Elton John: Now & Then (1970-2024)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 авг 2024
- #eltonjohn #gershwin
In this episode I discuss the recent Gershwin Award ceremony awarded to Elton John and Bernie Taupin. Their greatest songs (written between 1970-76) will continue to be celebrated centuries from now.
Check out my other EJ episodes:
• Why Did Elton Fire Dee...
• Reflections On Goodbye...
• Recording with Dee Mur...
• Elton John Guitarist C...
• When Nigel Played On M...
• Elton John Recording E...
If you'd like to support my channel please make a donation at paypal.me/Only...
#eltonjohn #gershwin 
Видеоклипы
The band's breakup in 1975 also broke the magic. I've found every subsequent album interesting in the context of the '70s work, and they often contained a masterwork or two, but the original band had the chemistry of a living unit.
Elton's biggest mistake. I love Qualeb Quaye but come on after he canned Dee and Nigel it went to shit.
I agree. There were songs on Rock of the Westies and Blue Moves that I liked, but I never felt the excitement for the entire album like I did with Yellow Brick Road. I mean, every song on that album was just, ... I don't even have words. I never bought another album after Blue Moves.
Thanks for your comments! Obviously I agree and I really like how you described the original band as a “living unit”. That’s a gift that very few enjoy; and it was a very reckless decision he made to throw that away. It’s no coincidence that his most memorable post 70s songs (I guess that’s why they call it the blues, and I’m still standing) featured his original band. Those three guys along with producer Gus Dudgeon were a very special team. Unfortunately Elton wasn’t able to fully appreciate that blessing. Which is why I said I don’t think Elton understands what made his early music so special. As of now he doesn’t seem to have a clue just how special his early music is; otherwise he wouldn’t enjoy watching it butchered by a parade of such unremarkable pop stars. Thanks again!
Thanks for your comments! Something very special died after Blue Moves. The album after that (single man) was such a shock when I bought it. There was none of the magic and power of the music that preceded it. Then came “victim of love” (an abomination). That’s when I faced the facts about Elton. That’s when I realized he was a different artist. There were a handful of very good songs and three very decent albums after that; but he never again touched the highest peaks again. The last time I saw him live was 2001. He had invited Nigel back in the band and the setlist was full of deep album cuts like Holiday Inn, Meal Ticket, Country Comfort that fit beautifully with tracks from his new album Songs From The West Coast (his last great album). After that he went to Vegas and every show was just the same greatest hits set. I’ve continued to give every new album a fair chance; but I haven’t liked a single song since Captain and The Kid. Everything he’s done since then sounds the same to me. There’s no spark of inspiration anymore.
@@JonBlackstone Yes, EJ is a great composer and performer solo (I saw the show at NYC's Palladium in 1978), but the cumulative power of Dee and Nigel ignited magic. Imagine Jimmy Page switching out Jones and Bonham after IV.
Could not agree more! Elton is a genius and a legend, as well as my rock hero! None of the artists did his repertoire justice! Thank you for your honest evaluation!
Thank you so much for the encouraging comment. I was a little worried about putting it out; but I thought honesty is the best policy point. Thank you for watching!
Completely agree!
Yes, how can one remake a masterpiece? But you can treat it with the respect it deserves.
Jon: "What happened to that Elton John I once knew and loved and admired as an artist?" That person and his voice went somewhere into the ether never to be seen again. Thank goodness he left us with some of the best music ever written and performed in the first half of the '70s.
I really appreciate what you said in your comments. You’re absolutely right. The thing that so hard for me is that that body of work is so important; and Elton John keeps doing everything he can to make it look like a novelty or even worse something from Broadway. As I said, in my video, I really don’t think Elton knows what made his music great. If he did, he wouldn’t be presenting those songs the way he did at the show and in the movie. Thanks again for the great comments!
60 year old American female madly in love with Elton and his music growing up in the 70s.
I agree with everything you say here. It’s sad, so sad, it’s a sad, sad situation, but Mr. John de-Eltonized himself in the late 70s. Probably the drugs, drinking, depression and depraved lifestyle which emptied him out of that God-given genius.
Thank you for the excellent and insightful comments. You put it very eloquently. And I love your quote from the song. Thank you!
I'm you peer here. It's tragic that fame for ones God given talent robs so many of the best of theirs.
