Fixing Bad Percussion Writing (part 1)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 дек 2024

Комментарии • 225

  • @EMCproductions
    @EMCproductions  3 года назад +483

    I'm thinking about turning this into a series. Maybe even covering other percussion instruments. What do you think?

    • @5amu22
      @5amu22 3 года назад +1

      Think that would be cool. I play Mello but I still find your stuff cool. Hope you are doing well. 😁

    • @lukeharris8303
      @lukeharris8303 3 года назад +5

      Ok hear me out. EMC cadence writing contest part 2. Also I think I'd love to see this in a series. I occasionally write for percussion and bands as a whole and this gives me great advice.

    • @nathanaelslater814
      @nathanaelslater814 3 года назад

      I'd love it

    • @takumii0529
      @takumii0529 3 года назад +4

      basses plz. I feel like a lot of schools just overlook basses when it comes to writing it and it makes it very boring for the students to play. Also just poor writing in general.

    • @Drummerboy_marc
      @Drummerboy_marc 3 года назад +1

      Please do

  • @rackfocus
    @rackfocus 3 года назад +234

    As a non-tenor player, I do my best and then let the tenors players change what they want to make it work within the context of the original writing. They often do a better job than I do once they get a feel for it.

    • @SeanLaMontagne
      @SeanLaMontagne 3 года назад +13

      Honestly this is a great approach and there's nothing wrong with letting your quad players change parts so long as the skeleton of what you wrote is still there to fit with the rest of the ensemble.

    • @bobbarksofficial4335
      @bobbarksofficial4335 2 года назад +3

      @@SeanLaMontagne that's what my tech does too

    • @SeanLaMontagne
      @SeanLaMontagne 2 года назад +3

      @@bobbarksofficial4335 this year only one of my quads has the skills required to feel out better parts, so I won't get to hand it off to them this year, but hopefully next year theyll get to take a lot more liberties with their parts.

    • @bobbarksofficial4335
      @bobbarksofficial4335 2 года назад +1

      @@SeanLaMontagne mmm

  • @RedDogMamaHD
    @RedDogMamaHD 3 года назад +138

    So, for most of you, you are focused on the suggestions on the tenor writing ... I am instead so happy to see the licks recorded at the Albert Einstein bronze sculpture at 22st NW and Constitution Ave NW. Why? Because Eric was nice enough to come here to appease me! Parking was a bit difficult, but we made it work with the Tiny Tenors and the Spockenspeil. Several people enjoyed watching Eric play. Also, there is a Geocache there: GC1B64. Stop by if you are ever in DC!

    • @christinashelby6083
      @christinashelby6083 3 года назад +3

      And here I was wondering just how he managed on the Metro with those drums!

    • @derekgreene5748
      @derekgreene5748 2 года назад +2

      A little over a week ago, my marching band was in DC for a parade. I noticed the statue and immediately recognized it from this video. Enjoy your day!

    • @ferretyluv
      @ferretyluv 2 года назад

      Doesn’t Eric live in the DC area?

  • @GeorgeCollier
    @GeorgeCollier 3 года назад +7

    here because i'm transcribing drums

    • @theresa.y5221
      @theresa.y5221 16 дней назад

      how does this have no comments
      Wait..

  • @TheSquareOnes
    @TheSquareOnes 3 года назад +62

    I'm going to need a full tenor cover of Toxicity, please and thank you.

    • @illusionvii
      @illusionvii 3 года назад +2

      I didn't realize until I read your comment!

    • @cherrypepsi2815
      @cherrypepsi2815 3 года назад +3

      Like
      By system of a down?

  • @bro748
    @bro748 3 года назад +59

    7:42 This is so quick to fix, you can make every stem on a staff automatically point in a certain direction.
    Staff Tool -> Staff (the menu option) -> Edit Staff Attributes -> Stem Settings... -> ⦿ Always Up -> OK.
    (there are a few other ways to reach this option, but this is the simplest to describe in text form.)

