Dude, take a close look at the last 25 years of taxation, do a calculation compare. Keep in mind that your income has also increased so it automatically counts for a higher tax. Not that the TAX % has drastically increased. Actually Compare !!!
Bhai sometimes getting access to those facilities makes you seem you are in Somalia in US as well. For getting access to a normal general physician, one has to wait for 3-5 months minimum. Merely having a facility is not enough. I am currently living in US so i know how it works.!
@@prameyprabhudesai864 correct. Healthcare is superb in india as per me. All good doctors are available in private hospitals and surgery or opd fees are much less than usa
Sir how are you guys so optimistic Yaha taxes high hai services low Yaha na infrastructure hai na saaf hawa pani Yaha corruption lowest level tak hai USA ki tarah sirf high level par nahi Direct tax code aa raha hai jiska sirf ek kaam hai salaried class se aur tax le lo To what makes you think positive abt Indian systme
Saaf hawa saaf khane k baad bhi 75% of usa citizens are on prescription medicines,,, the so called usa dream country have highet no of depressed people,, Cancer is also there,, my relatives have 2 cancer patients in their home only ,, then what the difference ???
Do you have same data abt India? Atleast for US u know how many people are depressed and fallen sick. Here in India no one is bothered how many are dying due to pollution, depression or suicides because life here has no value
The work culture, air quality index (AQI), road conditions, overall infrastructure, healthcare (even after accounting for insurance), and schooling for children are subpar. Despite all this, taxes and other costs remain high, coupled with limited availability of high-quality employment opportunities.
tell people not take take ab kahan Gaya feminism jab koi bolta hum direct bank main transfer karenge 2000 ya 2500 ya 8000 bjp jmm and congress respectively everybody knows smoking causes cancer fir bhi log pite h na ab toh 35% gst lag gaya fit bhi piyenge log so people should and youtubers can take part and educate them not to freebies yes if they getting rice atta dal that's fine for BPL category for example my annual salary is only 3 lakh I do sip I not any subsidy I am eligible to take gas subsidy but I don't take if you don't know people below 10 lakh income can take gas cylinder subsidy where are the feminist girls tell political parties hum kaam kar k paisa kamayenge haram ka paisa nahi chaiye see everybody wants free things there is no class in taking that hope you got my point we are lower middle class but never cry or take freebies
What government do.. If people vote for freebies.. Democracy is only suitable in countries where people are highly educated .. Not in countries like India. See China how fast they grew without democracy
@@Bunny-k1qit's not feminism. Had the govt invested in skill development in last 10-11 yrs they would not to have to pay women to buy votes. They paid women coz till now women votes where husband said and husband got the money in return. They just have money to them to buy votes. Please see the big picture. We don't care if Congress ever comes but that doesn't mean we still don't get benefits even after voting for this govt.
It's not just about the fastest growing economy, (in such a low base we should actually grow much more) it's about quality of life in India as compared to developed countries.....we can't even breathe clean air which I think should be the basic human right besides all other issues like corruption, extreme gap in wealth between rich and poor etc etc. India is the most polluted country in the world and I don't see our leaders are taking any substantial steps to curbe as they are busy buying votes and distributing free ration to 80 crores from the hard earned tax payers money. So please don't compare US problems with India's. Even after 100 years, we won't be able to come close to their GDP per capita.
In india most problem created by govt employees. Govt don’t have online portals for each small or large work no timeline. Govt should hire more contract employees as well. Lot’s of corruption. Tehsil biki hue lagati hai.
Kuch na kuch issues rehte hain I agree with you but itna TAX from anywhere any side it’s brutality in the form of TAX na sir we pay Road Tax road hi nahin hai na sir other countries this is not the stuff at least we thought Congress is like tat but BJP is mother of all dash here
These people have high investment in 🇮🇳 so they obviously they want, all productive people to stay in india. Foreign minister Jaishankar son is settled in USA 🇺🇸 with green card. Isha ambani had her kids in 🇺🇸 to make them 🇺🇸 citizens. Very simple. Whichever country has more powerful currency, military, law & order, education than 🇮🇳, go settle down there. You can invest in 🇮🇳 from 🇺🇸 or 🇸🇬 or Saudi and you will be taxed less.
I'm new to investing, and I've lost a good sum trying out strategies I found in online tutorials. I would sincerely appreciate any recommendations you have
Next 10 years belong to us if Mr modi goes away and his self proclaiming self satisfying policies r hurting india Jobs r not gearing created and that's why freebies r getting needed
Never thought growing up, that i would ever think of moving abroad. But the taxation is increasing so much.. its insane.. Even after earning good salary.. due to taxation, higher rents in metro cities and commodity prices rising by month.. u are left with so little.. buying a house in metro city is just a dream..
Well leaving a country is like buying a house i.e., not just a financial decision. I personally prefer lower quality of life while staying with my extended family than upper quality of life abroad while staying alone.
