For me, the song deals with the death of the girl, that's why she gave him her heart to not be forgotten, but Tyler didn't want her to die because he loved her. He made an analogy of jesus dying for love to humanity and did the same with his love one. A love story.
About his mention of "south" in this song. In the song THE JUDGE he mentions going south when he left his house...and later says "i should have stayed inside my house". I personally think "south" has significance for him. Or maybe it doesn't mean anything. I suspect 2 possible meanings. (1) south = hell... like heaven up and hell down...north up and south down. (2) or the popular old saying when things gone south..like when things went wrong...or pun-- when things went to hell- pun combo there lol. EDIT... after writing this I'm strongly suspecting the 2nd one...when people say things have gone south it means things have gone wrong. It's an old saying.
I was thinking about this line a little more and kinda came to the same conclusion as to it being a reference to "things going south" are things going badly.
I think the meaning is Tyler witnessing people around him going through what he was going through. He sees the “demon” which may or not be an actual demon, but what is certain is that it represents pain, depression and anxiety. Tyler recognizes this as something he’s been through and could currently be experiencing. He speaks to the demon and would rather be tortured so that he can later write the messages in his songs to help people fight the demon/bad stuff. He begins to realize God died to protect us simarlarly. God packed his heart in Tyler’s “car” so that he may go and do the same for others. They suffer for us.
Tyler has a cover for Jar of Hearts from around the same time this album was made, so you might be right about the reference. Also, in the video for that cover you can actually see the previous lineup of Twenty One Pilots.
Living life without lying or being lied to sounds perfect until you really think about it. The majority of human beings are not built to handle unadulterated truth. We lie to ourselves, for goodness sake. Thanks for another thoughtful reaction!
This is such a deep song in many ways but what I always get from it is that he’s ready to give up, end it but then remembers that the other gave him their heart, their love is with him and to give up is to let down the trust of the person that has given him something so important. Nah you can’t get through life without a lie. Lies are ‘bad’ but there are ‘white’ lies that protect. To protect Peoples feelings at times, times where it’s not quite right to give truthful information like to young children stuff like that. They are all part of life.
There’s an episode of Supernatural where an angel (kind of) made it so that no one could lie and the whole world broke down and went to hell - not good😆
self titled is an absolute masterpiece in and of itself, but just like everything tyler does, there’s a storyline thorough out the album. it always helps to listen in order, but i realize that’s not exactly how your channel is set up ( going off requests ). there’s so much raw emotion that you can get caught up in just thinking about. i agree with you. i don’t think there’s any way to go through life without lying either.
Love this song. He has such a way of writing.. can be interpretated so many ways. This is some of my interpretations...note interpretation either psychological/religious (in order).... -she's suffering depression or demonic oppression (depending how literal he was). -he has to leave her but KNOWS she's in trouble (gave her heart in the car) so he drives away troubled (thin air...barely feels smile...envies cars heading south where she is in trouble --cause going south means when things go wrong-- where he left her) -once he's gone and unable to support her/ or protect her...the demon took over/depression took over...and she killed herself. -he intuitively knew she killed herself (chills in his bones...breath not his own like the breath was her ghost) and demon told him so (literally). -he says send the demons his way and away from her so that he would die and save her (like Jesus) -don't understand the skin frame line...maybe referring to the skin just being a vessel for the soul...meaning our earthly flesh lives not meant for him to deal with earthly matters??????? Can't wait to see what other commenters say about that line. -now he understands Jesus dying for us...the love. -again the air is thin like he had felt in the beginning...foreseeing and then grief. -morning is coming. Tyler songs ALWAYS refers to these problems at night and morning being the relief and freedom from mental anguish or demonic oppression depending on how literal you want to interpret. --she had given him her heart for safekeeping foreseeing what was going to happen. --he now understands sacrificing for the love of others..like Jesus.
Wow your interpretation actually blew my mid because the meaning never clicked for me. If you're keeping with the older stuff, i'd love to see you react to taxi cab! Also if you ever do fall away, do a double feature with the studio version and the live version featuring Dr. Blum.
