Never Before Seen Object Collided With a Neutron Star and Nobody Knows What

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 май 2024
  • Get a Wonderful Person Tee: teespring.com/stores/whatdamath
    More cool designs are on Amazon: amzn.to/3QFIrFX
    Alternatively, PayPal donations can be sent here: paypal.me/whatdamath
    Hello and welcome! My name is Anton and in this video, we will talk about a very strange gravitational wave that suggests a never before seen cosmological object
    Links:
    dcc.ligo.org/P2300352/public/
    news.northwestern.edu/stories...
    arxiv.org/abs/2404.04248
    arxiv.org/abs/2309.12644
    #gravitationalwaves #neutronstars #blackhole
    Relevant and similar videos:
    • Black Hole Collision T...
    • Major Discovery of Lou...
    • Recent Powerful Kilono...
    • Black Hole Collision T...
    • Using Gravitational Wa...
    • After 3 Years of Hiatu...
    • Major Gravitational Wa...
    • Does Universe Remember...
    • Life on Earth May Only...
    Support this channel on Patreon to help me make this a full time job:
    / whatdamath
    0:00 Unusual gravitational wave detection
    1:00 How gravitational waves work and are detected
    2:50 Unusual new detection
    4:10 Previous detection of something similar
    5:15 But what is this though? PBH?
    7:20 No explanation yet
    7:55 New facility soon!
    8:30 Other mysteries
    Bitcoin/Ethereum to spare? Donate them here to help this channel grow!
    bc1qnkl3nk0zt7w0xzrgur9pnkcduj7a3xxllcn7d4
    or ETH: 0x60f088B10b03115405d313f964BeA93eF0Bd3DbF
    Space Engine is available for free here: spaceengine.org
    Enjoy and please subscribe.
    Twitter: / whatdamath
    Facebook: / whatdamath
    Twitch: / whatdamath
    The hardware used to record these videos:
    New Camera: amzn.to/34DUUlv
    CPU: amzn.to/2LZFQCJ
    Video Card: amzn.to/2M1W26C
    Motherboard: amzn.to/2JYGiQQ
    RAM: amzn.to/2Mwy2t4
    PSU: amzn.to/2LZcrIH
    Case: amzn.to/2MwJZz4
    Microphone: amzn.to/2t5jTv0
    Mixer: amzn.to/2JOL0oF
    Recording and Editing: amzn.to/2LX6uvU
    Some of the above are affiliate links, meaning I would get a (very small) percentage of the price paid.
    Thank you to all Patreon supporters of this channel
    Special thanks also goes to all the wonderful supporters of the channel through RUclips Memberships
    Credits:
    Carl Knox, OzGrav-Swinburne University
    I. Markin (Potsdam University), T. Dietrich (Potsdam University and Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics), H. Pfeiffer, A. Buonanno (Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics)]
    S. Galaudage/Observatoire de la Côte d'Azur
    LIGO • Most Precise Ruler Eve...
    • Exaggerated Effects of...
    Licenses used:
    creativecommons.org/licenses/...
    creativecommons.org/licenses/...
    creativecommons.org/licenses/...
    creativecommons.org/licenses/...
    creativecommons.org/licenses/...
    creativecommons.org/licenses/...
    creativecommons.org/licenses/...
    creativecommons.org/licenses/...
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 571

  • @shanianichols6554
    @shanianichols6554 23 дня назад +3

    Hi Anton, I was a part of the editorial team for this discovery. Thanks for covering GW230529 on your channel!

  • @1e33n7
    @1e33n7 26 дней назад +136

    Keeping the unknown in our feeds.
    Thank yews, Anton!

    • @douglaswilkinson5700
      @douglaswilkinson5700 26 дней назад +7

      Remember RUclips takes 30% of what you donate to Anton.

    • @carmenmccauley585
      @carmenmccauley585 26 дней назад +1

      ​@@douglaswilkinson5700I don't believe so.

    • @1e33n7
      @1e33n7 26 дней назад +8

      @@douglaswilkinson5700 I am aware! friendly reminder tho, thanks, m8

    • @DeletiriousAction
      @DeletiriousAction 26 дней назад +11

      ​@@douglaswilkinson5700You've gotta be kidding..... I could see 10%, maybe, but that's a lawyer level cut. YT has incredible creators, but it's really gone downhill as a platform in the past 3 or 4 years.

    • @sandrajones1609
      @sandrajones1609 26 дней назад +2

      The newly developed caste system in the comments is a means for the sense oars to delete subject matter that is not to be intelligently discussed by critical thinking humans ✌️on this venue it is almost impossible and I urge all to migrate for a more realistic experience. r u m b l e . love& light ✌️

  • @pamelahood
    @pamelahood 26 дней назад +130

    There is only one remaining mystery in the cosmos. How does Anton read, comprehend, and explain all this research in such engaging ways? Daily? Even if he might have help? 😲🙌. Amazing! Thanks Wonderful Person Anton! ❤ 🙏 from a retired PhD down the road from Stanford.