    • @dipayds523
      @dipayds523 3 года назад +1

      Thanks, I also write on Finale. This helps a lot 👍

    • @SecretWalrus
      @SecretWalrus 3 года назад

      That’s how I’ve always done it.

  • @Randler101
    @Randler101 3 года назад +408

    I am sucky at writing for tenors but I tried to write a cadence and now I’m writing for a horror movie (composing) so this is gonna help… I think🤔. Anyways so far a minute it very good and interesting thx emc. I can learn more from hear than in school. ( HA take that school System)

    • @jackthecommenter2768
      @jackthecommenter2768 3 года назад +5

      Which one?

    • @ATLDRUMACADEMY
      @ATLDRUMACADEMY 3 года назад +9

      Congratulations

    • @jackthecommenter2768
      @jackthecommenter2768 3 года назад +14

      @@ATLDRUMACADEMY wait your the people with the really good kid drum line wow hello

    • @ATLDRUMACADEMY
      @ATLDRUMACADEMY 3 года назад +7

      @@jackthecommenter2768 hellooo there

    • @D-Vinko
      @D-Vinko 3 года назад +10

      Except ofcourse word order, and spelling.
      You still need school for both of those.
      Ellipses, capitals, punctuation, basic spelling, and probably reading comprehension are all things you'll need to improve.

  • @senor_sensei
    @senor_sensei 3 года назад +35

    This is the kind of video I think a lot of people needed. Thank you!

  • @rowanxxd3366
    @rowanxxd3366 3 года назад +104

    Writing for tenors seems to be my worst downfall in battery writing, thanks for this lol

    • @ashleyhefner2721
      @ashleyhefner2721 3 года назад

      I marched snare drum at Music City Mystique in the early 2000's.. so I am a snare drummer by nature. That being said, when writing tenor parts I always play them to make sure that they feel comfortable when executed properly. (Example, no pushes - example 4 16ths on drum 1 and the downbeat of the next beat on drum 4. This is attainable with a crossover but it needs to be notated as such and you need to think forward as to how the parts are going to flow going forward in the music. And always write stickings. Those are my biggest tips. Along with play the parts before you send the music off to check for any awkward feeling parts, and these can often be fixed with just moving a few notes to other drums. Good luck in all your endeavors!

  • @oscargill423
    @oscargill423 3 года назад +6

    It's so satisfying to watch him demonstrate all the different optional sequences, and it's a great learning opportunity for anyone trying to get into battery writing. Definitely support the idea to turn it into a series!

  • @Splooie128
    @Splooie128 3 года назад +13

    Thank you! It's not just tenors (although they're the most obvious)! I would say a series is in order for ALL marching percussion.
    It's very, VERY easy to tell when battery parts have been written by composers without battery experience.

  • @nathanaelslater814
    @nathanaelslater814 3 года назад +9

    I'm the guy at 3:29. The music was written by our drum instructor and the part you chose was one of the least awkward

    • @melvina753
      @melvina753 3 года назад +8

      Hello this is the drum instructor. You are in big trouble for not liking my music Nathanael. I spent many hours putting this together and this was my life’s work. I am moving you to marching glockenspiel tomorrow for the rest of the season.
      Thank you for perfectly playing my music Mr. Carr

    • @nathanaelslater814
      @nathanaelslater814 3 года назад +4

      @@melvina753 sad thing is that this is probably the response I'd get

  • @collinsbuchanan4573
    @collinsbuchanan4573 3 года назад +13

    I play trumpet in a marching band and I’ve always had respect for tenor drums ( and everyone else!) but I didn’t know it was this hard! Subbing immediately

  • @zephlyn5886
    @zephlyn5886 3 года назад +17

    yeah at 2:15, this is my first year on tenors, i've only been playing for a few months now so it was kind of weird to me. they wanted that buzz on spock for the full quarter note staright in to the crossover.

