im so fed up with people criticizing louis. stop. he's a judge for a reason. he can give his honest opinion. he can say no. and HE IS NOT A ĶID. he god this god damn job because he fits in or otherwise he wouldn't be there.
Nataly Ab ... i’m sick of people defending him when people say that don’t agree with him. Like a lot of people don’t agree with ayda and that fine but when it comes to Louis everyone’s saying lay off him.
Yeah, i think u re right, and i'm a big fan of louis so... he has his opinion, and even if i would not be a his fan, i would agree with his choice, not really my type of performance
he's precious, such heart: i 'thanks god' for his parents, they raised him well! 👍👍 i like his voice and his personality..thinking he needs only some professional support and guidance.. lucky for him, he's in the right place!..bravo!! 👏👏
I've seen him perform in Bat Out of Hell the Musical and in the program book is an impressive list of shows he preformed in. I think nervousness got to him because he can actually sing and move on a stage, all be it a musical stage. I think with some work he can get far
its all set up lol even down to when some people sing one or two songs, for instance there was this audition in particular that was totally obvious. Its decided already whether they are going to let a person sing just one song and cut them off or if they sing one then recover it with a second song choice. As for the microphones in the audience yes audience reactions set up beforehand.
That's called Bad Habits from singing in pubs & other places to wake up the crowd. Those habits need to go when you're auditioning on a show of this magnitude! Simon hates all that as well. However, In 2009 a Rocker by the name of: "Jamie Afro-Archer." did the same thing with holding the mic to the audience. He was singing "SEX ON FIRE!" And excellent audition and Simon picked him to go through on to the live shows. But, the guy in this videos audition did the same thing has Jamie Archer did in 2009 and it didn't work for him at all. I think it's the way a contestant represent themselves as a performer!
I think he was nervous! Giovanni I think you can sing! And it would be nice to hear you sing something from Steven Tyler. Your voice has a similar style in sound and range. I hope to see more of your performances! Kudos
“And I don’t want the world to see me because I don’t think that they’d understand, when everything’s meant to be broken I just want you to know who I am “ ❤️❤️❤️
Why does it all looks like it's scripted?? "Ok. Sing for me a bit.... Yeah nice voice.... Now for your audition do a bad song, perform your worst.... Simon will stop you.... Give you another chance which will make him the good guy.... THEN you sing a song that'll shock the audience.... BOOM! You're selected"
Nah, They chose the song they think would get the audience on their side. Sometimes they gamble wrong. He had a vision of the Crowd rocking out with him and it tanked.
Gio is currently playing Ledoux in Bat Out Of Hell in the Westend and has a band called Deviance that is pretty much heavy metal. I love him but his song choice was NOT good for getting to move forward on X Factor. His fan base will love it but it did not show his vocals and that's what he needs to do. His voice is wonderful and he has to show that. He is also one of the kindest most gracious and humble of people. So, he DID move on and I'm glad, but he needs to be careful with his song choices. I don't think he can use anything from Bat Out of Hell and that's too bad because when he sings Objects In The Rear View Mirror, it's fabulous. I doubt he'll win but he's be capable with the right songs. Lastly, yes, I think when Simon tells them to sing something else, it's very contrived. He was doing that on American's Got Talent this year. I'm done with most of these shows, they've been going on for years and frankly, and just speaking for myself, I'm getting really tired of them. Obviously they have decent ratings and sell advertising so I'm "odd man out", but that's what I'm feeling at this point. I head Gio was going to be on and looked for his clip. Knowing what I know about him and having heard him sing before, this was disappointing.
Well he got a chance. that's nice. It must be so hard to be on stage, but this competition is no joke. Or you make it or you are out, simple as that !! They gave him a chance. Louis is a hard one but quite objective I must admit :-)
after watching these shows kinda too much! I have a conclusion that is all fake and manipulative to just get more audience! one thing that make be vomiting is when someone uses his wife, kids or any emotional story or trauma happened in his life to get to be liked by playing the pitty! that is a complete super high level of hypocrisy, dishonest and fakery
I don't see why everyone is hating. He can sing (lower notes are shaky though but the belting is great), he is not bad looking and he is different. The problem is his act feels dated.
