I’ve been working almost every weekend in another city for the last 2 years, and 1,5 years with this bag. I do see where this review stems from, but I’m still very happy with my bag. Three reasons: #1 at the end of the day, every bag is a compromise. I have bags which are more comfortable and lighter, but they don’t protect my gear and are definitely not stovable. Get some lose some. In my use this really ticks all of the boxes, and is good compromise. #2 It does not like to be over packed. Once you accept this, it’s a lot more comfortable. #3 When you travel a lot, organization is everything. It just makes leaving the house a breeze. And with the small camera cube, my camera is always accessible.
This is the first time I've seen a review actually critical of a bag after some real world use. In a landscape of youtubers that seem to use the bag once or twice over the course of two weeks and basically are making an ad for it, this is very refreshing.
I've had this bag for a few years and love all the features. I agree with the strap comfort annoyance that is mitigated with the waist strap. Love the security features (check the peak design video on that). I'm not using it as a camera or computer bag so my loads are lighter. Love the materials and features. I can see why people would bail on this bag though. More soft padding on the shoulder straps would solve 90% of my issues. Raw weight is on the heavy side; 4.5 lbs.
I watched another video video, where they said, that this backpack packs surprisingly little compared to the liters declared in comparison to an Osprey. So I ordered both for comparison, this one here and an Osprey Transporter Carry-On 44 for direct comparison before making my decision and I couldn‘t disagree more. This PeakDesign Travel Backpack 45 packs quite a bit more than the mentioned Osprey, I tried with the exact same things. Not sure, how everyone comes to the conclusion, that this backpack here is comparatively underwhelming in packing space, as from my impression it‘s the other way around?
Your video review was a much-needed reality check, preventing me from falling into the same pitfalls I experienced with the Aer Travel Pack (33l). Your shared frustrations about limited space and excessive compartmentalization echoed my own sentiments. Despite owning it for an extended period, I found its complex design, limited size and bulky feel when full led to infrequent use. Having recently tried a 60l duffle-style backpack, I contemplated a return to a more organized and well designed, but bigger, travel bag like the Peak Design. However, your review served as a clear reminder for me of the efficiency of the duffle style with pack cubes, offering ample space and airline carry-on compliance. Thanks to your insights, I've decided to stick with the practicality of my current duffle bag setup.
If you're always on the move travelling, this is the best backpack. This bag made my 3 week Japan trip a breeze. No annoying luggage to pull around, stylish and small enough not to get mistaken for a mountaineer. Space for a camera, clothes for a week and some essentials.
Thanks for this review. Really like seeing critical stuff as well in this day and age of "everything's awesome". I'm considering on buying this PD 45L and even after this video I'm considering it still 😅 I think the annoyances you mentioned are things I can live with. Also I actually like the concept of the clamshell mechanism and I've had (cheapo) backbags with laptops against my back without any issue so I think my laptops going to be okay there.
So after using the bag for YEARS you finally decide to get rid of it because there are things that annoy you? -___- I’ll be honest, for the amount of travel bags I owe this is the best one. You’re entitled to your opinions but there is way too much nitpicking here. Saying you don’t like that the bag gives off a perception that it’s full? Or saying you have a hard time closing it when it’s full? Huh. Then saying you’re scared your laptop would break in the sleeve? Lmao how many laptops broke in the bag? 0. Not sure what’s the issue here. I’m gonna pass on this review.
I’ve taken the everyday backpack in week trips. Yea the straps aren’t the most comfortable, but they are durable as heck! The materials made from these are head over heals better than any Osprey (and I own 3 Ospreys - 1 of which I take on multi week trips to Europe). You’re review doesn’t scare me in the slightest. I’m purchasing this bag. The engineering and quality alone with PD spare no expense. Stop posting videos that oppose the normal perception of these bags just to get views lol. And stop not picking. You’ll never find a perfect bag.
Could not agree more... and why I got this bag, along with the 35L duffle. The ability to move the packing/camera cubes between them with total ease. I'm going to grab the 65L on sale as a checked bag for cloths (never camera gear). The clamshell abilities are also more for photographers... you set the bag down to access and not put the side down that goes against your back. I love my travel backpack.
I appreciate the critical review. As someone who is an amateur backpack enthusiast not every backpack feature is rainbows and sunshine., but no one ever complains about its flaws!
I love negative/low points or cons as it gives the deal breakers in a nutshell. Def honest by a guy who’s actually used it extensively. Dont like laptop in top its just not ergonomic for instance. Thanks!
Humorous and insightful. Thank you. At the end of the day, your review and annoyances remind me of the Piña Colada song. The bag’s become “Like a worn out recording of a favorite song.” Interested in what you finally landed on as a replacement.
Thank you! My replacement is quite a boring one, but it's working for my needs. A classic Patagonia Duffel, haha. We'll be reviewing some more 1 bag carry bags here soon though!
Thank you for this review. I agree with your comments on the straps and the storage. I wouldn't use this backpack for hiking. I have the Nya-Evo Fjord 36C that is excellent for that, but I want something slimmer for carry-on on smaller aircraft. I will put the small camera cube in it and fold down the organizer panel in the front so that I can have front access to the contents of the bag. The Nya-Evo is very fabulous in that regard as it has rear-access for the camera only and top access to the rest of the bag. But it is super bulky, 8cm more in depth than the PD, so I will give that one a try as a second option :-)
Appreciate the review! I agree with you, but I ended up buying this bag anyway because I realized there's no bag that exists today that fits all of my nitpicking requests 😂After all my research it was between this and the Tortuga lite bag. I almost picked the Tortuga, but ended up going with the PD simply because it had more pockets, a couple of secret compartments, and the magnetic waist belt design is quite innovative. Some things that irritate me about the PD bag: - 2 water bottle holders, which probably got calculated into the liters (I don't even need one water bottle holder most of the time)! - The misalignment of the handles, and the "duffle" bag handle on the back is terrible, so I can't really use this as a duffle - of course the straps aren't too good - the compression idea is awesome, but the buttons keep unbuttoning even when there's practically nothing in the bag. I think they could have been a bit more creative than a button, maybe adding some sort of clamp so it doesn't keep de-compressing. I'd prefer to put this thing under the seat if I could. - zippers ... no idea why they didn't use YKK - The main compartment digs into the second compartment. I don't feel like this is an issue with a Tumi bag I have. Can't really explain why but they definitely conflate with each other a bit too much for my tastes. Everything else is pretty awesome and beats almost all the other bags out there. I mostly ended up buying it because I got it for ~$235. So ~$65 (20%) off had me sold and it was cheap enough that if I didn't want it after my next trip I can always swap it for a bit of a loss. Not the end of the world.
1. Sounds like you’ve just been overpacking it. They’re not compression zippers. 2. Same with the laptop complaint. Don’t overpack the bag. Have clothes? Use their compression bags to keep the size down. And like you say, your laptop never got damaged. So it’s fine. 3. Yes, the strap thing is just nitpicking. Most bags don’t even allow you to stow the straps. Be glad there’s at least the option. 4. The thin straps thing is subjective I guess. They shoulder straps have always felt very comfortable to me. 5. Sternum strap. I’ve used peak design bags for the last 5 and a little bit years, and they’ve all used that same sternum strap system. I haven’t every lost it. Might be a manufacturing defect if yours falls off easily. 6. How do you know how Peak Design measures the internal volume of their bags? That’s not really based on anything, is it? Every bag is a tradeoff, and I’ve yet to see another bag that beats the Peak Design one. WANDRD gets close I think, but I still think it loses to the Peak Design. Keep in mind, these are CAMERA bags. At one point you compared it to some other bag where you said you could pack way more into it than the rating, but that's really not a fair comparison.
