This was a magnificent production in every way. Have heard Placido Domingo over a long lifetime, and his acting, timing, voice, musicianship increase. Hear the crowd! Great partner in conductor James Conlon, sense of timing, orchestra - wonderful!
It just goes to show that opera crowds lack any taste. If it's flashy and well sung they don't give two shits about what the composer wanted. And Verdi didn't want a tenor who thinks he is a baritone in this. Here is Leo Nucci singing this just one year younger than Domingo and also past his prime, but at least he was a baritone all his life: ruclips.net/video/4Q8xeAuzV5k/видео.htmlh22m41s
I heard him singing this aria in LA opera. It took me into ecstasy! Later I compared with other famous baritons and realized that his singing could be rated as one of top performances. It is no surprise considering that he started his career as a baritone and converted to tenor later. Splendid singing by Semenchuk for the role of Lady Macbeth made it a unforgetable night.
Nessuno infatti! Non ha una sola nota del baritono e gonfiando i centri in maniera così artificiosa lo rendono monocorde e totalmente inespressivo.... Mi chiedo solo perché? ! I soldi non sono una motivazione sufficientemente valida ... Brutta fine.....sta tradendo la sua arte.( se ha mai pensato di averne una) .....
Sorry, I do admire this man & his mammoth career but the comment below defining the term DOMINGO BARITONE is no substitute for the real thing. It’s not that his singing is bad for he is too an intelligent & well trained artist to allow for this. Nevertheless he adds little if any to his stature by undertaking these Verdi Baritone roles. His timbre is without a distinctive color for this repertoire & the lower range (such as it is for a Verdi Baritone) is weak. He has considerable talent as a conductor & perhaps should solely concentrate his contributions there. Domingo had over 40 years as a great singer & we are all grateful for that.
The last time I saw/heard Plácido Domingo in person was at the Met's dress rehearsal for MACBETH on September 21, 2019. I wonder if he pondered the irony of those last words he sang from the Met stage: "Compassion, respect and love, the comforts of declining years will not scatter flowers on your gray-haired age, nor will soft words be uttered over your royal monument. Curses alone will be your funeral dirge." How the mighty are fallen! But most of us knew the truth for decades.
It must be very hard to leave the stage, and who can blame him for wanting more,especially when audiences still applaud, but in the service of opera , baritones and his own legacy, he should retire.
He acts and sings like a male version of Maria Callas imho. He should sing tenor roles tho, he might have lost all those high Cs, since he's not young anymore, but he's still a textbook tenor, not a baritone!
Ive never been much of a Domingo fan but I dont get all this hate. the theater is sold out, audience is enjoying, dont like it ? go listen to something else ... all the best
@Richard, your poor little futbol club lost to Real Madrid again? Hahahahahaha Look, if you're being forced to click these videos you clearly hate so much, let us know we'll send help... eventually. Paz y salud.
anche lui canta onore??? non è possibile....... ma i libretti non li legge più nessuno????? GIUSEPPE VERDI MACBETH Melodramma in quattro atti Libretto di Francesco Maria Piave [e Andrea Maffei] Pietà, rispetto, amore, Conforto a’ dì cadenti, Non spargeran d’un fiore La tua canuta età. Nè sul tuo regio sasso Sperar soavi accenti: ah! Sol la bestemmia, ahi lasso! La nenia tua sarà!
Ivan .Ivanov la prima versione del 47 il libretto dice onore poi come dice il maestro muti tutti hanno iniziato ha cantare amore ma in teoria verdi voleva pietà rispetto onore
Verdi scrive la romanza come :”Pietà,rispetto,onore” infatti se guardi l’opera ,e segui passo passo la trama di Macbeth, ha molto più senso mettere l’aggettivo Onore. Purtroppo le ultime generazioni di cantanti l’hanno cambiato con Amore perché suona meglio ed è molto meno complesso da scandire di Onore.
Il fatto è che ho l'impressione che più avanti andiamo e più non ci saranno le distinzioni delle voci per carità a me piace e lo dico da studente di canto però Ho come l'impressione che la distinzione delle voci e andando avanti nei prossimi decenni non ci sarà più per due motivi Il primo è che ci sono dei tenori che si spacciano da baritoni ho ancora peggio dei baritoni che si spacciano da tenori l'essere baritenore forse è un vantaggio perché la voce si potrebbe quantomeno adattare ai repertori baritonali ma dipende quale tipo di repertorio tipo mozartiano ma un baritenore che cerca di cantare un repertorio Verdiano da baritono la vedo molto dura ma se ha avuto questa capacità di andare avanti nonostante la sua voce da tenore ormai i risulta molto faticosa data l'età Penso che da un lato ha fatto bene sto continuando a coltivare questa passione per l'opera ed è un uomo molto intelligente perché se n'è fregato degli stereotipi E ha continuato per la sua strada non penso che vuole prendere in giro qualcuno per me resterà sempre un grande artista poliedrico poi ognuno le sue critiche a me personalmente piace in quest'aria.