This guy has the looks and got the rock and roll voice but needs guidance for him to succeed in this business, oh I love that hear it’s dame great hear
He's got talent, but is putting/pushing his ego out there before anything else with his 1st act...2nd song WAY more sincere and was great, I do like his talent as a singer..
6:26 Some times it makes me wonder if xfactor is really about talent as they don't recognize rock and roll as music that really bothers me 6:266:26 Louis Tomlinson Giovanni was great
There´s something about him. But, yeah, he picked up many bad habits from musical theatre. He´s hiding something, his inner truth. If he can be brave enough to let it out, he could be amazing.
Did not know he was part of a successful boy band, was unduly harsh. But I still say that older music,does require, a sense of being there. I see the way ,to be a little less hostile. I sometime assume rather than presume.
Adya is just scared of disagreeing with her husband, robby is fun but not a really good judge, Louis is just honest and sassy (maybe I’m biased tho), I hate Simon with my entire heart but he is kind of a genius in the music industry but he’s not doing well this season for me hahaha
Louis’ death stares are the funniest thing ever lmfaooo
Louis was so done as soon as he started singing 😂
"Thank you for listening".. wow. That was very humble. I enjoyed his performance first and second song.
Louis' face the whole time 😂
Louis’s is not judge material and he wasn’t going to win the competition as a solo artist when he auditioned!
wou seeing louis tomlinson as strict as a judge now
im so fed up with people criticizing louis. stop. he's a judge for a reason. he can give his honest opinion. he can say no. and HE IS NOT A ĶID. he god this god damn job because he fits in or otherwise he wouldn't be there.
Nataly Ab ... i’m sick of people defending him when people say that don’t agree with him. Like a lot of people don’t agree with ayda and that fine but when it comes to Louis everyone’s saying lay off him.
the thing im trying to prove id that he isnt stupid or lacks of knowledge in this as people make him to be. u get me?
Yeah, i think u re right, and i'm a big fan of louis so... he has his opinion, and even if i would not be a his fan, i would agree with his choice, not really my type of performance
Especially because they have to judge based on whether they could work with them.
He looks so young and old at the same time
Louis face 😂😂😂
I just really love Louis.. ❤❤❤❤❤
1:45 Louis face, omg, i love him so fucking much😍💚
he's precious, such heart: i 'thanks god' for his parents, they raised him well! 👍👍 i like his voice and his personality..thinking he needs only some professional support and guidance.. lucky for him, he's in the right place!..bravo!! 👏👏
He has been singing at the West End in Bat out of Hell for years, don't know how much guidance he needs but....
Louis surely listen and met so many talented artists so I think he know what he's doing..
he's just being real... respect that!
Louis in my opinion wasn’t judge material!
Louis is the toughest judge now, Aiyda just goes with her husbands flow,Simon is still Simon. lol
Idek why they putted Ayda as a judge. I wish Nicole could come back and replace her
@@pablomoncion3637 Honestly,i don't know why she is a judge cos she is too irrelevant for the show.
Gurashi Madoka She's afraid to disagree with her husband
@@doloresdavidson-george5495 afraid of what exactly?
@@carolineo6558 ikr
He doesn't really have a bad voice, but when he's not screaming he's not on tune.
LOL! As soon as he started singing, louis was just like, "oh good grief." You could see it on his face!
I've seen him perform in Bat Out of Hell the Musical and in the program book is an impressive list of shows he preformed in.
I think nervousness got to him because he can actually sing and move on a stage, all be it a musical stage. I think with some work he can get far
Same :(
Saw him as well in Bat out of Hell.
How many of you like Louis ? He is a cool guy
One of my favourite auditions, so far. Keep it up man. !
I love the panel
This year
He should sing some Daughtry!!
better choice, i think his voice is more theater, less rock, and i feel like he is fighting that.
Chris Hatch he’s gone now :(
Why put microphones on the audience? Just shows how cringeworthy it is that they set up audience reactions
its all set up lol even down to when some people sing one or two songs, for instance there was this audition in particular that was totally obvious. Its decided already whether they are going to let a person sing just one song and cut them off or if they sing one then recover it with a second song choice. As for the microphones in the audience yes audience reactions set up beforehand.
Because this kind of show is fake lols
Nessi 09 - you are right! The auditiones are scripted! This year is so worst! One became 3 chances!
