The History of the Alans | Total War Cinematic Documentary
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 окт 2024
- #totalwarattila #alans #alani #history
The history of the Alani steppe people; their origins from the Pontic-Caspian Steppe, and their remarkable journeys throughout Europe and their resilient kingdom in the Caucasus Mountains
Video edited and created by = www.youtube.co...
Games:
Total War Attila
Total War Rome II
Mods:
Attila - Fall of the Eagles, 768 Age of Charlemagne Reskin, Medieval Kingdoms 1212 AD,
Rome II - Divide et Impera
Academic Sources:
The Horse, The Wheel, and Language; How Bronze-Age Riders from the Eurasian Steppes shaped the Modern World by David W. Anthony
The Scythians; Nomad Warriors of the Steppe by Barry Cunliffe
Visigothic Spain 409-711 by Roger Collins
The Chronicle of Theophanes by Theophanes the Confessor
Encyclopedia Iranica
Image/Vid sources
Alani reenactors-Jonas Thorwald (www.instagram....)
Alani Warlord (thumbnail) from Joan Francesco Oliveras (www.instagram....)
Aerial stock footage comes from Artgrid
Soundtrack:
Total War Rome II - With Sword and Spear
Total War Attila - Main Theme
Civilization V - Mongolia Peace Theme
Love live Alans❤From your Iranian cousin.
Well done to bring the history of Alans/Ossetians, a tiny nation that managed to navigate their way across the centuries without losing their identity.
they werent tiny in the past and they barely survive today with less then 500,000 people. They used to make up the majority of all Eastern Europe and the caucasus and pontic steppes so from Millions to barely a few hundred thousand.
@@teovu5557 Millions, eh? Population of agricultural Gaul was 5-6 million so the semi-nomadic Alans occupying a relatively small territory could not have possibly be counted in millions. So, I think not.
How is Eastern Europe, the caucsus to the Caspian sea area small? lol
They were numbered at least a few million at there peak hence why most Sarmatian army across several tribes was stated to have 200,000 men at arms each which means their base population is probably triple that including Women and children and old men/women.
@@teovu5557 You're mixing different nations together. Sarmatians are not Alans. The territories weren't that big - the western boundary was river Don, beyond which was the territory of Ostrogoths, Crimea included. The majority of northern Eastern Europe is forested even today. Again, nomads are less populous than agricultural societies so this is unlikely that Alans could number "in millions" while covering relatively small territory compared to such agricultural nation like Gaul.
@@reynardus1359могли и имели большие территории на всей Евразии.
Som iranier har alltid varit intresserad av alaners historia. Tack för videon
Приезжайте к нам в гости в Аланию 🤝
@@INGUSCHIMAMAEBISILA100%. I salute you all. 🟡🔴⚪️
❤
Я Ас-Туалл из Ю.Алании 🤝💪Спасибо за видео 🤝
An intersting fact about the Ossetians/ Alans is that The Tales of The Narts have been translated into English...but 80% of the material still needs translation. This was mentioned by the editor John Colarusso.
Ossetians and Alans are not the same. Early Alans came from Central Asia and were mostly R1B, Ossetians mostly G.
@DavidChekhoev Read Dzhaubermezov Murat and stop bullshiting
@@jailedtwice735Аульного ишака читай сам))
@@jailedtwice735кто это? Очередной фантаст?.
Был в Осетии Алании два раза очень понравилось.Что природа что люди .Добрые но гордые а иногда и вспыльчивые ,Привет Осетии Алании из Питера!!!)
Said Al Maghribi - Kitab Al Jagrafiyya - 13th century: “In the east of Georgia is the country of the Alans. "These are Turks who converted to Christianity."
(Sheshen, 1985: Ramazan (1985), Turks and Their Country according to Islamic geographers. - p. 203).
Abu-l-Feda - Arab Traveler of the 14th century. Takwim Al Buldan: Alans are Turks who converted to Christianity. Nearby there is also a people of the Turkic race called Assy: they are a people of the same origin and the same religion as the Alans.
(Reinaud-MacGuckin de Slane, Aleman Agusti. “Alans in ancient and medieval written sources” p. 202-204)
In Chinese sources, the Alans are listed as a Turkic tribe and are called Alang-ni. In Chinese sources they are also called An-tsi. The Romanians called these people Alani, and the Byzantines called them Asia.
(German Ethnologist EBERHARD, Wolfram. (1942), Northern neighbors of China - p. 153)
We knew the Karachais and Balkars under the name Alans and Ases and correctly calls them Turks. To this day, the territory of Karachay has been assigned the name Alana (in the mouths of the Mingrelians), and Balkaria has the name Asa...
(Ossetian Historian V. ABAEV About the origin of the Karachais and Balkars. Nalchik, 1960, p. 131)
Karachay Tatars or Alans live in the northern parts of the Caucasian Alps, where they are mostly engaged in cattle breeding.
(About the tribes of the globe. St. Petersburg, 1864, part 3, p. 133)
Здарова братик)
Спасибо за добрые слова, приезжайте еще!✊
Салам Питер🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝
The Spanish dog breed Alano Español are the descendents of dogs carried by the Alans into the Iberian Peninsula.
İf you wonder
HISTORICAL RESOURCES ON THE ALANS
Note: It belongs to Persian and Arab travelers who traveled to the Caucasus in the Middle Ages, Ancient Chinese sources, French, German, Russian, Spainian Hungarian, Italian, Georgian Ossetian and historians and scientists.
Original Quotes From Sources.
SAID AL MAGHRIBI "Kitab El Geography" - The Kasaks were the most western of the Caucasian peoples, Ashkeshi, Abkhazians and Alans lived in the east. All were Christians; Except for the Abkhazians, they were all Turks.
AL-TABARI (10th century): "In 112 AH (730-731 AD) al-Jarrah bin Abdallah al-Khaqakmi was defeated and killed by the invading Alanian Turks who came from the country of the Alans, who then took Ardabil.
VEGETIUS RENATUS - Alans and Huns are one people. And it is of the same origin. "Epitoma Rhea Militaris 4th century"
IOSEF FLAVIUS - Alanian language, similar to the Pechenek language. "Ivdevskaya Voyna 1 Century"
"DUAN, "Dinling, Gaoju and Tiele-" Alans; One of the Nine Turuki Tribes of Tiele. One of the Four Tribes of the Great Huns",
EL-BIRUNI- "As-Alans; Christian Turks speaking a mixture of Oguz-Kypchak Turkic languages.",
ABUL FEDA YUSUF “Abul Fida Geography/ Extraits des œuvres de voyageurs Arabes Médiévaux” 1980” “The Alans are Turks who converted to Christianity… Next to them lives the people of the Turkic race Assy. This people has the same origin, the same religion as the Alans."