Elton turned into Liberace. I’ve tried liking his releases from the 80’s onward but a lot of it is just schmaltz. Like you, I am a massive fan of Elton’s 70’s work and maybe he’s tried to capture that magic but, with a few exceptions, the magic is gone. Great post by the way
I couldn’t agree with you more! In fact, Elton was a very big Liberace fan from early days. It should be no surprise that he’s emulating him now. It’s just so sad. Thanks for the great comments. And the nice compliments!
You are spot on, my friend. I'm so happy that Elton and Bernie received the Gershwin Award as this is a legitimate award for artists who have written original and innovative popular music that becomes iconic and timeless. They are truly deserving. The awards show, however, was just too painful to watch. I saw a promotional clip for it, and that was quite enough. I can hardly stand the fact that the original EJB never gets the recognition and credit they deserve. I saw an online comment somewhere from someone who claimed they were actually there at the show. They said that when the band was introduced, Nigel got a standing ovation. I would have suffered through the show just to see that.
I watched the broadcast, and Nigel and Davie were there playing in the band, but there was no point when the band was introduced. In fact, the camera never filmed Nigel at all. So I’m not sure what your friend was talking about? That was one of the points I mentioned in the video how disappointed I was when Alton was talking about the band the camera filmed all the other guys, but never filmed a Nigel. Anyway, the whole thing was disappointing. It seems that I’m not alone in that feeling. Thanks so much for commenting!
I'm inclined to think that the band introductions actually took place but were edited out in favor of devoting more time to the "performers." Incredible.
@@girlsgotgame2351OMG I shudder to think it... But yes, You are probably right and it speaks to Jon's outstanding "mediocrity" video.
Couldn't agree more about Mitchell changing the lyrics...when you're honoring a lyricist that's the last thing you should do.
I couldn’t agree more. You said so much and you’re short comments. Thank you!
Couldn't agree more. You said how I have felt for decades. Thankful for those years. My favorite music
Thanks for watching, and your great comments!
Jon:to answer your question: NO! You are NOT crazy! More like spot on!
Thank you good sir! I appreciate the support and thank you for watching!
Elton had such a great voice once and the 70’s Albums were part of my life growing up.
This video nails my thoughts exactly.
Sorry, I’m just now seeing your comment. I couldn’t agree more. He had the most amazing voice when he was young. His older voice is interesting; but nowhere near as versatile or unique as his young voice. Thanks for watching!
This is one excellent video! I agree that the 70's was his best time period. When Elton stopped working with Bernie at the time A Single Man came out, that's when I knew Elton's career started to go down the drain.
Thank you so much for watching and for your comments! I was a little afraid about being so bold; but I’ve been receiving so much positive response to this video. It’s really nice to know I’m not alone and feeling the way I do. Thanks for watching!
As a nine-year-old in 1971, I was turned on to Elton/Bernie because of Levon. Elton has been my musical crush ever since. To hear your take, and to see many of these performances, I am majorly upset. It all seems so shallow. Bernie is arguably the best lyricist of the rock era. Elton's band in the early 70s never got the credit they deserved because they were overshadowed by an ICON.
I really appreciate what you wrote in your comments. Honestly, I couldn’t agree with you more; especially about the honor not paid to Bernie. However, Bernie seems totally happy during the show so I have to assume that he’s on board with all of this. I just don’t understand it!
@@JonBlackstone I'm reminded of the video clip of Sting wincing when Jose F. butchered his song during a tribute event.
@@pattipostcard8489That’s a perfect illustration of how I felt watching the “tribute”. Too bad Elton had the opposite reaction.
@@JonBlackstone Well, what else is Bernie going to do? I mean, his face and body language may not reveal how he truly feels. I would bet that after a lifetime of being in Elton's shadow he might be kind of used to it by now? And I really don't mean any disrespect, but I think it's like you said. Elton is a "celebrity" now. I too, had the offer of a ticket when the farewell tour came to Birmingham but I declined it like you did. I just couldn't do it.
