i get people singing, but the people screaming piss me off. especially threw this song or skin and bones. those two are the songs that it's like you just don't scream throughout them.
brittney wispinski amen. Josh has even said it in a show that the crowd he was singing to was perfect, because they would scream after the song then stop perfectly. It was like, scream for two seconds in between songs, stop, then wait till the next song was over and repeat
I don't know if it's just me, but I hate it when people scream and cheer during this song, and skin and bones, and actually now forget me not as well. Like it just seems rude to cheer during these songs about really hard times for him.
Guess for everyone wondering why they picked her up out of the crowd it was cause she was having an anxiety attack you can tell by the shaking and you can see that the other trenchers beside her were trying to get the guys attention
I always though that when Josh said it was so hard to sing, he was talking about the incredible vocal range. But now I realize he's talking about having to relive that terrible time he sings Lover Dearest.
guys, NOBODY can appreciate this song unless they understand it. these assholes talking crap are jealous and immature, this song has SAVED people. thats the greatest gift Josh has ever given us. Trenchers
what i will never understand is why people sing along to this song. you need to keep your mouth shut and scream later, not during a song so emotional as this.
You can hear the raw emotion in his voice.. having gone through this so roughly and making it through alive, you can just see what kind of person he is now. He even stated how hard it was for him to sing it in the start. Josh is my idol. Having insomnia, bulimia [I have/had both too], been through heroin and possibly other drugs along the way before that, I just... wow. People hate him and I don't get how. He was able to pull through it so well, against all odds. Joshua Ramsay, you are my idol.
For all the people saying that the audience needs to quiet down, when you at a concert usually the band is so loud you could scream as loud as you could in someone's ear and they wouldn't be able to hear you. But I do agree that they should be a bit quieter for this particular song out of respect.
I always immediately start crying as soon as he starts singing. Not only because it's an insanely powerful and emotional song, and Josh has the voice of a million angels, But also because the song is about Josh's previous addiction. And I always think about how if I had suffered from an addiction similar to his, I would in no way have the strength like he has to write several songs about them and then record them onto an album and sing them over and over again for several performances. That takes some serious courage. I wish I had that much courage, but I don't, sadly.
well, usually when he sings that part, he sings in falsetto (luckily his falsetto is pretty similar to his normal voice) in any case, that time, he forces his voice to go higher by crushing his vocal chords and screaming. not sure if you were actually asking or were marveling at it. either way, easier said than done, takes alot of practice to nail it.
She may have been getting crushed by the mosh pit and ended up getting hurt. Or she could have been having a claustrophobia panic attack. She looked a bit shaky so I'd go with the second but I'm not entirely sure
That girl was being squished so badly that they had to pull her out of the audience....It was super crazy on the floor with pushing-- trying to touch Josh !!
I can't wait for them to go on tour again, I am totally going to got to one of there shows. I saw them at Stampede and they were amazing! As if that's a suprize though😁. It seems like no matter what expectations I have for them live, a new song, or video they all exceed it some how. I know how much this song means to not only the fans but Josh as well. It's amazing. I'm sure it is really hard to sing. I dislike the screaming but I kinda understand it. Josh plays with the vocals live and that's what everyone screams at. It takes a lot of work to pull off some of the things he does vocally, well deserving of screams. Just amazing. 😀
Everyone, calm down, people can say what they want on here. Its called public access? I love marianas trench, they have helped me through rough times, but you don't need to go saying that every five seconds. Josh and matt and mike and ian just want to know that there helping people, you can tell your story, but don't go telling people whats wrong and whats right. because thats not right.
hate the song? sure. boring song? cool. don't know his name? awesome. but one thing that isn't cool is to comment on this video, showing how much you hate it. we come to youtube to enjoy what we love. not to read your stupid shitty comments telling us that this song is shit. we love what we want to love, and we don't need to be judged by you. and if you actually listened to the whole song and actually gave it a chance, you would see that josh actually has talent.
