Original comic can be found here -- ruffu.deviantar... Collaborators: Webshoter (Doctor Stable) / webshoter EpikIllousionVA Moose (Apple Bloom) / epikillousionva
To lose the ability to bear children is a terrible thing for anyone to have to go through. And even though I know there are many who can accept it and move on, there are just as many, if not more, who see it as something that has ruined their lives forever. It isn't something I'd wish on my worst enemy.
Jay I'm gonna be honest. I'm 16 and I know I'm never going to have children. School is just so stressful that I'm not going to bother getting a job. No one takes my opinions in life seriously. When I finally get to that long waited day of 18 I'm leaving. I'm gonna move to Siberia and live in isolation and survive for the rest of my life...
Makes me sad that hardly anyone even thinks about adopting a child anymore. I was adopted myself; my biological mother, for whatever reason, more than likely had the finances and resources to only care for one child (my biological sister, who's two years older than me), but not me, so she turned me over to my adoptive parents because my adoptive mother couldn't conceive.
Same. Just got into watching these dubs, and I saw "Core of the apple" before this one... Major feels, along with music to really tug at your heartstrings.
The artwork where she cries reading the letter really rips me up inside, that is some serious art. I will never be able understand what it feels like to never have a child, but I know what it feels like to be told there is something wrong with you... and that there's nothing you can ever do about it.
Danika Toler No no, I'm one o' them there non-bronies. basically not a brony, but likes pony show. basically a "hey, that's neat" sort of level of interest.
+James Sotelo How would she have a surrogate child? If she can't bear children, she just can't bear a child. If she were a stallion, it would be a different story.
Applejack is a very kind soul. No matter what happens, she gets through her problems, even if she seems to sacrifice a bit of her own health or happiness. Still, she has her family, and seeing how Applebloom seems to notice that side of her sister's sadness, I'm sure she will be there for her sibling.
we make a living by what we get, but we make a life by what we give, at times wen all seems lost a light shines through the darkness,that light is love stay classy
Its funny how everyone comments ''ooh i'm crying'' ''buuuhuuu im bursting to tears'' when in reality, they just smile infront of a monitor. Its like when they say ''OMG ROFLMAO HAHAH XDXDXDXDDXD''
Not really. I see it as a blessing to not be able to have children. I mean, I guess it sucks if you actually want kids the way AJ did but I am far from wanting that. I don't see the appeal, really.
wait is there like a sequel because when apple bloom saw that letter i would like to know what would happen after if it isn't too much trouble can u make more to go with this because u might be going somewhere with this
Whenever I decide to have children (I won't) I'll have many medical complications and uphill battles. What terrifies me most is that I don't have a maternal bone in my body; so the topic of having children is an extremely sensitive subject. This comic dub has helped me so much to remember I'm not less of a woman if I can't have children or be 'motherly'.
This hits hard. I'd like to bear a child of my own but even I'm not sure if I'll be able to. As a female, I haven't gotten that one thing that occurrs monthy for the past few years. Haven't gone to the doctor but, it'd still hit hard. No matter how hard. I try to prepare myself.
I could not sleep so I was having a look around you tube, After this there is no way I could get some sleep. You always do the best work Scribbler. Sad, Funny or different. Its 0200 in the morning here time to try to sleep.
im going to make a little part 2 in this very coment section ''Applejack? Whats that paper there? It says your name on it.'' Applebloom said, looking up at her big sister. ''What does that mean?'' Applejack swiped the paper and stuffed it in her bag. ''It's personal..'' Applejack replieded in a low, sad voice.''Please tell me! Ah' share all oh my personal things with you! You have to repay me for telling you who ah' used to like!'' Applebloom snaped back.''Ahm' sorry, sis'. But now isn't the time for games. You should go to bed.'' Aj replied. Applebloom looked up at her sister, who had been staring at the window. Applebloom reached out and gave AJ a big hug.''Sis, ah' don't know why, but yah' are sad. Ya' don't have to tell me. Ah don't wanna put pressure on yah'.'' the little yellow earth pony said in a low upsetting voice. Applejack hugged her back, as a tears dripped from her eye. Applebloom , taking one last look at the note before she would go to bed gasped a little. She hugged her big sister tightly.''Ah'm so sorry AJ!'' Applebloom cried out as she buried her face into AJ's chest, tears dripping from her eyes.''Ah didn't know that happened to you!''''It's alright lil' sis. It ain't your fault..'' Aj said as she pat her hoof on Appleblooms head. ''It ain't your fault..''The End.
