Mouin Rabbani: Israel, US & ceasefire plan, Gaza, Lebanon, violence, democracy, UN, Modi's India
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
- 🔴🔴🔴
Link for donation: paypal.me/sank...
🔴🔴🔴
Become friends of the show by joining the channel: / @indiagloballeft
🔴🔴🔴
In this video, we discussed with Mouin Ranbani about his thoughts on the ongoing events in Gaza. We asked Mouin about the cease fire plan proposed by the Biden administration. We also asked him about the situation in Israel-Lebanon border. Mouin also commented on whether non violence is the only strategy of resistance available to the Palestinians. We also discussed the roles and responsibilities of the internationalcommunity, including pro Israeli government like that of the US and Modi in India. Mouin discussed the significance of the struggle for Palestinian freedom and its links with democratic movements across the world, including that of the Global South.
🔴🔴🔴
Follow us on
Twitter: / indiagloballeft
Instagram / indiagloballeft
🔴🔴🔴
We are also looking for sponsorships or small donations. If you can, consider giving us what you can. Thanks.
Write to us at indiagloballeft@gmail.com
🔴🔴🔴
Introduction audio by Ronit Bannerjee ( / ronitbanerjee503 )
#iran #israel #us #usforeignpolicy #trump #netanyahu #gaza #hamas #modi #india #palestine #peaceprocess #UN #lebanon #hezbollah
Link for donation: paypal.me/sankymudiar
Guys, we want to work full-time on this, but our financial woes keep us pushing away. If your wallet allows please drop us some support. We prefer the PayPal method since we don't lose half of the money, but you can also give us a super chat. If you are a large donor, we would obviously get in touch with you to give something back if we can. But if you can't no worries. Please like, share, and subscribe. That means a lot already
I do appreciate your truthfulness Mr Rabbani. I wonder if you could put me in contact with someone who could take up my cause. I must use scripture to tell truth. Perhaps you are not religious that is okay with me. However if you would give me some of your consideration I have been spoken to by a person chosen from heaven and I must make known what the writings of the Prophets reveal. Christianity fail to take note of the writings pertaining to the fact that the Palestinians are descendants of Abraham by his wife Keturah who bore six sons to our Patriarch as documented in Genesis 25:1-3. Also 1 Chronicles 2:55 being descendants in Abraham and Keturah's linage mentioning the Kenites by Rechab along with others..
I pray you or someone will recognise how important these facts are. Moses was married to one of Arab descendants of Abraham and Keturah. Her name was Zipporah who bore two sons called Eliezer and Gershom Exodus 2:22 and Exodus 18:3, 4 also 1 Chronicles 26:24-26.
Jeremiah 35:8-19, was instructed to tell the descendants of Rechab they are blessed by our Elohim. I am a descendant of Aaron. I learned this when our Elohim chose a person from heaven to tell me my Elohim would instruct me and teach me bible scripture. I can reveal many prophesies as they have been fulfilled including the second coming of Christ.
You might not accept these truths but I need to make this known to very important people. I would speak with President Netanyahu or any Israelite or President Biden or any other President. I will stand up and make known prophesy and judgment that will come upon anyone who does not repent of all that bloodshed and all the wars and egregious plans for the whole of humanity by WEF who I would be prepared to speak with. Perhaps even black rock globalists. Anyone. I need to give a message from the Most High Elohim Yahveh or Yahuveh-Nissi-Yireh being the name I remember being told and hope my recollection is correct. That whole name refers to the Battle of the Great Day of God the Almighty at Mount Megiddo.
Always a pleasure to listen to Mouin. He is so sensible, clear and calm.
I could see Mouin being very successful with podcasting - of course for his knowledge and insight, but also he has a great "radio" voice. Makes it much easier to take in what he's saying especially if you're only listening and not watching.
I love Mouin Rabbani and we need more people like him, as well as Norm Finkelstein, Ilan Pappe, Gabor Mate, Haim Bresheeth, Sheri Berman, and so on... We are either for peace, love, compassion, mercy, humility, and integrity, or you lack the higher virtues and are for evil.
Remember the new generation of real leftists Aaron Mate, Kshama Sawant, Nick Cruze, and James Fauntleroy, Rome, Max Blumenthal, and many more ❤
@@MetalRat518 Absolutely! And so many others. 💚
Exactly!
They all support terrorism. Where's the compassion in that? They all celebrated Oct 7 knowing full well what was to follow.
Pappe is a zionist and promotes zionism
This gentleman guest is a brilliant commenter on complicated issues---especially (this) one!
Thank you Mouin Rabbani for your answers!
I love what Rabbani has to say!!!! He is so smart!!!!!
