Thanks for floating through space with me while I experience this epic song! Don't forget to subscribe, like and comment so you can go with me on a long journey of discovering masterpieces from the best 30 years of music ever 🥰
You should definitely react to the live 1994 Pulse version of this song. The guitar solo is much longer and takes you into a different dimension. Also you get to see the greatest light show of any rock concert ever.
Check out the LIVE version of Comfortably Numb from the PULSE CONCERT. The extended guitar solo and spectacular light show combine for an unforgettable performance.
A Pink Floyd song, by its own, is generaly very hard to fully comprehend. To get a good understanding, you really have to listen to the full album, from begining to end. This song, like most Pink Floyd song, is like a movie score. The music (and few lyrics) guides you through your own life's experiences and the movie occurs in your head. It's for you alone!
Thanks for watching and commenting Jacques. Wow what a great description! Definitely thinking about how to do full album reactions here. I think I must do The Wall in 2 parts at the most. Thanks again!
The reason Pink Floyd was so good was that dichotomy…. Roger Waters’ dark sinister lyricis, David Gilmour’s hopeful positive tone and voice. I can think of no other band that quite pulled that off, the yin and the yang, like they did
@@retroreactions.... they both sang, as did they keyboard player Richard earlier. Their best songs are the ones where they both sing. Hey You, Comfortably Numb, Mother, to name a few
I assume you mean David and Roger both sang. Syd also appears to be a lead singer (still learning about the band). I love bands that utilize multiple lead singers (ala Fleetwood Mac).
You must listen to the 1994 Pulse concert version. The outdo solo is without doubt, the best guitar solo of all time. The whole Pulse concert is an out of body experience. Well worth a watch,
You said you wanted the solo to keep going. I recommend listening to one of the live versions. Either on Pulse or The Delicate Sound of Thunder.... awesome really long solo for Comfortably Numb on those.
I first listened to this song a few years ago when my husband played this song to his Dad as he was passing away. Very emotional. Beautiful Pink Floyd song. My fave songs are moody too.
Pink Floyd is Legendary man, an Experience, they are one of the GOAT's in Rock Music history. Likely the greatest Progressive Rock band ever, they have sold over 250 million albums worldwide. Pink Floyd was formed in London in 1965, they are especially known for their extended compositions, spacey psychedelic sonic experimentations, prodigious live performances, and philosophical lyrics. I've been a PF fan since 1973 when they released their epic "Dark Side of the Moon" album, one of the best-selling albums of all time, over 55 million. If you're planning on going down the Pink Floyd Rabbit Hole, you're in for a Hella ride, being exposed to some of the finest music ever written, performed by some of the most proficient Rock musicians and artists in the business!
Thanks for the info! That's why I gravitate towards them so easily. My kind of thing musically. It boggles my mind that, always being a huge lover of music and writing songs since childhood, I never delved into this band. Guess the universe had it in store that I discover them through this channel!
Some people consider Comfortably Numb to be Pink Floyd's finest song. It may well be their most recognisable and famous song, though wether it's their best is always, and constantly up for debate. Everyone has their own preferance of course, as no two Pink Floyd concept albums sound alike, and their songs cover and incorporate a broad spectrum and mix of Genres. From Classic Rock to Country, Symphonic, Orchestral, Classical, Blues, Folk, Synth, Big Band, Acapella, Male Voice Choir, Psychadelic, 80's, New Age, and just about everything else in between, Pink Floyd's got you covered. Not bad for one group... Cheers for the reaction video.
🤭 For the solo to keep going, you have to watch the Pulse Concert Video version of Comfortably Numb. 🤗 Do The Wall! 😏 I usually suggest DSoTM but, you're a DM fan! 😉 You'll totally "get" the Album. 😊🐰
Been a crazy few days, but should be able to watch the live version tonight. Hmmm, now I'm really curious about The Wall! 26 tracks?! WOW, that's a big undertaking. Looks like I only know 2 songs from it. Interesting that you made the DM comparison...
No wonder we get along so well LOL...Awesome! I've been a true fan since around 1987. Didn't get to start seeing them live till 1990, what a tour that was! Also had the extreme luck and pleasure of meeting them backstage twice! ('94 and '09, sadly Dave was not there either time). So excited for the new material!! Been too long...