1: Respectfully, I don't feel like I "overpacked" this bag. 2: I use compression bags. I'm still disappointed with the "layout" of the bag. 3: Nitpicking is the name of the game on this channel! It's how we can IMPROVE products! :) 4: Glad you like them! It certainly is a preference thing. 5: It's possible! 6: I can guarantee you, most manufacturers, including PD, do not use any kind of scientific metrics for measuring their volume. That said if a representative of PD would like to weight in on how they do it, I'd love to be proven wrong. I appreciate you commenting and watching and it's great that you like and have had a good experience with this bag. A lot of people love them, but I think there are better options out there - at least for my uses and possibly other peoples.
Thank you so much for your “nitpicky” review! I love this type of review, because this is where you learn how it really feels and functions or gets caught on things, etc. My next thought is let’s get a woman who has at least a D cup try these things on too! Please!!
A bit late but anyway. Good and informative video! I'm looking into this bag as a bigger photo and travel/camping backpack. I own the 20l everyday backpack and love it but it's a bit too small for travel or camping. I noticed one thing tho, when you talked and demonstrated about the sternum strap, you hooked the wrong end of the strap. The one without the little pulltab is the one you install semi-permanently, and the one with the tab is the one you attach and re-attach on an everyday basis. You took it of in the right end but the semi-permanent end doesn't look like it's properly attached. I have the same sternum strap for my everyday backpack 20l and i have never experienced the issue you're mentioning. But as said, overall a good and informative video! Cheers!
I agree with all the positives and negatives this bag has brought out of people. Personally, the bag would be the #1 all-time bag with a better shoulder strap and hip belt, but that's just me. The ability to tuck away the carry system is a concept that has been introduced previously. I had a pack back in the late 90s that did the same thing, and it did just as well with zippers vs magnets. AND it could be accomplished again with a better carry system. PD selling the 45L as a camera bag needs to be revised. The ability to put a camera cube in a backpack doesn’t make it a camera backpack. Yes, the camera cubes are excellent, and attaching them in PD packs is a fantastic option for lugging your equipment around. I invested in my PD camera cubes long before I purchased the Traveler 45L pack for that reason, and to this day use them in luggage and now in my F-Stop Shinn backpack. However, the one thing PD didn’t consider before they started pushing the Traveler 45L as a photographer backpack alternative was the convenience most, if not all, camera backpacks offer, and that is storage for accessories. Anyone looking to use this bag as a full-time camera pack must know that all zippered storage areas are in the front of the bag. Meaning if you are inside the bag pulling out camera equipment (from the back) and suddenly remember that that specific Arca plate you need or camera battery is in the zippered compartment up front, you have to close the clamshell, turn the bag around, unzip the front, and find the zippered pouch you stored it in. ALL UP FRONT. With all that said, the workflow for the bag as a camera bag is horrible. If you carry a camera body and maybe two small prime lenses, then you have plenty of room in the camera cube to store what-nots. But if you are using the bag to carry that, I question why you are hauling around the Traveler 45L in the first place.
BTW, with all that being said, I bet Traveler 45L 2.0 will solve some of the negatives many people have pointed out. Personally, I'm keeping my bag as a traveler's bag. It works great with a medium or small cube and some packing cubes. Keep the weight down and comfort should be acceptable.
I’ve had several travel backpacks. I also adhere to the idea of traveling with one carry on compliant bag. I only have a few things to say about your gripes. First, the laptop flap is not the only access to the main packing space. You can also access that space thru the front flap by zipping the organization panel. As far as the ‘sunglass pocket’ goes, why would you not use it to store something, i.e. wallet, keys, air pods, dongles then store your glasses in a place you feel is more secure? The storage spaces designed into a travel bag don’t have to be used for anything in particular. If it fits there the way you want it to then put it there otherwise find another space. So, after 6 years you’ve decided to use another bag. Which you’ll undoubtedly find issues with. I’m curious what your choice is?
@@ComputerStuff That’s a great bag. I’ve got a 32. When I don’t need organization it’s my ‘go to’. I get your point. I can’t use the same bag for every situation. I’m trying to have the ‘perfect’ bag depending on what I’m using it for. The Peak 45 definitely isn’t a do-it-all solution but I do use it 75% of the time. My biggest gripe ( yeah, I have one, ha) is the weight. I’m still searching for the perfect combo of durability, weight, comfort, organization, aesthetic. I am finding that 32-35 liters capacity, whatever that is, seems to fit 99% of my needs. I enjoyed your video 👍🏾 nuthin wrong with stirring the pot skittle, ha
The strap wings fold in. For my use cases, it is perfect. I can't see how any of your nits are worth bailing on the backpack. You may need a dump purse instead.
I enjoyed this video, thanks for it. Torn between this, the Wandrd Prvke 41, and maybe a few others I seem to have crossed off the list, but am not totally sure yet. 1. Have you used the Wandrd Prvke? 2. Fun review, but what I loved was reading your responses to the comments here. I read them all. Hats off to you for staying so calm, friendly, and unfazed in the face of the kind of ridiculous insults and trolling that inevitably come when you simply take the time to share your own opinions on something you've used for years. I may still get this bag, but am really stoked I got to hear your opinions after all this time. THanks for what you do, subbed!
1: I haven't yet. I'll see if I can get my hands on one. 2: Really appreciate the nice response here. Glad we could help David. Never trying to yuck anyone's yum on this channel, just trying to give my feedback without all the smoke and mirrors other RUclipsrs use. I hope you enjoy the bag if you get it!
I’ve never once thought my laptop or iPad was at risk in the laptop section, or have ever lost the sternum strap. And my bag has never been “floppy” when packing. Yes, the shoulder straps suck - though better than their Everyday Backpack IMHO.
I've owned 4 different peak design backpacks that all use the same sternum strap and I've never lost one. Tens of thousands of miles in travel, 0 lost sternum straps. Not sure if you're unlucky or i'm the opposite - but i've never had a problem.
@@ComputerStuff i almost finished your video, but i see that your strap is upside down. it might be the reason why you keep losing them? And you should only remove the side with the little flap attached to it.
Spent some time looking at the PD videos on this bag and I just kept wondering "ok but what's wrong with it?" Thanks for criticizing it, and I'm glad you nitpick so I can consider what I can and can't live with. Might have to try those straps IRL before paying a lot of money. How many years have you had it? How heavily did you use it? How well did it re-sell? It still looks in good condition.