    • @1e33n7
      @1e33n7 26 дней назад +5

      Its inhuman .. He is just that wonderful of a person.

    • @Joel-st8pj
      @Joel-st8pj 26 дней назад +6

      The mystery thickens, when you realize that anton is not a physicist, or have a phd.

    • @eXWoLL
      @eXWoLL 26 дней назад

      ChatGPT xd

    • @sluggo3slug
      @sluggo3slug 26 дней назад

      Please stop 🛑

    • @grish1u927
      @grish1u927 25 дней назад

      Thought that was my comment

  • @Jm-wt1fs
    @Jm-wt1fs 26 дней назад +15

    Considering neutron stars and black holes all merge with each other at least fairly regularly, and can easily produce a black hole in the so called mass gap, I think the simplest conclusion is probably the correct one here

  • @DeletiriousAction
    @DeletiriousAction 26 дней назад +43

    This channel is rapidly becoming my nightly watch. Best astronomy/astrophysics channel on YT, next to PBS Spacetime. Keep up the excellent work!

    • @michaellee6489
      @michaellee6489 26 дней назад +1

      I keep asking for an Anton/Dowd collaboration. Fingers crossed, that would be awesome!!!!!!!!

  • @jarodmasci3445
    @jarodmasci3445 26 дней назад +9

    We know nothing, clearly. We observe, guess, and then come up with elaborate math that is quickly disproved when we apply it to better observations.....but Anton still rocks. Keep fighting the good fight sir!

  • @wylinout2257
    @wylinout2257 26 дней назад +143

    Man I love this channel ❤
    Thx Anton l, I leaning more awesome things about space here, than anywhere ever!!

  • @michaelhale881
    @michaelhale881 26 дней назад +18

    I never miss a day of Anton. Great stuff.

  • @BrianFedirko
    @BrianFedirko 26 дней назад +45

    I love LIGO, and I was so excited when i found out they were planning on building it. Even more amazed they pulled it off. I know we are going to discover so much about everything. It applies to quantum physics just as much as "large" reality. Thank you Anton!!! Gr8! Peace ☮💜Love

    • @Pax.Alotin
      @Pax.Alotin 26 дней назад

      It's lies. They faked the so called gravity waves - result & continue to defraud the government.

    • @robertb6889
      @robertb6889 26 дней назад +1

      As a kid I wanted to be a physicist and had to interview someone in my future career. I was connected via telephone with a guy working on the early days of ligo. I became an engineer but still remember that guy who took time to talk about ligo with a 14 yr old.

    • @rsa4510
      @rsa4510 26 дней назад +1

      @@robertb6889I wonder who you spoke to? I retired last year after working almost 30 years as an engineer on LIGO. Don't think it was me though... Glad you had a nice experience.

    • @charlesbrightman4237
      @charlesbrightman4237 26 дней назад +1

      QUESTIONS:
      a. What exactly is 'space' that it can warp?
      b. What exactly is 'time' that it can warp?

    • @robertb6889
      @robertb6889 25 дней назад +2

      I don’t know. I think it was a physics PHD student or postdoc - not someone with an engineering degree. It would have been in the early 2000’s, for someone with a relative who was a librarian in a middle school.
      I know make computer chips.

  • @thehellyousay
    @thehellyousay 26 дней назад +19

    a quark star. strange matter bubbling under a quark crust.
    that's been my ill-informed guess of the day.

    • @MarsStarcruiser
      @MarsStarcruiser 26 дней назад +1

      I’m curious what the separation would even be from a blackhole though, unless we’re somehow not past Schwarzschild Radius yet🤔

    • @CriminalonCrime
      @CriminalonCrime 24 дня назад

      it's a Spactertron.

  • @user-je5do6jn2f
    @user-je5do6jn2f 26 дней назад +10

    Professor Petrov, you never cease to entertain and enlighten.

  • @davidarundel6187
    @davidarundel6187 26 дней назад +13

    Hi Aton , and Thankyou , to the Team , 💐🎁

  • @andrewruiz7894
    @andrewruiz7894 26 дней назад +28

    It's crazy but before I even read comments, I wanted to say how awesome Anton is! There was something about this post that drew out our praise of this wonderful person. Kudos Anton!

    • @aristoclesathenaioi4939
      @aristoclesathenaioi4939 26 дней назад +2

      I joined his Patreon after watching a number of his videos. I hope he makes enough money from his Patreon that he can spend time finding out about this stuff that most us would never know otherwise.

  • @johnmckinney9324
    @johnmckinney9324 26 дней назад +9

    Thank you Anton. Stay wonderful.

  • @anatrejos8879
    @anatrejos8879 26 дней назад +59

    ❤❤❤Anton much love to you and family❤❤❤

    • @archlich4489
      @archlich4489 26 дней назад +6

      He is a wonderful person 🙂

  • @Taomantom
    @Taomantom 27 дней назад +27

    Just had my Anton Fix for the day!

    • @AdrianaVRodriguez06
      @AdrianaVRodriguez06 26 дней назад

      Same here , I need to always make sure to watch one of his videos daily. Either it be a new one or a recap of an older one.