I believe in coming decade, Indian equities going to give good returns. Although beyond that, I believe Indian growth story may fizzle out. The reasons are below 1. India is going to face aging population problem even before it becomes middle income country, forget rich. I don’t see India becoming developed economy in foreseeable future 2. Lack of innovation by Indian companies. Indian companies are based either on domestic consumption or act as a low cost centers to global firms. Indian companies won’t be spending on R&D which acts as beacon to innovation. 3. Lack of work ethics - Forget about govt departments, even in IT companies cutting corners (which we term as Jugad) is rampant. Countries like Vietnam, Philippines, Thailand and other south East Asian countries are getting more work than India from China +1 policy of global supply chains.
But what should have discussed is what is middle class is getting in return after getting the tax? Government must focus providing quality education and infra for the same.
First time i disliked a video 👎 for not being un biased and honest, Other countries if they pay tax, they get benefits in return, like 1 free quality education 2 Good roads 3 pure drinking water (basic need) Etc etc list is too long but u get the point
Don't agree with you Due to baised view of influencers like you we are suffering Just go out India and see the value of people's and in India no budy care
I agree that there should be less disparity among the rich and the poor but in this case the government is taxing just a middle class! The taxes on the businesses is kind of going down
Sir we follow you for honest non bias information and guidance, if US has high taxation then they have free quality education, you can drink water from tap in US, here we have to buy an RO plus luxury tax for that. Please dont be bias, whats wrong is wrong
Social welfare is not the issue, the problem is direct money transfer in these ladli behena schemes etc, I dont mind govt charges tax but Indian middle class dont have the social security which other country middle class enjoy. The govt should focus on the Higher education and job creation, rather than direct money transfer by these schemes to indirectly buying votes. Nowadays people are not encouraged to go for higher education as there is no job, not interested to work harder due to these direct money transfer schemes, I am not sure how India will grow in next ten years with these kind of situation. I know some people in the comment section will come to call me pessimistic but this the current reality of India and we can see the effect of this in all the consumption companies result this year.
Social welfare is not distributing freebies. Give better education, skill set & domain expertise to all so that one can fit the job requirements. Giving freebies will make people lazy, unskilled and useless.
Social welfare ka matlab election time ke pahle free ka paisa baatna ladki laadli and other ke naam par Yahi social welfare hota hai kya gadho Are bhai Neta loot rhae hain taxpayers money Thats all
We get what we deserve … Completely disagree with all the points mentioned in the video … Taxes are insanely high and services are pathetically poor .. AI is going to eat into our low skilled jobs … and our demographic dividend is going to turn into a liability … Next ten years India ka definitely ho sakta tha but we are losing the plot completely by giving religion utmost importance … Sad to see all this!
I have noticed a trend amongst influencers, especially finance and podcast organisers that they narrate from the pov of the well developed urban metropolitan demographic background. An eye opener should be presented on behalf of tier 2, 3 or rural background. Especially the North East region of india. Yes, things are pretty well sorted for the viewers they are catering to. But truth is that there is an other side of india too that they either have no idea about or are shy to address it.
Government here seems more interested in middle class income. Also after paying income tax, we have to pay tax again in our saving, investment and the other stuff which we are buying.
Sir freebie not going to reduce the gap between rich and poor, social security cames with better health infrastructure and education. Unemployment is major problem. Human capital will not work if it is not skilled.
What about middle class? They are paying taxes but not getting any benefits from the state. Otherside government encouraging a major section of the population to get free money without doing anything
Agreed that Social Welfare might be a need to avoid major problems but misusing the concept of Social welfare by Central and State Govts is a concern. Also, Its good to have to have lowest possible difference between rich and the poor but we need to understand that if someone is rich that doesn't mean he is earning easy money. He is sacrificing a lot of things and might be burning midnight oil to have that kind of life so no one in the world has the right to take 35% of his money (Without giving him any benefits) and give it to someone who might be just sitting idle, playing cards and just waiting for the welfare money to come to his bank. Logically welfare money should only be allocated to the people who prove that they are trying to do something, even if they are failing but unfortunately our govt doesn't think in that way as by doing this they will upset other lazy people who are just sitting idle but have the voting power. Also, though every country has issues but the decision of migrating or not migrating should be based on the Question - Is govt. trying to resolve the issues in the country? If you think govt. is trying to resolve those issues then it is best to stay otherwise to move to a country where govt. is thinking logically instead of thinking only from Vote bank politics. Currently in our country, Govt is too slow and the major issue is that they don't want to be part of any major modernizations. For instance, Crypto, AI Innovations etc. Most of the AI innovations are happening in US. India is just waiting to use them and become the consumer. Moreover our finance minister clearly says she doesn't have any answers when questioned about so many taxes in Equity investment. All these issues forces us to think again. I myself moved back from US to India few years back despite having option to get a Green Card but I had hope with this govt at that time. Even now I am little hopeful that this govt will think about taking some bold decisions instead of just keeping quiet. However, if they don't think it now then it is really a grim situation for our country. Though our country is one of the fastest growing economy but is this money really flowing to the middle class and the lower class is the question. We should ask ourself if our country is really going to be developed by 2047. - Traffic issues where common man himself doesn't want to improve and hope to improve is also very less as kids learn from there parents and parents drive like anything on the roads. - We speak about cleanliness but when it comes to even the best cities of India, "cleanliness" word itself is not in the dictionary. Is the govt trying to do something regarding this? Answer is Yes but is common man trying to do something about this? Answer is No. 90% of our population is actually uncivilized who doesn't care about their surroundings etc. - Govt portals rejecting claims, Insurance playing with their customers. Slow justice system because of Chalta hai Attitude. Is govt doing anything regarding this? Answer doesn't look like "Yes". - Our police : Is it really competent? Answer is No. Most of the police officers are not even capable of running few minutes, not is shape, always try to behave as if they are doing some favor to people. Are they even near to improvement? Answer is "No" and the reason is it comes under State Jurisdiction. A politician controls a police offers transfer orders. Seriously? We made our police system a Joke. Obviously if a officer is controlled by the politician how in this world is that officer going to take action against any issue created by that politician itself.