Now that the series has ended, it is not that far fetched to think that anymore, as she is shown without any children. Granted most of the mane six are not shown with a child either but anyway.
That's really heart touching!! Good job on trying to make something sad. Except, all my tears are out and I'll never cry as much again, not from this. I've been through sad things that NO-ONE should see, and I'm only nine
I kinda assume if AJ got married the dude would move in with her. It's the family farm after all and she seems to run it. I guess Big Mac could take care of it...
I have come to understand,, sorta,, what this is like. Having PCOS makes you infertile (Some people at least, like me) which makes it very difficult for you to bear children. I may not have 0% chance of bearing children, but this comic just,, reminds me of my painful issue. The voice acting and editing is beautiful :)
Is it wrong that I was coming in expecting to cry tears of sadness and left crying tears of joy because when I figured out the title I swear I could not stop.
This actually hit me hard as in my twenties i was diganosed with PCOS.. and was told as well i probally wont be able to have kids without medical help. ..
I think i understand the meaning of this comic....Since Applejack won't be able to have kids biologically. Applebloom is the next best thing. What i'm saying is that's one of the reasons why Applejack is like a mother figure to Applebloom while still being her older sister.
I don't get it how people don't get it?! Okay, the comic isn't extremely sad, but it is about Appeljack learning that she quite possibly is never going to be able to have a biological baby of her own (that explains the headline "An Apple without seeds"). Well, young viewers propably won't get it, since it may not be crystal clear to them that a woman and a man can't just go and decide "Oh, let's make a baby!" and it will be a fact that a they will get one. It really is not like that. It is sad how big percent of couples really want and try to make their very own baby, but are unable to get one. At the same time babies are born due to unintentional teen-pregnancies and rapes, and some people just are so lucky that they will get more than one healthy child. I can imagine how unfair that may feel for a couple who would do like anything to get their own biological child, but still won't get it. Getting a child may seem like the most simple thing in the world, because after all, "so many people have children", "even my and my friends' parents have children, so why wouldn't I get one?". Well, it may come as a big shock when you learn you may never have a child. That one big thing that at first seemed like a fact and simplicity itself, is torn from you forever. True, you can always adopt a child and love it like it was your own, but you still know it is or never will be your very own.
is there a part 2. cause what will applebloom say or will she be really sad that her dream or nightmare comes true? What will happen next? Will she run away? willl she stop talking to applejack because she lied? WHAT WILL HAPPEN NEXT I NEED TO KNOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Guy brains alert: The good news is Applejack can have a lot of 'fun' without having to...eh heh, worry about certain problems. But for a woman to want a family and be cursed with this is just awful. My sister kept on miscarrying and it clearly hurt her bad.
To lose the ability to bear children is a terrible thing for anyone to have to go through. And even though I know there are many who can accept it and move on, there are just as many, if not more, who see it as something that has ruined their lives forever.
It isn't something I'd wish on my worst enemy.
Does it mean that I'm heartless if I would?
Even worse for Applejack! ; ^; She's so proud of having a family.
You have such a great heart, and I'm glad someone understands how tough that could really be on someone.
Jay I'm gonna be honest. I'm 16 and I know I'm never going to have children. School is just so stressful that I'm not going to bother getting a job. No one takes my opinions in life seriously. When I finally get to that long waited day of 18 I'm leaving. I'm gonna move to Siberia and live in isolation and survive for the rest of my life...
Makes me sad that hardly anyone even thinks about adopting a child anymore. I was adopted myself; my biological mother, for whatever reason, more than likely had the finances and resources to only care for one child (my biological sister, who's two years older than me), but not me, so she turned me over to my adoptive parents because my adoptive mother couldn't conceive.
Doctor: You can't have children.
Apple bloom: I had a nightmare. You had children and you went away.
Ouch.
Apple means family and family never gets left behind
or forgotten
Or die- oh wait family always die wow that was unexpected!! :D
@carmen
#relatable
Now imma say to my family
“Your my Apple”
It's not nearly as devastating as 'Core of the Apple' but it was certainly sad. Sweet but sad.
Same. Just got into watching these dubs, and I saw "Core of the apple" before this one... Major feels, along with music to really tug at your heartstrings.
