A Veteran’s View of India’s Defence Institutions | P.K. SAIGHAL | TEDxIITBHU

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
  • This veteran of the Indian Armed Forces takes us on a journey through the contemporary history of Indian Defence Institutions, citing inspiring examples of bravery, cooperation and loyalty, and documented instances of their various accomplishments and international standing. He then explains the high relevance of youth participation and their contagious impact on the survival of these institutions.
    Major General (Retd.) P K Sehgal is a veteran of the Indian Armed Forces and a leading expert in electronic warfare. He has served with the Indian Armed Forces for forty-one years and has served in the 1962, 1965, 1971, 1999 wars and has been involved in insurgency and anti-insurgency operations for close to 25 years. He has also been a part of several rescue missions during his career. He is also a renowned orator and has spent much time interacting with young audiences. He is featured in several television news programs and is known for his controversial views.
    This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at ted.com/tedx

Комментарии • 92

  • @தமிழ்ராஜன்
    @தமிழ்ராஜன் 7 лет назад +16

    Respect you Major General, it is people like you make billions of Indians sleep peacefully. Thank you is small word for the services our fellow Army men, you make us proud.

  • @ksvprasad6243
    @ksvprasad6243 5 лет назад +4

    No words can express my appreciation for my country army other than my heart and soul say to bow to them and if need arise i shall be by there side on the front line all though I am physically weak but mentally solid . GOD'S BLESS MY MOTHERLAND . JAY HIND .

  • @anuradhadubey8952
    @anuradhadubey8952 8 лет назад +33

    nothing so overwhelming, so beautifully crafted, impressively rhetorical can be heard from anywhere but only from a military officer. jai hind

  • @abhishekmishra783
    @abhishekmishra783 7 лет назад +32

    he is pure legend
    damn sir
    massive respect for u

  • @anupamsingh3409
    @anupamsingh3409 7 лет назад +9

    this guy has an amazing aura in his personality ...which seems difficult to describe...so confident....so proud....very inspiring....and yes of course an amazing speaker

  • @samindian4987
    @samindian4987 7 лет назад +13

    excellent speech sir . Indian Army Rocks

  • @baljindersinghsidhu3959
    @baljindersinghsidhu3959 7 лет назад +28

    huge respect for our jawans....

    • @samindian4987
      @samindian4987 6 лет назад

      please dont pick out points . try to understand wat he want to say. he is referring to a lack of central power before independence. indian army was actually the imperial army. british indian army. i have served in punjab for 6 years . brother let me tell you out of every 5 families one has someone in the armed forces. thats why. even villagers used to smile after seeing Army movement in their area. they know wat is right n wat is wrong.

    • @khalidwaseem411
      @khalidwaseem411 6 лет назад

      Baljinder Sidhu
      Sardaaar jee
      Guru Sahebaan dee dhirtee tuo sattt sri akaaal aaakhney aaaan tuhano .....Sardaar jee Allaah daaa waaasta ager waqaiee guru dey suchay sikh ho tey phair June 84 Darbaar saheb tey attack tey indra gandhi dey Qatal tuon baaad phair sikkkhaa daa Qatal e aaaaam naaa bhollllo

  • @mirrorflame1988
    @mirrorflame1988 7 лет назад +22

    Jai Hind!

  • @darshanjadhav6147
    @darshanjadhav6147 4 года назад +1

    Ptoud of Indian armed forces. Jai Hind! Vande Mataram!

  • @prateekkumarpanda8856
    @prateekkumarpanda8856 7 лет назад +12

    loved it and inspiring

  • @devacharya3786
    @devacharya3786 7 лет назад +1

    It's very fruitfulness to listen the stories of Indian Army from an Army veteran.

  • @aamirjamal6833
    @aamirjamal6833 7 лет назад +3

    Jai hind! Proud of my country's army..

    • @doydark4ever
      @doydark4ever 5 лет назад

      change ur name back to sanskrit pls

  • @PCHITALE
    @PCHITALE 7 лет назад +25

    With all due respect sir I don't believe that Indian army were weak army for moment also. The only problem was we answered in form of Marathas, Rajput, gorkha, dogra or Sikhs pre-independence. But after post independence for first time we started hitting enemies as India.

    • @abhaysinghrawat5520
      @abhaysinghrawat5520 2 года назад

      Meanwhile
      Garhwalis and Kumaoni heroes rest in darkness of ignorance...

  • @shashwatdohare5980
    @shashwatdohare5980 7 лет назад +8

    jai hind sir respect

  • @pritamrakshit5633
    @pritamrakshit5633 7 лет назад +5

    Jai Hind! Jai Bharat!

