I would love to see a comparison of the two bands live. This is where you find out what their vocal abilities truly are. It's shocking how the Warning gets BETTER live, vocally, and VOB is vastly superior in the studio (vocally, not instrumentally). I hope VOB continues to work on their live vocals... I want to support them, and I do support them, but not in competitions with other groups like The Warning, Nemophila etc, who have spent so much time honing their live vocals with professional guidance and, mostly, lots and lots and lots of very hard work. That being said, VOB's instrumentals, live, well at least in the bass and drums, are INSANE. Guitar is good live, but their rhythm section is nuts for heavy funk rock. Just like The Warning's rhythm section is outstanding for rock... two of the greatest bands out there.
Yeah the warning Video viewer for their single and live only 2,9 mil , but VOB 4,4 mil. VOB are a live band, what you heard are what you see on stages, and their song had meaning and soul for METAL HEAD.
Views don't mean anything if you talk about talent, in any case VOB would lose since TW has 100M in total between all the videos and VOB 23M. Both banda are amazing.
They're both rock bands, but the similarity ends there. I'm really digging The Warning's style in their entirety. Since I hear some good musicianship and song structure, I will probably listen to some more VOB just to see if something they do floats my boat.
VoB adalah band yg terlahir dari segala keterbatasan... Wajar jika mereka kalah di banding The Warning... Tapi saya percaya dan Yakin bahwa talenta VoB masih bisa jauh lebih berkembang dan lebih Top lagi...
Saya berusaha untuk obyektif, mohon maaf jika salah. Menurut saya the warning pun tidak kalah bagus. Sudah kelas dunia kwalitasnya. Namun tidak dipungkiri karena didasari dan dibekali fasilitas yang mencukupi untuk pencapaian sampai saat sekarang. Hanya satu yang menurut saya kurang, musiknya lebih terkesan/cenderung komersil. Menurut pendapat saya Skill dan idealis musik VOB lebih bagus. Dipoles dikit 95% sudah sempurna. VOB hanya kalah bahasa, teknologi audio & visual. dan tentunya marketing penting dalam pengenalan kualitas. Tinggal cari sponsor dan marketing handal sudah high end performa.
I have been a The Warning fan for many years and a VOB fan for the last year or so. I feel playing bands of against each other can be devisive and turn fan bases against listening to other bands music, even if it is just done for fun. The competition is hard enough for young female artists as it is, especially in rock as a whole. ❤✌🤘 U.K.
Fair enough. You're entitled to your opinion. We like both bands and we're hoping that by combining them together in one video, we may help to promote each band. So The Warning fans may get acquainted with VOB and vice versa. No harm intended.
They both are great bands!! The Warning is just more versatile. They can sing a ballad type song and make you tear up or flip the switch and i bang my head. The Warning has my vote! 👊🏼
I think..THE WARNING and VOB have the same music talent. The only difference is in the flow of the music. VOB is more prominent metal punk rock, while THE WARNING to rock. Then from playing the instrument, VOB is more prominent. But in that case, back to each individual, because not everyone likes the music or the lyrics. We hope that these two bands can go global and be accepted by many people. We are waiting for VOB to tour America in Agustus 2023 about 12 cities in America.🤘🤘🤘🤘
The Warning, hands down. I like VoB a lot but their problem for me is the depth of their discography. The Enemy of Earth is You is actually an old song that they've gone into the studio and produced a slick updated version of it. They did a similar thing with their previous release PMS from last November. While these new versions are good and well produced, I kind of like the raw live session recording of PMS from 2019. I've seen live footage of The Enemy of Earth is You from 2017 and it's quite good as it was back then. I believe a lot of their difficulties lies in financing since I think they're still an independent band which leads to a lot of touring to support themselves. I wish them the best and hope for a new album of originals someday. Edit: Same goes for their most recent release What's The Holy (Nobel) Today?, another old song that got a refresh and professional recording. In all 3 of these songs (What's The Holy (Nobel) Today?, The Enemy of Earth is You, and PMS) they reworked the lyrics to be mostly in English. As far as I know, only the lead singer can converse in English so that makes backing vocals a bit tricky.
VOP does not has stage presence like TW. For me TW is more versatile and is not metal band. They get my feelings out, VOP sounds like another metal band mold
I try to be objective, sorry if I'm wrong. In my opinion, the warning is no less good. The quality is world class. However, it cannot be denied that it is based on and provided with sufficient facilities for achievements up to now. There's only one thing that I think is lacking, the music seems more commercial. In my opinion, VOB's musical skills and ideals are better. Polished a little 95% and it's perfect. VOB is only inferior to language, audio & visual technology. and of course marketing is important in introducing quality. Just look for sponsors and reliable marketing, I'm sure it will be a high performer.
VOB are great musicians and have great stage presence for a relatively young band starting to get attention; however The Warning wins hands down when it comes to vocals and songwriting and are arguably just as talented musicians, though their instrumental style is less “showy” than VOB. I wish both bands continued success.
For me Marsya VOB's guitar skills are extraordinary, Widi's bass is also okay, Siti's drums are also great,... the VOB song with the best vocals in my opinion is PMS,... it sounds very typical for Indonesian female vocals,... for other songs vocals are pretty good (not bad) because mostly rapping. The Warning is of course good,.. only the genre doesn't sound ROCK enough so it doesn't really hit me (because basically I like metal) Success for them (VOB & TW),.. I hope one day the two groups can have one stage, one event... that must be fun🤘🏼🔥
Not particularly a rock/metal fan but I enjoyed Warning. The lead could really sing. I didn't care at all for VOB. Not me cup of tea. Warning hands down winner! ❤
For me, it's a bit of a shame that The Warning and VoB get thrown up against each other - while they're both very good and superficially similar, they're making very different kinds of music (to my ear). For me, it's an apples and oranges comparison. It makes a little more sense when both are covering a standard (e.g. Enter Sandman), but even then, the covers sound completely different to me. But there is a definite plus side to the Warning/VoB rivalry on YT - it drives a viewership and exposes people around the world to talent they might not otherwise hear.