If you want full gigantic sound try two songs off of Dark Side Of the Moon. Try the song "Time" and then "Us and Them"! Some of the Floyd songs have long intros Before lyrics starts such as their fabulous song "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" from the "Wish You Were Here" album!!! That's just a few of a massive amount of incredibly great songs by them! You've tripped into a bottomless rabbit hole with these guys! Enjoyed the reaction, keep going......we'll enjoy them together!
Hi Jon. Thanks for the kind words. Us and Them I heard a few times a couple of years ago and instantly loved. Listened to it yesterday and the intro still makes me tear up and goosebumps. I will definitely react to Time and on the channel. I'm a huge fan of long intros, long outros and long songs! For Shine On..., are parts 1-5 better than 6-9? I see they are separated on the album. Are they 2 different songs? Or 1 whole song that needs to be listened back to back?
You won’t be sorry!! The voices are even more dark in the Pulse version. This was written by Roger Waters. He went to a Dr before a show which gave him a shot that numbed him. The dark was the Dr speaking to him. All sorts of fuzzy as he was numb. He once said that he has know idea how he even got through the show being his arms and hands were numb!
I watched it yesterday and it blew my mind, and yes it made me cry! Was not prepared. Of course they are masters of live performing, but the multiple voices and harmonies on the verses which I already loved made them even more amazing and haunting. Then the extended solo and light show were off the charts. What legends....thanks again for the suggestion!
Absolutely magical. Yes, it’s funny you said you wanted it to keep going. This original studio album recording from ‘The Wall’ does fade out quite quickly. But as all Pink Floyd fans know, we’ve been blessed with phenomenal Live Versions of ‘Comfortably Numb’, with the extended ‘Solo’. I agree with everyone that the Live ‘Pulse’ version is amazing. There are many fantastic performances of it from different Live Shows too. But another incredible performance of it which I personally love and recommend you try, is David Gilmour and his Band, performing back at the Roman Amphitheater at Pompeii, in 2016. Here’s the link below. Goosebumps every time, incredible. ruclips.net/video/eHKG7EMxWW8/видео.html I’d also recommend you listen to the Albums, ‘The Dark Side Of The Moon’ (1973), ‘Wish You Were Here’ (1975) and ‘The Wall’ (1979), from beginning to end, as they are all Concept Albums. And there is also of course, the movie of ‘The Wall’, starring Bob Geldof. These are just my own feelings, of course. Enjoy. 🎶🎸❤️🎸🎶
@@retroreactions.... Yeah, fully understand. Maybe in two halves, for your Show. Or one Vinyl side at a time, as they were originally. It’s also for your own personal listens though, headphones on, as loud as possible and eyes closed. And away you go. 👍🏼 Enjoy. 🎶🎸❤️🎸🎶
@@retroreactions.... I hope you were able to treat yourself to this scintillating version I sent you, Brandon. Even if just for own personal viewing. Here’s a reminder just in case. You’ll never regret seeing this. ruclips.net/video/eHKG7EMxWW8/видео.html 🎶🎸❤️🎸🎶
@@retroreactions.... 🤔 Actually, it's their 'Echoes Live in Pompeii'. 😏 It's got a "haunting melody" that sticks in your head. 🤷🏿♀️ Keep in mind these are the Albums I did homework to in JHS & HS at my friend's house. When we did homework at my house, it was Motown & P-Funk! 🤭 She fell in love with Marvin Gaye & Smokey Robinson. 🥰 I fell in love with David Gilmour, Geddy Lee & Roger Daughtry. I was memorized that 🤯 Tina Turner was going to play "The Acid Queen" in the Movie, Tommy. Led Zep, The Song Remains The Same, also left an impression on me. 🤭 🐰
@@retroreactions.... I say do the live video. They film in Pompeii and it is breathtaking. 🥰 Bonus points for the shirtless band members! 😉 I ain't mad at Gilmours nipples making an appearance! ☺️🐰
Ha, I'll take that as a compliment! I'm close to 50 years old so I was alive through most of this music...written songs and been a huge music fan since childhood, attended tons of live shows over the years. I like both those bands you mentioned, though similarly I only know most of their hits, not their deep catalog. Whatever you decide I really appreciate that you watched :)
Thanks for floating through space with me while I experience this epic song! Don't forget to subscribe, like and comment so you can go with me on a long journey of discovering masterpieces from the best 30 years of music ever 🥰
Agreed 100%. Best live music performance I’ve ever seen :)
All Pink Floyd albums should be listened to in their entirety song after song to get the full true experience.
