साधु ऐसा चाहिए जैसे सूप सुभाय । सार सार को गही रहे तो था देइ उडाय।। अयान सर आपने उपरोक्त दोहे के अनुसार मनुस्मृति को पढने की बात सही ढंग से समझाई समय के साथ बदलाव आते है ओर अन्य धर्म सम्प्रदायो के बजाय सनातनीयो ने हर समय बदलाओ को स्वीकार कर अच्छे विचारों को प्रधानता से माना है ।।ॐ।।
As A.L. Bashan used to say read ancient India as curiosity and pleasure (like esa bhi hota tha) without being judgemental..... One is not forced to follow any norms that were being followed at that time...... They used to follow because of their understanding of that period's circumstances..... And that's totally different from nowadays circumstances..... .. 😊Nice conclusion sir.. ❤
My uncle was professor in mithi bai college in Mumbai in hindi language. Aapka session sun kar jab maine unse manu smriti ke baare me discuss kiya to dicto vo hi paya jo aapne bataya. Kamaal ke ha aap dono
अपने गुर्दे बिल्कुल सत्य कहा और यह वाकई में आपने जो कभी बातें वह बिल्कुल सच्ची हैं और इस किताब यदि आप लोग इस किताब को पड़ेंगे और लोगों ने यह किताब पढ़ ली तो बाद में एक सच्चाई अलग ही मालूम पड़ जाएगी
I agree theres many positive message for society in manusmriti still we can see during those times there were practices of castes based discrimination and also chauvinistic attitudes towards women which still exists in india nepal. This is one of the reason south asia specially Indian subcontinent lags behind than rest of the world. Bhramanical system has never proved to be fruitful for the entire region.
Bharat ka mahan Granth sanvidhan hai sanvidhan ke rachyita Dr bheemarav Ambedkar Ambedkar Sahab ne manusmriti me Aag Laga di thi aur videshi brahmanon ke jitne bhi Granth Kale Kanoon Wale granthon Ki nasbandi kar di thi
Hello Ayaan Sir, very thankful for this informative video, I m planning for long to read our hindu scriptures, but I m just procrastinating for long, I really need to start now, anyways if you could make another videos about Manusmriti, we would be happy, anyways thankyou 🙏
Aapne sahi kaha sir ki insaan sach me kaamchor hai. Insaan ne bhagwaan , ishwar , allah, god ko kabhi dekha bhi nahi fir bhi woh dusro ko dekh kar use manna shuru kar deta hai. Woh apne aas paas ke logon ko pariwar se prabhavit hokar pooja padditi apna leta hai.
That was just like a theory my brother! Just like the organic theory of State and Kautilya's " Saptanga Theory of State " Where we consider state as a Human being. I hope you got your answer
Iss chutiye ko sir kyon bol rahe ho sala mediator banke badi hi chalaki se sirf ek pakchh ka bat kiye ho or woh bhi bat me koi dam nahi hai bc jo isse padhane me time waste karega usse achha samvidhan ya koi or mordern book na padhega jisse kuchh sikhe 👊👊👊
Please take care of yourself Ayyan. It’s good that you personally do not show up in any of your videos. You are doing real good service to our people. I like Share academy channel too.
Thank u sir for this great information.. Aur is book me jo aise shlok h jo aapko lgta h ki sbke sath share krna chahiye pls us pr b ek video bnaiye...🙏🙏🏻🙏🏻
अच्छा प्रयास अयान, तटस्थ होकर ही हम किसी पुस्तक की सही विवेचना कर सकते हैं। शंकराचार्य एक महान दार्शनिक थे, उनके दर्शन पर आधारित किसी पुस्तक का अध्ययन रूचिकर हो सकता है।
Aaj ke samay manusmriti ki koi jaroorat nahin hai. Bharat main SAMVIDHAN lagoo hai, isliye SAMVIDHAN hi sarvshresth hai. SAMVIDHAN ko study karna va lagoo karna hi uchit hai.