India is agricultural based country, it is our strength, we have to work on increasing productivity, logistics, agro based industries of world class including milk product and meat based industries. And Indians has to work hard, As Mr Narayan Morty pointed out. Definitely we will be world no 1 economy, like sone ki chidiya
U r correct sir , But tell me why should I pay for someone who doesn't belong to my country and contribution is nothing from them. I mean y should I pay to Bangladeshi and Rohangiyas?
Fastest growing ka achar dale jab saans leke zinda hi ni reh payenge pollution me and Tax hm de or log free me khaate jaaye... middle class piss rha h sirf india me
Compare the Per capita Income of No. 7, 8 ,9 countries with that of India which is presently no.5 economy. Poor are used to suffer and Survive somehow, middle class is the worst sufferer of the tax terrorism. Unless the growth is broad based, it won't sustain.
when people say that they pay tax and government pay it to poor. They forget that almost every Indian pays taxes in the form of gst. Many Income Tax payees conveniently forget the tax payed by ordinary citizen through GST.
The current government has destroyed the small business environment in the country They are focusing on corporates who are focussed on profits and not employment Entrepreneurs make economy better
the way govt is spending money is the biggest reason why inequality is increasing.... these guys making videos sound like 15 years old discussing on economy...
High inflation in low income country like India, not possible to live for middle class who pays more income tax than corporate gives taxs. In return they get no benefit. Its good to not criticize our India, but constantly saving goverment from their faulty policies is not acceptable.
A video on Tata consumer share will be welcomed with open arms as fmcg market is going through a tough phase. Your views and recommended advice will be of a great help for "tuch prani" like us.
The root cause of all these problems is over population. If you want to improve the quality of life, the population of India must decline from the current level.
Tough times ahead for general public, who have only one income sources, employers don't increase the salary more than 5-10% in a month where the inflation is more than 15% in real world, prices of everyday commodities, groceries all are all time high but the useless government is busy to find another ways to tax the common people, whereas the super riches are enjoying almost a tax free income, and moving to different countries and divert their wealth in every possible way!
Giving free money in hand is also not sustainable.. generate employment. Make policy that are favourable for business. But im 100% sure this wont happen. Human capital tabhi kaam aayega jab econmy pe focus hoga, but sab hindu-muslim mein busy hai. Percapita income is poor, record low savings rate here, aur consumption ki baate ho rhi hai😂
Government should look at equality as per the constitution. Equal right for education, health, remove caste and racism. Stop freebies for people who do not contribute to nation building, support for women empowerment, old people. Social benefits for tax payer.
What about communal harmony. So many hate speeches for muslims are given bjp govt when it will stop. 90% of indians dont earn more than 20k per month. We are still a very poor country
Delhi aaja, fokat me 50 cigarette rooz ka phooko itna air pollution hai, rehne laayak nahi bacha hai city areas. Isse accha gaav me jaake raho fir sahi hai.
What are the benefits and services Govt giving for paying taxes? Instead of rewarding Tax payers, Govt sending clarification letter if any discrepancy arises during filing tax 😂
Come on Parimal Ji. Kuch bhi defend mat kro. Jo galat hai usko openly bolo bhi. Jo thodi boht GDP growth aa bhi rahi (genuine or not idk) wo government capex ki wajah se hi hai. Consumption, manufacturing jaise sectors mein naa ke barabar growth hai. Aise tarakki nahi hoti. And 29 saal avg age ka kya kroge jab bnde tumhare berozgaad ghum rahe. High end jobs create krne se hi desh ameer hota. And FYI Adani only employs around 25k people. And don’t forget jo taxes hain wo freebies mein ya politicians ki pocket mein divert hota. Government businesses ko itna dikkat krti ki ye rules follow kro, business code specify kro, and for baad mein bolti ki hme ye nahi pta ki konse sector kitna paise generate krta. Bhai tumne hazaron crores GDP system develop krne ke liye khrch kiye taaki tax collection simplify ho jaye, lekin ab tum bolte hmaare paas category wise data nahi. Is this a joke? And aap jaise log job jaisa hai waise usko accept toh krte sath mein defend bhi krne lg jate. Sarkar tumhe paise nahi de rahi. Khud kmaate ho tum.