  • @DickGallo-dk7wi
    @DickGallo-dk7wi 26 дней назад +26

    Anton, how do they manage it? When I use a laser on something, the cat attacks it. This really screws up any potential findings. I am baffled, and very impressed.

    • @andrewbouskill5444
      @andrewbouskill5444 24 дня назад +2

      You adopt the Schrodinger’s cat that’s dead.

    • @pfzht
      @pfzht 24 дня назад +6

      A cat MUST be present to supervise. Quite the conundrum.

    • @DickGallo-dk7wi
      @DickGallo-dk7wi 24 дня назад

      @@andrewbouskill5444 😆

    • @CyCloNeReactorCore
      @CyCloNeReactorCore 21 день назад +2

      i don't think you'll have an issue with the cat anymore after it jumps in front of LIGO

    • @DickGallo-dk7wi
      @DickGallo-dk7wi 21 день назад

      @@CyCloNeReactorCore 😆😆😆😆😆

  • @lindaseel9986
    @lindaseel9986 26 дней назад +9

    Hello Wonderful Anton! Thank you for your hard work and keeping us informed about many interesting things. Love, Grandma Linda in Martinsburg WV USA. 🤗🤗

  • @Siphr0dias
    @Siphr0dias 26 дней назад +4

    I only discovered your channel a short while ago, but am incredibly thankful for your outpu! :)

  • @tinkerstrade3553
    @tinkerstrade3553 26 дней назад +6

    With a nod to the old soft rock tune, "Good Vibrations". 😎

  • @jarrettloden1342
    @jarrettloden1342 26 дней назад +12

    Love your videos Anton !

  • @marknovak6498
    @marknovak6498 26 дней назад +4

    The gravitational telescope sees something we have not planned for routinely. Finally, an opening it a staid theory to study.

  • @callejondorado
    @callejondorado 26 дней назад +2

    Can you please explain to us how energy (in whatever form) can escape two black holes colliding, if not even light can escape. Are we talking about the circling gas around the black hole that hasn't fall beyond the horizon?

  • @jimcurtis9052
    @jimcurtis9052 26 дней назад +7

    Wonderful as always Anton. Thank you. 🙏😄

  • @anthonyalfredyorke1621
    @anthonyalfredyorke1621 26 дней назад +4

    Thanks Anton for another great video, more good brain food for a Friday. Staying WONDERFUL and still WAVING have a wonderful weekend. PEACE AND LOVE TO EVERYONE ❤❤.

  • @dr.traplord1227
    @dr.traplord1227 26 дней назад +10

    Keep killing it man, as i always say: Yeet.

    • @1e33n7
      @1e33n7 26 дней назад +1

      *yeets in support*

  • @solanumtinkr8280
    @solanumtinkr8280 26 дней назад +13

    How about 2 merged White dwarfs that leave one object spinning ridiculously fast, for the mass gap object..

    • @99pncrft
      @99pncrft 26 дней назад

      Same

    • @douglaswilkinson5700
      @douglaswilkinson5700 26 дней назад +4

      When two white dwarfs combined mass exceeds ~2.4 solar masses it produces a type 1a supernova.
      Less than that the angular momentum is conserved so the new object is spinning quite fast. How fast I don't remember. Neutron stars merge at about ⅓c.

    • @denizkacan8007
      @denizkacan8007 26 дней назад +1

      @@douglaswilkinson5700 ~1.44 solar masses

    • @DEANISME_
      @DEANISME_ 26 дней назад

      Idiot question

    • @douglaswilkinson5700
      @douglaswilkinson5700 26 дней назад

      ​@@denizkacan8007You are right. Good catch!

  • @spidalack
    @spidalack 26 дней назад +3

    Ever since the discovery of gravitational waves, I've been wondering how the change in distances would affect quantum system and if it might not explain some things.
    Makes me wish I was able to study this stuff for a living.

    • @atticmuse3749
      @atticmuse3749 26 дней назад +1

      What kind of effects are you thinking? Cause remember that the LIGO detectors have 4 km long arms that are only contracted/expanded by ~10^-18 m (thousand times smaller than a proton).

    • @mr-x7689
      @mr-x7689 26 дней назад

      "Makes me wish I was able to study this stuff for a living." Well you can, if genuinly serious about it. There are grants you can applie for, stipends handed out by goverments, and EU, and probably a few universeties that work on these kinds of stuff, that would be interested. Tho you have to go looking for those your selfe. I dont know where to start as i'm not interested in said fields and thusly dont know what to search for.
      Nothing is ever truly impossible. We humans have a knack for saying that things are impossible, just to prove ourselfe wrong later on, after tecnology have caught up. We just havent figured out how to remove the IM from the POSSIBLE yet.
      So if that is what you want, go, go look for it. follow your dreems, you never know where they will take you, if you are dedicated and hard working enough. I belive in ya buddy.

