I'm a new EXO-L and I loved Baekhyun playing piano singing with Suho & D.O.'s live performance the same way I absolutely LOVE this version of Lay playing piano singing with Chen and D.O. too! I swear EXO are thee most multi-talented live, vocal, male K-pop group I've ever seen and heard! I may be late to the party but I'm so glad I finally found them! 6 month baby EXO-L loving and supporting from Canada!
The way Lay sings while playing piano and also mouths other members' parts....now that's a real musician right there. He memorized everyone's parts while playing the piano. Also during his solo parts, he sings with a lot of stamina without sounding like his voice would crack. He really does a good job of trying to sing like the track. Lay also puts that pedal to good use and plays stronger in the bridge and outro to create more energy and a stronger texture. Overall, I REALLY love this version of My Answer.
Ikr! What I prefer about this version is that there is a greater vocal range compared to the Korean version. And of course, the fact that Lay gets to showcase his awesome vocals and actually has a lot of lines in this song makes this version even better *_*
LAY really is genius . He has never been teached how to play guitar or piano. All he learn by himself. He cant read music sheet but he play song by ear.
👏🏾 hats off to them, Lay's vocals are just as top tier and don't get me started on the playing of the piano, and Kyungsoo and Jongdae bringing so much emotion to the song. Magnificent 🤍 I adore both versions
my 3 favorite voices in EXO will always be Chen, D.O. and Lay's; after them, Luhan, Tao, Kai and Chanyeol; then, Baekhyun and Kris; and lastly Suho, Sehun and Xiumin... but I love all 12 original members, they're all pure talent and beauty :D ALSO I'M IN LOVE WITH THIS PERFORMANCE
This is beautiful. I can’t believe I’m just seeing the live version for this song. Yixing’s voice is always so mesmerizing and soft, hearing him sing makes me so happy. Jongdae’s voice is amazing, he always does incredibly well im in love with his voice. Kyungsoo, his voice is perfect, full of emotion, he makes me feel things i love him so much.
I prefer this version than korean one,what a performance ,their vocals blend well,overflowing with emotions .Chen ,D.O,Lay every one is so good .All of them gave me goosebumps .As always my favorite part is Chen's .
watching this at 2020.. missing the ot9. chen didn't show up for months after the news, kyungsoo is on the military and lay.... yeah. *i miss everyone*
This version is underated. Why i just come across this version?! 😭😭 its been years why i never notice this 😭😭 their voices really suirs together convey softer melody than korean version. Korean version could make me cry but this version is like weep in silence too sleep 😭😭😭
I came here to see this performance after watching Baekhyun, D.O. & Suho's korean version just now. And both performances are equally OUTSTANDING!!! Love em so much!
I'm sad, Kungsoo is in the military now, a lot of antis are trying to get Chen to leave the group because he is married with a beautiful daughter, and after 4 years Lay still hasn't come back. This is my favorite Chinese song (along w/ Promise). I love their emotions. Chen and Kungsoo's vocals were amazing as I expected. But my king Lay... his voice was amazing. Such a pity SM never gave him a lot of lines in their songs (even Chinese versions). But he is thriving now. I hope they are all doing well. *All of them are my biases, I couldn't have been more proud of this arrangement.
Thing about D.O. is that he, most of the time, has the near accurate pronounciation in diff languages(English, Chinese, Filipino, Spanish) and his tone fits the song.
![150531 EXO'luXion in shanghai Hurt (LAY focus) [4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AzSFkZqR75Q/mqdefault.jpg)
![Gunna - one of wun [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/w_JtBYqMgk8/mqdefault.jpg)
Lay sings very good SM should give him more line
+Min sun I've literally been saying this for years!!!!!!!!!!!
Same!
Min sun Agree with u.
Yeah i agree with u
he's at least until now the only exo member that gets the most lines (read : album) xD
Love this version. Love to hear Lay sing!!!!! Baby boy is soooo talented.
Omg I love the show Daria sooooooo much
1:41 lay perfection
To whoever gave Lay the Ad-lib lines: Bless you!!!!