No one bothers about the taxes if we get the services. And you are saying that welfare schemes are good to reduce the gap between Poor and rich but please elaborate how giving 1500 Rs narrow the gap if that money will not giving poor any significant skill? Parties are giving bribe in form of freebies and no one is bothered to talk about capex in manufacting or any other sector. Moreover Income Tax is surpassing Corporate Tax this shows the mentality of Govt that they treat the taxpayer class as their slaves who are there to pay only taxes in one form or other. Good that you guys are optimistic but we shouldn't become ostrich. If welfare schemes are necessary so is providing basic facilities to taxpayer class.
Sorry. Most of your views dont make sense. (1) Most employment generation is done by MSME not corporate houses. Manufacturing is down due to china + no incentives by govt + msme shops who employ the most are shutting down due to benefits to big houses/ecommerce. Execpt may be some like Tata. Others like Adani etc..employment is minisule with them (2) What is govt doing for skill debelopment why is education budget going down every year Insteadof ladki behan yojna...its clear that it is being given to buy votes. Has the govt done real work they would not have to pay. Is int? (3) beto bacho yojna- minister in parliament said out if 500cr 80% got utilised in marketing rather than real benefit being passed (4) Please also specify why employees /indicidual tax more than coporate for alnost a decade? + (5) Evem small benefits of gas subsidy & senior citizen railway benefit was taken away. (6) Why is maharahstra which was No1 now is at 5/6th . How come Tamil nadu is no.1 even gujrat is before MH at no 4 when infact maharashtra had same govt at state & central for 8 yrs? (7) Why is food inflation so high? Metro cities inflationn of food & educatoon & hospitalisation is 11-15% Please appreciate ppl are really tired . They are working hard yet eveyday living cost is increasing without much increase in salary/income. Plus we have to fend for old age, private schools /hospitals..etc. in our own what benefit do we get for our taxes. Leave alone infrasteucture with potholes and no repairs & maintenance So many more. Please appreciate that stock market & economy may look like different but eventually they will get affected. We dont have money to buy ..and thats shown by HUL, Nestle, asian paints. No consumption coz whatever one has goes into buying basic food, school & hospital which has become so expensive Infact you must use this platform to update govts & draw thier attention
Ghanta next 10 yrs belong to India.. Could you name any one thing we are ahead of the world???? AI research is going on US, all big companies, Quantum Computing etc..
No need just get Nirmala Tai relocated.
well said
Tax like European countries
Services like Somalia. 😡😡
Exactly
Leave go to your pyaara bangladesh
Dude, take a close look at the last 25 years of taxation, do a calculation compare. Keep in mind that your income has also increased so it automatically counts for a higher tax. Not that the TAX % has drastically increased. Actually Compare !!!
@@DssArnabbhai tumhari baaton se lg rha ke tumne kabhi direct tax pay nahi kiya hai.
Pls get lost to lungidesh.😂😂😂
USA have tax but they have very good facilities as well.
Tax bhi humse jyada hai waha 😂😂😂
What good facility. Private school, college, hospital. Tax kharcha kaha hota hai? Ukraine me,Syria me
Bhai sometimes getting access to those facilities makes you seem you are in Somalia in US as well. For getting access to a normal general physician, one has to wait for 3-5 months minimum. Merely having a facility is not enough. I am currently living in US so i know how it works.!
@@prameyprabhudesai864 correct. Healthcare is superb in india as per me. All good doctors are available in private hospitals and surgery or opd fees are much less than usa
@@aksman8563 true this. Even my friends here and family living here in US currently say that Indian medical treatment is better than US
Corporate tax collection was less than the income tax collected. Employees are paying more taxes than the employer.
We are employees they are employment generators. Its a much bigger role and should be respected.
@KR-oy9bn lol... Ur happy I guess? Do u even pay any tax 🤔.
Distributing cash in the name of social welfare is plain spudity.
They have started "Ladki Behan Yojna" in maharashtra.
Problem is that ultra rich are not paying but middle class whose income is stagnant have to pay.
Sir how are you guys so optimistic
Yaha taxes high hai services low
Yaha na infrastructure hai na saaf hawa pani
Yaha corruption lowest level tak hai USA ki tarah sirf high level par nahi
Direct tax code aa raha hai jiska sirf ek kaam hai salaried class se aur tax le lo
To what makes you think positive abt Indian systme
Dono bhakt hai bjp ke.😂😂😂
Saaf hawa saaf khane k baad bhi 75% of usa citizens are on prescription medicines,,, the so called usa dream country have highet no of depressed people,, Cancer is also there,, my relatives have 2 cancer patients in their home only ,, then what the difference ???
Do you have same data abt India? Atleast for US u know how many people are depressed and fallen sick. Here in India no one is bothered how many are dying due to pollution, depression or suicides because life here has no value
@ all counties have issues ,, we dnt really know till we live there i think
The work culture, air quality index (AQI), road conditions, overall infrastructure, healthcare (even after accounting for insurance), and schooling for children are subpar. Despite all this, taxes and other costs remain high, coupled with limited availability of high-quality employment opportunities.
