What a curse to be related to him, be close to him, or even to come to his attention. Poor Svetlana, her mother, and brothers. All the people whose lives he wrecked or ended. That number would be in the millions or tens of millions I guess. Too much to comprehend. There's little joy to be found in this story, but at least people were kind to her during her life.
She could not overcome her origin. Her unhappy childhood. Her mother’s suicide. Khrushchev’s son and granddaughter did because Khrushchev attempted to open the USSR’s eyes to Stalin’s brutality even though he was later put to pasture. For that we can thank Nikita. His descendants survived because of that. 😊
@@donjoaoresort8565 Well thank you for that suggestion. I appreciate it. What resources or authority have you found most useful in your studies of Uncle Joe?
unfortunately none of us can choose our parents. we can only hope become better than them. worse would be related to a hitler, but these two are so alike
This complex and gripping story makes me wonder, why is it that the world's tv stories are now full of goo garr junk tv,when they have the ability to compose intelligent stories like this one.Well done documentary team.
I feel so for her. Her father wasn't her fault. I find it fascinating how one person can cause so much grief. It's a testament to human hypnotism. Thank you.
Stalin wasn't Russian, his entourage wasn't Russian; Krushtchev was Ukrainian - he's the one who gifted Crimean to Ukraine; Breznev was from somewhere else. There were jews and peoples from surrounding republics throughout the Soviet era in charge of Russia. Even today's hugest propagandist Simonian is from some republic - not Russian. How did this happen? If only kerensky had acted sooner... maybe...
I can’t imagine living in the USSR during that time. Stalin was awful to his sons but adored his daughter which was surprising. He even had family members arrested
Right, Stalin suffered from extreme paranoia, that's why he had so many killed or arrested. I'm not a doctor but I would say his daughter has the same mental illness. Mental illness is usually passed on and if Stalin wasn't mentally ill than really who is?
What you missed was that a """"""""""PRINCESS" says it all..reference the hyena where a princess was raised at the expense of all siblings..you have only SVETLANAs side not her mother, family.446
A tragic life led by a warm, sensitive and emotional human being, who had to live in the shadow of her terrible father till she died. Both the American and Soviet govt., used her for their own propaganda and would not leave her alone. Her heart was torn apart by her love for her motherland and her aversion for the soviet system of essentially creating a prison for all their citizens. May she rest in peace. I am from India.
There’s a very detailed book, ‘The court of the red tsar’ by Simon Sebag Montefiore, particularly on the period following the death of Nadeszhda. The writer studied the archives during the ‘90s and talked to numerous survivors. A must read if you’re interested in the subject. The archives have been closed by Putin.
Stalin is the worst father In the world he could have saved his son but instead he threw his son to the wolves a REAL father would have done whatever it took to save his child/children
Although Fidel Castro inspired terror in Cuba pretending to follow Stalin and fighting Trostkitism he was more like Hitler in many ways except anti semitism. And just like Hitler in Germany he destroyed Cuba.
Not “untold.” I believe I read her first book about life growing up as his daughter and the effects it had on her. And there were other books she wrote.
@@MandalayMoore33 Stalin was born and raised in a poor family of the Georgian Orthodox faith, and his initial ambition was to become a priest in that faith.
Does any woman in history live her own life..was a woman in clay a vessel filled with some male s desires for better or worse..what pretense did you advocate..Cupid had more bearing on a woman girl on the loose than your misleading statement meant to build simone de beauvoir.444
To be "socialist" since musa was raised by pharaoh his father sun tzumar means """""TO KILL acia..THE CIA..ALL SOCIAL PLATFORMS ARE SET DARKNESS TO SEARCH SEEK AND execute the cia. So nickname for sun tzu..susu simsim..open sesame ali baba.
The only Americans that admire Stalin is college students. Everybody either does not like Stalin or is just trying to learn about why people from the Soviet Union love him so much.
Svetlana had lots of unresolved mental issues! This was the reason she can't be happy with any man or any place in the world. She tried Russia twice US twice, many men! May be if given asylum could have lived in India and could have been happy! I doubt it!
I don’t choose a video to read. I would choose a book to read, and I don’t speak any language but English, so unfortunately, these videos are a thumbs down for me.
What a curse to be related to him, be close to him, or even to come to his attention. Poor Svetlana, her mother, and brothers. All the people whose lives he wrecked or ended. That number would be in the millions or tens of millions I guess. Too much to comprehend. There's little joy to be found in this story, but at least people were kind to her during her life.
Wiseman - I suggest you to study Stalin over a couple of years.
She could not overcome her origin. Her unhappy childhood. Her mother’s suicide. Khrushchev’s son and granddaughter did because Khrushchev attempted to open the USSR’s eyes to Stalin’s brutality even though he was later put to pasture. For that we can thank Nikita. His descendants survived because of that. 😊
@@donjoaoresort8565 Well thank you for that suggestion. I appreciate it. What resources or authority have you found most useful in your studies of Uncle Joe?
