OH KAILEE!!! Believe me when I said I've seen them perform this album live and I can swear to god I cried so much hearing hold it in, and I still tear up watching this reaction!! Hold it in and thank you are really the best songs out of this album!! I hope you can watch the documentary where they showcase the making of this album!
I'm a Jihoon stan but ASAHIxHARUTO performing THANK YOU in Kyocera Dome during the HELLO Tour last year holds a special spot in my heart. Seeing how ASAHI blossomed from an introvert robot predebut to the rockstar weirdo we all love, running around the stage just tugs at my heartstrings. Him screaming "OSAKA TADAIMA(I'M HOME)" always brings tears to my eyes. Hope you can check it out even off-cam! Also, we Teumes like to think that THANK YOU and YAMAI(Japanese single) are love letters for MashiDam 💔
"Hold It In" is my favorite TREASURE song - written by Choi Hyunsuk himself. Have you heard his own full version of his song? It's as amazing as his tone in Treasure's version but the lyrics is way better. I hope you get to watch it. ruclips.net/video/IHLz-m-Kh3k/видео.html&start_radio=1
Hold it in was made by hyunsuk that's why hyunsuk's voice really conveys the feelings well in this song, you should listen to the concert version too it will be more sad. Thank you for your reaction I've always love it💜
we can all agree that hold it in holds a special place in teumes' hearts. 🥺 i was dumbfounded too when i first listen to it. it's so magical and yet so sad. 🤧
hold it in my❤ thank you for my bias hyunsuk for make this sad but beautiful song😭 you must hear yamai/lovesick and orange too by asahi🥹 and their ballad song " it's okay"
Hold It In was made by Hyunsuk. The concert version is even better especially when Hyunsuk raps his part with kinda shaking voice and change the way he sings the last part of the song, it becomes more and more touching 😢
Hold it in is a song that Hyunsuk wrote before his debut, I really like the song, especially the demo version that Hyunsuk showed live, it really has a sad vibe 😭❤ Sorry if my words are strange, I'm still learning English 😁
I need to check out the demo version, I love seeing the differences between originals/guides with the official audio so thanks for letting me know! Although if it’s even sadder I’ll just be balling the whole time 🙃 and absolutely no worries, your English is great!
"Clap" was written and composed by Asahi with the help of Hyunsuk, Haruto, and Yoshi, who wrote their own rap parts. "Thank You" was once again written by Asahi and Haruto and composed by Asahi. "Hold It In" was written and composed by Hyunsuk.
Treasure is one of the few groups in kpop with a very WELL-PRODUCED discography, and self-producing at that. And the way all their voices compliment and fit each other in each song. Can't wait for your Reboot listening through!
That’s one of my favorite things and what I noticed right away! They have such a good understanding of where to place each members voice so it doesn’t sound messy or jarring at all, it always transitions and leads into the next members part so well(:
'Hold it in' during their concert ,I feel with the live band is even better, especially Junkyu's bridge. I went to my dad's house and kicked him out of his surround sound man-cave and watched the Hello at the Kyocera dome in Osaka and you can feel that bridge through out your body with the drums alone and I began to cry. One day I hope to see them here in America.
I am loving the way you react to their album. Also very happy that Thank You and Hold It In resonated so much with you. Just like what the other comments said, I feel like those two songs were lowkey dedicated to the former members of the group. They had to hold everything in while the “negotiations” with the two to stay were on-going until they decided to leave which could have happened even before it was announced. Then when them leaving got finalized, all they could do was to thank them for all the memories they have shared with them.
Thank you is a bitter sweet song. It is sad that you broke up but at the end you are still thankful for the love and for all the good memories you spent together.
..this is why i do not know why they are so underrated.. people are closing their doors to TREASURE.. they do not know how good and talented they are, and it is so so sad.. 🥺 ooohh, i can't wait with the REBOOT reaction.. 🙏
Hold It In is very special to me especially when i was in tough times. I was in a fresh break up and I had neuropathy ,so I feel so lost at that time but the song helped me somehow to cope with the situation.
