Religion for Atheists by Alain De Botton

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 112

  • @TalhaM-j3y
    @TalhaM-j3y Месяц назад +9

    Excellent video as always!
    However, in the end it all comes to the question "Do we really need to believe something on insufficient evidence in order to lead fulfilled lives?" Botton has got it right that human beings have an innate need for community however I think (like Sam Harris) that this need can be fulfilled through secular means although it is difficult.

  • @aaochalen9439
    @aaochalen9439 Месяц назад

    بہت عمدہ طریقے سے آپ نے رویو پیش کیا ہے ۔ میری اس کتاب کو پڑھنے کی خواہش بڑھ گئی ہے ۔ اس سلسلے کو ضرور جاری رکھیں۔ شکریہ۔ آداب

  • @genuinebombayite1966
    @genuinebombayite1966 Месяц назад +2

    Please continue to post such reviews - I wanted to write this in Urdu but Kaash main aapke jaisi Urdu bol saktaa! 🙏 You sound absolutely wonderful! Partition ki vajah se hum Indiawalon ne ek haseen zubaan kho dee 😢

  • @pappu33
    @pappu33 Месяц назад +4

    How can a healthy person benefit from Smoking.

  • @zubairsiddiqui896
    @zubairsiddiqui896 Месяц назад

    Keep it up ma'am. A very candid yet insightful analysis. And yes you're definitrly right: reading Bottom is as devouring poetry; one may not agree with his argument but would agree with how he has substantiated his case.

  • @justsofarah1
    @justsofarah1 Месяц назад

    omg how unique are your videos. probably the only person/vlog that helps me make sense in this particular way. this is the kind of things I keep thinking all the time but no one to discuss these with.. thank you!

  • @zainbuttar1
    @zainbuttar1 Месяц назад +3

    Yes please, will wait for mazeed book reviews.

  • @tariqamin7684
    @tariqamin7684 Месяц назад

    Such a brilliant review! You captured the essence of the book so well, making it both insightful and engaging. Amazing job! 👍👍

  • @little_laughs_family
    @little_laughs_family Месяц назад

    Awesome video, and I would say, that this channel is very under-rated.

  • @hichgooniyani
    @hichgooniyani Месяц назад +1

    بہت خوب صباحت جی! کافی اہم موضوع چن لیا آپ نے۔
    نئے ریویوز کا انتظار رہےگا۔

  • @naumanmustafa7728
    @naumanmustafa7728 Месяц назад

    Great book review, well done
    It's such a good idea to have a authentic crisp analytical talk on such topics of other authors also, thanks

  • @sohailgillani8363
    @sohailgillani8363 Месяц назад

    Awesome and edifying book summary. Thanks for making the effort. Please continue to do such book summaries.

  • @mubashiraliunar
    @mubashiraliunar Месяц назад

    Amazing review, Mam.
    Looking forward to listening more such reviews!

  • @naumankhawaja
    @naumankhawaja Месяц назад

    Well done again Sabahat! Will definitely try to read the book. Keep the book review series going please.

  • @syedwasiqaliadv387
    @syedwasiqaliadv387 Месяц назад

    بہت خوبصورت انداز ہے آپکا explain کرنے کا

  • @wamiqhamid1388
    @wamiqhamid1388 Месяц назад

    This is really wonderful. Please keep it up

  • @muhammadowais3502
    @muhammadowais3502 Месяц назад

    Very good analysis

  • @swifterr7
    @swifterr7 Месяц назад +1

    Great video. would love to see more like these

  • @arshaddurrani3885
    @arshaddurrani3885 Месяц назад

    I agree that religion has a value, in that, an all-powerful entity does exist which keeps the human grounded,humble and more humane.

  • @Emaankashaf-rs5fl
    @Emaankashaf-rs5fl 6 дней назад

    Religion understands human psychology well because religion is from the creator of human. Only creator knows very well about his creature psychology. Only the creator knows best about the thing that has been created - what its needs are, how it will function properly, and what it requires therefore it is great evidence that we are created by someone who underatand us completely

  • @gugukt9478
    @gugukt9478 Месяц назад

    Your posts always very nice , but very rare come. Thank you Ji .