@@GeorgeTennesseeWisemanAuthor Stephen Kotkin bio, 2 volumes of planned trilogy.
unfortunately none of us can choose our parents. we can only hope become better than them. worse would be related to a hitler, but these two are so alike
This complex and gripping story makes me wonder, why is it that the world's tv stories are now full of goo garr junk tv,when they have the ability to compose intelligent stories like this one.Well done documentary team.
I knew Stalin was a monster. This documentary just added to the list of cruel he was. Spared no one, not even his family.
surely, this was the most depraved, deranged, criminally insane gang that's ever gathered together.
I feel so for her. Her father wasn't her fault. I find it fascinating how one person can cause so much grief. It's a testament to human hypnotism. Thank you.
When Stalin kicked the bucket a restaurant in Washington DC gave out free Boscht to celebrate the death of Stalin
США всегда так относятся к своим союзникам 😂
My father was Jewish and a paratrooper in WW2. He was a political man and he thought Stalin was worse than Hitler.
That’s saying something
He was worse than Hitler.But there are still Russians who think he had to be the hard man,the European centric world will never understand Russia.
Indeed
That poor woman….. this was an incredible documentary ❤ Thank you ❤
And she must suspect her angry drunken father of shooting her mother in the temple. A suicide seems very unlikely. The man was a beast.
The way Stalin treated ukrainians and others nationalities i don't blame them for switching sides
Stalin wasn't Russian, his entourage wasn't Russian; Krushtchev was Ukrainian - he's the one who gifted Crimean to Ukraine; Breznev was from somewhere else. There were jews and peoples from surrounding republics throughout the Soviet era in charge of Russia. Even today's hugest propagandist Simonian is from some republic - not Russian. How did this happen? If only kerensky had acted sooner... maybe...
He treated Russian like a mule
Am convinced to watch and understand about Stalin's daughter
I can’t imagine living in the USSR during that time. Stalin was awful to his sons but adored his daughter which was surprising. He even had family members arrested
Right, Stalin suffered from extreme paranoia, that's why he had so many killed or arrested. I'm not a doctor but I would say his daughter has the same mental illness. Mental illness is usually passed on and if Stalin wasn't mentally ill than really who is?
It was better than modern day Russia
Fathers only adoring their daughters is creepy.
Stalin, Hitler and Mao had in common, that their father's beat them so bad they were hospitalized! (The childhood, makes the man!)
What you missed was that a """"""""""PRINCESS" says it all..reference the hyena where a princess was raised at the expense of all siblings..you have only SVETLANAs side not her mother, family.446
On the little part on Stalin’s rise to power you conveniently missed out the part about his life where he actually was a thief robber & gangster .
Koba!
Except for this fact wasn't well known. In fact he kept this locked up tight
@@tinahale9252it is well known now. Should have been included.
@@tinahale9252 I knew this as far back as 1971. It's no secret.
Being a thief pales in comparison to being a murderer, so I would say that information is of little consequence
Thank you for sharing this story with us. Now I know what happened to her. She was my mother's age. RIP dear lady.❤
If I only could have met her. She died in Wisconsin only a few hours away from where I was living at the time.
A tragic life led by a warm, sensitive and emotional human being, who had to live in the shadow of her terrible father till she died. Both the American and Soviet govt., used her for their own propaganda and would not leave her alone. Her heart was torn apart by her love for her motherland and her aversion for the soviet system of essentially creating a prison for all their citizens. May she rest in peace. I am from India.
No you're not
Don't think ld get that carried away, damaged person who damaged her own children.
There’s a very detailed book, ‘The court of the red tsar’ by Simon Sebag Montefiore, particularly on the period following the death of Nadeszhda. The writer studied the archives during the ‘90s and talked to numerous survivors. A must read if you’re interested in the subject.
The archives have been closed by Putin.
He thinks there's Western spies and propagandists creeping around Moscow...How crazy is that??
Well put together. Sad tho. Thx 4 posting.
Stalin is the worst father In the world he could have saved his son but instead he threw his son to the wolves a REAL father would have done whatever it took to save his child/children
The kid was a private. You heard his reasoning. It was sound. Kid was a slacker 😂😂😂
Thank you so much for this documentary, it was very interesting.
Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
What an incredible arc of life.
Although Fidel Castro inspired terror in Cuba pretending to follow Stalin and fighting Trostkitism he was more like Hitler in many ways except anti semitism. And just like Hitler in Germany he destroyed Cuba.
Not “untold.” I believe I read her first book about life growing up as his daughter and the effects it had on her. And there were other books she wrote.
Ehh. Untold? She wrote a book about it?
Read her book Letters to a friend and was fascinated by her life!😊
Yes!
Very sad to watched Svetlanas life.She grow under pressure her Dictators father to understand what happened to her Mother.😢
At least she had the opportunity to grow up and live a life.
Untold, except I first saw her interviewed in documentary about 30 years ago FFS.
Heartbreaking.😥
She was lucky to survive those days of mass murder...yet when you hear of what an affectionate father Stalin was, it makes one sad...
Please provide audible translation so we could listen as a podcast.
She said he died the most ter death ,he was struggling. She was a nurse,and she changed her life
Thank you for this. I found this so interesting!
