it can either come from the last triple, the poison quad, or the supposed quint, cus I can feel it that the crystal quad is gonna be percussion. as for what kind of string, an electric guitar like what nova and exclaim did would work wonders, yieyie like orchestra could also be great.
@@RoThunder100 this is definitely a stretch, but the 1st quad released (whaill) was vocalist, then the 2nd one (vhenshun) wasn't vocalist, then the 3rd quad (pentumbra) was vocalist, there might be a pattern with it
@EGGStreme_cheese The fanmades are pretty dang well made, but you can't lie, pentumbra is a REALLY good addition. Unique design/concept, interesting sound, and adds a lot to the lore. But X'rt? Nah.
I'm going to miss these fanmade monsters, now that the official monsters with the same elements have been released. I hope your next waves are cool even with the lack of them.
I like all four of them but i think the official ones are more creative with their designs on sound like even though x'rt is pretty ugly the sound is really creative and the idea of pentunbra casting a shadow through its body is really clever 😊
Why are people hating on X'rt? I feel like big boy actually does a good amount to the build up of the first verse. And to the ppl saying "well it doesn't play for the whole song!!!" 1. It doesn't always have to play to be good 2. It would be very bad if any monster on this island repeated too much
he's creative it is because they are really realated to the game because monster is the right way to go now how ugly how scary it is a good drawing of a monster
Man they complement each other so well musically, it feels criminal that we can't have all 4 of them in the game. Like really, Exclaim did such a good job with this composition/remix of the Ethereal Workshop song, and X'rt+Pentumbra only made it better.
I feel that Snarlequinn's design could work well as a Mythical now that there's an official shadow quad, maybe change the colors to separate it from it's "shadow" origins. Snarlequin's bio already says that he can freely travel across dimensions and islands so he could really be a "Caine" figure that comes from the outside and likes to mess with the workshop monsters knowing they can't get out.
Glad to see you aren't just forsaking your monsters that had their elements fulfilled. Hope to see the final song mixed with your monsters when that's out
@@Thecyanpult I hope that's the case, maybe its just me being extremely picky. I get that the theme for this island is a WIP made by the Ethereal Colossal and I like it, its creative. But we only have one or two more waves left for this island (not counting if we get a quint or seasonal or mythical), it just sounds like the monsters are singing over each other trying to outshine the other to me. It literally needs that one monster to tie all of the parts together. Sorry for the mini rant XD
I like X'rt in a non ironic way first of all its official and I can experience it in game, but also this monster actually looks and sound like a monster. It also helps out the atmosphere in song which I really love I feel the main take away for this is community, please don't hype up the wave so much that it wont reach your super duper high expectations like I get it hype it up bit but don't hype it up soo much that it won't ever reach your expectations.😃
Oh hey! The fanmade Poison Quad's here! I'm hoping next update actually adds a string instrument, and maybe Whail's secret verse to go with all the other monsters that only play once. Edit: OH! Not finished watching the video, but Penumbra mimicking Whail's verse might be cool for the ending
Согласен. Тоже зашел в игру и стало обидно, что среди всех классных неофициальных монстров разработчики решили сделать своих, тем самым просто сделали хуже песню своим X'rt.
GORGEOUS SOUND! I was waiting for this comparison video! So glad you made it for us :) I honestly think I prefer your fanmade monsters, but of the two new ones Pentumbra has grown on me and does so much for the song. I'm so happy to hear a version where I don't have to choose one set or the other XD I think this is my new favorite version of the workshop!
Your prediction of the shadow quad is amazing but I love the official one more the fact it use it shadow to make is sound is so cool it now my favorite monster even but hey at least you got the spider theme for it design
I’m definitely in the boat that thinks YieYie over X’rt, YieYie makes the song sound so majestic with auglur in its verses while X’rt…um…burp transition?…I guess?