Holy fuck Yixing's a musical genius he can't even read notes & I'm absolutely melting over here >.
i think d.o,chen and lay should make a sub-unit :P
YES this!!
there have been theories by fans that they might have a sehun-do-lay subunit or a chanyeol-suho-kai one we never know haha
(based on the sfy poster)
Kim Nguyen Agree baby
I watch this over and over again especially at the end. Yixing"s piano play always makes me awe and full of emotion
Am I the only one that almost died when Lay was singing at 1:22 - 1:33 and was playing piano.😘😘🤓😊
Trust me. You're not the only one. I'm making funeral arrangements right now
JenniferYTR You are not alone
This song is so pretty. It's almost bittersweet :) And Yixing's outro in the end *sighs*
I'm a new EXO-L and I loved Baekhyun playing piano singing with Suho & D.O.'s live performance the same way I absolutely LOVE this version of Lay playing piano singing with Chen and D.O. too! I swear EXO are thee most multi-talented live, vocal, male K-pop group I've ever seen and heard! I may be late to the party but I'm so glad I finally found them! 6 month baby EXO-L loving and supporting from Canada!
Doesn't matter how late you are, welcome to Exo planet 🤍
It makes me cry when lay does the piano part near the end omg what is wrong w me. I'm an emotional mess 😭
Me too it makes me cry...
Chen's voice is so heavenly ;^;. So beautiful, filled with emotions. Chen, fighting!!
D.O smooth voice
my baby is so talented. love you lay. dont give up. Fighting!☺️
I LOVE LAY
I like this version more than the korean version, their voice blends so well together
And the wider vocal range in addition to that is awesome too *_*
i just came across this now and boy i missed a lot. this is gold. lay is gold plus kyungie and chennie too.
i think i have seen my ultimate bias :((( zhang yixing please always be my sunshine :((((
The way Lay sings while playing piano and also mouths other members' parts....now that's a real musician right there. He memorized everyone's parts while playing the piano. Also during his solo parts, he sings with a lot of stamina without sounding like his voice would crack. He really does a good job of trying to sing like the track. Lay also puts that pedal to good use and plays stronger in the bridge and outro to create more energy and a stronger texture. Overall, I REALLY love this version of My Answer.
Their voices are all so beautiful! Honestly this sounds better than the original studio version
First time hearing D.O. - Chen - Lay version. So beautiful, I wanna cry. Who's with me, let's cry together :(
Laaaaayyyyy!!!!!
i prefer this version over the korean version. i love all their voices together
Ikr! What I prefer about this version is that there is a greater vocal range compared to the Korean version. And of course, the fact that Lay gets to showcase his awesome vocals and actually has a lot of lines in this song makes this version even better *_*
***** the chinese version hits a higher pitch
This is better than the original, their voices go together so well! SM give Lay more lines his voice is beautiful!
Chen sings this song effortlessly. His range is really insane.
surprised to know lay can play piano....he is really very talented....
LAY really is genius . He has never been teached how to play guitar or piano. All he learn by himself. He cant read music sheet but he play song by ear.
D.O.最後好認真的看藝興彈琴
Lay sounds soooooo good!!!! I'm stunned! It's hard to hear how well he sings when he doesn't get many opportunities in EXO to sing like this
Am I the only one who finds Lay driving this piano around the stage to pick up da boys hilarious!!
👏🏾 hats off to them, Lay's vocals are just as top tier and don't get me started on the playing of the piano, and Kyungsoo and Jongdae bringing so much emotion to the song. Magnificent 🤍
I adore both versions
sLAY 😍😍😍
LAAAAAAAAAAAAAY !!
my 3 favorite voices in EXO will always be Chen, D.O. and Lay's; after them, Luhan, Tao, Kai and Chanyeol; then, Baekhyun and Kris; and lastly Suho, Sehun and Xiumin... but I love all 12 original members, they're all pure talent and beauty :D ALSO I'M IN LOVE WITH THIS PERFORMANCE
I miss Lay and I watched this right now. I love this version a lot. I hope there is DVD ver. of their concert in China also. 😭😭😭
Absolutely beautiful! Very talented young men.
2020 and still missing LAY to not gonna comeback with EXO. man he's good at dancing, playing the piano, and harmonizing!! 🖤
King of China👑♥I Love Lay so much ❤
Lay❤
I liked this too, very much, with Lay, Chen and D O, this version is very nice sang in Chinese!
This is beautiful. I can’t believe I’m just seeing the live version for this song. Yixing’s voice is always so mesmerizing and soft, hearing him sing makes me so happy. Jongdae’s voice is amazing, he always does incredibly well im in love with his voice. Kyungsoo, his voice is perfect, full of emotion, he makes me feel things i love him so much.