Mr. Parimal you know where government is spending money(just win the election), so the gap between the poor and rich is increasing rapidly.
tell people not take take ab kahan Gaya feminism jab koi bolta hum direct bank main transfer karenge 2000 ya 2500 ya 8000 bjp jmm and congress respectively
everybody knows smoking causes cancer fir bhi log pite h na ab toh 35% gst lag gaya fit bhi piyenge log
so people should and youtubers can take part and educate them not to freebies
yes if they getting rice atta dal that's fine for BPL category
for example my annual salary is only 3 lakh I do sip I not any subsidy I am eligible to take gas subsidy but I don't take
if you don't know people below 10 lakh income can take gas cylinder subsidy
where are the feminist girls tell political parties hum kaam kar k paisa kamayenge haram ka paisa nahi chaiye
see everybody wants free things there is no class in taking that
hope you got my point
we are lower middle class but never cry or take freebies
So true 😢
What government do.. If people vote for freebies.. Democracy is only suitable in countries where people are highly educated .. Not in countries like India. See China how fast they grew without democracy
@@jubairmohammadfor whose commet
@@Bunny-k1qit's not feminism. Had the govt invested in skill development in last 10-11 yrs they would not to have to pay women to buy votes. They paid women coz till now women votes where husband said and husband got the money in return. They just have money to them to buy votes. Please see the big picture. We don't care if Congress ever comes but that doesn't mean we still don't get benefits even after voting for this govt.
And what about social security
Civic Sense
Independent
Health care
Education
It's not just about the fastest growing economy, (in such a low base we should actually grow much more) it's about quality of life in India as compared to developed countries.....we can't even breathe clean air which I think should be the basic human right besides all other issues like corruption, extreme gap in wealth between rich and poor etc etc. India is the most polluted country in the world and I don't see our leaders are taking any substantial steps to curbe as they are busy buying votes and distributing free ration to 80 crores from the hard earned tax payers money. So please don't compare US problems with India's. Even after 100 years, we won't be able to come close to their GDP per capita.
Leave india simple.. kyun he ab tak yahaan.. bo..
Social welfare means providing means of employment to the needy, not distribution of money to the freeloaders
Please for God Sake , stop comparing india with America... People laugh at us
I will leave India if Direct Tax Code is implemented and it has flat tax !
Who is stopping you now.
@ DTC is not implemented yet !
In india most problem created by govt employees.
Govt don’t have online portals for each small or large work no timeline.
Govt should hire more contract employees as well.
Lot’s of corruption.
Tehsil biki hue lagati hai.
Kuch na kuch issues rehte hain I agree with you but itna TAX from anywhere any side it’s brutality in the form of TAX na sir we pay Road Tax road hi nahin hai na sir other countries this is not the stuff at least we thought Congress is like tat but BJP is mother of all dash here
You're missing the point about quality of life and healthcare and education and policing situation.
These people have high investment in 🇮🇳 so they obviously they want, all productive people to stay in india. Foreign minister Jaishankar son is settled in USA 🇺🇸 with green card. Isha ambani had her kids in 🇺🇸 to make them 🇺🇸 citizens. Very simple. Whichever country has more powerful currency, military, law & order, education than 🇮🇳, go settle down there. You can invest in 🇮🇳 from 🇺🇸 or 🇸🇬 or Saudi and you will be taxed less.
I'm new to investing, and I've lost a good sum trying out strategies I found in online tutorials. I would sincerely appreciate any recommendations you have
As a beginner, it's essential for you to have a pro or a very good trader to keep you accountable.
If you can, then get a professional to trade for you I think that way your assets are more secure.
Someone like expert Marilyn Knowles
Next 10 years belong to us if Mr modi goes away and his self proclaiming self satisfying policies r hurting india
Jobs r not gearing created and that's why freebies r getting needed
Never thought growing up, that i would ever think of moving abroad. But the taxation is increasing so much.. its insane.. Even after earning good salary.. due to taxation, higher rents in metro cities and commodity prices rising by month.. u are left with so little.. buying a house in metro city is just a dream..
Well leaving a country is like buying a house i.e., not just a financial decision. I personally prefer lower quality of life while staying with my extended family than upper quality of life abroad while staying alone.
Atleast people get good services after taxation in USA
I believe in coming decade, Indian equities going to give good returns. Although beyond that, I believe Indian growth story may fizzle out. The reasons are below
1. India is going to face aging population problem even before it becomes middle income country, forget rich. I don’t see India becoming developed economy in foreseeable future
2. Lack of innovation by Indian companies. Indian companies are based either on domestic consumption or act as a low cost centers to global firms. Indian companies won’t be spending on R&D which acts as beacon to innovation.
3. Lack of work ethics - Forget about govt departments, even in IT companies cutting corners (which we term as Jugad) is rampant. Countries like Vietnam, Philippines, Thailand and other south East Asian countries are getting more work than India from China +1 policy of global supply chains.
But what should have discussed is what is middle class is getting in return after getting the tax? Government must focus providing quality education and infra for the same.
First time i disliked a video 👎 for not being un biased and honest,
Other countries if they pay tax, they get benefits in return, like
1 free quality education
2 Good roads
3 pure drinking water (basic need)
Etc etc list is too long but u get the point
German Shepherd ka video dekha karo 😂
Don't agree with you
Due to baised view of influencers like you we are suffering
Just go out India and see the value of people's and in India no budy care
I agree that there should be less disparity among the rich and the poor but in this case the government is taxing just a middle class! The taxes on the businesses is kind of going down
Guruji i respect you a lot. I also support BJP. But what's wrong is wrong. Don't be part of Andhbhakti
but sir we need to define the social welfare too very clearly. is it SW or vote bank
Sir we follow you for honest non bias information and guidance,
if US has high taxation then they have free quality education, you can drink water from tap in US, here we have to buy an RO plus luxury tax for that.
