What is inside the AZ-5 SWITCH and other Chornobyl controls?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 дек 2024

Комментарии • 469

  • @KanalFrump
    @KanalFrump Год назад +172

    that optical beam gauge is fantastic! love the intuitive zone band color masks and the unexpected regulation feature.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +13

      that was a big discovery for me to see those films...)

    • @Wtfinc
      @Wtfinc Год назад +7

      Me too, that was so exciting! It makes it a 100x more useful, i love it.

    • @Wtfinc
      @Wtfinc Год назад +5

      @@ChernobylFamilyso glad u did! That was just great fun

    • @emilracovita8421
      @emilracovita8421 Год назад +6

      To be honest that gauge is mind blowing

    • @markevans2294
      @markevans2294 Год назад +2

      Clever how it can give a yellow via mixing the green and red light sources.

  • @MicraHakkinen
    @MicraHakkinen Год назад +54

    The design of the meter is pretty brilliant really. It gives a very clear indication by design, even from a distance. And the feedback from the adjustable green and red film allows not just for a response to an out-of-bounds indication, but also allows a connected system to detect a discrepancy (ie a faulty meter) if it's sending out a known good value but is receiving an alarm from the meter. Clever, compact, and still with multiple functions. I love it!

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +7

      The only trouble, they need MUCH space - we'd like to use them for something, but the space needed.... and these are not the biggest used at the NPP!

    • @MicraHakkinen
      @MicraHakkinen Год назад +4

      @@ChernobylFamilyYeah they are quite deep. Small frontal area, but there's a lot going on behind it. I can imagine that limits where you can use them.

    • @Melanie16040
      @Melanie16040 Год назад +2

      @@ChernobylFamily What were the largest?

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +2

      @@Melanie16040 they looked the same just double as wide, and taller for around 1 cm. It is possible to notice them on wall-mounted panels of the control room.

  • @djohnsto2
    @djohnsto2 Год назад +127

    That's pretty cool, it's super low tech but probably reliable - No overflowing integer variables to blow up your reactor.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +32

      As far as I can see, everywhere at power plants there are notably many mechanical controls along with modern digital stuff. ChNPP is a standalone thing in this aspect - it was planned to be shut down in 1994, actually worked up to 2000 as generating facility, so it received modernization in safety systems, but controls remained mostly as they were.

    • @heinzk023
      @heinzk023 Год назад +24

      Yes, blowup had to be done manually...

    • @MadScientist267
      @MadScientist267 Год назад +14

      Reliability is key with this. Not "fancy". The tech world could take notes 🤣

    • @oliviamoore3426
      @oliviamoore3426 Год назад +9

      They’re waiting for you Gordon, in the tessssst chamber. Last time I heard integer overflow was in half life 1. I had to nerd out a little 😄

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      )))))))))

  • @tekvax01
    @tekvax01 Год назад +24

    The meter is called a Mirror Galvanometer first made in the 1800s by Lord Calvin.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +9

      Thank you for the hint (still much to learn... and refresh in the memory - because NOW I remember I read something like that in the far past...)

  • @peteroc7395
    @peteroc7395 Год назад +22

    I just so love the old analog stuff from the 80s, so simple and very accurate and stable thank you so much 😊

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +3

      I think i'll find some more meters/loggers to show in the future!

    • @eightbitguru
      @eightbitguru Год назад +2

      It's 80s tech in the USSR. For the West, it's 50s.

  • @SBBurzmali
    @SBBurzmali Год назад +36

    As a heads up, the stiffness of the switches is usually the result of that spring being designed to force the contacts together at the end of the throw. The more force holding the contacts together, the higher the current the circuit can handle, AC mixes that up some which is why they can handle slightly hire AC voltages. The term used for a switch that returns to the initial position is typically "momentary" and generally switches are classified by the number of contact sets and positions it can take, a switch with two positions is "single throw" a switch with two sets of contacts is "dual pole" switch, with three positions, these would be "dual throw, sextuple pole, rotary switches" in English terminology, though I never dealt with anything with 6 sets of contacts during my time in the switch industry.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +15

      I am sincerely thankful for this explanation, which is very valuable given that English is not my native language.

    • @gregoryclemen1870
      @gregoryclemen1870 Год назад +5

      allen- bradley controls are made to add more contacts( n.o/ n.c.) to the rotary switch as needed, and the throw is also stiff.

    • @jurajlutter
      @jurajlutter Год назад +1

      Also it ensures that the spring loaded mechanism will close the contacts "momentarily" in a very short time when triggered.

  • @jameskirk9996
    @jameskirk9996 Год назад +4

    Here in the US I worked in the the fiels of mechanical testing of composites and metals. I have never seen such a meter as this before. The meters we used were either D'arsonvall or mechanical driven by a servomotor. Such systems had a feedback loop. I found this meter type facinating and well thought out.

  • @DB-47
    @DB-47 Год назад +7

    Actually those optical mechanical indicators used to be in some older Czech locomotives like classes 111, 163, 363 as speedomter and cruise control speed setting indicator

  • @Q1745
    @Q1745 Год назад +5

    Of your videos, for some reason this one resonated with me. That meter is really the definition of following the KISS principle. Great stuff, thanks for sharing!