IBNI KHALDUN "Mukaddime"
- Alans, Azkeshs, Kipchaks, Kerkets, Kimeks and Khazars are Turkic communities.
JORDANES "Kerti Alanorum" in the "Karachai language", 4th Century
EL DIMESHK - "Alans" " in Turkic groups",
JOSAFAT BARBARO-Alanian kings in the Karachai language "Biyberdi, Kertibiy",
EL-MESODI-"Murudjuz Zeheb" As-Alans; Turkish-speaking blonde Turks with a powerful kingdom in the Caucasus. Their western neighbors, the Bulgarians, speak the same Turkish language as them.
The well-known Ossetian origin state historian professor
GEORGY KOKIEV
Claims that the As-Alans are the Karachay-Balkarian people, and not the Ossetians. It is doubtful that the Ossetians were Alans. It is authentically known that Alans were Karachay Turks. Ossetian-Alanian theory is doubtful. And coercion is a theory. (Ossetian professor of history Georgy Kokiev - "On the origin of the Alans" / 1949)
Even GOMEZ TABENERA, J. MANUEL, one of the most famous historians of Spain, says in his book “HISTORIA DE ESPÁNA / Soviet ethnography. - Topic. 5. - M., 1966 "that the Alans, who founded powerful kingdoms in Spain, Portugal and Southern France, were of Turkic origin and that the Alans are the ancestors of the Karachay-Balkarian people.
The well-known historian and expert L.N. GUMILEV says that the Alans are one of the components of this tree in the Genealogical map of the Turks until the 5th century.
E. P. ALEKSAYEVA in the book "Ancient Peoples of the Caucasus. Moscow 1993. P. 13" writes that "Karachay-Balkarians, one of the most ancient peoples of the Caucasus, are the last carriers of the As-Alan ethnonym."
Old Georgian sources often give information about the Basians.
The Kartvelian (Georgian) Prince Vakhushti writes the following: “The Basians are the noblest of all peoples...”
In the newspaper "KAVKAZ" dated December 5, 1853 No. 90 in the article "Turkic tribes" the following quote
“It is written: “Basians” are called Karachays, or Alans, in the valleys of the North Caucasus near Elbrus.”
Also "On the Tribes of the World", St. Petersburg, 1864) writes the following. "Karachays or Alans, live mainly in the northern parts of the Caucasian Alps, where they are engaged in cattle breeding."
JACOB REINEGGS explains: “In the valleys of the Gordion mountains there lives a small tribe named Lazi (Mingrelians), and in the valleys of the main ridge there lives a small people called Alans, and the Nogais call them Edeki-Alans. These people speak a special dialect of the Caucasian Tatar language.”
The German ethnologist and sinologist WOLFRAM EBERHARD also claims that the Alans are mentioned in Chinese sources as a Turkic tribe called Alang-ni.
On the map of the Caucasus, drawn by "Postlethwaite, MALACHI, BULTON, S" in 1755, the for Ossetians were called "Ovseti" Digors "Digori" Kabardians "Kabartians" Karachais "Alani".
HEINRICH BERGHAUS also shows the Karachay-Balkarian people as "Alans" and Ossetians as "Ossetians" on a map in the "Die Völken Des Kaukaus" section of the 1848 Physical Atlas. In the Classification of Nations and Languages; he defined the Alans as "an ancient Turkic people speaking the Turkic language in the North Caucasus".
The famous perologist and historian Maximilian wrote that the Ossetians are a Caucasian people of Iranian origin, even in the book “History of Persia”, written by the award-winning writer FRIEDRICH VON SPIEGEL at the end of the 19th century. He wrote that the inhabitants of Karachay-Balkaria, his neighbors, are the descendants of Alanian.
The French archaeologist and historian RENE GERAUD also stated that the As-Alans were the same people as the Turkic tribe of Uz.
The Russian geographer and historian R.LATAMA also stated in the Scientific article of the Russian Geographical Society in 1854 that the Scythians-Alans were undoubtedly Türks.
The well-known French cartographer and geographer NICOLAS DE FER also called the Ossetians "Usets" and the Karachais "Alans" on a map he compiled in 1691, and wrote a note: "Alanian Karachais and Svans were two peoples living freely in the mountain valleys of Elbrus."
At the beginning of the XIX century. Famous Hungarian scientist and traveler YEVGENY ZICHI: “... Ossetians call the "As" of the for Balkaria and the Karachays in Malka and Kuban” (“Ossetians through the eyes of Russian and foreign travelers”, Ordzhonikidze, 1967, p. 283).
VASILY ABAEV, who first put forward the “Ossetian-Iranian-Alano-Scythian” theory, admitted that the Ossetians called the Karachay-Balkarian people “Ases” and that the Karachay and Balkar peoples could be the descendants of the Proto-Alans. (IESOYA vol. 1 p. 79).
Article "Svaneti", 1845:
"It is remarkable that the Svanetians do not call their neighbors the Karachays otherwise than the Alans. This is a trace for the historians of the ancient people - About the Alans.
LZ. The above information was written down by me after a conversation with the son of the Sovereign Prince of Svanetia, Mikhail Didishkeliani, who was brought up in the S.P. Cadet Corps * and ** is now in Tiflis in military service. October 15th day, 1845. "
N.G. VOLKOVA "Ethnonyms and tribal names of the North Caucasus:
"The Ossetians, flat and mountainous, the names Asi (Balkaria) and Asiag, Aesson (Balkarians) are well known to the Digorians, and they quite clearly associate them with the Turkic-speaking population living beyond the Stuliaftseg pass. The Digor name of Karachay is Ustur-Asi, i.e. (As - Alans Other Name)
The Hungarian Turkologist GYULA NEMET also stated that most of the words in the 1422 Dictionary of Old Words of the Hungarian Ases (Alans) are Turkic origin.
The well-known geneticist of Slavic origin Professor ANATOLE KLESOV also claims that as a result of research, the genetics of the Alans is compatible with the peoples of Karachay-Balkaria and has nothing to do with the Ossetians.
Alanian Dna Haplogrup (R1a-M198- Z123-124-93 clad G2a-P15-16 clad J1+J2a clad)
Karachay Dna Haplogroup Pool R1a-M198-Z123-124-93 clad/ G2a-P15/ J1+J2a1a
Ossetian Dna Haplogroup Pool G2a-P17-J2a1a-E1b1b none R1a clads
@@Sranuriчурка 😂😂😂😂😂 из тебя Алан ,как из маймуна Человек 😂😂😂😂
Did you notice in the maps early in the video of the eastern 'Iberia' in approximately the Georgia region of the Caucus? The eastern branch of the Alans eventually went there.
Yes, an alliance of Goths and Alans migrated to Iberian peninsula. They were the Goth-Alans and an area came to be known as Gothalania >> Catalonia.