Please dont be bias, whats wrong is wrong
US has liberal gun culture also... Which is dangerous
Ruko abhi Anti-national bolne wale aate hi honge 😂😂
Social welfare is not the issue, the problem is direct money transfer in these ladli behena schemes etc, I dont mind govt charges tax but Indian middle class dont have the social security which other country middle class enjoy. The govt should focus on the Higher education and job creation, rather than direct money transfer by these schemes to indirectly buying votes. Nowadays people are not encouraged to go for higher education as there is no job, not interested to work harder due to these direct money transfer schemes, I am not sure how India will grow in next ten years with these kind of situation. I know some people in the comment section will come to call me pessimistic but this the current reality of India and we can see the effect of this in all the consumption companies result this year.
Social welfare is not distributing freebies. Give better education, skill set & domain expertise to all so that one can fit the job requirements. Giving freebies will make people lazy, unskilled and useless.
Social welfare ka matlab election time ke pahle free ka paisa baatna ladki laadli and other ke naam par
Yahi social welfare hota hai kya gadho
Are bhai Neta loot rhae hain taxpayers money
Thats all
Yes 😂
We get what we deserve … Completely disagree with all the points mentioned in the video … Taxes are insanely high and services are pathetically poor .. AI is going to eat into our low skilled jobs … and our demographic dividend is going to turn into a liability … Next ten years India ka definitely ho sakta tha but we are losing the plot completely by giving religion utmost importance … Sad to see all this!
Social welfarism is different thing and social bribery for vote by political parties r criminal act .
services toh hain na, social welfare and freebies to win election is not the same
I have noticed a trend amongst influencers, especially finance and podcast organisers that they narrate from the pov of the well developed urban metropolitan demographic background.
An eye opener should be presented on behalf of tier 2, 3 or rural background. Especially the North East region of india. Yes, things are pretty well sorted for the viewers they are catering to. But truth is that there is an other side of india too that they either have no idea about or are shy to address it.
Government here seems more interested in middle class income. Also after paying income tax, we have to pay tax again in our saving, investment and the other stuff which we are buying.
Bhai Direct tax code aa raha hai
Ab sab kuch seedhe income mein add hoga
Political parties farmers aur army walo ke liye sab free free free
Brain drain is a major problem which is suffering now . this is the speed breaker of developed India
Then why weren't any of these individuals like Indira Nooyi, Sundar Pichai, Raghuram Rajan recognised when they were in India ?!
Sir freebie not going to reduce the gap between rich and poor, social security cames with better health infrastructure and education. Unemployment is major problem. Human capital will not work if it is not skilled.
You Both need get your act together.
Shrinking Middle Class and growing economy. Sir please shed some light on this.
What about middle class? They are paying taxes but not getting any benefits from the state. Otherside government encouraging a major section of the population to get free money without doing anything
Agreed that Social Welfare might be a need to avoid major problems but misusing the concept of Social welfare by Central and State Govts is a concern. Also, Its good to have to have lowest possible difference between rich and the poor but we need to understand that if someone is rich that doesn't mean he is earning easy money. He is sacrificing a lot of things and might be burning midnight oil to have that kind of life so no one in the world has the right to take 35% of his money (Without giving him any benefits) and give it to someone who might be just sitting idle, playing cards and just waiting for the welfare money to come to his bank. Logically welfare money should only be allocated to the people who prove that they are trying to do something, even if they are failing but unfortunately our govt doesn't think in that way as by doing this they will upset other lazy people who are just sitting idle but have the voting power. Also, though every country has issues but the decision of migrating or not migrating should be based on the Question - Is govt. trying to resolve the issues in the country? If you think govt. is trying to resolve those issues then it is best to stay otherwise to move to a country where govt. is thinking logically instead of thinking only from Vote bank politics.
Currently in our country, Govt is too slow and the major issue is that they don't want to be part of any major modernizations. For instance, Crypto, AI Innovations etc. Most of the AI innovations are happening in US. India is just waiting to use them and become the consumer. Moreover our finance minister clearly says she doesn't have any answers when questioned about so many taxes in Equity investment. All these issues forces us to think again. I myself moved back from US to India few years back despite having option to get a Green Card but I had hope with this govt at that time. Even now I am little hopeful that this govt will think about taking some bold decisions instead of just keeping quiet. However, if they don't think it now then it is really a grim situation for our country. Though our country is one of the fastest growing economy but is this money really flowing to the middle class and the lower class is the question. We should ask ourself if our country is really going to be developed by 2047.
- Traffic issues where common man himself doesn't want to improve and hope to improve is also very less as kids learn from there parents and parents drive like anything on the roads.
- We speak about cleanliness but when it comes to even the best cities of India, "cleanliness" word itself is not in the dictionary. Is the govt trying to do something regarding this? Answer is Yes but is common man trying to do something about this? Answer is No. 90% of our population is actually uncivilized who doesn't care about their surroundings etc.