    • @douglaswilkinson5700
      @douglaswilkinson5700 26 дней назад

      ​@@mr-x7689It takes 10 years of post-secondary university education to earn a PhD in astrophysics. The advanced mathematics -- e.g. differential geometry and tensor calculus -- is very difficult.

  • @kjdtm
    @kjdtm 26 дней назад +1

    It is interesting that gravitational waves are a thing ! We always say that gravity is not a force, but it still has waves.
    I think it's more accurate to say quantum field wave. A wave in space, but not in time (because it travels)

  • @zucottimanicotti7112
    @zucottimanicotti7112 26 дней назад +4

    What if it was an electroweak star? Like a rare transitional object between massive neutron stars and black holes that can only exist within an extremely minuscule mass range. It would appear like an unusually lightweight black hole from earth, especially when observed through gravitational waves exclusively. These grapefruit sized electroweak stars are only theoretical tho, but it’s a fun thought experiment. (under those extreme conditions, the electromagnetic force and the weak force combine into a single force called the electroweak force, creating repulsion force holding the barely stable softball sized star from fully collapsing into a singularity)

    • @robertb6889
      @robertb6889 26 дней назад

      Wouldn’t it already be a black hole if it had stellar mass inside a space the size grapefruit?

    • @zucottimanicotti7112
      @zucottimanicotti7112 26 дней назад

      @@robertb6889 from the outside it would look extremely similar to a regular black hole but with a low mass. I’m not really an expert tho, I just read about in a Wikipedia article lol

    • @MarsStarcruiser
      @MarsStarcruiser 26 дней назад

      Need additional mechanism for vibration. How exactly can such vibration be preserved, even under the immense repulsion that you are employing to counter gravitation? My reasons for asking are similar to how hyper-nova’s avoid event horizon formation

    • @zucottimanicotti7112
      @zucottimanicotti7112 26 дней назад +1

      @@MarsStarcruiser Best way I can describe it is that under extreme and very specific circumstances, the neutrons break down into quarks and the quarks still have volume in space, albeit many times smaller than even the neutrons. Two quarks still really don’t want to be in the exact same volume and they’re literally packed together as tightly as physically possible, so they repel enough via the electroweak force to hold against gravity for a short period until quantum fluctuations cause instabilities or enough mass is acquired to allow full collapse into an unusually low mass black hole. I also don’t think they form from stars directly, more likely through some sort of collision between a low mass neutron star and a white dwarf or some other neutron star related collision event. They are still theoretical objects after all. None have been directly observed. There is a supernova upper mass limit where once a star exceeds it, the radiation pressure starts shredding off the outer layers of the star until enough material is lost and the radiation pressure is lowered enough to allow for full core collapse, kinda like what Eta Carinae is currently doing inside the homunculus nebula, resulting in a supernova and a regular stellar mass black hole.

    • @MarsStarcruiser
      @MarsStarcruiser 25 дней назад

      @@zucottimanicotti7112 For me, I do think super nova around 25+ stellar masses can form black holes, but thats less than .01% of stars. An overwhelming majority of black holes would have had to been produced via neutron stars progressions, either quiet core collapse or kilo-nova, and then absorptions or mergers could then go on to explain the size variations, atleast on the lower levels. Hyper-novas don’t change my thoughts on this, only show something else I find interesting.
      A large part of black hole formation may come down to the overall working of entropy rather than just specifically gravitation(unless 260+M). Super compression is a fight between repulsion and gravitation, and through that escalating restriction, a point is reached of bringing halt to particle vibration. Now effectively heatless… interact-ability declines(as we’re beginning to understand through BEC) and they start falling through each-other creating void for enhancing inward entropic flow, paving way for event horizon formation.
      140+M stars can avoid this problem through sheer thermal saturation, at-least to an extent. Enough heat and even core collapse alone becomes insufficient to halt particle vibration. Entropic flow remains directed outward preventing event horizon even at densities potentially below Schwarzchild Radius, no black hole and maximum rebound lol… and pure unadulterated “Hyper-Nova” probably destroying almost everything within a few thousand light years and sterilizing a decent chunk of the galaxy😅
      But anyways, for your scenario to work, I’ve kind of wondered if what you may need is a hidden charged 3rd body, electro inductively causing vibration to the spinning participants upon each pass. Scientists may not be able to discern this third wheel at play, just the two spinning via the gravitational waves.

  • @brolol3136
    @brolol3136 26 дней назад +8

    That's pretty cool 😊Hello and Thanks from Belarus😇😇😇

  • @AdrianBoyko
    @AdrianBoyko 26 дней назад +7

    Thumbnail: “Nobody knows what it was!!!” Video: Tells us what it was.

    • @Terran.Marine.2
      @Terran.Marine.2 26 дней назад +1

      That's so much better than all the videos saying "business x destroys business y" or similar when maybe business x had a breakthrough that will take years to get to market and actually change anything.

  • @aclearlight
    @aclearlight 26 дней назад +1

    Beautiful and deeply-informative work as always; your channel rocks!