Alano is absolutely fabulous, versatile, intelligent and very strong dog. Just like the Alans and all Sarmatians were.
This is a really great video. Keep up the great work and hope you guys get recognition in the future.
This is so cool. Respect from Kurdish relative to all Ossetians Iranian family
Fuck off. We’re not part of your Iranian family kebob
Kurds were not a specific ethnic group. Persians were dependent on slavery, and they were hunting for
slaves. These slaves turned into different Iranian speaking groups. So don't be that much thankful.
@@almazchati4178 Kurds are decant from Qutians Lullubians Elamites and Medes we are older than persians
Are you a diguasting Turko-mongo which tries to lunch his subh**
politic agenda @@almazchati4178
Your mother is maybe also not specific, we can't see who the turkic woman is in anatolia maybe the ottomans raped your turkic mother there and remember the ottomans are genetically not turkic @@almazchati4178
Thank you for this great episode. I wish there could be one or two episode about our Iranian (Aryan tribes) migrations over time along Danube to north of Azov Sea and naming the various Iranian tribes (example Medes, Persians, Alans, Sintashta, Scythians, Tocharians...) by approximate date as we went east to north of India and Western China and South to Iran's current territory. And as you briefly touched on going back to Europe to Central Europe, Hungary, France, Spain and Italy and melting into those populations culturally and Genetically. The Alan king that ruled part of France (Burgendy) was Gohar and then his son Sangvand (Sangiban). Gohar means rare gem.
Irata razma!
This is a really cool way to do history, I really enjoyed it! Subbed and looking forward to seeing more
Welcome aboard!
I'm from Hungary and I have partial alan roots.
Because you have Jasz ancestors?
Приезжайте на свою Родину ❤ буду рад встретить 🤝
@@alexanderlejon9958well from my father side my grandma is mixed with jasz and cuman and a bit gypsy
Ты тогда наш брат получется😊 Я сам из Осетии
Если ты из Яссов, то ты наш брат 😊
In modern Ossetia they have a sub-ethnic group called the Alae and Alagirs(Alan-men)
Also the Aorsi is still apart of modern Ossetian sub-ethnic groups like the Ors-tual(White/Shining Tuals.
and the Tagaurs(Shining/white Mountaineers). Also caucasian tribes used to call all Ossetians as "Asi".
In modern Pakistan and Afghanistan there is an Iranic and Aryan ethnic group called The Sarmastani(Sarmatian)
In Mongolia the Alans who joined the Mongol is called the Asud clan today also called the Jasin.
And in Hungarians the Jasz people.
im afghan and got Alan in my dna lmfao
@@kreany8981В Вашем Горном Бадахшане До сих пор Проживают Достойные Потомки Своих Сакских Предков Тохаристана со Столицей Арианна и До Сих пор Эти Сакские Потомки носят Сакский Этноним»ТОХАРЫ»,Что скажете насчет Сакского Этноса Тохары в Афганистане?!.
Очень Интересная и Объективная Историческая Информация🔱🍙⚜️🐺🐎🦅🗡️🏹🛡🎠👨👩👧💕😍💂♂️🧕🥰😇🤝🤲✊Вы из Какой Страны и из Какого Этноса ЕвраАзий будете Сами?!.
Какие еще субэтнические группы алагирцы, аланмэны, ты что куришь?) Алагирский говор это часть иронского диалекта, также, как и туальский, и тагаурский
Holy crap! This is an excellent video! Great work. Really good video. Cheers from Tennessee
Cheers from Alania-Osetia
Another great total war channel to subscribe to. Looking forward for more amazing videos like this.
Ikr?! Seems like an explosion of Total War content recently. I love it!
Bro ...very well done. You pack so much relevant detailed info into your presentation. That must have been so much work. Thank you so much. Thoroughly enjoyed it
Much appreciated!
I have read that "Alan" is a corruption of sorts of the word "Aryan," as is the name "Iran." So they were probably of the Indo-Persian branch of the Indo-European peoples.
Yes, this is correct.
alans!! alans!!alans!! alans!!alans!! alans!!
wait, maybe thats steves...STEVES!!STEVES!!
The historical capital of the Romanian medieval kingdom of Moldavia is the city of Iasi, today in Romania (and country's second largest city after the capital, Bucharest), also named historically Targul Iasilor/Iesilor, meaning in Romanian "the market place of the Yasik people"
Also many Alans from Franks went to Brittany and then to America, where the name Alan is very common...
also I've heard that alans were fighting for Spain as payed soldiers
You mean Armorica, I presume.
Да. На счёт имени Алан вы правы
A very good video with plenty of historical info
Keep up the good work
Alans Call Their Homeland Eiran/Ireston/ Iron
Был два раза в Осетии Алании ,и местные на осетинском говори что это Иристон .Я их спрашиваю так это Осетия Алания или Иристон,они ответили и то и другое
Осетия Алания это название не на нашем языке, а на осетинском - Ирыстон
Точнее Ирия , если на русский лад @@norangli1571
Осетинские историки Петр Козаев, Георгий Кокиев и Махти Дзуртубаев писали, что осетины не были аланского происхождения, а карачаевцы были аланского происхождения. Что ты об этом думаешь?
@@Nebulavis А чем вы слушаете?
Или вы в это время в мечтах летаете и свои фантазии потом пишете?
Что то я их тоже слушаю и нигде они не говорят что осетины не Аланы
И то что Козаев говорил что у Алан в разных местах под разными именами знают,это не говорит что они не Аланы
Вы ни к одной из этих имен не подходите
Аорсы и Сираки, РоксАланы это все только к одному народу
И Кокиев тоже не писал что предки осетин не Аланы
Он наоборот писал что осетины в Грузии не пришлые, что наши предки Скифы всегда там и жили.
Вот за это его и расстреляли
Точно так же как и Гаглоева Рутена который построил тоннель между двумя Осетиями
А вы настолько глупы, что не слушая,не читая, свои мечты озвучиваете
Cheers to the Iranian/Aryan family
❤️
🤝🤝🤝💪
Do PIE people like pie?
Today, G2a y DNA haplogroup is found in many late period Alan graves. The Ossetian people have the most genetics in the world today. Alans are undoubtedly the ancestors of the Ossetians, genetics and language also say this. science no longer discusses this. Ossetia-Alania.
So you say that the Alans are the ancestors of the Ossetians. Because the Ingush and Georgians say that the Alans are not Ossetians and the Ossetians are lying.
G2a и r1a-z93 вместе присутствуют в y-ДНК аланов. Субмутации g2a также несовместимы с осетинами. У карачаевцев есть гаплогруппы как r1a-z93, так и g2a-p15. r1a-z93 характерен также для скифов и хазар.