Vaise to main aapki baat se sahmat hun Kyunki aapki video aisa mahsus hi nahin Hota ki Nafrat faila rahi hai aapke bolane Ka Tarika aur Samjhane Ka Tarika bilkul Sadharan hai aapki video itni acchi Hai Un Logon se jo log Nafrat failate Hue Kisi Ko expose karte hain aap kripya Karke Rajiv Dikshit ke upar bhi video banaen unhen bhi bahut Sare log Navratri ke tarike se expose Karte Hain Jo ki theek Nahin Hai
आज तक पढणेका मौका नही मिला. मगर समाज मे बहुत सारी गलत पहमिया है/ और जो सुटलेले है, वही कुछ सही है ऐसे मान लेते है/ आपने कहा.... ऋषी ने लिखा है/ हिने सुना है...... मनु एक पशुपालक का मुख्यालय है/ उसने आपने समुदाय क्रिया भले केले लिये क ई नियम बनायचे है, वह इस किताब मे है/ दुसरी बात.... मानव, मानवता, मानवियता.... ऐसे जो शब्द होते इस किताब मे है/ नारद उसजमानेका विचारले आनूसार सामाजिक नियम बनायचे गये हो तो उमेदवार बुराई तो नही दिखती/
A food for thought, if varna was karma based. That simply means marriage across varna should be allowed. After procreation the new offspring will earn their status basis of their karma. But manu smriti is dead against the cross marriages. And lets the cut the slack, if a book is not suitable to present scenario so lets put in efforts to safeguard it. Or Atleast lets maintained a stand this book was suitable yo those circumstances when it was written for now its not relevant. One more point to think over, what was position of women in this entire stages of life system which are bramcharya, grastha, vanprastha and sansya.
अच्छा है, लेकिन अज्ञानी ये मानता ही नहीं है कि वह गलत है।और यहीं सारी समस्याओं की जड़ है। बाकि phycology of money के 10th चैप्टर से आगे का इंतजार कर रहे है?
Thanks a lot for all the clarification Sir . Waiting for the detailed one .And aap ne bilkul sahi kaha. Koi mehnat nahi karna chahta he . including me . But I want to change my shelf any suggestions please
Appreciate the balanced take. However, I think you have missed to cover a few things. In addition to the two types of people you mentioned, there is a third category of people who believe that ancient books like Manusmriti are perfect as these are the words of God. Also, you must also keep in mind Manusmriti has been used for centuries in India as a legal tool for a casteist society and keep the majority of population in miserable state by making it illegal for them to study and conduct normal business in the society. Now, the question comes who would benefit from such an arrangement? Obviously, the upper caste people who wrote this book. It's alright to read a book out of pure academic interest. Mein Kampf, the autobiography of Hitler, who killed six million jews, is also a very popular book. But, one should think twice to read such books for finding life lessons as it could be used to justify the wrongs did by Hitler or the wrongs propogated by Manusmriti. I hope I was able to convey my message and you would take it in good spirits. Thanks
Thank u sir itni achchi jankari Dene ke liye
साधु ऐसा चाहिए जैसे सूप सुभाय ।
सार सार को गही रहे तो था देइ उडाय।।
अयान सर आपने उपरोक्त दोहे के अनुसार मनुस्मृति को पढने की बात सही ढंग से समझाई समय के साथ बदलाव आते है ओर अन्य धर्म सम्प्रदायो के बजाय सनातनीयो ने हर समय बदलाओ को स्वीकार कर अच्छे विचारों को प्रधानता से माना है ।।ॐ।।
आपके विचार अछे है मैभी जरूर पडूगा धन्यवाद.
As A.L. Bashan used to say read ancient India as curiosity and pleasure (like esa bhi hota tha) without being judgemental..... One is not forced to follow any norms that were being followed at that time...... They used to follow because of their understanding of that period's circumstances..... And that's totally different from nowadays circumstances..... ..
😊Nice conclusion sir.. ❤
Sir राधे राधे 🙏 आपके द्वारा इतना अच्छा व्याख्यान 💐 सुन कर इसको स्वयं पड़ने की इच्छा हो रही है, कृपया खरीदने का link 🔗 share करने की कृपा करें🙏
बहोतही अच्छी जानकारी मिली
मनुस्मृती खुद पढनेकी कोशिश आवश्य करेंगे
It teaches us how to divide and rule.