i also mentioned singing i was only listing tht as another reason his (astroboirap) opinion was stupid i dnt really like screaming all tht much theres something different about Josh's i cnt describe wat exactly just a different sound quality ig but thnkz for the band listings i may check them out sometime
@astroboirap They've been around since I was like born. They're fanbase is huge. Also Marianas Trench has saved tons of lives with their music. This song isn't boring. It's one of there best. Josh is the most talented guy alive. He's been doing music since he was 14. His dad owned a record label. He's written and produced songs like Call Me Maybe. Which are famous world wide
@astroboirap Um, wow, this band has been around sense what....2001, at least? That's about 11 years now. I won't say anything about his talent, because even though he clearly does have it, I guess it's a matter of opinion. But I do applaud you on spelling his name correctly. That must have taken a lot of effort.
i personal dislike how people scream while Josh is singing this song i see that is a sign of disrespect cause josh poured a personal part of his life into a song you should respect that so shut up and scream when it's the right time to
-.-. r u okay? honestly? who do U LISTEN TOO? WHO HAS MORE TALENT THEN JOSH RAMSAY? HOW IS THIS A BORING ASS SONG? i'm just going to stop talking before i rip out ur heart. (wait u might not have one if u think this is boring....)
Omg!! Josh have holes in his pants.. Why dosent he have holes in his shirt? I would just melt even more if he sang this song, while having holes in his shirt or being shirtless... If u know what Im saying, lol ;D
I wasn't talking about this song, I was talking about the song I was referencing "ripped jeans, skin was showing" that is lyrics from Call me Maybe...the song that he Co-wrote for Carly Rae Jepsen.
@blackpolishdiamon OMG yess. I completely understand. I went to see them at the CNE and we couldn't even move our arms half the time. The crowd got soo crazy ! People were pushing and shoving !
That girl getting pulled out looked really awkward... I wonder what the guys thought. I hope she didn't just get shoved into the back of the crowd, after practically being squished to death!
I love love love hearing him sing this song but when he sat down and I looked at his knees all I could think was "ripped jeans, skin was showin" And dont dis, he wrote that song for her.
Sorry to bother you, but I'd like to point out that you are wrong. You are wrong when you state that his opinion is flawed. This is because it is impossible for an opinion to be flawed.
@astroboirap They're name is Marianas Trench. He's singing about what he's been through. He's a great musician,but you probably love Justin Bieber. Get a life
I have a shit taste in music? Please, enlighten on what you listen to, and I'm also glad that other people don't know what Marianas Trench is. That means they won't get fan-girled by Justin Bieber, or Miley Cyrus looking mothafuckas. And I have grown up, it's you that hasn't. Why comment such a hateful thing on this video. Plus, the singer was talking about his heroin addiction, don't judge a book by it's cover. This guy had alot of shit in high school. He did heroin, bulimia. etc.
@1bookfish I know i love how he's so open about it to his fans and doesn't hide the troubles he's had in his past I cant watch him sing this song without crying now he's so sweet
choosing music over something very hard to not be addicted to like heroin is a big move but a good choice. props to josh for his work ethic. love the song!
@1bookfish I noticed that too! i was there but couldnt quite see to that extent but after watching it on here i was like woah wait! was he actually crying???
He says its hard to sing. Then how does he sing it so perfectly :') this song is my favourite
Ikr!
Benedict cumberbitch But he's right though. The song is hard, evem for him. The song has a A4 to sing.
Cause he probably dont like to sing really loud to where it strains his voice, cause the last part is kinda rough lol
@@mariaabrunhosa398 and it's about his drug addiction.. which would be hard to say too
Yeah, he does amazing with it. I imagine it would take its toll if he had to sing it every single night while on tour.
i get people singing, but the people screaming piss me off. especially threw this song or skin and bones. those two are the songs that it's like you just don't scream throughout them.