  • @Underestimated37
    @Underestimated37 Год назад +2

    RUclips is finally sending me notifications for your videos again, (they haven’t for ages even though you’re on all) jumped on this as soon as I saw you posted, even though it is 1am here. I’m very excited for the next video, can’t wait to hear what you have.
    I find the switch interesting, it’s a great solution for a mechanical fail safe, no relying on other circuitry to change multiple systems. It’s really interesting to see designs that are designed to be multi purpose, versus the other parts of the world where everything manufactured usually has a single specific use and can’t be adapted. Even if the tech is simple, it’s fairly ingenious really.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      Thank you! Welcome back! And you certainly have a point.

  • @Damien.D
    @Damien.D Год назад +8

    Fantastic looking equipment. I love the meter, it's called a mirror galvanometer by the way, earliest ones were used to find faults in the very first transatlantic cable. The light beam was reflected on a much longer distance for that, as the distance between the mirror and the screen acts as a multiplier to measure minuscule variations of signals.
    I'm not surprised that there was a way to detect the beam of the meter, safety critical display devices have a way to self-check for faults. I'm sure these displays were used in nuclear submarines too....
    It's very clever and elegant to use a camera-type film holes and sprockets to do the moving green and red flat-flex PCB. Isn't it a very early example of flat flex PCB, by the way?
    I'm also surprised that the illuminated switches didn't have a way to self check if the bulb actually works... It's also safety critical to have readouts of your control rods status. I think. Lol :P
    (9:32 , beautiful sight with all the display working.. should have been a very special workplace to be)

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Yes, it can be considered an early flex PCB. Later they learned how to make them better, but all of them still were very fragile. As for buttons, the button is general-purpose, it is not NPP specific; I believe there was an external schematics to check that and also control panels had a test light-it-all-up sequence

  • @alexh.5579
    @alexh.5579 Год назад +6

    Awesome video! I'm interested in learning more about the mnemonic luminescent displays, selsyns and loggers as you've shown in the Exploring SKALA video!

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +4

      Stay tuned! Gradually we will go through many things like that!

  • @filip.zivkovic
    @filip.zivkovic Год назад +3

    Man I need to get that optical meter. A marvel of engineering!

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      We can get you one. Use the About Channel tab (on desktop) -> there is a contact button

    • @filip.zivkovic
      @filip.zivkovic Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily I'll look into it thanks

  • @XH1927
    @XH1927 Год назад +10

    I tripped over your channel before, but this video got you a sub. This is the kind of in-depth technical content the internet NEEDS. Very interesting and awesome. Where did you even source new-old-stock Soviet era switches and buttons like that? Very cool.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +6

      The thing is, many, many things like this were overproduced. It is possible to find them from electronics surplus sellers, metal scrappers, etc. here in Ukraine, but it takes a big effort to search for them. Also, sometimes items are not cheap, especially if they are narrow-specialized.

  • @enoladeveu3653
    @enoladeveu3653 Год назад +9

    Of course we want more. For a computer person like me it's super duper interesting to see this old school kind of widgets. Thank you for the interesting content.

  • @rrb6544
    @rrb6544 Год назад +2

    the optical meter is awesome and cute. Very interesting :)

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +2

      I think I will find some more gear to show in action. There are even more interesting devices out there!

    • @rrb6544
      @rrb6544 Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily That sounds great!. Wish I could help you with my lab gear for your channel content , but we are far apart :( Regards from Madrid, Spain

  • @KeritechElectronics
    @KeritechElectronics Год назад +5

    Ah, the things of beauty! The mirror galvanometer is just so damn lovely. Using photoresistors for limit indication is just brilliant - the only thing is that the alarm condition will never go off if a lightbulb blows, haha! But then checklists and other operating procedures were probably in place to make sure everything was in a good working order.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Likely yes, though I can't recall seeng those color film used in the actual power plant conditions. I also know there are modifications which do not have those films at all.

    • @SeanBZA
      @SeanBZA Год назад +1

      @@ChernobylFamily I would say there is a lamp monitor in there, either sensing lamp current, or even simpler another phototransistor that detected part of the lamp beam, and if it went out would be part of SKALA that this input is failed, and needs service. Probably one of the printed messages that the operators got the most, x channel indicator inoperative.

  • @MarkMcCluney
    @MarkMcCluney Год назад +6

    The 'swinging mirror ' guage reminds me of the galvanometers which I used to repair when I worked for a school. Those delicate but regularly abused meters were much more simple than but frighteningly expensive for what they were. I shudder to think how much these units cost brand new. Thanks for sharing Alex.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      Thanks for sharing! This one I got as a gift, but a quick googling says around 10-50$ per one depending on a type and size.

    • @MarkMcCluney
      @MarkMcCluney Год назад +1

      @@ChernobylFamily That's a terrific bargain! The school laboratory galvos that I repaired were a thousand pounds sterling each! (That's why I repaired them rather than buying new ones.)

