down to us what really happens. I can see the digital identity we have with mandatory vaccination against all kinds of CoVid's with chip or tattoo and tracking wherever we go......They will simply tell us "You have to get used to the new normal".
56:55 - 58:20 Beautifully stated.
Her speech starts at 13:30
45:35 ~ "How do we remote control human behavior at scale?" omfg ... Toby, I don't think we're in Kansas anymore, said Alice in Wonderland to the white rabbit ... 🔥 IAMCC/IYA
Xtube
Is there a transcript for this?
This lecture should be part of school curriculum…
Our world our planet human life all these things are in so much Danger from so many things it's hard to stay positive
THE WORLD IS A STAGE, AS YOU LIKE AND DISLIKE IT.
Those powerful people don't fear ordinary people at all.
The wall didn't fall because of the people either, and its falling enabled the monopoly game to flourish. The microphone is a form of policing too, as it enables people's contributions to be recorded, though they are not as bad as CCTV probably.
I've just been out protesting against 5G and few people are interested is disengaging with their addictive contraptions.
Lets face it the owners of all the media sites have foundations and act as patrons to all sorts of causes, which discourages people from paying taxes, that is the only way to distribute wealth in Western capitalist societies. Tax paying gives people an interest in the communities they inhabit.
You talk about the entrepreneurs who might be enabled if Google etc didn't exist, but most of young people don't want to work, but they do aspire to be Gates etc.
They don't want to be me, a communist (I know that's a dirty word to many people on You Tube) sitting in a state owned Council house, living on a state pension, having worked with all sorts of vulnerable people all my life for nominal wages.
It's psychological, Britain and your country have been working on people's psyches for decades, just to ensure the monopoly game to continues, and your country print dollars as well, just to undermine everyone else's currencies.
Oh goodness doesn't the concept of SMART house, flat etc go against everyone you've said.
I'd rather have dog baskets blatting around my computer screen than be surrounded by cars that are the most addictive commodities ever, cause wars and affect people's mental health. Worse still people are again talking about the world being over-populated. People would prefer to wipe out continents rather than scrap their metal boxes.
What democracy? Britain and America have no concept of democracy, the rest of Europe are better, but now Britain is leaving and will break up the EU for sure. It likes to be in charge and of course America pays for the mayhem.
Your second paragraph in particular has loads of truth.
Keine Frage, ich weiß warum das nicht mit Übersetzung gesendet wird.
Die übersetzte Lecture gibt's hier: ruclips.net/video/ScsVe6nktk4/видео.html
@@HiigDe Tausend dank sehr lieb von dir.
This must have begun with the phrase Human Resources. We have become nothing more to the elites than resources to mine and destroy. I wonder what would happen if people served by a robot kicked the things over? I always go to the human cashier... they are much faster.
I'm gonna post this to Facebook !!!!
Great. Add the remedy to the poison. Good one
So.... are you a whistleblower or the Leader of some kind of controlled opposition? why no mention of the Quantumn computers behind all of this?
If you actually looked into the researchers who cover these topics, you would KNOW that they are some of the most diligent, intelligent and militant proponents of exposing this system that we have ever seen.
@@piecebombs5911 Sounds very communist to me.
This is not a technical lecture. Everything she says it's truthful and relevant.
I'm amazed how easy it is for people to understand technology and it's implications, yet be so confused about the distinct difference between a Republican form of government (which recognizes the rights of the individual as non-negotiable) and the Democracy (51% having control over the minority 49%).
Eccellente
Actually the scenario was first analysed by Hartford Van Dyke in the 1970's in a tour de force he titled "Silent Weapons for Quiet Wars", in which he detailed his deductions from an article in Scientific American by Wassily Leontief. (Sept. 1980, "The World Economy in the Year 2000").
George Dantzig later adapted Leontief's industrial model to work for the U.S. Military to
Linear predictive programming.
pubsonline.informs.org/do/10.1287/orms.2005.04.15/full/
When Surveillance Capitalism becomes Physical Torture,
Chng.it/PgsdqrRyW2 (FEB 2021)
Targeted Individuals (TI) Demand Formal (ODNI) Probe Into Radio Frequency (RF) Terrorism
ATTN TARGETED INDIVIDUALS AND THEIR ALLIES (EMF Refugees too!): THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION WANTS NO GAPS IN ITS ‘COMPREHENSIVE THREAT ASSESSMENT’ OF DOMESTIC VIOLENT EXTREMISM. NO GAPS.
Petition ‘Snapshot’:
Tell Director of National Intelligence Avril Danica Haines she must not omit ‘Radio Frequency (RF) Terrorism’ from the “comprehensive threat assessment” of Domestic Violent Extremism the White House appointed her-we learn Jan. 22 from Psaki-to oversee (and tell SHSA you need a PIN).