    • @gargi96
      @gargi96 Месяц назад

      Develop patience for quality bhai. Though she can be prolific. Or is it the case ki yeh dil maange more! 😂

  • @PakistaniKitaabghar
    @PakistaniKitaabghar Месяц назад

    کتابوں کا اچھا تجزیہ پیش کیا ۔اس سلسلے کو جاری رکھیے بہت شکریہ

  • @explorer8824
    @explorer8824 Месяц назад

    Aapke videos ka intezaar rahta hai, kindly videos frequently banaya kare. ❣️

  • @ahmadjamalmughal47
    @ahmadjamalmughal47 Месяц назад +1

    I'm having argument with someone and here for quick revision. 😂

  • @bhalugoshe
    @bhalugoshe Месяц назад

    Excellent vlog. Thanks for the review.

  • @TheIshfaque
    @TheIshfaque Месяц назад +2

    Brilliant review. Please do more. Loved the دو ہزار بارہ میں چودہ سو کی لی تھی
    part😂 لڑکیوں کو قیمت نہیں بھولتی بھلے بارہ سال گزر جائیں

  • @Aleem_K_Lodhi
    @Aleem_K_Lodhi Месяц назад

    Amazing video, Sabahat. You always teach me something new. Adding the vocab in Urdu and English is a nice touch.
    Please work on your source of light, your videos have low light.
    Thank you for making such unique videos.

  • @AimanKhan-zd5pf
    @AimanKhan-zd5pf Месяц назад

    Excellent review. Please review books on Islamic Feminism too.

  • @alphabetagamma12
    @alphabetagamma12 Месяц назад

    I really enjoyed this video, well done! 👍🏾

  • @shahid3520
    @shahid3520 Месяц назад

    Facing imminent death or poor health, atheists become believers ! Founder of Game Theory John von Neumann, when dying of cancer in the hospital, sought the ministrations of a Catholic priest.

  • @bilalbajwa
    @bilalbajwa Месяц назад +1

    Sabahat it we had 50 more like you in our society our trajectory would have been different

  • @ahmadjamalmughal47
    @ahmadjamalmughal47 Месяц назад +5

    14:00 پسند؟ میں کہنا واں کمال کر دتا اے یار۔ میں بھی خود سیکولر لبرل ہی تصور کرتا ہوں۔ اور اپنے کچھ ذاتی تجربات کے باعث مذہب سے بیزار ہی ہوں۔ یہاں تک کہ اگر میں کل کو دیکھتا ہوں کہ کوئی میرے چھوٹے بچے کو مذہب کی تلقین کر رہا ہے تو میں سخت کاروائی کروں گا اس کے خلاف۔ مذہب کا میری بہنوں اور میری امی کی زندگی اجیرن کرنے میں بڑا کلیدی کردار ہے، میں اس کو برداشت نہیں کرتا۔ لیکن عمر کے ساتھ ساتھ غم و غصہ تھوڑا کم ہو رہا ہے، اور میں مذہب کے رجحان کو ذرا گہرائی میں پڑھنا چاہ رہا ہوں۔ معذرت کے ساتھ جورڈن پیٹرسن کو مینشن کرنا چاہوں گا، اب مجھے لگتا ہے کہ ان کا مذہب کے بارے میں پوائنٹ آف ویو اتنا احمقانہ نہیں جتنا دیکھنے میں لگتا ہے۔ جس اَیلَکس آکانر کی ایک ویڈیو مختصراً آپ نے سکرین پر دکھائی، ان کا بھی مذہب کے بارے خیالات کافی متوازی ہیں۔ بہت شکریہ ویڈیو بنانے کے لیے، جیوندے رو۔

  • @justsofarah1
    @justsofarah1 Месяц назад

    interestingly, after becoming an atheist, I felt a lot more humble. for once, i am able to look at mortality in the eye because I am not scared of hell fire. i feel personally responsible for destroying nature, because i don't feel k dunya faani hai/test ki jagah hai/end of times ki sign from God etc. I can wear second hand clothes because 'halal paisay ko enjoy karna jaaiz hai' wali philosophy laikar nahi chal rahi, i am a better wife because i am not obsessed with husband duties in Islam and 'his money is my money' wali soch. I feel like I can be an adult ready to see myself as a morally grey and forever work in progress, unlike the absolutism that Islam offered...