Hum 12 shlokon per accha sa discussion chahte appreciate your work
Explained in a simple way
Great job
Dhanyawad 🙏🏻😊
My uncle was professor in mithi bai college in Mumbai in hindi language. Aapka session sun kar jab maine unse manu smriti ke baare me discuss kiya to dicto vo hi paya jo aapne bataya. Kamaal ke ha aap dono
बहुत बहुत आभार श्रीमान जी। 🙏🙏🚩🚩🚩😊👌👌👍👍🤗🤗
सकारात्मक विचार हमारे अंदरउत्पन्न करने के लिए।🤔
बहुत ही सुन्दर प्रस्तुति दी आपने,
दोनो पहलुओं को रखा आपने,
आपकी बातो से इस किताब के पढ़ने ऐम समझने की इच्छा हुआ, ,,,,
बहुत बहुत साधुवाद
Thanks sir for this great information for this great ancient book 🙏🏼🙏🏼
अपने गुर्दे बिल्कुल सत्य कहा और यह वाकई में आपने जो कभी बातें वह बिल्कुल सच्ची हैं और इस किताब यदि आप लोग इस किताब को पड़ेंगे और लोगों ने यह किताब पढ़ ली तो बाद में एक सच्चाई अलग ही मालूम पड़ जाएगी
I agree theres many positive message for society in manusmriti still we can see during those times there were practices of castes based discrimination and also chauvinistic attitudes towards women which still exists in india nepal.
This is one of the reason south asia specially Indian subcontinent lags behind than rest of the world.
Bhramanical system has never proved to be fruitful for the entire region.
बहुत ही अधभूत ज्ञान सर आपको हदय से प्रणाम🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 आपके सरल और और सटिक बात को सुनके मेरे को भी मनु स्मृति पढ़ने का मन हो गया है🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Bharat ka mahan Granth sanvidhan hai sanvidhan ke rachyita Dr bheemarav Ambedkar Ambedkar Sahab ne manusmriti me Aag Laga di thi aur videshi brahmanon ke jitne bhi Granth Kale Kanoon Wale granthon Ki nasbandi kar di thi
सही राय, धन्यवाद 🙏
भाई मैने पूर्ण तो नहीं लेकिन जितनी भी पढी है , मैं उससे 80% सहमत हूँ।।।💯
thx for brief intro about this book sir. aap sirf jo relevant points he unke sessions banaye, it will be helpful !
Yes I will
Apka live channel 2020 se follow kar Raha hu aur good portfolio bana liya hey
Hello Ayaan Sir, very thankful for this informative video, I m planning for long to read our hindu scriptures, but I m just procrastinating for long, I really need to start now, anyways if you could make another videos about Manusmriti, we would be happy, anyways thankyou 🙏
Bahut sundar sessan
I have reached in chapter seven. I had also the confusion regarding the shudras relating to manusmriti.
सर जी एक सत्यार्थ प्रकाश भी पढ़िए ,महर्षि दयानंद सरस्वती द्वारा रचित
मनु महाराज इस पृथ्वी पर प्रथम मनुष्य थे-और प्रथम विधि-निर्माता थे --जय श्री राम--
Simply great sir
Your content & ur knowledge is so helpful for us..u r always an inspiration
Very well explained❤
Aapne sahi kaha sir ki insaan sach me kaamchor hai. Insaan ne bhagwaan , ishwar , allah, god ko kabhi dekha bhi nahi fir bhi woh dusro ko dekh kar use manna shuru kar deta hai. Woh apne aas paas ke logon ko pariwar se prabhavit hokar pooja padditi apna leta hai.
आप ये बताए उस जामने मैं कोन सी टेक्नॉलिजी थी कि मुख से पैरों से जांघ से मनुष्य पैदा होता था
हाथी बन के अपनी माँ को प्रेग्नेंट करने वाला बुद्ध कैसे सच हो गया
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
That was just like a theory my brother! Just like the organic theory of State and Kautilya's " Saptanga Theory of State " Where we consider state as a Human being. I hope you got your answer
@@kanishk8263😅😅😅😅😅
@@kanishk8263 Aap kahena chaahate ho ki jangh se aur pair se insaan paida ho sakta tha.
It's a good attempt
Pls continue
Any spiritual topic will help us.
People should again adapt reading habit.
Thanks Sir
आज के दिन उसका पूनरिक्षती संस्करण आना चाहिए.ये तत्कालीन समय के लिये योग्य थी.आज की स्थिती मे संशोधन की आवश्यकता है.
This book was relevant in past not present be practical and except new things because nothing is permanent everything is changing.