Realize this is a little older, but an interesting point of view. I've had mine for a while and aside from your complaint about potentially losing the sternum strap, don't really agree with your assessment. I find the straps to be fine, and this holds a ton of stuff. However, people should realize it's really only 35 liters until you use the expansion zippers. Even then, is it really 45 liters? The expansion is a little hard to take full advantage of, but has been fine for me. I like the general layout, as it's similar to the Goruck GR2. Bag is somewhat compact, while something like the full-size Tortuga pack will likely hold more. However, these pack better, zippers are great (never had an issue), sides aren't floppy and backpack straps are more appropriate for what this is. Different entry points are nice when you're on the go. You do have to be careful with any pack that includes a laptop sleeve. Pack smartly, put your cords and chargers in the front of the pack so your soft clothes are against the laptop. I just got back from a 2-week trip to a warmer climate and had no issue fitting everything. Clothes for the trip, running clothes and such, sandals, laptop and associated work essentials, camera, binoculars, hats, etc. A lot of stuff and it packed just fine. Was full, but all good and fit into overhead bins just fine. If I primarily just packed clothes for hanging out, this would be super easy. But if you're more active and need gear, it can get tight. Throw in some diving / snorkeling equipment and you'll like need more capacity. Considering the Peak Travel Duffel Backpack for a checkable option, and for trips where I just need to bring more 'gear.' Good to get differing opinions. Cheers.
I have had the 45L bag for years now. Is it a perfect bag? My answer is no, but this is very subjective. There is one issue I do agree with and that is the sternum strap. I’ve lost a number of them and while getting them replaced is easy, you must pay for them. Not so easy. However, this is the only thing in this video that has merit. The PD travel backpack is not meant to be an “outdoors” backpack. It is also not built to hold 50lbs of stuff. No airline will allow you to carry on a bag with 50lbs of stuff. If you want to carry 50lbs on your back, you need a much more structured pack that will balance the load. He is entitled to his opinion, of course. Most people who have the bag love it.
Thanks Chris, nice review! I have several travel and photo backpacks and still have not found the "One". I am looking at Peak Design at the moment. As I already have the EveryDay slings in 3l and 6l size, I know that Peak Design is on the small side for stuffing things. Currently I am looking at the Everyday 30l backpack and the 45l travel backpack. I will be combining with a trolley, so the 30l is maybe a better option. Greets from Berlin!
Hey Martin, I think its worth a shot - I didn't love this bag but a lot of people do. Are you a photographer? If so, this may be a good fit. If you're just using it for travel you may want to consider looking at a Mystery Ranch or something more apt to PACKING it in!
@@ComputerStuff thanks, I am a vlogger and videographer with a heap load of kit ; ) and I am also looking at the Gomatic Peter McKinnon Daypack right now. Choices are not easy!
Ok, I'll go along with the 'comedy' review of this backpack because otherwise I'd feel I had to take your review seriously. There are always advantages & disadvantages to clamshell designs but I like the depth that the one compartment design affords. It suits my needs & how I like to pack. And whether you want to say 'comedy' review or nit-picker review, I'll leave to you but I do have one practical suggestion for you, get your wife to do your packing 😉
I've been going back and forth between this bag and the Tortuga Outbreaker 45L. It's incredibly useful to find a *critical* review and not just neutral and/or glowing ones. Thank you! Do you have any familiarity with the Tortuga? I wonder how many of your nitpicks it might solve...
I’m also not fond of the clamshell style where the laptop can potentially slide out of that lid. I finally got TSA pre-check so now I shouldn’t have to open my bag up wide now. Fortunately, I only had to do that once.
Have the PD backpack and a few other PD bags but don't have the travel bags yet. It's $90 off right now so trying to convince myself to get it.. Lol. Thanks for the review!
Dude, I loved the story about the hidden cocaine pocket and the escape of the Mexican Cartel :) Bigs thumbs up for me for me ....I dont need such a big bag and sometimes yes too much features can be overkill... For my next 1 or 2 week travels trip, i will try to travel with my new 25L ( venture safe X24...) but i am not sure it is a real 24L seems much smaller ...I also got a foldable backpack from Osprey for everyday commute. Also i am not a photographer so ... PS : will look into the Osprey 30l you mentionned since it seems to be able to pack so much.
Getting to this video right now. It was posted 2y ago. So, in this timeframe, which other backpack you got? Genuinely curious, because I’m about to buy a new backpack and I like to hear from the other side. Thanks.
Looks pretty rugged. I may have to check that out and do a review on it!
Год назад
Nice video. But Chris, I think the Travel Duffel 35L from Peak Design might beat the Patagonia-it is not a black hole, specially using the packing cubes.
I had one of their Travel Duffels (I think we did a review on it?). It's a solid bag and looks amazing - but I still think Patagonia is more functional. That said, to each their own! Thanks for commenting and watching!
Could the Peak Design Travel Bag 45L hold a 17.3" ultrawide laptop (0.71 x 16.18 x 9.06 inches) + a 15.6" external monitor (standard 16:9 aspect ratio) + a 11" tablet? All three items together?
I bet you bought this with your money. So the review is really honest. All the videos when dudes got this for free to review is 100% amazement. 45L is to big for me, although I'm looking at new 30L (which is actually 27L), cause I got their cubes already. And I'm kinda skeptical. Also love the jokes. So subbed for more ;). I guess closing this back opening is the same issue with every photo related backpack. Got the same issue with my Manfrotto. Although PD backpacks with cubes seem to be better idea than these 100% photography backpacks.
Yea after 17mins --- you just really need a larger backpack. Not trying to say this is a bad review, but it feels like most of the problems you mentioned came from the fact for your need this backpack gets stuffed too hard. (I mean sunglasses pouch never work with a stuffed bag unless it's hardshell, which cut into internal volume even when not used)
Bro, you sound so annoyed! (especially at 1.5x!). I say get rid of it and make your life better so you don't have to be annoyed by it. Design looks good for me and I like the rear open (clamshell) for photo gear, makes things very easy (I have a bunch of their other stuff). I think your wife will be happier when you get rid of the bag because you'll be happier! Happy travels!
The straps don't look comfortable. The bag is to heavy. The bag is to expensive. If they update the bag make the straps more comfortable shave off half the weight and shave 35% off the price it might be worth buying. They can get rid of one of the side access panels. And sell a lefty and righty version.
Agree with most of what you're saying, haha. A lefty and righty version may stand to muddy their supply chain a bit, but removing a side access panel (or both) maybe isn't a bad idea. In looking back, I can't recall how many times if ever, I used them.
You are not a bag person. You are a simple traveler. Get your wide mouth duffle bag and throw your stuff in it. This bag is meant for people that appreciate bag technology.
I did not. And for that matter I wouldn't say I'm against clamshell designs entirely, but the implementation on this bag... meh... Great question, though.
I have this bag and two other PD bags. I don’t have many complaints about this bag but I have come to hate their bags. They are make the most clever bags but also very uncomfortable and often unpractical.
Sorry, but I do not think I can agree with you on one major aspect. Clam shell opening is the best think which can happen to a travel backpack. This is certainly not a hiking backpack with a top opening. as regards to your observation about laptop compartment, the point was not clearly understood. Where would you like the laptop to be adjusted? If it is in the main section, i.e. touching your back, it may hurt your back and eat up the space of main section. The same basic design considerations are generally being followed by all companies with minor modifications.
What i don't like about this pack is the back padding (not existing almost) and very thin straps. Osprey 40 litter FairPoint new version is way better than this. They have the airflow system and better straps. Also i think you will definitely fit more in it. I agree that as far as design Peek is winning but everything else not.
