Refuting MARXISM & SOCIALISM - Islam: Left or Right? (Day 2) Abdullah Al-Andalusi

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 окт 2024

Комментарии • 43

  • @Amgd212
    @Amgd212 Год назад +7

    May God reward you. I have been waiting for this lesson. I hope that the rest of the lessons will be uploaded soon.

  • @jimfromwakanda7991
    @jimfromwakanda7991 Год назад +12

    I always love hearing brother Abdullah Al Andalusi speak, MashaAllah, Alhamdulillah. May Allah Azzawajjal bless you, ameen.

  • @hikmawise2161
    @hikmawise2161 Год назад +7

    May Allah SWT bless Ustadh Abdullah and his family. Aameen.

  • @a4482921
    @a4482921 Год назад +24

    MashaAllah, this is very important as a lot of Muslims have resorted to socialism to counter the injustice of monopolistic, neo-colonial capitalism without realising its kufr elements.

    • @Xenor999
      @Xenor999 Год назад +3

      Tbh socialism is worse when implemented and it's much more haram atleast according to my knowledge.dont think iam wrong but could be.

    • @AryaputraGemilang
      @AryaputraGemilang Год назад

      ​@@Xenor999no you are right, look at Indonesia where they killed Muslims while they were praying, and the millions who starved at holodomor........

    • @user-ks1hp2pb5g
      @user-ks1hp2pb5g Год назад +3

      @@Xenor999 sadly the brother simply hasn't studied economics, marxism or the labour theory of value. He butchered marx's conception of value.

    • @CraigTheBrute-yf7no
      @CraigTheBrute-yf7no Год назад

      @@user-ks1hp2pb5gmarx was a kafir

    • @Xenor999
      @Xenor999 Год назад +5

      @@user-ks1hp2pb5g i don't think that's true and i will rather believe him than you tbh unless you bring evidence and tbh I still might not see it because ultimately it's not important.i have evidence that it's not moral simply because God said so.that should be enough for any rational person if he understands what God actually is

  • @fahmihassen7498
    @fahmihassen7498 Год назад +4

    mashallah ya ustath ..i was thinking will there be a second part? ....lets play it

  • @abdurrahimturker5479
    @abdurrahimturker5479 Год назад +6

    Very informative lecture and I really enjoy your sense of humor. Could listen to you speak all day. JazakAllah khayran

  • @hasanulakib
    @hasanulakib Год назад +13

    🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation:
    00:09 🎙️ Abdullah Al-Andalusi: Islam and Muslim affairs intellectual activist, co-founder of Muslim debate initiative.
    25:49 🌍 Ideas create change through clashes and synthesis in history.
    32:12 🏛️ Socialism involves state ownership for equal distribution.
    50:10 🏭 Materialism: Thoughts reflect society; Marx focuses on abolishing classes.
    59:16 ⚖️ Marx aims to abolish property ownership; contrasts Islamic principles.
    01:35:01 🧠 Human purpose defines morality; understanding morality is vital.
    01:52:56 🇮🇱 Israel's political landscape includes right-wing parties due to historical factors.
    02:37:53 🧠 Marxists adopt theories even without evidence to avoid contradicting beliefs.
    02:48:45 💡 Muslims gravitated to Marxism due to accurate criticism of capitalism.
    02:50:08 🕌 Islam clashes with capitalism; guarantees needs, leaves distribution open.
    Made with HARPA AI

    • @RidwanAlQudbi
      @RidwanAlQudbi Год назад +1

      This must be pinned. JazakALLAHU khayran brother. Please do the same for the DAY1 Lecture as well.