  • @thomaswharton4078
    @thomaswharton4078 3 года назад +12

    this will help me as a front ensemble arranger who has been thrust into battery arranging inadvertently

  • @brickerupdike5908
    @brickerupdike5908 3 года назад +2

    This made me want to go back into drum parts I wrote 3 years ago and fix them.
    This thought me a lot about drum notation I didn't know.
    Also, props to the guy that sent in his own stuff, that was cool.

  • @jrexine234
    @jrexine234 2 года назад +1

    You can add a shortcut for Sticking -- Edit > Preferences > Shortcuts > *search Sticking bottom mid-right* > Define...
    I use ctrl + alt + s. Most everything else is already assigned.

  • @nolanfinke3729
    @nolanfinke3729 3 года назад +2

    0:11 the very left tenor player for blue stars is my assistant drumline director
    *nice*

  • @blxckyy_9568
    @blxckyy_9568 3 года назад +5

    My music was actually written by a quad Alumni from Phantom Regiment. Needless to say it’s still pretty awkward in some spots and there aren’t any stickings written in.

  • @cmyk8964
    @cmyk8964 3 года назад +2

    All this about “sticking” and “crossovers” reminds me of making stepcharts for Stepmania-basically the pattern of arrows on a DDR level. We care a lot about the foot alternation flowing well, and we actually use the term “crossover” for patterns where you cross your feet over, like ⬅️⬇️➡️⬇️⬅️.

  • @frostygamer8737
    @frostygamer8737 3 года назад +4

    I would love this as a series

  • @drumset09
    @drumset09 3 года назад +38

    I've only written once cadence, but did tenors for a couple years. As I was writing it, I just thought - would I want to play this?
    I also played bass for 4 years - the bass part is, um, complex, lol.
    This was a great video, and I'll defiantly be utilizing the advice.

  • @Robo0595
    @Robo0595 3 года назад +2

    This is Adam Neely's "How to Not Suck at Music" series but for percussion.
    This definitely needs to continue.

  • @96per58
    @96per58 3 года назад +5

    Check that rhythm again at 2:23 😂😂

  • @chrisroode
    @chrisroode 3 года назад +1

    TO FIX QUAD AND BASS PARTS IN FINALE! ctrl-k, click "instrument list" select quad/bass part, then next to staff (bottom right) click drop down, select "other." The staff setup window appears. 3rd from bottom on the right is "stem reversal" set that to '0' and your stems on 2-4 will always be up, only 1 and the spocks will be down, and the down stems will not cross the bottom staff.

  • @billybudnick4957
    @billybudnick4957 3 года назад +6

    Eric, I’d be super interested if you did a video of Do’s and Dont’s for wind arrangers put in a position where they have to write battery parts.

  • @robertcozart6081
    @robertcozart6081 3 года назад

    Tenor drumming is indeed an art and you never fail to make that apparent to me.

  • @benmastergeneral7637
    @benmastergeneral7637 Год назад

    Everyone needed this, he is doing a favor, thank you

  • @FeloniousPedigrees
    @FeloniousPedigrees 3 года назад +1

    I played first trumpet in band but chilled and played with the tenors.
    I still just stare blankly and drool looking at some of the shit you guys do.

  • @ryandesselle5457
    @ryandesselle5457 3 года назад +1

    I liked the System of a Down at the end EMC

  • @seansdr3743
    @seansdr3743 3 года назад +1

    That one dislike was someone who was offended because they wrote a piece you fixed

  • @Pharry_
    @Pharry_ Год назад

    Your videos helped me realize I wasn’t bad at tenors I just got music written by non percussionists which are more difficult than any other form of music

  • @stephenbyrnes7205
    @stephenbyrnes7205 3 года назад +4

    Video 35 of commenting until EMC makes an entire battery percussion out of spocks and 8 inch splash cymbals

  • @canobeansyummers1667
    @canobeansyummers1667 3 года назад +1

    my marching band director was a quad player while in high school and again while he was at ucla.