@@Nebulavis Турок, ты куда лезешь, иди в очко залезь к Эрдогану
У осетин основная гаплогруппа g2a1 p18 (>70%)и ей не более 1000 лет и к тому же эта гаплогруппа является дочерней к основной сванской гаплогруппе g2a1 p16 (78%) то есть отец осетин это сван.Такая же гаплогруппа и у грузин.Поэтому ну никак осетины не могут быть потомками алан, осетины являются потомками или сван или грузин.
@@iosifkappush Это говорит заслуженный доктор наук в области фантастики?)
Travels through Europe, Asia and Africa, from 1394 to 1427. [Johann Schiltberger]
“….. Even when the river near which the city of Ornas, flooded by the Mongols, lay was called Don, as stated in several manuscripts, this apparent contradiction would be explained by the fact that the Alans, of whom part of the townspeople consisted, to the main river receiving in their own homeland, the tributaries Ardon (mad river), Ursdon (white river), etc., could use the name Don!!!, just as their Turkish fellow citizens could mean the same river with the common name Itil or Edil."
"Don" in Ossetian language "WATER"
• Don is a large river in the European part of Russia, flowing into the Sea of Azov.
• Don is a river in England on which the cities of Sheffield and Doncaster stand.
• Don is a river in Scotland on which the city of Aberdeen stands.
• Don is a river in France, a tributary of the Vilaine.
Today, the entire central Caucasus is full of hydronyms with the “DON” part, especially in Ossetia, including the Ardon and Ursdon rivers.
Отлично написано☝️👍👍👍 Так и есть. Правда
Дон и в этой реке КАФА РЫБА с осетинского
Феодосия АвдАрта семибожный город
И Кафа РЫБА с осетинского
Есть и месяц рыб, это октябрь КафТы маей
Есть и КафХьуынДар у осетин дракон волосатая рыба с которой были Аланы
И рыба, дельфин это символ Христа и христианства.
Христос это ИХТИС рыба
И Крещение водой
И головной убор у католиков и в православной религии называют МИТРО, который похож на голову рыбы, дельфин
И Дзерасса дочь ДонБеттара ВЛАДЫКИ МОРСКОЙ, рыба птица
И Сатана, Сатеник внучка ДонБеттара ВЛАДЫКИ МОРСКОЙ
Olá sou do Brasil! Seu vídeo ficou excelente, põe sobre mais povos das estepes, eu coloquei as legendas em português e consegui acompanhar todo seu trabalho! Parabéns
Вы далеко от нас😂 Привет из Осетии-Аланий
Subbed, liked, belled. This is some amazing, in-depth history there, loved it!
Весь Мир знает и говорит,что Асетины и есть скифо сармато аланы, а некотопые все еще бьются о скалы пытаясь стать Аланами..
Характерные гаплогруппы карачаево-балкарских тюрков и скифов одинаковы;
С VI века до н.э. Карта Y-ДНК
Понтийские скифы: R1a-z93-z2123 %40
Карачаевская Y-ДНК: R1a-z93-z2123 %36
Осетинская Y-ДНК: R1a-z93-2123 %0,8
(familytreedna/groups/k-balkar-dna/about/)
(familytreedna/groups/ossetian-dna/about)
И никогда не станут 😜😃😅😝🤓😂😂
@@ГеоргийАбаев-к9м ☝👍👍👍конкчно! Потому,что это --невозможно
❤❤❤
Even the Karachays and Balkars are largely Ossetian. They largely carry Ossetian G2a haplogroups. We can say that they are Ossetians who assimilated into the Kipchak language.
Они и есть татары кипчако половецкой группы, со всем ихбагажом-язык,верования,обычаи,самоназаание,быт--кьумыс,къазы, къайра,бешбармакъ итд итп, а не асимилированные асетины.
We belong to different subclades of the g2a haplogroup. We are different from the Ossetians. Ossetians G2a-3b1 + g2a-p16. Karachay g2a-p15
Lol! Have you seen Karachay-Balkar Y-DNA nigg**+
Love the way they dressed. It's a cross between old-Viking, Mongol and old Greek before they put all those heavy metal shields around their body and horses. These warriors could tolerate cold weather and basically tough. They know the practical way to train the horses and pack lightly from one place to another
Great idea for a video, got a new subscriber!
The ALANI a few times fought against the Byzantine empire, but most of the time were allies and mercenaries of the Byzantine Greek Orthodox Empire. A friend from Greece
"Byzantine Greek Orthodox Empire""??? there is no such empire
who sees similarities with the Serbs? Even Yazigis migrated in todays Serbia long BC, Alans came with other Slavic peoples also to Serbia. On the other hand, there is a mention from ancient Greek records about Serboi, Amazones, Albanians etc. that lived in the Caucassus... So interesting x)
I from Alania Ossetian ✊✊✊
unfortunately Osetians are not Alan. You are genetically Karvelian origin Ossetian Y-dna Haplogrup G2a-P18+J1+E1b1b haplogrup. Alanian y-dna Haplogrup R1a-z93-123-124-m198(arian) G2a-p15(Caucausoid) j2a
@@Sranuri 🤦🤦🤦I don't talk to stupid people...
study this question again
Haplogroup G2a (P15+) was discovered in an Alan burial of the 5th-6th centuries
Further: a certain amount of DNA from the Alans from the 2nd to the 10th centuries has already been studied. And among them, the haplogroup G2a1a was also found, as well as other haplogroups found both among Ossetians and other peoples of the Caucasus...🤭🤭🤭
@@hohag 😄Don't worry, I know better than you. I'm already talking about him. In the analysis extracted from Alan tombs in Dargavs, Crime, Zelenchuk, Terek, Teberdi tombs, almost all of the Alans carry 38% R1a-z+m haplogroup and 35% G2a-P15 genetics in their DNA pool. The r1a rate in Ossetian genetics is 1%. G2a-p15 belongs to the suborder Kubanoid, Caucausid. Also, Ossetians have subclades of p17 and different clades unrelated to Alans, in contrast to G2a-p15. and even this ratio does not match. 60% and above.
@@Sranuri 🤣🤣🤣🤣Georgian fairy tales.......
you are Ottoman Mamluks, you got to lie everywhere about Ossetians
@@hohag I have no intention of attacking you. this is real. You are Georgians who have adopted the Persian language. You are of Georgian origin. Christianity even passed on to you from the Georgians. i remind. it's a scientific fact. You wouldn't even be semi-independent without Russia.
thanks for posting this, idk why but alan is a highly common name for men in sorani kurdish
Alan is actually a derivation of the word Aryan, Iran etc. All Iranic peoples.
❤️
Совершенно верно 🎉🎉🎉
Hey , remember "Decisive Battles" back when the History Channel wasn't garbage?? That show got me into Total War. I was like: I must own that game 😮
Great!!! Good job!
Thanks!!
