Superman Movie Serials vs Captain Marvel 1941

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024

Комментарии • 86

  • @DarrylRuiz-s1w
    @DarrylRuiz-s1w Год назад +6

    Love how Captain Marvel.machine guns down the bad guys and throws them off the roof The Captain means business!

  • @tvcrazyman
    @tvcrazyman  Год назад +5

    I added some new stuff and compiled a comparison using some clips from my other movie serial videos on the similarities and differences between the Superman and Captain Marvel movie serials.

    • @ronpetersen2317
      @ronpetersen2317 Год назад +1

      Well if you need some ideas for future videos maybe you can ask us for suggestions. Maybe a comparison of old shows to modern movies? I know I love the fake team ups you do those are fun. There are characters from the eightys and nineties you could tackle. I think you did The Greatest American Hero but there are more obscure ones. I forget the name of the show but the guy basically could bring a video game tron type of character into the real world his car drove like the tron cars defying the laws of physics etc. I don't know if you did Isis which not sure if youtube might get triggered by her name for terror group reasons. Electra Woman and Dyna Girl perhaps? I am trying to remember other more obscure ones.

    • @ronpetersen2317
      @ronpetersen2317 Год назад +1

      I pulled this from ChatGPT
      1920s:
      "The Mark of Zorro" (1920)
      "The Bat" (1926)
      "The Black Pirate" (1926)
      1930s:
      4. "The Shadow Strikes" (1937)
      "The Green Hornet" (1939)
      1940s:
      6. "The Shadow" (1940)
      "The Green Hornet Strikes Again!" (1940)
      "Adventures of Captain Marvel" (1941)
      "The Batman" (1943)
      "The Phantom" (1943)
      "Captain America" (1944)
      "Batman and Robin" (1949)
      "Superman" (1948)
      1950s:
      14. "Adventures of Superman" (1952-1958)
      1960s:
      15. "Batman" (1966-1968)
      "The Green Hornet" (1966-1967)
      1970s:
      17. "Wonder Woman" (1975-1979)
      "The Amazing Spider-Man" (1977-1979)
      "The Incredible Hulk" (1977-1982)
      1980s:
      20. "Superman II" (1980)
      "Swamp Thing" (1982)
      "Supergirl" (1984)
      "The Adventures of Superboy" (1988-1992)

  • @mateusbaldi
    @mateusbaldi 6 месяцев назад +3

    I grew up watching those old Republic-Columbia movie serials -- Captain Marvel is my favorite, the effects are astonishing for that time, and it's a really cool mystery serial. Nice video! Thanks!

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  6 месяцев назад +1

      Glad you enjoyed it

  • @cadeevans4623
    @cadeevans4623 Год назад +3

    These were entertaining man loved both of them

  • @johnjames-glover4630
    @johnjames-glover4630 Год назад +4

    Great video. Informative and fun.

  • @ts-900
    @ts-900 4 месяца назад +1

    That was interesting. Didn't realize that was Kirk Alyn in the Superman movie scene with Noel Neill on the train. I didn't get to see the Kirk Alyn Superman very often, but I remember how strange it was that he turned into a cartoon and back.

  • @Lee-Darin
    @Lee-Darin Год назад +7

    I still call him Captain Marvel

    • @kali3665
      @kali3665 Год назад +2

      So do I. That's whom he has ALWAYS been. Marvel has had several "Captains Marvel" because they had to keep using the name -- no matter how unsuccessful the character proved to be -- to keep their copyright on the character. But there's only one TRUE Captain Marvel.

  • @paulbookwood6410
    @paulbookwood6410 Год назад +2

    Awesome! I'm lucky enough to have the Superman movie serials on DVD, and I've watched them many times. It's worth it just to see the old cars.😎

    • @hawleygriffon9290
      @hawleygriffon9290 10 месяцев назад +1

      Yeah, the old vehicles and locations around LA at the time and how they've changed over the years and if any of those old places still exist.

  • @dwaynelangerhr6985
    @dwaynelangerhr6985 Год назад +3

    Wow someone that calls Captain Marvel by his REAL name.

  • @jamesb.9155
    @jamesb.9155 Год назад +2

    Tom Tyler (August 1903 - May 1954).