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Yes, BUT, it is the price for them as old obsolete stuff. I am afraid to imagine their price back in the times when those were modern.

    • @theelmonk
      @theelmonk Год назад

      The thing about spot galvanometers was not their compact size (the ones I knew were large and heavy) but the distance from mirror to screen. This is effectively a very long but weightless pointer, giving a clear pointer indication of very small current changes in the coil.
      Here is a typical school galvanometer : www.preproom.org/equipment/eq.aspx?eqID=5037

  • @marioserafimov6714
    @marioserafimov6714 Год назад +5

    Lived it. While the switches looked pretty much as a package switch, the meter looks like something that would spark my child imagination into wild believes some 25 years ago.
    Also, by watching this I can't help but feel gratitude for my position in time where I can look back on analogue devices through videos like this and make straight comparsion to their digital equivalent devices.

  • @douro20
    @douro20 Год назад +3

    They're standard aviation type lamps. They are available in 12V versions.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      Did not come across 12V ones, but now I'll look for some! Thanks!

  • @vleiswalker9374
    @vleiswalker9374 2 месяца назад

    GREAT! Well done! Adjustment of Green and Red zones very impressive!

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  2 месяца назад

      True! Although many gauges at the NPP do not have those.

  • @wtmayhew
    @wtmayhew Год назад +4

    Thank you very interesting!
    The beam deflection is twice the angle of the mirror movement, so a galvanometer light deflection meter can be very sensitive. The use of the films with the photo resistors is very clever. I like it. I am in the US, and I have not yet seen anything exactly the same in industrial controls, but there may be, just I have not seen it.
    I built a light deflector using two plotter galvanometer motors to make an X-Y light raster on a wall. A brain researcher used it to map the positions and motions to which hamster visual cortex neurons respond.

  • @williamrekow7513
    @williamrekow7513 Год назад +2

    The word you're looking for with the 'return' switches is 'momentary'.

  • @mertozsoy
    @mertozsoy 6 месяцев назад +2

    gördüğüm en iyi kanal "chornobyl family"

  • @phildem414
    @phildem414 Год назад +1

    Super nice indicator display, the color indicator is a clever thing

  • @Sparkington9
    @Sparkington9 Год назад +4

    Honestly that the coolest meter I've seen, the fact you can trigger event from the scale in a simple robust format is amazing. Why I love Soviet equipment :D

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +2

      Well, as other commenters explained, there existed similar western devices as well:)

  • @jpjude68
    @jpjude68 Год назад +5

    i never expected to see film tape holding light sensors like that in the percentage meter.. it's so surprising

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +3

      I must say, I was surprised too. Even more I was surprised to see something close to a modern LED stripe but made by Soviets.

  • @codaalive5076
    @codaalive5076 7 месяцев назад +1

    These are rotary switches with several positions and even more poles, they allow for switching several connections with one position. Some poles might be in parallel for redundancy in case one contact fails, i would expect this in critical applications like NPP control.

  • @JeSuisUnePatate
    @JeSuisUnePatate Год назад +3

    I guess there was a «Test» button somewhere on those console to verify that the lights were working on every buttons? Very interesting again! Thank you :)

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      I am not 100% sure for ALL buttons, but it should be. Absolutely surely there are buttons that initiate a test of individual panels. Actually, you can see green SKALA mnemonic displays glowing, that is exactly a test in action.

  • @electriccomics
    @electriccomics Год назад +1

    So cool. Great presentation, you're a good and clear speaker.

  • @Gersberms
    @Gersberms Год назад +13

    I agree that it's weird for that gauge to send signals as well as receive them. It's beautifully made though, very impressive. Those switches are nicer than I thought they would be but I wonder how reliable those contacts are, they're just metal points that slide across each other. I suppose the spring makes sure it happens quickly.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +6

      They look pretty reliable and that spring seems to ensure a good contact.

    • @SeanBZA
      @SeanBZA Год назад +6

      Pretty reliable, once you remember the correct operating condition for the contacts. They run best with 24V across them when open, and 20 to 100mA of current when closed, which helps by keeping the contacts free from oxide, as they wipe across each other, and this make good metal to metal contact. You get a totally different switch, with thick gold contact faces, for low level signals, such as those from the hundreds of thermocouples and platinum resistance thermometers that were used to measure temperature, and the hundreds of bridge type pressure transducers as well.
      Those AZ-5 switches look like they break before make, so while you operate there is a brief period where all contacts are open, so as to prevent shorts. Others will be make before break, where you do not want interruption, while say changing the range on a meter.
      The mirror galvanometrs are very interesting, with them not only showing up as readout, but also being a simple interface to the SKALA system to be able to input state information without needing complex extra converters, and also associated programming on them as well to set limits. Just built into the existing display, annd an easy way to show if nominal, or which way the deviation is. Likely there is a further phototransistor there that also acts to inform that the lamp has failed, and print it out for a repair operation. 28VDC lamps, run on 24VDC, probably with a series resistor as well, so as to drop voltage to around 22VDC, so leading to greatly increased lamp life.
      The type of lamp is classed as prefocussed beam, as the optical path is fixed in the lamp construction, so that in use no further focussing is needed during changing the lamp, as all of them are adjusted in the factory to have the filament in exactly the same orientation and plane, so you simply swap the failed lamp out, and close the panel up.

