Seungmin ver. vs jisung ver. / Jisung sings Seungmin's part in the S-class ☺️
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 июн 2023
- #shorts #kpop #kpopshorts #edit #ytshorts #straykids #skz #stay #lovestay #youmakestraykidsstay #bangchan #skzfelix #skzbangchan #changbin #in #leeknow #leeminho #hyunjin #hyunjinedit #jisung #yangjeongin #jyp #seungmin #skzsclass #sclassskz #bangchanskz #recording #kpopshort
Развлечения
![[EN/JP] [8회] ♬ Love poem - 메이플라이(보컬 유닛 은광, 승민, 종호)ㅣ3차 경연 1R#KINGDOM EP.8 | Mnet 210520 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/r_BhdTWXq10/mqdefault.jpg)
3racha usually sing it as a guide for the other members to follow, that’s all.
That’s why it’s called a guide 😭
@@Kiyomidle Yeah I see some people mistaking it as a demo lmoa
@@straykiss_wooLMFAO FRRR
They are so talented that they can do that!!
(No offense) but duh
They both slayed🙇♀️🙇♀️🙇♀️
Yes ❤
Jisung's "we're special" is so 😩💗
jisungs sounded absolutely HEAVENLYYYYY but seungmins voice suits that part of the song better
They both sound good and Seungmins version doesn't even have the backing track with it yet.
Han's and seungmin's got me like: 😟🥺
It's a demo song where han sang it for seungmin as an example, so don't misunderstood it. Han sang it cuz he's the one wrote it (also which is why it sounds very autotuned, since it's really just for seungmin to sang it)
*don’t misunderstand
*for seungmin to sing it
Doesn't "sound very autotuned" at all.
@@damselflyable I just meant for those in comments keep saying something like "han's autotune sounds worse than live vocal" bullshits, so I'm just kinda used back their words, like I'm pissed what do they expect it's seungmin lines and honestly if bro sang it like for real, it'll still be so good (how can you even compare a demo and recording vocals? Ugh). Basically it's kinda a sarcasm for those who saying about Hans singing in autotune (except I'm bad at sarcasm but I still want to say it cuz I'm annoyed)
@@damselflyableshut up
@@damselflyableummm it does thought.
they both sing so good why do you have to compare..?? Han chose seungmin to sing that part because he want to
Hannie loves seungmin’s voice so much, I love how they work together:((
don't worry they are not comparing, it's just a guide for seungmin
No one's comparing tho
Dude, it's perfectly reasonable to put both versions next to each other. It's interesting to hear the differences. Chill.
Why are some people in the comments comparing who's better? A good producer will let the artist know what they want, that's all this is.
Há muito tempo alguns stays toxicos tentam criar uma rivalidade entre Han e Seungmin mas, não vão conseguir.
Han ama a voz de Seungmin.
Seungmin ama a voz de Han.
Um sempre incentiva o outro a cantar.
Because they Don't Know what a GUIDE IS!!!
@@Lewis-hl9qw yes this puppy 😊
@@Lewis-hl9qw You know they're both singing differently from each other, do u know?? While Seungmin makes a melody, Han has a rap voice. They are different styles and it is impossible to compare, if it were to compare, the two would have to sing with the same technique!
Seungmin é barítono e Han é tenor ?
Hearing it raw vs already recorded will sound different
Yeah
It bcuz 3 racha wrote this song so it more suitable for Seungmin vocal be demo by Han
Han Jisung 's, "We're Special" 👌
Han's voice in the guides is so good!
I love both 😭😭
Wooow Han really nailed it
I LOVE both. THAT SO BEATIFUL . Debería haber como un dúo en esa parte
Totalmente de acuerdo! SKZ necesita hacer mas duetos/harmonías! Siempre les quedan preciosas
I love the craziness of HAN version
Both slayd ✨
He is PERFECTTT
I probably think Han wrote that lyric for seungmin and made a guide for him 👽
SEUNGSUNG SLAYYY
Only puppy
I would have love the song either way! I wish they would do a demo album!! It would be great
Han’s voice was just part of the guide for the song so seungmin could understand the intended sound for the line. The members of 3racha (often all) participate in the vocal creation of the guide. In the behind the scenes videos of the recording of S class you can also hear Changbin’s and Chan’s vocals that all together combine to create the whole guide of the song. There is no original vs Han version
I need them to release the guide version of every song thank you very much
Won’t the guide version just 3 racha tho?