  • @pirateradioFPV
    @pirateradioFPV 26 дней назад +5

    Scientists: B-b-but the math
    Universe: B-b-but the reality

    • @sortasurvival5482
      @sortasurvival5482 26 дней назад

      Anyone who has built a grid cieling knows that reality does not reflect the math...

  • @AndrewJohnson-oy8oj
    @AndrewJohnson-oy8oj 26 дней назад +2

    Wow, that was fascinating. Thanks, Anton. I'd never even heard of LIGO before. The detection apparati we have now would have been impossible fantasies when I first because excited about astronomy and cosmology. What a time to be alive.

  • @stayfrosty1758
    @stayfrosty1758 26 дней назад +10

    Anton, the only real wonderful person here is you. You do precious work to spread the great thruth. I and many others will forever be in your debt

  • @thomasgeorgecastleberry6918
    @thomasgeorgecastleberry6918 26 дней назад +7

    Analyzing waves;- about 4 years ago I gave a "hot babe," I didn't even know a wave (I lost count of the number of atoms I displaced performing this task) , she replied with a "get lost creep," tome.

    • @DeletiriousAction
      @DeletiriousAction 26 дней назад

      I've never had a girl give me a book as a rejection symbol... 🤔

    • @sandrajones1609
      @sandrajones1609 26 дней назад

      Why would you want to share this kind of information? I don't perceive your motivation?✌️

    • @Anne2u
      @Anne2u 26 дней назад

      ​@@sandrajones1609Its a joke Sandra.

    • @michaelrichter9427
      @michaelrichter9427 26 дней назад

      @@Anne2u Just not a very good one.

  • @lonnylasagna
    @lonnylasagna 26 дней назад +2

    What if dark energy could be explained by the entirety of the fabric of spacetime being in a "crumpled state" from the singularity of the big bang. No different than if you crumpled up a table cloth, then spread it out across the table and charted it through time. And those huge vibrations in the fabric of spacetime that was mentioned at the end is just us going through a big crumpled part of spacetime as it smooths out.

    • @hankscorpio42069
      @hankscorpio42069 26 дней назад

      Finally! Someone who understands.
      Though the deeper implication here is that, you and I and anything that is a "crumpled state" of spacetime is that which expands the universe because the vacuum is the lowest (smoothest) and most fundamental form of energy that all other forms of energy convert to, as the universe reaches equilibrium by smoothing out. There are also further implications that this "uncrumpling" through the expansion of space is actually what causes gravity... which sounds absurd to some, except when you consider that GR predicts that vacuum energy should also produce gravitational effects. Indeed, you need only understand that dark matter seems to concentrate in a galaxies galactic halo to understand that all of the expansion of space within has to go somewhere. It doesn't just magically appear at however many megaparsecs. When the bullet cluster came to be, the expansion of space of those two clusters obviously had to go somewhere.

  • @LotusFlower420
    @LotusFlower420 27 дней назад +8

    Heyy Anton 🎉

  • @blech71
    @blech71 25 дней назад

    I always hit like even before seeing the full vid! Good guy Anton always delivers! 😊

  • @epiccurious3536
    @epiccurious3536 26 дней назад +2

    IMHO.... The universe is vibrating because of all the gravitational waves of all strengths and frequencies from all directions all the time.

    • @douglaswilkinson5700
      @douglaswilkinson5700 26 дней назад

      All frequencies: perhaps. All strengths: no. At high enough amplitudes gravitational waves would rip the Earth apart.

  • @stuartmaclean8668
    @stuartmaclean8668 26 дней назад +5

    Oh a Blitzar!!! Entering guru meditation mode.

  • @MCsCreations
    @MCsCreations 26 дней назад +2

    That's some heavy lifting!

  • @joemcintyre2090
    @joemcintyre2090 26 дней назад +3

    How could the universe not be vibrating? With all that energy bouncing around out there. Whatever material space is made out of transmits this energy all around like a big gong.

    • @conked944
      @conked944 26 дней назад

      Or the energy released is intense enough to persist in the void? Maybe it bounces off nearby objects to maintain its momentum??

    • @joemcintyre2090
      @joemcintyre2090 26 дней назад

      @@conked944 The universe is quite a trip! How about instead of one big bang, there are millions times millions of bangs like popcorn popping? Each bang produces a galaxy. These bangs are still happening far far away at the source. I dreamt this just a few nights ago. Mark my words if some scientist comes up with the theory!

  • @OmegaWolf747
    @OmegaWolf747 26 дней назад +2

    Our universe is vibrating and rippling with great power.

  • @NWLongstreet
    @NWLongstreet 26 дней назад

    you're the most wonderful person! thank you for each and every video and smile you make!

  • @1337Elisha
    @1337Elisha 26 дней назад +2

    detectors are way longer than 4kl, they bounce the light many times so its like way way longer man.

  • @rwfrench66GenX
    @rwfrench66GenX 26 дней назад +2

    Thanks Anton. Why does it have to be a single object? It’s 650 million light years away, it could be a binary pair of white dwarfs orbiting a neutron star and their close orbit acts as a single mass when propagating the gravitational waves.