Quando debuttò erano ancora in piena attività i migliori cantanti del secolo scorso.... Quindi ha potuto ascoltare ( e a volte anche a lavorare) baritoni come Bastianini , Capucilli, Gobbi, Bruscantini etc.... Come fa a non capire la differenza? Perché queste esibizioni deplorevoli? I soldi non sono una giustificazione sufficiente.... Sta tradendo la sua arte ....
I really like Domingo's singing AND acting in most of opera's he sang. However, this is pretty tacky. He looks and acts cartoonish like a king from a deck of cards come alive,. At the start of the aria he acts like a petulant child instead of a general - who is in doubt yes, perhaps feeling guilty and scared sensing he may not be as invulnerable as the prophesy suggested that he recants like a mantra, but also filled with rage and determination. The lack of gravity in his tenor voice doesn't help in coming across more threatening.
HE IS MOCKING ON OPERA, REALLY! SHAME! HE HAS ENOUGH MONEY, ENOUGH FAME, ENOUGH EVVVERYTHING...WHY TRYING TO ACT LIKE A YOUNG DRAMATIC BARYTON WHEN HE IS NOT? ENOUGH!!
To all the bitter Italian futbol club fanboys who deny it, show some integrity and just admit you're Bjorling Bellringers, Pavi Peeps or Carusian Cultists, that you've never liked the Great Domingo and never will. That way we can reassure you with true sincerity that the cure for what ails you is to go watch videos of your guys and savor the relief. Stay there, and commune with your fellow spleen venters. See? A win-win. Because clearly, no amount of you eating your heart out here is going to make us give Domingo up until we're good and ready to. Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha Paz y salud!
@Adler, exactly. Just based on the Bravos and applause he gets, clearly, there are enough people buying his tickets who don't care what his voice is officially called these days. But the Richard Guglielmis of the world (strange how the haters are usually Italian boys) act like it's their job to insult us into caring. Excuse me, I'm going to order this performance on DVD, and a few others in the Domingo Baritonal Epoch. Paz y salud.
Wrong country Poofy Longstockings. I follow American football . But you do like Italian boys don't you ? Dark, hairy ,steamy. Signore Doming is 80 yrs old . How long will his ego allow him to take food out of the mouths of other up and coming singers . When he was Domingo the tenor. He struggled for a b flat. I saw Signore Domingo 3 times at the Met. His Otello was horrible . His Ariggo ,so so. His Aneas . He looked like a stuffed cabbage. NO personality at all
Richard Guglielmi they applau to ignorance! The music it was written for a certain type of voice. Not even a Rossini/Baritone is allowed to sing repertoire that doesn’t fit it. Mr. Domingo has a incredible musicality besides his name and his person are a brand. A product.
Was für ein Blödsinn. Es ist sehr leicht einen phantastischen Jahrhundertsänger zu kritisieren. Kann sehr gut verstehen, warum Domingo nicht aufhört zu singen. Er ist ein genialer Künstler und die Rollen die er jetzt singt passen sehr gut zu seiner Stimme und seinem Alter. Er macht sich nicht lächerlich. Die Opernhäuser sind ausverkauft, wenn er singt. Das gibt ihm absolut das Recht weiter zu machen. Klar bleibt seine Stimme heller als ein echter Bariton. Man muss seine Stimme auch nicht mit Capucilli, oder Bruson vergleichen. Auch Fischer Dieskau hatte eine tenorale Stimme und hat mit großem Erfolg den Macbeth gesungen. Die Bühne gibt dem Domingo viel Kraft. Ich bin sehr froh, dass er weiter so phantastisch singen kann.
Con tutto il rispetto per il Grande Placido, credo che ci siano in giro interpreti vocali migliori in questo momento. La voce prettamente baritonale del personaggio richiede altra interpretazione.
Otherwise known as a "mezzo-tenor." Other examples include Ramón Vinay (1911-1998) and Renato Zanelli (1892-1935), both born in Chile and both enjoyed long international careers as both dramatic baritone and dramatic tenor.
Pobre Digo da pena creyéndose barítono retires metro ni como teneo sirve no borre lo poco bueno q hiso falastima con los grandes barítonos q cantaron y cantan esta área de sublime, x favor t conozco cuando viniste. Alcolon 1973ahi.eras muy bueno.pero.ahora. gritas x no x no cubría.el sonido ocaso de Dgo
A mi ni me gustaba como tenor, nunca fué un tenor con buena técnica y poco elegante y como Barítono es penoso. Eso sí se ha sabido vender como ninguno y ha utilizado el marketing y al público inexperto de manera magistral.
Let's admit there is still quite a big taboo in men singing roles of a different range even they can pull it off (not so much the case for soprano/ mezzo or mezzo/contralto). Closing my eyes and focusing purely on the music (though I believe the sound is amplified) I certainly hear a voice that pulls it off quite well and still with nice legato and high notes, even if it sounds tired at some places. After all, this aria is probably one or the highest-lying parts in the score for Macbeth. I would be curious to hear the duets and the ensembles where the real low notes are... Yes, it is not as dark as we would prefer it to be and the recitative was somewhat hammy, but I admit he performs well. One certainly needs to admire Plácido for learning new parts and going on stage to sing full operas for the public rather than the "sympathy" concerts of certain soloists who have lost their voices in their 40s and present 5 obscure "songs" to the public in their recitals with 2 orchestral intermissions and just throw in 2 easy arias in the end to save some face.