First time? Woah. If only I could go back to that time.
Better late than never for me haha!
You should definitely react to the live 1994 Pulse version of this song. The guitar solo is much longer and takes you into a different dimension. Also you get to see the greatest light show of any rock concert ever.
I definitely will. Ha, I should add my own light show in a future PF reaction, if I can figure out how! Thank you.
And me in the audience lol
LUCKYYYYYY
Yes this is a definite.
My favourite live performance ever
I watched it that night and cried! I also just watched Shine 1-5 from pulse.....and cried....that concert is perfect in every way!
Perfect rating for a beautiful, classic piece of music!
Check out the LIVE version of Comfortably Numb from the PULSE CONCERT. The extended guitar solo and spectacular light show combine for an unforgettable performance.
I def will asap, a few others said the same thing. Can't wait! Thanks.
LOVE THIS SONG!!!!!
A Pink Floyd song, by its own, is generaly very hard to fully comprehend. To get a good understanding, you really have to listen to the full album, from begining to end.
This song, like most Pink Floyd song, is like a movie score. The music (and few lyrics) guides you through your own life's experiences and the movie occurs in your head. It's for you alone!
Thanks for watching and commenting Jacques. Wow what a great description! Definitely thinking about how to do full album reactions here. I think I must do The Wall in 2 parts at the most. Thanks again!
COMFORTABLY Numb will ROCK YOUR WORLD....THE GUITAR....
WHAT???
AMAZING!!
Everything from them and Genesis is rockin my world so far!
The reason Pink Floyd was so good was that dichotomy…. Roger Waters’ dark sinister lyricis, David Gilmour’s hopeful positive tone and voice. I can think of no other band that quite pulled that off, the yin and the yang, like they did
That's what makes the songs so amazing, yet haunting. Was David the only singer, or did they share lead vocal duties?
@@retroreactions.... they both sang, as did they keyboard player Richard earlier. Their best songs are the ones where they both sing. Hey You, Comfortably Numb, Mother, to name a few
I assume you mean David and Roger both sang. Syd also appears to be a lead singer (still learning about the band). I love bands that utilize multiple lead singers (ala Fleetwood Mac).
Pulse 94 a MUST.
Hi Mark. Heard CN Pulse shortly after and it blew my mind, so powerful I cried...
You won’t regret the live version (Pulse)
Oh I've heard it since, and yes I cried...blew me away!
You must listen to the 1994 Pulse concert version. The outdo solo is without doubt, the best guitar solo of all time. The whole Pulse concert is an out of body experience. Well worth a watch,
Oh I did right away after this reaction... and YES I cried....
they extend it in the lives
You said you wanted the solo to keep going. I recommend listening to one of the live versions. Either on Pulse or The Delicate Sound of Thunder.... awesome really long solo for Comfortably Numb on those.
Heard Pulse version soon after this reaction, made me cry...
I first listened to this song a few years ago when my husband played this song to his Dad as he was passing away. Very emotional. Beautiful Pink Floyd song. My fave songs are moody too.
Wow, what a story. I'm sure they have many beautiful songs. Wanna hear everything! Thanks 😊
Pink Floyd is Legendary man, an Experience, they are one of the GOAT's in Rock Music history. Likely the greatest Progressive Rock band ever, they have sold over 250 million albums worldwide.
Pink Floyd was formed in London in 1965, they are especially known for their extended compositions, spacey psychedelic sonic experimentations, prodigious live performances, and philosophical lyrics.
I've been a PF fan since 1973 when they released their epic "Dark Side of the Moon" album, one of the best-selling albums of all time, over 55 million.
If you're planning on going down the Pink Floyd Rabbit Hole, you're in for a Hella ride, being exposed to some of the finest music ever written, performed by some of the most proficient Rock musicians and artists in the business!