The greatest known Alan king is David Soslan. The name Soslan is mentioned in Ossetian Nart epics. Georgians knew the Alans best in the Caucasus. They called the Alans "Os". Those. Alans are genetically and historically the ancestors of the Ossetians.
"Alan!" - A velociraptor from the dream of a famous movie paleontologist.
Instant Subscribe. Excellent niche
Wanna know something I found that I have yet to hear?
Well Wū Zetian and Mary of Scots are in same family line on my tree.
Mary was an alan and I’m 99.9% sure zetian is an early form of Ossetian and the “Aussie” part of Ossetian may have been added after the exile of Wu zetians peeps to chinas neighboring famous prison land…
Also Wū has a parallel in British history as Edda/Ida/Oda the beggar saint.
Great video I’m loving it!
Ossetian are not Alans. Karachay-Balkar Turks are Alanian origin.
I am Mexican American, 4% North Caucasian (Circassian/Ossetian). 4% of my DNA comes from these people.
I confirmed Alans invaded Spain.
I’m 55% Spaniard. 40% Native American.
Lol how do you know you’re Circassian Ossetian? 😅
Мир твоему дому Брат 🤝 Я Алан Асетин 🤝 рад буду встретить тебя на древней Земле Алании 🤝
@@2pock DNA tests. My markers, at least 4% match with those from those areas. I’ve learned I got this DNA from Alan Kingdom in Southwestern Spain.
@@thearyamehrrf6886 there’s no such thing as Circassian/Ossetian, because the sample would broadly show you Western Asia, Georgia, turkey, or eastern Anatolia. This is what real Circassian/ossetians get. How did it precisely determine Circassian/ossetian for you? this isn’t cherry picking my guy. And even if that’s the case, really? You’re going to go on about 4%?!?!
@@2pock
I know there’s no such thing, Circassian is completely separate from North Iranian Ossetians. I put the slash, because my results tend to match people from those groups in those regions I’m in now way trying to say they are the same people or one in the same… definitely not..
Circassians and Ossetians seem to have the highest percentages of my group, though. That’s all.
No need to feel some kind of way. No one’s cherry picking nor am I going on about anything… I’m in an open forum sharing my genealogical research. If it bothers you, I’m sorry.
Again, I get it from the Alans of Spain. There can be no other way.
I'm from Pakistan an my caste is aryan proud of my
Ancestral heritage
The Alans of Gaul are not given enogh attention in Western history. Glad you spoke of them.
There is a Germanic tribe named Alan as well. A researcher drew attention to this fact. The result of mixing the origin of the Caucasus Alans and the Germanic tribe is total confusion
A similar case is that of the Getai of N Thrace and the Jutes of Jutland[Denmark].
Где можно за это взять информацию?
Я в дестве слышал от дедушки, что немцы и осетины родственны.
@@Hudal.7912Гот Алания☝Готы от аланов и пошли
AWESOME VIDEO MAN
The Caucasian Alans were received by the Hungarian king ...they were fleeing the invasion of Timur the Khan of the Mongolians. The Iazyges are still found in Hungary as a community...i think this clip is actually mixing the Germanic Alans with the Caucasian Alans.
are there any proof/writings about "massagetae" and "thyssagetae" tribs being located so far away from black sea, and near the aral/caspian see?
Woooooow always thought Alenquer was from arabic... I am honestly surprised! Great video!
One correction. In 33" till 60'' you show a map that depicts Bosporus in the Crimean peninsula. The Bosporus is close to the Dardanelle, in CONSTANTINOPLE. A friend from Greece
Yeah, that is weird haha.
It's supposed to be the Bosporan Kingdom, which ruled in that region during that time
I am so proud of our Iranian tribes contributing to the history of the world and it is interesting when Ossetian language is spoken how much of it can be understood by Iranians of Iran or our other tribes now in Russia or Europe. A lot of times we just need to speak slower and pronounce things clearly so many of our tribes can communicate with each other. Maybe one day we can all go back to our pagan past along Danube and Azov sea.🎉 Our industrious people have contributed so much to the world's progress and stability when few regions were stable.
"Pagan past"?? Wtf are you talking about? Indoeuropeans are the real Chosen People, and their way is the highest one, in Christ! Danube? You make me laugh- there were, and still are, Daoi/Daks. They are called Romanians now.
How old are you, like 12??
I am ossetian and I've started learning farsi
@@Мария-л2ю9ж I am so glad to hear that. I think you already know a lot of words. From what I have heard a lot of words are the same, maybe different pronunciations and some of the words used in Ossetian are the exact words in Persian (Farsi), but today's Iranians do not use the words as in the past few centuries (last 500 years, Iranians have started to use substitute words. Sort of Icelandic people (like Ossetians) use an older original version of modern German! I think this can be very interesting. Please let me know if you need any help with Persian or English. I am not sure if there are any Persian /Ossetian dictionaries available (since I cannot read any Cyrilic. Let me know if I can help.
@johndewey6358 متشکرم thank you. How can I contact with you?
Сами откуда вы? Извините..
Very interesting. Thanx.
Alans were also called Ass, Os. The Germanic peoples pre-Christian gods were called the Aesir (also called Ass and Os) and in the Ynglinga Saga says the came from East of the Don Diver above the Black Sea - right where the Alans come from. It’s seen in English names like Osborne and Oswald and many other Germanic peoples like Scandinavian names as well.
"Hungarian scientist and traveler Evgeny Zichi: The Ossetians call themselves "Iron", and the Balkars and Karachays of Malka and Kuban are called "As" by the Ossetians."
(“Ossetians through the Eyes of Russian and Foreign Travelers - (XIII-XIX вв.), Ordzhonikidze, p. 283 - [Collection] Зевакина И. С. / Северо-Осетинское книжно е изд-во 1967)
"ALANI: Mingrelians call the Karachay Turks who live on the northern side of the main ridge of the Caucasus, near Elbrus, at the source of the Kuban River, 'Alans'. ALANI KOCHI: Strong like the Alans.."
(Georgian Linguist and Philologist Prof. Dr. Ioseb Kipshidze - "Грамматика Мингрельского (Иверского)Языка - "Megrelian-Russian Dictionary" section, p.193, Изданной В Санкт-Петербурге, В Типографии Императорской Академии Н аук, в 1914 г.")
"Two closely related peoples - Alans and Ases - are the direct ancestors of the Karachays and Balkars, and the Mingrelians (Western Georgians) call the Karachays still Alans, the Ossetians call the Balkars the As, and call the region in which they lived "Asiag" (i.e. "Land of the Ases"), and the Karachays "Stur Asiag". ("Greater Asia") they call it."