But the warning also have strong massages, depends on the song but also have strong messages, XXI century blood, Error, disciple, kool aid kids, Cooper bullets, etc, And the warning is much more a stage band than a radio songs band, although, they are more histrionics than VoB, and that can be excessive for some
To me, "Disciple" or "Evolve" would have been a better comparison song to VOB's song, as those are harder rock than "Choke". But for me The Warning still takes the win.
The Warning gets my vote. Maybe VOB has a slight edge when it comes to instrumentals. IDK. It's hard to say because The Warning perform whatever suits the song with no intention of showing off or designing solos into the performance. I dare say each band is well aware of the other and are as likely as not fans. I know for a fact that TW are fans of Band-maid, another all-female international band. TW just returned from their first tour in Europe and (I hope) are going to spend some time laying down new tracks before going back on tour in August. They have been designing their songs around playing them live. They are truly a band that comes off better live because of the amount of energy they put into their shows.
I just saw this video after a year it has been uploaded. What can I add to what's been said already? Well, just look at where are each band one year later. That should be enough: In the last months two singles by The Warning have breaking into the Billboard Rock Top 40 Chart (More & S!ck). S!ck actually peaked at #8! Their new album Keep Me Fed debuted as the Top selling rock/metal album in the UK. Debuted at Number 6 in the USA. They have sold out every venue where they've played. They sold out two shows at Auditorio Nacional in Mexico City (a 10,000 seats venue), the first one went sold out in just 1 hour! and it's going to take place until february 2025! Many VOB fans mentioned in the comments the fact that they've played at Wacken Open Air Festival, well, guess what? Within a few weeks The Warning will play there as well, and right after that, at Pol and Rock festival. Then a extense tour by USA/Canada with Halestorm and Evanescence. The Warning is now considered #1 emerging artist by Billboard. They are at #27 at Billboard Hot Artist 100. Should I continue? Don't get me wrong, I wish only success to the girls of VOB, they deserves all the best things in the world, but the hard facts are undeniable. The Warning is destined to super stardom.
I don't particularly like this competition structure from reactors. Two very different bands (style-wise) aside from the fact that they are both trios. But since I'm here, I enjoy The Warnings songwriting more, lyrically, melodically, song structure and vocally. Great musicianship for both bands, but again I find myself drawn to The Warning. I've heard a few songs from VOB, some covers and originals, but they haven't grabbed me enough to want to hear them on a daily basis.
just correction for you brett and lee... if you want to making the comparison for both of bands... you must be fair... one with the official music video and for another one it must be same with the official music video... sorry if i'm saying like that guys... because just for your motivation making contents...
The Warning, of course. You know, if I’m into Ferraris, and I buy one, I’m not going to be constantly looking at other Porsches and BMWs. I feel that The Warning more than adequately addresses my needs for enjoying rock music. I may occasionally wander off to checkout a Nightwish song or something similar, but after rocking out for the last 50+ years, The Warning is all I need to be happy! BTW, I’m pretty sure that in the past 3 years I have listened to more of The Warning than I have of all of my other favorite groups (Genesis, Floyd, Zep, etc.) combined!✌️❤️🔥
The Warning wins. VOB a good rock band. Especially what they have to do to do what they love. The Warning does everything. They did have to overcome some absticles also (mostly stereo typical). Being young girls. The Warning has more of their own sound. Not strictly a set genre sub group..
Because this is voting, it means you are invited to choose between one, talking about VOB is not just a band, they carry a social mission, and change for a better world, of course those of us who are older will be ashamed, because we don't dare to say what they voiced, success for VOB, I choose VOB🤘
@@jonassaldana444 who said VOB doesn't have a better goal? Talking about issue, VOB talking about their soul not only just issue. A great song without social issue are lack of meaning. Music nowdays just talking about SEX are borring.
@@jonassaldana444 thank you for the comment, maybe that's what's in your head, for me social is broad, so it's not just the scope of religion, and nowadays many teenagers don't care about social issues, for me VOB is one of the movers who care about social issues that growing and sweeping the world.
I think both are great and talented. but it must be understood that there is a considerable difference in their career paths, so one cannot simply compare them. the Warning may be luckier because they get full support in all aspects, while VOB really has to struggle hard starting from unsupportive environmental and cultural conditions and so on. I really hope that both of them can achieve their goal of becoming a world-class grub band
Don't compare VOB with The Warning, VOB started studying music since 2014. They are not froma rich family or a musician family, they are from a small village where all of the residents work as farmers, breeders. Even their parents and family forbade them to play music and some religious experts there forbade it. They had no musical equipment, only borrowed from schools and music studios. Luckily, some musicians gave them guitars and basses, only the drummer until now doesn't have a drum set. It seems they lack the funds to make an album
Well, The Warning aren't millionaires either, they are well of girls, but well of by the standards of Mexico (And I say this because I have seen that there is a tendency among many of the fans of VoB to believe that de Warning are American, but they don't). The warning do not come from a family of musicians, their band started independently (the Mexican industry does not support rock bands at all), so the financing came through patreon pages, and although it is true that they had more support from their parents, the advantages that the warning had are not as many as you think, it wasn't easy for them either, Mexico is not a bed of roses for rock bands, maybe it's not as difficult as in Indonesia, but the conditions of the Mexican music industry are not the best for rock.