I prefer this version than korean one,what a performance ,their vocals blend well,overflowing with emotions .Chen ,D.O,Lay every one is so good .All of them gave me goosebumps .As always my favorite part is Chen's .
thanks for the fancam huhu miss lay so much
LAAAYYYY OH MY GOODNESSSSS 😍😍😍
藝興太棒拉 ♥♥♥ 嘟嘟和倩倩也好棒～～～
here in 2020 and i'm still crying over this song
My top 3 biases in1 frame. So Blessed.
watching this at 2020.. missing the ot9. chen didn't show up for months after the news, kyungsoo is on the military and lay.... yeah. *i miss everyone*
Yixing’s parts 😍
Miss you lay ❤❤❤❤
Lay❤️❤️❤️❤️
i really love this version
Just wow! I like both korean and chinese versions. Specially when Lay and Baek plays the piano :)
Lay is everything!! 😭💕💕
It’s the best version
This version is underated. Why i just come across this version?! 😭😭 its been years why i never notice this 😭😭 their voices really suirs together convey softer melody than korean version. Korean version could make me cry but this version is like weep in silence too sleep 😭😭😭
Jongdae you beautiful angel why so handsome
Love this version tooo!!!!! Lay voice just amazing
its been 2 years but this song always make me crying :(
THIS REALLY SUITS YIXING'S VOICE!! HOLY FUCKING COW!!
balad songs really suit chinese more and pop song with upbeat fit the korean ver more
I KNEW YIXING SANG THE LAST LINE AND NOT JONGDAE I THOUGHT I WAS GOING INSANE
I LOVE THIS SONG SO DAMN MUCH
this is beautiful and everything is perfect, I'm crying now~! thank u so much!!
yes...my request is already heard yehet!!!! I love this favorite
I came here to see this performance after watching Baekhyun, D.O. & Suho's korean version just now. And both performances are equally OUTSTANDING!!! Love em so much!
鹿晗走了以后，lay又是主舞，又是主唱。怪不得SM公司给lay那么多发挥空间就为了留住他。。。
一开始他的定位就是主舞，就是给的镜头太少了。现在也不是主唱，只不过在中国主场，所以多给他一点line. 以前真的是line少的令人发指，不知道一直在压他还是不重视他，明明很有实力。
I love this song in any language
PLSS YIXINGGG😞💘💘
애들 목소리도좋고♡♡♡이씽이 피아노소리도좋고♡♡♡♡♡피아노 치는 모습도좋고♡♡♡
best song ever!!!
neta amo con todo mi corazón a kyungsoo 😭❤️
Dyo❤❤
I'm in love!!! I mean deeply, more than ever
So beautiful
i love baekhyun
I love this version😍
muchas gracias x compartir tu video me encanta esta canción en voz de ellos tres saludos desde mexico
Chen looks really sad.
韻律孑然的瀟灑
Las dos versiones me encantan por qué todos son increíbles y los dos tocan el piano genial 👍👏 EXO 👑
3:23 The look on D.Os face is me when my mom says no more K-Pop for you lol
My heart 😭😭😭😭😭💜
I'm sad, Kungsoo is in the military now, a lot of antis are trying to get Chen to leave the group because he is married with a beautiful daughter, and after 4 years Lay still hasn't come back. This is my favorite Chinese song (along w/ Promise). I love their emotions. Chen and Kungsoo's vocals were amazing as I expected. But my king Lay... his voice was amazing. Such a pity SM never gave him a lot of lines in their songs (even Chinese versions). But he is thriving now. I hope they are all doing well.
*All of them are my biases, I couldn't have been more proud of this arrangement.
I died ♥
Jongdae so handsome
💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
A carinha do D.O olhando o Lay tocar o piano 😍😍
🌟💖💖
i love d.o and his singing but i feel like xiumin should of gotten his parts.
D.O.'s chinese pronounciation may be a big reason
agreed. D.O's chinese pronunciation is actually one of the most accurate for a Korean member.
Thing about D.O. is that he, most of the time, has the near accurate pronounciation in diff languages(English, Chinese, Filipino, Spanish) and his tone fits the song.
Me imagining Chennie used this to propose to his wife or sing at his wedding😍😍😍😍
(ToT)/~~~ EXO-M
Jongdae vocals
2:35 ❤
vuelve pronto chinito hermoso. te extrañamos. !!!!
(cảm nhận riêng) bản Trung này nghe hay hơn bản Hàn và Lay đàn piano hay hơn
I think I am not the only one but Chinese Version is better than the Korean Version.
Their voices blend so well. I love this
很抒情的歌，可是鋼琴移動時，好好笑呀!
每次看到b站上有弹幕说倒琴入库我就无法直视这个视频了，明明非常有感觉！
有一個鏡頭叫做剛琴相遇韻律
Is it the only one that they sing it live?
no, they sing live frequently.
autumnleepea only when the concert is in china
Napakagwapo ni d.o shuta