You should check out thank you live especially in reboot tour. I cried seeing it live last year. Asahi is so genius he changes some melody every stop most memorable is in his hometown Osaka😭
Thank you for reacting and appreciating my boys❤. They bring smile to us. Now that you reacting to them, you also making me smile. THANK YOUU. Please react both the live of THANK YOU and HOLD IT IN from their concert it was a master piece and beautiful especially when asahi singing thank you, then shouting OSAKA TADAIMA😊
you should check out the behind the scenes of this album. It's a 2 episodes short documentary film how they wrote, produce and record the songs it called- TREASURE - ‘THE SECOND STEP : CHAPTER TWO’ DOCUMENTARY FILM
I cried when I saw and listened to THANK YOU, because ASAHI is a rockstar!! All his hardships during YGTB flashback to me. This song proves that he deserves to be in TREASURE. If you can do reaction to live performance to it and some song during HELLO Tour, I will love it
Listening to Thank You will always be having mixed feelings. The lyrics hit the hardest even more knowing that former members left the group. And this becomes more bitter-sweet especially when I heard this live during their concert 😭
the second step chapter two has to be my fave treasure album yet. the songs are so genuine and that has a lot to do with the fact that the members were so involved in the production process. they released this album during a time full of so many uncertainties with how the group's going to move forward esp since hello felt like a reintroduction for the 10 members. i'd like to think they already knew what was gonna happen and thank you and hold it in were their goodbye songs. my biases are hyunsuk, junkyu and asahi but i saw them perform live last year and the only time i almost teared up was when asahi was performing thank you. hold it in's also so special for me since it's by hyunsuk and so dear to him because he's been working on it since ygtb and that bridge gets me everytime. thanks for appreciating the boys' music and songwriting. firm believer that these boys don't wanna be seen as just idols but as actual artists.
I don't know why but Thank You is a different level of "favorite" for me when it comes to TREASURE songs. Overall I do like their discography and I have favorites, but Thank You has this power to put me into a nostalgic memory of childhood. Asahi is a really gifted writer/musician and I like how his character rasonates through the songs he created/participated with. Orange, Clap, Thank You, and Yamai all personifies Asahi's character in their sound/lyrics and it's amazing!!! I also like Yamai but moreso the Korean version because it's so poetic translated in english but what more if I can understand korean/hangul.
Oh I definitely get that. Thank You has been legitimately on repeat and probably my most listened to on this album so far. I love the instrumental especially and their vocals are just perfect for that style of music. For sure part of the music I grew up listening to and yeah I can tell I’m just going to love Asahi’s writing style and the way he specifically makes music just from the couple songs I’ve heard from him and I can’t wait to check out more 👌🏼
I really like your reaction. Please help react to the documentary about this album. They worked really hard to make these songs. The story along the way of making music has many different emotions and feelings. You will fall in love with them even more after watching their music production.
You should listen to Asahi and Haruto's Thank You Performance in Kyocera Dome Osaka. The official audio is in their RUclips Music. It's only music but you can sense Asahi tearing up especially in the bridge part of the song.
one of the best albums ever imo. Im biased af bc they're my ults but just every song is so good and the range of sounds and emotions and they just have such good b-sides.
your treasure reactions have been my go-to recently. thank you for the album reaction and the way you appreciate the voices of the members. i cannot wait for the reboot album reaction.
U should definitely check the documentary series they have released for second step chapter two . It shows the creative process of the album and some behind the scenes of recording. U will definitely love it . 😊😊
Thank you and hold it in always makes me tear up every time I listen to it. It is so beautiful. I need Hyunsuk and Asahi to make these kind of masterpieces again in the upcoming comeback!
No hold it in isnt about mashidam, hyunsuk wrote it right after treasurebox so the members were still in treasure back then hold it in is about treasurebox and his traineedays ❤️❤️
asahi made clap because of pandemic. since attendees can't scream that time in concerts and all so, he made that song ^^ they are genius, fr!! thank you for reacting!!💙
you should check out their mini-documentary on how they worked on this album, they documented how they worked on the composing, recording, and dance practice. it has 2 episodes uploaded on their youtube channel.
hold it in holds a very special place in hyunsuk and teumes heart. hyunsuk really made it well!! the live version is more emotional and i agree that hyunsuk and junkyu suits this song, this is their song!!