    • @douglaswilkinson5700
      @douglaswilkinson5700 26 дней назад +1

      Read the papers upon which Anton bases his videos. There are links in the description.

    • @rwfrench66GenX
      @rwfrench66GenX 26 дней назад

      @@douglaswilkinson5700thanks, I actually did look at them. I was referring to the mass gap object. The premise is it’s a single object. My question is how do they know it’s not a pair of close orbiting objects that from this distance appear to have that mass. I didn’t find that in the articles. It’s the same thing with looking for exoplanets and determining the mass of the planet. That planet could have many close orbiting moons that appears to make the planet’s mass larger when measured from our distance.

    • @douglaswilkinson5700
      @douglaswilkinson5700 26 дней назад

      ​@@rwfrench66GenXAfter making observations -- as accurate as possible -- astrophysicists use mathematics to determine masses, etc. of planets, stars, BHs, etc. In addition it's is known that multiple moons with close orbits to a planet can perterb each other's orbits causing them to crash into the planet or be ejected from the system. Moons have lower masses than the planets they orbit. Our Moon is only 1/80th or 0.0125 of the Earth's mass. Also, the two objects' orbital velocity increases significantly as the spiral down toward mergering. (E.g. two neutron stars' velocities are almost ⅓c!) At these velocities any moon, etc. would be ripped away from these inspiraling objects.

    • @rwfrench66GenX
      @rwfrench66GenX 26 дней назад

      @@douglaswilkinson5700 and every day Anton releases a video of some new discovery or event astronomers didn’t believe was possible. Jupiter has four moons that would be considered major planets if they were orbiting the sun because of their mass. There’s been deep learning computers that have discovered exoplanets because astronomers only looked at data that had a 95% or higher chance of having an exoplanet. I get their time is limited but the quality of the data isn’t the best, from there it’s filtered and analyzed using preconceived notions, and when we can’t explain 95% of what’s going on it seems precarious to label a mass gap object as a single object instead of considering it could be a pair of smaller very close orbiting objects that from a distance of 650 million light years appear to create a gravity well of a mass gap object that defies explanation of what we believe we do know.

  • @PtolemyJones
    @PtolemyJones 26 дней назад +1

    I really wonder if things could poke at the other side of the space-time fabric, and be noticed as a gravity wave on our side.

  • @jessicaandtrains7768
    @jessicaandtrains7768 26 дней назад +1

    6:16 I thought that was most likely also.

  • @sergeigarbar1948
    @sergeigarbar1948 26 дней назад +4

    10 minutes old video,1,5 k watches, 256 likes

  • @moondogaudiojones1146
    @moondogaudiojones1146 26 дней назад

    Very cool. I hope there will be a more solid theory soon.
    Great episode Anton!

  • @imelatedrn
    @imelatedrn 26 дней назад +1

    I'm not pretending to know, but I just had a thought that maybe this unknown object is in transition between states of mass, but the incredible space time waves are slowing the collapse.
    just a theory, please don't take it so seriously

  • @SpeedyMechnic
    @SpeedyMechnic 24 дня назад

    Such effort. So much respect

  • @rich9697
    @rich9697 26 дней назад +2

    Thank you Anton you really are .my favorite top of the league youtuber/teacher. Love.

  • @sinisterresident
    @sinisterresident 26 дней назад +2

    waves are the heartbeat of the universe, when it stops, all life stops.

    • @oberonpanopticon
      @oberonpanopticon 26 дней назад

      Well, seeing as according to quantum field theory everything is made of waves, you’re not wrong

    • @sandrajones1609
      @sandrajones1609 26 дней назад

      magnetic waves, electrical waves, lights waves, sound waves and no doubt some unidentified waves✌️

  • @SheSweetLikSugarNSavage
    @SheSweetLikSugarNSavage 26 дней назад +3

    Just saw the store...I need a white wonderful person T-shirt

  • @JodeSpoderman
    @JodeSpoderman 26 дней назад +2

    I think I'm going to buy one of your shirts, particularly that blue one that I see on the shop next month because I think it's cool

  • @jarrodstover5172
    @jarrodstover5172 26 дней назад +1

    Every day more and more I find tesla was the Smartest person to ever live. How many decades ago did he say " if we want to understand the universe we need to understand energy, frequency, and vibration"

  • @jasonlow6943
    @jasonlow6943 26 дней назад

    Mind boggling stuff... Thanks Anton you always supply me with wonderful videos.

  • @yvonnemiezis5199
    @yvonnemiezis5199 26 дней назад +1

    Interesting information and knowledge, thanks 👍😊

  • @Jokers_Yugioh666
    @Jokers_Yugioh666 26 дней назад +10

    Thanks anton!

  • @Votd66
    @Votd66 26 дней назад

    All the science channels repeat the same stuff but Anton gives us fresh content daily THANK YOU

  • @timothy8426
    @timothy8426 26 дней назад +2

    Renewable dark energy outside of entanglement of mass passes through mass in chain reactions until resistance is overcome by open space itself, then returns to dark energy outside of entanglement of mass?