That's called Bad Habits from singing in pubs & other places to wake up the crowd. Those habits need to go when you're auditioning on a show of this magnitude! Simon hates all that as well. However, In 2009 a Rocker by the name of: "Jamie Afro-Archer." did the same thing with holding the mic to the audience. He was singing "SEX ON FIRE!" And excellent audition and Simon picked him to go through on to the live shows. But, the guy in this videos audition did the same thing has Jamie Archer did in 2009 and it didn't work for him at all. I think it's the way a contestant represent themselves as a performer!
This guy makes me feel like superman. Love you
He actually has a good rock voice.
"Iris" is my most favourite song of all time :)
He was being a bit too try-hard, what with the hair flipping and all, but he does have a decent voice.
I think he was nervous! Giovanni I think you can sing! And it would be nice to hear you sing something from Steven Tyler. Your voice has a similar style in sound and range. I hope to see more of your performances! Kudos
Louis is a mood 😂😂😂
Rob's wink, though! :)
i actually like his voice :3
Robyn Williams is having so much fun..... 😋😋😋😋
I almost cry, rock needs to be more valued for don't lose it
I can't stop watching his second song 😍😍
“And I don’t want the world to see me because I don’t think that they’d understand,
when everything’s meant to be broken I just want you to know who I am “ ❤️❤️❤️
I LIKE HIS STYLE
The top half of his face is of a beautiful woman. :)
The bottom half is creepy af
@@thatoneawkwardgirlonsocial4535 awkwardddd!! 🙊
The forehead?
@@Beyondme7700 Top "half"! 🙄
😂😂😂😂
The no from the judge will make him a fighter😊
Something about his performance was just.... off, I mean WAYYY off.
Not that I could do any better...lol
Uh huh. Imagine him versing louis. I bet louis would win.
Why does it all looks like it's scripted??
"Ok. Sing for me a bit.... Yeah nice voice.... Now for your audition do a bad song, perform your worst.... Simon will stop you.... Give you another chance which will make him the good guy.... THEN you sing a song that'll shock the audience.... BOOM! You're selected"
Nah, They chose the song they think would get the audience on their side. Sometimes they gamble wrong. He had a vision of the Crowd rocking out with him and it tanked.
Because it is scripted
Jagyanseni Pruthal - You are right - it is scripted!
This has repeated too much now
@@beaceballos_ exactly!! Hence my irritation 💁💁
Gio is currently playing Ledoux in Bat Out Of Hell in the Westend and has a band called Deviance that is pretty much heavy metal. I love him but his song choice was NOT good for getting to move forward on X Factor. His fan base will love it but it did not show his vocals and that's what he needs to do. His voice is wonderful and he has to show that. He is also one of the kindest most gracious and humble of people. So, he DID move on and I'm glad, but he needs to be careful with his song choices. I don't think he can use anything from Bat Out of Hell and that's too bad because when he sings Objects In The Rear View Mirror, it's fabulous. I doubt he'll win but he's be capable with the right songs. Lastly, yes, I think when Simon tells them to sing something else, it's very contrived. He was doing that on American's Got Talent this year. I'm done with most of these shows, they've been going on for years and frankly, and just speaking for myself, I'm getting really tired of them. Obviously they have decent ratings and sell advertising so I'm "odd man out", but that's what I'm feeling at this point. I head Gio was going to be on and looked for his clip. Knowing what I know about him and having heard him sing before, this was disappointing.
He is so cool,like him
LOUIS AJAKAKKSAK he never changed his facial expression
He looks like cole from coleandsav
thought you were going to saw cole from coleslaw LOL
No he kinda looks like 2015 Harry styles coz of that fricking hair!
no tf he does not
Any Bat out of Hell fans here ???
michi me!
Amazing singer
He puts too much effort and stress on his vocals to just sing flat .
I thought he sounded good the second time?!??
I've seen him live (same hometown, yay!) and he's pretty good live
One Direction kid is a real judge here 😂
It’s crazy to think a few weeks later I saw him in “Bat Outta Hell” the musical
Well he got a chance. that's nice. It must be so hard to be on stage, but this competition is no joke. Or you make it or you are out, simple as that !!
They gave him a chance. Louis is a hard one but quite objective I must admit :-)
When you are rock, you are rock!
Louis the only one who got it right
SIMON THE GENIUS....RESPECT...