And also I had a idea for the crystal quad idk if you made one but my idea is Crystotaur (Minotaur crystal) So the strong arms would bel covered in an armor of crystals, crystal horns, and the sound… something like Torrt
I have an idea for a video, when you release the complete sound of the island you could combine the complete sound with all your fanmade songs from this island.
Isn't it strange we expected an eldritch abomination and we got a spider axolotl with a shadow with a face that has an insane lore drop by the way I would love Pentumbra's 1st track with whaiil's unreleased track
I like the idea behind X'rt, it's a silly personification of how we, or titans and collosals in this case, sometimes briefly forget their train of thought
Lets be honest, most of the fanmade problem is that they continue the song, they dont add anything new to the song or at least smth that its not the same melody as the song and a different voice/instrument, so thats why I choose Pentumbra "D
These are one of the few fanmade tracks that i can really get behind, as they're not just existing melodies in different soundfonts like the majority of them. Its a bit ironic that Pentumbra does exactly that, but also in a very experimental and completely unexpected way to make up for it
Whichever quad comes next needs to be a string instrument, I could see the mech crystal poison triple being a string instrument or the poison quad like you've predicted. I'm very curious what the next quad will be, I wonder if they'll switch it up and release poison early instead of crystal due to the relation to earth island and warm summer heat.
Honestly, I don't want to take any side and I prefer to think that both the fanmade and the original sound good and even more so when they sound together in a beautiful harmony. In short: I take the position that I love how the fanmade and the original sound together.
Shadow quad fanmade vs original Fanmade: creepy wonderful instrumental fits with the design overall great Original: literally mimic but 10x better creepy a bit and took shadow quad to a whole different level than I was expecting overall amazing
i like the workshop feal that xrt adds and i like his desine being a couldrin in a dragon head like shape but yie yie string adds alot too and its desine is good tobut . yie yie is prob better but snarlequinn and pentumbra is a tie form me i love the creappy feal from snarequinn and the sound is creappy to but i like how silly pentumbra is it kinda looks like i has a brainfart and forgets to trun on the shadow think so cus of that it gets scared .i sayd like also the pentumbra desine is creppy to its based on a daddy long legs and an axolotl and one of those lamps that makes a star light on the ground or smt , i think the desine is based of that . i like that the snarlequinn is a jester and that its desine is creappy. sorry for bad english and or incorect info thing.
I actually like Snarlequinn more than official one, even though Pentumbra is super cool. This guy adds so much to the vibe, especially in their duet with X'rt (2:56)
Both Shadow quads, both official and unofficial are just so amazing, pentumbra is my favorite quad, and if snarlequinn released instead it would be my favorite, these monsters are just that peak (sorry if this is phrased weird)
Honestly, when wave 5 comes, I would want Snarlequinn and YieYie as the Wave 5 monsters in my personal opinion, as they with make X'rt and Pentumbra sound better in the song.
What do you think of the Ethereal Workshop Wave 4 monsters?
Their pretty good X'rt was highly disappointing tho
X’rt didn’t do much but I was happy with pentumbra
Pet umbra was insanely above my expectations
There’s “Sir Burps-a-Lot” and “Mimic if it was a Spider”.
Both are great
This comparasion between Snarlequinn and Pentumbra made me realise how small Snarlequinn's shadow is
Their the same height
@@objetosmassivosopticos6893their shadow
@@objetosmassivosopticos6893He's talking about the shadow, not the actual monster.
@@kristinhorner4628 oh, ok, I get it now
@@objetosmassivosopticos6893 It's okay.
Which is better?
A beautiful string sound
or
Burp.
Burp obviously
Beautiful string sound
*BURRRRRRRRP*
*ME LIKE BURP METEOR*
The same monster
As much as I love X'rt, a string instrument is REALLY needed on the song.
YES
Maybe the next triple will be strings
it can either come from the last triple, the poison quad, or the supposed quint, cus I can feel it that the crystal quad is gonna be percussion.
as for what kind of string, an electric guitar like what nova and exclaim did would work wonders, yieyie like orchestra could also be great.