Music is a matter of personal preference, not something to be competed over to see who wins. They are all great musicians with their own genres, whether it's VOB, Bandmaid, The Warning, Lovebites, or others. But I still choose The Warning because they suit my taste.
Not a fan of vob’s vocals at all, the most critical part of a rock group to me. The Warning wins for me. But as heavy Funk instrumentalists, if that is what I’m looking for, vob are leading the world right now. The modern replacement for the red hot chile peppers, but unfortunately vob’s vocals aren’t enjoyable for me to listen to, so i can never vote them into a win when the other band has outstanding vocals… and the warning has 3 excellent vocalists where two of them are world class
yep vocally the vob is inferior in quality, but what amazed me, this band actually has extraordinary quality compared to other bands, siti(drums) who only had capital like hitting the table in class, he taught himself using only homemade drums and connected it with a string, then widi(bass) learned bass using only a used acoustic guitar from his school, the same goes for marsya(vocal) they are all just farm children who don't have artistic blood in their family, when they find a tool like that they are just happy and feel they had found his soul there. but now they are known and handled by professional people, and I'm sure one day they will become very extraordinary, and it is clear from their development now, the warning and vob are idols that every fan must support so that they get better, don't think of this as a battle, but make it a unity between fans to support each other and respect each other, warm regards 🤝
You must understand that ofcourse vob can't compare with tw because different background where vob basically came from poor farmer family with limited financial support but tw came from wealthy family with good music basic education and from English native language so ofcourse it's normal if seem look better but at least we must appreciate to vob for their struggling until possible to go international, right? Further more from Asia where the west always underestimate, right? But one thing why we must compare while in music we can be enjoying listen together no matter where you are from!
@@bandrio-qv9xn TM? Who is TM? But anyway, "The warning" are Mexican, so that means that their native language is Spanish, and of course they have songs in Spanish (Martirio, narcisista), they also have a song with France choirs (Amour) an other whit japanese ones (queen of the murder scene) and one with binary code (Error). VoB are great but they are the little sisters of The Warning, VoB start after the warning and they just have an EP and a coming LP, but the warning have 3 LP and 2 EPs and VoB are their fans
The Warning are more polished. Their many behind the scenes videos make the fans feel like they really know them personally. Both bands will continue to produce great music for many years. The Warning is my go to band right now.
Well the Warning was number one in Metal Heads magazine 🤷🏽♂️, although it is more of a hard rock band, I am talking seriously guy, to judge both bands you have to know both bands not just make assumptions
VOB band from Garut sundanese west java Indonesia, 3 girls hijab amazing, members: Marsya guitarist and vocalist, Widi bassist, SITI Drummer. Sundanese pride.
Power trio has better song's structure , singing able song and is not necesary thousands of notes to impress me. VOP has fast tempo but fall into is another genre more towards Metal progressive but is very good. My vote is for TW
Love that you are talking about The Warning but I think this format will split your audience. Generally I think its comparing apples to oranges. They are both 3 piece bands consisting of all women....that's it.
That's fine. We don't mind doing something a bit controversial to spice up our channel and generate some interest whether that be positive or negative.
I like VOB..I like TW..their songs are in my playlist. Make a rock band competition event that will be broadcast throughout the world..select some competent judges in rock music. As a music connoisseur I prefer that way
One thing that does not get mentioned enough about The Warning is the quality of the lyric. Especially as it is in their second language. Conceptually and structurally sound and inciteful. I hadn't heard VOB before this but was struck how trite and childish the lyric was. As I said it is the first thing of theirs I have heard , so maybe their other work doesn't sound like a 13year old wrote for a school poem. One a different note ( pun intended) VOB's vocal quality and musicianship is extremely good and well put together.
The Warning las diosas del Rock!! Además hay mucho mucho que puedes reaccionar a ellas ya que son tan buenas que a pesar de su corta edad ya han creado mucha música increíble, en vivo son fenomenales puedes ver todo lo que tienen del concierto en el Teatro metropolitano en la ciudad de Mexico en Agosto del 2022 ❤❤🎉🎉
I'm not really sure how this is a competition. Musically VOB has a pretty cool sound...but even if it's even with The Warning, The Warning wins every other category. In my opinion.
This comment goes to those crying vob fans who keep trying to belittle the warning, they already lost, the warning won, accept the defeat that was resounding and will not change. Curious fact vob is even a fan of the warning, they have already said it and in fact vob follows the warning in instagram, learn some humility from them that following the warning does not make them less, partly for that reason vob has my respect, but the weeping and toxic fans of vob don't deserve respect when according to them wanting to support vob they disrespect other bands like the warnig.
Sejalannya umur yang mendewasakan personil VOB,nantinya mereka akan menunjukan lebih maju lagi,,insyaalloh,semoga VOB sukses selalu dalam berkarir,,aamiin😊
The fans of every other band want their band compared with The Warning😂 It's clear what the standard reference is for everyone... The Warning fans are not interested in band comparisons, for them, no band is comparable to The Warning.😂
Likewise for us vob fans, there is no band that compares to them, every fan has their own role to support their idol, for us this competition is just entertainment, not a battle between bands and fans
We are also not interested in comparing with other bands, this is just a vote because the real vote is definitely our choosing to be more serious about voting for other big Chanels
The great strength of The Warning lies in the fact that THE WARNING's great compositional capacity is incredible, excellent lyrics and intelligent messages, TW the new geniuses of Rock, there is no one who performs live and composes the volume of quality songs like THE WARNING, nobody and VOB have 2 problems 1- they lack a singer 2- more volume of original songs, a big difference with TW, this is rock
Hi guys! I’m not into the Japanese or Asian rock bands, I know they’re very talented but to me The Warning are a better band more versatile and creative! Just can get enough of them!