(Historian Prof. Dr. Laipanov Kazi Tanaevich - "Этногенетические Взаимосвязи Карачаево-Балкарцев С Др угими Народами" p.10 Cherkesssk/2000)
"We conclude this overview of the various Iranian peoples with a scattered branch of them that lives quite separately from all other tribes. The Osseti live in the north and south of the Caucasus, where the Daryal passes form the main northward passage of the Caucasus. Their name gives a clue to their origins, since they call themselves not Ossen but Iron and their country Ironistan. The name Ossen was given to them by neighboring peoples, but they themselves use it for the Balkars, the descendants of the western Alans, who lived northeast of Elbrus."
(Prof. Friedrich von Spiegel, Member of the Prussian Academy of Sciences, German Orientalist and Scientist, Pioneer of Iranian Philology - Erânischen Altertumskunde {Leipzig, 1871-78, 3 volumes} Volume 1 p.369/German)
"..It is known that the Ossetians called their western neighbors, the Balkars, "As" and their country "Asiag".
(Prof. Dr. Vladimir Aleksandrovich Kuznetsov - "Аланские Племена Северного Кавказа" p.87 Издательство Ака демии Наук Ссср Москвва /1962)
"{14th Century AD} Abu'l Fida - Takvim al-Buldan: East of Abkhazia there is a city inhabited by Alans. The Alans are Turks who converted to Christianity. Nearby there is also a Turkic people called As. They are a people of the same origin and religion as the Alans."
(Géographie d'Aboulféda. Traduite de l'arabe en Français. Par M. Reinaud. Tome II. Première partie. Paris. 1848. s. 286-287.)
"{13th century AD} Said al-Magribi - Kitab al-Jagrafiyya: To the east of Georgia is the land of the Alans. These are among the Turks who converted to Christianity"
(Prof. Dr. Ramazan Şeşen (1985). According to Islamic Geographers Turks and Turkish Countries. p.203 - Ankara: Turkish Culture Research Institute Publications)
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Спасибо!
nothing about Sambida and Beorgor the alani chieftains in Valentia???
Documentaries as short as this one will always leave out one or two things, either intentionally or otherwise. But now's your chance to enlighten us on these characters
Lol recently, I start back replay rome total war 2, currently I playing campaign as alans, surprising this vid is right on time I want to know more of history
I already did alani campaign on Atilla total war, now starting replay other game total war
Actual Aryans in Europe
We Kurds name our sons Alan 😁 we are close to Ossetians
Курды тоже иранской группы?
@@Hudal.7912yes
Обратите внимание на карты, а конкретно на южную часть Алании на каждой из них.
Это даст вам ответ на вопрос, почему Южная Осетия всегда хотела быть независимой от Грузии.
Very interesting to hear about the alanis people Which I always thought were Germanic people, But there different Types went different ways and come into europe been from Scotland always heard that we came out from the cimmerians scythian The Celtic nation Pontic Celtic, people . Still live there. Near turkey
Alani best frends for Bulgarians in midle age .
They were eastern Iranic speakers. The Persians, Parthians and Medes ( settlers of the Iranian plareau)were western Iranics, th Eastern and western split took place some 2500 bc ,actually the eastern- speakers were considered as Turanis or an-Irani / un-Iraians by ancient Persians , we were always at war and they killed Zoraster .
Ancient Iranians defined the term Turan to mean Turkic speaking tribes who had migrated to the Eastern frontier of Iranzamin (Iran)encompassing much of Central Asia NOT the original Iranic inhabitants of those lands as you mentioned.
I have met persons from present day Iran. One can mistake them with present day western Europeans such as France or the uk .
Whoa! What a tough group of people
All iranic people are welcome to their home land 🤗💜.
👍🏻👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻
ALANIA - NORD -OSETIA
🔱🍙⚜️🐺🐎🦅🗡️🏹🛡🎠👨👩👧😍💕💂♂️🧕🥰😇🤝🤲🕋🤲✊Это-Истина,Не то что,Выдуманная и Высосанная из Карманных(Личных Историков)Кровавого Осетинского Тирана и Диктатора Иосифа Дзугаева(Сталина) Подарившего Всю Славную и Доблестную Историю Кочевых,Воинственных и Свободолюбивых Племенных Союзов ЕвраАзий Пришлым на Северный Кавказ из Персий с Войском Персидского Шаха Оседлым Земледельцам/Ремесленникам Персам/Иронам🤫🤭🥲Дигорский Автохонный Этнос и Пришлые Персы/Ироны Это Совсем Два Разных по Этногенезу и по Происхождению Два Разных НаРода/Этноса В Силу Сталинской Системы Геноцида и Преследований Всех Кочевых Племенных Союзов ЕвраАзий и Коверкания и Заново Сочиненный Версий под Дулами Чекистов и Партийной Цензуры Переписи и Исковеркавшей и Сочинивших Всю Историю Братских НаРодов СССР🤫🤭🥲Уже Видя ,Что Вся Лживо/Сказочно/Сочиненная Пропагандонами Сталинской Системы Тираний и Диктатуры Вранье,Ложь и Фантастическая Версия Происхождения Кочевых,Воинственных и Свободолюбивых Сакских Племенных Союзов Всю Свою Героическо/Драматическую Историю Мужественно и Доблестно Отражавших Военную Экспансию и Завоевательную Политику Оседло/Земледельческой Персидской Империй Тщетно Проводивших Свои Попытки по Завоеванию Сакских Кочевников и на Этом Пути Сакские Кочевники Всегда Ломали Хребет и Гордыню Алчных и Надменных Иронских Шахиншахов и Теперь Видя Что Весь Ворох Грязного Персидского белья и Сказочно/Фантастической Версий Сталинских ЛжеИсториков и Нигде в Мировых Научных Кругах Никем Не признанных и СамоЛично Награжденных Иосифом Сталиным Осетинских ЛжеАкадемиков Сочинивших Новую Историю Братских НаРодов СССР и Видя Какое Позорное Фиаско и Скандальное Раскрытие Всех Последствий Этой Кровавой и Мрачной Тайны СвежеСочиненной Историй НаРодов СССР под Диктовку Сталинских СпецСлужб и Партийной Цензуры за Эти Годы Тираний Сталинской Кровавой Диктатуры