@@RoThunder100 this is definitely a stretch, but the 1st quad released (whaill) was vocalist, then the 2nd one (vhenshun) wasn't vocalist, then the 3rd quad (pentumbra) was vocalist, there might be a pattern with it
Wait, people actually love X'rt?
Well YieYie is definitely more majestic than X'rt lol!
Also I love the new revised intro theme
Thank you!
The thing is,I made a fan made monster with the same elements X’rt has the day before they was released.
@EGGStreme_cheeseFanmade are always better then the actual song xd
@EGGStreme_cheese The fanmades are pretty dang well made, but you can't lie, pentumbra is a REALLY good addition. Unique design/concept, interesting sound, and adds a lot to the lore. But X'rt? Nah.
@@Darealmelody lowkey I like Pentumbra over sharlequinn but Yieyie beats X’rt a million times over
Expectation of Nova: a Scary Monster with 4 Legs with clown face
Reality: a spider with 4 thin legs (but the sound is is good like snarlequinn)
You mean kinitio pet
Reality: the baby of KinitoPet and Groovy Long Legs from Pikmin 4
@@CarlosAlexandre-gv2knI read that as kinitopet from pikmin 4 for a split second and that was hilarious
You mean monster connected to Mirror islands?
However, petunmbra in some tracks is really disturbing both in terms of animation and sound
I'm going to miss these fanmade monsters, now that the official monsters with the same elements have been released. I hope your next waves are cool even with the lack of them.
But we can still keep them right? I mean what is rule of when creating a fanmade monster?
I really like both the official and fanmade Shadow quads they both sound amazing
2:56 I like how Snarlquin made X'rt sound so creepy, I love it!!
How
Wait how???
I don't think what burping sound can get creepy...
Everyone here is confused, I can't explain it other that the creepy bells of snarlquin made X'rt sound kinda creepy, I can't describe it lol
Ah Yes. B U R P is Creepy With Jester Looking Guy
I like all four of them but i think the official ones are more creative with their designs on sound like even though x'rt is pretty ugly the sound is really creative and the idea of pentunbra casting a shadow through its body is really clever 😊
I just wish the song comes out to be great cuz I had VERY high expectations for this wave and I honestly didn’t like it that much.
@@emilianogolazx7928that’s your fault, if you have big expectations for a wave prepare to be fumbled, they save the best for last
The sound is literally burping...
@@Bonlon0 we need more comedy monsters. like hyehehe and X'rt. burp boi.
Wdym x'rt is ugly he's a cutie... Yes he's obviously not holding me captive and this is a conscious decision
Why are people hating on X'rt? I feel like big boy actually does a good amount to the build up of the first verse. And to the ppl saying "well it doesn't play for the whole song!!!"
1. It doesn't always have to play to be good
2. It would be very bad if any monster on this island repeated too much
You've got a point!
He’s just a good boy full of soup. Super creative design and I love his gurgles.
he's creative it is because they are really realated to the game because monster is the right way to go now how ugly how scary it is a good drawing of a monster
its good to know theres other people who like X'rt
If they hate x'rt! That means it is really popular
Man they complement each other so well musically, it feels criminal that we can't have all 4 of them in the game.
Like really, Exclaim did such a good job with this composition/remix of the Ethereal Workshop song, and X'rt+Pentumbra only made it better.
I feel that Snarlequinn's design could work well as a Mythical now that there's an official shadow quad, maybe change the colors to separate it from it's "shadow" origins. Snarlequin's bio already says that he can freely travel across dimensions and islands so he could really be a "Caine" figure that comes from the outside and likes to mess with the workshop monsters knowing they can't get out.
Or an april fools seasonal
@@kuutti256we already have Aprils Fool seasonal, well, sort of
@@LoarvicLoarvicfhool is fanmade
So is this now going to be the noun for that kind of being? A "Caine figure"? Can't say I don't like it, though
Caine...is that a Digital Circus reference
The unreleased track part is INSANE it just sounds so heavenly in my opinion,i really wish that was in the game.