![[#2024MAMA] TREASURE - INTRO + KING KONG + RUN | Mnet 241122 broadcast](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/62q9vtyvbRg/mqdefault.jpg)
OH KAILEE!!! Believe me when I said I've seen them perform this album live and I can swear to god I cried so much hearing hold it in, and I still tear up watching this reaction!! Hold it in and thank you are really the best songs out of this album!! I hope you can watch the documentary where they showcase the making of this album!
“hold it in” is a song written by Hyunsuk, I very like Hyunsuk's demo version
I'm a Jihoon stan but ASAHIxHARUTO performing THANK YOU in Kyocera Dome during the HELLO Tour last year holds a special spot in my heart. Seeing how ASAHI blossomed from an introvert robot predebut to the rockstar weirdo we all love, running around the stage just tugs at my heartstrings. Him screaming "OSAKA TADAIMA(I'M HOME)" always brings tears to my eyes. Hope you can check it out even off-cam!
Also, we Teumes like to think that THANK YOU and YAMAI(Japanese single) are love letters for MashiDam 💔
I love that🤍 thanks for letting me know, will 100% be checking out live stages
"Hold It In" is my favorite TREASURE song - written by Choi Hyunsuk himself. Have you heard his own full version of his song? It's as amazing as his tone in Treasure's version but the lyrics is way better. I hope you get to watch it. ruclips.net/video/IHLz-m-Kh3k/видео.html&start_radio=1
Thanks so much for the link! I’d love to check out the original version!(:
Hold it in was made by hyunsuk that's why hyunsuk's voice really conveys the feelings well in this song, you should listen to the concert version too it will be more sad. Thank you for your reaction I've always love it💜
Hold it in.. when I heard it live for the first time.. it was magical 😭😭😭😭😭❤❤
Oh I can imagine a song like that is even better live and just something special 👌🏼🤍
we can all agree that hold it in holds a special place in teumes' hearts. 🥺 i was dumbfounded too when i first listen to it. it's so magical and yet so sad. 🤧
Hyunsuk wrote Hold it in pre-debut. it's said that he wrote it during Treasure Box it's survival show how Treasure was created
hold it in my❤
thank you for my bias hyunsuk
for make this sad but beautiful song😭
you must hear yamai/lovesick and orange too by asahi🥹
and their ballad song " it's okay"
Hold It In was made by Hyunsuk. The concert version is even better especially when Hyunsuk raps his part with kinda shaking voice and change the way he sings the last part of the song, it becomes more and more touching 😢
Hold it in is a song that Hyunsuk wrote before his debut, I really like the song, especially the demo version that Hyunsuk showed live, it really has a sad vibe 😭❤
Sorry if my words are strange, I'm still learning English 😁
Your English is great :)
I need to check out the demo version, I love seeing the differences between originals/guides with the official audio so thanks for letting me know! Although if it’s even sadder I’ll just be balling the whole time 🙃 and absolutely no worries, your English is great!
"Clap" was written and composed by Asahi with the help of Hyunsuk, Haruto, and Yoshi, who wrote their own rap parts.
"Thank You" was once again written by Asahi and Haruto and composed by Asahi.
"Hold It In" was written and composed by Hyunsuk.
The absolute talent 👏🏼 they all did such a great job with this album
Hold it in is my fave bside i really like the live concert version
Treasure is one of the few groups in kpop with a very WELL-PRODUCED discography, and self-producing at that.
And the way all their voices compliment and fit each other in each song. Can't wait for your Reboot listening through!
That’s one of my favorite things and what I noticed right away! They have such a good understanding of where to place each members voice so it doesn’t sound messy or jarring at all, it always transitions and leads into the next members part so well(:
'Hold it in' during their concert ,I feel with the live band is even better, especially Junkyu's bridge. I went to my dad's house and kicked him out of his surround sound man-cave and watched the Hello at the Kyocera dome in Osaka and you can feel that bridge through out your body with the drums alone and I began to cry. One day I hope to see them here in America.
I am loving the way you react to their album. Also very happy that Thank You and Hold It In resonated so much with you. Just like what the other comments said, I feel like those two songs were lowkey dedicated to the former members of the group.