Same opinion in regards to Countertenors. As a Tenor I’m quite picky but there are some falsettists whom I’d choose to sing female or castrato roles over tons of female singers, despite their « nasal » and « hooty » sounds ! At the end of the day, I think if the technical approach is good, then just live and let live. You don’t like them ? Just pass them to the side and listen to what you like. I personally don’t like Domingo singing Baritone roles but he was not the first Tenor to ever do so in the history of singing. It’s actually quite impressive to see someone pushing their body to its limits.
Domingo No puede ser barítono, mejor que se quede como tenor con un registro muy acortado. No cumple con la tesitura y color de barítono. Igual pasa en La Traviata en el papel de Giorgio Gernomt. Ni modo, el tiempo cobra, mejor retirarse,
Por favor alguien que conozca a este señor Domingo le puede decir que se retire, que si bien ninca fue buen tenor y bajo trucos y buena presencia construyó una carrera más que respetable, ahora de barítono deja al descubierto todos los fallos que siempre tuvo a pesar de escudarse en la edad. Que se retire por respeto propio y por respeto a nosotros los operomanos.
@@joseblanco9456 hahahaha, esta bazofia siempre bajaba las arias y jamas daba un digno Do de pecho. Tenores como Bonisolli y Giacomo Lauri Volpi se burlaban de el todo el tiempo. Voz engolada, tonos bajos y alteraba grabaciones, es un asco este hombre.
After such a stellar tenor career, why is he doing baritone roles? He was a good tenor and is certainly not a Verdi baritone. I admire his longevity but would much rather hear a baritone timbre in any Verdi baritone role. He's 78 for heaven's sake; hang it up, Placido!
@Campuscoll, we say no. Did you hear the Bravos and applause at the end? Yes? Then you have no say. The next time your futbol club loses to Real Madrid again, go to their YT channel and complain to them. Oh, and if you have a gun to your head, let us know, we'll send help... eventually! Paz y salud!
Sacrificed his top notes? You might tune down the hyperbole. Domingo just suffers from blindness to his age. And instead of retiring gracefully he sours his legacy by trying to be what he is not. And the audience only furthers his delusions by applauding him for what he was instead of what he is.
Will this man never stop? Give up no Domingo. You are not a baritone by any stretch of the imagination. You are going to ruin your past reputation and end up a joke.
Asquerosamente horrible el tenor que. de tanto abarca vino a la nada desde su obcecación de interpretar OTELLO se derrumbó al abismo de la mediocridad y la vulgar popularidad eso hasta la fecha lo a mantenido vigente no su voz muerta antes que el a principios de los 80 pobre es digno de la lastima
Sencillamente: dispone de muy buena técnica vocal, PERO NO TIENE VOZ PARA VERDI. Todos son jugadores de fútbol, pero no pongas a Messi de back derecho ni a Diego Lugano de puntero izquierdo.
As much as I respect Domingo's great artistry it is depressing to hear him singing dramatic baritone roles such as Macbeth. He is not a baritone at all and this is a disservice to opera.
Que pena lastimoso DGO, como tenor faltó de agudos y ahora en su ocaso, lastimoso, nunca será barítono y x favor escuchén al mejor del mundo Warren irrepetible, insuperable, voZ dramatismo, carácter, pasión, lo aplaudió el mundo, Domingo, dedícate a otra cosa,menos a cantar, digo de lástima lírica mente, yo cante en el colon otros y tengo autoridad para hablar
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 sounds like Domingo the tenor 😂😂😂😂 do you believe the balls on this guy how many young baritones needed a chance starting a career ? But he couldn’t stop ? needed the adulation ?
Que mala intención demuestra usted. Podrá gustarle o no (está en su derecho) y es cierto que es hora de retirarse. Pero lo que no lo es, es que usted quiera embarrar el éxito y la brillante carrera que se ha forjado con mucho esfuerzo y trabajo. Así que...váyase a escuchar a otros
Ha presa i forbici a la linea Verdiana. E ridicolo. Disastro. Vergogna. Non e baritono, non e ancora tenore. Com'era grande. Com'e un ombra di prima. Pero...non ci sono baritoni grandi oggi e...dobbiamo accettare lui...
Horrible. Voz gritona, engolada y nasal en algunos momentos. Esto es querer alargar una carrera pq desde hace mucho ya no puede cantar de tenor. Pero la gente no tiene ni idea y deja llevar por el marketing.
Magnificent! I was there! Conductor James Conlon. Hundreds of people from many countries crowded the lobby afterwards to thank Domingo & Conlon. Left at 1:20am. Was in a daze, had ideal seat to hear. You cannot imagine!
Mariano Muñoz menos mal que estás tú para ilustrarnos, el mundo entero está lleno de sordos menos tú, deberías reflexionar si es que te queda alguna neurona, no será que el sordo eres tú???