Congrats on 100k and the verification! You deserve it. 👏 🎉❤
Also i love how you included Cuddaloft into the song without showing them on screen.
Glad to see you aren't just forsaking your monsters that had their elements fulfilled. Hope to see the final song mixed with your monsters when that's out
Yeiyei > X’rt
Snarlquinn < Pentumbra
Both are great tho
I kind of disagree on your opinion about the shadow one
snarlquinn better pentumbra wont take a break
Imo X'rt is better than YieYie
X'rt is love, X'rt is life
@@FadeTheStupidCat oh you better be kidding me
@@thehampterguy1104 No, my actual opinion
Once again, I will say that Snarlequinn needed to play more
I’m not saying give it a new track, just use track 1 on BOTH Yoreek verses
am i the only one that thinks snarlequinn compliments x'rt EXTREMELY well? like it makes him sound so good.
Fr, it would be awesome to be able to have all 4 of them in the song
Holy crap, just by adding your monsters to the mix you literally fixed the entire problem I had with the song thank you I have breathed a new
I think the reason is due to the island not being finished later when all get added it might sound better thats why
@@Thecyanpult I hope that's the case, maybe its just me being extremely picky. I get that the theme for this island is a WIP made by the Ethereal Colossal and I like it, its creative. But we only have one or two more waves left for this island (not counting if we get a quint or seasonal or mythical), it just sounds like the monsters are singing over each other trying to outshine the other to me. It literally needs that one monster to tie all of the parts together. Sorry for the mini rant XD
@@datechna3 makes sense
Snarlequinn and pentumbra go so good together!
Hearing the way you mix pentumbra into the already majestic ending is so great
Pentumbra really completed the final verse here
Dude hearing them all together is so cool!!!
I like X'rt in a non ironic way first of all its official and I can experience it in game, but also this monster actually looks and sound like a monster. It also helps out the atmosphere in song which I really love
I feel the main take away for this is community, please don't hype up the wave so much that it wont reach your super duper high expectations like I get it hype it up bit but don't hype it up soo much that it won't ever reach your expectations.😃
Oh hey! The fanmade Poison Quad's here! I'm hoping next update actually adds a string instrument, and maybe Whail's secret verse to go with all the other monsters that only play once.
Edit: OH! Not finished watching the video, but Penumbra mimicking Whail's verse might be cool for the ending
Моя первая мысль когда я увидел официальное обновление. Боже мой, а ведь неофициальные лучше! Но вместе они просто шикарны идеально восхитительны
Согласен. Тоже зашел в игру и стало обидно, что среди всех классных неофициальных монстров разработчики решили сделать своих, тем самым просто сделали хуже песню своим X'rt.
@@PivozavrAyeeeX’rt didn’t ruin the song but instead advanced on it and added variety
@@user-lr7pj3pi2z 👍
AHHHHH I REALLY WISH SNARLEQUINN COULD BE AN OFFICAL MONSTER AND NOT JUST FANMADEEEEEE! SNARLEQUINN IS MY FAV FANMADE MONSTER!
The unreleased track sound part is just.. ✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️
I agree 🥹
This is were it starts🥹
5:24
Srry this one 5:02
2:42 Nova’s Ethereal Workshop
Каламбур НОВЫя эфирная мастерская (надеюсь оно правильно переведётся)
Congratulations on reaching 100k!!!
GORGEOUS SOUND! I was waiting for this comparison video! So glad you made it for us :) I honestly think I prefer your fanmade monsters, but of the two new ones Pentumbra has grown on me and does so much for the song. I'm so happy to hear a version where I don't have to choose one set or the other XD I think this is my new favorite version of the workshop!
Yea we can all agree that Ethereal Workshop needed a string instrumental monster.