    • @Gersberms
      @Gersberms Год назад +1

      @@SeanBZA You're right about the operating conditions of switches being an important factor. Microswitches in computer mice are now operating on such low currents that there's no wetting current. Omron switches rated for a million cycles don't last more than a year, it's insane. That all has to do with the low currents of the new microcontrollers being used. I bet you my old MX518 from 2005 still works, but I can tell you that a mouse I bought 2 years ago is already getting flaky.

  • @MrEdwinHubble
    @MrEdwinHubble Год назад +1

    Yes please! This is an awesome device! I have a similar mirror movement microohm meter. Very well done video!

  • @sammorgan31
    @sammorgan31 26 дней назад +1

    From the look of the label on that rotary switch it's up to 220 volts DC or 380 volts AC.

  • @FixitFrank
    @FixitFrank Год назад

    Oleksander, I have been looking for one of these for a few years! Thank you for the video! Now I have a chance to locate one. Дякую тобі!

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Glad I could help! Well, if you need help - write us an email.

  • @wisteela
    @wisteela Год назад +1

    Fantastic. I wasn't expecting those rotary switches to be as long as that. That meter is fantastic, and it looked great seeing them all moving in the dark. Yes, more of these videos would be great.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Thank you! We surelynwill have when get enough verious devices (some we got)

  • @AnthonyFrancisJones
    @AnthonyFrancisJones Год назад +1

    I am sure someone has said it below somewhere but many of us have used EdSpot galvanometers which work in a very similar way with a light beam and moving mirror with the 'throw' acting to amplify the weak signal. Many very early galvanometers used a magnet/coil light and mirror system and could project onto a scale across a room. In your case they are very visible even in low light levels and the light beam replaces what would be a large needle.

  • @movax20h
    @movax20h Год назад +20

    Pretty cool. Looks all well built.
    The green / red zones using tape and sensors in the meter itself, is indeed fascinating, and a bit ridiculous and complicated, but it has some charm and straightforwardness to it.

  • @NeilVitale
    @NeilVitale Год назад +2

    Two "non-standard" uses I can think of the dial gage would be to wire it up as a vu meter or possibly a CPU load meter for a single board computer or in a 5.25" drive bay.

  • @emilschw8924
    @emilschw8924 Год назад +2

    That is really cool old tech! Thanks for sharing!

  • @RFC3514
    @RFC3514 Год назад +3

    If you often need to power DC devices up to 30 volts, I'd recommend getting a Korad KA3005P power supply. It's one of the best you can get for a relatively affordable price (under 120 euros).

  • @marianaldenhoevel7240
    @marianaldenhoevel7240 Год назад +7

    Thank you for well-researched and wonderfully presented content from a corner of the tech-world us westerners know way too little about.

  • @rosco4659
    @rosco4659 Год назад +1

    I have some old soviet nixie tube digits that I tell myself are spare parts from an RBMK control room. Great video thanks!

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +2

      The truth is, there ARE devices in the control room which use nixie tubes.

    • @rosco4659
      @rosco4659 Год назад +2

      @@ChernobylFamily Good to know, they are brand new in the box. no writing on the box, just a plain cardboard box. I will dig them out of my workshop and look for part numbers, maybe there is a way to cross reference them.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +2

      Those used are IN-15 and IN-12, SKALA uses the IV series.

    • @rosco4659
      @rosco4659 Год назад +2

      @@ChernobylFamily I actually think they might be IN-12

  • @GothGuy885
    @GothGuy885 Год назад +1

    thank you! these were some very interesting components. 😀😍
    my take on how I think the last item works: the Mirror is on a pivot
    which is connected to the movement of something like an Analog meter,
    and when the milliamp value changes, the meter's armature moves forward , thus
    causing the mirror to rotate X amount of degrees , and the light spot moves
    across the scale.
    we have similar industrial rotary switches here in America, but they differ in that the contact layers are modular, so they can be customized , by adding or removing contact modules.

  • @drneves1
    @drneves1 Год назад +2

    Excellent work. Greetings from Portugal.

  • @danbrit9848
    @danbrit9848 Год назад +4

    you are amazing and i truly love your work ...i always wounder how this old stuff worked its so much cooler then modern stuff of o look a chip ok ...and you know what your talking about its not a tairdown as much as class ...and i love every min of every vid ...stay strong

  • @edgeeffect
    @edgeeffect Год назад +2

    The optical metres are fantastic and that adjustable coloured gel to mark the rad and green zones on the dial is just so cool. I remember seeing something a bit similar in old audio equipment but there the gel is just placed over the meter... the adjusting mechanism is simply genius. And those rotary switches are the most amazingly robust electronic devices I think I've ever seen.... I'd love to have some of those but I don't think any of the enclosures I use could take the strain. ;) all 3 devices seem to be beautifully "over engineered". Fabulous!