Placimingo is so delusional thinking he is a baritone. So selfish and in love with himself. No dignity, no honor. As a tenor he was mediocre at best! Always nasal and screaming everything, hiding behind his "amazing" acting skills. Many great singers could not make it to the Met because of the influence of this self centered man. People forget that although theater is part of opera, the singing is the heart of it. Mingo was a good actor but a mediocre singer. A good voice is the most important thing in Grand Opera. This man is literally making a mockery of Opera. He does not need the money, so my guess is that he can't live without the applause of the morons who pay to see horrific performances like these. Have some dignity Mingo and retire already. Know your limits man. You are NOT the great Giacomo Lauri Volpi who could sing a wonderful nessun dorma at 80. You were pretty decent in your good times but it is time to go now. All great singers are turning in their graves every time you keep singing baritone parts man. The state of grand opera is very depressing and sad nowadays, and you are making it even worst with your actions. Your legacy will be that of a ridiculous old fool who could not accept his time onstage was finish. Dignity Mingo, Dignity!
Q verguenza como tenor siempre con problemas d agudos y ahora el desfachatado como.seudo baritono.escuchen x favor esta hermosa area en la voz e interpretacion del mejor de mundo Leonard Warren fall3cido en 1960.Dgo no le puede lustrar las botas a eeste grandioso d la opera en su defecto a otros grandes como Mc Neil.etc Don Dgo Retirese x favor q esta viejo cascoteado moralmente x acoso a las prima donas q triunfan sin su apoyo🎀
Verdaderamente lastimoso da pena y lastima n7nca fue.baritono.hub8lese mtro y abandone el arte lirico ud.ademas esta acusado de acosador.ud da mucha pena como cantante dirija y toque el piano....
Siempre UN GRAN INTÉRPRETE. Siempre. !!!BRAVO!!!!!
This was a magnificent production in every way. Have heard Placido Domingo over a long lifetime, and his acting, timing, voice, musicianship increase. Hear the crowd! Great partner in conductor James Conlon, sense of timing, orchestra - wonderful!
It just goes to show that opera crowds lack any taste. If it's flashy and well sung they don't give two shits about what the composer wanted. And Verdi didn't want a tenor who thinks he is a baritone in this.
Here is Leo Nucci singing this just one year younger than Domingo and also past his prime, but at least he was a baritone all his life: ruclips.net/video/4Q8xeAuzV5k/видео.htmlh22m41s
Пока есть интерес он просто обязан петь. Конечно это не звучит так как должно но при этом заучит его неповторимый тембр. Браво!!!
his voice color is still Tenore.......
I heard him singing this aria in LA opera. It took me into ecstasy! Later I compared with other famous baritons and realized that his singing could be rated as one of top performances. It is no surprise considering that he started his career as a baritone and converted to tenor later. Splendid singing by Semenchuk for the role of Lady Macbeth made it a unforgetable night.
Pietà e basta. Non c’è più ne rispetto ne onore.
Come umiliarsi dopo una brillantissima carriera, che triste fine
pietà,rispetto,onore ...
quali ?! ...
Pietá. Rispetto...ORRORE!!!!
Infatti... Voglio Bastianini, Ruffo, Cappuccilli e gli altri!
Nessuno infatti! Non ha una sola nota del baritono e gonfiando i centri in maniera così artificiosa lo rendono monocorde e totalmente inespressivo.... Mi chiedo solo perché? ! I soldi non sono una motivazione sufficientemente valida ... Brutta fine.....sta tradendo la sua arte.( se ha mai pensato di averne una)
.....
@@andrealupini6769 megalomania?
@@jackbigbug in effetti......
Sorry, I do admire this man & his mammoth career but the comment below defining the term DOMINGO BARITONE is no substitute for the real thing. It’s not that his singing is bad for he is too an intelligent & well trained artist to allow for this. Nevertheless he adds little if any to his stature by undertaking these Verdi Baritone roles. His timbre is without a distinctive color for this repertoire & the lower range (such as it is for a Verdi Baritone) is weak. He has considerable talent as a conductor & perhaps should solely concentrate his contributions there. Domingo had over 40 years as a great singer & we are all grateful for that.
I didn’t know Burger King sang opera
The last time I saw/heard Plácido Domingo in person was at the Met's dress rehearsal for MACBETH on September 21, 2019. I wonder if he pondered the irony of those last words he sang from the Met stage: "Compassion, respect and love, the comforts of declining years will not scatter flowers on your gray-haired age, nor will soft words be uttered over your royal monument. Curses alone will be your funeral dirge." How the mighty are fallen! But most of us knew the truth for decades.
Who books this guy? He may sing baritone roles now but he remains a tenor without the high notes. Stick to conducting from now on Placido!
I would book him. This is great. I would book him till he blows his last breath, so beautiful.
But his conducting is even worse!
It must be very hard to leave the stage, and who can blame him for wanting more,especially when audiences still applaud, but in the service of opera , baritones and his own legacy, he should retire.
He acts and sings like a male version of Maria Callas imho. He should sing tenor roles tho, he might have lost all those high Cs, since he's not young anymore, but he's still a textbook tenor, not a baritone!