They had to hold everything in while the “negotiations” with the two to stay were on-going until they decided to leave which could have happened even before it was announced. Then when them leaving got finalized, all they could do was to thank them for all the memories they have shared with them.
Thank you is a bitter sweet song. It is sad that you broke up but at the end you are still thankful for the love and for all the good memories you spent together.
i always feel hurt every listening hold it in 😭
..this is why i do not know why they are so underrated.. people are closing their doors to TREASURE.. they do not know how good and talented they are, and it is so so sad.. 🥺
ooohh, i can't wait with the REBOOT reaction.. 🙏
Hold it in always be my favorite,
the fruit of hyunsuk's hard work in HOLD IT IN 🥺🥺🥺 he even said in recording that junkyu and asahi's part are perfect
It's obvious that I would watch everything, I didn't even see the time go by
Hold It In is very special to me especially when i was in tough times. I was in a fresh break up and I had neuropathy ,so I feel so lost at that time but the song helped me somehow to cope with the situation.
Don’t skip B.O.M.B. when you do Reboot because there’re some differences from the Kaboom version.
You should check out thank you live especially in reboot tour. I cried seeing it live last year. Asahi is so genius he changes some melody every stop most memorable is in his hometown Osaka😭
hold It in my favorite songs, and just to let you know the composer of the song is Choi Hyunsuk😊💙
thank you, hold it in and yamai will always be my mashidam song 😭
the only thing that i need is hearing Jihoon's voice. I'M IN LOVE WITH JIHOON VOICE ❤
Treasure 💎
Thank you for reacting and appreciating my boys❤. They bring smile to us. Now that you reacting to them, you also making me smile. THANK YOUU. Please react both the live of THANK YOU and HOLD IT IN from their concert it was a master piece and beautiful especially when asahi singing thank you, then shouting OSAKA TADAIMA😊
you should check out the behind the scenes of this album.
It's a 2 episodes short documentary film how they wrote, produce and record the songs
it called- TREASURE - ‘THE SECOND STEP : CHAPTER TWO’ DOCUMENTARY FILM
Will definitely be checking out the behind/documentary episodes soon!😊
I cried when I saw and listened to THANK YOU, because ASAHI is a rockstar!! All his hardships during YGTB flashback to me. This song proves that he deserves to be in TREASURE.
If you can do reaction to live performance to it and some song during HELLO Tour, I will love it
Listening to Thank You will always be having mixed feelings. The lyrics hit the hardest even more knowing that former members left the group. And this becomes more bitter-sweet especially when I heard this live during their concert 😭
my favorite album from them to date!! i prefer this their debut album, T10 debut album 🥹🫶🏻
"thank you" in reboot tour is the best version!! please react more like live performances. thankyou!!💙
you should also watch the documentary of this album :) its in their channel too
Kailee you shpuld watch THANK YOU Live it feels soooo difderent and Asahi is really superb Live. There are lots of good fancams for this.
I love your TREASURE reaction
Thanks so much(: appreciate taking the time to watch 😊
the second step chapter two has to be my fave treasure album yet. the songs are so genuine and that has a lot to do with the fact that the members were so involved in the production process. they released this album during a time full of so many uncertainties with how the group's going to move forward esp since hello felt like a reintroduction for the 10 members. i'd like to think they already knew what was gonna happen and thank you and hold it in were their goodbye songs. my biases are hyunsuk, junkyu and asahi but i saw them perform live last year and the only time i almost teared up was when asahi was performing thank you. hold it in's also so special for me since it's by hyunsuk and so dear to him because he's been working on it since ygtb and that bridge gets me everytime. thanks for appreciating the boys' music and songwriting. firm believer that these boys don't wanna be seen as just idols but as actual artists.
I don't know why but Thank You is a different level of "favorite" for me when it comes to TREASURE songs. Overall I do like their discography and I have favorites, but Thank You has this power to put me into a nostalgic memory of childhood.
Asahi is a really gifted writer/musician and I like how his character rasonates through the songs he created/participated with. Orange, Clap, Thank You, and Yamai all personifies Asahi's character in their sound/lyrics and it's amazing!!!