Jon, you have the greatest collection of Elton photos! I am always seeing ones in your videos that I have never seen before. Regarding that Gershwin concert: I watched it on PBS and thought that Annie Lennox & Brandi Carlile & Jacob nailed their performances. I must say that I am glad that Jacob didn't simply copy "Bennie and the Jets" but, rather, made it his own and did it with originality & with spirit. I am still trying to come to grips and form an opinion on the "I Still Standing" performance. Agreed, not enough attention is given to Elton's "music" these days and in honouring the musicians (Dee, Nigel, Davey, Ray, Caleb, Roger, James, Kenny, etc.) who played such a creative important role in Elton's earlier landmark albums. Dee, Nigel, and Davey could easily have received some nod or attention in "Rocketman." I, too, felt a little sad watching the movie and not seeing ANY nod to EJ's great musicians. Producer Gus Dudgeon and arranger Paul Buckmaster were also instrumental (pun intended!) in creating that Elton sound and deserve a little more applause. I keep waiting for Elton to get inspired by young new musicians known for their playing of their instruments rather than their ability to sing basic pop songs. He is a life-long chart watcher and wants to be relevant and it shows in his decisions. I do feel your sense of loss in terms of writing and performing MUSIC that matters. I could not handle "Cold Heart" being done in a karaoke fashion on the FAREWELL YELLOW BRICK ROAD. I'd rather see "Hercules" or "Madman Across the Water" or "Tonight" or... Yeah, "pop" music (in general) now lacks risk-taking, chord changes, tempo changes, instrumental playing, etc. which leaves it derivative and way too familiar. There is very good music being written today but you have to look frequently outside of the hit charts to find most of it. Elton seems fixed on watching and connecting to the artists on the hit charts. Is this a way, in his mind, to stay relevant and "happening?" I appreciate that he helps young artists. We are more likely to see Elton working with younger musicians in the future rather than attempting something ambitious with a band like BLUE MOVES...a flawed but incredibly interesting, vital, and brave album performed from the heart covering so many genres without commercial appeal being the focus. At that Gershwin concert, it would have been a true treat seeing Elton perform "Tonight." Hearing Elton say that seeing "Cold Heart" go to #1 on the UK charts a few years ago meant the world to him made me very sad. It wasn't a new song, it didn't involve Elton lifting a finger, but it did make him "relevant" on the charts again...
Thank you Douglas for your insightful comments! As I read the comments, people are posting I’m amazed at how many people feel the same things I do. And I tried to make it clear that this is just my opinion. It seems that you enjoyed this tribute more than I did, but I can understand the reasons why. I just got a terrible feeling from the entire thing. And I think you encapsulated the reasons why. Thank you for the great comment.
Great perspective Jon!
Thank you friend I really appreciate it!
100% accurate assessment!
Thank you for the vote of approval! And thank you for watching!
Jon, this video was well worth the wait. I do 1000% agree with you on all points covered.
I couldn’t even watch the majority of the clips of the show. It was just appalling from the standpoint of a really hardcore Elton and Bernie fan.
I read Bernie’s autobiography recently , he has so many other interests, I don’t think he cares to be honored, but he cares for Elton and is there to support him.
Rocketman, the movie, should have been on Broadway. I feel it wasn’t the story I wanted to see. I wanted to learn something about him and his start I didn’t already know but it was all the same. The opening of the movie should have told us something about where we were headed in this film.
If you notice all shows are like this now. It’s all focused on the new and shiny, regardless of talent. There was a time where I couldn’t wait for the Grammy nominations/show and now I wouldn’t watch it for all the money in the world.
Also if you notice, Elton likes to associate himself with the new and the shiny artist. The collaboration with Dua Lipa was horrible!! All it turned out to be is a series of lyrics from his hits mashed into one new song.
I could go on but the 1970’s Elton we love so much is only now in our memories.
Fantastic video Jon - so happy to see you so passionate about our beloved Elton John ❤
I’m not surprised to discover I really love what you wrote. I feel the same exact way about the Grammys; are used to love watching the Grammy awards. But now it’s like a parade of mediocrity. If you read the other comments, there are some folks that are angry at me for sharing my negative views. I think that’s what separates people like you and I from other fans. There are some fans that just absolutely love everything that Hilton touches; but there are other fans more discerning. When I saw that Elton was dedicating, four minutes of his final tour to leading the audience in a karaoke version of “cold heart“ I knew than that the Elton I once loved is long gone. It makes me so sad. Thank you for the kind words about this video. I’m really proud of it because it incorporates some comedy and I really enjoyed that aspect of editing and producing it. As always, thank you so much for your kind words!
@@JonBlackstone thank you! We are definitely likeminded on this subject.
I did see some of the responses that were posted and I feel they didn’t get your point, especially about changing the lyrics. At a private party or some other function, it would have been appropriate but not at the prestigious Gershwin Awards.
I completely agree with you about the Elton John movie. I love Elton John the singer/songwriter musician but not so much the celebrity caricature of Elton. The film was so stylized it focused on production numbers and costumes. A dramatic film or documentary ideally should focus on the music and the musicians who helped create it.