Can I have your Peak Design Backpack if you're getting rid of it? Hahaha I love your review btw, very honest and critical about pieces that could use improvement
Hopefully they make 50-55L as the 45L is a bit small. Literally said it’s a ‘Travel’ backpack. However, another concern about 50-55L is a matter of TSA friendly. Great review. Liked and subbed!
Patagonia Black Hole! fave.co/3AaQvmy Been very happy with using it as a one pack traveler. That said it doesn't have conveniences like the PD such as a water bottle holder. You'll have to throw your water bottle into the main compartment and fish it out if you want a drink. That doesn't bother me though, and in some ways I prefer it. (water bottle always fell out of the water bottle pocket).
In reality, there is no perfect bag overall. You can find faults to any bag period. There are however great bags and despite what the overly critical guy said on this video PD is a great bag. The end.
No, you're not crazy. After using certain travel bags or luggage, I find deal breakers and not as happy traveling with it. I am in that process now watching different reviews and did not care much for Peak, not my style.
You can't open it from the front no, only the "rear main zip" and side zips. I suppose you could lay it on its back and open it that way but that'd be even worse!
@@ComputerStuff Yes. You can open it from the front. You have to open the the outside zipper at the front first. Then there's another zipper inside that opens to the main compartment. I'm not sure how your didn't notice that.
@@jexler5 The hidden zip? Yes true this does exist but it's not a quick or practical access for packing. But yes its there if you need access to an item that you know for sure is sitting at that item.
Thanks for your honesty opinion man. I was going to get one but something about it seemed not right. After seeing your video now I know why. Plus it's 5byeaes old?? I'll wair for an update. Incidentally I'm leaning g towards the Patagonia MLC Tres version. Only thing missing is the water bottle holders. Or the Peak Designs 45L (unzips to 65L) Tavel duffel. Looks more basic and also no water bottle holders. Have you tried this one?
I have tried PDs duffel and prefer Patagonia's Black Hole duffel - fave.co/3AaQvmy The lack of water bottle holder doesn't bother me, and in some ways I prefer beacuse my bottle always fell out of the dedicated pocket. PD's duffel is a fine bag and may be preferred by some, but I prefer Patagonia's simplicity and durability. The PD bag just has too many zipper and pockets and "things" you have to fuss with. Black Hole is WYSIWYG! Patagonia can be converted into a backpack as well, and you truly can stash your entire house in the thing. I think one could enjoy either or!
![Peak Design Travel Backpack Review [The only review you'll ever need!]](/img/1.gif)
I’ve been working almost every weekend in another city for the last 2 years, and 1,5 years with this bag. I do see where this review stems from, but I’m still very happy with my bag. Three reasons: #1 at the end of the day, every bag is a compromise. I have bags which are more comfortable and lighter, but they don’t protect my gear and are definitely not stovable. Get some lose some. In my use this really ticks all of the boxes, and is good compromise. #2 It does not like to be over packed. Once you accept this, it’s a lot more comfortable. #3 When you travel a lot, organization is everything. It just makes leaving the house a breeze. And with the small camera cube, my camera is always accessible.
Glad you like the bag! To each their own!
This is the first time I've seen a review actually critical of a bag after some real world use. In a landscape of youtubers that seem to use the bag once or twice over the course of two weeks and basically are making an ad for it, this is very refreshing.
Thanks for the nice comment! We try really hard here to give non-BS reviews!
I've had this bag for a few years and love all the features. I agree with the strap comfort annoyance that is mitigated with the waist strap. Love the security features (check the peak design video on that). I'm not using it as a camera or computer bag so my loads are lighter. Love the materials and features.
I can see why people would bail on this bag though. More soft padding on the shoulder straps would solve 90% of my issues.
Raw weight is on the heavy side; 4.5 lbs.
I admit I do like the materials of the bag. They feel good.
In a year you’re gonna make a video on how you miss the clamshell design because any other design makes it so difficult to find things.
Quite possibly!
I watched another video video, where they said, that this backpack packs surprisingly little compared to the liters declared in comparison to an Osprey. So I ordered both for comparison, this one here and an Osprey Transporter Carry-On 44 for direct comparison before making my decision and I couldn‘t disagree more.
This PeakDesign Travel Backpack 45 packs quite a bit more than the mentioned Osprey, I tried with the exact same things. Not sure, how everyone comes to the conclusion, that this backpack here is comparatively underwhelming in packing space, as from my impression it‘s the other way around?
They are probably unorganised or not good packers bluntly.
Your video review was a much-needed reality check, preventing me from falling into the same pitfalls I experienced with the Aer Travel Pack (33l). Your shared frustrations about limited space and excessive compartmentalization echoed my own sentiments. Despite owning it for an extended period, I found its complex design, limited size and bulky feel when full led to infrequent use.
Having recently tried a 60l duffle-style backpack, I contemplated a return to a more organized and well designed, but bigger, travel bag like the Peak Design. However, your review served as a clear reminder for me of the efficiency of the duffle style with pack cubes, offering ample space and airline carry-on compliance. Thanks to your insights, I've decided to stick with the practicality of my current duffle bag setup.
Thanks for the wonderful comment Richard! Best of luck on your travels!
If you're always on the move travelling, this is the best backpack. This bag made my 3 week Japan trip a breeze. No annoying luggage to pull around, stylish and small enough not to get mistaken for a mountaineer. Space for a camera, clothes for a week and some essentials.
Glad to hear you like it!
Thanks for this review. Really like seeing critical stuff as well in this day and age of "everything's awesome". I'm considering on buying this PD 45L and even after this video I'm considering it still 😅 I think the annoyances you mentioned are things I can live with. Also I actually like the concept of the clamshell mechanism and I've had (cheapo) backbags with laptops against my back without any issue so I think my laptops going to be okay there.
Thanks for responding Ari. Enjoy the bag! It should hold up well for you!
So after using the bag for YEARS you finally decide to get rid of it because there are things that annoy you? -___- I’ll be honest, for the amount of travel bags I owe this is the best one. You’re entitled to your opinions but there is way too much nitpicking here. Saying you don’t like that the bag gives off a perception that it’s full? Or saying you have a hard time closing it when it’s full? Huh. Then saying you’re scared your laptop would break in the sleeve? Lmao how many laptops broke in the bag? 0. Not sure what’s the issue here. I’m gonna pass on this review.
You can pass all you want but you still watched it and I appreciate you for it!
I’ve taken the everyday backpack in week trips. Yea the straps aren’t the most comfortable, but they are durable as heck! The materials made from these are head over heals better than any Osprey (and I own 3 Ospreys - 1 of which I take on multi week trips to Europe). You’re review doesn’t scare me in the slightest. I’m purchasing this bag. The engineering and quality alone with PD spare no expense. Stop posting videos that oppose the normal perception of these bags just to get views lol. And stop not picking. You’ll never find a perfect bag.
lmao this is the weirdest comment section ever, like why bother commenting ???
is this good for 17inch laptop , keyboard , then all cloths
is there spong so laptop doesnt broke while carrying it
You have side and front access if you choose. Also, the packing cubes (camera and clothes) are game changers here.
