To me, there seem to be two differences: the overall brightness of the image is higher in SPCC-late based on the statistics and the stars, even after correction, seem more bloated in SPCC-early. RUclips's algorithm may be affecting some of that, but logically, there might be an explanation. You got to choose the brightness level using Astro Image Primer, whereas there is a baked-in value in SPCC-early. Not sure why the SPCC-early image would have more bloated stars though. Unless, again, the baked-in brightness value is somehow referenced using BXT-Correct only. Thanks for this - good to know. I think though that for my workflow,, it does make more sense to address the flaws in the image (like gradients) before doing any colour calibration.
Thank you. I learned some very useful things in this video. For example, I have the SETI Astro scripts loaded into PixInsight, but I had no idea that Find Background did what you demonstrated. I’ve always been a little bit anxious about picking the background sample, fearing I wasn’t doing it right. Now, thanks to Franklin, I can have it done automatically. And the main point of the video reinforces doing Linear Fit at the beginning of the process. This was 20 minutes well spent!
It was very interesting but clear as mud with your terms as early and late. 😢. Can you just tell me if you run the one on the left or the one on the right. The one on the left looks much better but for the life of me I not sure with your explanation.
I apologize about that :( I use the one on the left “SPCCLATE”. The main idea is to use SPCC as a final correction. Using SPCC as a final correction will retain the changes SPCC makes. I’m more than happy to reword differently and if you would rather email me with something you’d like explained differently you’re more than welcome to do that as well :)
the big difference , is the order you use ADBE , before or after SPCC...You change 2 factors , linear fit AND the order you use background extraction ..'.
Exactly. Both of those will change what SPCC does. The reason they were ordered this way in the video was to answer the question of why not use SPCC to get rid of the color cast in the beginning. Doing so will still need the background extracted, thus rendering SPCC void.
To make a fair comparison of whether you need to do linear fit to get rid of the colour cast as well as SPCC, you should have done auto DBE before SPCCearly, not after - as stated you have changed two variables so the question of whether linear fit is needed has not been addressed.
To me, there seem to be two differences: the overall brightness of the image is higher in SPCC-late based on the statistics and the stars, even after correction, seem more bloated in SPCC-early. RUclips's algorithm may be affecting some of that, but logically, there might be an explanation. You got to choose the brightness level using Astro Image Primer, whereas there is a baked-in value in SPCC-early. Not sure why the SPCC-early image would have more bloated stars though. Unless, again, the baked-in brightness value is somehow referenced using BXT-Correct only. Thanks for this - good to know. I think though that for my workflow,, it does make more sense to address the flaws in the image (like gradients) before doing any colour calibration.
Thank you. I learned some very useful things in this video. For example, I have the SETI Astro scripts loaded into PixInsight, but I had no idea that Find Background did what you demonstrated. I’ve always been a little bit anxious about picking the background sample, fearing I wasn’t doing it right. Now, thanks to Franklin, I can have it done automatically. And the main point of the video reinforces doing Linear Fit at the beginning of the process. This was 20 minutes well spent!
It was very interesting but clear as mud with your terms as early and late. 😢. Can you just tell me if you run the one on the left or the one on the right. The one on the left looks much better but for the life of me I not sure with your explanation.
I apologize about that :( I use the one on the left “SPCCLATE”. The main idea is to use SPCC as a final correction. Using SPCC as a final correction will retain the changes SPCC makes. I’m more than happy to reword differently and if you would rather email me with something you’d like explained differently you’re more than welcome to do that as well :)
@@Hidden.Light.Photography Thanks for the update. I’m very new to pixinsight so thank you for your expertise.
the big difference , is the order you use ADBE , before or after SPCC...You change 2 factors , linear fit AND the order you use background extraction ..'.
Exactly. Both of those will change what SPCC does. The reason they were ordered this way in the video was to answer the question of why not use SPCC to get rid of the color cast in the beginning. Doing so will still need the background extracted, thus rendering SPCC void.
To make a fair comparison of whether you need to do linear fit to get rid of the colour cast as well as SPCC, you should have done auto DBE before SPCCearly, not after - as stated you have changed two variables so the question of whether linear fit is needed has not been addressed.