  • @bevan4602
    @bevan4602 3 года назад +1

    Anyone else notice toxicity by System of a Down at 11:46

  • @nickpisarczyk
    @nickpisarczyk 3 года назад +2

    good morning! love your videos eric!

  • @raul.litoo2
    @raul.litoo2 3 года назад

    7:44 looks super cool and groovy . Who ever wrote it is super talented

  • @Tacibell
    @Tacibell 3 года назад

    that outro is chaotic.. i love it lol

  • @liamstewart4806
    @liamstewart4806 3 года назад +1

    I'm going to try and play tenors this upcoming indoor percussion season, I am normally a trumpet player but I have always thought it would be cool to play tenors. Its unlikely I'll play tenors but rather be placed on bass, but I am going to try.

  • @allegorysplatterpunk1829
    @allegorysplatterpunk1829 3 года назад

    Would love to see more of these! Great video 🤘

  • @MrIzzy5466
    @MrIzzy5466 3 года назад +1

    Me, a saxophone player: "How did I get here?"

    • @ferretyluv
      @ferretyluv 2 года назад

      I’m voice. I’m lost as well.

  • @anastonishingnick
    @anastonishingnick 3 года назад +1

    Nice touch with toxicity at the end

  • @ryancollins9511
    @ryancollins9511 3 года назад

    Our drum tech told me and the other tenor player that he sucks at writing tenor music and to tell him to rewrite it if needed. Nice that he was so humble and he didn’t write it that bad

  • @jimmyj956
    @jimmyj956 3 года назад +3

    The composers for the my high school show music keep writing pushes and forget a lot of stickings 😔😣

  • @SerenityMusic3
    @SerenityMusic3 3 года назад

    I'm officially in love with you!🎶🎵 Thank you for showing Tenors Love 💙💜 😘

  • @Startail267
    @Startail267 2 месяца назад

    EMC: I'm playing it a little under-tempo because--well, I'm sightreading, okay?"
    Also EMC: *plays the tenors more smoothly than I've ever seen before*

  • @DouglasStevens0521
    @DouglasStevens0521 3 года назад +2

    I learned how to write for tenors after having to rewrite many unplayable parts I was given

  • @gavinscience4146
    @gavinscience4146 3 года назад

    I saw how the straight eights weren’t paradiddled in the thumbnail and had flashbacks to our band director making us do impossible crossovers thinking it looked cool

  • @redbeardthepilot3168
    @redbeardthepilot3168 3 года назад +2

    Hope that trip to DC was fun!

    • @RedDogMamaHD
      @RedDogMamaHD 3 года назад

      It was my second time in 2 years in DC! Both times to see Eric in The Commandant's Own! (Actually, I did come through once with my husband on a vacation between Williamsburg and my Mom's house in Ohio ... driving in 2015. He has since passed away ... His Harley riding name was RedDog.

  • @robynholley2180
    @robynholley2180 3 года назад +3

    when your fanbase is legit talented and can write rather solid licks

    • @cozycowboy
      @cozycowboy 3 года назад +1

      Funny, the tenor guy on our line is like ride and die kit player. Death metal, thrash, full force blast beats, that kind of stuff-but he’s also killer on tenors. A little interesting

  • @KishPlaysBassDrum
    @KishPlaysBassDrum 2 года назад

    eric in front of an e=mc^2 is iconic

  • @austinorlikowski768
    @austinorlikowski768 3 года назад +1

    How did I watch this entire thing as a brass player?

  • @drhall343
    @drhall343 3 года назад +4

    That third one was like a horror movie for tenor players. 😂

  • @aiporia1284
    @aiporia1284 3 года назад +2

    I was considering sending in some of my marimba part as a joke but it looks like you got enough submissions

  • @Max-dd4ow
    @Max-dd4ow 3 года назад

    Make this a series

  • @masonmarler5595
    @masonmarler5595 3 года назад +9

    I’m really having a hard time on the tenors do you have any tips

    • @drumset09
      @drumset09 3 года назад +2

      Start slow
      practice
      practice
      practice

    • @drumset09
      @drumset09 3 года назад +2

      For me, I tend to learn parts for the rhythm first, then start making the accents pop and getting dynamics where they need to be. As long as you can hit the correct drums, you can worry about how you're hitting them later.

