The explanation of “reasonable doubt” with a dollar bill that is ripped to pieces whereby some pieces are removed, is excellent. Like a puzzle missing some pieces you can still see the picture, and therefore the dollar bill. The other explanation with the snow was also great. The best explanation I have ever heard of the principle. Excellent attorney.
Yes he has intently watched & listened the whole time, I don’t know how he made it through listening/watching Millie without showing emotion but he did! Very attentive judge
The prosecution in this matter have done an exceptional job! All three prosecutors have done amazing. They have been professional, polite and have told the truth, unlike the defense. I have never seen prosecutor's do such an amazing job during an entire trial. I truly believe they met their burden and justice will prevail for Laila and Millie next week!
I love Mr Chase! I love all 3 of the prosecutors! I especially loved how Chase completely discredited Dr Sperry! Defense wasted money on that sketchy SOB.
Katherine Kelly ~ I thought his approach to the mother-in-law was smart. He was delicate and sensitive with her; made her feel like he understood her heartache, while still forcing her to see the terrible abuse that was inflicted on the girls. He presented the evidence in such a way that she *had* acknowledge that the abuse was sustained while the girls were under JS/JS’s care. I think that she knows in her heart the Jennifer is guilty... and that her son knew what was happening. She just can’t admit it to herself. But she knows... and Mr. Chase forced her to say that the evidence cause her concern.
His voice is very easy to listen to, he’s clear and straight to the point without being rude and that , after watching the defense, is clearly a skill not everyone has.
The prosecution have been exceptional. It is clear they worked hard to ensure Laila and Millie get justice for the abuse they suffered. If they are found guilty I hope they are held without bail until sentencing . I think JR is crazy and may do something!
Well this wouldn’t have happened if Mull got her way. She asked for sentencing on a later date. Smart judge denied that request bc facing the amount of time they were facing, they would have been major flight risks.
All of the prosecutors were great. But, this gentleman is golden. He is exactly what I would want to defend the justice of a loved one in the face of a monster.
For all those people out there blaming the mother who was on drugs . It took these two monsters just 16 weeks to kill Layla. Both girls had been completely safe and cared for by people that genuinely loved them including the mother who even though she was on drugs never once abused them. Her instincts were proved right when she started recording the calls The foster mother who reported the abuse had the children removed from her because she was causing too many problems for the social worker. It was the government intervention that did this as per usual. They could have supported Nana, so she could have kept them or even the mother. What good is it to send a drug addicted mother to jail??? She failed the drug test however there were other people in the house caring for the kids.
It is GAME OVER for the Rosenbaum's. The prosecution on this case is AMAZING! And their story is so ridiculous, their witnesses are ridiculous. Everyone who lied on the stand for them and the DFCS workers who covered it up should all be arrested the minute the guilty verdict comes down on these psychopaths. Joseph makes sad faces, it's an act. Don't feel sorry for him. He could speak up. He isn't doing that. Both of them should be found guilty on all 49 counts.
Indeed!!! Those witnesses for the defence that was clearly lying and even said opposite things should be held accountable!! We have PERJURY in the law. And it should be used more often. Why have perjury in the law if its not being used? Then anyone can take an oath and lie! These people need to be charged with pejury!! not only the state of Georgia, but people around the world have seen these witnesses get up on the stand and lie for the defence. I also want to add that some seemed to be coached imo, and if that is the case then Ms.Mull needs to be held accountable for that as well. Because you are NOT allow to coach witnesses.
I think one of the most obvious liars were Jennifer's sister Summer and Dr Sperry. Both just total pathological liars. Just awful liars. Very noticeable and they should be arrested for perjury
The Prosecution's closing argument and then their rebuttal closing argument gave me chills. This Team and Judge Amero are amazing. The passion they brought to prosecute those monsters, in this tragedy, are unmatched.
If we are to protect innocent children from demonic adults, we must always believe the child even if they are not 100% believable! Narcissistic adults can be believably deceitful, manipulative liars & convince well meaning adults & society to believe them. Always look beyond what they say & learn to observe their behaviors & body language. There's a little Laila somewhere every hour crying out for help! Little Millie is a voice crying in the wilderness for every abused child in USA! Bless you Millie for your Bravery!
Iv been a mother since 16‼️my son is 15 has autism&truly is rough/tumble child&hes never broken/fractured a bone🤷♀️dont know how lol👀iv had more accidents then him🤦♀️i know all kids have accidents&I have been very fortunate but as he said COMMON SENSE💯
Exactly. The girls never had any of those issues or injuries with any other foster home or family member. Crazy how all of a sudden, within a very short time, became “rough and tumble”. Omg if I heard Mull say rough and tumble one more time I was going to punch my phone
He really is. He doesn't mess up his words and he speaks clear and concise, just like the other two prosecutors. Miss young and I can never remember the other lady's name but she's equally as awesome. I just have to give them a huge bravo for the work well done on this trial and I'm sure other ones that they have done as well
Amazing, thorough, & effective closing. Well done defense team. The time, energy, & effort that you've put into this case on behalf of those innocent little girls, is clear. I pray that the jury will find that you've proven your case beyond a reasonable doubt, & that the defendants will never have an opportunity to abuse another child ever again. I pray that Millie will heal from the emotional wounds that abuse creates, & that she'll live a happy life, surrounded by people who unconditionally love & respect her.