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +3

      Especially those square buttons are insane. Pause on the moment where I show the lightbulb inside - there is such a metal 'bucket' around, secured with a shaped nut around the lamp holder. So to install that button, one would need to remove the cap, then the nut, then take out that 'bucket' and insert it into the control panel opening, place the button from the another side and then assemble that back. And repeat that 223 times per quantity of buttons on that SUZ panel.
      PS.: if you will eventually wish to have some those meters, we can find, but they are ~40$ as I can see by surplus shops. Also, our is missing a special installation clip.
      Both clip and buttons you can see well in our old video about the walk through the power plant when we come to control room 4, there devices are missing.

    • @myg931
      @myg931 Год назад +1

      That's sounds like the 'korry switch', which is the same kinds of switchs used in the western world. BTW, what's the price of the meter in the surplus shops?@@ChernobylFamily

  • @ct6502c
    @ct6502c Год назад +2

    Very cool! I really like that the switches were still in their original boxes! It's always fun to see vintage equipment still in new condition like that.

  • @coffeecodecameras
    @coffeecodecameras Год назад +2

    The pushbutton indicators are very reminiscent of the MIL-PRF-22885 push button/indicators produced by companies such as Eaton, Korry, Applied Avionics etc and still used extensively in modern avionic and military systems. The optical beam guage is very interesting - it reminds me of the vertical tape displays used in avionics (and some naval applications) in which a tape with a printed scale is positioned (often by a synchro/resolver). Such tape displays are still used although often implemented graphically such as in modern EFIS systems (LED versions also exist).

  • @WestAviationSim
    @WestAviationSim Год назад +1

    I really love this. Please indeed show more. I'm very interested in the depth gauges for the control rods. Servo meters?

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Sure! Check the video about SKALA, we briefly explain there how those work. But we are thinking to bring a couple of actual selsyns to show them in action.

  • @a-z-n-b-a-i
    @a-z-n-b-a-i Год назад +1

    thanks for this epic haul
    the executive function in the end blew up my mind

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      Glad that you liked!

    • @a-z-n-b-a-i
      @a-z-n-b-a-i Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily we have waited for a channel like yours since years, while polusepars and vandals like kreosan were dishonoring the great and tragic heritage which you seek to preserve

  • @Melanie16040
    @Melanie16040 Год назад +1

    Yes! Please share more devices with us!

  • @rexthewarhorse
    @rexthewarhorse Год назад +3

    Very cool. Love old meters

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      I think I'l find some more, there are even more interesting.

    • @rexthewarhorse
      @rexthewarhorse Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily looking forward to it 😊

  • @jw200
    @jw200 Год назад +2

    Very cool. Thanks so much. Keep making the videos.

  • @АлександрПономарев-и4я

    Hello! Another great video from you. Can you tell us something about alarm systems-relays in БЩУ-4-3? They sound very interesting, but I do not think they are that simple. Thanks in advance.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      Thank you! Right at the moment I do not have any details, but maybe in future.

  • @konserv
    @konserv Год назад +1

    The optical beam gauge is a masterpiece!

  • @TheNavalAviator
    @TheNavalAviator Год назад

    10:32 The coloring feature may seem a bit ridiculous but if you have dozens of meters to monitor simultaneously, I can imagine it's quite handy that the indicator light also changes its color. The RBMK was definitely pushing the boundaries of operator workload, so it's probably worth it to implement.

  • @JCTsFascinatingHobbies
    @JCTsFascinatingHobbies Год назад +1

    Absolutely brilliant video and a superb channel. I have more than a passing interest in nuclear power. Out of interest, where did you find these parts?

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Thank you! From electronic surplus sellers. Those parts are not unique to the NPPs, but well, they are not widespread though.

  • @derekchristenson5711
    @derekchristenson5711 Год назад +1

    That rotary switch was switching many more contacts that I was expecting. Interesting!
    I'm also sure that I've seen another RUclips channel demonstrate an antique current-measuring device that used the same principle as gauge you showed. Similar, but much, much older (perhaps over 100 years old, even), and without the film + photodiode parts. A very interesting piece of old tech.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Thank you! Yes, there should be such a video as undoubtedly this meter is not a soviet creation.

    • @derekchristenson5711
      @derekchristenson5711 Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily I found it! This is the 19th-century lab instrument I was thinking of: ruclips.net/video/QLlYhhPjsDs/видео.htmlsi=-BYN0XdbdMa7x4od

  • @_hackwell
    @_hackwell Год назад +1

    this meter has a pretty clever design! In the first place I thought it was some kind of nixie display. An my guess it that was quite reliable. Neat !

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      I must say, I was pretty surprised to see all that optical system...)