    • @smot6706
      @smot6706 3 года назад +2

      I usually play hard stuff on one drum first until I get the rhythm down then moving it around the drums is way easier

    • @rawhidelamp
      @rawhidelamp 3 года назад +1

      Play your rhythms on a single drum first, and then go around the drums

  • @roadkillcatgirl3620
    @roadkillcatgirl3620 3 года назад +1

    you and Stevie T should do a collab since your style of comedy is really similar. I bet you'd get along. Also quad djent would be fire

  • @bradontrace3846
    @bradontrace3846 3 года назад

    @Emcproductions you should check out the Ohio University Marching 110 drumline. Very old school that uses timbales and tenors instead of tenors.

  • @JoshuaWillis89
    @JoshuaWillis89 2 года назад +1

    Are you in Washington, DC? I recognize that Einstein statue.

  • @vohehuli
    @vohehuli 3 года назад +1

    I’m not a drummer so some of these terms I don’t understand. What does he mean by a “push”?

  • @SeanLaMontagne
    @SeanLaMontagne 3 года назад

    Man I should start submitting stuff when EMC requests it

  • @christianmichalsky2826
    @christianmichalsky2826 3 года назад

    Do a Part 2!!!

  • @gregaaron89
    @gregaaron89 3 года назад

    Now I want to see a 10/10

  • @zanfacit1
    @zanfacit1 2 года назад +1

    Stupid question. What is a push?

  • @explosavemaster7524
    @explosavemaster7524 3 года назад

    I play drum kit so i dont have to deal with those sort of issues
    and my school does not have a Drumline or marching band
    we have 2 concert bands, 1 big band, and several rock bands

  • @pogman9490
    @pogman9490 3 года назад

    The Einstein statue looks so disappointed

  • @leejones9055
    @leejones9055 3 года назад

    Wish I'd seen the post for this before. I'd have sent what I've written in. Glad I didn't see it pop up from my student though.... I know he watches these.

  • @MichaelManza
    @MichaelManza 3 года назад

    Niceee man, so excited

  • @staticbadgers690
    @staticbadgers690 3 года назад

    As a brass player who would like to learn percussion ALL of this is confusing as hell

  • @SerenityMusic3
    @SerenityMusic3 3 года назад

    Tenor drum practice pad, why didn't I think of that?!!! OMG
    Where can I order that from?????
    God I love you Now!!!

  • @taternater7495
    @taternater7495 3 года назад

    don’t think we missed the We Are Number 1 at 2:05

  • @thats10guy60
    @thats10guy60 3 года назад +1

    Are you going to grand nationals in Indianapolis this years EMC

  • @k2skater870
    @k2skater870 3 года назад

    me trying to find EMC production on 9/11/21 on NBC live like👀👀

  • @musicianintraining
    @musicianintraining 3 года назад

    I like how you were at Georgia Tech in front of Einstein 😂 @EMCproductions

  • @princealigorna7468
    @princealigorna7468 Год назад

    Given the natural speed of tenor drums, I'm honestly shocked you don't hear them in metal. I know Slipknot's percussionists use marching snare, but I don't think they've used tenors

  • @Thebestfemboydrummer
    @Thebestfemboydrummer 10 месяцев назад

    Hey, EMC. I’m currently a high school student who is looking forward to joining the Drumline. I was wondering if there was a way to turn a generic con. snare sound like a marching snare. Is there a way you could turn that into a video or something?