Well, technically VoB are not that "famous", I mean, at this point of their career they have a similar kind of fame that The Warning had like more than three years ago, The warning three years ago was 7 Year together as a band, and also they was an independent band sponsored by fans through patreon page. The girls from Warning do have more money than vob but they are not millionaires
@@ontoseno9653 What does that have to do with anything? The base fandom of the warning began to follow them when they were primary school girls, they didn't look as today, when they became adults they became pretty, but they already had a fandom since before, their today prettiness was just incidental
![Digital Circus Episode 4 [TRAILER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/abZtsmMUbJo/mqdefault.jpg)
The winner is ME
I declare ME the winner, for having the good fortune of discovering The Warning and Voice Of Braceprot .
I would love to see a comparison of the two bands live. This is where you find out what their vocal abilities truly are. It's shocking how the Warning gets BETTER live, vocally, and VOB is vastly superior in the studio (vocally, not instrumentally). I hope VOB continues to work on their live vocals... I want to support them, and I do support them, but not in competitions with other groups like The Warning, Nemophila etc, who have spent so much time honing their live vocals with professional guidance and, mostly, lots and lots and lots of very hard work. That being said, VOB's instrumentals, live, well at least in the bass and drums, are INSANE. Guitar is good live, but their rhythm section is nuts for heavy funk rock. Just like The Warning's rhythm section is outstanding for rock... two of the greatest bands out there.
Yeah the warning Video viewer for their single and live only 2,9 mil , but VOB 4,4 mil.
VOB are a live band, what you heard are what you see on stages, and their song had meaning and soul for METAL HEAD.
Views don't mean anything if you talk about talent, in any case VOB would lose since TW has 100M in total between all the videos and VOB 23M. Both banda are amazing.
Hambatan utama VOB adalah di Bahasa Inggris, secara teknis punya kelebihan masing-masing
𝐘𝐚 𝐬𝐚𝐲𝐚 𝐦𝐞𝐧𝐠𝐚𝐤𝐮𝐢 𝐝𝐚𝐥𝐚𝐦 𝐡𝐚𝐥 𝐕𝐨𝐤𝐚𝐥 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐖𝐚𝐫𝐧𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐥𝐞𝐛𝐢𝐡 𝐮𝐧𝐠𝐠𝐮𝐥 𝐚𝐩𝐚𝐥𝐚𝐠𝐢 𝐝𝐢 𝐭𝐮𝐧𝐣𝐚𝐧𝐠 𝐛𝐚𝐡𝐚𝐬𝐚 𝐈𝐧𝐠𝐠𝐫𝐢𝐬 𝐲𝐚𝐧𝐠 𝐥𝐞𝐛𝐢𝐡 𝐛𝐚𝐢𝐤. 𝐓𝐚𝐩𝐢 𝐮𝐧𝐭𝐮𝐤 𝐦𝐮𝐬𝐢𝐤 𝐬𝐚𝐲𝐚 𝐥𝐞𝐛𝐢𝐡 𝐬𝐮𝐤𝐚 𝐕𝐎𝐁. 𝐊𝐞𝐝𝐮𝐚𝐧𝐲𝐚 𝐬𝐚𝐦𝐚-𝐬𝐚𝐦𝐚 𝐛𝐚𝐠𝐮𝐬. 𝐒𝐮𝐤𝐬𝐞𝐬 𝐮𝐧𝐭𝐮𝐤 𝐦𝐞𝐫𝐞𝐤𝐚.
@@sutediheriyonoBaladMaUngkelemahan orang indonesia tidak mau menerima kritikan, gua orang indo tapi mengakui vob mempunyai vocal yang kurang
They're both rock bands, but the similarity ends there. I'm really digging The Warning's style in their entirety. Since I hear some good musicianship and song structure, I will probably listen to some more VOB just to see if something they do floats my boat.
I won't just choose one of them..I support them the warning//VoB because they deserve to stand on the world stage
VoB adalah band yg terlahir dari segala keterbatasan... Wajar jika mereka kalah di banding The Warning... Tapi saya percaya dan Yakin bahwa talenta VoB masih bisa jauh lebih berkembang dan lebih Top lagi...
VOB mungkin kalah terkenal.... tetapi pengakuan " metal band the world needs right now " lebih berharga dibandingkan sekedar terkenal
Absolut awesome.. Bravo VOB
Yeess vob
Vob juara nya bro🤘
Saya berusaha untuk obyektif, mohon maaf jika salah.
Menurut saya the warning pun tidak kalah bagus. Sudah kelas dunia kwalitasnya. Namun tidak dipungkiri karena didasari dan dibekali fasilitas yang mencukupi untuk pencapaian sampai saat sekarang. Hanya satu yang menurut saya kurang, musiknya lebih terkesan/cenderung komersil.
Menurut pendapat saya Skill dan idealis musik VOB lebih bagus. Dipoles dikit 95% sudah sempurna. VOB hanya kalah bahasa, teknologi audio & visual. dan tentunya marketing penting dalam pengenalan kualitas.
Tinggal cari sponsor dan marketing handal sudah high end performa.
I have been a The Warning fan for many years and a VOB fan for the last year or so. I feel playing bands of against each other can be devisive and turn fan bases against listening to other bands music, even if it is just done for fun. The competition is hard enough for young female artists as it is, especially in rock as a whole. ❤✌🤘 U.K.