OMG Congrats on 100k!!! And i really love the new intro :D
Snarlequinn and pentumbra really look alike, especially the color scheme
Got the colours and 4 legs right
And glowy appendage(s) on the head
Both the officials and your fanmade ones are dope as heck.
BREAKCORE NOVA INTRO GOES HARD 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥
It's just Amen break bro
5:41 the pentumbra sound was so perfect here ❤
3:23
3:51
2:56 This is a duet
BRO THE UNRELEASED PART ALMOST MADE ME VRY WTF YOU ARE TOO GOOD ;-;
0:06 love this intro
0:00 important
0:22 YieYie + X'rt
1:37 snarlequin + pentumbra
2:42 full song
4:58 unrealeased track
I love x,rt's design but i like yieyie's siund more! (but snarlequin always will be my fav)
Pou’s game died a long time ago. Now he’s in a different game and loved to sing now. Now he’s just a shadow for pentrumba! His new buddy!
It literally even sounds like him
YieYie and X'rt:🦥🤝⚱️
Snarlequinn and Pentumbra: 🃏🤝🕷
Why you put a sloth
@@Azio666 there is no YieYie
That last part got me thinking “maybe the workshop was the friends we made along the way”
thanks nova for this now i can listen to this beauty
Ok but the unreleased track with Yie Yie goes hard, and I love that X'rt makes more sounds.
Your prediction of the shadow quad is amazing but I love the official one more the fact it use it shadow to make is sound is so cool it now my favorite monster even but hey at least you got the spider theme for it design
I’m definitely in the boat that thinks YieYie over X’rt, YieYie makes the song sound so majestic with auglur in its verses while X’rt…um…burp transition?…I guess?
2:22 scary horror game be like
I like it how you just kept the poison quad here because the song just sounds 🔥
I forgot its name:/
And also I had a idea for the crystal quad idk if you made one but my idea is
Crystotaur
(Minotaur crystal)
So the strong arms would bel covered in an armor of crystals, crystal horns, and the sound… something like Torrt
I think YieYie is WAY better than X’rt. Also love the new into music!!
I have an idea for a video, when you release the complete sound of the island you could combine the complete sound with all your fanmade songs from this island.
These both look so good. Love them!
Who
Isn't it strange we expected an eldritch abomination and we got a spider axolotl with a shadow with a face that has an insane lore drop
by the way I would love Pentumbra's 1st track with whaiil's unreleased track
3:04 Wave 4 vs Fanmade Wave 4
They all sound good ngl
I love X'rt's design,the sound isnt that much but to be honest, it kinda adds to the Song.
I really like X’rts design, the sound also adds a nice flow
I like the idea behind X'rt, it's a silly personification of how we, or titans and collosals in this case, sometimes briefly forget their train of thought
Lets be honest, most of the fanmade problem is that they continue the song, they dont add anything new to the song or at least smth that its not the same melody as the song and a different voice/instrument, so thats why I choose Pentumbra "D
They should lowkey hire you on the team you have mad talent dude
Snarlequinn: You. . . YOU Think This Is Official. Don't You?
OOOH STRING INSTRUMENTSSSSS
I LOVE YIEYIE!
WE need string instruments in etherealworkshop.
I'm NOT kidding.
3:24 I hear something special
Cuddaloft
@@MsmProLovesDrummidaryyou're right
5:27 its too perfect❤❤❤
The strings make me goosebumps, why would I ever want a burp over the most beautiful sound ever conceived by man.
Because burp funny
That new intro 👌👌👌
Also your monsters were way better. TBH we jinda need a string instrument.
I hope we get something like YieYie for the last triple in Wave 5! I absolutely love your designs and composing!
Dispite how much i want a jester monster i do like spider
Hyehehe?
@@threstheknucklord hush he doesn't count in this context
@@Random_flasque_on_the_internet OH, ethereal jester?
@@threstheknucklord yea
Snarlequinn kinda looks like a spider.
These are one of the few fanmade tracks that i can really get behind, as they're not just existing melodies in different soundfonts like the majority of them.