The artwork where she cries reading the letter really rips me up inside, that is some serious art. I will never be able understand what it feels like to never have a child, but I know what it feels like to be told there is something wrong with you... and that there's nothing you can ever do about it.
Damn it all, i keep saying that i am not a brony, but i find myself watching these vids. I think i am beginning to turn.
also, poor AJ.
WE WILL REMAIN STRONG, WE WILL RESIST THE HERD. STAND TOGETHER AS THE NOT-BRONIES.
Danika Toler
No no, I'm one o' them there non-bronies. basically not a brony, but likes pony show. basically a "hey, that's neat" sort of level of interest.
Danika Toler
is a story we all would like to hear
*****
any fandom is full o' those, yo.
*****
I can dig it.
Who gave Scribbler the Feels Button!? ;A;
RIGHT? N-now I w-wanna slap I-it out of there h-h-hands ;2
Me
SasukeX53 not me probably was the doc
People who make this s**t, maybe.
There's always adoption, Applejack ^_^
It's not the saameeee :(
+regularshow960 Yeah.
Or maybe surrogates
+James Sotelo How would she have a surrogate child? If she can't bear children, she just can't bear a child. If she were a stallion, it would be a different story.
apple jack is cute
Applejack is a very kind soul. No matter what happens, she gets through her problems, even if she seems to sacrifice a bit of her own health or happiness. Still, she has her family, and seeing how Applebloom seems to notice that side of her sister's sadness, I'm sure she will be there for her sibling.
APPLE JACK!!! APPLE BLOOM knows everything!!!
Scootaloo Scoot aloo What Apple Jack write on the paper?
ᏊᎲᏋᖇᎴ ᏃᎲLLᎯ
She didn't, that was doctor. Applebloom read it if that's what you mean
I lost a child and it hurts like hell... So this really hit close to home, I can't imagine not being able to have children
poor poor aj she would be a very awesome mom it is a shame that ppl or ponys that will be good parents r not :(
Barbara Varner
Well, maybe magic and in-vitro seed fertilizing can help AJ.
Hopefully.
P.S.:
Thanks Lauren Faust, this is not canon. Aye?
The inability to bear a child is something I wouldn't be able to handle. For someone who is obsessed with having a child. I would be devastated
we make a living by what we get, but we make a life by what we give,
at times wen all seems lost a light shines through the darkness,that light is love
stay classy
I watched for the art but stayed because the gosh darn video ripped a tear from my eyes! Curse the fandom's!
Such a great audio dub, it was so well done that it felt like I could see apple bloom and apple jack moving between each panel
Family isn't about blood it's the bond you hold with them
That's so true, I'll never forget it
This is one of my favorite comics. Thank you so much for dubbing it. It was beautiful!
This comic is actually the embodiment of one of my worst fears, so it hits close to home.
huh. im the opposite, i dont want to give birth.
poor AJ she will never have a family of her own ;(
Well at least, she could save other children from orphanage by adopting them :)
Sparks ya
Its funny how everyone comments ''ooh i'm crying'' ''buuuhuuu im bursting to tears'' when in reality, they just smile infront of a monitor. Its like when they say ''OMG ROFLMAO HAHAH XDXDXDXDDXD''
They have a normal face and be like omg this is sooooo sad :( I'm gonna die
Leyna Luu Thats the sad thing about the internet, you never know..
haha
they are crying and laughing inside
Button Mash As i said, nobody knows
this is one of the most that girls fear in their life, seeing if they can ever have a child. :'(
True fluffy, True :'( sad
Not really. I see it as a blessing to not be able to have children. I mean, I guess it sucks if you actually want kids the way AJ did but I am far from wanting that. I don't see the appeal, really.
@@kathrynd.t.4960 neither do i want children.... but I unterstand of other might feel broken my this
wait is there like a sequel because when apple bloom saw that letter i would like to know what would happen after if it isn't too much trouble can u make more to go with this because u might be going somewhere with this
1:31 awww he says to applejack u were married ❤️😊 nice voice acting.
you mean *she* ?
Whenever I decide to have children (I won't) I'll have many medical complications and uphill battles. What terrifies me most is that I don't have a maternal bone in my body; so the topic of having children is an extremely sensitive subject. This comic dub has helped me so much to remember I'm not less of a woman if I can't have children or be 'motherly'.
Great work!
I know how you feel applejack, apples without seeds are like Christmas without a tree is like easter without eggs.