  • @debangsubanerjee2155
    @debangsubanerjee2155 7 лет назад +2

    God bless you Sir..

  • @AnkitKumar-bm8om
    @AnkitKumar-bm8om 7 лет назад +2

    Living Hero...Salute to you sir .

  • @vandanasingh6686
    @vandanasingh6686 3 года назад

    Every word is absolute truth.

  • @neerajkant3728
    @neerajkant3728 6 лет назад +1

    Baba vishwanath kripa kren...hr hr mahadev...bhu banal rhe

  • @baljindersinghsidhu3959
    @baljindersinghsidhu3959 7 лет назад +48

    no sir, not whole indian army lost for 1000 year, our 10th Guru all time defeated others nd outsiders.. nd many more warriors fought too..

    • @csheru
      @csheru 7 лет назад +3

      Watch full........

    • @baljindersinghsidhu3959
      @baljindersinghsidhu3959 7 лет назад +1

      manish awasthi , ha bhai dekhli h full

    • @TheHitism
      @TheHitism 7 лет назад +5

      chattrapti shivaji completely wiped out of text books

    • @facelesstongue128
      @facelesstongue128 7 лет назад

      Sidhu tention ni, baba chadhdi kala ch rakhe.. te appa karna kehna ni

    • @Naruto-oj8qs
      @Naruto-oj8qs 7 лет назад

      Bro Indian army means Delhi s or ancient India s capital army lost war ,aur guru govind Singh Ji maharaja god hai wo kaise haar sakte hai isliye WO incomparable hai

  • @soumyadatta223
    @soumyadatta223 7 лет назад +5

    Jai hind indian army zindabad

  • @amitkumarsingh3072
    @amitkumarsingh3072 4 года назад

    You are amazing sir... You motivated me very intesenly....

  • @RajuRaj-if3oq
    @RajuRaj-if3oq 6 лет назад +6

    Ahom king had defeated mughals army badly they never ever dare to come near Assam border.

    • @swapnilrawat9691
      @swapnilrawat9691 4 года назад +1

      Garhwal never fell to any mughal invader either

  • @devendraaswal1816
    @devendraaswal1816 3 года назад

    Jai Hind

  • @narayanaraokdsss4833
    @narayanaraokdsss4833 2 года назад

    Jaihind

  • @deepakinstruz
    @deepakinstruz 7 лет назад +1

    Jai Ho!

  • @jinkazamaaa
    @jinkazamaaa 7 лет назад +1

    Respect!!!

  • @mohit7150
    @mohit7150 7 лет назад

    salute jai hind

  • @veshnuadhitya7
    @veshnuadhitya7 7 лет назад +1

    south India wasnt shamed and maimed for 1000 years..even after cholas vijaynagar empire came into picture..

  • @daliyaverenker5665
    @daliyaverenker5665 6 лет назад

    Jai hind

  • @viraldazzy
    @viraldazzy 7 лет назад

    jai hind!!

  • @robiu.k.4504
    @robiu.k.4504 6 лет назад +2

    Don’t lie uncle I’m a truth seeker we lost the 1965 war but we defeat them at 1971

    • @pranavdwivedi7678
      @pranavdwivedi7678 6 лет назад

      Robi U.K. why we lost ( what we lost)

    • @funnytale9995
      @funnytale9995 5 лет назад

      robi u.k you are a paid pakistani troller.

    • @josephstalin9604
      @josephstalin9604 2 года назад

      You got caught up in Pakistani propaganda comrade.

  • @sps6
    @sps6 6 лет назад

    Tedx needs to do something on audio quality

  • @ankurhooda4326
    @ankurhooda4326 3 года назад

    But isn't the comparison with Pakistan after independence like
    India fighting itself?

  • @Anshul9Kumar
    @Anshul9Kumar 6 лет назад

    never disrespect the Indian Army

  • @sudheerkumar4421
    @sudheerkumar4421 7 лет назад

    isnt there a difference between 10th century army(which isnt indian in the modern sense) and today's army(whose budget is supported by the entire country)..why conflate these seemingly unequal armies separated by thousands of years in every sense...

  • @pieeyedpiper6377
    @pieeyedpiper6377 6 лет назад +1

    If there is a shortsge of people in army it is because of the increasing brutality & bullying towards new cadets by seniors. Videos are simply sickening. Army is steadily losing its values, discipline & humane touch. So is the demeaning behaviour towards female recruits sick.. The quality of people entering defence has deteriorated.