Осетинского Фашиста/Расиста Залившего Кровью Всей Советской Интеллигенций и Мировых Академиков/Востоковедов/Тюркологов и После Таких Скандальных и Позорных Раскрытий Этой СвежеСочиненной Сталинскими Карманнными Фальшивыми Академиками Лживо/Исковерканной Пропагандистской Историй Всех НаРодов(((Особенно Кочевых ПротоТюркских и Тюркских Племенных Союзов ЕвраАзий в СССР подручными Чекистскими Палачами и Подхалимами Отца Всех НаРодов Иосифа Сталина и Видя Что Все Тайное-Как Всегда Становится Явным и Эти Расисты/Фашисты/Нацисты из Последователей Своего Осетинского Фюрера Иосифа Дзугаева(Сталина) Теперь в Спешном порядке и Панически Пытаются Весь Этот Смрадный Мусор Коммунистическо/Чекистской Идеологий и Этот Грязно/Кровавый Ворох Персидско/Иронского Сталинского Белья в Спешном Порядке пытаются Экспортировать в Неискушенную в Нашей Кровавой Диктатуре и Никогда Не слышавших Что Творил в СССР Маньяк и Фашист Сталин Европейской Публике🔱🍙⚜️🐺🐎🦅🗡️🏹🛡🎠🤝😇🤲✊
🔱🍙⚜️🐺🐎🦅🗡️🏹🛡🎠👨👩👧😍💕💂♂️🧕🥰😇🤝🤲🕋🤲✊Это-Истина,Не то что,Выдуманная и Высосанная из Карманных(Личных Историков)Кровавого Осетинского Тирана и Диктатора Иосифа Дзугаева(Сталина) Подарившего Всю Славную и Доблестную Историю Кочевых,Воинственных и Свободолюбивых Племенных Союзов ЕвраАзий Пришлым на Северный Кавказ из Персий с Войском Персидского Шаха Оседлым Земледельцам/Ремесленникам Персам/Иронам🤫🤭🥲Дигорский Автохонный Этнос и Пришлые Персы/Ироны Это Совсем Два Разных по Этногенезу и по Происхождению Два Разных НаРода/Этноса В Силу Сталинской Системы Геноцида и Преследований Всех Кочевых Племенных Союзов ЕвраАзий и Коверкания и Заново Сочиненный Версий под Дулами Чекистов и Партийной Цензуры Переписи и Исковеркавшей и Сочинивших Всю Историю Братских НаРодов СССР🤫🤭🥲Уже Видя ,Что Вся Лживо/Сказочно/Сочиненная Пропагандонами Сталинской Системы Тираний и Диктатуры Вранье,Ложь и Фантастическая Версия Происхождения Кочевых,Воинственных и Свободолюбивых Сакских Племенных Союзов Всю Свою Героическо/Драматическую Историю Мужественно и Доблестно Отражавших Военную Экспансию и Завоевательную Политику Оседло/Земледельческой Персидской Империй Тщетно Проводивших Свои Попытки по Завоеванию Сакских Кочевников и на Этом Пути Сакские Кочевники Всегда Ломали Хребет и Гордыню Алчных и Надменных Иронских Шахиншахов и Теперь Видя Что Весь Ворох Грязного Персидского белья и Сказочно/Фантастической Версий Сталинских ЛжеИсториков и Нигде в Мировых Научных Кругах Никем Не признанных и СамоЛично Награжденных Иосифом Сталиным Осетинских ЛжеАкадемиков Сочинивших Новую Историю Братских НаРодов СССР и Видя Какое Позорное Фиаско и Скандальное Раскрытие Всех Последствий Этой Кровавой и Мрачной Тайны СвежеСочиненной Историй НаРодов СССР под Диктовку Сталинских СпецСлужб и Партийной Цензуры за Эти Годы Тираний Сталинской Кровавой Диктатуры Осетинского Фашиста/Расиста Залившего Кровью Всей Советской Интеллигенций и Мировых Академиков/Востоковедов/Тюркологов и После Таких Скандальных и Позорных Раскрытий Этой СвежеСочиненной Сталинскими Карманнными Фальшивыми Академиками Лживо/Исковерканной Пропагандистской Историй Всех НаРодов(((Особенно Кочевых ПротоТюркских и Тюркских Племенных Союзов ЕвраАзий в СССР подручными Чекистскими Палачами и Подхалимами Отца Всех НаРодов Иосифа Сталина и Видя Что Все Тайное-Как Всегда Становится Явным и Эти Расисты/Фашисты/Нацисты из Последователей Своего Осетинского Фюрера Иосифа Дзугаева(Сталина) Теперь в Спешном порядке и Панически Пытаются Весь Этот Смрадный Мусор Коммунистическо/Чекистской Идеологий и Этот Грязно/Кровавый Ворох Персидско/Иронского Сталинского Белья в Спешном Порядке пытаются Экспортировать в Неискушенную в Нашей Кровавой Диктатуре и Никогда Не слышавших Что Творил в СССР Маньяк и Фашист Сталин Европейской Публике🔱🍙⚜️🐺🐎🦅🗡️🏹🛡🎠🤝😇🤲✊
It’s crazy that a lot of Western Europeans origin is form the east
Of course, our origins are between black sea, azov sea, caucasous, caspian sea and ural mountains.
why was that part cut at 14:22?
Subscribed
Tyyy im Alani and this is really nice history stuff I didn’t know that lmao
Goa Goa Goa ! I took my laptop flee as a wind ! I seen their real faces ! Toxic ! 😂
They started as YANCAI in NW China
А где перевод тут только субтитры на английском,я как Осетинка мне интересно,что тут рассказывает автор. Буду благодарна если будет перевод на русском языке.❤❤❤❤
в настройках можно сделать перевод субтитров на русский.
Having met the Allan of 2024 Barbie movie, this all takes on new meaning: 6:10 , 6:12 , 6:18
14:14= OSI = ŐSI ! [ IN HUNGARIAN LANGUAGE ] = OLDES : the "unmixed" alan's . That mean = the oldest alan's branch , who they was not joyned any other relative races . Etc...
Я ОСЕТИН ..И СПАСИБО ЧТО ВЕСЬ МИР ЗНАЕТ НАШУ КУЛЬТУРУ И ХРАБРОСТЬ НАШИХ ВОИНОВ....КАТОРЫМ НЕБЫЛО РАВНЫХ.. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
👍
Did Alans have haplogroup Q1a
yes they did
Kurd ❤ Alan
Ossetian alans = ŐSSZÉKI ALÁN'S -> A BRANCH OF THE SAKA ->SZAKA -> SZÉKI -> SZÉKELY RACE BRANCH . Etc...
Another Turkic tribe with which Alans came in contact in the 5th and 6th century was Bulgars and then Khazars who pushed the Alan state beyond the river Terek . Alania was a vassal state of Khazars for two centuries .
Thanks for the info
@@TotalWarHistory. Will you cover Turkic nomads like Bulgars, Khazars, Avars, Cumans, Huns, Kipchaks, Pechenegs, Naimans, Shatuo, Khalajs etc.?
@@papazataklaattiranimamfck Turk kopek
I am from republic of North Alania
Basically my wavelength is completely on top of all of you ! Sudan Suleiman comes peasants leaves ! I am that him the tall man 180 190 CM behind that Bosnian Ughur girl !
Damn dude, must be some really strong hashish you have over there!
There is yet another case of confusion based on homonyms, that of the Caucasian Albanians and the European Albanians[ shqip].