  • @dadsonworldwide3238
    @dadsonworldwide3238 26 дней назад +1

    multi verse of galaxy Fireworks is beginning to shape up with more & more highlights on scale plus emerging energetic subjective properties than anyone imagined

  • @Juice-chan
    @Juice-chan 26 дней назад +1

    So good to know that the universe is vibing 🎉

  • @jaymethodus3421
    @jaymethodus3421 26 дней назад +1

    My theory of cosmology predicts lots of small super dense remnant "ejected" singularity masses, as well as the remnant
    "cooling" cores of the once smbh's that were formed in the chaotic mass-momentum exchanging process that formed the ejected masses. I'm almost certain that "black holes" need to be re-thought from the ground-up(yes I mean ground-state* of the electron). I believe it's mass is in some configuration that does NOT form into the "elementary" particles, due to it's inherent di-polar stability.
    Yet this mass would still exist and "take up space", and could be interpretted as infinite density, the more precise any measurement of density is made.
    Hydrogen came AFTER the 1st SMBH era. Before that, the di-pole collapse and creation of physical-space.

  • @andrewsteer7075
    @andrewsteer7075 25 дней назад

    Just a comment to help out, banging channel brother and thanks for your time and effort...

  • @benruniko
    @benruniko 26 дней назад

    My guess would be an object that used to be a neutron star that previously either accumulated mass over time or already collided with something but instead of spreading all over managed to pull itself back together.

  • @KrunoslavSaho
    @KrunoslavSaho 24 дня назад +1

    String theory was right all along!

  • @Unmannedair
    @Unmannedair 26 дней назад +2

    I just realized that any orbital version of the gravitational observatory would require an insane amount of computational power. This is because the distance is between the units would be constantly changing and would result in interference patterns just from the drift alone. So now you have to computationally separate the interference from the drift from the interference from the gravitation... That is a lot of math. 😅

    • @douglaswilkinson5700
      @douglaswilkinson5700 26 дней назад

      Fraser Cain discussed an orbital LIGO with a scientist. There are several challenges in designing, building and operating one.

  • @epiccurious3536
    @epiccurious3536 26 дней назад +2

    @AntonPetrov... I'm wondering why accretion discs around black holes don't create supernovas like they are created around white dwarfs in binary systems wherein the dwarf is absorbing material from its partner. Can you explain that? It might make an interesting episode in your wonderful channel's exploration/explanation of the universe.

    • @peppermintgal4302
      @peppermintgal4302 26 дней назад

      If I recall correctly, the nova created by white dwarves are caused by ignition of the gas cloud and outer layer of the orbiting star's atmosphere, triggered by something happening in the white dwarf. Something happening inside a black hole is probably not going to trigger such ignition, because that energy can't escape.

    • @MarsStarcruiser
      @MarsStarcruiser 26 дней назад

      Please note the temperature difference of white dwarf surface(18,000) vs hottest parts of accretion disk(18,000,000). You’ll see it differ by about 1000 times. One is cool enough to essentially build up pressure for a spontaneous burst down the road while other is on continuous ignition

  • @leonmusk1040
    @leonmusk1040 26 дней назад +1

    This does make me wonder if we checked a map of all of the high metallicity stars and did a fine structure gravitational lensing search if it could possibly be a good search area for mass gap black holes and also help bring the gaps in cosmology closer in line more so if it gives more weight to primordial blackholes in the process every little bit helps. Collating all of the newest data as a whole including the new neutrino data (Still waiting ) might certainly help being as it's now looking into the great attractor etc.

  • @user-qs7gx7rp7m
    @user-qs7gx7rp7m 26 дней назад +2

    What scares me about the universe we currently belive in is how every eliment in it seems different . . . Not like water in a river as most might reasonably infer. The thought inspired is that whatever is going on in water must be even more amazing that space because the time gap is less.
    Feedback welcomed.

    • @nilo70
      @nilo70 26 дней назад +1

      Anton ,
      Could this vibration be a remnant of the BIG BANG ?

  • @Pan_Fryer
    @Pan_Fryer 26 дней назад

    the symphony is awe inspiring

  • @throwabrick
    @throwabrick 26 дней назад

    I have been waiting for LISA since Kip Thorne mentioned it in a speech at UBC in 1998.

  • @ROLtheWolf
    @ROLtheWolf 26 дней назад

    Binary stars are very common. One became a Neutron star before the other more massive one collapsed, so the Neutron star became more dense and drew the corona off the other star, maybe with multiple novas, until the non-neutron star couldn't have a proper super-nova - leaving an odd-sized black hole.
    IDK enough to say that I'm even close.

  • @michaellee6489
    @michaellee6489 26 дней назад

    That graphic at about :40 seconds deserves a seizure warning... Wow.

  • @billcarruth8122
    @billcarruth8122 26 дней назад

    Maybe the larger object was a recent neutron star collision that was still spinning at such a high rate that it couldn't collapse into a black hole.