Always interesting listening to Mouin
Thank for this most informative conversation with Mouin Rabbani.
Thank you. Excellent discussion.
Thank you for always clarifying you mean the "American government". They absolutely do not represent the will of the people. Great episode. Mr. Rabbani is always a great source of information and analysis.
Thank you. Excellent analysis on a terrible crisis presented in a measured & dispassionate manner. An amazing feat, given the nearly 80 year-long tragedy Palestinians have endured with regards to getting their Sovereignty over their Land recognised.
Nice and rational observations as well as analysis from Rabbani. 👋👋🌺🌺🙏-bmd
Mouin Rabbani is one of the very best. So knowledgeable, incisive. And he has a way with words! Thank you both🙏🏼
Protesting on behalf of Palestinians was made illegal within Israel - why the watermelon became a symbol, since the Palestinian flag was ban in Israel.
that's because of all the democracy , you know...
🍉Protesting injustice always finds its way
If you protest on behalf of Israel in Gaza, what do you think Hamas does to you?
@bidhrohi12 Apples to oranges comparison, is Hamas occupying Israel?
@@bidhrohi12hamas blamer. Cleanser enabler
Thank you! ❤
Free Free Palestine 🇵🇸
From zionist invaders!
.Wow!! Mr. Rabbani's take on israel/Palestine, coming with it facts I hadn't heard, or not heard in this way, makes one feel capable of thinking about the situation. Something about his calm assurance and lack of prophecy makes one's imagination open up. Maybe there is a way. Very grateful for the turn of this conversation, both men seemed so prime for discussion and so polite.
To make their parent's proud!!!
Agree!
Thanks Jyotishman and Mouin!
The world has woken up and seen Israel's true colors and the horrific atrocities they are carrying out against the Palestinian people.
Yes, and we won't forget nor forgive.
The world has always seen the brutality of the Israelis. The reasons anything has changed is the resistance to Israel and the erosion of European total control of the world. Other countries are now trying to break the colonial stranglehold on the rest of the world.
Yes, it's all told here: STOP Occupation by ALYA, please share!
People are also realising how the Zionist control the USA
This guest is a national treasure. We've learned so much.
I had agreed with Blumenthal until the professor said that the Palestinians should decide who and what they are.
Good analysis!
Mouin Rabbani has a refreshingly nuanced view of these issues. Always a pleasure to listen. I just want to point out that Israel has failed to 'wipe out Hamas' by various means for over two decades now. Given that fact, the old threat of continuing to attempt to wipe out Hamas should *not be utilized* to delay acceptance of the cease-fire formula. Women and children of Gaza are currently starving to death and a phase 1 pause in the killing would allow aid to flow. That should be the priority. Seeking some pie in the sky ultimate solution or unobtainable "guarantee" is a great way to use up the current international window of opportunity to take the *first step* toward peace. Similarly, the exchange of hostages/prisoners can not wait for the establishment of a *new leadership on either or any side* of the conflict. American attention in particular will soon shift to domestic politics and opportunity for forward motion will be lost soon. Just sayin...
Thank you. Very interesting and informative discussion 👍👍👍
MOUIN RABBANI IS ONE 1️⃣ OF MY MENTORS AND HEROES
HIS WEALTH OF HISTORICAL FACTS AND HIS UNRUFFLED NATURE ALWAYS COOL AND LOGICALLY ANSWERING THE QUESTION AT HAND
I HAVE TO THANK YOU AND INDIA AND GLOBAL LEFT FOR YOUR EFFORTS TO BRING THE TRUE NARRATIVE TO THE WORLD 🌎 UNFILTERED ....
Thanks, IGL, for bringing the esteemed Mouin Rabbani's objective exposition of the Palestinian plight. I particularly appreciate his view that the intrinsic moral right of the oppressed to engage in armed resistance should never be renounced. In my opinion, Arafat's renunciation of Palestinian armed resistance was the height of historical ignorance that the US is wholly untrustworthy and nefarious in its "foreign policy" and condemned Palestinians to decades of destruction. His observation that it is not for external players to determine Palestinian internal governance is spot on. I would appreciate a further interview that addresses differences among internal Palestinian political and military forces including areas of agreement and disagreement and possible consensus. It appears that Russia and China are working with Hamas and Fatah to that end.
admiration for the kind and assertive empathy Mouin displays when he speaks about Palestinian struggle. thank you for this interview.
Thanks for this. I always learn much from Mouin!
Thank you for having Mouin on. One of my favourite experts on Palestine and the middle east.
smart move to invite Rabbani to your show. He is one of my favorite. You just got a subscription and a big thumb up
Thank you Mouin. It is tough to take that position.