- Govt portals rejecting claims, Insurance playing with their customers. Slow justice system because of Chalta hai Attitude. Is govt doing anything regarding this? Answer doesn't look like "Yes".
- Our police : Is it really competent? Answer is No. Most of the police officers are not even capable of running few minutes, not is shape, always try to behave as if they are doing some favor to people. Are they even near to improvement? Answer is "No" and the reason is it comes under State Jurisdiction. A politician controls a police offers transfer orders. Seriously? We made our police system a Joke. Obviously if a officer is controlled by the politician how in this world is that officer going to take action against any issue created by that politician itself.
Correct
actually its not a bad idea if you can get a good job in US or something like that. The saving there for 5 years is enough to build a large corpus.
India is agricultural based country, it is our strength, we have to work on increasing productivity, logistics, agro based industries of world class including milk product and meat based industries. And Indians has to work hard, As Mr Narayan Morty pointed out. Definitely we will be world no 1 economy, like sone ki chidiya
all the best for those who leave india and dont ever comeback like on 2020 corona
U r correct sir ,
But tell me why should I pay for someone who doesn't belong to my country and contribution is nothing from them. I mean y should I pay to Bangladeshi and Rohangiyas?
Doesn’t matter which goverment … Leave India .. stay out for 12/15 years … then only India later would be affordable 🤣🤣
Where is this full Live?
Fastest growing ka achar dale jab saans leke zinda hi ni reh payenge pollution me and Tax hm de or log free me khaate jaaye... middle class piss rha h sirf india me
Relaxo share ke bare me btao kuchh
Compare the Per capita Income of No. 7, 8 ,9 countries with that of India which is presently no.5 economy. Poor are used to suffer and Survive somehow, middle class is the worst sufferer of the tax terrorism. Unless the growth is broad based, it won't sustain.
Giving free money won’t reduce the gap between rich and poor.
People who are shouting to relocate abroad: Please remember that other countries' people are always treated as second class citizens
In India middle class are treated as second class 😂
In India, if you are a salaried middle class and fall in the general category you will be treated as 3rd class😅
Have you been abroad? I have been and I wasn't treated like a second class citizen
@@prashantmaheshwari4066 yup I have been to six countries in my 20yrs of IT job service.
What a joke you mean here treatment is good lol😅😅😅
when people say that they pay tax and government pay it to poor. They forget that almost every Indian pays taxes in the form of gst. Many Income Tax payees conveniently forget the tax payed by ordinary citizen through GST.
Excellent Analysis
Corporate tax collection is lesser than income tax collection😢
The current government has destroyed the small business environment in the country
They are focusing on corporates who are focussed on profits and not employment
Entrepreneurs make economy better
the way govt is spending money is the biggest reason why inequality is increasing....
these guys making videos sound like 15 years old discussing on economy...
High inflation in low income country like India, not possible to live for middle class who pays more income tax than corporate gives taxs. In return they get no benefit. Its good to not criticize our India, but constantly saving goverment from their faulty policies is not acceptable.
I do not agree as said by Analyst that will be fastest economy in coming 10 years how can that will be possible with Ladki behna to win elections
Thank you parimal Sir and gaurav sir
We should bank on our institutions, EC, CBI, ED, Courts etc etc 😅
A video on Tata consumer share will be welcomed with open arms as fmcg market is going through a tough phase.
Your views and recommended advice will be of a great help for "tuch prani" like us.
Do you really think we should compare our problems with USA? They are far ahead.
In Every country problems are there.. it is how you think
Ofcourse.. if you not leave india.. 😂😂
Dont act as if the burden of defending the Govt is on your shoulders ,Parimal and Gaurav.
lol
tax like america
services like india.....
even somalia is better...atleast they dont have to pay this much tax
The root cause of all these problems is over population. If you want to improve the quality of life, the population of India must decline from the current level.
Tough times ahead for general public, who have only one income sources, employers don't increase the salary more than 5-10% in a month where the inflation is more than 15% in real world, prices of everyday commodities, groceries all are all time high but the useless government is busy to find another ways to tax the common people, whereas the super riches are enjoying almost a tax free income, and moving to different countries and divert their wealth in every possible way!
Giving free money in hand is also not sustainable.. generate employment.
Make policy that are favourable for business. But im 100% sure this wont happen.
Human capital tabhi kaam aayega jab econmy pe focus hoga, but sab hindu-muslim mein busy hai.
Percapita income is poor, record low savings rate here, aur consumption ki baate ho rhi hai😂
क्या सर....?? किधर है वेलफेयर??
Fastest growing Economy मे अगले 10 साल मे 70% टॅक्स होगा तो क्या करेंगे??
Government should look at equality as per the constitution.
Equal right for education, health, remove caste and racism.
Stop freebies for people who do not contribute to nation building, support for women empowerment, old people.
Social benefits for tax payer.
Mr modibhas gone mad to introduce dtc
He is giving free houses to rohingya but not building bangladesh border
There has to be a new planet to accomodate our country if we all are thinking to move out.
What is next then
Who will work Parimal sir if free ration and money and healthcare and gas is given? There must be impetus to work.