I think that was the point lmao
You might get Seugmiin on the newer guides as Hyungin says he uses him as his guide
Then just have 3 racha why would skz need. Recorded version, demo, live vocal recording booth all of them different things. They can’t release demo actually. If they release their will be this stupid people saying which one is better.
@@Miniverse-binnie bro calm down 😭 it’s not that deep man. 🧍♀️ I just love hearing different versions of their songs cause I love all their music
Both guys are doing well, but Han's voice is loud and sonorous, Seungmin's is gentle, lyrical, soft. Which one is more suitable is up to the author to decide.❤❤❤
Han yang membuat lirik/menulis lagu ini
@@Amellpesex Terima kasih. Penulis akan memutuskan suara siapa yang lebih cocok untuk pertunjukan ini
3 Racha membuat lagu ini,dan membagi suara sesuai karakter vokal para member sendiri.
jadi Han tau bahwa lirik ini cocok buat seungmin.
Han mengambil bagian lirik yang kusus rep,karena dia memiliki suara yang tinggi dan tempo cepat.
han's 💕💕
I know when 3racha is making the guide for the guys they think about who'll do each part, I mean, Han knew Seung was going to aaateeee, even if he already done it himself 😗✨
I think seungmins is better his voice just fits it perfectly. Both
Slayed tho
Probably because you have listened to the seungmin ver more than the jisung ver, so the jisung ver sounds odd.
Jisung's one is just the 3Racha guide for members to learn their parts.
@@torquoise9456 no it’s really just cause the line was made for seungmin since it fits him more
2人とも素晴らしすぎるから、よりこのパートをスンミンにしてくれて嬉しいなって思った😭
seungmin, changbin and han were the only ones who could actually sing/rap in tune in this recording video lol.. seungmin is so underrated, people should stop being so obsessed with hyunlix and should pay more attention to seungmin and changbin because they're so much more talented
Hannie does many of the singing guides with :((( I wish we could hear it all, he’s so good
Seungmin's voice great❤❤❤
Anytime seungmin slays, someone has to ruin it and compare.
Edit: and jisung also slayed hes my fav vocalist (after seungmin)
Solo stans can’t handle other members rising up to the top
@@purplesmoke833 bro I'm talking about vocals, who said seungmin is my fav? I'm a OT8 and you should not assume. People like you ruin biasing. I wasn't trying to make seungmin rise higher then the other members. And if you read my comment I said AND JISUNG
@@minievemidzy bro, I’m with you here. Don’t misinterpret me. I mean, when other members rise, esp the least biased members. Those who are solo stans of the most biased members can’t handle the praises that least biased members are getting. Seungmin is my bias too and Jisung is my wrecker. I’m with you on this
@purplesmoke833 oh ok
I'd go for Jisung's but of course Seung's good too, but it sounded too clean I prefer sth more complicated 😅
The way he sounds here isn't even how he sounds on the track, and it's raw vocals compared to a more produced recording, though-
This is clearly not just his voice, I'm not saying he can't sing, There's autotune in there, you can hear that voice sounds kind of robotic
han's "we're special yeah" transitioninng to changbin's rap is smooth to listen to. particularly that "yeah" part. ngl i want to hear the guide ver after hearing changbin ang chan's voice in the guide too. seungmin slayed too
Aaaa i get it. I confused when heard guide its i think all changbin. And dont know there is Han jisung do guide too
All 3racha
if you watch the intro pt 3 you can get more info, it’s really good
Both sound very great
Sesine kurban olayım Seungummmm❤❤
I'm glad that they gave that line to Seungmin, thank you producer-nims, 3racha, you're the best 🎉🎉🎉
Seungmin's version 💥💯🙇🏻♀️
Oml, the voice of Seungmin is~😩😩❤✨
(and also Han Jisung's~)
I want to listen the deno by they both slay
amazing vocals❤❤❤❤
seungmin ate, in the final song he sounded more raw and clearer, the auto-tune is so heavy on jisung's cuz its just a guide
Hannnnnnm❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I really want to hear demo version,, hans voice daebak
I love them both!!!!