Ive never been much of a Domingo fan but I dont get all this hate. the theater is sold out, audience is enjoying, dont like it ? go listen to something else ... all the best
Up vote 10,000 times.
Listen to Leonard Warren sing this aria , listen to Robert Merril sing it , Listen to Piero Cappucillie sing it. And then you will know
@Richard, your poor little futbol club lost to Real Madrid again? Hahahahahaha Look, if you're being forced to click these videos you clearly hate so much, let us know we'll send help... eventually. Paz y salud.
他年纪大了,唱歌剧是为了维持歌剧在年轻人当中的影响力。同时帮助年轻的演员有更多登上舞台的机会。他作为男高音,在威尔第和其他作曲家的歌剧作品中,已经无法很好的完成。
anche lui canta onore??? non è possibile....... ma i libretti non li legge più nessuno?????
GIUSEPPE VERDI
MACBETH
Melodramma in quattro atti
Libretto di Francesco Maria Piave [e Andrea Maffei]
Pietà, rispetto, amore,
Conforto a’ dì cadenti,
Non spargeran d’un fiore
La tua canuta età.
Nè sul tuo regio sasso
Sperar soavi accenti:
ah! Sol la bestemmia, ahi lasso!
La nenia tua sarà!
Ivan .Ivanov la prima versione del 47 il libretto dice onore poi come dice il maestro muti tutti hanno iniziato ha cantare amore ma in teoria verdi voleva pietà rispetto onore
RIGHT, RIGHT! YOU ARE ALL RIGHT!!
Grazie per detti Voglio cantare comme lui.
Verdi scrive la romanza come :”Pietà,rispetto,onore” infatti se guardi l’opera ,e segui passo passo la trama di Macbeth, ha molto più senso mettere l’aggettivo Onore. Purtroppo le ultime generazioni di cantanti l’hanno cambiato con Amore perché suona meglio ed è molto meno complesso da scandire di Onore.
Triste fine per questo grande artista.....😡😔😖
You just read my mind :(
Proprio cosí.
narcissism it's called 😂
Casa le e sucesso
Il fatto è che ho l'impressione che più avanti andiamo e più non ci saranno le distinzioni delle voci per carità a me piace e lo dico da studente di canto però Ho come l'impressione che la distinzione delle voci e andando avanti nei prossimi decenni non ci sarà più per due motivi Il primo è che ci sono dei tenori che si spacciano da baritoni ho ancora peggio dei baritoni che si spacciano da tenori l'essere baritenore forse è un vantaggio perché la voce si potrebbe quantomeno adattare ai repertori baritonali ma dipende quale tipo di repertorio tipo mozartiano ma un baritenore che cerca di cantare un repertorio Verdiano da baritono la vedo molto dura ma se ha avuto questa capacità di andare avanti nonostante la sua voce da tenore ormai i risulta molto faticosa data l'età Penso che da un lato ha fatto bene sto continuando a coltivare questa passione per l'opera ed è un uomo molto intelligente perché se n'è fregato degli stereotipi E ha continuato per la sua strada non penso che vuole prendere in giro qualcuno per me resterà sempre un grande artista poliedrico poi ognuno le sue critiche a me personalmente piace in quest'aria.
Quando debuttò erano ancora in piena attività i migliori cantanti del secolo scorso.... Quindi ha potuto ascoltare ( e a volte anche a lavorare) baritoni come Bastianini , Capucilli, Gobbi, Bruscantini etc.... Come fa a non capire la differenza? Perché queste esibizioni deplorevoli? I soldi non sono una giustificazione sufficiente.... Sta tradendo la sua arte ....
Aprendiz de todo maestro de nada.
От всей души благодарю, УУВАЖАЕМЫЙ РУСЛАН))) Много слушала в юности - в РИГЕ,, по СССР, в театрах Украины!!!
I really like Domingo's singing AND acting in most of opera's he sang. However, this is pretty tacky. He looks and acts cartoonish like a king from a deck of cards come alive,. At the start of the aria he acts like a petulant child instead of a general - who is in doubt yes, perhaps feeling guilty and scared sensing he may not be as invulnerable as the prophesy suggested that he recants like a mantra, but also filled with rage and determination. The lack of gravity in his tenor voice doesn't help in coming across more threatening.
Alguien me podrá decir qué instrumentos se utilizan, es para un tp. Graciass
Bravissimo come sempre, sia come tenore sia come baritono.
HE IS MOCKING ON OPERA, REALLY! SHAME! HE HAS ENOUGH MONEY, ENOUGH FAME, ENOUGH EVVVERYTHING...WHY TRYING TO ACT LIKE A YOUNG DRAMATIC BARYTON WHEN HE IS NOT? ENOUGH!!
Perché si deve vergognare? Il maestro Domingo è da ammirare invece, perché dimostra di essere davvero appassionato della musica lirica.
Epa, no digas eso. Aprende a apreciar la expresión lírica.
Although I don't like, at all, this Placido's bariton thing, this particular aria was sung prety well.