Could not agree more... and why I got this bag, along with the 35L duffle. The ability to move the packing/camera cubes between them with total ease. I'm going to grab the 65L on sale as a checked bag for cloths (never camera gear). The clamshell abilities are also more for photographers... you set the bag down to access and not put the side down that goes against your back. I love my travel backpack.
The packing cubes help and are game changers in almost any bag! I maintain my gripes, though. I simply don't miss this bag!
I think PD assumes photographers are the ones buying their bags, haha.
Great review, thank you! You said a ton of complimentary things about the bag, but I really appreciate when reviews include the nitpicks too.
Thanks Bellaluce! Glad you enjoyed the video!
I appreciate the critical review. As someone who is an amateur backpack enthusiast not every backpack feature is rainbows and sunshine., but no one ever complains about its flaws!
Thanks for the nice comment! Appreciate you watching!
Love this review, good sense of humor! I just got the bag and am anxious to try it out. It seems to get the best overall reviews.
Really appreciate the nice comment! Enjoy the bag!
I love negative/low points or cons as it gives the deal breakers in a nutshell. Def honest by a guy who’s actually used it extensively. Dont like laptop in top its just not ergonomic for instance. Thanks!
Thanks for the nice comment!
Humorous and insightful. Thank you. At the end of the day, your review and annoyances remind me of the Piña Colada song. The bag’s become “Like a worn out recording of a favorite song.” Interested in what you finally landed on as a replacement.
Thank you! My replacement is quite a boring one, but it's working for my needs. A classic Patagonia Duffel, haha. We'll be reviewing some more 1 bag carry bags here soon though!
Thank you for this review. I agree with your comments on the straps and the storage. I wouldn't use this backpack for hiking. I have the Nya-Evo Fjord 36C that is excellent for that, but I want something slimmer for carry-on on smaller aircraft. I will put the small camera cube in it and fold down the organizer panel in the front so that I can have front access to the contents of the bag. The Nya-Evo is very fabulous in that regard as it has rear-access for the camera only and top access to the rest of the bag. But it is super bulky, 8cm more in depth than the PD, so I will give that one a try as a second option :-)
Thanks for commenting!
I load from the other side (non laptop side) by tucking away the middle divider in the bottom compartment. Works well.
Excellent!
Finally an honest review of this backpack on RUclips not biased with sponsorship!
That's our shtick ;)
Appreciate the review! I agree with you, but I ended up buying this bag anyway because I realized there's no bag that exists today that fits all of my nitpicking requests 😂After all my research it was between this and the Tortuga lite bag. I almost picked the Tortuga, but ended up going with the PD simply because it had more pockets, a couple of secret compartments, and the magnetic waist belt design is quite innovative. Some things that irritate me about the PD bag:
- 2 water bottle holders, which probably got calculated into the liters (I don't even need one water bottle holder most of the time)!
- The misalignment of the handles, and the "duffle" bag handle on the back is terrible, so I can't really use this as a duffle
- of course the straps aren't too good
- the compression idea is awesome, but the buttons keep unbuttoning even when there's practically nothing in the bag. I think they could have been a bit more creative than a button, maybe adding some sort of clamp so it doesn't keep de-compressing. I'd prefer to put this thing under the seat if I could.
- zippers ... no idea why they didn't use YKK
- The main compartment digs into the second compartment. I don't feel like this is an issue with a Tumi bag I have. Can't really explain why but they definitely conflate with each other a bit too much for my tastes.
Everything else is pretty awesome and beats almost all the other bags out there. I mostly ended up buying it because I got it for ~$235. So ~$65 (20%) off had me sold and it was cheap enough that if I didn't want it after my next trip I can always swap it for a bit of a loss. Not the end of the world.
Great comment!
Love this review. It is exactly what I need when trying to buy something expensive
Glad it was helpful!
which one you recommend? cocane part best !!!
1. Sounds like you’ve just been overpacking it. They’re not compression zippers.
2. Same with the laptop complaint. Don’t overpack the bag. Have clothes? Use their compression bags to keep the size down. And like you say, your laptop never got damaged. So it’s fine.
3. Yes, the strap thing is just nitpicking. Most bags don’t even allow you to stow the straps. Be glad there’s at least the option.
4. The thin straps thing is subjective I guess. They shoulder straps have always felt very comfortable to me.
5. Sternum strap. I’ve used peak design bags for the last 5 and a little bit years, and they’ve all used that same sternum strap system. I haven’t every lost it. Might be a manufacturing defect if yours falls off easily.
6. How do you know how Peak Design measures the internal volume of their bags? That’s not really based on anything, is it?
Every bag is a tradeoff, and I’ve yet to see another bag that beats the Peak Design one. WANDRD gets close I think, but I still think it loses to the Peak Design. Keep in mind, these are CAMERA bags. At one point you compared it to some other bag where you said you could pack way more into it than the rating, but that's really not a fair comparison.
1: Respectfully, I don't feel like I "overpacked" this bag.
2: I use compression bags. I'm still disappointed with the "layout" of the bag.
3: Nitpicking is the name of the game on this channel! It's how we can IMPROVE products! :)
4: Glad you like them! It certainly is a preference thing.
5: It's possible!
6: I can guarantee you, most manufacturers, including PD, do not use any kind of scientific metrics for measuring their volume. That said if a representative of PD would like to weight in on how they do it, I'd love to be proven wrong.
I appreciate you commenting and watching and it's great that you like and have had a good experience with this bag. A lot of people love them, but I think there are better options out there - at least for my uses and possibly other peoples.
This is the funniest thing I've watched in a long time
Thank you! Appreciate the nice comment!
Thank you so much for your “nitpicky” review! I love this type of review, because this is where you learn how it really feels and functions or gets caught on things, etc. My next thought is let’s get a woman who has at least a D cup try these things on too! Please!!
LOL - I can't help with that one, sorry. But an interesting perspective for women (I didn't think of). Thanks for the nice commend Debby!
I completely understand this review. I reach for my Pakt travel backpack 9 out of 10 over this PD 45L.
Pakt looks like a solid bag. Maybe I'll have to get my hands on one.
Pakt Travel Bag? Im trying to decide between this PD and Pakt (35L or 45L with a 15L). I like both. You have both? Pls tell more.
A bit late but anyway. Good and informative video! I'm looking into this bag as a bigger photo and travel/camping backpack. I own the 20l everyday backpack and love it but it's a bit too small for travel or camping.
I noticed one thing tho, when you talked and demonstrated about the sternum strap, you hooked the wrong end of the strap. The one without the little pulltab is the one you install semi-permanently, and the one with the tab is the one you attach and re-attach on an everyday basis. You took it of in the right end but the semi-permanent end doesn't look like it's properly attached. I have the same sternum strap for my everyday backpack 20l and i have never experienced the issue you're mentioning.
But as said, overall a good and informative video! Cheers!
I agree with all the positives and negatives this bag has brought out of people. Personally, the bag would be the #1 all-time bag with a better shoulder strap and hip belt, but that's just me. The ability to tuck away the carry system is a concept that has been introduced previously. I had a pack back in the late 90s that did the same thing, and it did just as well with zippers vs magnets. AND it could be accomplished again with a better carry system.