Its a bit ironic that Pentumbra does exactly that, but also in a very experimental and completely unexpected way to make up for it
I will definitely get hate but I actually prefer X’rt over YieYie. Pentumbra is WAY better than Nova’s quad. No hate :)
Ik right X’rt has that goofy charm i like all of them ngl
Bruh 💀
you sure will, imagine wanting attention this bad
@@whitetigerwhite3788 it just an opinion no one is begging for attention
Ikr he is really good!
Very nice fan work, really well done and even more so at the end.
Death battle
4:56 is just FIRE🔥🔥🔥
CONGRATS ON 100K NOVA!!!
I really liked how phantumbra has its shadow singing out of all things, also it’s just a cute design to me, but I would prefer anything over x’rt.
I like x'rt
Whichever quad comes next needs to be a string instrument, I could see the mech crystal poison triple being a string instrument or the poison quad like you've predicted. I'm very curious what the next quad will be, I wonder if they'll switch it up and release poison early instead of crystal due to the relation to earth island and warm summer heat.
CONGRATS ON 100K
Honestly, I don't want to take any side and I prefer to think that both the fanmade and the original sound good and even more so when they sound together in a beautiful harmony. In short: I take the position that I love how the fanmade and the original sound together.
10/10
YieYie: Beautiful sound with clear soul and heart being put into the song
X’rt: *b u r p*
HAPPY 100K SUBSCRIBED!!!!! 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Shadow quad fanmade vs original
Fanmade: creepy wonderful instrumental fits with the design overall great
Original: literally mimic but 10x better creepy a bit and took shadow quad to a whole different level than I was expecting overall amazing
i think pentumbra was just a bit better than snarlequinn just bcuz i really wanted mor vocals lol
i like the workshop feal that xrt adds and i like his desine being a couldrin in a dragon head like shape but yie yie string adds alot too and its desine is good tobut . yie yie is prob better but snarlequinn and pentumbra is a tie form me i love the creappy feal from snarequinn and the sound is creappy to but i like how silly pentumbra is it kinda looks like i has a brainfart and forgets to trun on the shadow think so cus of that it gets scared .i sayd like also the pentumbra desine is creppy to its based on a daddy long legs and an axolotl and one of those lamps that makes a star light on the ground or smt , i think the desine is based of that . i like that the snarlequinn is a jester and that its desine is creappy. sorry for bad english and or incorect info thing.
Nova's fanmade Wave 4 >>> offical
I genuinely love this. Just the pure creativity of both official and fanmade just brought a smile to my face
I wish Yieyie was the real X'rt😞😞
Hi
Too true
How the hell do you manage to make them so realistic, THATS ILLEGAL!
Honestly yours were better
True
𝑰 𝒄𝒐𝒖𝒍𝒅 𝒏𝒐𝒕 𝒂𝒈𝒓𝒆𝒆 𝒍𝒆𝒔𝒔
Несовсем
I like offbrand kinito pet ngl
Were?
I actually like Snarlequinn more than official one, even though Pentumbra is super cool. This guy adds so much to the vibe, especially in their duet with X'rt (2:56)
5:27 the middle of the song btw
Both Shadow quads, both official and unofficial are just so amazing, pentumbra is my favorite quad, and if snarlequinn released instead it would be my favorite, these monsters are just that peak (sorry if this is phrased weird)
Haan yaar, 4RA community amazing hai. Sab tips share karte hain aur teams ko cheer karte hain. Enjoying every moment
4:59 Wow, what kind of music went
This made me cry, I love this island so much and people's remixes, like yours! 💖❤🔥
I love the version at the end with the official wave 4s and the predictions all playing at the same time
Honestly, when wave 5 comes, I would want Snarlequinn and YieYie as the Wave 5 monsters in my personal opinion, as they with make X'rt and Pentumbra sound better in the song.
*song*
@@chellea1442 you know you can just edit your comment and fix the typo, right?