  • @AbdulfaiZan4313
    @AbdulfaiZan4313 Месяц назад +2

    what is your perspective on religion...Asking as a friend and a beloved fan🥰

  • @sharjeeljawaid
    @sharjeeljawaid Месяц назад +1

    Great talk
    Jazakallah

  • @muhammadirfanmajed8954
    @muhammadirfanmajed8954 Месяц назад

    Excellent

  • @umer.on.youtube
    @umer.on.youtube Месяц назад +1

    CORRECTION TO A COMMON MISTAKE PAKISTANI AND OTHER RELIGIOUS PEOPLE MAKE:
    Not believing in a particular religion does NOT necessarily mean that person doesn't believe in a God as well. Please look into the definitions of Theism/Deism and Agnosticism. There's a difference b/w Atheist and Agnostic (similar to Deist and Theist).
    Urdu Explanation for local people: Kisi specific mazhab mayn belief na rakhne ka mtlab yeh nahi ke woh aadmi/aurat kisi Khuda mayn bhi emaan nahi rakhta. Mazhab aur Khuda mayn belief 2 alag concepts hein. Thanks.

    • @feminustani
      @feminustani  Месяц назад +1

      Yes. Botton is talking about organised religion.

  • @markeugenelee2083
    @markeugenelee2083 Месяц назад +1

    3 kind of ppl.imda world
    1. Who believe a creator created universe
    2 believe universe by accident came into being
    3 don't know
    The eord religion is perceived as some kind of philosophy or science thatan has made
    The correct word is believe
    Do you believe in the realty tht God exists
    Or not

  • @Rksahni39
    @Rksahni39 Месяц назад +1

    Aaj ki duniya me har koi Atheist hai ,kyuki kisi ko khuda se bhagwan se Darr nahi lagta logo ko bas mauka milne ki baat h jaise hi mauka Mila kuchh fayde wala to Maulana aur pandit bhi atheist ban jayenge ye sachai h aaj ke jamane ki

  • @priynksingh547
    @priynksingh547 Месяц назад

    More power to you, you are amazing 👏🏻🎉

  • @zameerchaudhry2476
    @zameerchaudhry2476 Месяц назад +1

    Excellent 👍❤!!

  • @khalilchishtee2036
    @khalilchishtee2036 Месяц назад

    بہترین، ہمیشہ کی طرح۔

  • @Shafaullah_Songs
    @Shafaullah_Songs Месяц назад

    Yes

  • @Rksahni39
    @Rksahni39 Месяц назад

    Apke videos mujhe bahut achhe lagte hai apke bolne ka tarika aur knowledge bahut achhi hai love you mam from india🇮🇳 isse pahle Duare channel par dekhta tha apka show

  • @muhammadusman-vu2uo
    @muhammadusman-vu2uo Месяц назад

    Excellent ❤

  • @aadi1862
    @aadi1862 Месяц назад

    You are saying even after knowing the reality we should follow some religion culturally. It might be good.

  • @ahmadjamalmughal47
    @ahmadjamalmughal47 Месяц назад +2

    1:25 ڈین ڈینٹ صاحب کی تحقیق عین اسی بارے میں ہے۔ جو کہ ان کی کتاب بریکنگ دا سپیل کا مرکزی خیال ہے۔ کہ مذہب کیوںکر لوٹتا ہے بار بار۔ ماضی سے لے کر اب تک، یہاں تک کہ لیفٹ وِنگ لبرلزم بھی ایک مذہب ہی کی شکل اختیار کر چکی ہے

  • @ImranNafees-xo5ru
    @ImranNafees-xo5ru Месяц назад +1

    the author is a hyper-individualistic self-help guru, guised as a sage. Thoray se thinking, progressive-leaning burgeron ka Jordan Peterson hy.
    His take is only the other side of the coin of neo-atheism - both sides discuss religion in a context removed from class, geography and age. An exclusively Idealism-based approach as opposed to materialist analysis leads to a simplistically homogenous treatment of complex questions such as how religion expresses itself, what function it serves for what class, etc.
    Even looking at Pakistan, it is so obvious how faith means drastically different things for different classes. From a Marxist-leaning perspective religion is actually a “cope”. Thinkers like de Botton have us try to find the “utility” in something that is clearly a super-structure to the base-structure of economic disenfranchisement.
    Pondering over the utility of religion to be able to counter it is fine, but to engage in open-ended curiosity over this is just privileged self-pleasuring.
    At least the neo-atheists have one thing figured out: all religions are not created and practiced equal. The purpose they serve have some overlap but are fundamentally distinct in other ways - Judaism’s eschatology, for example, explains Zionism in ways another Abrahamic religion could not have.