PD selling the 45L as a camera bag needs to be revised. The ability to put a camera cube in a backpack doesn’t make it a camera backpack. Yes, the camera cubes are excellent, and attaching them in PD packs is a fantastic option for lugging your equipment around. I invested in my PD camera cubes long before I purchased the Traveler 45L pack for that reason, and to this day use them in luggage and now in my F-Stop Shinn backpack.
However, the one thing PD didn’t consider before they started pushing the Traveler 45L as a photographer backpack alternative was the convenience most, if not all, camera backpacks offer, and that is storage for accessories. Anyone looking to use this bag as a full-time camera pack must know that all zippered storage areas are in the front of the bag. Meaning if you are inside the bag pulling out camera equipment (from the back) and suddenly remember that that specific Arca plate you need or camera battery is in the zippered compartment up front, you have to close the clamshell, turn the bag around, unzip the front, and find the zippered pouch you stored it in. ALL UP FRONT. With all that said, the workflow for the bag as a camera bag is horrible. If you carry a camera body and maybe two small prime lenses, then you have plenty of room in the camera cube to store what-nots. But if you are using the bag to carry that, I question why you are hauling around the Traveler 45L in the first place.
BTW, with all that being said, I bet Traveler 45L 2.0 will solve some of the negatives many people have pointed out. Personally, I'm keeping my bag as a traveler's bag. It works great with a medium or small cube and some packing cubes. Keep the weight down and comfort should be acceptable.
Thank you for sharing this.
My pleasure!
Its quite funny, this is like an angry review, but he is still selling it very nicely hahaha
It's what I do best!
I’ve had several travel backpacks. I also adhere to the idea of traveling with one carry on compliant bag. I only have a few things to say about your gripes. First, the laptop flap is not the only access to the main packing space. You can also access that space thru the front flap by zipping the organization panel. As far as the ‘sunglass pocket’ goes, why would you not use it to store something, i.e. wallet, keys, air pods, dongles then store your glasses in a place you feel is more secure? The storage spaces designed into a travel bag don’t have to be used for anything in particular. If it fits there the way you want it to then put it there otherwise find another space. So, after 6 years you’ve decided to use another bag. Which you’ll undoubtedly find issues with. I’m curious what your choice is?
I've been using a Patagonia Blackhole for my 1 bag travel. For my needs it does everything I need it to do.
@@ComputerStuff That’s a great bag. I’ve got a 32. When I don’t need organization it’s my ‘go to’. I get your point. I can’t use the same bag for every situation. I’m trying to have the ‘perfect’ bag depending on what I’m using it for. The Peak 45 definitely isn’t a do-it-all solution but I do use it 75% of the time. My biggest gripe ( yeah, I have one, ha) is the weight. I’m still searching for the perfect combo of durability, weight, comfort, organization, aesthetic. I am finding that 32-35 liters capacity, whatever that is, seems to fit 99% of my needs. I enjoyed your video 👍🏾 nuthin wrong with stirring the pot skittle, ha
@@ricardomontes6309 Haha, thanks Ricardo!
@@ComputerStuff Are you able to fit that as a carry-on? It's quite large.
The strap wings fold in. For my use cases, it is perfect. I can't see how any of your nits are worth bailing on the backpack. You may need a dump purse instead.
OMG, this is my favorite review of all time. Oh, you are such a riot. Thank you for your sassy tude.
Glad you enjoyed it!
I enjoyed this video, thanks for it. Torn between this, the Wandrd Prvke 41, and maybe a few others I seem to have crossed off the list, but am not totally sure yet.
1. Have you used the Wandrd Prvke?
2. Fun review, but what I loved was reading your responses to the comments here. I read them all. Hats off to you for staying so calm, friendly, and unfazed in the face of the kind of ridiculous insults and trolling that inevitably come when you simply take the time to share your own opinions on something you've used for years. I may still get this bag, but am really stoked I got to hear your opinions after all this time.
THanks for what you do, subbed!
1: I haven't yet. I'll see if I can get my hands on one.
2: Really appreciate the nice response here. Glad we could help David. Never trying to yuck anyone's yum on this channel, just trying to give my feedback without all the smoke and mirrors other RUclipsrs use. I hope you enjoy the bag if you get it!
I got it for the cocaine zippered pocket
Hell yeah.
I’ve never once thought my laptop or iPad was at risk in the laptop section, or have ever lost the sternum strap. And my bag has never been “floppy” when packing.
Yes, the shoulder straps suck - though better than their Everyday Backpack IMHO.
Thank you for sharing.
Informative and funny review! Thanks! The lack of comfort in the shoulder straps will be the dealbreaker for me.
Thanks for watching!
Great review, thanks!
Thanks Aprenda!
I've owned 4 different peak design backpacks that all use the same sternum strap and I've never lost one. Tens of thousands of miles in travel, 0 lost sternum straps. Not sure if you're unlucky or i'm the opposite - but i've never had a problem.
I walk under ladders a lot :(
@@ComputerStuff i almost finished your video, but i see that your strap is upside down. it might be the reason why you keep losing them? And you should only remove the side with the little flap attached to it.
@@DevranUenal Thanks for watching Devran. I dont believe that's the reason but I'm willing to concede if it is!
Spent some time looking at the PD videos on this bag and I just kept wondering "ok but what's wrong with it?"
Thanks for criticizing it, and I'm glad you nitpick so I can consider what I can and can't live with. Might have to try those straps IRL before paying a lot of money.
How many years have you had it? How heavily did you use it? How well did it re-sell? It still looks in good condition.
Had it a couple years. Used it pretty heavily (I travel frequently). Resold easily but for a 25% hit or so. It held up well.
What did u switch to?
What are your thoughts with upcoming Pakt, WANDRD carryall, Aplaka elements?? This PD was in my top 3....you make good points!
Have a look at the Tortuga 40L backpack! Might solve your issues.
I have demo'd some Tortuga's yes. I liked 'em.
Realize this is a little older, but an interesting point of view. I've had mine for a while and aside from your complaint about potentially losing the sternum strap, don't really agree with your assessment. I find the straps to be fine, and this holds a ton of stuff. However, people should realize it's really only 35 liters until you use the expansion zippers. Even then, is it really 45 liters? The expansion is a little hard to take full advantage of, but has been fine for me. I like the general layout, as it's similar to the Goruck GR2. Bag is somewhat compact, while something like the full-size Tortuga pack will likely hold more. However, these pack better, zippers are great (never had an issue), sides aren't floppy and backpack straps are more appropriate for what this is. Different entry points are nice when you're on the go.
You do have to be careful with any pack that includes a laptop sleeve. Pack smartly, put your cords and chargers in the front of the pack so your soft clothes are against the laptop. I just got back from a 2-week trip to a warmer climate and had no issue fitting everything. Clothes for the trip, running clothes and such, sandals, laptop and associated work essentials, camera, binoculars, hats, etc. A lot of stuff and it packed just fine. Was full, but all good and fit into overhead bins just fine.
If I primarily just packed clothes for hanging out, this would be super easy. But if you're more active and need gear, it can get tight. Throw in some diving / snorkeling equipment and you'll like need more capacity. Considering the Peak Travel Duffel Backpack for a checkable option, and for trips where I just need to bring more 'gear.' Good to get differing opinions. Cheers.
I have had the 45L bag for years now. Is it a perfect bag? My answer is no, but this is very subjective. There is one issue I do agree with and that is the sternum strap. I’ve lost a number of them and while getting them replaced is easy, you must pay for them. Not so easy.