I always take the beginning of this song as a reference to the difficulty of his Christian walk. It's hard and he struggles with it. He sees the non-christians heading the other way and is jealous of the easier, more fun route and he wants to give in (crack the door and just fall out...). But then he's reminded of Jesus inside him (reached in the back and buckled up your heart...) And that gives him strength to continue.
You're spot on with how its cool looking back on these songs and seeing how his writing started and thoughts were starting to form - the music itself sounds way different but you can see the lyrics are still cryptic and at the same time very descriptive- kid always had talent - just needed time for it to grow
This album is amazing. My favourites are Isle of flightless birds and Air Catcher, and then Trapdoor, Fall Away, Implicit demand for proof and Pantaloon.💙💛🧡💚
Wednesday night is the BILLBOARD MUSIC AWARDS and TWENTY ONE PILOTS have some nominations! 2 categories-- ROCK ARTIST and the other category is ROCK SONG nomination BOTH CHLORINE and HYPE!! Can't wait hope they win Best Rock Artist cause they deserve it.
There's a movie with ricky gervais and jennifer gardner called THE INVENTION OF LYING. The premise is... a world where nobody lies. The word "lie" does not even exist in the vocabulary because it just doesn't exist. Well, something happens and ricky gervais discovers lying...which works very well cause everyone naturally believes him. It's an interesting movie.
Ele percebe o sofrimento dela e absorve a sua dor. Ele entende o que é ter depressão: empatia! He realizes her suffering and absorbs her pain. He knows what it is like to have depression! Empathy!
I was soooo excited that you did another TOP song!!! I think you are definitely on the right track of thinking but there again that's what Tyler wants you to do...think 😉 To live a normal life without lying.....no just because if we all were brutally honest with each other no one would like anyone else lol.
Thank you :) I would love to know what it would be like if everyone was actually honest with one another. The truth hurts but we would always know that we aren't being deceived or lied to. So there would definitely be things I'd enjoy about that haha
@@SuffiReax I totally agree! I actually have a friend who is brutally honest. When I first met her I thought she was a rude but once I got to know her I respected the fact that she was so honest.
Emilee Bailey I actually have immense respect for people who can be truly honest and not fake things or sugarcoat them just so not ruffle things. Like don’t be mean about it but I truly believe in “it’s not what you say it’s how you say it”. You can still be honest without being a jerk. So when I find someone who does that (which is rare) I have a lot of respect for their boldness to be honest.
I love this song, Taxi Cab, Pantaloon, Implicit Demand...okay forget it, the entire album! Tried to fool myself into thinking that I could actually pick my favorite TØP songs. I honestly cannot bring myself to choose, so I’m just going to request that you react to all of Self Titled. Then, if you can find a way to not get them blocked, check out songs from Regional At Best. Pretty-please and thank you! 💛😁
i know this is so random but i saw the thumbnail without reading the title and i was like ? is there an a before every emoji because all the words start with an a (in spanish car=auto, torch=antorcha, coffin=ataúd). funny coincidence
Ha! I about choked on my spit when you compared the heart in a jar to pirates of the Caribbean....hahaha. That's always the thought I have when I hear that line 🤪😉😂😂. Totally don't think it has anything to do with it but I totally go there too. So funny... What are the chances. 😁. Great reaction. Keep em' up.
"However, a closer look at the lyrics shows that these words may be said from the perspective of Jesus himself during his time of prayer and contemplation in Gethsemane, prior to his arrest and crucifixion. They also depict Tyler coming to realise why Jesus died for the sins of humanity." Source Genius *No, people always tell white lies, to keep their relationships intact.