  • @hawleygriffon9290
    @hawleygriffon9290 10 месяцев назад +2

    You do know they used real bullets in those old movies and serials. The cartridges held a much smaller charge of gunpowder though. You can see a metal plate protecting Tom Tyler in front of his chest in closeups where the crooks are firing at him. In the scene where the crook fires at him point blank, you can see him wince because of the impact of the bullets. Low charge notwithstanding, at that range, the bullets will still hurt! A couple good books on old serials are "To Be Continued" and "The Great Movie Serials". Great reading if you can find them. I used to watch a lot of old serials on TVOntario's Magic Shadows, hosted by the great Elwy Yost. That's where I fell in love with them. Luckily, RUclips has quite a few of them, though The Adventures of Captain Marvel remains my favorite. Heck, I even met CC Beck at a convention in 1978. Good times...

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  10 месяцев назад +1

      I don't think I ever heard of the bullets thing before. Very interesting.

  • @disneyfan8178
    @disneyfan8178 2 месяца назад +1

    IMHO, I like the second train scene better. Also, I think Frank Coghlan looks a little like Tommy Kirk.

  • @irontaylor9992
    @irontaylor9992 11 месяцев назад +3

    Great video I like captain Marvel

  • @richardkent1328
    @richardkent1328 Год назад +2

    By the way I enjoyed your video and other videos you have put together online here. Keep up the good work. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼💯

  • @Donathon-qx8kq
    @Donathon-qx8kq 11 месяцев назад

    I have always loved Captain Marvel

  • @FirstnameLastname-my7bz
    @FirstnameLastname-my7bz Год назад

    2:09 a wild ask considering the Punisher came WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY later

  • @Skaramine
    @Skaramine 4 месяца назад

    One thing that I remember, Billy wasn't afraid to stick a revolver in his pocket when going on an investigation. Then again, Clark is bulletproof all the time, Billy wasn't.

  • @alanbear6505
    @alanbear6505 Год назад +2

    Captain Marvel’s name is a long story but basically Marvel Comics managed to steal the rights to name but not the character.

    • @hotroddave7597
      @hotroddave7597 Год назад

      That’s about right. In my opinion, all of the Captain Marvel characters that marvel comics has, they’ve all been terrible. In the courtroom the original Captain Marvel, one that battle, but it’s time passes, and I tell you got into such a mess. It’s just unreal with Captain Marvel.

  • @hotroddave7597
    @hotroddave7597 Год назад +1

    I am fortunate enough to have several issues from the 1940s of Captain Marvel along with Captain Marvel, Junior and Mary marvel. It’s easy to understand why these characters were so popular in the 1950s.

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  Год назад

      I have most of the 70's Shazam comics. I hope to start getting some of the 40' comics. They are kind of expensive. I got one Captain Marvel Jr from 1949, but the cover is loose. Sounds like you have a awesome collection!

    • @hotroddave7597
      @hotroddave7597 Год назад +1

      @@tvcrazyman I remember when Shazam made his first appearance in DC comics I think it was a battle with Superman. How ironic is that ? There was a time when you got 52 big pages for $.10 and I must say I really enjoyed the comics from the 1940s especially Batman the world of Batman that Bob, Kane and Bill finger created is my absolute favorite.

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  Год назад

      Yeah, I think Superman was on the cover of the 1st DC Shazam book in the 70's. I've got a 70's giant magazine sized comic with Superman vs Shazam that is one of my favorites to go back and look at every now and again. Back in the 40's you got all those pages and hardly any ads which I kind of like looking at old ads, but there's not a lot of them in older books. Most of my oldest books are in the 50's and 60's. It's getting harder and harder to get books in the 40's.@@hotroddave7597

    • @hotroddave7597
      @hotroddave7597 Год назад +1

      @@tvcrazyman collecting comic books is truly disease 😻

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  Год назад

      Yeah, collecting comics does tend to be addictive and time consuming and costly. But it is fun too. 😀@@hotroddave7597

  • @FirstnameLastname-my7bz
    @FirstnameLastname-my7bz Год назад

    Captain Marvel guy looks more like earliest Shuster Superman (who was, partly inspired, by Weissmuller)

  • @danatownsend9155
    @danatownsend9155 11 месяцев назад +1

    As far as I'm concerned Kirk alyn was the first Superman

  • @giovannigandara5845
    @giovannigandara5845 10 месяцев назад

    IT WAS TO COMICAL!!!