Yeah, me too! I didn't even know about this case until it started being shown on this RUclips channel. Plus, I like that it's in Georgia. I've seen so many cases out of Georgia, that I'm more familiar with Georgia law than the law codes of my own state. 😁 Makes it easier to follow along. Can I get a "woop woop" for this young prosecutor? He is phenomenal! He seemed to have made a study of the esoteric medical elements of the case, and thus was able to ask proper, probative and intelligent questions. He's going to be a star if he continues on with such dedication.
I also wanted to say, it's so sad that Tessa couldn't get in control if the drug use, because aside from that, it sounds as though she was a caring, capable, and loving mother, and those little girls would have been best off with a sober Tessa and family. I just pray Millie is okay. I was quite taken with her. 💖
@@La_Ru-yg8es he has done an excellent job! along with the other 2. they did wonderful with opening AND closing! I wonder why the black lady prosecutor didnt do closing bc she an excellent job on opening. she was FIRED UP!!
Look at ALL THAT GUILT on Joseph's face. 40:40 Jen's telling him to hold it together. 'Take my hand Joey I love you' THE GUILT is written ALL OVER HIS FACE. 'I told you, I told you Jen! He's replaying all abuse in his head. Damn Joe!
At about 1:00:00 you can see he blushes major on his cheek and his ear gets redder. As soon as prosecution says she went to law school…she was laying down her defense…
At the end of the trial & during the victim impact statement, for Joseph Rosenbaums mother to say, “I still think it was an accident caused while trying to save Laila” and others say, “they got it wrong “ shows how disturbed they are. Seeing the condition of these children’s wounds and observing X-rays still did not convince them, then nothing will.
At about 1:00:00 you can see he blushes major on his cheek and his ear gets redder. As soon as prosecution says she went to law school…she was laying down her defense…
I dont know how he didn't see that Mull was defending Jennifer💯and would OCCASIONALLY add him into it🤷♀️Jennifer also laid down some bread crumbs to place blame at his door🤦♀️
I heard legal analyst say Mull & Jennifer probably told Joe that his charges are ridiculous, he wasn't home usually and she is the one who they are saying beat them so he's homefree so to help his wife stand by her with one lawyer. He never thought in a million years he would get the time he got. I bet his mama isn't so fond of "Jenn" now that the dust has settled. The analyst said if he would of turned state's witness or did a plea he would have gotten little to no time. Hindsight is 20/20. When you marry a psychopath and go along with all her antics, you will go down with her.
Watching their defense was actually painful, these witnesses were merely circumstantial, offering nothing but character testimony. None of them offered any crucial information, or knew if the children were actually abused, or not
No one really matters the witnesses aren’t circumstantial all they were was witnesses for their character. No one new enough about seeing those girls to see the abuse.
HockeyMom Allan, Dr. Sperry, I think it’s part 2 of his testimony. The video was about 40 minutes long and it’s within the 1st 5 minutes that he falls off his chair. I feel bad for the guy, but the sounds he made was hilarious!😬
And the last person she saw before she died was the person who killed her, huge impact! Now lets get this jury back out with the guilty verdict and throw this evil monster and her little side kick in prison...
They should both get life without the possibility of any chance of getting out .. let them live with their actions of killing and allowing the death of a innocent 😇 baby girl Rip ... 💔🙏🏾
First they each deserve every punch, slap, kick and stomp this poor baby was forced to endure! Break their bones arms and legs, puncture their livers, beat their pancreas' in half, then spend the remainder of their miserable lives in general population. This is far kinder and humane than they deserve. RIP sweet little Kaila🙏🏻💓🙏🏻
I haven’t been as anxious about a verdict in a long, long time. I really wish someone would watch the verdict for me & tell me if it’s safe to watch. Don’t know if my heart can handle a complete not guilty verdict.
Damn, he’s goooood! What’s really sad is, he doesn’t even have a worthy opponent. LOVED the Prosecution team! They, the judge, and all witnesses brave enough to fight for those precious girls, especially those that wanted to protect them before the Rosenbaum’s came into the picture, and the medical and law enforcement after ARE BEAUTIFUL PEOPLE. Those that turned your heads to what was clearly and obviously apparent, you suck. But, the the girl (you know the one. Who didn’t recall a damn thing...even WITH notes, only had a few same answers, and had to look into the freaking air for eternity. And for what?!?!) assigned to this case to check on these girls, to be the first line of protection while in the Rosenbaum’s home FAILED MISERABLY and should pay. Lastly, THANK YOU A MILLION times to the beautiful family that took them in and took all of this on, out of love and a wish for children to see true happiness in this world!🌹🌹🌹 Miss Laila, you are exquisite!! I’d like to think it was you kicking the corrupt Dr right off the step and out of his seat.😘🦋💕
That girl was the dfcs worker that was supposed to be keeping an eye on things and checking those girls every single time that she was with them and did not do it. She started slacking and then Laila lost her life. Which is precisely why Tessa sued her and multiple other people at DFCS. Because they didn't do their job and a child lost their life and the other one is probably traumatized for life
I love this guy! It’s great how he simplified the definitions of law and how they apply to a common scenario. He doesn’t speak in that snide big shot way that the defense attorney does. The prosecutor team are not bumbling idiots who have nothing but to repeat stupid questions that have been answered several times over. The defense talked nonsense to distract from the facts that those little babies were abused, tortured and Laila was killed by this demons abuse.
OMG I have seen it all now!!!!! 41:07 He gestures to hold her hand!!!! WTF!!! It's very telling though as she quickly holds it, then puts their hands under the table, as she knows that it won't look good doing that in front of the court. The only good thing to come out of this trial is the beatings that both of them will now suffer at the hands of of prisoners. Karma is a beautiful thing!
