Miniware Compact, Precision PowerSupply II MDP-XP Review

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 фев 2025

Комментарии • 65

  • @hinokikuaimu
    @hinokikuaimu Год назад +1

    @Schematix: Hybrid (Switching/Linear) bench PSUs exist for quite some time, they are also known as "mixed mode" PSUs. British (GB) made EX-R Series from AimTTi are just this. Some forum posts can also be found (ex from TI,...).

  • @SeanHodgins
    @SeanHodgins 3 года назад +6

    Wow cool, this would be a great rack mount power supply system.

  • @peteb2
    @peteb2 3 года назад +2

    Good to see you again fellow Kiwi & thanks for reducing my boredom in a L4 Lockdown...

    • @Schematix
      @Schematix  3 года назад +1

      Glad it passed some time. Hopefully we'll be back to 'normal' soon ;)

  • @BikerCaf
    @BikerCaf 3 года назад +7

    Nice regulator, pricey though !
    Linear regulators have been used to clean the outputs of switch mode regulators for years, they do SMD chips with both built-in for just this purpose too as well DIY. Not all linear regulators are suitable for the purpose though, it has to respond very quickly to smooth out spikey HF switch mode noise.

  • @tanishqbhaiji103
    @tanishqbhaiji103 3 года назад +2

    Switching PSUs don’t necessarily have high output ripple but they are slower in transient response compared to linear ones and most PSUs reach low to mid 80% efficiency figures when drawing a significant portion of the rated power, the poly-phase switching regulator such as the ones used to provide power on modern X86 processors like on the various X570 and Z590 motherboards are quite impressive in every regard.

  • @flexairz
    @flexairz 3 года назад +1

    Great review, awesome product.
    Just bought one too!

  • @ianhouston1144
    @ianhouston1144 3 года назад +3

    Quite an impressive little unit. Could you share more info regarding the resistive load tester you used in the video?

  • @tanishqbhaiji103
    @tanishqbhaiji103 3 года назад +1

    Amazing feat by Miniware and E-Design.

  • @fvckyoutubescensorshipandt2718
    @fvckyoutubescensorshipandt2718 3 года назад +2

    Handy if you don't need a huge amount of power I guess (I tend to need as much as I can get, typical power souce is a 120v 32s lipo battery that can do 120A continuous/300A for a few seconds into a converter that puts out 12-150V and 10-150A current limit). For smaller things I just use 2x 0-30v 10A supplies in series or a 0-500V 30A one I built that runs on 240V 60A mains.

  • @tanishqbhaiji103
    @tanishqbhaiji103 3 года назад +1

    The switching part must be in the multiple 100s of KHz range as the electrolytic bulk caps look not that high performance and it must be the high Capacitance MLCCs for the regulation. I love those tiny MLCCs, they are quite performant specially considering the price and form factor. Would have loved to see some Moulded Aluminium polymers but this is very good.

  • @andymouse
    @andymouse 3 года назад

    Great review and great product, I'm am seriously thinking of getting this and if I do I will use your link .....cheers.

  • @smartypants5036
    @smartypants5036 3 года назад +1

    Great review. I am sold. I want one.

  • @KernsJW
    @KernsJW 3 года назад +3

    The supply without screen is 144, thats not too bad, but unless you need the small size you can find cheaper options. I do like the form factor though

    • @TylrVncnt
      @TylrVncnt 3 года назад

      Won’t find cheaper options with that level of ripple, there’s nothing like it in that size. You can absolutely find cheaper/as powerful PS’s but nothing out there that can beat those specs (atm)

  • @CaptainChrisMoore
    @CaptainChrisMoore 3 года назад +3

    Great. Another gadget I must buy. Ya know my wife is going to slap me and you for this when she finds out hahaha.

  • @tanishqbhaiji103
    @tanishqbhaiji103 3 года назад +1

    Does this use a ultra low drop out linear regulator with a tracking switching unit? I have wondered about this design for sometime and I got the answer after watching the whole video, thank you.

  • @sckirschstein
    @sckirschstein 8 месяцев назад

    Thanks for the interesting review.
    I'm wondering if I can stack two PS modules to be centrally commanded by the screen controller, as a differential power supply (common negative) and/or a series arrangement, both for versatile electronic breadboard projects and teaching.

  • @TheBadFred
    @TheBadFred 3 года назад +2

    What I don't understand why use an antiquated standard like QC3.0 instead of PD3.0 That can deliver 100W? I probably should wait for a revision with a PD chip inside. BTW I like the video, bro.

    • @Baztarp
      @Baztarp 3 года назад

      QC 3.0 is simple to implement. PD3.0 isn't, it might very well require another (or a more expensive and/or supply limited) microcontroller or a dedicated interface chip.

  • @givenfirstnamefamilyfirstn3935
    @givenfirstnamefamilyfirstn3935 3 года назад +1

    Nice apart from the price. Will your own power supply kit be back in stock again?

  • @Bennyboy-dog
    @Bennyboy-dog 3 года назад +2

    Yes, that is clever. The linear side only ever drops 0.5V so at max o/p of of 5A, there is a mere 2.5W loss as heat. Thats around 2% contribution to the overall loss of the system.
    The obvious question is can you design something using this principle to add to any switching regulator? Since the voltage drop will always be 0.5V this shouldn't be too hard?

    • @thenimbo2
      @thenimbo2 2 года назад

      Yes. This is a very common technique in any low noise high power design.