  • @jessejohnson3.24
    @jessejohnson3.24 Год назад +2

    I just saw Superman fight Captain marvel shazam on justice league 2000s animated series

  • @FirstnameLastname-my7bz
    @FirstnameLastname-my7bz Год назад

    1:27 because no kill thing was forced onto DC characters in 1941
    In Action Comics 23, which is Also first Luthor appearance, you can see Superman shooting machine gun to blow up planes

  • @kevinmcc3147
    @kevinmcc3147 Год назад

    I like both characters but I was and still is more into shazam captain marvel more.

  • @AustynSN
    @AustynSN 4 месяца назад

    While I do agree that Captain Marvel being called "Shazam" is ridiculous because he can't say his own name, it's good to remember that Captain Marvel Jr (AKA Freddy Freeman) always had that problem since he got his powers from Billy, not the wizard. And thus, his magic word was "Captain Marvel".

  • @hydrolito
    @hydrolito Год назад

    All the times knocked out from Chloroform on Wonder Woman would cause health problems also.

  • @FirstnameLastname-my7bz
    @FirstnameLastname-my7bz Год назад

    4:03 Ironically, in this particular moment it is EVERYTHING BUT 2 actors in tight cuits that aren't real (wire work against greenscreen)

  • @14DaveHunter
    @14DaveHunter Год назад

    Atom Man looked like a knock off, of Don Del Oro; from "Zorro's Fighting Legion".

  • @FirstnameLastname-my7bz
    @FirstnameLastname-my7bz Год назад

    11:22 why not, he is tough And lightweight, not a heavy rock.
    In previous examples his balance was supported by the floor.

  • @wesleycook7687
    @wesleycook7687 Год назад +2

    There's no comparison.. Captain Marvel 's serial was far superior to anything in the Superman serials. And saying one word to change Billy Batson to Captain Marvel is a better alternative to Clark Kent wearing the costume under his suit and hiding to become Superman. I've seen all the serials so I have to go with Captain Marvel
    .

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  Год назад

      That's fair. I liked them both though. I guess, Captain Marvel appealed to me more on the action adventure side and the Superman was a little more fun and cartoony. Cap definitely had Supes beat on the flying scenes, but if you were a kid at the time you may have preferred Superman's cartoon version. They were definitely both better than the first Batman serial, at least in my opinion.

  • @pulsarstargrave256
    @pulsarstargrave256 Год назад

    Jackson Bostwick made me a Captain Marvel fan and despite the efforts of DC Comics, there was no turning back!
    As for The 1943 BATMAN Serial, I'll bet you were shocked at how influential the cheesy series was on the comic book series! (I know I was when I first heard about it but seeing was believing!) I used to own it but gave it away after I bought the 1949 version! That one was also cheesy but it was less offensive to me and I liked the story a LOT more!

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  Год назад +1

      Yeah, I plan doing some more research but it's my understanding so far it was the first place we ever saw the batcave and it influenced how Alfred looked in the comics. I was irritated by how disrespectful Batman was to Alfred. There was one scene where he shoots a lazer at him and then basically calls him a coward for jumping. I think it was pretty bad writing. Maybe, they just sort of did it on the fly and made it up as they went along, but it was pretty boring on top of everything else.

    • @pulsarstargrave256
      @pulsarstargrave256 Год назад

      @@tvcrazyman In the comics it was just an underground hangar and tune up area but it had no name! The serial called it "The Bat's Cave" and turned it into an under ground headquarters! I might check out your video but eagerly look forward to your review of the second serial!

  • @kali3665
    @kali3665 Год назад +1

    Crazyman? Regarding the second Batman serial -- trust us, it doesn't get better. In fact, Batman gets even stupider!!🤣

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  Год назад +1

      I was afraid of that. I saw the first chapter last night of the second serial and it was kind of boring and Batman's ears were still looking like horns or something.