Thanks for watching! As I suspected I’m getting some mixed feelings about this episode. But I was expecting that! Thanks again.
The movie completely sucked!
@@bradalexander6295I couldn’t agree more!
It bothered me that they had songs in the wrong time frame, etc. But Elton seemed to love it and said he cried at some part or parts. It's baffling to me.
@@pattipostcard8489”Baffling” is a perfect word to describe how I felt. Glad to know I’m not the only one.
You've got some fantastic pictures there as well that I have not seen before.❤
Thank you so much for watching! I’m so glad you appreciate the photos in my video. I’ve been searching for decades for cool and unusual photos. I’ve been collecting them for so long. Whenever I’m looking at photos, I always choose the ones that remind me of the way I felt when I was discovering Elton’s music as a kid in the 70s. I focus on the pictures that present him as an artist; as opposed to a joke. Thank you so much for the great comments!
I was disappointed with the Gerswhin program also. I'm a die-hard Elton fan, and I prefer to hear the original versions. I truly love Joni Mitchell, but I am appalled with her version of "I'm still standing". How could she do such a thing??!! When will the music industry recognize and honor Davey, Dee & Nigel? They were an integral part of Eltons sound and success. You're not wrong Jon!!!
Thank you so much for your great comments! I, too, am frustrated by the lack of respect that the Elton John band receives. However, I believe that a lot of that is because of Elton. Elton makes it very hard to take his music seriously; and I really believe he’s been a detriment to his own legacy, and that his band members. if you ask the average person about Elton John, they can’t help but think of the diva image he’s embraced for so long. It hasn’t served his music well. Anyway, thanks so much for watching!
Oh thanks so much ! I’m not alone ! You are so right ! I feel the exact same way about the Rocket Man movie and this show. Thanks for your focus in previous videos on Dee, Nigel, Gus and the backing vocals.
You are very welcome! Thank you for the great comments and thank you for watching!
Elton is many things...enjoy the whole lot always.
Absolutely fantastic have a wonderful day ❤😊
Thank you! You too!
I fast-forwarded through the Gershwin Awards show for the same reasons you did-- it's not about artistry any more, it's about razzle-dazzle and acrobatics. Absolutely nothing appealed to me about the show- it was like a series of bad Elton John tribute bands. Throughout your video I was hoping you'd pull up the 1973 documentary scene where Elton said he wanted to be a legend, and you delivered. The point where Elton started cozying up to the celebrities and royals was the moment he lost the artistic integrity he'd built with his 1970s albums. Even Bernie alluded to this in his autobiography, saying "I can't relate to that world." They should have approached the award show the way they did "Two Rooms," where the *songs* were the focus-- it wasn't perfect, but it zeroed in on what made his partnership with Bernie great. Bonus points to you for using "The Sinatra Group" sketch, but I'm sure you could have easily fit in "BOB GOULET- THAT'S NOT TALENTED." 🤣
Oh man, I love your comments! Seriously, I can’t believe you brought up the Robert Goulet quote! 😂🤣😂 I almost put in the “chunks of guys like you in my stool” but thought it might push things over the edge! I really love your comments. Thank you!
I just read your comments again. You were so right on. I could not have said it better!
@@JonBlackstone "The Sinatra Group" is one of my 5 all-time favorite SNL skits-- I use phrases from that one all the time. "Swing, baby, you're platinum!"
@@jtlynn23 you and I could be great friends! 😂😂😂
@@jtlynn23 I suspect you are a huge fan of Phil Hartman like I am? I put him and Dan Aykroyd in the same category. Both were absolutely brilliant comedic actors.
It's so sad! You nailed this subject.
It’s been nice to receive so much agreement on this subject. It makes me feel good that I’m not alone. Thanks for watching!
Since Joni Mitchell changed the lyrics, and the arrangement/melody was also altered, wasn't she in effect performing a different song?
I agree! One of the other viewers commented about the fact that Joni had asked permission of Bernie and Elton to change the words to the song. To me, the fact that she even asked is questionable. As an artist, she should’ve honored Bernie by performing the song the way he wrote it. As I mentioned in the video Elton and Bernie seem so excited about it; but I found nothing to be excited about. Even as a Joni Mitchell fan I found nothing to get excited about. Anyway, thanks for your great comments!
It was dreadful😮🥰
@@sallyanne9430I completely agree!
That Kennedy Center honor to Led Zepplin where Heart did Stairway to Heaven had me crying!!