Fair enough. You're entitled to your opinion. We like both bands and we're hoping that by combining them together in one video, we may help to promote each band. So The Warning fans may get acquainted with VOB and vice versa. No harm intended.
They both are great bands!! The Warning is just more versatile. They can sing a ballad type song and make you tear up or flip the switch and i bang my head. The Warning has my vote! 👊🏼
Both already on my playlist..
I think..THE WARNING and VOB have the same music talent. The only difference is in the flow of the music. VOB is more prominent metal punk rock, while THE WARNING to rock. Then from playing the instrument, VOB is more prominent. But in that case, back to each individual, because not everyone likes the music or the lyrics. We hope that these two bands can go global and be accepted by many people. We are waiting for VOB to tour America in Agustus 2023 about 12 cities in America.🤘🤘🤘🤘
Tour America as well as promo for the new album "RETAS".
Yes🤘
Vob and The warning. The best Trio Female band on The World
The Warning, hands down. I like VoB a lot but their problem for me is the depth of their discography. The Enemy of Earth is You is actually an old song that they've gone into the studio and produced a slick updated version of it. They did a similar thing with their previous release PMS from last November. While these new versions are good and well produced, I kind of like the raw live session recording of PMS from 2019. I've seen live footage of The Enemy of Earth is You from 2017 and it's quite good as it was back then. I believe a lot of their difficulties lies in financing since I think they're still an independent band which leads to a lot of touring to support themselves. I wish them the best and hope for a new album of originals someday.
Edit: Same goes for their most recent release What's The Holy (Nobel) Today?, another old song that got a refresh and professional recording. In all 3 of these songs (What's The Holy (Nobel) Today?, The Enemy of Earth is You, and PMS) they reworked the lyrics to be mostly in English. As far as I know, only the lead singer can converse in English so that makes backing vocals a bit tricky.
VOP does not has stage presence like TW. For me TW is more versatile and is not metal band. They get my feelings out, VOP sounds like another metal band mold
VoB - The Enemy of Earth Is You (GOOD FOR Soundtrack film : Impossible, 007, Tranformers, or what?)
@@jonassaldana444vob cok😂
I try to be objective, sorry if I'm wrong. In my opinion, the warning is no less good. The quality is world class. However, it cannot be denied that it is based on and provided with sufficient facilities for achievements up to now. There's only one thing that I think is lacking, the music seems more commercial.
In my opinion, VOB's musical skills and ideals are better. Polished a little 95% and it's perfect. VOB is only inferior to language, audio & visual technology. and of course marketing is important in introducing quality. Just look for sponsors and reliable marketing, I'm sure it will be a high performer.
🇴🇯🇴 🇩🇮🇧🇦🇳🇩🇮🇳🇬🇰🇪
Music is the language of unity, don't clash. Ünethical❕
VOB are great musicians and have great stage presence for a relatively young band starting to get attention; however The Warning wins hands down when it comes to vocals and songwriting and are arguably just as talented musicians, though their instrumental style is less “showy” than VOB. I wish both bands continued success.
Menulis lagu apa yg anda maksud, lirik Marsya berat bro 😂
For me Marsya VOB's guitar skills are extraordinary, Widi's bass is also okay, Siti's drums are also great,... the VOB song with the best vocals in my opinion is PMS,... it sounds very typical for Indonesian female vocals,... for other songs vocals are pretty good (not bad) because mostly rapping.
The Warning is of course good,.. only the genre doesn't sound ROCK enough so it doesn't really hit me (because basically I like metal)
Success for them (VOB & TW),.. I hope one day the two groups can have one stage, one event... that must be fun🤘🏼🔥
Not particularly a rock/metal fan but I enjoyed Warning. The lead could really sing. I didn't care at all for VOB. Not me cup of tea. Warning hands down winner! ❤
Thanks for your vote Stu!
For me, it's a bit of a shame that The Warning and VoB get thrown up against each other - while they're both very good and superficially similar, they're making very different kinds of music (to my ear). For me, it's an apples and oranges comparison. It makes a little more sense when both are covering a standard (e.g. Enter Sandman), but even then, the covers sound completely different to me.
But there is a definite plus side to the Warning/VoB rivalry on YT - it drives a viewership and exposes people around the world to talent they might not otherwise hear.
Yes, totally different genre of rock music. No comparison here except "female trio"
True
Both great bands, but The Warning gets my vote, more than 50 originals songs, incredible live performance, i love them!!!!
I would listen TW on the radio, I will always enjoy seeing VOB on video. Simplicity, no show off, authenticity, strong message.
Agree..!
❤❤❤
Thats right.. Awesome
👍👍👍👍
But the warning also have strong massages, depends on the song but also have strong messages, XXI century blood, Error, disciple, kool aid kids, Cooper bullets, etc, And the warning is much more a stage band than a radio songs band, although, they are more histrionics than VoB, and that can be excessive for some
To me, "Disciple" or "Evolve" would have been a better comparison song to VOB's song, as those are harder rock than "Choke". But for me The Warning still takes the win.
The Warning are the most talented artist of this generation.
The Warning gets my vote. Maybe VOB has a slight edge when it comes to instrumentals. IDK. It's hard to say because The Warning perform whatever suits the song with no intention of showing off or designing solos into the performance. I dare say each band is well aware of the other and are as likely as not fans. I know for a fact that TW are fans of Band-maid, another all-female international band. TW just returned from their first tour in Europe and (I hope) are going to spend some time laying down new tracks before going back on tour in August. They have been designing their songs around playing them live. They are truly a band that comes off better live because of the amount of energy they put into their shows.