  • @ChrisHalden007
    @ChrisHalden007 3 года назад

    Great video. Thanks

  • @pajopa1able
    @pajopa1able 3 года назад

    Hi,
    Where I can buy compatible adapters for Technics SL-PD9/SL-PD7A & Technics SJ-HDA710?
    Please advise.
    Thanj you.

  • @tanishqbhaiji103
    @tanishqbhaiji103 3 года назад +1

    They has vRMS in the specs not vPP.

  • @electronic7979
    @electronic7979 3 года назад +1

    Nice product

  • @HMProjects
    @HMProjects 3 года назад +1

    Great video as always. The tipe of power supply that shares both worlds switching and linear is not something new, I have a Peaktech 6225 that shares both worlds. Another thing, high capacitance on the output is not always a good thing, if this power supply has a slow feedback loop it can ruin your day.

  • @cryptoscalpers9603
    @cryptoscalpers9603 3 года назад +1

    be good if you told us how practical it is to use it and how much time it would last....depending on draw.

    • @fvckyoutubescensorshipandt2718
      @fvckyoutubescensorshipandt2718 3 года назад +1

      given how small it is typcal use would be to run an Arduino or power some other circuit you built on a breadboard, same as the common 0-30v 0-5A supplies just about everywhere, it's just smaller and doesn't need a power outlet (handy if you need to be DC isolated from mains and don't have an isolation transformer on hand).

  • @moya9450
    @moya9450 3 года назад +3

    Oh god the price is insane. 250 USD for this? Although It is not actually power supply, it is a regulator. The PowerBank and That DC laptop charger are Power Supply.
    BTW if this device has high precision then it's worth it.

    • @flexairz
      @flexairz 3 года назад

      By your reasoning the DC laptop charger is not even the power supply as it gets its power from a wall socket. The power bank, yes.

    • @moya9450
      @moya9450 3 года назад

      @@flexairz By this logic Power supply doesn't exist. All real power supplies take AC voltage and give regulated DC voltage at output. All of them are like this. But the device that converts DC to DC is literally regulator or DC DC converter

    • @TylrVncnt
      @TylrVncnt 3 года назад

      Ive bought the P905 units on AliExpress (wait for sales) for ~$90 per... I have 5 of em

  • @besotoxicomusic
    @besotoxicomusic 3 года назад +1

    Was this purchased or sent free for review?

    • @Schematix
      @Schematix  3 года назад +2

      I hear your concerns. And I would like to assure you, my oscilloscope was not paid-off by miniware. I only use impartial testing equipment

  • @BoB4jjjjs
    @BoB4jjjjs 3 года назад +1

    Nice idea if they are reliable. :-)

  • @ancienttraveller9297
    @ancienttraveller9297 3 года назад

    Excellent 👌

  • @catalinalb1722
    @catalinalb1722 2 года назад

    Only if they could do logging.... Would have to measure charging over time....

  • @davelordy
    @davelordy 2 года назад

    What is the point of plugging a PSU into this device so that you can power something . . . . why not simply plug a PSU into the end device (bypassing the Miniware) ??

  • @navidrs
    @navidrs 3 года назад

    Your Riden uses a switching power supply as input power source so your compare is not fair

    • @flexairz
      @flexairz 3 года назад

      The Miniware too.. watch the video

    • @navidrs
      @navidrs 3 года назад

      @@flexairz no he uses LiPo battery as input power supply for miniware.
      The riden has a 60v switching power supply inside

  • @ab_ab_c
    @ab_ab_c 3 года назад +2

    Nice gadget---but 132$??
    Better to buy a cheap power supply & put the output through a linear regular. :)
    Thanks for sharing!

    • @jimmyb1451
      @jimmyb1451 3 года назад +1

      Is that all they're charging?
      That's cheap.
      It's the interface that ruins it for me.

    • @ab_ab_c
      @ab_ab_c 3 года назад

      @@jimmyb1451 Haha.. I like the interface--but the cost is way too much, imo for a 150W regulated power supply.

    • @jimmyb1451
      @jimmyb1451 3 года назад +1

      @@ab_ab_c I hear ya, there are far cheaper ones. Not with 4mV ripple though.
      But yeah. It's actually given me a few ideas for the PSU I'm designing.

    • @ab_ab_c
      @ab_ab_c 3 года назад

      @@jimmyb1451 That's why I suggested in my first post to add a linear regulator after the main voltage regulation--to eliminate the ripple just as they did with the 132 $ unit.

    • @TylrVncnt
      @TylrVncnt 3 года назад

      I really doubt its the linear regulator alone that gives those specs of ripple

  • @razpootis5802
    @razpootis5802 3 года назад

    Oh it's so cute :3

  • @jhoanrivero7885
    @jhoanrivero7885 3 года назад

    jajajjaajjjajjajajjjaa i like the neardental, hi from Venezuela

  • @ПростоПарень-е1н
    @ПростоПарень-е1н 3 года назад

    держи может пригодится.
    кто-то ламает двигателя электрические, а кто-то делает пользу для всех и себя.
    Видео ответ на вопрос подписчика. @

  • @Jibs-HappyDesigns-990
    @Jibs-HappyDesigns-990 3 года назад

    nice!🍟🍓🍓🦄

  • @kalmdwn7711
    @kalmdwn7711 2 года назад

    bush shirt

  • @VladekR
    @VladekR 3 года назад

    Good things come with price, unfortunately 😪

  • @thewondersofscience9740
    @thewondersofscience9740 3 года назад

    I am third, great video

  • @krisguntner4805
    @krisguntner4805 3 года назад

    Apparently I'm first. :P