  • @dinosaurus5531
    @dinosaurus5531 3 года назад +1

    Could you do the vibes or marimba pls

  • @ghostlight1868
    @ghostlight1868 3 года назад

    Emc is god

  • @bwen1047
    @bwen1047 3 года назад +1

    What do you put your tenor practice pad on? Do you have a stand? I have mine sitting on a table and would love a better option

  • @mrsquiddler
    @mrsquiddler Год назад +1

    What tenor practice pad is that

  • @daesendri
    @daesendri 7 дней назад

    11:40 is that toxicity by soad?

  • @minikretz1
    @minikretz1 3 года назад

    I want to see you do the whole warm up packet to see if they're all as awkward

  • @SerenityMusic3
    @SerenityMusic3 3 года назад

    I loved the set up at theemd how many toms were there???

  • @quoteonquoteartist1301
    @quoteonquoteartist1301 3 года назад

    *me who doesn't even play any drum*
    I like your funny words magic man

  • @mrgh0stman459
    @mrgh0stman459 3 года назад

    Do you know if I can use a snare drum stand for a tenor drum practice pad?

  • @SerenityMusic3
    @SerenityMusic3 3 года назад

    I want that T shirt!!!

  • @hannahplumleymycarnivaladd6365
    @hannahplumleymycarnivaladd6365 3 года назад

    Please wrap those small tenors like sour cream and onion prints please I’m begging you

  • @shauncarmer4307
    @shauncarmer4307 3 года назад

    WE CAN'T HEAR THE FIRE PLACE!

  • @PS4Gameplayz
    @PS4Gameplayz 3 года назад

    Can you transcribe Casey Brohard’s 2005 i&e solo?

  • @clarenceransom5205
    @clarenceransom5205 2 года назад

    Sweet!!!

  • @cochese95
    @cochese95 2 года назад +1

    Did you ever define what a “push” is for non tenor drummers? If so I missed it. If not then I think that could help a lot of people trying to write for Tenors.

    • @DaPvZBro
      @DaPvZBro 2 года назад

      A “push” is when you the written music doesn’t allow for proper flow between the hands and drums themselves, forcing your arms to move very quickly in order to move them to the next drum. They always feel very awkward and look awkward too. An example of a push is 4 hits of alternating sticking (RLRL) on drum 1 (second most right drum) followed by 4 hits of alternating sticking on drum 2 (second most left drum). The left hand being on drum 1 prevents the right hand from moving to drum 2 efficiently which as a result, gets forced to move very quickly and requires the entire arm to move in a very small amount of time. This can be solved by changing the sticking to paradiddles (RLRR LRLL) to allow for the left hand to move out of the right hand’s way and give more time between hand movements.

  • @owengalligan4052
    @owengalligan4052 3 года назад

    so I was wondering if anyone knew any programs or ways I could line up videos to record splitting myself

  • @warrior995
    @warrior995 3 года назад

    You have a lot of little clever references in your quad solo transitions. Clever dude. Haha.

  • @ashtonh2112
    @ashtonh2112 3 года назад

    Where did you get your practice pad tenors

  • @evangore511
    @evangore511 3 года назад

    Just so we're all clear, "skip ad" is no longer an option on this channel!!!! Don't do it.

  • @chutdigadut
    @chutdigadut 3 года назад +1

    Dude, YES! YEESSSS!! This needs to go viral gee wiz 🔥

  • @isopropyltoxicity
    @isopropyltoxicity 3 года назад +1

    Eric you need to do another video like the dance of eternity video you did

  • @Harmonikdiskorde
    @Harmonikdiskorde 2 года назад

    What would happen if you let a complete non-percussionist have a whack at drums and then notating it? (I volunteer as a viola / piano player)

  • @zabloing4815
    @zabloing4815 2 года назад

    i feel stupid for saying this but what’s the song called at 11:39

    • @monkael1438
      @monkael1438 4 месяца назад

      Toxicity System of a Down

  • @Syn_xmSyn
    @Syn_xmSyn 10 месяцев назад

    Can someone tell me what this piece is called?