Petition Demand:
We the undersigned, the cybertortured and their allies, together call on The Honorable Avril Danica Haines, Director of National Intelligence, to ensure-with a written assurance-the “comprehensive threat assessment” of Domestic Violent Extremism President Joe Biden on January 22, 2021, asked her to launch will include a “robust” (see Polymeropoulos) and rigorous analysis of terroristic tactics and terroristic techniques that target now, or have in the past targeted, civilians for microwave radiation poisoning and torture by focused beaming with concentrated, “directed, pulsed radio frequency (RF) energy” (see Relman) or by “directed-energy assaults and associated crimes” (see Arnegard).
Chng.it/PgsdqrRyW2
Yeah! Down with Slido!
"In Russia, TV watches you"
In the U.S. and Canada too.
None worst than the US. The most openly corrupt nation on earth! Blaming everyone else for the collapse they created!
The fiscal legacy of 9/11 and the rise of monetary mass surveillance ...the surveillance dividend would not be there with the anti- terror rhetoric
Exactly!!😊😊😊
We gave media an inside of our experience and they opened the world for us. It was a mutual gain. RUclips is a huge educational tool. Tv on the other hand is pathetic. Surveillance is terrifying but we did benefit from digitizIng interaction. It could have gone towards something a lot more beneficial for our society but it didn't. Still it's easy to downplay the importance of accessing all this information when you studied in the best and most expensive university. The world before internet was equally deprived of democracy.
While I can't agree 100% this is pretty dam enlightening.
I wonder if she learned all this from Rob Braxman the Privacy Tech on RUclips and Odysee. He helps us understand what to do going forward.
Emblematisches Google-Ad: "Privatsphäre ist Einstellungssache".
If you'd like to hear an old lady pitch for the censorship of ideas she doesn't like, skip to 2:00:00
No agenda here...
What a brilliant mind
1:17:20 well...
to the new human Renaissance
Which has nothing to do with planned collective actions, regulations, or laws.
Everything this lady says is true. But, how is she not overheating all the time under all that hair! Anyway, cool lady.
she does it by having a cold :-)
lol, you probably have either short or straight hair (or both, or...none lol).
@@apelsinuke Nah, I am a mountain man.
I bet she's number 1 on the 'hair product' list.
very interesting thank you!
So epic
Zuckerber said: "Privacy is the future" what he didnt say: " Because it sure isnt our present"
You're welcome
The hilarious thing when listening to socialists is that the USA has never seen a free market/"capitalism". We've got a shitload of socialist principles at play here.
three people needed to introduce Shoshana?
Namaste~)*
That explains the Clue app that tracks women’s menstrual cycle. Want to sell our data to Lyndt or something? 😂
actually happened
Lyndt sucks
Law is law and it has to be bend the right way
whew!!! @ 1:28:05
We are toast, it is over with us
First of all, we live in a Republic not a democracy. Try reading the Constitution, Article IV § 4 to be precise. "The United States shall guarantee to every state in this union a republican form of government, and shall protect each of them against invasion; and on application of the legislature, or of the executive (when the legislature cannot be convened) against domestic violence."
Democracy is an imposition by the National Government on the statutory United States and those who are US citizens by birth and those who claim to be a "US citizen" without knowing it's significance when mentioned by the government. The latter actually being American Nationals/constitutional US citizens or as the IRS refers to them as non-resident aliens. The statutory "United States" is defined in 28 USC § 3002(15)(a) and 26 USC § 3121(e), Title 28 USC being the judiciary and judicial procedure and Title 26 USC being the Internal Revenue Code.
Be wary of those preaching democracy. If you want real change you are going to have to claim and correct your status in the eyes of the system before you can ever expect remedy. Zuboff may mean well, just remember everyone counts in a Republic, 51% majority rule is a democracy. There is no democracy in the Constitutional Republic. Democracy is nowhere defined in the Constitution.
Try reading the Constitution and learning your heritage for crying out loud.
As George w. Declared the constitution is just a piece of paper that is not given any due respect any more. Wake up. Your rights to privacy are dead and destroyed. And the erasure of your former freedom of speech has been privatized and decentralized to any website that wants to erase your posts they are free to mute you and block you from posting.
@@beaubeaukitty5301 Your words are those of an apathetic coward. I suggest you take your own advice and you wake up and take an interest in the policies they wish to implement and place them up against the laws set in place to ensure your rights.
To simplify my previous post, only you can clarify your status in the eyes of the system, but you are going to have to know that there are separate jurisdictions. The 50 union States are a separate jurisdiction than that of Washington DC and the federal territories referred to as the "United States" as defined in the sections provided in my previous post. I'll give you a couple of hints. If you have ever claimed to be a "US citizen" on a government form, then you have changed your status and waived your rights as guaranteed by the Constitution. If you have ever filled out a 1040, then you have changed your status and waived your rights as guaranteed by the Constitution. The latter easily verifiable in that the apportionment clauses no longer apply to your private earnings. No 16th Amendment arguments please, because it only applies to the sections provided in my previous post and US source income.
