Are There 26 Versions of The Qur'an? || Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan || AMAU
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
- Sign up at www.amauathome... to stay up to date with all of our courses.
The Preserved Book is a short course brought to you by Al Madrasatu Al Umariyyah. Amidst the many false doubts that are thrown around about the religion of Islam, the preservation of The Qur’an is always a favourite for the non-Muslim orientalists. Here at Al Madrasatu Al Umariyyah, we’ve taken the time out to record a detailed course that tackles this topic head on. Join us on this journey as we explore exactly how our noble Book has been preserved word for word, letter by letter. Bring your pen and paper and get ready to defend the religion of Islam!
You can also find us on:
Instagram: / amauofficial
RUclips: / almadrasatualumariyyah
Twitter: / amau2525
BarakAllahu feekum.
#AMAU #QuranPreservation #AbdulrahmanHassan
🔰Lesson 20: Are there 26 versions of Qur'an?(lesson summary with timestamps)
📋0:20- Let's understand their claim first. They claim that the variations in the recitation is because of Uthman's(may Allah be pleased with him) mushafs
📋1:55- Our response is that there were differences because our beloved prophet(sallallahu 'alaihi wa sallam) recited as well as it was revealed in that ways not because of the Masahif
🎯Why didn't Uthman(may Allah be pleased with him) write the dots?(3:30)
📋 Ustadh will inshallah show the truth in six ways.
📃 First response - 4:10(differences of recitation was before the mushaf)
📃 Second response - 5:05(Uthman [may Allah be pleased with him] sent a reciter with every mushaf)
📃 Third response - 6:20(if their claim is true then their is no need of a chain going back to prophet [sallallahu 'alaihi wa sallam])
📃 Fourth response - 7:38(a historical event that rejected the recitations that didn't have any authentic chain let alone Mutawaatir)
📃 Fifth response - 8:40(if the recitations are based upon writing then all should recite in the same way, but that's not the case)
9:40- First example
12:50- Second example
📃 Sixth response - 16:38(if we say that the difference s are because of the mushafs then we are going against the clear cut verses where Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala tells us that Qur'an is the speech of Him, May He be glorified. And it is disbelief to believe that Qur'an has human things in it)
19:00- Conclusion
ruclips.net/video/2042GZ_P7Uk/видео.html
Jazak Allahu Khaira
Why didn't Uthman(may Allah be pleased with him) write the dots?(3:30) bc they were invented later to make sense of the words
SubhhanAllah Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan is the only person in the world addressing these issues right now! MashaAllah JazakAllahkheir!
Assalamu alaikum Ustadh Abdul-Rahman. May Allah bless you and increase you in knowledge and reward you for expelling the doubts bi idhni Allah. Very clarifying.
variants existed even before Utham RA that is why Uthman had the Quran written in qurayshi and had everything else burned there was too much confusion.
Barak Allah Feekum. Our kids need to hear this
Extremely beneficial lecture.BarakAllah feekum. JazakAllahkhair
*Qur'an preservation has never been based on manuscripts/scrolls. Even if ALL vulgates happen to disappear right now, Qur'an won't fade away. As simple as that*
shaykh, this is too simplified, this talk requires the presentation of supporting evidence to corroborate what you are saying. Why ? because the orientalist are using our sources to argue against the idea of quran preservation. we have to rise the same level in presentation of primary sources and answering their doubts about these sources.
You can never please them.
*And never will the Jews or the Christians approve of you until you follow their religion. Say, "Indeed, the guidance of Allah is the [only] guidance." If you were to follow their desires after what has come to you of knowledge, you would have against Allah no protector or helper."- Surah al-Baqarah, 2/120*
Well he tried his best ,and we can't guide anyone based on more or less evidences ,Its Allah Who Guides The Hearts , but it is better for us to know these things so we dont fall in debts ourselves and we'll have reply if someone asks or raises the question.
JazakALLAH khairun Sheikh
Q :
1. How do you confirm what the word revealed to the prophet since he couldnt read nor write is "exactly" the word recalled by prophet to his companion writer?
2. Noone witnessed that the prophet met Jibril in that cave. How then do you confirm the prophet's statement is true? based on faith?
The Majority of Muslims today read and memorize the 1924 Egyptian Edition Hafs Quran (Muhammad Ali Dynasty Albanians in Egypt) This specific edition is all messianic science. It was initiated by the Albanian/Egyptian King Ahmad Fuad.
Where does the Shaykh get his evidences from? It would really help.
Jazaak Allaahu khayran.
He is quoting and referencing as he goes along
He is even mentioning books/authors etc
As-salaamu 'alaykum,
Which Qaari/Recitor of one of The Masaahif of 'Uthmaan's (may Allaah ﷻ be pleased with him) Qur'aan are we reciting from today?
From Makkah, Madeenah, Kufa, Basra or Ash Shaam?
Salaam alaykum,
Depends on where you are in the world tbh
The most popular is that of the Imam of Kufa, Imam Aasim and we recite in the riwayah of his student Imam Hafs.
So the common Qira'ah is Aasim
And the riwayah is known as Hafs
For reference, this is how Sheikh Sudais recites quran
Hope that answers your question
All of them
جزاك الله
Subhanallah
They say theres 32 now🙄 These people
Baraku Allahu fikum
"The only guidance is Allah" ...... nope. he says the the sun revolves around the earth! come on guys, u need to reform!