The Warning. As sisters, they have the advantage of harmonies with similar voices, plus all three can sing lead.
Hi Timberwolf
I just saw this video after a year it has been uploaded.
What can I add to what's been said already? Well, just look at where are each band one year later. That should be enough:
In the last months two singles by The Warning have breaking into the Billboard Rock Top 40 Chart (More & S!ck). S!ck actually peaked at #8!
Their new album Keep Me Fed debuted as the Top selling rock/metal album in the UK. Debuted at Number 6 in the USA.
They have sold out every venue where they've played. They sold out two shows at Auditorio Nacional in Mexico City (a 10,000 seats venue), the first one went sold out in just 1 hour! and it's going to take place until february 2025!
Many VOB fans mentioned in the comments the fact that they've played at Wacken Open Air Festival, well, guess what? Within a few weeks The Warning will play there as well, and right after that, at Pol and Rock festival. Then a extense tour by USA/Canada with Halestorm and Evanescence.
The Warning is now considered #1 emerging artist by Billboard.
They are at #27 at Billboard Hot Artist 100.
Should I continue?
Don't get me wrong, I wish only success to the girls of VOB, they deserves all the best things in the world, but the hard facts are undeniable. The Warning is destined to super stardom.
I don't particularly like this competition structure from reactors. Two very different bands (style-wise) aside from the fact that they are both trios. But since I'm here, I enjoy The Warnings songwriting more, lyrically, melodically, song structure and vocally. Great musicianship for both bands, but again I find myself drawn to The Warning. I've heard a few songs from VOB, some covers and originals, but they haven't grabbed me enough to want to hear them on a daily basis.
just correction for you brett and lee... if you want to making the comparison for both of bands... you must be fair... one with the official music video and for another one it must be same with the official music video... sorry if i'm saying like that guys... because just for your motivation making contents...
I prefer The Warning’s songs. I recognize VoB’s talent and wish them every success.
The Warning easily
The Warning
No competition ... This IS music
And for those Who don't agree... Sit on It
What's your opinion on singing competitions such as Eurovision, The Voice, American Idol, X-Factor etc?
@@BackstreetGentsterrible tv program
@@BackstreetGents compare when they sing the same song. live vs live. studio vs studio
#vote The Warning!
Absolutely The Warning, can't get enough of them!
The Warning, of course. You know, if I’m into Ferraris, and I buy one, I’m not going to be constantly looking at other Porsches and BMWs. I feel that The Warning more than adequately addresses my needs for enjoying rock music. I may occasionally wander off to checkout a Nightwish song or something similar, but after rocking out for the last 50+ years, The Warning is all I need to be happy! BTW, I’m pretty sure that in the past 3 years I have listened to more of The Warning than I have of all of my other favorite groups (Genesis, Floyd, Zep, etc.) combined!✌️❤️🔥
Same!
Comparison is unhealthy. Each bands has their own style..message .. genres.. and fans as well. Everyone is entitle to his opinion. I VOTE VOB🤘
#vote the warning
The Warning wins. VOB a good rock band. Especially what they have to do to do what they love. The Warning does everything.
They did have to overcome some absticles also (mostly stereo typical). Being young girls.
The Warning has more of their own sound. Not strictly a set genre sub group..
The warning rules 😎🤙
VOB ... RAP N SLAP ...COMPLICATED 🤘
The Warning is Tier 1, world class rock, by far.
Because this is voting, it means you are invited to choose between one, talking about VOB is not just a band, they carry a social mission, and change for a better world, of course those of us who are older will be ashamed, because we don't dare to say what they voiced, success for VOB, I choose VOB🤘
I agreed wit you about "social mission" of VOP cause theIr religion. But TW has better goals "Enjoy and get fun"
@@jonassaldana444menurut saya tak ada hubungannya dengan "agama"tapi kemanusiaan ,tidak ada hubunganya dengan agama.
@@jonassaldana444 who said VOB doesn't have a better goal?
Talking about issue, VOB talking about their soul not only just issue.
A great song without social issue are lack of meaning.
Music nowdays just talking about SEX are borring.
@@jonassaldana444 thank you for the comment, maybe that's what's in your head, for me social is broad, so it's not just the scope of religion, and nowadays many teenagers don't care about social issues, for me VOB is one of the movers who care about social issues that growing and sweeping the world.
@@WildanFifa betul teman thanks komentarnya dukung selalu VOB
# THE WARNING,
I think both are great and talented. but it must be understood that there is a considerable difference in their career paths, so one cannot simply compare them. the Warning may be luckier because they get full support in all aspects, while VOB really has to struggle hard starting from unsupportive environmental and cultural conditions and so on. I really hope that both of them can achieve their goal of becoming a world-class grub band
en mexico tampoco es que hayan recibido mucho apoyo xd
i demand you guys on this channel to compare them in LIVE version !!!
the quality of musical talent they had will seen genuinly 🤘
For me The Warning. I did like VOB instrumentals, but I couldn't get pass the singer's voice. It sounded like a 14 year old was singing.
Don't compare VOB with The Warning, VOB
started studying music since 2014. They are
not froma rich family or a musician family,
they are from a small village where all of the
residents work as farmers, breeders. Even
their parents and family forbade them to play
music and some religious experts there
forbade it. They had no musical equipment,
only borrowed from schools and music
studios. Luckily, some musicians gave them
guitars and basses, only the drummer until
now doesn't have a drum set. It seems they
lack the funds to make an album
True! Totally opposite lives
Well, The Warning aren't millionaires either, they are well of girls, but well of by the standards of Mexico (And I say this because I have seen that there is a tendency among many of the fans of VoB to believe that de Warning are American, but they don't). The warning do not come from a family of musicians, their band started independently (the Mexican industry does not support rock bands at all), so the financing came through patreon pages, and although it is true that they had more support from their parents, the advantages that the warning had are not as many as you think, it wasn't easy for them either, Mexico is not a bed of roses for rock bands, maybe it's not as difficult as in Indonesia, but the conditions of the Mexican music industry are not the best for rock.