Yeh muslmaano ko bhi bolo aj bhi sharia bolke chilate h yeh sbh 1400 saal phle shi hoga lekin abhi nhi
Tark Aur ku-tark ka anter khatam ho jata hai jab hum kudh se padh kar eak apni soch aur Disha bane hain. Dhanwad ji
Very nice
सर आजकल बहुत सारी धार्मिक ग्रंथों में लीपा पोती कर दी गई है। Original जो प्राचीन काल में थी वो सत्य थी बाद में बहुत चीजों को बदला गया
Iss chutiye ko sir kyon bol rahe ho sala mediator banke badi hi chalaki se sirf ek pakchh ka bat kiye ho or woh bhi bat me koi dam nahi hai bc jo isse padhane me time waste karega usse achha samvidhan ya koi or mordern book na padhega jisse kuchh sikhe 👊👊👊
Ye dharmik granth nahi hai, ye law book hai
Ye brahmanwad hai
Dhamma to sirf buddha thaa
@@imexmuslim to bhai law book me bhi milaawat ho skti hai.. 😏
@@deepakkumarthing budh dharm me bhi bhar bhar ke jaati h.. Pad lo ek baar
Great !! I m with it
Please take care of yourself Ayyan. It’s good that you personally do not show up in any of your videos. You are doing real good service to our people. I like Share academy channel too.
Sir Manusmriti ke liye playlist taiyar kijiye please 🙏🙏🥺🥺
भारत के संविधान मे मनुस्मृति के आज के सन्दर्भ मे उचित नियमों को शत प्रतिशत शामिल करना चाहिये
Where can I get original manuscript I want to read
Thank u sir for this great information.. Aur is book me jo aise shlok h jo aapko lgta h ki sbke sath share krna chahiye pls us pr b ek video bnaiye...🙏🙏🏻🙏🏻
Great book, constitution of that times, and very important for life lessons
And greatest for financial
Manu smrity is agreat world famous granth which is relavent applicable notonly in India but also insome other countries.
Thanks
आपने बहुत ही अच्छी बात बताई मैं मनुस्मृति के पक्ष में हूं
Sachmuch meney nahi read ki hey apko bahut dhanyawad
Nice one
very nice teaching sir
अच्छा प्रयास अयान, तटस्थ होकर ही हम किसी पुस्तक की सही विवेचना कर सकते हैं। शंकराचार्य एक महान दार्शनिक थे, उनके दर्शन पर आधारित किसी पुस्तक का अध्ययन रूचिकर हो सकता है।
Very nice explanation
Aaj ke samay manusmriti ki koi jaroorat nahin hai. Bharat main SAMVIDHAN lagoo hai, isliye SAMVIDHAN hi sarvshresth hai. SAMVIDHAN ko study karna va lagoo karna hi uchit hai.
Ye video dekhne ke baad... Mujhe ise padne ki bahut ichcha ho rahi he....
सत्य को किसकी सहमती की जरूरत नहीं है
Thank u sir
Jisme ensan ensaan smaan nhi h bo kitab hi kis kaam ki bhut achha Kiya da.b r ambedkar ne ese jla ke
Book ki baat jo bhi ho lekin me aapse yeh janna chahta hu ki jatiwad se itane salo tak sosan hua wo kya sahi tha ???
Vaise to main aapki baat se sahmat hun Kyunki aapki video aisa mahsus hi nahin Hota ki Nafrat faila rahi hai aapke bolane Ka Tarika aur Samjhane Ka Tarika bilkul Sadharan hai aapki video itni acchi Hai Un Logon se jo log Nafrat failate Hue Kisi Ko expose karte hain aap kripya Karke Rajiv Dikshit ke upar bhi video banaen unhen bhi bahut Sare log Navratri ke tarike se expose Karte Hain Jo ki theek Nahin Hai
मनुस्मृती मे केवल वर्ण भेद का आधार जनंम दिया हैं जबकि कर्म ही वर्ण विभाजन का तरिका होना चाहिए था.
Superb👌👍
आज तक पढणेका मौका नही मिला. मगर समाज मे बहुत सारी गलत पहमिया है/ और जो सुटलेले है, वही कुछ सही है ऐसे मान लेते है/
आपने कहा.... ऋषी ने लिखा है/ हिने सुना है...... मनु एक पशुपालक का मुख्यालय है/ उसने आपने समुदाय क्रिया भले केले लिये क ई नियम बनायचे है, वह इस किताब मे है/
दुसरी बात.... मानव, मानवता, मानवियता.... ऐसे जो शब्द होते इस किताब मे है/ नारद उसजमानेका विचारले आनूसार सामाजिक नियम बनायचे गये हो तो उमेदवार बुराई तो नही दिखती/
सुन लिया वही.... पढीये
मुख्या है
Manu Smriti aur sanvidhan dono hi granth padne cahiye kyoun dono granth vidvan aur jaanbaan logo ne likhe hai
A food for thought, if varna was karma based. That simply means marriage across varna should be allowed. After procreation the new offspring will earn their status basis of their karma. But manu smriti is dead against the cross marriages.