THANK YOU!!!! it feels so disrespectful listening to them do that. i feel like people should just be silent and listen to him
+sarah kahlau yep, couldn't agree more.
brittney wispinski amen. Josh has even said it in a show that the crowd he was singing to was perfect, because they would scream after the song then stop perfectly. It was like, scream for two seconds in between songs, stop, then wait till the next song was over and repeat
I don't know if it's just me, but I hate it when people scream and cheer during this song, and skin and bones, and actually now forget me not as well. Like it just seems rude to cheer during these songs about really hard times for him.
Ava St. L or maybe they are supporting the band. He’s played this song so many times. Shut the fuck up
josh killed it at 3:31
+maripdsz I replayed that part so many times. It was so good.
+angelina lastname same
Guess for everyone wondering why they picked her up out of the crowd it was cause she was having an anxiety attack you can tell by the shaking and you can see that the other trenchers beside her were trying to get the guys attention
I always though that when Josh said it was so hard to sing, he was talking about the incredible vocal range. But now I realize he's talking about having to relive that terrible time he sings Lover Dearest.
"so leave me" at 3:32 gets me every time.
I fucking cryed literally just when he started to sing
same
my heart hurt from the moment he started..... so much emotion :'(
right?! you go to a concert to listen to the musician, its always been a peeve of mine..
guys, NOBODY can appreciate this song unless they understand it. these assholes talking crap are jealous and immature, this song has SAVED people. thats the greatest gift Josh has ever given us. Trenchers
I personally think this was the best performance of Lover Dearest live
what i will never understand is why people sing along to this song. you need to keep your mouth shut and scream later, not during a song so emotional as this.
Ohh!! I wish I were there!! And one question: Why at the end a random dude just comes on stage and takes a girl and goes backstage? That was funny!
god dammit that scream at 3:33 how does he do that
No offense to people that scream but i wish everyone would shut up when he's singing this so we can all hear his beautiful voice
You can hear the raw emotion in his voice.. having gone through this so roughly and making it through alive, you can just see what kind of person he is now. He even stated how hard it was for him to sing it in the start. Josh is my idol. Having insomnia, bulimia [I have/had both too], been through heroin and possibly other drugs along the way before that, I just... wow. People hate him and I don't get how. He was able to pull through it so well, against all odds.
Joshua Ramsay, you are my idol.
fxcking BEAUTIFUL i'm BAWLING
Wow this is amazing quality for it being live and your hand is actually damn steady geez. And this song tho
Rhia Fuller no shit they are just sitting there
For all the people saying that the audience needs to quiet down, when you at a concert usually the band is so loud you could scream as loud as you could in someone's ear and they wouldn't be able to hear you. But I do agree that they should be a bit quieter for this particular song out of respect.
What camera did you use!? the quality is amazing :D
"because its very difficult to sing" OK JOSH UR MAKING ME CRY JUST DONT OMG
I always immediately start crying as soon as he starts singing.
Not only because it's an insanely powerful and emotional song, and Josh has the voice of a million angels,
But also because the song is about Josh's previous addiction. And I always think about how if I had suffered from an addiction similar to his, I would in no way have the strength like he has to write several songs about them and then record them onto an album and sing them over and over again for several performances. That takes some serious courage. I wish I had that much courage, but I don't, sadly.
What camera do u use!? Its epic! Great video
4:23 brett to the rescue
wait why was that girl carried away? was she okay?
this song has helped to save my life.
i absolutely love this song. it's so pure and real, and it beautifully highlights the exquisite tone of josh's voice. it is just...wow
I bawl my eyes out every time i hear this song and when i saw it live holy shit i held some girls hand and we sung and cried together
well, usually when he sings that part, he sings in falsetto (luckily his falsetto is pretty similar to his normal voice)
in any case, that time, he forces his voice to go higher by crushing his vocal chords and screaming.
not sure if you were actually asking or were marveling at it. either way, easier said than done, takes alot of practice to nail it.