Questa è la prova che tra un tenore e un baritone c'è una grossa differenza e mi dispiace dirlo, ma Domingo che canta da baritono è ridicolo.
Es momento de retirarse. Un tenor siempre será un tenor.
un voz magnifico. No tenore no baritone.Un voz incredibile.Escuchar de nuovo
To all the bitter Italian futbol club fanboys who deny it, show some integrity and just admit you're Bjorling Bellringers, Pavi Peeps or Carusian Cultists, that you've never liked the Great Domingo and never will. That way we can reassure you with true sincerity that the cure for what ails you is to go watch videos of your guys and savor the relief. Stay there, and commune with your fellow spleen venters. See? A win-win. Because clearly, no amount of you eating your heart out here is going to make us give Domingo up until we're good and ready to. Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha Paz y salud!
Al fin le emboco
Chiedo scusa se non ho usato punteggiatura ma mi sto servendo della chat per via vocale.
He is NOT A VERDI BARITONE !!!!!!!!!!He sings like Domingo the tenor !!! Enough.
But not so bad for his age! He was a tenor.
@Adler, exactly. Just based on the Bravos and applause he gets, clearly, there are enough people buying his tickets who don't care what his voice is officially called these days. But the Richard Guglielmis of the world (strange how the haters are usually Italian boys) act like it's their job to insult us into caring. Excuse me, I'm going to order this performance on DVD, and a few others in the Domingo Baritonal Epoch. Paz y salud.
Wrong country Poofy Longstockings. I follow American football . But you do like Italian boys don't you ? Dark, hairy ,steamy. Signore Doming is 80 yrs old . How long will his ego allow him to take food out of the mouths of other up and coming singers .
When he was Domingo the tenor. He struggled for a b flat. I saw Signore Domingo 3 times at the Met. His Otello was horrible . His Ariggo ,so so. His Aneas . He looked like a stuffed cabbage. NO personality at all
Richard Guglielmi they applau to ignorance! The music it was written for a certain type of voice. Not even a Rossini/Baritone is allowed to sing repertoire that doesn’t fit it.
Mr. Domingo has a incredible musicality besides his name and his person are a brand. A product.
Richard Guglielmi espectacular!!!! Bravooo!!!
Was für ein Blödsinn. Es ist sehr leicht einen phantastischen Jahrhundertsänger zu kritisieren. Kann sehr gut verstehen, warum Domingo nicht aufhört zu singen. Er ist ein genialer Künstler und die Rollen die er jetzt singt passen sehr gut zu seiner Stimme und seinem Alter. Er macht sich nicht lächerlich. Die Opernhäuser sind ausverkauft, wenn er singt. Das gibt ihm absolut das Recht weiter zu machen. Klar bleibt seine Stimme heller als ein echter Bariton. Man muss seine Stimme auch nicht mit Capucilli, oder Bruson vergleichen. Auch Fischer Dieskau hatte eine tenorale Stimme und hat mit großem Erfolg den Macbeth gesungen. Die Bühne gibt dem Domingo viel Kraft. Ich bin sehr froh, dass er weiter so phantastisch singen kann.
Da stimme ich 100%tig zu!
Con tutto il rispetto per il Grande Placido, credo che ci siano in giro interpreti vocali migliori in questo momento. La voce prettamente baritonale del personaggio richiede altra interpretazione.
Bravo!!!
This actually isn't too bad, but will somebody please tell Domingo he is NOT a baritone
i think there is a new voice type of baritone called ''domingo baritone'' from now on.
Otherwise known as a "mezzo-tenor." Other examples include Ramón Vinay (1911-1998) and Renato Zanelli (1892-1935), both born in Chile and both enjoyed long international careers as both dramatic baritone and dramatic tenor.
Yeah. And this new type of voice is not good. lol
🤣 🤣 🤣
Pobre Digo da pena creyéndose barítono retires metro ni como teneo sirve no borre lo poco bueno q hiso falastima con los grandes barítonos q cantaron y cantan esta área de sublime, x favor t conozco cuando viniste. Alcolon 1973ahi.eras muy bueno.pero.ahora. gritas x no x no cubría.el sonido ocaso de Dgo
A mi ni me gustaba como tenor, nunca fué un tenor con buena técnica y poco elegante y como Barítono es penoso. Eso sí se ha sabido vender como ninguno y ha utilizado el marketing y al público inexperto de manera magistral.
Let's admit there is still quite a big taboo in men singing roles of a different range even they can pull it off (not so much the case for soprano/ mezzo or mezzo/contralto).
Closing my eyes and focusing purely on the music (though I believe the sound is amplified) I certainly hear a voice that pulls it off quite well and still with nice legato and high notes, even if it sounds tired at some places. After all, this aria is probably one or the highest-lying parts in the score for Macbeth. I would be curious to hear the duets and the ensembles where the real low notes are...
Yes, it is not as dark as we would prefer it to be and the recitative was somewhat hammy, but I admit he performs well.