Yes, that’s what I call a tribute! If only the Gershwin award have been like that. Thanks so much for watching!
Jon, I felt the same way about the performances on the Gershwin Award Show. Somebody had to say it. You are not crazy….lol.
Thank you for letting me know. I really appreciated hearing from folks who agree with my assessment. Thanks for watching!
Thank you for your videos. I had wondered for a long time why exactly I don't connect with Elton's stuff after the 1970's. And, no, you are not crazy. Nothing landed for me either among the Gershwin award performances. It was better and richer work in the early days. Makes me want to go back and dust off those albums!
Sorry, I’m just now responding to your comment. Thank you for your kind words. And thank you for sharing some of your own experience. I really love hearing from people who love this music as much as I do. Thanks for watching!
Seen Elton in concert in Las Vegas 1975 & Oklahoma 1984. I agree with everything in this video production. I must admit I walked out of the movie rocket man!
Thanks for watching and sharing your own thoughts about the Elton movie. It actually broke my heart to see how out of touch Elton has become about his own musical legacy.
Hi John,
Thanks for your thoughtful reply. I am 70 years of age and I have loved Elton since 1970, in other words, from the beginning. I loved his music through 1975 and then less during the drug-alcohol-influenced years until Elton achieved sobriety in 1990. Then he started to make great music again, not on the same other worldly plane of the early 1970s, but really great music, in my opinion. And I love “The Lion King,” “Billy Elliott,” “Aida,” and the other songs I mentioned previously. I believe your post and point-of-view would receive a far different assessment on platforms such as the Rocket Club and Friends of Elton John. Elton nurtures young artists, he always has and he always will. Your critique of the Gershwin prize show is the first negative one I read along then with the others who posted in agreement. One thing I noticed in the comments following your post was that people kept talking about watching “clips.” This tells me a whole bunch of people did not actually watch the whole show. I think one has to watch the whole show, not just individual clips. I also find it interesting that you mention Elton’s flamboyant side and how that was front and center on the Gershwin show. I think the 23-year-old who wore hot pants and kicked over his piano stool at the Troubadour in August 1970 was pretty flamboyant. I see the Gershwin show and Elton’s career since 1990 very differently. He likes sharing success with others and while I don’t enjoy some of the artists he likes, there are quite a few who are wonderful: Billie Eilish, Ed Sheeran, The Killers, The Scissor Sisters - all are artists whose careers benefitted immensely from Elton’s support. Yes, I agree that Elton and Bernie’s legacy will be carried by their wondrous work from the early 70s. But overlooking the music that came after, especially after 1990, is just a shame because a lot of it is really good. As for Bernie, he never wanted to be in the limelight, he just wanted to write the stories that became the lyrics to amazing songs. He says this in interview after interview after interview, consistently, through the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s through today. I have watched so so many videos related to the world of Elton and Bernie. It is how I found you, actually. One other thing. I was never a big fan if Liberace, but clearly many were. I do not believe the comparison of Elton to Liberace is a fair one at all and it seems to be meant to diminish them both. Anyway, thank you for listening. We can agree to disagree, but I am in lock step with your assertion that Elton and Bernie’s music - a whole big chunk of it - will endure forever.
Thanks for your reply! I hope you know I welcome the views of all. Everything I said in my video is just my personal opinion. As I said in my last comment, there are two distinct Elton John fans. One group are the folks that join his fan club and really enjoy everything about him and what he does. The other group is only interested in his music. I am one of those folks. I don’t like who Elton has become these days. I don’t appreciate his constant focus on his sexuality. I have nothing against the the sexuality itself; but I think it’s tacky and embarrassing to constantly obsess about sexuality. I’ve never liked it in any artist; especially modern pop artists. It seems like Elton is more of an activist these days than an artist. He and David seem more interested in promoting LGBT above anything else. I didn’t like it when John Lennon became a political activist either. Activism has never been a good thing for the artists I admire. So I understand that some people really love Elton John as a personality, a celebrity and a promoter of young gay artists. I’m not one of those people. And it seems that the two camps are very different from one another (as is made obvious by the overwhelming comments on this video). Anyway, I just want everyone to know all views are welcome and to say thank you for responding!
So glad I found your channel you and I are about the same age and have very similar taste especially regarding the recognition of the greatness that was the band not just Elton during 70-76. He was my first favorite artist and Captain Fantastic is one of my all time favorite albums of any genre any time. And they were a band, Elton was the musical arranger, lead vocalist and piano player of this exceptionally tight band, he was not a solo artist until later and you eloquently expressed what happened and where his head was at. He is not alone though so many of our musical heroes from the Golden Age of music have turned out to be real authoritarian putzes. :-(
I couldn’t agree more.