  • @C.O.S-MIX
    @C.O.S-MIX 6 месяцев назад +1

    Well, as already said the meter is fantastic. And please trust my experience that is not big. We used in Romania, somehow a similar meter, but the scale limits were detected by a induction based sensors which were mounted on a circle shape cogwheel inside to detect only the mix and max and that meter is way thick and a bit deeper.
    What is extremally interesting is that that multiple values (I mean multiple minimums and maximums values ca be detected and reported by the network of photoresistors planted on the film surface), plus, the only moving part inside is the mirror, which as it`s obvious it`s well protected).
    Another aspect is the color....a very logic scale....green---->yellow---->red.
    Redundancy of the limit detectors....if a photoresistor fails, the next in row, will send the signal. Even more, the tiny photoresistors can be planted in parallel... on this type of equipment the redundancy is crucial.
    One point of failure is the bulb itself, but even with a defective bulb, this can be easily observed by the staff from the day/night shift.
    For sure as the bulb is for 27V~ which often was used by navy/mil, even sometimes @400Hz, (for sel-syns for example), powered at 24V, will last a very very long time.
    I repaired some industrial electronics (sdelano v sssr) and noted really clever and extremely interesting ways of applying the physics, with very complex features, not easy to obtain, acquired thru simple means).
    The level of engineering, ingenuity was just insane...the engineers were really top top top of the class.
    I own as collector items some soviet electronics, also with lacquer on top, awesome.
    Don`t get me wrong, we had plenty top top engineers in Romania back in the days, yet this example with this special meter, which can be created today even smaller than the original one, is and absolute work of art.
    Could say more, but makes text too long to be read, about some of my experiences with sovietic electronics since it was largely spread and used in my country too.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  6 месяцев назад +1

      Thank you for this and for sharing your experience. Indeed, that is a very interesting device, and in fact the technology was hosen as before all those designed for marine use.

  • @GenaTrius
    @GenaTrius 7 месяцев назад +1

    I've seen a lot of meters, and I've never seen a meter quite like that one. That's a real electro-optico-mechanical contraption!

  • @peregrineclarke
    @peregrineclarke Год назад +1

    That is beautiful retro tech, I would love to get my hands on a pair of those milliammeters you demonstrated at the end of your video, they would make superb retro VU meters for an audio amp I'm building.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      It is very possible, they are not super cheap, but nothing really extreme. Write an e-mail via the button on About Channel page (desktop only)

  • @alexhajnal107
    @alexhajnal107 Год назад

    Those are absolutely gorgeous! They look very well made and well engineered,

  • @RRsalin
    @RRsalin Год назад +1

    For my whole life I have had an extremely intense obsesion with control panels (I'm autistic) and this video blew me away. Of course visiting the ChNpp was the best day of my life, but I was not interested in the disaster but in the technology and the control panels. I hope some day I will visit one of these simulators in Lithuania that you can actually touch. I hope they are preserved forever. I wish I will someday find controls like these for sale. I have to admit that I bought a lot of vintage analog meters in the fleamarkets of Ukraine

  • @AmauryJacquot
    @AmauryJacquot Год назад +1

    using what looks like cinema film was super smart !

  • @fullraph
    @fullraph Год назад +1

    I absolutely love this kind of videos!

  • @csocsobence
    @csocsobence Год назад +1

    The resistors on the green and red film probably used to control another instruments like a more noticeable light or an alarm. In this way they can save the wireing and the computing power.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      I also think so

    • @JBF-GST-Tanda
      @JBF-GST-Tanda Год назад +1

      Probably for some fault protection and notification operations, as they're not precise enough for feedback control.

  • @amarpehlic9345
    @amarpehlic9345 Год назад +1

    Hey man every video of yours i watch i wonder where do u get this stuff?

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Markets, stores, etc... though it requires A LOT of search.

  • @kermitinmountain6371
    @kermitinmountain6371 Год назад +1

    Thank you for the demonstration. I am at loss for the word, but I have a arduino power supply board like your along with white pcb board for my experience. Thank you for the another video.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      We are slowly gathering more types of controls to make a continuation in January!

  • @michaljazlowiecki
    @michaljazlowiecki Год назад +1

    The switches that have to be held in order to turn someting on are monostable (i.e., have exacly one stable position), the others are bistable, triple stable, etc.
    You can use three 9 V 6F22 "radio" batteries by connecting them in series (i.e., connect - of first battery to + of the second, - from second to + of the third) to get 27 V.
    And yes, the flat 4.5 V battery 3R12 is very rare nowadays. If you are not forced to use exactly this size of the battery pack, you can use three 1.5 V batteries instead (guess what the name of the battery pack stands for - yes, three R12 batteries, connected in series, just like I have described above for 6F22 batteries). R14 (or C) type batteries are more common, but they are larger, R6 (or AA, or UM-3) are smaller. The greater number after R (which basically means "round" for their cyllindrical shape), the greater capacity (with R20 or D size being the greatest of the common ones) the battery has.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      There is an interesting thing for 3R12 batteries. Soviets intentionally used individual R12 cells in military equipment, and R12s were not sold anywhere, so this way they prevented stealing any 'government-owned' gear by people. So I need to grab those time to time to power our old dosimeters.
      As for using 3x1.5V, yes, I know, in fact soviets even sold adapters, but as usual they reinvented a wheel, and soviet 1.5 cells were different in size comparable to AA. So it is always tricky...)