In one of the videos it shows the picture of her on the autopsy table with her head shaved and you see if for a split second as they carried it across the room and It made my stomach drop. So terrible and sad.
Prosecution is really great in this case. I’m so glad they fought so hard for that little girl who never had a real family. Never had a mom or dad like figure who truly loved as their own. She was never truly anyones baby. I wish Tessa could had loved her and provided for her. I hope she is clean now. I bed Amanda who adopted Millie and the other sisters wished she had this sweet girl too.
Iv loved the procession in this case. They have been fair, professional and polite. Well Done! The defence however has been underhanded, rude and extremely unprofessional. Before watching these trials I believed the defence was to seek a fair and honest trial for there client not to tell a story with as much passion to be believed in there lies so bad people can walk free. SMH
I think the thorough explanation of the law, understanding the law, and explanation of each charge should be done separately and not have to be done under closing. I understand prosecution explaining thoroughly the law but i do think they should've spent a little more time going over some of her lies and basic damning evidence. although I had a little "whoohoooo" when he said do you believe someone who's been paid to testify or someone who's dedicated her entire life to the truth and getting justice!
I would have ORDERED EVERY CASE WORKER AND SUPERVISOR that let them down to be there for the girls...look at EVERY PICTURE so they rather be OVER CAUTIOUS next time ....
Ilene Edmonds I agree! I broke my ankle when I was 4, broke my right arm in Kindergarten, broke my tailbone when I was 12 & broke my left arm when I was 24. Even those fractures that occurred at the age of 4 & 5 yrs old are crystal clear memories to me. (Despite me being 43 yrs old now) Breaking bones HURTS! That’s why I’ve given up such craziness in old age. Lol. These poor babies knew no other way of life.
Ilene Edmonds I know exactly what you are talking about. My tailbone was broken at 12 yrs old, while sledding. Now that I think about it I’m not sure I ever went sledding again? Tailbones take FOREVER to heal.
One of the only memories I have from my childhood is breaking my arm while roller skating and wiping out. I remember vividly, I was screaming my head off from the pain with people skating by me. I was so scared and felt helpless for just a few minutes before finally someone noticed and helped up and I found my mom. Breaking bones is so painful and traumatic that it's the one vivid memory I have until I was about 12. I can only imagine that scared and helpless feeling all the time because no one is saving you 😥
Did anyone see the reaction from Mrs lambert when he showed her internal head Injury in the bottom right. To say this lady was not good to those girls and to remove those babies from her to these horrible people is a travesty. God bless you Mrs lambert 🤗
I find it so weird that Joseph and Jennifer are being tried together. Joseph was neglectful for sure but Jennifer seems to be the main abuser. Joseph should throw that witch under the bus and admit what really happened.
If he was innocent he definitely would have. The fact that he is sitting there, holding her hand, all the way up to the last minute should tell you all you need to know about him. He is a grown man, he was involved, he knew. He makes sad faces, it's an act.
Maybe she has something disturbing on him apart from the physical abuse but related to the girls and he knows she will turn on him if he doesn't support her????
Mr and Mrs Rosenbaum are lucky that all they have to deal with is prison. I have 4 and 2 year old nieces and can say with absolute confidence that if somebody did to them what these two did to Laila and Millie, they wouldn’t make it to trial or prison. And it wouldn’t be quick and relatively painless like shooting them in the heart or head either. No I’d restrain them, take them somewhere nobody would see or hear (10,000+ acre ranches with outbuildings and/or natural concealment miles away from the nearest house or public road offer lots of places that meet those requirements), and see how they liked being treated like that.
I love that so many attorneys in the south use the snow situation with evidence! These attorneys were top notch! Henry county would love to have them as their prosecutors! Their passion is amazing!
Idk if Joseph will be found guilty of murder, but he may very well be found guilty of other charges. idk. its hard to tell with his case. almost as if hes been skipped over
Did anybody notice that the tree and latter wasn't even there yard becuz in the cops picture showed no trees in there back yard just a fence no swing set or toys that's messed up
If what the R'bergs said was true they would have taken the stand and explained what happened instead of allowing innocent witnesses be bullied by ms mool.
It's in an edited clip. Google "sister of Laila Daniel gives evidence". It's riveting. Even when she clearly blotted out stuff, which she did, poor petal, in order to survive
I think jennifer is a monster and abuser but I do have to say from experience I broke my arm when i was 1 and 1/2 and I didnt cry or anything. My parents didnt know for 2 weeks bc I never acted like it hurt. The only reason my mom took me to the doctor was bc 1 day she went to put my coat on and i kept pulling my arm away and it was something id never done so she took me to the doctor and it was completely broken. So not all toddlers that break a bone will act the same .... But these poor babies were def abused i realize its not the same thing but from MY experience some of the things he's saying about how Laila would have acted with a broken arm isnt always the case.