Thanks for the info! That's why I gravitate towards them so easily. My kind of thing musically. It boggles my mind that, always being a huge lover of music and writing songs since childhood, I never delved into this band. Guess the universe had it in store that I discover them through this channel!
We are many that feel as you Scozz. 👍🏼Also listened to them since 73… still listen to them.., 50 years later… 50 years later…
Some people consider Comfortably Numb to be Pink Floyd's finest song.
It may well be their most recognisable and famous song, though wether it's their best is always, and constantly up for debate.
Everyone has their own preferance of course, as no two Pink Floyd concept albums sound alike, and their songs cover and incorporate a broad spectrum and mix of Genres.
From Classic Rock to Country, Symphonic, Orchestral, Classical, Blues, Folk, Synth, Big Band, Acapella, Male Voice Choir, Psychadelic, 80's, New Age, and just about everything else in between, Pink Floyd's got you covered.
Not bad for one group...
Cheers for the reaction video.
Great synopsis of the band.... Thanks James
@@retroreactions....
Thank you.
🤭 For the solo to keep going, you have to watch the Pulse Concert Video version of Comfortably Numb. 🤗 Do The Wall! 😏 I usually suggest DSoTM but, you're a DM fan! 😉 You'll totally "get" the Album. 😊🐰
Been a crazy few days, but should be able to watch the live version tonight. Hmmm, now I'm really curious about The Wall! 26 tracks?! WOW, that's a big undertaking. Looks like I only know 2 songs from it. Interesting that you made the DM comparison...
@@retroreactions.... Huge DM fan since they played NYC in the 80's. Now they just play MSG or Barclays! Expensive but always worth it! 😉🐰
No wonder we get along so well LOL...Awesome! I've been a true fan since around 1987. Didn't get to start seeing them live till 1990, what a tour that was! Also had the extreme luck and pleasure of meeting them backstage twice! ('94 and '09, sadly Dave was not there either time). So excited for the new material!! Been too long...
If you want full gigantic sound try two songs off of Dark Side Of the Moon. Try the song "Time" and then "Us and Them"!
Some of the Floyd songs have long intros Before lyrics starts such as their fabulous song "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" from the "Wish You Were Here" album!!! That's just a few of a massive amount of incredibly great songs by them! You've tripped into a bottomless rabbit hole with these guys! Enjoyed the reaction, keep going......we'll enjoy them together!
Hi Jon. Thanks for the kind words. Us and Them I heard a few times a couple of years ago and instantly loved. Listened to it yesterday and the intro still makes me tear up and goosebumps. I will definitely react to Time and on the channel. I'm a huge fan of long intros, long outros and long songs! For Shine On..., are parts 1-5 better than 6-9? I see they are separated on the album. Are they 2 different songs? Or 1 whole song that needs to be listened back to back?
sorrow is awesome, live
Nice, I'm trying to find ballads by them, as I know those will be my favorites...
great reaction dude..I saw PF in the 80s....check out 'There's No Way Out of Here' on David Gilmour solo album. It is fantastic.
You'll have to watch the live version if you want it to keep going. Pulse concert is the best video version.
Hi Andy. I actually did react to the live Pulse version a few days ago if you're interested..
Check out the classic band Procol Harum, their song "Conquistador" mixes rock and orchestra.. they have many other songs like that.
That one is on the list...thanks Widkey!
Arrrrh! That makes sense, 3 guesses! Who were idols of pink floyd? ( can u draw on tha' similarities ) ❤️🇬🇧😊👋Xxx.
Oh wow that's a tough one....not sure I know enough about 60s music to know. Maybe later Beatles? Won't even try to guess the rest ha...
@Retro Reactions wat band did u mention towards tha' end of yr reaction/conversation! 😊👋
APP? I mean I know he worked with them so that would make sense :)
If you like orchestral mix take a listen to Cakra Khan doing cover of “Iris”(GooGoo Dolls)
If you want the solo to keep going check out the live version of comfortably numb from the pulse concert,it's fantastic .