STAYS VOTE FOR BANG CHAN(Shining Awards)
Where to vote?
@@Pinkshadow_skz Shining Awards Best Leader
They have different vibe...
Great voices)
Stray kids удивительные! Альбом 5-STAR ещё готовился за два года до его выхода. Конечно, в 2020 году они ещё не знали, что он вообще выйдет, но одна из песен из этого альбома уже была готова (Super Bowl) . Также Hall of Fame (вроде), которая должна была выйти вместе в альбомe MAXIDENT, а сам этот альбом тоже, скорее всего, был готов на несколько месяцев раньше до того, как вышел CASE 143. Судя по кадрам, все их песни из 5-STAR были сделаны ещё тоже за 4 месяца выхода comeback.
Разумеется, я понимаю, что именно так и работает киноиндустрия. Весь материал снимается за долго до оффициального выхода в свет, но это всë равно удивительно ❤
I always love Hannie's voice but no comparing here
Off topic but
Can we talk about Changbins voice crack for a sec 🤣🤣
THE WAY THEY KEPT MEMEING HIM ON IDOL THEATER AND THE INTRO DANCE PRACTICE LMAOOOO
His beautiful voice...❤
hannie's voice is perfect too but he only do it for an example to seungmin sang it❤
Seungmin = Han
They both slayed
HAN THE ACE OF KPOP Y'ALL
Хорошо, что оставили версию Сынмина она осталась у меня в памяти как ключевой момент песни.
Ее и должны были оставить, это демка была
Both sound good 🐿🐶👍
both were nice but minmin's has tht lil✨pazzazs✨yk
amo la voz de Seungmin
ooooooo
❤🖤❤🖤boths are good dont differetiate
His voice😊❤🐶😻
Both are lovely!!
No comparison please :)
Both slayed.
Both slays I can't choose 😭
I like hearing the guides since 3racha all have very strong tones when they sing/rap
Ambos lo hicieron bien
그는 놀라운 목소리를 가지고 있습니다👍👍👌
HANNIE SLAYED IT
Both slayed but I need to said that Hans voice fits so good in that part
Seungmin: soft, Han: POWERFUL
👏👏👏👏🎶🎤🎼👍🐿️❤nota bien alta y armoniosa y parte grave para el rock❤😂😂es un IDOL EXCELENTE Y COMPLETO ❤🎉🎉
Wawww
Ow so cute
So beautiful🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤😊😊😊
Stay ,please vote for bang chan in shining awards (best leader)
Seungmin all the way. It’s nice to see the other members get more lines.
OH MY GOSHHH
just personal opinion, HAN as one of the producer actually shows the "actual vibe" of this song
Han’s ver is really good
But I love Seungmin ver, cuz it’s really crazy
Hannie slayyyyyy (ofc both)
SEUNGMIN W THE MOST ICONIC LINE IN THE WHOLE SONG FRRR
Wait... Look at Seungmin's hair... It's from MAXIDENT era... Did they film it a long time ago?
Wasn't Han's version the demo ver.?
Han voice 😩
Sing a lot 👏🏻👏🏻
Main vocal kim seung min ❤
En sevdiğim kısım seungminin kısmı oldu ya çok güzel
I love you seungming and my idol han jisung
IT HAS A LITTLE ACCENT ITS SO CUTE
HAN💖💖😍😍😍😍😍
Beautiful vocals❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤star seongmin❤😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊oʻ😊
ВАААААУ КАК КРАСИВО
Seungmin is my perfect dog
Han is also amazing voice but seungmin is my bias sooooooo ❤❤❤❤ to both❤❤❤❤
Segumin 😂❤❤❤
seungmin and han ji-sung would be my husband❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
cool💓
Them: How many ti-
Me: don't even ask 😑
Both singers (Seungmin and Han) have a different vocal tone but I think for the purpose of the bridge…Seungmin is more suited to that particular line/phrase. I love both their ranges and each play a part in giving the song the pull it requires.