War chief Greenspan. 😊
Based iranics
Alan Partridge
Потому ты Босс ! Ты шучу ! 🧔👃😤
14:30 Their clothes look like Circassian.🤔
This dress does not belong to the Circassians. It is present in all communities in the Caucasus. and its name is "Chuha". Dode Zvezdana Vladimirovna from the Archaeological Research Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences stated that, according to her studies, the oldest prototype of this outfit belonged to the Khazar People and that it may have been inherited from the Khazar Turks in the Caucasus. It is also the same prototype as the Traditional costume worn by Central Asian Turks called Shepken. (Türkmen and Uygur Costume) . Also According to Georgian Sources, it is the oldest local costume of Georgians.
SOURCES:
Dode Zvezdana Vladimirovna. Medieval costume of the peoples of the North Caucasus: articles on history / T.V. Cantor. - Moscow: Eastern Literature, 2001. - P. 105. - 136 p.
Dode Z.V. Summary: 7.-17. Costume of the population of the North Caucasus in the 16th centuries (Reconstruction of ethnosocial history) / Doctor of Historical Sciences. State E.G. - Moscow: Archaeological Institute RAS, 209. - P. 24. - 35 p.
Abashidze, Irakli. Ed. Georgian Encyclopedia. Vol. IX. Tbilisi, Georgia: 1985.
luiza-m.narod.ru/smi/ethnic/kuban-kazak.htm
Kajitani, Nobuko (2001). "A man's caftan and leggings from the North Caucasus of the eighth to tenth century : a conservator's report / Nobuko Kajitani". Metropolitan Museum Journal. 36.
We knew the Karachais and Balkars under the name Alans and Ases and correctly calls them Turks. To this day, the territory of Karachay has been assigned the name Alana (in the mouths of the Mingrelians), and Balkaria has the name Asa...
(Ossetian Historian V. ABAEV About the origin of the Karachais and Balkars. Nalchik, 1960, p. 131)
Фэнтэзи в сторону гардаш, вы татары, кипчако половецкой группы,думаете тут свои бредни выставите и вуаля-станете индоариями Асетинами???😂😂😂😂Вы уже и на международный уровень вышли по выставлению себя смехотворидем, вас знают как кипчаков,
Вы кипчаки расселились на землях западной Асетии Алании☝☝☝Там вся топонииика именно Асетинская ☝, потому,что это Асетия Алания а не кипчакия, а мегрельское слово аланет означает просто -ГОРЕЦ☝☝а не Ариец,Ариан.Это все не ааше, никак.вы кипчаки.
It would seem at first glance the Alans are obviously related to the infamous Biblical peoples: Elon, Helon, even Eli and Heli!
Нет
The evidence that Alans were the ancestors of Ossetians is flimsy.
Secondly to call Alans Scythians as they were one df the vassals of Scythians is wrong. That’s tantamount to saying that Serbians were Turks as they were part of Ottoman Empire and providing soldiers to Ottoman military.
The characteristic haplogroups of the Karachay-Balkar Turkic people and the Scythians are the same;
From the 6th century BC. Y-DNA Map
Pontic Scythians: R1a-z93-z2123 %40
Karachay Y-DNA: R1a-z93-z2123 %36
Ossetian Y-DNA: R1a-z93-2123 %0.8
(familytreedna/groups/k-balkar-dna/about/)
(familytreedna/groups/ossetian-dna/about)
if you haven’t noticed, the video is about the Alans, not the Pontic Scythians. The most common haplogroup among Alans is G2a, as well as among Ossetians
@@David_Sirovsky writing in academically articles "The results from Pontic Scythian Tombs show that the Scythians belong to the r1a-z93 and "n" haplogroup." .
Mary, Laura (28 March 2019). "Genetic kinship and admixture in Iron Age Scytho-Siberians". Human Genetics. 138 (4): 411-423
@@Nebulavis Scythians and Alans are different peoples. Why do you quote scientists if you don’t know such basic things?
@@David_Sirovsky All written sources consider the Alans to be the successors of the Scythians. It was revealed that it belonged to the R1a-z94, R1z93, G2a-p15 , J2a-m410 , Q1-m haplogroups in the Don Alans. Haplogroups of Karachays r1a-z93 36% + g2a-p15 32% + j2a-m410 12%.
Even the geneticist Anatole Kylosov said about in Alan graves found in Don and Saltovo-Maya, "The submutations of haplogroups g2a and r1a are closer to the Karachays. The Ossetians have a different submutation." he explained.
It's because turco_mongols conquered them and assemble them and mixed with them , originaly Scythians were west Eurasian while Turks were purely east Eurasian like mongols
Alán, Szsittya, Hun-Magyar.
rtw or medieval II is better for illustration
Lol, what?
@@TotalWarHistory. Yes, better battle animations:
In Attila soldiers spend most of the battle poking weakly and softly with the tip of the spear to the center of the enemy's shield, as if they don't want to harm the enemy. Their posture has a hunchback like an old lady... plus other ridiculous animations. Not only that, behind their back the rest of soldiers are waving their weapon in the air shouting "weee! beeeeh! Booooh!!" As if it were a soccer match.
In RTW or medieval II, every soldier strive to get into melee, and they fight as if they want to win and kill the enemy.
Any documentary done with Rome 2 ahead (rome 2, Attila, Troy, etc...) looks ridiculous.
You realize those games came out 15+ years ago, right?
@@TotalWarHistory. And they are 20 times better. Isn't that shameful for CA? Totally shameful.
I could be playing Rome 2 (my first TW game), but I can't because in M2TW the mod "Bulat steel extended" plus "crimson tide" blood mod, together with a free zoom battle camera mod, have much better quality HD graphics, better mechanics, etc....
I invite you to try this mod Bulat steel. You won't be able to come back to modern TW, as it happened to me
A game having better gameplay has nothing to do with how good it is for illustration purposes. I think CK2 has great gameplay, but I can't do much with it visually.
Ossetians are iranian people who settled in Caucasus , they migrated from Iran. Ossetians have people called arse very iranic.
Not from iran. But central asia. Iranian peoples are from central asia
Асетины индоарийский народ а не иранский, и часть их в свое время дошла до территтрии Персии а не наоборот.Индоарии занимали обширный пласт от Китая,Монголии,части Алтая,Забайкалья,Перми,Урала,средней Асии,шли завоевввая северную Индию,Персию частью там оставаясь и смешиваясь с массой народов и при этом теряя многое от предкоа своих, в том числе и язык.А асетинв-ироны и есть Асы Аланы сохранившие язык,верования,обычаи,культуру,мифологию,эпосы своих предков индоариев Асов Алан, Ирон,Ариан.☝☝☝☝
@@HoVietKa
Indo O'Ryan shit 💩
😂😂😂
Lindians 🏳️🌈 and info oryans were slaves and kids of iranics.