I totally get what you are saying, and yes... kids are so very resilient!!! Some do sometimes injure themselves and it goes unknown until it is randomly figured out from some other way than a child expressing they had an issue. Now if they were on trial for being accused of child abuse or neglect because they had let a broken bone unknowingly go on for an extended time without getting Laila help, on a one time occasion, and they truly did not realize something had happened on that one occasion, and appeared to be in complete disbelief and emotionally destrought, and were saying "I would never purposely let my baby hurt, and what you all are charging me with is complete BS"... well, that is just a totally different situation than what we are facing here!!! Had this been an accidental one time event that did not result in death... I would think it was outrageous to go after a parent in that way if they otherwise showed themselves to be loving and caring. I would think it was totally unfair!!! But the truth of reality is that NONE of this can be excused away!!! This poor baby was tortured ON PURPOSE!!! On what seems to be a multiple time a day basis. Even having her old injuries reinjured in the same places multiple times. And none of this was invisible to the eye either!!! Bruises upon bruises upon more bruises. With proven lies about their excuses as to why this happened!!! Nothing they ever did to this baby was ever an accident. Laila's little arm was looking deformed because of the break they didn't get her any help for!?! This is all so awful. Like I said, I totally get what you are saying, and it can happen... BUT... that is so far from the situation that happened in the Rosenbaum home. What is sad... DCFS would probably be more likely to take action against a parent that truly had no idea that something had happened until a couple of weeks later, by accusing they of negligence!!! Look at all these horror stories of tragic events that occurred that were simply just ignored because of who they were. It is so twisted the way things work with things sometimes. So many people failed this child. Probably because they were too busy picking on a family that truly didn't deserve to be bothered!!!
It's a cover for her mouth as she records the words everyone is saying. Instead of typing, they speak into it. The covering mutes her completely from the courtroom hearing her.
20 mins later and we are still learning law ........get to the closing they are guilty!!! Zero doubt about it!!! Hope they both get life without parole in general population......lets see how they like it. Joseph will find that no one snitches in jail just like he didnt snitch on that monster sitting next to him, karma is a biatchè
Common sense tells me they are quilty as hell joseph will get his just desets when he goes to prison thery will love him there they look forward to child abusers arriving.all those moms in prison who can not see their kids oh yea they will get theirs.
Isso é o senhor juiz isso é o senhor tá suas palavras que está o senhorjuízo você sim ou não que não deve chamar de senhor porque ele tá respondendo receita aí como o juízo que posição você que posição você tem não responde como juiz responde o responde por que você está aí como tu está em que posição você tá aí na frente sentado
It's like a microphone but she's speaking into the thing to mute her voice from the courtroom. She's recording everything said, just instead of typing, she speaks.
![CHILE vs. BRASIL [1-2] | RESUMEN | ELIMINATORIAS SUDAMERICANAS | FECHA 9](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5ObJt_71AYc/mqdefault.jpg)
The explanation of “reasonable doubt” with a dollar bill that is ripped to pieces whereby some pieces are removed, is excellent. Like a puzzle missing some pieces you can still see the picture, and therefore the dollar bill. The other explanation with the snow was also great.
The best explanation I have ever heard of the principle. Excellent attorney.
Yes! So good!
What a brilliant closing. He was relatable, to the point and precise. He just got the guilty verdict I'm guessing love him
Can we just recognize the judges interest in this presentation. He straining his neck to reading every slide. Good for him.
The judge has been very deligent throughout this trial of long hours each day!
Yes he has intently watched & listened the whole time, I don’t know how he made it through listening/watching Millie without showing emotion but he did! Very attentive judge
I thought that as well!
The prosecution in this matter have done an exceptional job! All three prosecutors have done amazing. They have been professional, polite and have told the truth, unlike the defense. I have never seen prosecutor's do such an amazing job during an entire trial. I truly believe they met their burden and justice will prevail for Laila and Millie next week!
They've pulverized Mrs. Mull.
I pray that they have. Those babies need it.
ALL UNITE absolutely! Professionalism, integrity and empathy! Georgia should be proud.
@@thehaglin agreed!!
Don't forget Juan Martinez, prosecutor for the Jodi Arias trial 😊
I also love how real he is in explaining their just duty. He speaks to them like they’re human beings. And like he has faith in their intelligence
Georgia should be so proud of this prosecution team. They were amazing! Thank you for getting justice without any doubt.
I've enjoyed watching Mr. Chase. He's excellent, passionate and professional.
Me too. His genius was in display throughout but I was particularly impressed with how he questioned the mother-in-law.
I love Mr Chase! I love all 3 of the prosecutors! I especially loved how Chase completely discredited Dr Sperry! Defense wasted money on that sketchy SOB.
Katherine Kelly ~ I thought his approach to the mother-in-law was smart. He was delicate and sensitive with her; made her feel like he understood her heartache, while still forcing her to see the terrible abuse that was inflicted on the girls. He presented the evidence in such a way that she *had* acknowledge that the abuse was sustained while the girls were under JS/JS’s care. I think that she knows in her heart the Jennifer is guilty... and that her son knew what was happening. She just can’t admit it to herself. But she knows... and Mr. Chase forced her to say that the evidence cause her concern.
His voice is very easy to listen to, he’s clear and straight to the point without being rude and that , after watching the defense, is clearly a skill not everyone has.
I agree, Mr Chase was very skilled at hammering points home without being a bully or condescending ...Bravo👏👏👏👏👏✌🇨🇦
The prosecution have been exceptional. It is clear they worked hard to ensure Laila and Millie get justice for the abuse they suffered.
If they are found guilty I hope they are held without bail until sentencing . I think JR is crazy and may do something!
They will be leaving court room & straight to jail once guilty verdict is established. Do not pass go & do not collect $100!
Well this wouldn’t have happened if Mull got her way. She asked for sentencing on a later date. Smart judge denied that request bc facing the amount of time they were facing, they would have been major flight risks.
@@maryb6672 yes that was satisfying... judge answered before her request was even complete.
I love this prosecutor ! what an amazing job hes done ! so hope this is a guilty verdict
All of the prosecutors were great. But, this gentleman is golden. He is exactly what I would want to defend the justice of a loved one in the face of a monster.