  • @viditgrover28
    @viditgrover28 4 года назад

    Ye ant nahi hai beta... Ye to shuruwat hai.

  • @khalidwaseem411
    @khalidwaseem411 6 лет назад

    1962 ki humilation kay baaray mein kia khayaal hey jo Area china ney capture kr liea thaa woh aap kabbb waaapis lain gey ?

    • @boochivaadu9859
      @boochivaadu9859 6 лет назад +1

      I think you will live by the motto of Maj Gen Mohammed Jamshed's famous saying "Hatyar Pheko" and ordering the Hijras in uniform to march backwards. What a sight to behold. When are you taking back Bangladesh?

    • @funnytale9995
      @funnytale9995 5 лет назад

      bhai 1962 ka badla toh hum bangladesh se liya.😁😂🤣😂😁🤣🤣😂😁😁

  • @lshrm
    @lshrm 7 лет назад +3

    One thing left over from British is colonial divide between officers and soldiers, why different mess halls and food for officers and jawans and orderly treated as personal servants?
    Seems we have replaced Gora Sahib with Brown Sahib, the officer cadre has to treat jawans as human and only then we would become Indian Military else it is British in character.

    • @MainChoon
      @MainChoon 7 лет назад

      lshrm Aisa karo sarkar se awaz aur guhar lagao ki 10 lakh gypsy kharid ke har ek jawan aur officer ko de de . Kyonki tere logic ke hisab se sab barabar hain . Apne ghar main apne baap ko bhi baap mat bolo kyonki tere logic ke hisab se sab barabar hain . Sahi hai na .

    • @bhaskartripathi
      @bhaskartripathi 6 лет назад

      lshrm : has your mother ever felt proud of you?

  • @apurvnandy3077
    @apurvnandy3077 5 лет назад

    He is unaware of the Indian army's stint during the world wars especially at the battle of Ypres and Palestine during the first world war. How did he forget the Burma campaign during the second world war??
    Absolutely dishonour for those who took part in those battles!!

  • @sadenb
    @sadenb 7 лет назад

    We had Kautilya's brain and a civilisation and we fought for Dharma

  • @khalidwaseem411
    @khalidwaseem411 6 лет назад

    Shukar hey kisi indian ney tuo accept kia keh muslamano say musalsal 1000 saal takk jooooootay khaaatay rahay hein inshallah aaienda bhi khaao gey

  • @khalidwaseem411
    @khalidwaseem411 6 лет назад

    Jeee haaan 1971 ka Qerz utaaarna abhi baaaqi hey hamaray haaaan badlaaa lainaa puraaana nhi hotaa war is not over yet abh aaap ko aik Nuclear pakistan say saaamna krna hoga abh 1971 repeat nhi ho sakay gaa

    • @manasdubey5777
      @manasdubey5777 5 лет назад

      Best of luck..👍

    • @viren7050
      @viren7050 5 лет назад

      Aap ko bhi ek Nuclear India ka saamna karna hoga, India ki powerful economy ka samna karna padega, 13 crore Indians ka samna karna padega aap ke paas ginaney K liye sirf Nuclear weapons hai hamare paas end less list hai so be careful while talking.

    • @viren7050
      @viren7050 5 лет назад

      Aur jaha tak Badley ki baat hai to hamey bhi har us Hindustani k khoon ka badla lena hai tumse jo terrorism se mara gaya hai ab ki jang huee to Pakistan k 4 tukdey karenge so be ready, before talking rubbish See your condition you are a Begger country Haath me katora mu me paan aaur tumko chahiye Pakistan?

  • @kaitang1700
    @kaitang1700 7 лет назад

    Indians love to praise itself, you should bee more honest to solve your problems.

    • @MrPoornakumar
      @MrPoornakumar 6 лет назад

      Here is the Army man talking, Kai Tang ! You are going off at a tangent. What problems please specify?

    • @nithish1215
      @nithish1215 3 года назад

      Yes that's what the armed forces are doing in border Solving our national problems in return as layman citizen we are proud of them and we praise them behalf of them too.

  • @intelligenciea
    @intelligenciea 6 лет назад

    Fact no. 1 : Currently Indian army is getting a truck load of willing and motivated contenders seeking jobs at various level, so much so that application far outnumber the vacancies. If there is a shortage of junior officers its your slow recruitment and inadequate capacity of your training centers.
    Fact no. 2 : Salaries and perk being showered at Indian tri forces are among the best by Indian standard, and a pretty large chunk of Indian budget, so stop crying.
    Fact no. 3 not just 10 yers but next 50 years you stand no chance of becoming a mighty army. You could become a might army on T.V news propaganda pushed by ultra nationalist devoid of resoning and logic news channel or talks like this. An army who hasn't even got a basic small arm design and manufacturing right, who's most wepon system and platform are a mishmash and has no coherent central triservices command is just good for suppressing moment of secession and countering insurgency.