Message from VOB very strong with amazing music skill
VOB...👍❤️🇮🇩
I'm an Indonesian and I respect VoB. But I relate more to the Warning's music, so I'm voting for the Warning!
I'm an mexico and i respect the warning, but i relaye more to VOB, so i'm vote VOB and i love indonesia
@@raishakomputercell6477 haha .. and I love Mexican food very much ❤️
@@rufuspanjaitan5759 shes indonesian dude vob of course my vote .👍
Hi,,,? What's going on in this place insane words
Nice bro...we are Baladceprot Indonesian fans VOB🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻
@Najaemin-bs1vt so who cares if you're Indonesian? No one. VOB sucks.
# The Warning gets my vote ! Thanks guys
The Warning is the winner!!
# THE WARNING
VOB the Bassist is monster 🔥🔥🤟🤟 the Slaping the bass awesome.. Energic, Powerfull...
Vob real rabbel, with real blood and tears in their journy, their lyric has real story behind the song. Their come from poor farmer family.
Yes
That's Right
Bravo VOB 🤘🤘🤘
Music is a matter of personal preference, not something to be competed over to see who wins. They are all great musicians with their own genres, whether it's VOB, Bandmaid, The Warning, Lovebites, or others. But I still choose The Warning because they suit my taste.
# The Warning.
The Warning!!!!!
🔥🎶Widi🧕🎸🎶 🔥IS the Queen👑of bass!
Widi gets my vote and so does VoB! 🙃
VoB Mantap Forever!!!🔥🧕🎸🔥🧕🎸🔥🧕🥁🔥
Not a fan of vob’s vocals at all, the most critical part of a rock group to me. The Warning wins for me. But as heavy Funk instrumentalists, if that is what I’m looking for, vob are leading the world right now. The modern replacement for the red hot chile peppers, but unfortunately vob’s vocals aren’t enjoyable for me to listen to, so i can never vote them into a win when the other band has outstanding vocals… and the warning has 3 excellent vocalists where two of them are world class
yep vocally the vob is inferior in quality, but what amazed me, this band actually has extraordinary quality compared to other bands, siti(drums) who only had capital like hitting the table in class, he taught himself using only homemade drums and connected it with a string, then widi(bass) learned bass using only a used acoustic guitar from his school, the same goes for marsya(vocal) they are all just farm children who don't have artistic blood in their family, when they find a tool like that they are just happy and feel they had found his soul there. but now they are known and handled by professional people, and I'm sure one day they will become very extraordinary, and it is clear from their development now, the warning and vob are idols that every fan must support so that they get better, don't think of this as a battle, but make it a unity between fans to support each other and respect each other, warm regards 🤝
Funny it's the opposite for me, i can't listen to The Warning anymore, musically too boring for me
You must understand that ofcourse vob can't compare with tw because different background where vob basically came from poor farmer family with limited financial support but tw came from wealthy family with good music basic education and from English native language so ofcourse it's normal if seem look better but at least we must appreciate to vob for their struggling until possible to go international, right? Further more from Asia where the west always underestimate, right? But one thing why we must compare while in music we can be enjoying listen together no matter where you are from!
@@rudiheadbangarmy5583😂😂😂 nape ni orang indo😂
@@MrAdjiakui saja bro vocal vob sangat kureng
Warning
i concur... live would clearly show the warning as the superior band... they are both good, but live, the warning has no equal
I like VOB, ... hip metal Funky ...VOB is the best
but very weak vocals
VOB speaking in two lenguage, Indonesia and English, what about TM....???
@@bandrio-qv9xn TM? Who is TM?
But anyway, "The warning" are Mexican, so that means that their native language is Spanish, and of course they have songs in Spanish (Martirio, narcisista), they also have a song with France choirs (Amour) an other whit japanese ones (queen of the murder scene) and one with binary code (Error).
VoB are great but they are the little sisters of The Warning, VoB start after the warning and they just have an EP and a coming LP, but the warning have 3 LP and 2 EPs and VoB are their fans
the warning sounds like a pop song, not metal
Both great bands , just a matter of , do you prefer a great red wine or a great white wine !
The Warning are more polished. Their many behind the scenes videos make the fans feel like they really know them personally. Both bands will continue to produce great music for many years. The Warning is my go to band right now.
⚡THE WARNING⚡
the warning sounds like a pop song, not metal
VoB top 10 song for METAL HAMMER magazine 🔥🔥🔥
TW is not metal band
@@jonassaldana444 that's right... And VoB all genre for Rock metal funky.
@@jonassaldana444ywd mas jangan membanding2kan makanya,,🤷♂️🤦♂️😌
@@m0dy829😂😂😂
Well the Warning was number one in Metal Heads magazine 🤷🏽♂️, although it is more of a hard rock band, I am talking seriously guy, to judge both bands you have to know both bands not just make assumptions
Sorry I vote VOB.....really metal...!!
Firstable TW is not a metal band, TW is more versatile group that connect with people's feelings and is more valuable for me
😍😍😍 VOB full METAL FUNKY I LIKE IT ❤❤❤
VOB band from Garut sundanese west java Indonesia, 3 girls hijab amazing, members: Marsya guitarist and vocalist, Widi bassist, SITI Drummer. Sundanese pride.