    • @ImranNafees-xo5ru
      @ImranNafees-xo5ru Месяц назад

      Anyway, I got carried away-this was a wonderful video. Staying true to your brand, you're discussing bareek points no one else on desi youtube does. ✊🏽👏🏾

    • @feminustani
      @feminustani  Месяц назад

      Yes. Botton definitely sticks to a very genteel interpretation of things. But since I find Marxists rather literal and dour, I am perfectly happy indulging aesthetes and their world view. It takes all sorts to make the world. ‘Marxist literature’ has always failed precisely because it refuses to take into consideration the complexity of the world, and as a consequence, Art.

    • @ImranNafees-xo5ru
      @ImranNafees-xo5ru Месяц назад

      @@feminustani Just because Marxists refuse to keep pur-sukoon self-indulgence afloat in intellectual circles doesn’t mean they are dismissing complexity-it’s quite the opposite. They are taking into account the complexity of culture and art. They add another layer on top of aesthetics, removing nothing. By giving primacy to the socio-economic context of art, they are not only activism-oriented but are also offering a deeper, more objective understanding of the human condition. The Frankfurt School in particular tries to address this. You cannot criticize Marxism based on its uninspired, unimaginative representation in Pakistan (they often sound more moralizing than technical which can put people off). There’s beautiful complexity to be experienced art - holistically. In the individual sense, in the collective sense. Where you go from there is activism - or rejection of it - but Marxism takes nothing away from art, only contextualizes it.

    • @feminustani
      @feminustani  Месяц назад

      Aap ki Botton ke upar critique se tau mayn sehmat hoon lekin ‘Marxist Art’, jo explicitly Marxist ho hamesha nichlay darjay ka rehta hai. Baharhaal iss par behes ho sakti hai.
      Thanks for the deep engagement.

    • @rust719
      @rust719 Месяц назад

      Aray bhai kehna kya chahtey ho😅

  • @dundundun7215
    @dundundun7215 Месяц назад +1

    Mere khayal se mazahib ko historically tor pr dekhna, un ke urooj o zawaal ko smghna aur un ki sari achai buraion ko achi trha smghne se hi hum mazahib se age brh ske ge. New atheist trha ke ideas zabani tuo sahi lgte hein pr un ke logo pr munfi asrat hi zada hote aur isi lie wo rw ke sath ja milte hein. Atheism or atheist hone me new atheism ki koi gunjaish nahi. Kisi ke apne deeply personal spiritual beliefs pr hamla krna aur un ko kmtr dikhane ki koshish krne ka koi faida nahi he ulta nuqsan he

  • @diemanner7164
    @diemanner7164 Месяц назад

    Nietzsche's philosophy is a much better alternative to religion. And it's much more empathetic contrary to the popular ill informed belief regarding his philosophy.

  • @sewaligoswami781
    @sewaligoswami781 Месяц назад

    Brilliant content 🎉 you're awesome 👍

  • @rkhan722
    @rkhan722 Месяц назад

    You counted so many good things religion brings but you didn’t count the bad things ! You should look at the most religious counties ie Pakistan, Afghanistan, Somalia, Sudan, KSA, India etc and compare them with the most secular countries like China, Japan, Sweden, UK, Norway etc.

  • @imzrox
    @imzrox Месяц назад

    Behtreen as always! And plesse bring more book reviews for us. I know it is no easy task to put together such mindful and articulate content. A huge fan👏🏻👏🏻

  • @escapistreader3860
    @escapistreader3860 Месяц назад

    Interesting video. Botton is fantastic. Got to read this book of his. Currently reading his The School of Life.

    • @zubairsiddiqui896
      @zubairsiddiqui896 Месяц назад

      his writing style is sooo captivating. I read his book om and off while regularly read articles on his website.

  • @dharmvani
    @dharmvani Месяц назад

    Ek hota hai majhab ko manana
    Aur ek hota hai Ishwer ko manana
    Ishwer ke aage ham khud ko jhukate hai tab hame ye ahsas ho ki ham jo bhi kaam karte hai uske liye hame Shakti kaha se milti hai
    Matlab hamara apne aaap me koi existence nahi hai
    Majahab ko manna pahla step hai ishwer ko janane ka jisme

  • @shahid3520
    @shahid3520 Месяц назад

    Atheism is also a belief, a different kind of religion. there are even Churches of Atheism. People may or may not believe in God but they all worship wealth and power, money and guns i.e.