    • @shivangvats1305
      @shivangvats1305 6 лет назад

      Mahesh Bisht Pakistani?

    • @SS-hw1ou
      @SS-hw1ou 4 года назад

      Countering fact 1 SSB is one of the robust interview system giving quality officer
      Countering fact 2 defence budget is 3% of whole GDP now our GDP is quite big so the amount seems huge also most of the budget goes in pension
      Countering fact 3 HAL has been manufacturing parts for various aircrafts since WW2, Indian ordinance factory is considered very robust industry also no equipment is totally made in 1 country and even USA used British made Harrier aircrafts and UK uses lot of USA equipment.

    • @SS-hw1ou
      @SS-hw1ou 4 года назад

      Pakistan had tri service
      Results surrender in 4 wars.

  • @ChandanSingh-vq3es
    @ChandanSingh-vq3es 6 лет назад

    ours were a great army....British army was one of the best in the world bcs of indian soldiers.... kudos to British for bequiting such a fine institution else Indians don't hv the capability to raise Nd run such institution....I beg to disagree with this fouji....Nd not all our military leaders r great...kargil was a monumental leadership failure.....he needs to speak truth....ours is still not the best equipped army...

    • @SS-hw1ou
      @SS-hw1ou 4 года назад

      Kargil leadership failure was from Delhi side our armed forces showed what leadership could do no matter what the equipment or terrain

    • @sanjeevkoparde9840
      @sanjeevkoparde9840 4 года назад +1

      Not leadership failure but intelligence failure

    • @ChandanSingh-vq3es
      @ChandanSingh-vq3es 4 года назад

      @@sanjeevkoparde9840 .....but it was a leadership failure as well..

  • @khalidwaseem411
    @khalidwaseem411 6 лет назад

    Hehehehe 1948 mein jabh pakistan k age sirf 1 saal thee Pak army ney tum say Gilgit- Baltistaan aur Aazaad kashmit scheeeen lieaa thaaa yaaad hey naaa? Now CPEC is being built by china Pakistaan jisss ki tumhain bay intehaa takleeef hey

  • @khalidwaseem411
    @khalidwaseem411 6 лет назад +1

    Hehehe agar Indian Army itni hee bahadurrr hey tuo zara Pakistan ka border cross kr k daikh lo maza aaa jaiegaa

    • @anindyabagchi27
      @anindyabagchi27 6 лет назад +1

      Khalid Waseem didn't we already do that???

    • @anmolgupta8078
      @anmolgupta8078 6 лет назад +1

      Khalid Waseem didn't ur history books told u how Bangladesh is lebration war..!!poor guy

    • @khalidwaseem411
      @khalidwaseem411 6 лет назад +1

      anmol gupta
      First of all let me know that aaaap indians ko Hindi mein baaaat krtay huay sharam Q aaaatee hey ? Aaap aik Pakisitani say mukhaaatib hein jo keh bht achi Urdu/ Hindi boltay samajhtay hein
      1947 mein Britishers waaapis jaaa chukay laiken apnay puraaaanay aaaqao ki nishaaani English aaap logo ney abhi takkk seeeenay say lagaa rakkkhi hey duniya mein her achi Qauom apni heee bhaaashaa mein baaat krna pasand kertee hey laiken india mein tuo aik mochi naaie say lay kr business man takk her koie apni bhaaashaa ki bijaiey apnay saaabiqqaa aaaqaon ki zubaaaan hee bolnaa chahtaa hey Aaakhir Q ?
      Despite the bitterness of history (1971 )Bangladesh is still our brother and a Muslim country that is not part of India and never ll be
      War between two brothers it was extremely painful

    • @kumareshs6710
      @kumareshs6710 6 лет назад

      Khalid Waseem bangladesh is a country because we wanted it to be that way...our army is suffering because of unrest created by you people in Kashmir...we don't want another Kashmir to deal with...vaise tum log kyon comment karte ho Indian related videos mein....ham to kabhi nahi karte hein... khujli Bahut hota hai kya...

    • @phanikishan8432
      @phanikishan8432 6 лет назад

      Oh you guys dont understand surgical strike.. Not your mistake..if you are from pakistan.