Love Mouin Rabbani’s analysis on the dynamics of Gaza and the Apartheid State.
Thanks for the informative interview.
incredible insight
great. good morning brave and generous educators. a specially charged day. my sympathies go to the martyrs ‘s bereaved in palestine and worldwide and to all of us who have become educated by you. we who will resist all day every day.
Thank you both👏 Wonderful guests Dr. Rabbani is with his impactful delivery, deep insight & expertise. God Bless you both 🙏✌️
Good interview
Conclusion for me: There is a worldwide fight going on against Kolonialism and Neokolonislism.
Moulin explained all elements of the Palestinian war in such great detail. Thanks for sharing such great and factual insight.
Thank you for this conversation, I always enjoy listening to Mouin.
Mouin Rabbani is such an interesting , brilliant expert on this subject! Eloquent and well thought out
Thank you for hosting Maestro Mouin, always illuminating. Free Free Palestine.
Great discussion. Thanks!
Wonderfull interview. Thank you! ❤
Professor Finklestein did himself say thay he was mistaken in believing non violence was the way.
Cool. So you use violence. Then the other side uses violence better, and then you complain that the people you were murdering are better at murdering you. Cute.
He does not want to admit there is something deeply wrong with the Jewish culture and religion.
He actually said zionism itself was antithetical to judaism. Within Palestine, including Hamas' own charter, they do not condemn jews or Jewish religion but zionism. There have, for thousands of years, been Jewish and Muslim Palestinians, peace. In India, my Muslim and Hindu family lived, worked and played side by side until R wing nationalists fascist shift. I won't set foot in India again because of it.
@kindGSL
@@hunger4jsutice I have a 100% American perspective. My EXPERIENCE as a non Jewish, Christian or Muslim American is that most Jews support Israel in both the US and in Israel. I looked up the polls and I check the news. The ones saying this is not about their religion seem to be the small minority. I have been closely watching most of the topical Americans for decades so I know who they are, people like Kaiti Halper, Arron Mate and many others.
I notice their religious arguments are basically nonexistent. They just keep asserting this 'fact' for us to swallow whole. I'm not convinced. I like to study religions. I also feel perfectly qualified to make moral judgements about them. I judge religions by the people they produce. Based on that, and some of its other unsavory details, I think this religion is just awful.
I am not sure how the current replies relate to what i have said. I was only pointing out that the non violent position of Norman Finklestein is outdated, he now says he was mistaken and that non violence has proven to be a non viable option. Regarding jewish support for israel there is no surprise there, however one should be careful not to attribute this to the religion itself but rather to a state of massive brainwashing that led to a strong sectarian identification which supercedes any other consideration or rational argument.
Great interview
Moving is one of the best analysts out there
Fantastic speaker. And so logical and sensible.
Great commentary
Great program, great analysis, Rabbani!
❤️🙏❤️
The world should not allow this level of retaliation. ( if retaliation is even the appropriate word -as I think more will revealed). I could put it this way - : None of this should ever have been allowed.
34:30 I think this cuts to the heart of the issue. The temporary entity doesn't target Lebanese civilians in this war because they understand that Hezbollah has the ability to respond in kind, which must lead one to the conclusion that they are attacking gazan civilians because the temporary entity doesnt believe the gazan resistance can respond in kind. Seems to me the only way to keep Palestinians safe is to arm them with weapons capable of keeping deterrence. Israel wouldnt have responded to 7 October the way they did if they thought the resistance could do unto them what they have done unto the Palestinians.
Agreed, they keep saying humas is using human shields and also that Palestinians are shooting weapons as well..I guess if they are gonna use that bogus argument might as well arm everyone .. I'm white and get called by 🇮🇱 a terrorist , antisemitic ,pro Humas , Humas supporter or talk about my Muslim religion , meanwhile I'm not religious and none of the other claims are true .But maybe instead of sending money to charities in the area , I might as well send them money to arm themselves.
Brilliant!
Dr Rabbani. Is truly a wonderful analysts!
I always learn so much from this very great 🚹
Thanks!
Most Sincerely Michael Foley 🤔
Resistance is normal...violence is involved to negate the right to resistance of occupied and abused populations ... violence is what the dominating force exert on dominated populations...resistance is not violence..
Great information. Great speaker. Thanks
Great conversation
Review of all liberation conflicts by Anti Empire Project concluded that only violent struggle worked when there is colonized / colonizer dynamic.
Thanks!
Thank you so much, really appreciate it.
Mr. Lemkin had repeatedly mentioned in his writings that as a young man he was so troubled by the Armenian mass murders and the then on-going Holocaust that he coined the word genocide and worked tirelessly until the United Nations adopted the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, on Dec. 9, 1948.