BRAVO AMICO MIO... GIOVANNI
he just sounded.... off in some of it. Good on the choruses and faster bits. didn't sound anything like musical theatre to me! sounded more 80's rock
His face reminds me of a young Willem Dafoe.
1:47 haha gotta love him
after watching these shows kinda too much! I have a conclusion that is all fake and manipulative to just get more audience! one thing that make be vomiting is when someone uses his wife, kids or any emotional story or trauma happened in his life to get to be liked by playing the pitty! that is a complete super high level of hypocrisy, dishonest and fakery
Why ami disagreeing with Simon this season?
Omg he sang my favorite song " Iris"
Louis is the best!
Louis only make what Simon say!
@@thejjam4153 nope. Louis doesn't care what everyone else thinks. If he thinks it's a no he says no. Remember that Greece girl's audition??
TheJjam4 I have literally seen you comment the same thing about Louis in other comments
Tusa Solo - I watching these shows for twelve years! You became a feeling for that!
Louis is rather weak singer & not very interesting. At least this guy is someone that people will remember.
I don't see why everyone is hating. He can sing (lower notes are shaky though but the belting is great), he is not bad looking and he is different. The problem is his act feels dated.
Ikr
I love Nicole more than her..
This guy has the looks and got the rock and roll voice but needs guidance for him to succeed in this business, oh I love that hear it’s dame great hear
Hot rocker guy but hes out of tune when hes not screaming... Im behind Louis, No!
Roy Galindo - Louis only make what Simon say!
Hot??
He deserve the third yes!
Please Anthony bring out The "Antonino Spadaccino" one. I can't believe It's not online
Why in this tv shows is the same thing with rock voices? The guy is awesome handsome humble and his voice 😎😎😎😎🎸🎸🎸🎸
He should of won! Gio was the best!
There's a room for improvement but he's if he get some guidence from the music industry's lead he can be a star...
jumped on the stage from the 80's
Louis clearly threatened.
Mekela alexnder 19 403 0123 hey
Sean v 2 years ago
Theatened
who came here after the live shows?
Lmaoo😂😂😂Iook at Simon 😂😂😂I like him very much
Creepy ken doll face
Itati Ruelas looks like Robbie Williams really
I'm half italian.. fucking rock star!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
louis is the only one who seems to have ears
He was good, I like him.
It’s a no for me 😴✌🏽
Choice of song is very important
He's got talent, but is putting/pushing his ego out there before anything else with his 1st act...2nd song WAY more sincere and was great, I do like his talent as a singer..
hes fucking class too much hate in the comments
The second part of the second performance redeemed him.
Just watched the recording of the 2012 Arena tour of Jesus Christ Superstar and found out that he was Simon Zealotes!
he has this kind of babyface, it is creeping me tf out
Forget about his cocky personality. Trust me He is such a good Rock song singer.
I'm happy for him #LOT
6:26 Some times it makes me wonder if xfactor is really about talent as they don't recognize rock and roll as music that really bothers me 6:26 6:26 Louis Tomlinson Giovanni was great
Which song he sings in 2nd time?
Lou was not having it 😭
Do you also think Ayda is just following her husband's ideas????
wtf is wrong with your people he is good as a singer and he got a good pop star attitude
Great rocker!
I don't understand why they didn't give the firefighter a 2nd chance🤔
There´s something about him. But, yeah, he picked up many bad habits from musical theatre. He´s hiding something, his inner truth. If he can be brave enough to let it out, he could be amazing.
I thought the first song was better...
I like him
Some of these comments are so annoying. Just let people enjoy the damn show. Whether its scripted or not I really dgaf
My first thought was he reminds me of the lead singer of the Goo Goo Dolls (not as good obviously) and then he sang Iris!!!
Did not know he was part of a successful boy band, was unduly harsh. But I still say that older music,does require, a sense of being there. I see the way ,to be a little less hostile. I sometime assume rather than presume.
Whats the title of the second song?
Iris by goo goo dolls
Правильные связи... решающий фактор....
Gooooooood
Adya is just scared of disagreeing with her husband, robby is fun but not a really good judge, Louis is just honest and sassy (maybe I’m biased tho), I hate Simon with my entire heart but he is kind of a genius in the music industry but he’s not doing well this season for me hahaha