The Constitution is the supreme law of the land and the National government knows this, the document establishes government in the first place, for crying out loud. Beyond that, this is clearly stated in Article VI. However, this does not prevent those in government from utilizing word smithing and other schemes to trick you into giving up your rights. Please refer to the sections in my previous post. The literal United States Code I have referenced.
This woman here is pushing her own agenda. How about you think for yourself.
@@vengeance2825 your words are that of an ignorant moron you can't change legislation or the lack of it any more than I can. LoL
@@beaubeaukitty5301The only ignorant moron here is you. Congressional legislation cannot apply in the Constitutional Republic if it is in contradiction with the Constitution. It can only apply in the statutory US where Congress has absolute authority. So no, you do not need to change any legislation or lack thereof, you just need to know your status and what jurisdiction you live in. You consent to your situation and that is the bottom line.
You can easily verify the points I've stated, but instead you choose to be a pathetic victim lashing out like a child. What a sad person you are. "lol"
Well after you finish reading the constition and the bill of rights read the patriot act, the homeland security act, the military commissions act, and all of the Bush 2 and Obama presidential directives . You'll find out that you no longer have the republic . You have a dictatorship.
PRIVACY IS FREEDOM
When Surveillance Capitalism becomes Physical Torture,
Chng.it/PgsdqrRyW2 (FEB 2021)
Targeted Individuals (TI) Demand Formal (ODNI) Probe Into Radio Frequency (RF) Terrorism
ATTN TARGETED INDIVIDUALS AND THEIR ALLIES (EMF Refugees too!): THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION WANTS NO GAPS IN ITS ‘COMPREHENSIVE THREAT ASSESSMENT’ OF DOMESTIC VIOLENT EXTREMISM. NO GAPS.
Petition ‘Snapshot’:
Tell Director of National Intelligence Avril Danica Haines she must not omit ‘Radio Frequency (RF) Terrorism’ from the “comprehensive threat assessment” of Domestic Violent Extremism the White House appointed her-we learn Jan. 22 from Psaki-to oversee (and tell SHSA you need a PIN).
Petition Demand:
We the undersigned, the cybertortured and their allies, together call on The Honorable Avril Danica Haines, Director of National Intelligence, to ensure-with a written assurance-the “comprehensive threat assessment” of Domestic Violent Extremism President Joe Biden on January 22, 2021, asked her to launch will include a “robust” (see Polymeropoulos) and rigorous analysis of terroristic tactics and terroristic techniques that target now, or have in the past targeted, civilians for microwave radiation poisoning and torture by focused beaming with concentrated, “directed, pulsed radio frequency (RF) energy” (see Relman) or by “directed-energy assaults and associated crimes” (see Arnegard).
Chng.it/PgsdqrRyW2
SOYLENT GREEN IS PEOPLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
no, just a cold and forced vacines WitH this CUNTS payed normal of survaliences of a quantum needle tattoo so you can buy and sell?????????????????????????????????
13:29
You're welcome!
GILDA?
I'm a target the technology was used and experimented on me. and other targets... They still are doing it only to my death, I was told this is to my death . You describe gang stalking and remote neural monitoring..
Barbara, sign here,
When Surveillance Capitalism becomes Physical Torture,
Chng.it/PgsdqrRyW2 (FEB 2021)
Targeted Individuals (TI) Demand Formal (ODNI) Probe Into Radio Frequency (RF) Terrorism
ATTN TARGETED INDIVIDUALS AND THEIR ALLIES (EMF Refugees too!): THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION WANTS NO GAPS IN ITS ‘COMPREHENSIVE THREAT ASSESSMENT’ OF DOMESTIC VIOLENT EXTREMISM. NO GAPS.
Petition ‘Snapshot’:
Tell Director of National Intelligence Avril Danica Haines she must not omit ‘Radio Frequency (RF) Terrorism’ from the “comprehensive threat assessment” of Domestic Violent Extremism the White House appointed her-we learn Jan. 22 from Psaki-to oversee (and tell SHSA you need a PIN).
Petition Demand:
We the undersigned, the cybertortured and their allies, together call on The Honorable Avril Danica Haines, Director of National Intelligence, to ensure-with a written assurance-the “comprehensive threat assessment” of Domestic Violent Extremism President Joe Biden on January 22, 2021, asked her to launch will include a “robust” (see Polymeropoulos) and rigorous analysis of terroristic tactics and terroristic techniques that target now, or have in the past targeted, civilians for microwave radiation poisoning and torture by focused beaming with concentrated, “directed, pulsed radio frequency (RF) energy” (see Relman) or by “directed-energy assaults and associated crimes” (see Arnegard).
Chng.it/PgsdqrRyW2
I have this beautiful precious lady