Live version of , " Enemy of Earth Is You" has a heavy sound. The video did a remix but it sounds great too.
VoB Mantap Forever!!!🔥🧕🎸🔥🧕🎸🔥🧕🥁🔥
Power trio has better song's structure , singing able song and is not necesary thousands of notes to impress me. VOP has fast tempo but fall into is another genre more towards Metal progressive but is very good. My vote is for TW
👍
Vob dengan segala keterbatasannya tapi bisa bersaing dengan band pendahulunya.bravo vob
Music is not a sport, it's subjective, and as such competitions are meanless and only foster hostility between fans.
they are all good, it all goes down to personal preference , I vote for The Warning
Love that you are talking about The Warning but I think this format will split your audience. Generally I think its comparing apples to oranges. They are both 3 piece bands consisting of all women....that's it.
That's fine. We don't mind doing something a bit controversial to spice up our channel and generate some interest whether that be positive or negative.
I like VOB..I like TW..their songs are in my playlist.
Make a rock band competition event that will be broadcast throughout the world..select some competent judges in rock music. As a music connoisseur I prefer that way
One thing that does not get mentioned enough about The Warning is the quality of the lyric. Especially as it is in their second language. Conceptually and structurally sound and inciteful. I hadn't heard VOB before this but was struck how trite and childish the lyric was. As I said it is the first thing of theirs I have heard , so maybe their other work doesn't sound like a 13year old wrote for a school poem. One a different note ( pun intended) VOB's vocal quality and musicianship is extremely good and well put together.
All awesome, move on...
Voice of baceprot...🤘
VOB is the best...
The Warning is IMHO, the best band in the world right now.
The Warning las diosas del Rock!! Además hay mucho mucho que puedes reaccionar a ellas ya que son tan buenas que a pesar de su corta edad ya han creado mucha música increíble, en vivo son fenomenales puedes ver todo lo que tienen del concierto en el Teatro metropolitano en la ciudad de Mexico en Agosto del 2022 ❤❤🎉🎉
You must use #VoteTheWarning
I'm not really sure how this is a competition. Musically VOB has a pretty cool sound...but even if it's even with The Warning, The Warning wins every other category. In my opinion.
The Warning! No doubt! ❤️👍🎵🎼🔥⚡️💥👸👸👸
Guys, as inquired-- below is linked to the recent VoB performance overseas singing the song
ruclips.net/video/Ukj4L8CcHsQ/видео.html
#VOTE The warning
The Warning is awesome.
This comment goes to those crying vob fans who keep trying to belittle the warning, they already lost, the warning won, accept the defeat that was resounding and will not change. Curious fact vob is even a fan of the warning, they have already said it and in fact vob follows the warning in instagram, learn some humility from them that following the warning does not make them less, partly for that reason vob has my respect, but the weeping and toxic fans of vob don't deserve respect when according to them wanting to support vob they disrespect other bands like the warnig.
VOB ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Sejalannya umur yang mendewasakan personil VOB,nantinya mereka akan menunjukan lebih maju lagi,,insyaalloh,semoga VOB sukses selalu dalam berkarir,,aamiin😊
Don't bring into conflict between The Warning and VOB.
Try to listen "what's the holy (nobel) today by VOB.
- The warning 👍
- VoB ❤️
🤘🤘🤘
The fans of every other band want their band compared with The Warning😂 It's clear what the standard reference is for everyone...
The Warning fans are not interested in band comparisons, for them, no band is comparable to The Warning.😂
Likewise for us vob fans, there is no band that compares to them, every fan has their own role to support their idol, for us this competition is just entertainment, not a battle between bands and fans
My god, TW fans are terrible
We are also not interested in comparing with other bands, this is just a vote because the real vote is definitely our choosing to be more serious about voting for other big Chanels
Like in metal hammer or the best music duo group award in our country and of course we will vote for VOB yes and of course VOB won it
The great strength of The Warning lies in the fact that THE WARNING's great compositional capacity is incredible, excellent lyrics and intelligent messages, TW the new geniuses of Rock, there is no one who performs live and composes the volume of quality songs like THE WARNING, nobody and VOB have 2 problems 1- they lack a singer 2- more volume of original songs, a big difference with TW, this is rock
Voice of Baceprot ❤🎉
The Warning.. I prefer a live performnce and The Warning are great at it!❤❤❤
Hi guys! I’m not into the Japanese or Asian rock bands, I know they’re very talented but to me The Warning are a better band more versatile and creative! Just can get enough of them!
Remember that vob starting practice music in 2014 by limited facilities, they only need 7 years to famous. I respect to TW and I vote to VOB
Idem❤❤❤
Well, technically VoB are not that "famous", I mean, at this point of their career they have a similar kind of fame that The Warning had like more than three years ago, The warning three years ago was 7 Year together as a band, and also they was an independent band sponsored by fans through patreon page.
The girls from Warning do have more money than vob but they are not millionaires
@@Guwig the girls from tw are more beautiful than the girls from vob. you should be proud
@@ontoseno9653 What does that have to do with anything?
The base fandom of the warning began to follow them when they were primary school girls, they didn't look as today, when they became adults they became pretty, but they already had a fandom since before, their today prettiness was just incidental
VOB and THE WARNING my favorit band 🤘🔥🔥🎸❤❤
Vote vob biar mereka beli tshirt nya 😂
Ok
Vob...karena music vob lebih hebat...bakat bermusik yg luar biasa...vob
*The Warning!* Absolutely!