Thank you for the night of approval. It seems that most people feel the same way, which took me by surprise. I’m glad to know I’m not alone. Thanks for watching!
Jon, as usual, beautifully produced video. You do a great job. And yes, the performances during the Gershwin award show were pretty trite. Very Hollywood and "fabulous."
I frankly couldn't take much of it seriously. But Elton can still be an artist when he chooses. Examples being The Diving Board, Songs From the West Coast, or the Union.
Yet, he is also an entertainer in the classic showbiz sense. That is your conflict. The showbiz entertainer versus the artist. Bernie has expressed the same frustration as you regarding that conflict for decades. He generally, like you, doesn't like the cheesy Donald Duck suit wearing showbiz guy. For you, it seems hard to get past. I can understand it, but I guess I'm just not as much of a purist as you. Elton is a showbiz guy, but he is still an artist as well. He can and is both.
Much respect Jon. Keep doing your thing.
Thank you for the kind words, Michael; and thanks for watching. I really appreciate it!
Not my friend you have not ruffled any feathers at least not on anyone that is familiar with his 70s work I agree 100% with everything that you said every single word and I felt the exact same way. I am a fan that knows every word to every song in the 70s, I still think he’s one of the greatest of all time and his voice had gotten so poor. It was time for him to retire. I will remember him from the 70s always his music from the 70s will live on forever. Thank you for your channel. thank you for your comments and again for having great taste!
Thank you for the great comments. I agree with every word you said as well. Thanks for watching!
Well, you certainly didn't ruffle by feathers! I think you're exactly right about the performers taking songs from Elton and Bernie's classic period (1970-1976) and performing them like over the top broadway songs. I found it fascinating, but not all that enjoyable from an artistic point of view.
Thanks for watching and your great comments! I agree with every word you said (as you can tell from the video). It’s really sad that Elton makes such a fool of himself. He could have been remembered as The Beatles of the 70s; but he’s always doing something that stops people from taking his music seriously. The Gershwin ceremony was a perfect example.
Elton fan of 50 years here! I enjoyed every single performance at Gershwin - even covered Metallica's version of FFAF-LLB. I have all the deep respect in the world for both Elton and Bernie - still a massive fan today. I thought Joni's interpretation was really cool, even with different words. Loved Annie Lennox's singing of Border Song, a song that has kind of been lost to the ages ever since it was dropped from all the GH packages after the first one. My only real issue was that both Davy and Nigel were there but no one made any mention of them, and of course no mention of Dee. On the other hand, while they were easily the best band he ever had, I'm not sure they should get credit for launching Elton - he was already well launched by the time they made it onto the records as a unit with Honky Chateau in 1972.
Might I suggest the artists onstage were showing us exactly what the music meant to each of them personally, which to me does make a great tribute, even if it's different from the original. It gave us a sense of how it hit other people and affected them. Just something to consider. Appreciate your covering this event, and so glad to see Elton and Bernie celebrated for their talents.
Thanks for your comments. Actually, Nigel and Dee were part of the three piece band that played at the troubadour in Los Angeles. That was the gig that launched Elton‘s career. Prior to that point Elton was flailing and almost about to give up. So Nigel and Dee are a huge part of launching Elton’s career based on that amazing gig at the troubadour in Los Angeles. Davey Johnstone played on madman across the water and became a permanent member on the next album. I would say the records Elton made with Dee, Davey and Nigel are the most important records he made. Centuries from now, Elton will not be remembered for the Lion King or anything he released after 1976. Centuries from now people will be listening to the records he made between 1970 and 1976. Thanks for watching!
Right there with you…those years were incredible…if you ever saw the Library of congress tribute to Paul Simon…that’s how you pay genuine appreciation for an artist…you can still put your own artistic variation on an artist song …but give it it’s due…or check out Boyce avenues cover of Your Song…that’s how you pay your respects to an artist.Some artist stay true to their roots and still sound good as they age. Nancy Wilson…James Taylor…Mark Knofler…Billy Joel. I understand things change as you get older. I saw Elton in the 70…wow…..saw Billy Joel and Elton together…wow…and like many had no desire to see his final tour. Sorry to offend him or any of his fans. Thought maybe it was just me.
Thanks for watching and the great comments! As you know I agree!