And lets the cut the slack, if a book is not suitable to present scenario so lets put in efforts to safeguard it. Or Atleast lets maintained a stand this book was suitable yo those circumstances when it was written for now its not relevant.
One more point to think over, what was position of women in this entire stages of life system which are bramcharya, grastha, vanprastha and sansya.
Very nice 😊😊😊😊😊😊
Shri mad bhagwat Geeta ke bare me short story ka session laiye
Nice Session Sir
Science journey se debate karna chahoge.... Manusmriti ke bare me
sir iske 12 adhaya ke bare me detail se samjhaye plz
10वाँ अध्याय पे पूरा episod बनाये । अच्छा लगेगा
I have one doubt. To Ram naam japana bekar hai ess per video banaeyega plz
Very nice Ayan Sir 😊
Sir how do you manage so many tasks... I want to know your daily routine
Sir Bhagbat mahapuran pr video banaye.....
Need to trace original script of MANUSMRITI.
The moment it get traced, entire scenario will change positively.
Sounds good to me
Manu smriti me bramhan ko jyada achha dikhaya gya hai
Karm se brahman na ki janm se
Haa to brahamn ache hote hi h...kyoki wo mukh se paida hote h ....
@@moviesmania4054 HA BARABAR RAM BHAGWNA SE JADYA ACCHE TOH RAVAN THE Q KI VOH BRAHMAN THE
Baat aap sahi bol rahe ho
मैने संपूर्ण किताब पढी है. ब्रह्म मुहूर्ता मे.
Sir original book kaha se milegi
Kaash, Ambekar Sahab Bhi original padhte par unhone yahi galti ki angrejo ne Apne hisab se translation wali manusmriti Samaj mein bati.
Good brief 🙏
main app ko salute karta hun manusmriti bahut badhiya
चचनामाह (६वी सताब्दी का जिसमें दाहिर की चर्चा है)
अच्छा है, लेकिन अज्ञानी ये मानता ही नहीं है कि वह गलत है।और यहीं सारी समस्याओं की जड़ है।
बाकि phycology of money के 10th चैप्टर से आगे का इंतजार कर रहे है?
Kaha se milega te book?
Hindi translated??
Nyc video 🙏🏻
Now a days how many of us are reading manusmruti? Those are reading their brain should be washed.
Importance of Constitution has been damaged by Ammendments 100 Times since independence In last 70 years
क्याभृगुसंहिताके रचयिता के नाम भी भृगु होयानहै याभंृगु सिर्फ एक पद हो? स्पंष्ट करने कि कृपा। करें / जयगोर्खाभाषा जय भारत/ डाशर्मा
Those who are commenting should read world's oldest law book
What a way to convince. I would love to join lesson wise session.
Dr. बाबासाहेब आंबेडकर ने इस किताब दहन किया था... जाती प्रथा पर आधारित किताब जो समाज को बटाता हो.. कभी बुद्ध ज्ञान पर भी व्हिडिओ बना दो..
सत्य सनातन शुद्ध सनातन जय मनूवाद
नया सीखने के लिए हमेशा तत्पर
सर मैं यह जानना चाहता हूं मैं यह जानना चाहता हूं मनुस्मृति में जो बुरी बातें लिखी हुई है क्या पूरे वह हिंदुस्तान में लागू होती थी
Yes.
@@kamaleshyadav5222 नहीं, मनुस्मृति कभी भी पूरी तरह एप्लीकेबल हुई ही नहीं।
Thanks a lot for all the clarification Sir . Waiting for the detailed one .And aap ne bilkul sahi kaha. Koi mehnat nahi karna chahta he . including me . But I want to change my shelf any suggestions please
Appreciate the balanced take. However, I think you have missed to cover a few things. In addition to the two types of people you mentioned, there is a third category of people who believe that ancient books like Manusmriti are perfect as these are the words of God. Also, you must also keep in mind Manusmriti has been used for centuries in India as a legal tool for a casteist society and keep the majority of population in miserable state by making it illegal for them to study and conduct normal business in the society. Now, the question comes who would benefit from such an arrangement? Obviously, the upper caste people who wrote this book.
It's alright to read a book out of pure academic interest. Mein Kampf, the autobiography of Hitler, who killed six million jews, is also a very popular book. But, one should think twice to read such books for finding life lessons as it could be used to justify the wrongs did by Hitler or the wrongs propogated by Manusmriti. I hope I was able to convey my message and you would take it in good spirits. Thanks