  • @jagpow8079
    @jagpow8079 26 дней назад +1

    Everyone is going to scream aliens because they're stoopid 😂

  • @timealchemist7508
    @timealchemist7508 26 дней назад +1

    We live in the future! Amazing! Keep accelerating!

  • @benjaminbeard3736
    @benjaminbeard3736 26 дней назад +2

    It has to be a black hole that is the product of two smaller objects, white dwarves/ light neutron stars.

  • @michro1982
    @michro1982 24 дня назад

    Thank you for your dedication Anton. You were one of the first channels i ever subbed to. Waaaaaay back in the Universe Sandbox days. Its been amazing watching you grow yourself and your channel. You good sir are the wonderful person. God bless 🙏

  • @campbellpaul
    @campbellpaul 26 дней назад +3

    I love these vagabond intergalactic objects. I will marry one someday

    • @douglaswilkinson5700
      @douglaswilkinson5700 26 дней назад +1

      A rogue planet or star?

    • @1e33n7
      @1e33n7 26 дней назад +2

      Ima dance happily at the weddings parkinglot, m8

  • @dr.brysonsfamilymedicine2453
    @dr.brysonsfamilymedicine2453 26 дней назад +2

    Thanks

  • @howaboutataste
    @howaboutataste 26 дней назад +2

    What if, "dark matter" is all the same types of matter we have already discovered but existing on seperate vibrational planes? The quanta has slightly different value, such that we are 'out of tune' with it, and the only interaction is the gravitational field.
    The prediction this scenario makes is that we never find WIMPS, or any other DM candidates, or we find that they are super rare in the universe.
    This prediction matches observation wonderfully. That makes it a better scientific speculation than most other hypotheses.

    • @enriquea.fonolla4495
      @enriquea.fonolla4495 21 день назад

      what do you mean by vibrational planes? Like different dimensions?

  • @residentboejiden5796
    @residentboejiden5796 24 дня назад

    Here we areistening to you explain to us what something we dont know what it is being explained to us giving us no more knowledge than we had before. But im here for it cause i like it.

  • @stevenkarnisky411
    @stevenkarnisky411 26 дней назад

    The universe is a vibrator! That's the answer!
    Failing that, I am amazed that a neutron star can spin quickly enough to stave off collapse into singularity. Stranger than we can imagine, indeed!
    Thank you, Antonl

  • @oikkuoek
    @oikkuoek 25 дней назад

    If it stretches/expands, it also vibrates. You can't one without the other. An interesting study would be the direction of the vibration(s). If there is a definite echo, that means the universe has an edge.

  • @aquariussoda007
    @aquariussoda007 25 дней назад

    Gravitational waves is the essence of life throughout all the universes.

  • @carolinestagg6807
    @carolinestagg6807 26 дней назад

    Fascinating!!!!!

  • @BarackObamaJedi
    @BarackObamaJedi 26 дней назад

    I thought the limit of about 2.5 solar masses beyond which stars collapse into black holes was called the Chandrasekar limit, and Oppenheimer's was for white dwarves

  • @mdandry
    @mdandry 23 дня назад

    I absolutely love your videos, but I always think of the great Ricky Bobby quote “I don’t know what to do with my hands” each time I watch 💪🏻😂👍🏻 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

  • @joeyhinds6216
    @joeyhinds6216 26 дней назад +1

    Your previous video makes me think that it may be possible to explain some of these mass gap objects as near supermassive blackhole collisions could it not? Idk seems like a lot of exotic objects could be created in these galaxy forges.

  • @user-hz8uc9iu8c
    @user-hz8uc9iu8c 26 дней назад +2

    do you think there is an attraction between binary objects which involve more than gravity, such as energy in the form of combustion, although technically, combustion is an outward force? and does the collision of stellar bodies necessitate an n-body... please cover also the T Corona Borealis "coming up" !! thank you, Wonderful Person! ❤🎉

  • @axle.student
    @axle.student 26 дней назад

    Sooner or later someone is going to click to the Time-Space problem in physics lol
    Thanks Anton. Always interesting and informative :)

  • @kurhooni5924
    @kurhooni5924 26 дней назад

    I will never thank you enouth for your work, i learn a lot here, i becamea addicted to this, and this is the healthiest addiction of my life^^

  • @stargazer5784
    @stargazer5784 26 дней назад +1

    Cool beans Anton. Thx.

  • @darrenbrians5930
    @darrenbrians5930 26 дней назад +1

    There's a unaverse worth of dark matter. A unaverse worth of spacetime coming in. And a unaverse worth of dark phones hitting our radios. This was a dark star. And there is another dark unaverse. That murged with ours. This was the big bang. Come on, people.

  • @bradleydawson9043
    @bradleydawson9043 26 дней назад +1

    Throughout all of human existence, our only means of observing the Universe outside our planet has been limited to the electromagnetic spectrum. Even the invention of visible light telescopes, followed by radio and upper band receivers has been confined to the EM spectrum. The use of laser interferometry to detect gravity waves is a completely new way to detect events. The revolutionary, groundbreaking nature of this technology cannot be overstated. And it is in its infancy.