I also like Yamai but moreso the Korean version because it's so poetic translated in english but what more if I can understand korean/hangul.
Oh I definitely get that. Thank You has been legitimately on repeat and probably my most listened to on this album so far. I love the instrumental especially and their vocals are just perfect for that style of music. For sure part of the music I grew up listening to and yeah I can tell I’m just going to love Asahi’s writing style and the way he specifically makes music just from the couple songs I’ve heard from him and I can’t wait to check out more 👌🏼
CLAP IS MY COMFORT SONG
I need a title track written by Asahi. He's my fave lyricist & producer in the group
I really like your reaction. Please help react to the documentary about this album. They worked really hard to make these songs. The story along the way of making music has many different emotions and feelings. You will fall in love with them even more after watching their music production.
Thank you😊 and definitely will be watching the documentary episodes(:
You should also react to chapter two: step two documentary its like the behind the scenes of the recording and dancepractice:)💙💙
You should listen to Asahi and Haruto's Thank You Performance in Kyocera Dome Osaka. The official audio is in their RUclips Music.
It's only music but you can sense Asahi tearing up especially in the bridge part of the song.
I was waiting so much for this reaction, I thank you so much for reacting to this album 💎💙😭
Thanks for watching😊
one of the best albums ever imo. Im biased af bc they're my ults but just every song is so good and the range of sounds and emotions and they just have such good b-sides.
your treasure reactions have been my go-to recently. thank you for the album reaction and the way you appreciate the voices of the members. i cannot wait for the reboot album reaction.
OMG I'VE BEEN WAINTING FOR THIS MY WHOLE LIFE!!!!!
I CAN WATCH YOUR REACTION FOR 2 HOURS DONT WORRY
Haha thanks so much(:
LOVE YOUR TREASURE REACTIONS
U should definitely check the documentary series they have released for second step chapter two . It shows the creative process of the album and some behind the scenes of recording. U will definitely love it . 😊😊
Will be coming soon!😊
Thank you and hold it in always makes me tear up every time I listen to it. It is so beautiful. I need Hyunsuk and Asahi to make these kind of masterpieces again in the upcoming comeback!
Hi Kailee! Try also Second Step: Chapter One. Its also one of the gem b-sides 🤍
JUST WAIT UNTIL YOU LISTEN TO THE WAY TO
I think this is my favorite album but사랑해 is my favorite song
If only you knew them earlier😢. "Thank you" is somewhat dedicated to their former members who left the group😭😭
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
No hold it in isnt about mashidam, hyunsuk wrote it right after treasurebox so the members were still in treasure back then hold it in is about treasurebox and his traineedays ❤️❤️
@@zeamrilno, hold it in, the rumor is written about choi hyunsuk's love story 😃
'Hold it in' has nothing to do with mashidam.
u should watch how their making this album on documentary film, it has 2 episodes 👍
The way Treasure plays with our emotions😂💗💎
hi kailee, thanx 4 your beautiful reaction.. may i request your reaction their song "its okay". same vibes with hold in it for me. thanx 😊
🤍💍💙
When you react to Reboot Album, you should not skip B.O.M.B because there is a difference between it with the Kaboom Version.
YESSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!
asahi made clap because of pandemic. since attendees can't scream that time in concerts and all so, he made that song ^^ they are genius, fr!! thank you for reacting!!💙
I love every lyric in this album.
Reboot album treasure please
Hold It In written and composed/produced by the main rapper of the group! Such a talented man
you should check out their mini-documentary on how they worked on this album, they documented how they worked on the composing, recording, and dance practice. it has 2 episodes uploaded on their youtube channel.
I LOVE THIS REACTION OR LISTEN WHATEVER AHHH
Thanks so much!😂😊
hold it in holds a very special place in hyunsuk and teumes heart. hyunsuk really made it well!! the live version is more emotional and i agree that hyunsuk and junkyu suits this song, this is their song!!
Why do the songs “Thank You”, “Hold It In” make me miss Mashiho and Yedam even more, does anyone else miss them other than me, let me know.
🤍💙
🥲🤩😍🥰