I always thought this song could be connected to Scarlett Letter from NPI also she, the demon .. ig? cuz otherwise it would make a she, a you and the demon in that verse
You should react to the band Set It Off they are really good and if you do check them out listen to the songs horrible kids, hypnotized , and miss mysterious ( there is no specific order )
No it's impossible. God created us in his image... Yet we are still flawed in some way or another. He made us yes.. But he made us imperfect so that way we "struggle" to "find ourselves". He wants us to experience what His first born son gave to guve us this salvation from just saying (pardon my french) "Fuck it... I die and that's it." To my fellow cliquey!! Stay alive my friend!! You're only one step away from joining the banidtos! ||-\\
I think that you *could* live a whole life without telling a lie BUT I don't think you'd be very well liked because most people can't handle 100% truth all the time lol
A car- jumpsuit
A torch- nico and the niners
A death- levitate
😏
A car- Heavydirtysoul /
A torch- Trench Era/ Nico or Bandito
A death- Scaled and Icy( Clancy is dead)
For me, the song deals with the death of the girl, that's why she gave him her heart to not be forgotten, but Tyler didn't want her to die because he loved her. He made an analogy of jesus dying for love to humanity and did the same with his love one. A love story.
About his mention of "south" in this song. In the song THE JUDGE he mentions going south when he left his house...and later says "i should have stayed inside my house". I personally think "south" has significance for him. Or maybe it doesn't mean anything. I suspect 2 possible meanings. (1) south = hell... like heaven up and hell down...north up and south down. (2) or the popular old saying when things gone south..like when things went wrong...or pun-- when things went to hell- pun combo there lol.
EDIT... after writing this I'm strongly suspecting the 2nd one...when people say things have gone south it means things have gone wrong. It's an old saying.
Ah ma quindi ci sono altri italiani?
@@lilhomy6042 i don't speak italian. The name is for my lyric music channel.
I was thinking about this line a little more and kinda came to the same conclusion as to it being a reference to "things going south" are things going badly.
Morph as well has the up (above) and down (under) references should react to that if you haven’t
They actually did a cover of 'Jar of hearts'
And its amazing
Oh wow I didn't know that!
@@SuffiReax you should react to it soon. They also did a cover for cancer by my chemical romance and a cover for cant help falling in love by elvis
@@dontyoushyaway2523 Yeah, Suffi has reacted to cancer 2 months ago but he didn't reacted to can't help falling in love yet.
@@seihn oh i didnt know. Im definitely watching that then
I think the meaning is Tyler witnessing people around him going through what he was going through. He sees the “demon” which may or not be an actual demon, but what is certain is that it represents pain, depression and anxiety. Tyler recognizes this as something he’s been through and could currently be experiencing. He speaks to the demon and would rather be tortured so that he can later write the messages in his songs to help people fight the demon/bad stuff. He begins to realize God died to protect us simarlarly. God packed his heart in Tyler’s “car” so that he may go and do the same for others. They suffer for us.
Very powerful!
Tyler has a cover for Jar of Hearts from around the same time this album was made, so you might be right about the reference. Also, in the video for that cover you can actually see the previous lineup of Twenty One Pilots.
Oh for real? Interesting haha probably would make more sense than pirates of the Caribbean lol
Living life without lying or being lied to sounds perfect until you really think about it. The majority of human beings are not built to handle unadulterated truth. We lie to ourselves, for goodness sake. Thanks for another thoughtful reaction!
I totally agree, it would be very hard because the truth hurts but I would be very curious to see what it would be like. Just get a taste.
This is such a deep song in many ways but what I always get from it is that he’s ready to give up, end it but then remembers that the other gave him their heart, their love is with him and to give up is to let down the trust of the person that has given him something so important.
Nah you can’t get through life without a lie. Lies are ‘bad’ but there are ‘white’ lies that protect. To protect Peoples feelings at times, times where it’s not quite right to give truthful information like to young children stuff like that. They are all part of life.
There’s an episode of Supernatural where an angel (kind of) made it so that no one could lie and the whole world broke down and went to hell - not good😆
That is a great translation!
Yes I agree, sometimes they are needed and prevent a situation from becoming worse
Tyler mentions headlights in Fake You Out too.
self titled is an absolute masterpiece in and of itself, but just like everything tyler does, there’s a storyline thorough out the album. it always helps to listen in order, but i realize that’s not exactly how your channel is set up ( going off requests ). there’s so much raw emotion that you can get caught up in just thinking about. i agree with you. i don’t think there’s any way to go through life without lying either.
Love this song. He has such a way of writing.. can be interpretated so many ways. This is some of my interpretations...note interpretation either psychological/religious (in order)....