However, this is the only thing in this video that has merit. The PD travel backpack is not meant to be an “outdoors” backpack. It is also not built to hold 50lbs of stuff. No airline will allow you to carry on a bag with 50lbs of stuff. If you want to carry 50lbs on your back, you need a much more structured pack that will balance the load.
He is entitled to his opinion, of course. Most people who have the bag love it.
This bag is designed for either photography travel, or one pack travel. One has to assume it will end up heavy - and it does.
Thanks Chris, nice review! I have several travel and photo backpacks and still have not found the "One". I am looking at Peak Design at the moment. As I already have the EveryDay slings in 3l and 6l size, I know that Peak Design is on the small side for stuffing things. Currently I am looking at the Everyday 30l backpack and the 45l travel backpack. I will be combining with a trolley, so the 30l is maybe a better option. Greets from Berlin!
Hey Martin, I think its worth a shot - I didn't love this bag but a lot of people do. Are you a photographer? If so, this may be a good fit. If you're just using it for travel you may want to consider looking at a Mystery Ranch or something more apt to PACKING it in!
@@ComputerStuff thanks, I am a vlogger and videographer with a heap load of kit ; ) and I am also looking at the Gomatic Peter McKinnon Daypack right now. Choices are not easy!
which one can you recommend? thank you for review love it, cocane part was awesome
What kind of bag are you looking for? A one bag travel type thing?
Ok, I'll go along with the 'comedy' review of this backpack because otherwise I'd feel I had to take your review seriously. There are always advantages & disadvantages to clamshell designs but I like the depth that the one compartment design affords. It suits my needs & how I like to pack. And whether you want to say 'comedy' review or nit-picker review, I'll leave to you but I do have one practical suggestion for you, get your wife to do your packing 😉
I only let my mistress touch my bag….
I've been going back and forth between this bag and the Tortuga Outbreaker 45L. It's incredibly useful to find a *critical* review and not just neutral and/or glowing ones. Thank you!
Do you have any familiarity with the Tortuga? I wonder how many of your nitpicks it might solve...
I have seen them but not used one. Maybe I'll get my hands on one!
Mexican Cartel: "Where did you hide the drug?!"
Bag owner: "You'll never find it...motherf....!!!"
That's a "Breaking Bag" guys
Breaking Bag, hahaha. Love it.
I’m also not fond of the clamshell style where the laptop can potentially slide out of that lid. I finally got TSA pre-check so now I shouldn’t have to open my bag up wide now. Fortunately, I only had to do that once.
The reason why it open like that is to prevent thieves from getting into your bag while traveling in another country.
Incorrect. Peak Design does not advertise that as the design motive.
When did FRASIER CRANE start reviewing travel bags?🤣😂🤣
I'll take that as a compliment!
@@ComputerStuff Glad to know you have a sense of humor...
Have the PD backpack and a few other PD bags but don't have the travel bags yet. It's $90 off right now so trying to convince myself to get it.. Lol. Thanks for the review!
Any time! Happy to sell you mine, haha
Dude, I loved the story about the hidden cocaine pocket and the escape of the Mexican Cartel :)
Bigs thumbs up for me for me ....I dont need such a big bag and sometimes yes too much features can be overkill...
For my next 1 or 2 week travels trip, i will try to travel with my new 25L ( venture safe X24...) but i am not sure it is a real 24L seems much smaller ...I also got a foldable backpack from Osprey for everyday commute.
Also i am not a photographer so ...
PS : will look into the Osprey 30l you mentionned since it seems to be able to pack so much.
Thanks for watching, Joe! Hard to go wrong with Osprey products! Good luck with your future travels.
Haha I love this review. Just got the bag and first impression is awesome. But good with a bit of a reality check :-)
All the best Ludvig, enjoy the bag!
Are you happy with the Patagonia Black Whole
I wonder whether you can buy sternum strap if you lose it. Without it the bag with all its cool features wouldn't make much sense to me
I'm sure you can get a replacement for them, yes.
So did you replace this with another carry on backpack? If so which one? Thanks!
I replaced with a Patagonia duffel. Happier overall with that choice but we're about to review a Mystery Ranch backpack.
Getting to this video right now. It was posted 2y ago. So, in this timeframe, which other backpack you got? Genuinely curious, because I’m about to buy a new backpack and I like to hear from the other side. Thanks.
Mystery Ranch 3 Day Assault has been my daily carry / travel bag recently.
I got a Tom Bihn techonaut 30 and never looked back.
Looks pretty rugged. I may have to check that out and do a review on it!
Nice video. But Chris, I think the Travel Duffel 35L from Peak Design might beat the Patagonia-it is not a black hole, specially using the packing cubes.
I had one of their Travel Duffels (I think we did a review on it?). It's a solid bag and looks amazing - but I still think Patagonia is more functional. That said, to each their own! Thanks for commenting and watching!
Dude this video is so good! Like honestly I could watch it over and over again. Your channel is going to do great!
That's great praise, I really appreciate the awesome comment, Seth.
Can it pass spirit personal bag check if not packed all the way?
Yes
Could the Peak Design Travel Bag 45L hold a 17.3" ultrawide laptop (0.71 x 16.18 x 9.06 inches) + a 15.6" external monitor (standard 16:9 aspect ratio) + a 11" tablet? All three items together?
That's a tall order.
I bet you bought this with your money. So the review is really honest. All the videos when dudes got this for free to review is 100% amazement. 45L is to big for me, although I'm looking at new 30L (which is actually 27L), cause I got their cubes already. And I'm kinda skeptical.
Also love the jokes. So subbed for more ;).
I guess closing this back opening is the same issue with every photo related backpack. Got the same issue with my Manfrotto. Although PD backpacks with cubes seem to be better idea than these 100% photography backpacks.
Thanks for the nice comment! We purchase all the things we review just so there is full transparency!
@@sondretusvik9135 👍🏻
uh, magnets do NOT wear out over time. that is physics
There are a few factors including heat and being banged around, both things a bag is subject to, that can cause a magnet to weaken.
After watching first 7 mins of your review.... I only learned one thing: YOU NEED A BIGGER BAG.
Yea after 17mins --- you just really need a larger backpack. Not trying to say this is a bad review, but it feels like most of the problems you mentioned came from the fact for your need this backpack gets stuffed too hard. (I mean sunglasses pouch never work with a stuffed bag unless it's hardshell, which cut into internal volume even when not used)
Haha. I ended up going with an Osprey Duffel as main travel.
Appreciate you watching and commenting Derek.
What bag are you using for travel Any thoughts on Mindshift gear
I've been using a Patagonia duffel with pretty solid success. I haven't heard of them before but I'll check our their stuff!
Bro, you sound so annoyed! (especially at 1.5x!). I say get rid of it and make your life better so you don't have to be annoyed by it. Design looks good for me and I like the rear open (clamshell) for photo gear, makes things very easy (I have a bunch of their other stuff). I think your wife will be happier when you get rid of the bag because you'll be happier! Happy travels!
If you thought 1.5 is bad... try 1.75! Safe travels to you as well!
Can you please review everything I'm interested in purchasing? This was great!
Haha, I'll do my best! Thanks Marshall!