One certainly needs to admire Plácido for learning new parts and going on stage to sing full operas for the public rather than the "sympathy" concerts of certain soloists who have lost their voices in their 40s and present 5 obscure "songs" to the public in their recitals with 2 orchestral intermissions and just throw in 2 easy arias in the end to save some face.
agreed
Same opinion in regards to Countertenors. As a Tenor I’m quite picky but there are some falsettists whom I’d choose to sing female or castrato roles over tons of female singers, despite their « nasal » and « hooty » sounds !
At the end of the day, I think if the technical approach is good, then just live and let live. You don’t like them ? Just pass them to the side and listen to what you like. I personally don’t like Domingo singing Baritone roles but he was not the first Tenor to ever do so in the history of singing. It’s actually quite impressive to see someone pushing their body to its limits.
non si può sentire da baritono
finalmente un commento sensato dalla parte tua ...
Placido je t'adore, mais là, il faut que tu arrêtes. C'est plus possible. Tu dois grandir et admettre que l'age est là.
Domingo No puede ser barítono, mejor que se quede como tenor con un registro muy acortado. No cumple con la tesitura y color de barítono. Igual pasa en La Traviata en el papel de Giorgio Gernomt.
Ni modo, el tiempo cobra, mejor retirarse,
ma perchè Placido, perchè?????? sei stato un grande!! Perchè questa schifezza. Perchè?????
Perche ? Sordi !
No Problema. La voce e meravigliosa sempre!
reatestHe is still the g
??????????????tenor
Labai gerai dainuojate,skamba fantastiškai,bet tiek prirašyta apie prakeiksmus!
Por favor alguien que conozca a este señor Domingo le puede decir que se retire, que si bien ninca fue buen tenor y bajo trucos y buena presencia construyó una carrera más que respetable, ahora de barítono deja al descubierto todos los fallos que siempre tuvo a pesar de escudarse en la edad. Que se retire por respeto propio y por respeto a nosotros los operomanos.
¿Nunca fue un buen tenor?
Tan respetable fue su carrera que muchos lo consideramos el mejor tenor libra por libra del siglo XX. Si fuera por buena presencia le gana Corelli.
@@joseblanco9456 hahahaha, esta bazofia siempre bajaba las arias y jamas daba un digno Do de pecho. Tenores como Bonisolli y Giacomo Lauri Volpi se burlaban de el todo el tiempo. Voz engolada, tonos bajos y alteraba grabaciones, es un asco este hombre.
No comparto su opinión caballero. Y nadie le regalo nada que él no consiguiera con esfuerzo y trabajo.
After such a stellar tenor career, why is he doing baritone roles? He was a good tenor and is certainly not a Verdi baritone. I admire his longevity but would much rather hear a baritone timbre in any Verdi baritone role. He's 78 for heaven's sake; hang it up, Placido!
@Campuscoll, we say no. Did you hear the Bravos and applause at the end? Yes? Then you have no say. The next time your futbol club loses to Real Madrid again, go to their YT channel and complain to them. Oh, and if you have a gun to your head, let us know, we'll send help... eventually! Paz y salud!
The applause only strengthens my long term suspicion that opera audiences are basically tone deaf and clueless.
Sacrificed his top notes? You might tune down the hyperbole. Domingo just suffers from blindness to his age. And instead of retiring gracefully he sours his legacy by trying to be what he is not. And the audience only furthers his delusions by applauding him for what he was instead of what he is.
ahora ahy que convenverlo para que cante la reyna de la noche.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
No es un aria romántica ..se confunde ...es de resignación y de rabia ....no es necesario tantos pianos ..está la vi en directo
Grande tenore, perché vuole cantare una parte da baritono?
Perché non ha più gli acuti di un tenore… si sta rendendo ridicolo
Escucha a baritonos de verdad.
Grande
Sono ammutolito.
Will this man never stop? Give up no Domingo. You are not a baritone by any stretch of the imagination. You are going to ruin your past reputation and end up a joke.
This is very sad!!!
Fantastico 😊👍
Asquerosamente horrible el tenor que. de tanto abarca vino a la nada desde su obcecación de interpretar OTELLO se derrumbó al abismo de la mediocridad y la vulgar popularidad eso hasta la fecha lo a mantenido vigente no su voz muerta antes que el a principios de los 80 pobre es digno de la lastima
los comentarios favorables aqui deben venir de sordos como tapias, no digo mas . Escuchar Macbeth sin Macbeth
Horrible. A shame for this great artist, who obviously does not know when he should stop
I prefer Zeljko Lucic in this part
Canta sicuramente meglio lui che tanti altri.... che si spacciano per baritoni.... Placido sei e sarai sempre un grande.... ❤️
Che orrore 😱🤬
Sencillamente: dispone de muy buena técnica vocal, PERO NO TIENE VOZ PARA VERDI. Todos son jugadores de fútbol, pero no pongas a Messi de back derecho ni a Diego Lugano de puntero izquierdo.
No
Che brutta figura! Non è questa la voce di un baritono. Ritirarsi sarebbe la cosa migliore!!!
Die Farbe ist von einem Tenor!!! Kein Bariton,wie Paskalis Mac Neil,Cappuccilli.....usw.!! Völlig uninteressant
Horrible, disgraceful! I've run out of adjectives ... and the reaction of the public ... no comment ....