Tax burden will bury middle class. Only rich and poor will remain
Rich will ultimately shift to better countries, India will remain a poor country.
What about communal harmony. So many hate speeches for muslims are given bjp govt when it will stop. 90% of indians dont earn more than 20k per month. We are still a very poor country
aap only hope in INDIA
I can't leave my India ❤️ in any situation ❤
Delhi aaja, fokat me 50 cigarette rooz ka phooko itna air pollution hai, rehne laayak nahi bacha hai city areas. Isse accha gaav me jaake raho fir sahi hai.
Pms ke bareme ek video kare sir
Democracy ka Matlab... sirf naam ke liye election karvana nahi hota ..
Institutions to sab beek chukay hai...
What are the benefits and services Govt giving for paying taxes? Instead of rewarding Tax payers, Govt sending clarification letter if any discrepancy arises during filing tax 😂
The truth is bitter only intelligent people leave this courruption
Come on Parimal Ji. Kuch bhi defend mat kro. Jo galat hai usko openly bolo bhi. Jo thodi boht GDP growth aa bhi rahi (genuine or not idk) wo government capex ki wajah se hi hai. Consumption, manufacturing jaise sectors mein naa ke barabar growth hai.
Aise tarakki nahi hoti. And 29 saal avg age ka kya kroge jab bnde tumhare berozgaad ghum rahe. High end jobs create krne se hi desh ameer hota. And FYI Adani only employs around 25k people.
And don’t forget jo taxes hain wo freebies mein ya politicians ki pocket mein divert hota. Government businesses ko itna dikkat krti ki ye rules follow kro, business code specify kro, and for baad mein bolti ki hme ye nahi pta ki konse sector kitna paise generate krta.
Bhai tumne hazaron crores GDP system develop krne ke liye khrch kiye taaki tax collection simplify ho jaye, lekin ab tum bolte hmaare paas category wise data nahi.
Is this a joke? And aap jaise log job jaisa hai waise usko accept toh krte sath mein defend bhi krne lg jate.
Sarkar tumhe paise nahi de rahi. Khud kmaate ho tum.
No one bothers about the taxes if we get the services.
And you are saying that welfare schemes are good to reduce the gap between Poor and rich but please elaborate how giving 1500 Rs narrow the gap if that money will not giving poor any significant skill? Parties are giving bribe in form of freebies and no one is bothered to talk about capex in manufacting or any other sector.
Moreover Income Tax is surpassing Corporate Tax this shows the mentality of Govt that they treat the taxpayer class as their slaves who are there to pay only taxes in one form or other.
Good that you guys are optimistic but we shouldn't become ostrich. If welfare schemes are necessary so is providing basic facilities to taxpayer class.
India me itna sare minister ko nikalna chahiye safed hati sara tax payer ka paisa pe masti korte hai
Why people are asking to yadnya people.. If they knew better they would have relocated too
Market gir gaya to ye log india chodke janeki baat kar rahe, Kaha gaye ye long term investment wale ?
Sorry. Most of your views dont make sense.
(1) Most employment generation is done by MSME not corporate houses. Manufacturing is down due to china + no incentives by govt + msme shops who employ the most are shutting down due to benefits to big houses/ecommerce. Execpt may be some like Tata. Others like Adani etc..employment is minisule with them
(2) What is govt doing for skill debelopment why is education budget going down every year Insteadof ladki behan yojna...its clear that it is being given to buy votes.
Has the govt done real work they would not have to pay. Is int?
(3) beto bacho yojna- minister in parliament said out if 500cr 80% got utilised in marketing rather than real benefit being passed
(4) Please also specify why employees /indicidual tax more than coporate for alnost a decade? +
(5) Evem small benefits of gas subsidy & senior citizen railway benefit was taken away.
(6) Why is maharahstra which was No1 now is at 5/6th . How come Tamil nadu is no.1 even gujrat is before MH at no 4 when infact maharashtra had same govt at state & central for 8 yrs?
(7) Why is food inflation so high? Metro cities inflationn of food & educatoon & hospitalisation is 11-15%
Please appreciate ppl are really tired . They are working hard yet eveyday living cost is increasing without much increase in salary/income. Plus we have to fend for old age, private schools /hospitals..etc. in our own what benefit do we get for our taxes. Leave alone infrasteucture with potholes and no repairs & maintenance
So many more. Please appreciate that stock market & economy may look like different but eventually they will get affected.
We dont have money to buy ..and thats shown by HUL, Nestle, asian paints. No consumption coz whatever one has goes into buying basic food, school & hospital which has become so expensive
Infact you must use this platform to update govts & draw thier attention
Are you appreciating money credit(ladli behen)?
Don't behave like andhbhakt
❤da spotted
@@tanmaygumaste2788This was very unique bro😂😂😂😂😂
Sonia maa chatur speak but papu can't😅😂
We don't follow islam to be like that😂😂
Sir phir se offline session rakho Mai phir aaunga.
Ghanta next 10 yrs belong to India.. Could you name any one thing we are ahead of the world???? AI research is going on US, all big companies, Quantum Computing etc..
Both of these living in fairly tale. They have no idea of pain of middle class 😠😠
Giving bribes in cash ,doles , its social responsibility