  • @FirstnameLastname-my7bz
    @FirstnameLastname-my7bz Год назад

    10:09 correct! From Superman 59, Alan Shotwell story, character which actually inspired Kraven The Hunter and then inspired Back the Max Zharov in new52 Action Comics
    Also fan fact : heat vision (generally, some Could see them as laser eyes like Jim Starlin, Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons) was always x-ray vision extension in comics up until 1986 reboot (but heat vision was still mostly invisible to human eye only now Superman's were clearly red when he used or attempted to use them,which was "invented" by Jim Starlin but only became consistent Visible to characters in the comics only after 1986 reboot) . Which was also inspired (or predicted) by Kirk Aylin version of Superman, with Superman's hairstyle being much more natural just curly hair instead of how it was past Shuster Studio era with Superman having "forced" Spit curl right on the middle. Also Kirk's version was first ever version of Superman where Both Kents alive when Clark became Superman, which was carried into comics with 1986 reboot. Before that either both Kents died in the background (original Siegel version) or Mary/Martha dies first then John/Jonathan (opposite how it is in live action after George Reeves' show and especially after Christopher Reeve's The Movie) .

    • @hawleygriffon9290
      @hawleygriffon9290 10 месяцев назад

      I believe though that X-ray vision was invented by Max and Dave Fleischer for the cartoon "Superman and the Mechanical Monsters" where it was first used. It was later adopted by the comic. Sure would gave been a cool effect for a cartoon for viewers at the time.

  • @fosterlaff
    @fosterlaff Год назад

    In one brief moment in the 2nd Shazam movie, someone actually says the name "Captain Marvel." Did the producers not catch it, or they left it in on purpose?

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  Год назад +1

      That was the actor who played Billy Batson on the 70's TV show, Michael Gray.

  • @councilbaker7972
    @councilbaker7972 Год назад +3

    @TVCrazyman - the reason DC isn't calling him Captain Marvel is because after Fawcett went out of business and before DC Acquired the rights to the Fawcett material, Marvel Comics trademarked the name Captain Marvel (while making a completely new character for the name).
    Initially, DC titled the books SHAZAM! while still calling the character Captain Marvel. Over time, they made the decision to just call him Shazam, and call the wizard Shazam simply 'The Wizard'.
    So...the reason for the confusion with the name of this hero that dates all the way back to 1939.... is for reasons mightier than the Man of Steel and the World's Mightiest Mortal combined... legal reasons.

    • @ronpetersen2317
      @ronpetersen2317 Год назад

      It is more about Marvel being a jerk and wanting to snag the name. Then DC has been sue happy in the past. They sued over The Greatest American hero as being a rip off of Superman. Over things like usings sounds of a train indicating he was running more powerful than a locomotive and such nonsense. The dumb part is they had more grounds to sue over Green Lantern than Superman. The origin and his powers coming from a device given to him by aliens ... They borrowed a LOT more from Green Lantern than Superman. They also sued Fawcet over Captain Marvel.

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  Год назад

      Right, people started thinking his name was Shazam because that was the title they saw on the books and the 70's show, but I think those of us that were fans knew better, then like you said they decided to just go with Shazam for brand recognition, I suppose, but that didn't make as much sense in the context of the story. He'll always be Captain Marvel to me. i was never very crazy about Marvel Comics' versions, any of them, although some of the early books were pretty good, way back in the 70's.

  • @stanleyteriaca2184
    @stanleyteriaca2184 Год назад

    The thing is...between the first comic series and the DC Comics revival Marvel owns the Copyright over the name Captain Marvel. This they lost the ability to call him Captain Marvel.

  • @kenpope5798
    @kenpope5798 Год назад +1

    👍

  • @FirstnameLastname-my7bz
    @FirstnameLastname-my7bz Год назад

    19:58 what's also cool is that in comics of this era (1978) Sam Lane, Lois Lane's father actually looked like older Clark Kent, also she is ginger just like Joanne Siegel (Kovacs/Carter) was who was prototype for the comics Lois Lane
    Also I disagree, Henry Cavill is only one who truly looks like Superman from comics, especially Shuster's original face.
    George Reeves inspired (or maybe Weisinger insisted on it to have synergy) Curt Swan and Al Plastino to draw his Superman (and in case of Swan literally almost every male character aside minor details like haircolor, hair length, hairstyle or freckles or lack of them) with very similar face, but that came After, same way Gary Frank and Chris Reeve. While Cavill was predicted by comics art, including the very first ones (which were amalgam of earliest Hollywood actors, but still very first Superman)

  • @thesun564
    @thesun564 Год назад +2

    The reason he isn’t called captain marvel is due to some legal treason with the actual Marvel comic company lol.