Sweet I'll def check it out! Thanks Paul
You won’t be sorry!! The voices are even more dark in the Pulse version. This was written by Roger Waters. He went to a Dr before a show which gave him a shot that numbed him. The dark was the Dr speaking to him. All sorts of fuzzy as he was numb. He once said that he has know idea how he even got through the show being his arms and hands were numb!
I watched it yesterday and it blew my mind, and yes it made me cry! Was not prepared. Of course they are masters of live performing, but the multiple voices and harmonies on the verses which I already loved made them even more amazing and haunting. Then the extended solo and light show were off the charts. What legends....thanks again for the suggestion!
Wow crazy story...I'm sure they have lots of those!
Absolutely magical. Yes, it’s funny you said you wanted it to keep going.
This original studio album recording from ‘The Wall’ does fade out quite quickly.
But as all Pink Floyd fans know, we’ve been blessed with phenomenal Live Versions of ‘Comfortably Numb’, with the extended ‘Solo’. I agree with everyone that the Live ‘Pulse’ version is amazing. There are many fantastic performances of it from different Live Shows too. But another incredible performance of it which I personally love and recommend you try, is David Gilmour and his Band, performing back at the Roman Amphitheater at Pompeii, in 2016. Here’s the link below. Goosebumps every time, incredible.
ruclips.net/video/eHKG7EMxWW8/видео.html
I’d also recommend you listen to the Albums, ‘The Dark Side Of The Moon’ (1973), ‘Wish You Were Here’ (1975) and ‘The Wall’ (1979), from beginning to end, as they are all Concept Albums. And there is also of course, the movie of ‘The Wall’, starring Bob Geldof.
These are just my own feelings, of course. Enjoy. 🎶🎸❤️🎸🎶
I keep forgetting it's from that album! I think it's really hard to do full albums on here without cutting out a lot of parts. Gotta figure out soon!
@@retroreactions.... Yeah, fully understand. Maybe in two halves, for your Show.
Or one Vinyl side at a time, as they were originally.
It’s also for your own personal listens though, headphones on,
as loud as possible and eyes closed.
And away you go. 👍🏼 Enjoy. 🎶🎸❤️🎸🎶
@@retroreactions.... I hope you were able to treat yourself to this scintillating version I sent you, Brandon.
Even if just for own personal viewing. Here’s a reminder just in case. You’ll never regret seeing this.
ruclips.net/video/eHKG7EMxWW8/видео.html
🎶🎸❤️🎸🎶
🤗 Cool! 🥰 More PF! 😊🐰
What are your favorites by them and are there any really dark songs musically? Thanks so much for your support!💖
@@retroreactions.... 🤔 Actually, it's their 'Echoes Live in Pompeii'. 😏 It's got a "haunting melody" that sticks in your head. 🤷🏿♀️ Keep in mind these are the Albums I did homework to in JHS & HS at my friend's house. When we did homework at my house, it was Motown & P-Funk! 🤭 She fell in love with Marvin Gaye & Smokey Robinson. 🥰 I fell in love with David Gilmour, Geddy Lee & Roger Daughtry. I was memorized that 🤯 Tina Turner was going to play "The Acid Queen" in the Movie, Tommy. Led Zep, The Song Remains The Same, also left an impression on me. 🤭 🐰
Thanks for the suggestions! Is Echoes live a different arrangement than the studio version, or can I listen to either?
@@retroreactions.... I say do the live video. They film in Pompeii and it is breathtaking. 🥰 Bonus points for the shirtless band members! 😉 I ain't mad at Gilmours nipples making an appearance! ☺️🐰
OK, I know it'll be amazing...shirtless huh? Guessing it didn't happen last month hehe...
same song, live pulse 1994. must must must.
Hi Gerald, thanks. I have already heard it on my own based on other's suggestions... blew me away and yes I cried!
Why'd you skip the first parts??
Hi, didn't realize there was more to the song...I use Spotify and this is where the songs starts on there...
I think you're just to young to appreciate....what about The Beatles
Or Queen???
Jury is still out on you
Ha, I'll take that as a compliment! I'm close to 50 years old so I was alive through most of this music...written songs and been a huge music fan since childhood, attended tons of live shows over the years. I like both those bands you mentioned, though similarly I only know most of their hits, not their deep catalog. Whatever you decide I really appreciate that you watched :)