Good job as always Scribbler. I do enjoy you videos. I bet you love the clock sound. Anyways I hope this week is better for you than the last two.
OMG this is amazing voice reading! The voices and the background sounds and everything is awesome
oh god this was a tear jerker,
lovely job
Oh I get it an apple without a SEEDS.....
Ummm gross
And sad
j
I HAVE BEEN KILLED
*Throws head back in a Rarity motion*
BY THE FEELS
It's ok AJ ,gives her a muffin "it's okay now eat your muffin and go give a high five to derpy."
This hits hard. I'd like to bear a child of my own but even I'm not sure if I'll be able to. As a female, I haven't gotten that one thing that occurrs monthy for the past few years. Haven't gone to the doctor but, it'd still hit hard. No matter how hard. I try to prepare myself.
I could not sleep so I was having a look around you tube,
After this there is no way I could get some sleep.
You always do the best work Scribbler. Sad, Funny or different.
Its 0200 in the morning here time to try to sleep.
This video reminds me of my grandmother who past away before my siblings and I were born.
The voice acting in this was really good :)
The music choice, was wonderful. XD nice dub
im going to make a little part 2 in this very coment section
''Applejack? Whats that paper there? It says your name on it.'' Applebloom said, looking up at her big sister. ''What does that mean?'' Applejack swiped the paper and stuffed it in her bag. ''It's personal..'' Applejack replieded in a low, sad voice.''Please tell me! Ah' share all oh my personal things with you! You have to repay me for telling you who ah' used to like!'' Applebloom snaped back.''Ahm' sorry, sis'. But now isn't the time for games. You should go to bed.'' Aj replied. Applebloom looked up at her sister, who had been staring at the window. Applebloom reached out and gave AJ a big hug.''Sis, ah' don't know why, but yah' are sad. Ya' don't have to tell me. Ah don't wanna put pressure on yah'.'' the little yellow earth pony said in a low upsetting voice. Applejack hugged her back, as a tears dripped from her eye. Applebloom , taking one last look at the note before she would go to bed gasped a little. She hugged her big sister tightly.''Ah'm so sorry AJ!'' Applebloom cried out as she buried her face into AJ's chest, tears dripping from her eyes.''Ah didn't know that happened to you!''''It's alright lil' sis. It ain't your fault..'' Aj said as she pat her hoof on Appleblooms head. ''It ain't your fault..''The End.
Now that the series has ended, it is not that far fetched to think that anymore, as she is shown without any children. Granted most of the mane six are not shown with a child either but anyway.
Applejack loves Applebloom more than anything Ponyville
I remember running into this as I was looking for AJ pics...them feels when I ran into this T.T
I plan to adopt even though I can have my own kids, It breaks my heart to imagine creating a life when I could be caring for a lonely one.
Holy snails why am I crying so much 😭
Well, at least she doesn't have cancer. That's what I honestly thought at first when Applejack said "Doc"
Again two vids in a row I'm crying and worst part is not the tears it's that's now burning so bad!
Your videos are so good I literally cry 😭 but that’s ok keep up the good work 😁
That's really heart touching!! Good job on trying to make something sad. Except, all my tears are out and I'll never cry as much again, not from this. I've been through sad things that NO-ONE should see, and I'm only nine
Holy Luna... That sure was a sad story! Im happy that just fan-fic
Apple without seeds
But
Apple with fresh sugary juice the will mix happiness and sugar in everyone's heart
This isn't really sad. But it is cute!
Guys that means she might have kids that's 10 percent out of 90 percent she will have kids.
I guess Apple Bloom will feel very bad about telling her sister about her dream after seeing the medical exam result......
Me: Applejack I don’t care if you’re not able to have foals. I still love you all the same sweetheart.
Awwwwww *cries* that was really sad!
I kinda assume if AJ got married the dude would move in with her. It's the family farm after all and she seems to run it. I guess Big Mac could take care of it...
AN APPLE *WITHOUT SEEDS!?*
THAT'S SO FUCKING DARK!!
AHHHHHHHHHHHHH
I have come to understand,, sorta,, what this is like. Having PCOS makes you infertile (Some people at least, like me) which makes it very difficult for you to bear children. I may not have 0% chance of bearing children, but this comic just,, reminds me of my painful issue. The voice acting and editing is beautiful :)
There's So Much sad Stories With Apple Bloom And Apple Jack
I'm going through this rn my doctor told me it's highly unlikely that I'll be able to get pregnant
Excuse me for a moment, I need a tissue...