  • @azadprinda3186
    @azadprinda3186 Месяц назад +2

    Mazhab kay nuqsaanat kahein ziada hain faidon sa. Baqi har nazriya ka kuch faiday bhe hotay he hain

    • @Cine95
      @Cine95 Месяц назад

      najiaz bache mazhad [arha hota tou na bolta

    • @osamajuttg
      @osamajuttg Месяц назад

      apna kam kar mazhab par tanqeed ka tujhy koi haq nahen. Han tujhy yeh haq hay k tou kaya follow karna chahta hay apni marze say

  • @awabrana618
    @awabrana618 Месяц назад

    I want to talk

  • @zealousepileptic2690
    @zealousepileptic2690 Месяц назад

    3:15 religious dunya mei bhi yehi poocha jata hai ke "aap karte kya hain?" aur bilkul secular dunya ki tarah ussi basis par treat kiya jaata hai. do you seriously think religion cures societies of class divide?

  • @anarkali_217
    @anarkali_217 Месяц назад

    Love it more of this please. Also may be on marxism i am curious on your take

  • @bharatchauhan9268
    @bharatchauhan9268 Месяц назад +6

    Relegion man made hai isme kuch achai hoti hai or kuch burai

    • @Cine95
      @Cine95 Месяц назад +1

      ab tera religion hoga man made

    • @diemanner7164
      @diemanner7164 Месяц назад

      ​@@Cine95 han, saaray mazhab ghalat hain aur bas aap ka hee sacha hai. Saabit kr lain ge sacha issay?

  • @WorldwithoutReligion-j1l
    @WorldwithoutReligion-j1l Месяц назад +2

    Writer intellectual level is totally nonsense , 😂 Every line can be debunk

  • @mastan419
    @mastan419 Месяц назад

  • @GamerBahiya21
    @GamerBahiya21 Месяц назад

    Next time record k baad volume increase kr dena video k.

  • @SachinDolittle
    @SachinDolittle Месяц назад

    ❤❤

  • @ahmadjamalmughal47
    @ahmadjamalmughal47 Месяц назад +1

    امید ہے کہ اس ویڈیو کے بعد راجہ قیصر آپ کی جان چھوڑ دیں گے۔

  • @ImranNafees-xo5ru
    @ImranNafees-xo5ru Месяц назад +1

    تواڈی videos دا انتظار رہندا اے ۔ بوہتا نہ سوچیا کرو بس بنا کے سُٹ دیا کرو ایتھے۔

  • @ahmadjamalmughal47
    @ahmadjamalmughal47 Месяц назад

    3:26 دل دی گل کر دتی جے، یہی وجہ ہے میں نے سب سے ملنا چھوڑ دیا ہے، عجیب جانور لوگ ہیں

  • @umroyaar
    @umroyaar Месяц назад +1

    Nai mazhab k log hi khud ko ashraf ul makhlooqat ( superior creature ) smjhte hen jb k Bill Gates jese athiests poliovaccine k through logon ki madad krte hen

  • @MayaramChoudhary-qr4fi
    @MayaramChoudhary-qr4fi Месяц назад

    ex musmil sahil se mil lo bhai

  • @Cine95
    @Cine95 Месяц назад

    Liberandus ki new type 😂

  • @manzarab
    @manzarab Месяц назад

    Sorry Madam aap ki kisi bhi baat main koi khas wazan nahin hay ye sub batain aik illusion ko zinda rakhnay kay liay buhut achee husakti hain magar haqeeqat say door hain.

  • @OnThePakistan
    @OnThePakistan Месяц назад

    what a bad video editor. You need to find a professional one. Voice is too bad.

  • @raza.h
    @raza.h Месяц назад

    Botton is just another western writer with absolutely zero knowledge or regard for islamic, eastern and indian traditions. Whats worse is that these people are just riding the coat tails of internet sensations like jordan peterson and have nothing original to contribute.

  • @Indus720
    @Indus720 Месяц назад +2

    Murtad ke liye Islam me kya saza he ? Liberal Amreeki Yahoodi Ghulami me kyun lage he ?

  • @rohitpawa1871
    @rohitpawa1871 Месяц назад +2

    I would consider you a far left woke but your ideas turning right

    • @feminustani
      @feminustani  Месяц назад +1

      Love for religion is an extremely woke trait, btw

  • @Sami-pr7yp
    @Sami-pr7yp Месяц назад

    Islam is the True Religion.For eternal life prosperity must embrace Islam.
    No GOD but Only 1 Allah and Muhammad (peace be upon him)is the Last prophet (Messanger) of Allah (God).
    The Holy Quran is the Last and Greatest Book of God almighty.
    Thanks.

  • @rust719
    @rust719 Месяц назад

    Get out of mind, I just googled the advantages of following an Abrahamic religion 😮