A good physical proof is the sana palimpsest where we can see what was erased and can see that there were variants even before the time of Usman RA like there is a place where (النار) (fire) is used while in masahif Usman RA it is (الجهيم) (hell fire) and some others which are synonym they are the only changes rest the Quran is same. Now if you think why in the world would Uthman RA change it if it was one Qiraat?, this proving us that Uthman RA was honest in his work and the variants existed even before Utham RA
oc variants existed even before Utham RA that is why Uthman had the Quran written in qurayshi and had everything else burned there was too much confusion.
Andy Miller i know that Uthman RA burnt other ahruf. i was telling the people say that Uthman Ra changed Quran (I seek refuge in Allah SWT), when we look at sana manuscript the differences are the synonym word so it clearly means that there was ahruf before Uthman Ra and all what Uthman ra did was that he compiled Quran in one harf.
@@thepoorsultan5112 which brings us to the question who was Uthman to decide which harf was the best and why were the other ahruf descarded useless or unwanted ?
When Ibn Umar-son of the second Muslim caliph-heard people declaring that they knew the entire Qur’an, he said to them: “Let none of you say, ‘I have learned the whole of the Koran,’ for how does he know what the whole of it is, when much of it has disappeared? Let him rather say, ‘I have learned what is extant thereof.’”ix
One of Muhammad’s companions, Abu Musa, supported this claim when he said that the early Muslims forgot two surahs (chapters) due to laziness:
Andy Miller Uthman RA was caliph of the time, and the prophet PBUH himself has said that from whichever harf you read Quran it is the same. Probably i think you don’t know about history people were fighting because they were arguing whose recitation is best and even till today they would fight because of it if Uthman RA didn’t make it in 1 harf. Ibn Umar RA says of abrogated verses of Quran. And Musa al ashaari is also talking about the same subject in his hadith he says that surah ahzab was lengthy like surah baqarah and i was caused to forget it and the only verse i remember is (If the son of adam had a valley of Gold...). Which Allah SWT himself has approved that we can cause someone to forget verses, and there is a hadith also where 3 companions try to recite a surah but they freeze after in the name of Allah SWT the most beneficial the most Merciful, they came and told the prophet PBUH about it and the prophet PBUH said it was abrogated yesterday. Now an intersecting thing about this is 15 companions narrate but they only know this verse of it, no context of surah mo other verses nothing 15 companions in different places, narrate and only remember this verse of it (If the son of adam had a valley of Gold...) no other verse is narrated or any other context.
@@thepoorsultan5112 Ibn Masud went so far as to call the final edition of the Qur’an a deception! He said, “The people have been guilty of deceit in the reading of the Qur’an. I like it better to read according to the recitation of him [ Muhammad] whom I love more than that of Zayd Ibn Thabit.”
Should Muslims submit to this “deceit”? Ibn Masud advised Muslims to reject Zaid’s Qur’an and to keep their own versions-even to hide them so that they wouldn’t be confiscated by the government! He said:
"O you Muslim people! Avoid copying the Mushaf and recitation of this man. By Allah! When I accepted Islam he was but in the loins of a disbelieving man”-meaning Zaid bin Thabit-and it was regarding this that Abdullah bin Mas’ud said: “O people of Al-Iraq! Keep the Musahif that are with you, and conceal them.”
Ibn Ka’b believed that Zaid’s Qur’an was missing two chapters! Later Muslims were therefore forced to reject some of Ibn Ka’b’s recitation:
Umar said, “Ubayy was the best of us in the recitation , yet we leave some of what he recites.” Ubayy says, “I have taken it from the mouth of Allah’s Messenger and will not leave it for anything whatever
If Muslims say that the Qur’an we have today has been perfectly preserved, they must say that Muhammad was horrible at choosing scholars, since he selected men who disagreed . If, on the other hand, Muslims say that their prophet would know whom to pick when it comes to Islam’s holiest book, they must conclude that the Qur’an we have today is flawed!
((إن هذا الا قول البشر سأصليه سقر))
not وما هو بقول البشر
Let them *bring those 26 pseudo "versions"* of the Qur'an. *_Compare the Chapters order & the verse/word order_* Result ? it is the exact same [order]. What about transcription differences? Yes, they exist as in any language. *_neighbor vs neighbour_* ..etc *but they occur on the same page in the same line* .
Dont get what you saying
@@IM-yn8fz *The Qur'an writen copies all have the same Chapter/verse and word order*.
Even in the 26 "versions" he is blabbering about, the order is maintained [Sourate/verse and word order] They can NOT even lie about this characteristic
What the orientalists disregard is the muttawatir oral transmission of the Qiraat and Quran. If they understood the efforts early and to this day it is to memorise the Quran they wouldn’t make this claim. Abu DharDhar dedicated every Fajr to teaching people Quran and among his class was over 1600 daily.
@@vbandz2645 Qur'an preservation has never been based on manuscripts/scrolls. Even if ALL vulgates happen to disappear right now, Qur'an won't fade way. As simple as that
It is claimed is preserved no change in words and letters so that is why it can be memorised
i think they got 37 different Arabic quran`s now...
Lol no
10 Qiraat 20 student 7 aurof
Okaay!
Muslims scholars admits there are plenty holes in the standard narrative of Quran. 😂😂
We don't want your fake rewards!
the current version of the quran is the cairo edition of 1929. ancient qurans discovered where different
It’s actually just difference in spelling