I'm so with you Jon!! How can I contain myself to a comment section on ones so profound and prolific as Elton John, Bernie Taupin & Dee, Davey and Nigel! I watched the Gershwin awards 3x as a self check. 1st, crushing BIG on Nigel at age 9 as an aspiring drummer, I was STUPEFIED at camera fixed on THE OTHER (dancing) percussionist. Where the hell was Nigel?? He only launched Elton's career and fortune. Did the floor crew screw up the notes? Unless Nigel specifically said, "I have acne, don't put me on camera," I don't get a mistake of that magnitude. That's straight out of the box my TOP complaint. Unforgivable.
I do love Annie and Brandie...So no quibbles. They did what they do and they did it flawlessly. Their voices worked with the tone of the music and they held to its feel. Kept reminding myself that, yes, Jon, in fact Elton hand picked these performers. I could critique each but you already did and I agree with you adding I admire the genius of Joni's recordings, and God bless her for crawling back from a stroke. But... 😮
My overall take is Elton has made a point to be relevant with performers who he thinks are on the rise, especially LGBTQ, so the rising tide lifts all boats, keeping him relevant at 75. This makeover I long attributed to David Furnish, a strategy to provide ongoing income for Elton's notorious spending and a nest egg for the children.
Frankly, I think Elton doesn't give himself and his music enough credit. A revenue stream often follows self esteem. Perhaps it is an after-effect of growing up gay in his generation despite his global success.
That's the only explanation I can find for some of his musical affiliations, on the Gershwin show and off, who shall remain nameless.
While I thought some of the show's performers we're charming, I would rather have a dynamic more straight up to the music than theatrics, as you reference. But again it's what Elton wanted; and there was some talent there, save 2 pitiful performers. The audience can figure that out.
My Elton John in 1973, age 8, was my first musical passion. First album collection. Grew the catalog backward and forward every birthday and Christmas to Rock of the Westies & Here and There.
I saw Sir Elton in the 2000s, 2nd row Boston Garden, gobsmacked to be in his aura and wept throughout. He could have filed his nails on stage and that would have been fine for me. And like you, I don't need to hear him live anymore. I will adore him always, and weep like a baby should he proceed me. But he is now the stuff of legends and not the passionate singer-songwriter who touched this child's soul.
I’m sorry I’m just now seeing your excellent comments. I really appreciate you sharing from your own experiences. Your story sounds very similar to mine. I hope you check out my other videos. I think you’ll find them equally wonderful. It’s great to hear from you and I hope to hear from you again!
good channel!!
Agree with you about Joni and the whole show
Thank you very much for letting me know. I’m actually shocked how much people seem to agree with my assessment. I thought I was alone in my feelings. It’s pretty obvious I’m not which is kind of sad. Thanks again!
Hi Jon, Yes it made me mad! Pathetic is the right word! Most artists not a patch on the talent gone by. I agree with everything you said. also I know what you mean about the recent concert, where you refused the tickets .
I hated it when everyone started playing in the stadiums and arenas. With everybody walking round posing 😂 lots of people have no idea do they about Elton!🥰 I was still love to see him again if he ever does a small concert, I know he's not the same, but I'm sure he's still more talented than a lot of artists today🤔😘
Thanks for the great comments Sally. As you already know, I agree with every word you said. Thanks for watching!
John since your a fan of Kinevil here is a more extended report . The World of Sport was a Saturday morning tv program in England . They talked about Evil Kinevil jumping the Grand Canyon ! But he couldn’t get a license so then the jump went to Snake River canyon, we were obsessed with the notion . Then in 1975 Evil Kinevil was going to jump in London on a Saturday. On the day the tv coverage went on all morning and I sat there waiting . Then my mother announced we had to go out to a shopping centre to pay the tv rental . In 1975 we were renting a black and white tv ! I said but no wait this is a big day for me and I need to watch Evil Kinevil jump ! No we are going out to pay the tv rental . So I never saw the jump and when we came back my friends told me Evil Kinevil was dead ! I was standing in the street in tears . I was devastated . I was 8 years old. He didn’t , but he crashed in a massive way and left Wembley in an ambulance with all kinds of injury. I didn’t see the jump until I was 47 . Watched a history of evil Kinevil that included the jump . Back to 1975 it must have been that Xmas and I got the motorbike toy . Incredible toy and I recreated different jumps with books and cardboard ramps .