Sol la bestemmia... 🤬
it's orribile.... stop this person must stop ruining the opera!
RIGHT!!!
this was great singing. I tried to sing with him. No way i can do that.
why? This great opera singing.
As much as I respect Domingo's great artistry it is depressing to hear him singing dramatic baritone roles such as Macbeth. He is not a baritone at all and this is a disservice to opera.
Que pena lastimoso DGO, como tenor faltó de agudos y ahora en su ocaso, lastimoso, nunca será barítono y x favor escuchén al mejor del mundo Warren irrepetible, insuperable, voZ dramatismo, carácter, pasión, lo aplaudió el mundo, Domingo, dedícate a otra cosa,menos a cantar, digo de lástima lírica mente, yo cante en el colon otros y tengo autoridad para hablar
Leonard Warren uno de los más grandes barítonos de la historia
Domingo: haciendo el ridiculo. Tendría que haberse retirado hace 10 años.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 sounds like Domingo the tenor 😂😂😂😂 do you believe the balls on this guy how many young baritones needed a chance starting a career ? But he couldn’t stop ? needed the adulation ?
(((((
Que mala intención demuestra usted.
Podrá gustarle o no (está en su derecho) y es cierto que es hora de retirarse. Pero lo que no lo es, es que usted quiera embarrar el éxito y la brillante carrera que se ha forjado con mucho esfuerzo y trabajo.
Así que...váyase a escuchar a otros
Pitiful!! And he got paid for this!!
Go fishing darling. You sound dreadful. Poor Verdi.
RIGHT!
furter is long distance. That is what you are.
so what? He is a singer.
Patetico
Nunca fue un gran tenor: no tenía buenos agudos
Y se parece a un barítono tanto como yo a un avestruz de tres patas.
Pues para no ser un gran tenor (según usted) me parece que algo le falla, a usted por supuesto
Ha presa i forbici a la linea Verdiana. E ridicolo. Disastro. Vergogna. Non e baritono, non e ancora tenore. Com'era grande. Com'e un ombra di prima. Pero...non ci sono baritoni grandi oggi e...dobbiamo accettare lui...
Make it stop
Pathetic excuse for a Verdi baritone.
Horrible. Voz gritona, engolada y nasal en algunos momentos. Esto es querer alargar una carrera pq desde hace mucho ya no puede cantar de tenor. Pero la gente no tiene ni idea y deja llevar por el marketing.
Magnificent! I was there! Conductor James Conlon. Hundreds of people from many countries crowded the lobby afterwards to thank Domingo & Conlon. Left at 1:20am. Was in a daze, had ideal seat to hear. You cannot imagine!
Moira Clegg Nunca ha sido ni será baritono la vieja vociferante.
Si bueno....el tema es que para ningun cantante es facil dejar de cantar, si cantaras opera lo entenderias amigo mio ;)
Aparte aun estando asi canta mejor que cualquier reguetonero/popero...
Mariano Muñoz menos mal que estás tú para ilustrarnos, el mundo entero está lleno de sordos menos tú, deberías reflexionar si es que te queda alguna neurona, no será que el sordo eres tú???
Penoso el bajobaritenor.
Stai zitto...
horror
Awful Macbeth!
Placimingo is so delusional thinking he is a baritone. So selfish and in love with himself. No dignity, no honor. As a tenor he was mediocre at best! Always nasal and screaming everything, hiding behind his "amazing" acting skills. Many great singers could not make it to the Met because of the influence of this self centered man. People forget that although theater is part of opera, the singing is the heart of it. Mingo was a good actor but a mediocre singer. A good voice is the most important thing in Grand Opera. This man is literally making a mockery of Opera. He does not need the money, so my guess is that he can't live without the applause of the morons who pay to see horrific performances like these. Have some dignity Mingo and retire already. Know your limits man. You are NOT the great Giacomo Lauri Volpi who could sing a wonderful nessun dorma at 80. You were pretty decent in your good times but it is time to go now. All great singers are turning in their graves every time you keep singing baritone parts man. The state of grand opera is very depressing and sad nowadays, and you are making it even worst with your actions. Your legacy will be that of a ridiculous old fool who could not accept his time onstage was finish. Dignity Mingo, Dignity!
I’m laughing on my ass 😂Domingo you were be tenor what’s the difference 😂
Q verguenza como tenor siempre con problemas d agudos y ahora el desfachatado como.seudo baritono.escuchen x favor esta hermosa area en la voz e interpretacion del mejor de mundo Leonard Warren fall3cido en 1960.Dgo no le puede lustrar las botas a eeste grandioso d la opera en su defecto a otros grandes como Mc Neil.etc
Don Dgo
Retirese x favor q esta viejo cascoteado moralmente x acoso a las prima donas q triunfan sin su apoyo🎀
Verdaderamente lastimoso da pena y lastima n7nca fue.baritono.hub8lese mtro y abandone el arte lirico ud.ademas esta acusado de acosador.ud da mucha pena como cantante dirija y toque el piano....