For all those people out there blaming the mother who was on drugs . It took these two monsters just 16 weeks to kill Layla. Both girls had been completely safe and cared for by people that genuinely loved them including the mother who even though she was on drugs never once abused them. Her instincts were proved right when she started recording the calls The foster mother who reported the abuse had the children removed from her because she was causing too many problems for the social worker. It was the government intervention that did this as per usual. They could have supported Nana, so she could have kept them or even the mother. What good is it to send a drug addicted mother to jail??? She failed the drug test however there were other people in the house caring for the kids.
Kirks 71 I totally agree!
Exactly what I was thinking! Well said!
Thank you
It is GAME OVER for the Rosenbaum's. The prosecution on this case is AMAZING! And their story is so ridiculous, their witnesses are ridiculous. Everyone who lied on the stand for them and the DFCS workers who covered it up should all be arrested the minute the guilty verdict comes down on these psychopaths. Joseph makes sad faces, it's an act. Don't feel sorry for him. He could speak up. He isn't doing that. Both of them should be found guilty on all 49 counts.
Indeed!!! Those witnesses for the defence that was clearly lying and even said opposite things should be held accountable!! We have PERJURY in the law. And it should be used more often. Why have perjury in the law if its not being used? Then anyone can take an oath and lie! These people need to be charged with pejury!! not only the state of Georgia, but people around the world have seen these witnesses get up on the stand and lie for the defence. I also want to add that some seemed to be coached imo, and if that is the case then Ms.Mull needs to be held accountable for that as well. Because you are NOT allow to coach witnesses.
@@donnacox8541 Absolutely!!
I think one of the most obvious liars were Jennifer's sister Summer and Dr Sperry. Both just total pathological liars. Just awful liars. Very noticeable and they should be arrested for perjury
Excellent Closing By The Prosecution
The Prosecution's closing argument and then their rebuttal closing argument gave me chills. This Team and Judge Amero are amazing. The passion they brought to prosecute those monsters, in this tragedy, are unmatched.
If we are to protect innocent children from demonic adults, we must always believe the child even if they are not 100% believable! Narcissistic adults can be believably deceitful, manipulative liars & convince well meaning adults & society to believe them. Always look beyond what they say & learn to observe their behaviors & body language. There's a little Laila somewhere every hour crying out for help! Little Millie is a voice crying in the wilderness for every abused child in USA! Bless you Millie for your Bravery!
Well said
Amen🙏
Spoken perfectly and 100% true! Praying for guilty verdicts and the maximum sentence/penalty! Also praying for all of the Layla's and Miley's tonight.
So well said! I’ll believe a child until proven otherwise. Their recollections may not be as precise, but much more raw than a calloused adult.
Millie saying" She can not tell who is good or bad anymore." Broke my heart.
2 kids with multiple fractures and bruising living in the same house , now what are the chances of that happening by accident???
Iv been a mother since 16‼️my son is 15 has autism&truly is rough/tumble child&hes never broken/fractured a bone🤷♀️dont know how lol👀iv had more accidents then him🤦♀️i know all kids have accidents&I have been very fortunate but as he said COMMON SENSE💯
Exactly.
The girls never had any of those issues or injuries with any other foster home or family member. Crazy how all of a sudden, within a very short time, became “rough and tumble”. Omg if I heard Mull say rough and tumble one more time I was going to punch my phone
The most powerful display of a prosecution’s argument on behalf of the state to a jury. Well done Miss Dasha young . This needs an Emmy ❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏
Only Ms Dasha Young not acting. She just took us all to church with that close!
Jennifer Rosenbaum deserves the Emmy.
I really like the prosecutors explanations. He’s good!
He really is. He doesn't mess up his words and he speaks clear and concise, just like the other two prosecutors. Miss young and I can never remember the other lady's name but she's equally as awesome. I just have to give them a huge bravo for the work well done on this trial and I'm sure other ones that they have done as well
Amazing, thorough, & effective closing. Well done defense team. The time, energy, & effort that you've put into this case on behalf of those innocent little girls, is clear. I pray that the jury will find that you've proven your case beyond a reasonable doubt, & that the defendants will never have an opportunity to abuse another child ever again. I pray that Millie will heal from the emotional wounds that abuse creates, & that she'll live a happy life, surrounded by people who unconditionally love & respect her.
I'm more excited about this verdict , than any other trail , lately.
Yeah, me too! I didn't even know about this case until it started being shown on this RUclips channel. Plus, I like that it's in Georgia. I've seen so many cases out of Georgia, that I'm more familiar with Georgia law than the law codes of my own state. 😁 Makes it easier to follow along.
Can I get a "woop woop" for this young prosecutor? He is phenomenal! He seemed to have made a study of the esoteric medical elements of the case, and thus was able to ask proper, probative and intelligent questions. He's going to be a star if he continues on with such dedication.
I also wanted to say, it's so sad that Tessa couldn't get in control if the drug use, because aside from that, it sounds as though she was a caring, capable, and loving mother, and those little girls would have been best off with a sober Tessa and family. I just pray Millie is okay. I was quite taken with her. 💖
I am concerned there will be one witness who was confused by so much crap put out by defense. all it takes is one that has doubt.
@@La_Ru-yg8es he has done an excellent job! along with the other 2. they did wonderful with opening AND closing! I wonder why the black lady prosecutor didnt do closing bc she an excellent job on opening. she was FIRED UP!!
@@jennifers.3818 She did the second closing/rebuttal.
Look at ALL THAT GUILT on Joseph's face. 40:40 Jen's telling him to hold it together. 'Take my hand Joey I love you' THE GUILT is written ALL OVER HIS FACE. 'I told you, I told you Jen! He's replaying all abuse in his head. Damn Joe!