Love this band, love this song. Holds so much feeling, Josh you are amazing 😘
wow. only word i can say
She may have been getting crushed by the mosh pit and ended up getting hurt. Or she could have been having a claustrophobia panic attack. She looked a bit shaky so I'd go with the second but I'm not entirely sure
That girl was being squished so badly that they had to pull her out of the audience....It was super crazy on the floor with pushing-- trying to touch Josh !!
I can't wait for them to go on tour again, I am totally going to got to one of there shows. I saw them at Stampede and they were amazing! As if that's a suprize though😁. It seems like no matter what expectations I have for them live, a new song, or video they all exceed it some how. I know how much this song means to not only the fans but Josh as well. It's amazing. I'm sure it is really hard to sing. I dislike the screaming but I kinda understand it. Josh plays with the vocals live and that's what everyone screams at. It takes a lot of work to pull off some of the things he does vocally, well deserving of screams. Just amazing. 😀
Damn people in the croud need to stfu. -_- but other than that, he has such an amazing voice.
Everyone, calm down, people can say what they want on here. Its called public access? I love marianas trench, they have helped me through rough times, but you don't need to go saying that every five seconds. Josh and matt and mike and ian just want to know that there helping people, you can tell your story, but don't go telling people whats wrong and whats right. because thats not right.
hate the song? sure. boring song? cool. don't know his name? awesome. but one thing that isn't cool is to comment on this video, showing how much you hate it. we come to youtube to enjoy what we love. not to read your stupid shitty comments telling us that this song is shit. we love what we want to love, and we don't need to be judged by you. and if you actually listened to the whole song and actually gave it a chance, you would see that josh actually has talent.
i also mentioned singing i was only listing tht as another reason his (astroboirap) opinion was stupid i dnt really like screaming all tht much theres something different about Josh's i cnt describe wat exactly just a different sound quality ig but thnkz for the band listings i may check them out sometime
@astroboirap They've been around since I was like born. They're fanbase is huge. Also Marianas Trench has saved tons of lives with their music. This song isn't boring. It's one of there best. Josh is the most talented guy alive. He's been doing music since he was 14. His dad owned a record label. He's written and produced songs like Call Me Maybe. Which are famous world wide
@astroboirap Um, wow, this band has been around sense what....2001, at least? That's about 11 years now. I won't say anything about his talent, because even though he clearly does have it, I guess it's a matter of opinion. But I do applaud you on spelling his name correctly. That must have taken a lot of effort.
I fucking cryed literally just when he started to sing
i personal dislike how people scream while Josh is singing this song i see that is a sign of disrespect cause josh poured a personal part of his life into a song you should respect that so shut up and scream when it's the right time to
-.-. r u okay? honestly? who do U LISTEN TOO? WHO HAS MORE TALENT THEN JOSH RAMSAY? HOW IS THIS A BORING ASS SONG? i'm just going to stop talking before i rip out ur heart. (wait u might not have one if u think this is boring....)
Omg!! Josh have holes in his pants.. Why dosent he have holes in his shirt? I would just melt even more if he sang this song, while having holes in his shirt or being shirtless... If u know what Im saying, lol ;D
I wasn't talking about this song, I was talking about the song I was referencing "ripped jeans, skin was showing" that is lyrics from Call me Maybe...the song that he Co-wrote for Carly Rae Jepsen.
@blackpolishdiamon OMG yess. I completely understand. I went to see them at the CNE and we couldn't even move our arms half the time. The crowd got soo crazy ! People were pushing and shoving !
That girl getting pulled out looked really awkward... I wonder what the guys thought. I hope she didn't just get shoved into the back of the crowd, after practically being squished to death!
I love love love hearing him sing this song but when he sat down and I looked at his knees all I could think was "ripped jeans, skin was showin"
And dont dis, he wrote that song for her.
Sorry to bother you, but I'd like to point out that you are wrong. You are wrong when you state that his opinion is flawed. This is because it is impossible for an opinion to be flawed.