I'm not crying you are
OMG, this made me cry a bit {- (
{-
well two things
one: they are now apples (they are lucky I didn't eat them)
two: they seemed to have some superglue which has now stuck them together
the feels :( and it's so sad
Dont worry Apple Jack theres always Adoption!
It will not only help u, but also the filly
Is it wrong that I was coming in expecting to cry tears of sadness and left crying tears of joy because when I figured out the title I swear I could not stop.
Now I know why it's called An Apple Without Seeds. So AJ can't have a kid?
Hard, but not impossible.
She could, but she would keep having to have -sex- until she was preggers .D.
Life is cruel and works in mysterious ways, not being able to have kids something that we got to deal with, though it still hurts
i hope that AJ will be a good aunt if Applebloom or Big Mac have kids
That was an amazing Applejack voice!
I'm on the verge of crying right now 😣 so frekin sad, and that music in the background wasn't helping lol, sounded beautiful though
Im watching this after the episode where applebloom is pissed about how much applejack wont let her be
Short but sad I ALMOST shed some tears usually I'd be balling like a baby but I saw Core of the Apple before this
my heart just stop from the sadness please stop making my feels explode ;_;
Dont give up hope AJ, my ma was told the same thing, yet here I am.
Darnit, this pony here won't leave mah emotions alone ;~;
This actually hit me hard as in my twenties i was diganosed with PCOS.. and was told as well i probally wont be able to have kids without medical help. ..
My celestia god this story was even more sadder then the mini my little dashie moviw i saw a few days sgo,even if that was out for a while
I think i understand the meaning of this comic....Since Applejack won't be able to have kids biologically. Applebloom is the next best thing. What i'm saying is that's one of the reasons why Applejack is like a mother figure to Applebloom while still being her older sister.
I don't get it how people don't get it?!
Okay, the comic isn't extremely sad, but it is about Appeljack learning that she quite possibly is never going to be able to have a biological baby of her own (that explains the headline "An Apple without seeds").
Well, young viewers propably won't get it, since it may not be crystal clear to them that a woman and a man can't just go and decide "Oh, let's make a baby!" and it will be a fact that a they will get one. It really is not like that. It is sad how big percent of couples really want and try to make their very own baby, but are unable to get one. At the same time babies are born due to unintentional teen-pregnancies and rapes, and some people just are so lucky that they will get more than one healthy child. I can imagine how unfair that may feel for a couple who would do like anything to get their own biological child, but still won't get it.
Getting a child may seem like the most simple thing in the world, because after all, "so many people have children", "even my and my friends' parents have children, so why wouldn't I get one?". Well, it may come as a big shock when you learn you may never have a child. That one big thing that at first seemed like a fact and simplicity itself, is torn from you forever. True, you can always adopt a child and love it like it was your own, but you still know it is or never will be your very own.
is there a part 2. cause what will applebloom say or will she be really sad that her dream or nightmare comes true? What will happen next? Will she run away? willl she stop talking to applejack because she lied? WHAT WILL HAPPEN NEXT I NEED TO KNOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yo on some serious note I would love an episode where AJ gets married to a decent stallion and have kids.
Applejack still in the closet be like:
aww appleblom! :( *gives applebloom a hug*
mlp lunalover *hugs you* its ok :3
I'm actually crying in this video
Shouldn't this be labeled sad and uplifting, not just sad? I mean it is kind of uplifting if you ask me.
I couldn't help but notice that the doctor is a blank flank.
Guy brains alert: The good news is Applejack can have a lot of 'fun' without having to...eh heh, worry about certain problems. But for a woman to want a family and be cursed with this is just awful. My sister kept on miscarrying and it clearly hurt her bad.
very nicely made! :)
Aj would be a good mom. Poor aj.
This is why AJ is best in my opinion they always stick together 😄😄
whoa amazing job and sad XD i would be more happy to see more!
I LOVE THEM SO FAR!
this is so cute!
Don't worry Apple Jack there's hormone therapy and other treatments to help you. They told my sister she couldn't have kids and she did
If Applejack can't have kids than I don't even wanna know how the rest of the "story" of MLP goes.
Aww that was so sweet I love it
well, look at it this way, if she does ended up with rarity, rarity could be the one that bears the child :3
That was sweet I really liked it