    • @michaljazlowiecki
      @michaljazlowiecki Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily The R12 batteries were never sold alone, AFAIK. In 1980s, 3R12 batteries pack was the most common one found in almost every shop or newspaper stand, with R20 (D size in current terms) and R14 (C size) following (I think this was the order of their popularity). R6 (AA or UM-3, as it was designated in Germany) was pretty uncommon, gaining popularity in 1990s. R3 (AAA or UM-1) was sold only in two places in my home town by mid-1990s!
      I was not familiar with the secret idea behind selection of R12 batteries to create the famous "flat" battery pack 3R12. As I haven't seen this battery pack for ages, I'm not entirely sure whether there is no accumulator (i.e., rechargeable one) with the (almost) the same size as R12 battery and the same voltage (still, many accumulators produce only 1.2 V, so this could be the case). I wonder whether my father could shed some light on it...

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      @@michaljazlowiecki in Ukraine 3R12 so far as I can see by quick googling are only "old stock"... I think at least will try to find a proper adapter.

  • @ZiomMarcin
    @ZiomMarcin Год назад +2

    Can you show crane in reactor hall with details? I would like see electrical inside and mechanisms (winch, main ride etc.) :)

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +2

      in the episode about RBMK that will be. We do not have much footage, because it is pretty dark there for our gear, and now we can't make any new; but we will try to explain as much as possible.

  • @SovietLensReviews
    @SovietLensReviews Год назад +2

    That control panel meter is a perfect example of Soviet design methodology: "Who needs things like buttons or extra knobs when a screwdriver will do the adjustments just as well!"
    Crude, but beautiful in its own way.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +2

      Pretty true. Now the fun, russians still produce them.

    • @SovietLensReviews
      @SovietLensReviews Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily I would say I'm surprised, but they still produce Soviet lenses as well 😂

  • @YukariAkiyamaTanks
    @YukariAkiyamaTanks 6 месяцев назад +1

    Very fascinating video!

  • @spokehedz
    @spokehedz Год назад

    Oh! The 'film' on either side for the normal/max ranges looks a lot like regular film just with no coatings on it. Such a clever solution.

  • @kevb1816
    @kevb1816 Год назад +1

    A pair of those optical meters would make a cool VU meter for a stereo Hifi system!

    • @stefanhuebner5358
      @stefanhuebner5358 Год назад +1

      Actually, german (both of them) broadcast electronics used such galvanometers ("Lichtzeigerinstrument", light pointer instrument) for exactly that -> de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Lichtzeiger_Instrument_Siemens_%26_Halske.jpg

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      Wow! That sound cool! We don't know much about sound equipment but that sounds very cool as far as we can imagine :)

  • @UpLateGeek
    @UpLateGeek Год назад

    That meter has a very clever design. I imagine the photoresistors on the green and red films could be used to provide signals to the computer so it can record the levels that the meter is reading. Perhaps it could be used with some other circuitry for simple automations, like flashing a warning light on one of the the operator's panels, or actuating a coolant valve or something.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Yes, though I'd not risk attaching to it something important as all in fact will depend on a single light bulb.

  • @DieselKotov
    @DieselKotov Год назад +1

    Світлова панель з дзеркальцем прям топова. Ніколи таких не бачив! Дякую за відео!

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Чесно кажучи, поки мені не сказали, як воно працює, я б ніколи не здогадався би :)

    • @DieselKotov
      @DieselKotov Год назад +1

      @@ChernobylFamily я коли побачив, я думав там тіпа вузький канал поворотний в шось підбиваюче пофарбований. Але дзеркальце було несподіванкою)))
      Ну добре хоч не лучева трубка, бо совки могли)))

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Це точно))

  • @marcinkowalczyk647
    @marcinkowalczyk647 8 месяцев назад +1

    I'd love to see more of such tech

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  8 месяцев назад

      This year will be TONS of it. Stay tuned - we are looking for funding, as we need hell of expensive components.

  • @robinwells8879
    @robinwells8879 Год назад +1

    Beautiful, elegantly simple analog mechanical equipment. Hugely robust and very serviceable. Just what you want in a reactor location. They would still work in lethal ionising radiation or EMP fields. ❤

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Well, during normal operation the radiation levels are far from elevated or lethal, but you certainly have a point...))))

    • @robinwells8879
      @robinwells8879 Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily absolutely. But in the event of a major incident I suspect that they would be very resilient. If fukashima had been able to maintain its control and monitoring capabilities it might have been a different story.

  • @techman2553
    @techman2553 Год назад +1

    An optical meter seems like a strange choice for critical monitoring because if the bulb burns out, you can't read the meter at all. A backlit needle will at least allow you to see the needle if the lightsource fails.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Perhaps they had a control for this, as there is a test sequence of all panels (check one of previous videos with the archive footage)

  • @puciohenzap891
    @puciohenzap891 Год назад +1

    Loved it, thank you!

  • @julientihema4851
    @julientihema4851 Год назад

    Excellent very content I've been looking for, I watched an interview about launch keys from the Soviet era they were made from titanium which is very difficult to work with, they were also used for space launch.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      That's interesting, i did not know about those.