-she's suffering depression or demonic oppression (depending how literal he was).
-he has to leave her but KNOWS she's in trouble (gave her heart in the car) so he drives away troubled (thin air...barely feels smile...envies cars heading south where she is in trouble --cause going south means when things go wrong-- where he left her)
-once he's gone and unable to support her/ or protect her...the demon took over/depression took over...and she killed herself.
-he intuitively knew she killed herself (chills in his bones...breath not his own like the breath was her ghost) and demon told him so (literally).
-he says send the demons his way and away from her so that he would die and save her (like Jesus)
-don't understand the skin frame line...maybe referring to the skin just being a vessel for the soul...meaning our earthly flesh lives not meant for him to deal with earthly matters??????? Can't wait to see what other commenters say about that line.
-now he understands Jesus dying for us...the love.
-again the air is thin like he had felt in the beginning...foreseeing and then grief.
-morning is coming. Tyler songs ALWAYS refers to these problems at night and morning being the relief and freedom from mental anguish or demonic oppression depending on how literal you want to interpret.
--she had given him her heart for safekeeping foreseeing what was going to happen.
--he now understands sacrificing for the love of others..like Jesus.
Excellent interpretation! I think you nailed it and that we have very similar interpretations of most of the lines.
Wow your interpretation actually blew my mid because the meaning never clicked for me. If you're keeping with the older stuff, i'd love to see you react to taxi cab!
Also if you ever do fall away, do a double feature with the studio version and the live version featuring Dr. Blum.
Oh good! That makes me glad :)
Yes that one is definitely on the list!
I always take the beginning of this song as a reference to the difficulty of his Christian walk. It's hard and he struggles with it. He sees the non-christians heading the other way and is jealous of the easier, more fun route and he wants to give in (crack the door and just fall out...). But then he's reminded of Jesus inside him (reached in the back and buckled up your heart...) And that gives him strength to continue.
You're spot on with how its cool looking back on these songs and seeing how his writing started and thoughts were starting to form - the music itself sounds way different but you can see the lyrics are still cryptic and at the same time very descriptive- kid always had talent - just needed time for it to grow
One of the best takes on this song I've heard.
loved your reaction. implicit demand for proof it's another great song, you will love it!
Thank you :)
Awesome I will check it out!
This album is amazing. My favourites are Isle of flightless birds and Air Catcher, and then Trapdoor, Fall Away, Implicit demand for proof and Pantaloon.💙💛🧡💚
I thought this song was great! So thanks for the suggestions
Wednesday night is the BILLBOARD MUSIC AWARDS and TWENTY ONE PILOTS have some nominations! 2 categories-- ROCK ARTIST and the other category is ROCK SONG nomination BOTH CHLORINE and HYPE!! Can't wait hope they win Best Rock Artist cause they deserve it.
Loved the reaction Danny, go to see you back..
Thank you Kim :)
When the camera was blurry etc. I thought you did it on purpose as a Blurryface reference!! Ha ha lol.
Lol that would have been very fitting
Please react to their entire self-titled album. It's so beautiful. The lyrics are so deep as Tyler struggles with his faith.
I definitely plan to!
you moved the camera again lmao
also ty for the twenty one pilots reaction they are my fav!
I did haha I am trying to find that perfect spot that just works well for everything but also looks great
And sure thing!!
I was really looking forward to this reaction!! I hope some more self-titled songs will come next
There most certainly will be :)
There's a movie with ricky gervais and jennifer gardner called THE INVENTION OF LYING. The premise is... a world where nobody lies. The word "lie" does not even exist in the vocabulary because it just doesn't exist. Well, something happens and ricky gervais discovers lying...which works very well cause everyone naturally believes him. It's an interesting movie.
That does sounds very interesting! What a cool premise
really like your reactions, also the new background looks neat! please upload more and, keep up the good work!
Ele percebe o sofrimento dela e absorve a sua dor. Ele entende o que é ter depressão: empatia!
He realizes her suffering and absorbs her pain. He knows what it is like to have depression! Empathy!
Yes!
Made me cry.