At about 1:00:00 you can see he blushes major on his cheek and his ear gets redder. As soon as prosecution says she went to law school…she was laying down her defense…
At the end of the trial & during the victim impact statement, for Joseph Rosenbaums mother to say, “I still think it was an accident caused while trying to save Laila” and others say, “they got it wrong “ shows how disturbed they are. Seeing the condition of these children’s wounds and observing X-rays still did not convince them, then nothing will.
40:45 Joseph actually realises he's done for .......the penny has finally dropped!!!!
At about 1:00:00 you can see he blushes major on his cheek and his ear gets redder. As soon as prosecution says she went to law school…she was laying down her defense…
I dont know how he didn't see that Mull was defending Jennifer💯and would OCCASIONALLY add him into it🤷♀️Jennifer also laid down some bread crumbs to place blame at his door🤦♀️
I heard legal analyst say Mull & Jennifer probably told Joe that his charges are ridiculous, he wasn't home usually and she is the one who they are saying beat them so he's homefree so to help his wife stand by her with one lawyer. He never thought in a million years he would get the time he got. I bet his mama isn't so fond of "Jenn" now that the dust has settled. The analyst said if he would of turned state's witness or did a plea he would have gotten little to no time. Hindsight is 20/20. When you marry a psychopath and go along with all her antics, you will go down with her.
Excellent closing 👏👏👏 Thank you for giving Layla & Millie the Justice they deserved!
Watching their defense was actually painful, these witnesses were merely circumstantial, offering nothing but character testimony. None of them offered any crucial information, or knew if the children were actually abused, or not
No one really matters I think they sealed their fate with the vodka sipping colonel who can’t stay upright in his char.
No one really matters the witnesses aren’t circumstantial all they were was witnesses for their character. No one new enough about seeing those girls to see the abuse.
@@happyshit2506 LOLOLOL
Temper Love which witness was that? I didn’t get thru all of the defense witnesses.
HockeyMom Allan, Dr. Sperry, I think it’s part 2 of his testimony. The video was about 40 minutes long and it’s within the 1st 5 minutes that he falls off his chair. I feel bad for the guy, but the sounds he made was hilarious!😬
And the last person she saw before she died was the person who killed her, huge impact! Now lets get this jury back out with the guilty verdict and throw this evil monster and her little side kick in prison...
The last person she saw was Jesus because he decides when he takes her and he offers a beautiful scene
God bless these children
Wow his final two statements before he sat down gave me chills up and down 😢😢
They should both get life without the possibility of any chance of getting out .. let them live with their actions of killing and allowing the death of a innocent 😇 baby girl Rip ... 💔🙏🏾
First they each deserve every punch, slap, kick and stomp this poor baby was forced to endure! Break their bones arms and legs, puncture their livers, beat their pancreas' in half, then spend the remainder of their miserable lives in general population. This is far kinder and humane than they deserve. RIP sweet little Kaila🙏🏻💓🙏🏻
I haven’t been as anxious about a verdict in a long, long time. I really wish someone would watch the verdict for me & tell me if it’s safe to watch. Don’t know if my heart can handle a complete not guilty verdict.
Me either. I would be so pissed if that stupid defense Lawyer gets them off.
@@GailMarie1972 I feel the same
I think the last time I was this anxious about a verdict was Casey Anthony. We can only hope these jurors are smarter than the ones in her case!🤦🏻♀️
Yea! It’s safe for everyone to watch the verdict! Yea!
Lol 😂 it’s hard eh!
Damn, he’s goooood! What’s really sad is, he doesn’t even have a worthy opponent. LOVED the Prosecution team! They, the judge, and all witnesses brave enough to fight for those precious girls, especially those that wanted to protect them before the Rosenbaum’s came into the picture, and the medical and law enforcement after ARE BEAUTIFUL PEOPLE. Those that turned your heads to what was clearly and obviously apparent, you suck. But, the the girl (you know the one. Who didn’t recall a damn thing...even WITH notes, only had a few same answers, and had to look into the freaking air for eternity. And for what?!?!) assigned to this case to check on these girls, to be the first line of protection while in the Rosenbaum’s home FAILED MISERABLY and should pay. Lastly, THANK YOU A MILLION times to the beautiful family that took them in and took all of this on, out of love and a wish for children to see true happiness in this world!🌹🌹🌹 Miss Laila, you are exquisite!! I’d like to think it was you kicking the corrupt Dr right off the step and out of his seat.😘🦋💕
That girl was the dfcs worker that was supposed to be keeping an eye on things and checking those girls every single time that she was with them and did not do it. She started slacking and then Laila lost her life. Which is precisely why Tessa sued her and multiple other people at DFCS. Because they didn't do their job and a child lost their life and the other one is probably traumatized for life
Yesssss! Laila's payback to the lying doctor! I love that thought!
A dollar bill and a snowstorm sealed their fate..!
Watching right now and see that Joseph and Jennifer are looking down at the desk rather than look at the slides of baby Laila's injuries...
I love this guy! It’s great how he simplified the definitions of law and how they apply to a common scenario. He doesn’t speak in that snide big shot way that the defense attorney does. The prosecutor team are not bumbling idiots who have nothing but to repeat stupid questions that have been answered several times over. The defense talked nonsense to distract from the facts that those little babies were abused, tortured and Laila was killed by this demons abuse.
Agree! 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Joseph has realized his goose is cooked.
OMG I have seen it all now!!!!!
41:07 He gestures to hold her hand!!!! WTF!!!