    • @julientihema4851
      @julientihema4851 Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily whoever made these launch keys was a master craftsman had to be a Soviet engineer, fact they're made from titanium is rare indeed they can't be replicated from normal metals.

  • @joir2000
    @joir2000 Год назад +2

    Pretty nice devices.
    But I am still wondering what happens exactly when Аз-5 is activated.
    Are there any schemetical diagrams of it?

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +3

      I think to explain it in one of future episodes.

  • @ptonpc
    @ptonpc Год назад +1

    The meter is beautiful. I wonder what the failure rate or operational life of the meters and switches was.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      From what I remember from documentation, switches would last at least 10K commutations. As for the meter, need to check...

    • @ptonpc
      @ptonpc Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily Thank you :)

  • @milklk4414
    @milklk4414 21 день назад +1

    Where did you find all this? I also want to start a collection with some buttons, switches, and even screens when possible.

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  21 день назад +1

      @milklk4414 No jokes :in Ukraine this is sold in markets... i just came and bought.

    • @milklk4414
      @milklk4414 21 день назад +1

      @@ChernobylFamily what? So they have shops with shelves filled with them?!

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  21 день назад +1

      @milklk4414 ruclips.net/video/SAkvLTjZpqc/видео.html

    • @milklk4414
      @milklk4414 21 день назад

      @@ChernobylFamily oh, I actually saw that video a long time ago but I forgot about it. Thank you.

  • @FixitFrank
    @FixitFrank Год назад

    More of these please!

  • @techn1kal1ty
    @techn1kal1ty Год назад

    Hey guys, happy Monday! Can't wait to watch 😊

  • @TheFanOrTheMask
    @TheFanOrTheMask Год назад

    love your videos, very interesting to see the technology.

  • @station240
    @station240 Год назад +2

    I thought the control panel meter was over-engineered with just needing two mirrors, then you got to the part where it has light meters on the coloured film.
    I'd think the reason the switches have multiple sets of contracts (poles), is for safety reasons.
    Most of them are just inputs into the computer, but you'd want redundant parallel contacts (and perhaps inputs).

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      Makes sense!
      As for the meter, I believe they used light instead of a mechanical pointer because it gives a more stability in environments like sea, and it is also visible from higher distance.

    • @station240
      @station240 Год назад +1

      @@ChernobylFamily I've seen this arrangement used in barcode scanners, but they managed to do it with just one mirror.
      Though laser diodes are much smaller and easier to focus.

  • @DjResR
    @DjResR Год назад +1

    The first switch can handle 220VDC or 380VAC. Quite a contact gap to disconnect DC that high.
    The square battery can be substitute with Li-Ion battery as the voltages are close to each other._

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Thank you! Yes, of course it is pissible to substitute that battery, but I will need exactly that one for, let's call it this way, "authentic approach"

  • @neil4306
    @neil4306 Год назад +1

    What a great video. Thank you😊

  • @thestormchasingconcorde6184
    @thestormchasingconcorde6184 Год назад +2

    can you show BAZ, AZS and KOM switches under the covers?

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +2

      In the next video yes, will check my pictures. But technically they all are of those three variations.

    • @thestormchasingconcorde6184
      @thestormchasingconcorde6184 Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily by the way, what is the model of the two switches in the middle at 2:32 ? the one with the arrows on them

  • @CommandProMC
    @CommandProMC 2 месяца назад +1

    "Fixation when turned" = stays turned
    "Auto-return" = springloaded

  • @fishfinder7083
    @fishfinder7083 Год назад

    Hey, i was curious where i can find those “ aviation “ light bulbs that are in the buttons. I need them for a project of mine

  • @Silanael
    @Silanael Год назад

    It's great to see the internal workings of these things, looking forward to more!

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад +1

      Thank you! I'll go for some shopping for this, if you wish to chip in - links are in the description - we'll be happy!

  • @KnaufL
    @KnaufL Год назад +1

    You could connect 3x 9V batteries in series and get 27V to light up the bulbs fully

  • @VaisakhSudhakaran
    @VaisakhSudhakaran Год назад +1

    Hi Can you shows us how the control board panel looks from back side 🙂🙏

    • @ChernobylFamily
      @ChernobylFamily  Год назад

      Will try to find some pictures to show in the next episodes.

    • @VaisakhSudhakaran
      @VaisakhSudhakaran Год назад

      @@ChernobylFamily Hi can you tell me exact name of that Optical beam panel /Meter
      🙂

  • @Jappmannen
    @Jappmannen Год назад +1

    I have actually been in a control room like the one in Chernobyl when I was visiting the Ignalina NPP in 2014.
    When I were there the reactors had not been operating for maybe 4 years or something like that. And because of that there were only one guy there. A sleeping guard who looked after the fire protection systems. 😅
    And yes there are similar instruments in swedish npp too. 😊

  • @zaloopakonya3068
    @zaloopakonya3068 Год назад +1

    Those beam gauges are still widely used in Russia, had worked with those myself, very reilable stuff compared to their more "modern" replacements from the 90s

  • @lort_prodisz
    @lort_prodisz Год назад +3

    these optical milliammeters were also in nuclear bunkers... I have several working ones :)