I was soooo excited that you did another TOP song!!! I think you are definitely on the right track of thinking but there again that's what Tyler wants you to do...think 😉
To live a normal life without lying.....no just because if we all were brutally honest with each other no one would like anyone else lol.
Thank you :)
I would love to know what it would be like if everyone was actually honest with one another. The truth hurts but we would always know that we aren't being deceived or lied to. So there would definitely be things I'd enjoy about that haha
@@SuffiReax I totally agree! I actually have a friend who is brutally honest. When I first met her I thought she was a rude but once I got to know her I respected the fact that she was so honest.
Emilee Bailey I actually have immense respect for people who can be truly honest and not fake things or sugarcoat them just so not ruffle things. Like don’t be mean about it but I truly believe in “it’s not what you say it’s how you say it”. You can still be honest without being a jerk. So when I find someone who does that (which is rare) I have a lot of respect for their boldness to be honest.
what's with him and South
The Judge "I forgot about the drought of light bulbs in this house so I head out
down the route I think os heading south "
I think it is a reference to when people say "well that went south" to mean "that did not go well". That would be my guess
Hi, new subscriber here! Here are of my favorite older songs that I’d recommend: Save, Anathema, and Trapdoor :)
I love this song, Taxi Cab, Pantaloon, Implicit Demand...okay forget it, the entire album!
Tried to fool myself into thinking that I could actually pick my favorite TØP songs. I honestly cannot bring myself to choose, so I’m just going to request that you react to all of Self Titled. Then, if you can find a way to not get them blocked, check out songs from Regional At Best. Pretty-please and thank you! 💛😁
i know this is so random but i saw the thumbnail without reading the title and i was like ? is there an a before every emoji because all the words start with an a (in spanish car=auto, torch=antorcha, coffin=ataúd). funny coincidence
Pov the beginning of the video: my name's blurryface
Ha! I about choked on my spit when you compared the heart in a jar to pirates of the Caribbean....hahaha. That's always the thought I have when I hear that line 🤪😉😂😂. Totally don't think it has anything to do with it but I totally go there too. So funny... What are the chances. 😁. Great reaction. Keep em' up.
"However, a closer look at the lyrics shows that these words may be said from the perspective of Jesus himself during his time of prayer and contemplation in Gethsemane, prior to his arrest and crucifixion. They also depict Tyler coming to realise why Jesus died for the sins of humanity." Source Genius
*No, people always tell white lies, to keep their relationships intact.
You should react to taxi cab at some point :)
Definitely!
I always thought this song could be connected to Scarlett Letter from NPI
also she, the demon .. ig?
cuz otherwise it would make a she, a you and the demon in that verse
Please do “march to the sea” it’s a self titled song too!!
You can tell accidental lies, so it depends what you consider a lie to be
You should react to the band Set It Off they are really good and if you do check them out listen to the songs horrible kids, hypnotized , and miss mysterious ( there is no specific order )
Hey I think you should react to Leave the City by Twenty One Pilots and Pet Cheetah by Twenty One Pilots. Love your reactions!
No. Sometimes it's ok to lie, to not hurt people. It's called being polite. Tell me lies, tell me sweet little lies.😊
Excellent point!
You need to react to this whole album bud...it's PHENOMENAL II-//
Yes!
Oh MS believer by top
I dont think its possible. Everyone has had to have told even a small fib within their life lol
No it's impossible. God created us in his image... Yet we are still flawed in some way or another. He made us yes.. But he made us imperfect so that way we "struggle" to "find ourselves". He wants us to experience what His first born son gave to guve us this salvation from just saying (pardon my french) "Fuck it... I die and that's it." To my fellow cliquey!! Stay alive my friend!! You're only one step away from joining the banidtos! ||-\\
It not possible to live normally without lying
I agree
I think that you *could* live a whole life without telling a lie BUT I don't think you'd be very well liked because most people can't handle 100% truth all the time lol
No, we are all sinners.
It's not possible
Everything is perfect but please consider changing the thumbnail.....PLEASE
Nope.. I seriously doubt it..
Saaaame
as soon as you say you could live your whole life without lying, you lie