  • @thewhitepage4345
    @thewhitepage4345 Год назад +7

    🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation:
    02:02 🔴 2nd day discussing non-Islamic ideologies.
    03:09 🎙️ Open to discussion.
    06:54 🌐 Marxism complexity, scholars' differences.
    14:07 📚 Philosophers' arguments in ideologies.
    25:22 🌀 Hegel's influence, dialectics.
    27:12 🌱 Marx's materialist view of ideas.
    29:32 🔗 Economic systems shape beliefs.
    36:06 🚀 Marx's vision: abolish class distinctions.
    50:10 🌍 Ideas reflect social relations.
    52:32 🏛️ Religion as symptom of oppression.
    57:16 🏭 Abolish private property and classes.
    01:13:20 👥 Islam's stance on family and wealth.
    01:14:00 💼 Islam allows wage labor and wealth.
    01:14:56 💰 Islamic wealth tax vs Marxist redistribution.
    01:21:21 🔮 Neo-Marxism and cultural hegemony.
    01:36:18 🧐 Marx rejected equality for class abolition.
    01:57:59 🗳️ Israel's shifting political ideologies.
    02:05:55 🎭 Addressing historical relationships.
    02:22:07 🌍 Bosnian Muslims and Nazi units.
    02:42:46 🤯 People adopt theories without evidence.
    02:46:31 🌍 Marx's vision for post-capitalism.
    02:51:20 🔀 Muslims urged to seek Third Way.
    Made with HARPA AI

  • @zeenatmohammed2608
    @zeenatmohammed2608 Год назад +8

    Salaamualaikum from South Africa. Looking forward to listening to the lecture. May Allah swt preserve this great thinker and orator

    • @aboetarikske
      @aboetarikske Год назад +1

      Aleikoem salaam. Hoe is het daar, hoe gaat het met jullie?

    • @zeenatmohammed2608
      @zeenatmohammed2608 Год назад +1

      @@aboetarikske baie goed dankie,en met julle?

  • @aboetarikske
    @aboetarikske Год назад +4

    Yazaak Allahu khayr brother. Finally someone who speaks on Marxism and Muslims.

  • @salamtofsl
    @salamtofsl Год назад +3

    Vert very important lectures

  • @hashemalhemyari7590
    @hashemalhemyari7590 Год назад +3

    Please share the slides with us kindly abdullah al Andalusi
    جزاك الله خيرا كثيرا

  • @szamani2043
    @szamani2043 Год назад +1

    Jaza kallah khair. Excellent information. But the spicy parts 3,4,5 are missing

  • @homtanks7259
    @homtanks7259 Год назад +2

    JazakAllah'u khairan

  • @alberxenos
    @alberxenos Год назад +3

    Assalamu’alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh
    السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ

  • @asulkarim2303
    @asulkarim2303 Год назад +3

    Remember, if its an ism other than Islam and the Sharia its wrong

  • @gazirehman9421
    @gazirehman9421 Год назад +2

    At 2:12:20 The non-muslim claims that the Prophet( sallallahu Alayhi Wasalam) saw Zaynab(RA) naked and then later married her, supposedly because he was taken by her beauty. The hadiths which relate this story are considered very weak and unreliable. So basically there is no proof that the Prophet saw her naked and then later made moves to marry her.
    He also seems to think that Zaynab(RA) was the adopted daughter of the Prophet( sallallahu alayhi wasallam). This is obviously wrong, it was not Zaynab(RA) but her husband Zaid(RA) that was an adopted son of the Prophet.

  • @hasinabrar3263
    @hasinabrar3263 Год назад +3

    A very good lecture but the audiance seems so boring 😅

    • @snakejuce
      @snakejuce Год назад +1

      The audience is too soy, shy, and weak.

  • @TazKidNoah
    @TazKidNoah Год назад +2

    43:22 😂 he great at storytelling

  • @siyovushm2317
    @siyovushm2317 Год назад +1

    Yes

  • @ahnafrashik
    @ahnafrashik Год назад +1

    35:40 ikhwani approach

  • @tranium67
    @tranium67 Год назад

    51:39

  • @snakejuce
    @snakejuce Год назад

    I wish the children there would speak up more. Check their estrogen levels, please.

    • @AryaputraGemilang
      @AryaputraGemilang Год назад

      Hey Little boy, you sure love acting tough but when the real men Appear then you starting to have erections😂😂😂

  • @Saber23
    @Saber23 8 месяцев назад

    Isn’t Dugin’s or philosophy called Eurasianism?