What a story.
Sad, so sad
Wow. I never knew this. I was born in 68. How sad.
Svetlana inherited her mother's personality?
Very cool.
Exquisite 💯❤️
Informative
Nice introduction
A wonderful documentary many thanks.
Stalin was a Georgian
_And_ Jewish.
That ain't the photo of a person who shoot herself on her head ,or who was shoot in her head at all.
@@MandalayMoore33 he was not.
@@davidakopian9490 Yes, he was. Do your research properly.
@@MandalayMoore33 Stalin was born and raised in a poor family of the Georgian Orthodox faith, and his initial ambition was to become a priest in that faith.
so sad, this life--typical of so many human beings.
P.S. Stalin was a Sakasvilli. He was from GEORGIA!!! HELLO
Other world is not always rosy
But he push the Nazi out?
Yes I agree with this informations Completely This is The most Dangerous to TRAST Anyone in Communist Lifetime
Yes it was very very Painful Time
Stalin and Putin started as criminals and ended or will end as criminals.
what a beautiful music in a background 🙂
HOW SAD
When she was chucking a hissy fit, she needed to be told "without your Father's story noone would give a F about your story.
Brave
Svetlana the victim of Stalins time, She miss her country she felt back inUSA that she's lonely ,Her life is tragedy,that she couldn't avoid😮
What a curse to be related to anybody famous. Double curse if they are famous and gifted. Triple curse if they are famous, gifted and rich.
To better understand Stalin you must read Big Brother "1984" written by George Orwell.
You're kidding right?
Extremely sad
I read her books many years ago. I found them in a charity shop.
shame that she didn't have the ability to live her own life
Does any woman in history live her own life..was a woman in clay a vessel filled with some male s desires for better or worse..what pretense did you advocate..Cupid had more bearing on a woman girl on the loose than your misleading statement meant to build simone de beauvoir.444
To be "socialist" since musa was raised by pharaoh his father sun tzumar means """""TO KILL acia..THE CIA..ALL SOCIAL PLATFORMS ARE SET DARKNESS TO SEARCH SEEK AND execute the cia. So nickname for sun tzu..susu simsim..open sesame ali baba.
NO SHAME ON YOU!!! NO SHAME ON me
WHY ARE WE SCREAMING!
She definitely had a temper, as in the end of the documentary where she hits herself and tears up paper! No wonder she couldn’t keep a marriage
Umm, hitting oneself is very different than inflicting it on others.
Her father robed, killed his own people, displaced his own people so in reality all her life she was the daughter of a poor, cruel, thief man
I know it's in the past but I really do think some of these scenes should come with a warning!.........
Those scenes are a warning from the past for the present and the future.
That was excellent. Ya never hear about the kids. What a nightmare if ya just wanted to skip through life as a happy go lucky kid.
Svetlana my kindergarten collegue
Her leaving her children is so fcked
I feel bad for Svetlana. but i agree with you on that one.
Reaganism needs to be abolished.
I think it's more Stalinism that needs to be abolished, @Tocktail.
@@coreycox2345 Yep.
Obama's/Biden's/Harris' Marxism needs to be abolished. The Soros family should be prosected and abolished.
Piss poor of Svetlana to pursue a second love interest in light of what her father did to the first.
Did he have her killed?
No!
Why do so many Americans admire Stalin?
Because the Soviets vowed to destroy the USA through the education system within it. We now have millions of miseducated former and current students.
We don’t!
We don’t!
The only Americans that admire Stalin is college students. Everybody either does not like Stalin or is just trying to learn about why people from the Soviet Union love him so much.
😅
Absolute pi
And now stalin, the idol and role model for poo tin, is rehabilitated and his statues are being erected again.
Too many subtitles. Just voice it over.
Stalins russia is starting in the uk
Slowly starting globally.
So happy I’m older. Had so much freedom and fun 🤩
USA as well.
Your off your friggin rocker, your about as bright as the idiots that followed Stalin.
So sad
Becker Canyon
Bongo drums over a RUSSIAN documentary? ridiculous...and insidious
Svetlana had lots of unresolved mental issues! This was the reason she can't be happy with any man or any place in the world. She tried Russia twice US twice, many men! May be if given asylum could have lived in India and could have been happy! I doubt it!
Stalin is the devil incarnate.
Poco di vero. I commenti delle persone che sanno niente o poco. Poca obiettività nel video.
rewriting history
Russian speaking parts was difficult to watch and listen to English. How a person can be so cruel.
I don’t choose a video to read. I would choose a book to read, and I don’t speak any language but English, so unfortunately, these videos are a thumbs down for me.
US propaganda
I cannot understand one word of what these ppl are saying. Are they all speaking Russian??!!? Sad!!
Lousy editing!!
There are subtitles.
like father like daughter ,,first her lover gets 10 yrs in jail and after a year shes moved on then she dumps her kids ,,awful cow
Ya that poor bastard gets tossed into the Gulag. Wonder if he survived. But what were you thinking 🤔 dating that girl
Harsh judgement for someone who has no idea of what she must have gone through. I hope you won't get judged like that. 🙄