It's very telling though as she quickly holds it, then puts their hands under the table, as she knows that it won't look good doing that in front of the court.
The only good thing to come out of this trial is the beatings that both of them will now suffer at the hands of of prisoners. Karma is a beautiful thing!
A facade is putting it lightly!
I don't think I and anyone would be able to stand to view those crime scene photos , it is good they don't show it.
In one of the videos it shows the picture of her on the autopsy table with her head shaved and you see if for a split second as they carried it across the room and It made my stomach drop. So terrible and sad.
This closing is riveting.
I would be on trial for murder if I found out my husband was hurting our babies. Shame on you Joseph
Mr Chase explains every sent. Amazing attorney, all three.
Finally, after all the unnecessary nonsense from the defense!
Hope u two enjoy your last few days of house arrest
Totally! And I hope she enjoys getting her ass kicked by big Bertha in prison; once they hear about what she did!
Were they found guilty?
They never paid attention to the whole trial.
@@sharaycarter5523 yes
They need to show their faces
Prosecution is really great in this case. I’m so glad they fought so hard for that little girl who never had a real family. Never had a mom or dad like figure who truly loved as their own. She was never truly anyones baby. I wish Tessa could had loved her and provided for her. I hope she is clean now. I bed Amanda who adopted Millie and the other sisters wished she had this sweet girl too.
Omg the holding of her hand while describing the horrible injuries.. Such pathology
Iv loved the procession in this case. They have been fair, professional and polite.
Well Done!
The defence however has been underhanded, rude and extremely unprofessional.
Before watching these trials I believed the defence was to seek a fair and honest trial for there client not to tell a story with as much passion to be believed in there lies so bad people can walk free. SMH
This prosecutor is also gold.
I think the thorough explanation of the law, understanding the law, and explanation of each charge should be done separately and not have to be done under closing. I understand prosecution explaining thoroughly the law but i do think they should've spent a little more time going over some of her lies and basic damning evidence. although I had a little "whoohoooo" when he said do you believe someone who's been paid to testify or someone who's dedicated her entire life to the truth and getting justice!
I would have ORDERED EVERY CASE WORKER AND SUPERVISOR that let them down to be there for the girls...look at EVERY PICTURE so they rather be OVER CAUTIOUS next time ....
shame on them they cant even look at what they have done bright pink nails what evil heartless monsters
Bravo to the prosecutors. They've gone above and beyond and so brought some small justice for these poor children.
Millie was in lots of pain my girl broke both her arms before she was 12. I tell you now there was lots of pain even after drs set the bones.
Ilene Edmonds I agree! I broke my ankle when I was 4, broke my right arm in Kindergarten, broke my tailbone when I was 12 & broke my left arm when I was 24. Even those fractures that occurred at the age of 4 & 5 yrs old are crystal clear memories to me. (Despite me being 43 yrs old now) Breaking bones HURTS! That’s why I’ve given up such craziness in old age. Lol. These poor babies knew no other way of life.
@@maryb6672 I know broke my ankle 11/07/77 a Sunday roller skating memory is vivid last pare of skates i have had on.
Ilene Edmonds I know exactly what you are talking about. My tailbone was broken at 12 yrs old, while sledding. Now that I think about it I’m not sure I ever went sledding again? Tailbones take FOREVER to heal.
I’ve only ever broken toes and that’s painful enough. I can only imagine the amount of pain these precious girls suffered...completely heartbreaking!
One of the only memories I have from my childhood is breaking my arm while roller skating and wiping out. I remember vividly, I was screaming my head off from the pain with people skating by me. I was so scared and felt helpless for just a few minutes before finally someone noticed and helped up and I found my mom. Breaking bones is so painful and traumatic that it's the one vivid memory I have until I was about 12. I can only imagine that scared and helpless feeling all the time because no one is saving you 😥
Did anyone see the reaction from Mrs lambert when he showed her internal head Injury in the bottom right. To say this lady was not good to those girls and to remove those babies from her to these horrible people is a travesty. God bless you Mrs lambert 🤗
I find it so weird that Joseph and Jennifer are being tried together. Joseph was neglectful for sure but Jennifer seems to be the main abuser. Joseph should throw that witch under the bus and admit what really happened.
He's too entangled in her slimy web just like everyone else. He's probably scared to disagree with her about anything..
If he was innocent he definitely would have. The fact that he is sitting there, holding her hand, all the way up to the last minute should tell you all you need to know about him. He is a grown man, he was involved, he knew. He makes sad faces, it's an act.
Meredith Lincoln Joseph looks pretty terrified. The witch, well, looks like a witch. These are terrible people!
Connie P. He’s a huge wimp!!! She definitely has control over him.
Maybe she has something disturbing on him apart from the physical abuse but related to the girls and he knows she will turn on him if he doesn't support her????
Mr and Mrs Rosenbaum are lucky that all they have to deal with is prison. I have 4 and 2 year old nieces and can say with absolute confidence that if somebody did to them what these two did to Laila and Millie, they wouldn’t make it to trial or prison. And it wouldn’t be quick and relatively painless like shooting them in the heart or head either. No I’d restrain them, take them somewhere nobody would see or hear (10,000+ acre ranches with outbuildings and/or natural concealment miles away from the nearest house or public road offer lots of places that meet those requirements), and see how they liked being treated like that.
Are you saved?
I hate that court reporting method. Why have someone else re-speak what she hears the atty etc say? Just record him saying it into the machine. Geez
I love that so many attorneys in the south use the snow situation with evidence! These attorneys were top notch! Henry county would love to have them as their prosecutors! Their passion is amazing!