Hi. Can this backpack be taken as hand luggage on international airlines like Turkish airlines?
yes it can!
Forget that. They make a great duffel
Not a fan.
When using the waist strap does that mitigate the poor shoulder straps - too thin and cutting into your shoulders?
Yes, by a lot! Waist straps are a savior on a lot of packs!
Great video! Which travel bag are you using now?
In Vegas currently and using a Patagonia 55L duffel and a Mystery Ranch briefcase. But going to test some new bags here soon!
The straps don't look comfortable. The bag is to heavy.
The bag is to expensive.
If they update the bag make the straps more comfortable shave off half the weight and shave 35% off the price it might be worth buying. They can get rid of one of the side access panels. And sell a lefty and righty version.
Agree with most of what you're saying, haha. A lefty and righty version may stand to muddy their supply chain a bit, but removing a side access panel (or both) maybe isn't a bad idea. In looking back, I can't recall how many times if ever, I used them.
You are not a bag person. You are a simple traveler. Get your wide mouth duffle bag and throw your stuff in it. This bag is meant for people that appreciate bag technology.
lol
What did you end up replacing it with?
GoRuck GR2 34L and a Patagonia 55L Black Hole (depending on length of trip).
when its on 45l capacity, can it still pass as carry on without being question at the door for being too big for carry on?
I never had an issue using as carry on!
Did you know that you don't like clamshell designs when you bought this one?
I did not. And for that matter I wouldn't say I'm against clamshell designs entirely, but the implementation on this bag... meh... Great question, though.
I have this bag and two other PD bags. I don’t have many complaints about this bag but I have come to hate their bags. They are make the most clever bags but also very uncomfortable and often unpractical.
Thanks for commenting!
as a traveler what would you recommend for a 45l backpack carry on ?
What budget are you trying to stick within?
@@ComputerStuff 350 $ would be an average.
@@adv67 Have you considered going with a duffel style pack such as Patagonia or do you want backpack specifically?
@@ComputerStuff will the duffle bag be considered as a carry-on ?
@@adv67 Yes. I use a 55L blackhole as carry on almost every time I fly now with 0 issues including on budget airlines like Southwest or Spirit.
Sorry, but I do not think I can agree with you on one major aspect. Clam shell opening is the best think which can happen to a travel backpack. This is certainly not a hiking backpack with a top opening. as regards to your observation about laptop compartment, the point was not clearly understood. Where would you like the laptop to be adjusted? If it is in the main section, i.e. touching your back, it may hurt your back and eat up the space of main section. The same basic design considerations are generally being followed by all companies with minor modifications.
What alternative backpack then?
I've been using a Topo Mountain pack for my "one bag carry" and love it. Here's our review: ruclips.net/video/ZUnQk5YKZeM/видео.html
What i don't like about this pack is the back padding (not existing almost) and very thin straps. Osprey 40 litter FairPoint new version is way better than this. They have the airflow system and better straps. Also i think you will definitely fit more in it. I agree that as far as design Peek is winning but everything else not.
Can I have your Peak Design Backpack if you're getting rid of it? Hahaha I love your review btw, very honest and critical about pieces that could use improvement
Haha, thank you! Sorry to report but we've already parted ways with it! :(
@@ComputerStuff Haha aww no worries!! Thank you anyways :D
Hopefully they make 50-55L as the 45L is a bit small. Literally said it’s a ‘Travel’ backpack.
However, another concern about 50-55L is a matter of TSA friendly.
Great review.
Liked and subbed!
So…basically defeating the entire purpose of being a travel backpack
If you need more space, Peak Design makes a 65L DuffelPack with backpack straps that is actually less expensive.
So what bag do you use now?
Patagonia Black Hole! fave.co/3AaQvmy Been very happy with using it as a one pack traveler. That said it doesn't have conveniences like the PD such as a water bottle holder. You'll have to throw your water bottle into the main compartment and fish it out if you want a drink. That doesn't bother me though, and in some ways I prefer it. (water bottle always fell out of the water bottle pocket).
@@ComputerStuff good of you to reply :)
Holy cannoli. Thanks for the review, but you might want to try meth light. I learned to keep up with your pace by the end.
Haha, thanks for watching. No problem just watch the video a second time ;).
Try putting 70% of the bag weight on the hip belt.
In reality, there is no perfect bag overall. You can find faults to any bag period. There are however great bags and despite what the overly critical guy said on this video PD is a great bag. The end.
Right? The guy in this video is a real piece of work!
No, you're not crazy. After using certain travel bags or luggage, I find deal breakers and not as happy traveling with it. I am in that process now watching different reviews and did not care much for Peak, not my style.
Thanks for sharing!!
I'll buy it from it! ;p
Hah. Sorry, it's long gone, otherwise I'd give it to you!
@@ComputerStuff 😭😭😭😭😭
Thank you, sir!
I’d be happy to take it off your hands if you don’t want it anymore 😊
Hah! Sorry mate, we already got rid of the bag
Do shoulder shrugs. Problem solved. I love my bag..
To each their own!
@@ComputerStuff yep 😂😂
You didn’t mention that you could probably sell it for 80% of what you paid for it… even after 5 years 😉
True. And I did ;) haha
I like the option for a clam opening, but a different way to get in it so I don't have to open the whole thing every time
You may like Mystery Ranch's 3 way zip system then!
Can’t you open it from the front instead of awkward laptop clamshell? Does this help? Thanks for helpful video.
You can't open it from the front no, only the "rear main zip" and side zips. I suppose you could lay it on its back and open it that way but that'd be even worse!
@@ComputerStuff Yes. You can open it from the front. You have to open the the outside zipper at the front first. Then there's another zipper inside that opens to the main compartment. I'm not sure how your didn't notice that.
@@jexler5 The hidden zip? Yes true this does exist but it's not a quick or practical access for packing. But yes its there if you need access to an item that you know for sure is sitting at that item.
@@ComputerStuff I feel like you need to just use the bag the way it was designed to be used. Not from the back, but from the front.
You had me at cocaine 🤣
It's Narcos up in here!
Love the channel!
Glad you enjoy it! Thanks Michael!
I could only watch so much of this hissy fit style of review 😂
That's a shame.. there are some zingers in here..
Meanwhile in another country they struggle to get water to survive and here you are complaining about your bag
Yep! First world problems!
Thanks for your honesty opinion man. I was going to get one but something about it seemed not right. After seeing your video now I know why. Plus it's 5byeaes old?? I'll wair for an update.
Incidentally I'm leaning g towards the Patagonia MLC Tres version. Only thing missing is the water bottle holders.
Or the Peak Designs 45L (unzips to 65L) Tavel duffel. Looks more basic and also no water bottle holders. Have you tried this one?
I have tried PDs duffel and prefer Patagonia's Black Hole duffel - fave.co/3AaQvmy
The lack of water bottle holder doesn't bother me, and in some ways I prefer beacuse my bottle always fell out of the dedicated pocket. PD's duffel is a fine bag and may be preferred by some, but I prefer Patagonia's simplicity and durability. The PD bag just has too many zipper and pockets and "things" you have to fuss with. Black Hole is WYSIWYG!
Patagonia can be converted into a backpack as well, and you truly can stash your entire house in the thing. I think one could enjoy either or!