Thanks for another informative interview. ❤❤❤🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Palestinians have the right to resist the occupation and its occupiers by all means
The security council must be made more democratic with membership on it changed periodically by vote of the General Assembly for limited terms.
BRICS+ will ultimately decide what happens with security councils and such.
God willing when this is all over we will all help to rebuild Palestine , we all want to . Care for every child, every family, every history, every story, soon very soon 🙏
Talibans have been recognized by America and so many countries ! Then why not Hamas ? 😮-bmd
Hamas also does not want Israel to return as an Occupying Force.
Thanks
Thank you Permjit, it means a lot to us. Stay in touch
Please forgive my reaction, but I just have to say this! Mr. Rabbani looks like the Doctor from Star Trek Voyager!
He does look like Robert Picardo who also played Richard Woolsey in the Stargate franchise. Great actor. Mouin Rabbani is a great geopolitical thinker and speaker.
❤
Good work on your channel, comrades.
Never in the history of mankind has a people achieved liberation and self determination without armed resistance. The idea that if the Palestinian people dropped arms and sang "we should overcome" could end the occupation is ridiculous.
Remember that in the west bank Arafat and his party decided to drop armed resistance against the zionist occupation forces. Since they made that stupid decision Israel has taken more land, built more settlements, killed more civilians and have the best collaboration government you could ask for. Arafat and his party really screwed up with that decision to drop armed resistance
The destruction of the Soviet Union was a blow to national liberation struggles worldwide. And the US and Israel are joined at the hip. Conditions were not there at the time for a successful armed resolution. But in principle, correct. Timing and persistence, in practice.
This current phase of the conflict will be fought to a finish. There will be no going back to pre Oct 7th
Goodbye is Ray Lees..Blinkin🤥 will lose his dual citizenship 😂😀😃🙂
Resistance can only be successful if you can inflict as much damage on your oppressors as they can impose on you. The method of Oppression determines and defines the way one resist.
Minute 27:00: "...the deep chasm between rulers and ruled in the United States." Yup.
Nice discussion. To the interviewer regarding Hamas; you may not be aware of the webinar series on the "The Just World Educational" channel and website on who are Hamas as most in the West don't have a clue and many even in Western Asia may not know a great deal about apart from stereotypes. There are five webinars in the series. In fact the fourth one is a discussion with your guest on your show here as he is one of the world experts on Hamas. The interviewer sort of implied that Hamas wants to be viewed as the legitimate authority of Palestine, I believe that they do not want this and are in agreement with your guest but as always interactions between the different groups are not that straightforward and there is some history. The first webinar may be found here: ruclips.net/video/w3duIG-bPdg/видео.htmlsi=w_UPBvwIW3GAKxa2
Up until the question of Hamas as leadership. Based on Max from Grayzone.i thought this guest was objective and honest. But listening to the non answer to the question. Makes me thibk twice about this man.
The 'non answer' I'm hearing is your ignorance or being hearing-impaired. I listened to an informed expert making sense. I admire Max's guts and a lot of what he does is great but he's not totally uncontroversial in his analyses.
1942 Quote from #Orwell: "Pacifism is objectively pro-fascist, this is elementary common sense"
Ironic, coming from an MI5 snitch.
@@fun_ghoul I think he knew more than us and decided to leave a sort of message.
People change dude. Well, most people do...
@@a.randomjack6661 He did the snitching on his death bed, he started out as a British imperial cop in Burma, and he spent all the time in between shitting on Stalin and Soviet socialism.
Power concedes only to more power , esp if you have psychopaths against u
No wasting time listening to this!
What fun_ghoul said
This man is a lump
Nice of you to come scoop up another dollar, Corntrollio.
@@fun_ghoul hi racist
Is Rabanni defending Israel’s genocide of Palestinians!???!!! Who attacked first?? Who stole territory?? Who occupied illegally??
Rabbani has been a champion of the Palestinians for many years.
You should watch more than 30 seconds of a thing before you pretend to understand, compagna.
I’m glad someone said this! I condemn renunciation of forcible resistance. Don’t be trying to give away other people’s rights.
(It also makes the language of ceasefire under occupation kinda sketchy.)
If Palestine wants peace don't started a war!!!
You obviously don't have a clue and must be too lazy to study history, I don't even believe you are capable of listening to everything that has been said here either. Attention disorder is a disease that increases exponentionaly in modern society. Whenever you're sick, you better see a doctor instead of self diagnosing based on symptoms and getting reasurance in your bubbles. No justice, no peace. ⚖ It's that simple. Start over
Thanks!
Thank you so much, really appreciate it. Solidarity