Good their family and friends are there i hope they see everything they did every break..bruising..and beating
Idk if Joseph will be found guilty of murder, but he may very well be found guilty of other charges. idk. its hard to tell with his case. almost as if hes been skipped over
Joseph looks extremely uncomfortable right now.
So!
It's an act.
Did anybody notice that the tree and latter wasn't even there yard becuz in the cops picture showed no trees in there back yard just a fence no swing set or toys that's messed up
I thought that was supposed to be at a relative’s house.
She did it!! And he help as well as watched
If what the R'bergs said was true they would have taken the stand and explained what happened instead of allowing innocent witnesses be bullied by ms mool.
God Help Us If These Monsters Get Away With This....I Just Cant 😠😡!
This prosecutor is just amazing.
I hope they are anxious and crippled with fear waiting to see if their lives end....just like they did every day to the girl's..
Can someone tell me which day and which part Millie was on the stand in please? Thank you :)
Logan Hensley day 3 I believe 💔
It's in an edited clip. Google "sister of Laila Daniel gives evidence". It's riveting. Even when she clearly blotted out stuff, which she did, poor petal, in order to survive
@@shaynelahmed6323 thank you SO MUCH!!
@@Mrs.B89 thank you!!!
@@loganhensley1042 your welcome
What are those two doing.....sleeping 😡
I think jennifer is a monster and abuser but I do have to say from experience I broke my arm when i was 1 and 1/2 and I didnt cry or anything. My parents didnt know for 2 weeks bc I never acted like it hurt. The only reason my mom took me to the doctor was bc 1 day she went to put my coat on and i kept pulling my arm away and it was something id never done so she took me to the doctor and it was completely broken. So not all toddlers that break a bone will act the same .... But these poor babies were def abused i realize its not the same thing but from MY experience some of the things he's saying about how Laila would have acted with a broken arm isnt always the case.
I totally get what you are saying, and yes... kids are so very resilient!!! Some do sometimes injure themselves and it goes unknown until it is randomly figured out from some other way than a child expressing they had an issue. Now if they were on trial for being accused of child abuse or neglect because they had let a broken bone unknowingly go on for an extended time without getting Laila help, on a one time occasion, and they truly did not realize something had happened on that one occasion, and appeared to be in complete disbelief and emotionally destrought, and were saying "I would never purposely let my baby hurt, and what you all are charging me with is complete BS"... well, that is just a totally different situation than what we are facing here!!! Had this been an accidental one time event that did not result in death... I would think it was outrageous to go after a parent in that way if they otherwise showed themselves to be loving and caring. I would think it was totally unfair!!! But the truth of reality is that NONE of this can be excused away!!! This poor baby was tortured ON PURPOSE!!! On what seems to be a multiple time a day basis. Even having her old injuries reinjured in the same places multiple times. And none of this was invisible to the eye either!!! Bruises upon bruises upon more bruises. With proven lies about their excuses as to why this happened!!! Nothing they ever did to this baby was ever an accident. Laila's little arm was looking deformed because of the break they didn't get her any help for!?! This is all so awful. Like I said, I totally get what you are saying, and it can happen... BUT... that is so far from the situation that happened in the Rosenbaum home. What is sad... DCFS would probably be more likely to take action against a parent that truly had no idea that something had happened until a couple of weeks later, by accusing they of negligence!!! Look at all these horror stories of tragic events that occurred that were simply just ignored because of who they were. It is so twisted the way things work with things sometimes. So many people failed this child. Probably because they were too busy picking on a family that truly didn't deserve to be bothered!!!
Why is the judge looking at during the last few minutes?
Notic the deficit could cause the injuries but can’t look at the evidence. What cowards 👹 👹
Defendants??
5:36 elle fait quoi la femme en vert avec son truc sur la bouche????
Why are FOSTER PARENTS, REQUIRED TO BE CERTIFIED IN CHILD, CPR !???
Sweetly creeping in They weren’t foster parents. JR pulled some strings & got the girls as a kinship placement, which requires no classes or training.
To be able to provide essential basic life support to children in their care, until help arrives! Every responsible parent and adult should know it.
What is the court reporter holding up to her mouth?
It's a cover for her mouth as she records the words everyone is saying. Instead of typing, they speak into it. The covering mutes her completely from the courtroom hearing her.
20 mins later and we are still learning law ........get to the closing they are guilty!!! Zero doubt about it!!! Hope they both get life without parole in general population......lets see how they like it. Joseph will find that no one snitches in jail just like he didnt snitch on that monster sitting next to him, karma is a biatchè
Common sense tells me they are quilty as hell joseph will get his just desets when he goes to prison thery will love him there they look forward to child abusers arriving.all those moms in prison who can not see their kids oh yea they will get theirs.
Isso é o senhor juiz isso é o senhor tá suas palavras que está o senhorjuízo você sim ou não que não deve chamar de senhor porque ele tá respondendo receita aí como o juízo que posição você que posição você tem não responde como juiz responde o responde por que você está aí como tu está em que posição você tá aí na frente sentado
Did I miss something? Did Jennifer testify?
His closing arguments sound almost identical to his opening statements. Is this a rerun?
Neva Kendrick his? Who’s? He didn’t have an opening statement it was a woman
He didn’t do an opening statement.
Exactly!!! Show there face
Could anyone tell me what the lady sitting down in front of the judge is speaking into?
It's like a microphone but she's speaking into the thing to mute her voice from the courtroom. She's recording everything said, just instead of typing, she speaks.
@@chefsusansavage2784 thank you!