@astroboirap They're name is Marianas Trench. He's singing about what he's been through. He's a great musician,but you probably love Justin Bieber. Get a life
This is amazing omg, this is why they're my favorite band ❤️
I have a shit taste in music? Please, enlighten on what you listen to, and I'm also glad that other people don't know what Marianas Trench is. That means they won't get fan-girled by Justin Bieber, or Miley Cyrus looking mothafuckas. And I have grown up, it's you that hasn't. Why comment such a hateful thing on this video. Plus, the singer was talking about his heroin addiction, don't judge a book by it's cover. This guy had alot of shit in high school. He did heroin, bulimia. etc.
From my experience, it's because she either passed out from standing for 8 hours with no water or she was being unberably crushed by the crowd.
I cried watching this, but I got extremely annoyed when girls kept screaming their heads off in the middle of a difficult emotional song.
HOLY FLIPPER NUGETS IS THERE A FREAKIN CHILD THERE? IN THE BEGINNING THERES SOUNDS OF A LITTLE CHILD I THINK HE SAID JACKALOPE OR SOMETHING
i think it's okay to sing along because it shows support rather than disrespect.. it would be rude to scream during this song though.
i cry everytime
@astroboirap uhm. marianas trench has been a well known band since like 07. thats a bit more than 10 months. get some respect.
i feel like i know where josh is coming from when he laugh's i laugh when he cry's i cry i almost cried at 4:09 to 4:23
@1bookfish I know i love how he's so open about it to his fans and doesn't hide the troubles he's had in his past I cant watch him sing this song without crying now he's so sweet
choosing music over something very hard to not be addicted to like heroin is a big move but a good choice. props to josh for his work ethic. love the song!
@1bookfish I noticed that too! i was there but couldnt quite see to that extent but after watching it on here i was like woah wait! was he actually crying???
why did in the middle of the performance a person pick someone out of the crowd and walk off somewhere??
LOVE MT!!!! and omg!!! this song should be on greys anatomy!!!!!!!!!! :D thumbs up if you agree! ;)
What the hell is happening at 4:24 this the man dragging off the fan? Can someone explain to me?
What was with the girl being taken to the side of the stage?? luv Josh n Marianas Trench
OMG this is so perfect I just wish people wouldn't scream while he's pouring his heart out.
So don't judge the lead singer, that he's a gormless idiot. You never know what could be behind the sweet smile.
i think he totally did cry in the middle of the song if you are really paying attention
so fuckin sad.. made me cry... everytime i hear it, it makes me even sadder than before
she was probably being crushed and about to pass out. That tends to happen up front...
@LyndseeyAnne I did! Lol. Glad I'm not the only one who heard that, I'm not crazy.
BUT FUCK IT! hhahahahahahah luv ya josh and did anyone else here jackalope???
Why does Brett have to run on stage and get that girl?? Does anyone know why?
@greykitty745 idk that girl isn't me. I was asking why she got pulled out.
What happened to that girl who had to get taken out of the audience? D:
Oops I mean "because its difficult to sing" aww josh
HIS VOICE
I just....*Tears* Please come to England soon, before i just...die.
Idk why but I always find it funny when the girl says jackalope
god he sings so perfectly even live. i wish i was like a real person back then and knew who they were but i was like 5
She was getting crushed by the audience, people at that show were crazy.
its been over ten year...nit for the video for the band
This was my absolute favourite performance of Lover Dearest ive ever seen live in concert. so glad i went to that show! :')
Did anyone else hear a little kid say Jackalope?.. :/
you must be a justin bieber fan... go away... =D
It sounds like Josh finally hit puberty at 3:31 xD
LMAOO what happen to the gurl at the front row ?
Gosh.. looking and sounding so damn good ❤
Ha, at 32 seconds he said Butfuck.
why was that girl pulled from the crowd lol
She got crushed to its harder to go so she went up
@musiclover1045 omfg yes thank you jesus
well. josh just tweeted this.. so. XD
what happened to the girl at 4:34?
The kid at 0:26 is my hero! JACKALOPE!
...slowly becoming a trencher
great performance.
3:31 omg.