    • @jamesb8193
      @jamesb8193 Год назад

      Tell us something we don't already know.

  • @richardkent1328
    @richardkent1328 Год назад +1

    Quick question! So how can you put a car motor on top of glass on the side of the car and the car motor didn’t go through the glass and crushed the driver and passengers in the car there’s no way that just the framing of that car would have held up that engine. Just saying!💯

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  Год назад +1

      I didn't think about that.

  • @hydrolito
    @hydrolito Год назад

    Atom Man vs Superman was filmed before Star Trek so Star Trek copied it. Although similar in comic was the Phantom Zone projector instead of the atomizer.

  • @FirstnameLastname-my7bz
    @FirstnameLastname-my7bz Год назад

    14:04 why not?!
    And in comics Superman actually had times when he either caused traffick accident by being clumsy like in Action Comics 14 or straight up tripped (NOT on purpose) like in Superman 47
    Absolutely NOTHING about super strength or super durability stands for super perfect balance, in fact I'd argue for the opposite.
    Spider-Man has perfect balance because he is sticking to the surface and Daredevil is just Mary SueSue and without super powers

  • @dustincongello5802
    @dustincongello5802 Год назад

    the worst thing about the new shazam movie is that billy acted more childish when he was cap marvel

    • @tvcrazyman
      @tvcrazyman  Год назад

      Yeah, I found that very puzzling. I also thought there was way too many super powered characters. I mean, they all had the same powers so it was very redundant. I like Zachary Levi as an actor though. Just wished he played it a little more mature.

    • @dustincongello5802
      @dustincongello5802 Год назад

      @tvcrazyman i just think cap marvel should at more childish as a kid. even in the comics he tries acting mature when hes cap marvel cause i believe for awhile the justice league didnt know he was a kid... as far as all the other kids having powers yes they are then same but each one has a specialty like the little girls speed or th fat kid being stronger or the asian kid being better with the energy blasts or what not. but i agree its to much.. lets get to know the 1 character first . let us see the other kids watch from the outside for awhile so when they get their powers it feels earned

  • @anthonyj.mickey6451
    @anthonyj.mickey6451 4 месяца назад +1

    No contest Capt Marvel was a better serial, better special effects

  • @richardlaceyfield9
    @richardlaceyfield9 Год назад +1

    Thank you for doing this ,Captain Marvel to me was always better then Superman.

  • @Pratman
    @Pratman Год назад +2

    Don't do superhero movies like this anymore 😀

  • @ronpetersen2317
    @ronpetersen2317 Год назад +1

    I want to see Captain Marvel shout Shazam!!! and turn into Brie Larson :D
    I love your stuff ... but maybe don't recycle old videos so much?

    • @bobbuethe1477
      @bobbuethe1477 Год назад +1

      I want to see Captain Marvel shout Shazam and turn into Gomer Pyle. 😊

    • @ronpetersen2317
      @ronpetersen2317 Год назад +2

      @@bobbuethe1477 He should make some clips with that sort of thing Have Gomer say Shazam and have the serial captain Marvel appear in his place

    • @bobbuethe1477
      @bobbuethe1477 Год назад +1

      @ronpetersen2317 I like that idea. Or even Mork from Ork saying "shazbot!"

  • @sethkaicer319
    @sethkaicer319 Год назад +1

    Now Captain marvel is a transsexual transvestite from Transylvania😢

  • @giovannigandara5845
    @giovannigandara5845 10 месяцев назад

    THE 1970S SHAZAM WAS ALOT BETTER!!!

  • @giovannigandara5845
    @giovannigandara5845 10 месяцев назад

    THAT SHAZAM MOVIE SUCKED!!!

  • @FirstnameLastname-my7bz
    @FirstnameLastname-my7bz Год назад

    1:27 because no kill thing was forced onto DC characters in 1941
    In Action Comics 23, which is Also first Luthor appearance, you can see Superman shooting machine gun to blow up planes