Wow, what a great story! I really appreciate you sharing that. It’s so interesting to know that a young kid in England could be so interested in evil Knievel. I was a kid at that time too, and I never could’ve imagined it. I had the same toy and I loved it so much. Thanks so much for these great comments. And thank you for watching!
I had no idea about the award or the tribute concert until I watched this video. From what you showed, I absolutely agree. Especially that Jacob Lusk performance of Bennie and the Jets --- at first I couldn't tell if that was one of the SNL parody clips you were showing for contrast. I had to look it up to be sure. I also agree with what you said about Joni Mitchell. I think she is being somewhat manipulated by a coterie of sycophants and "protectors" (a la Eugene Landy's crew), such as Brandi Carlisle, who seems to try to upstage Mitchell every time they're on stage together. Why is Carlisle even on stage with Mitchell all the time anyway? In that comeback concert, Carlisle was doing a pantomime similar to what we saw all evening at the Elton show, as if she was pointing at herself and gesturing to the audience, "You have me to thank for this historic moment. Look at how much I'm diggin' this!" So there we see Carlisle again on stage with Mitchell at the Elton/Bernie tribute, and I suspect it was her and others prompting, or at least encouraging, Mitchell to change the words and "sing her life." It was the wrong moment to do that.
By the way, I love your editing and your humor. You seem to know classic comedy as much as you do music.
I can’t tell you how much I appreciate your comments. You really made my day. First, I agree with every word you said; and you’re so insightful in your observations about Brandi Carlile and Joni Mitchell. Second, it made me so happy that you appreciate my humor and the way I incorporated classic comedy into this episode. As I was editing I was laughing hysterically. I enjoyed putting this episode together so much! I think it might be my favorite episode ever. I’m going to start incorporating that kind of comedy into my videos from now on. Thank you so much for the great comments; I really truly appreciate them!
As huge an EJ fan as I am *70-76* I never bothered watching the movie (thank God) after seeing that ridiculous trailer- I was wise enough to wait a few months for his autobiography
Very good move. Don’t ever watch the movie. Thanks for watching my video though!
when jacob lusk introduced bennie and the jets he said “a hero… and HIS name is bennie” bennie is a girl! that killed me
i must say i love brandi’s various performances of madman across the water. i think she gets the song and is a great performer
Thanks for pointing that out. I noticed that too. It was just further illustration of how detached he was from the heart of the song. I agree Brani was the highlight of the show which makes sense as she’s a true blue Elton fan. Thanks for watching!
Hey, Jon! Great video! I did like the Gershwin Prize Ceremony, but there was something a little off about it when I watched at the time, and now listening to your perspective, I realize that it did not really honor the musical genius of Elton, Bernie, and the band, at all, and just played to the celebrity caricature of Elton John, as you said. Thank you for posting this. Keep it up with the great content, especially the Elton stuff!!
Hi Matthew! Thanks for the great comments. I really like how you expressed your feelings about it. “Celebrity caricature” is a perfect way to describe it. Thanks for the kind words and thank you for watching!
Jon, I agree with you 100% on both this and the Rocketman movie. The unbelievably great music is overshadowed by what I refer to professional “gayism”. Like most of his fans I don’t care a fig that he’s gay but now it seems to be paramount to put that ahead of what was a decade of incredible songs that were turned into even more incredible records!! Btw I have worked as recording engineer, arranger, and session keyboard player. I’ve had some good Facebook conversations with Paul Buckmaster who along with Gus were my 2 biggest musical heroes growing up. Also, I thought you would like to Dave’y Johnstone’s star licks video is on RUclips. I look forward to your videos and having many conversations with you. Cheers Tom Flowers
Thank you, Tom for the excellent comments! I totally agree with your assessment. Like you, I don’t care at all about Elton’s sexuality; but it seems like he is focused on that in everything that he does. Why? It all just feels so pretentious and forced, and unnecessary. I also believe it’s a reason why Elton’s music hasn’t been taken more seriously. He’s his own worst enemy. That’s very cool that you spoke with Paul Buckmaster! He and Gus Dudgeon are huge influences in my life as well. The body of work between 1970 and 1976 is so amazing and it seems like Hilton really doesn’t understand what made it so amazing. Anyway, thank you for the great comments!
Love this video and your insight! I thought Mettalica did a fabulous job. I guess as long as Elton and Bernie were happy with the other performances is all that matters. Keep up the great work, I love your stuff!
Thanks for the kind words and thanks for your comments!
Couldn't agree more! Personally, I became physically ill trudging through that awful program! Silly, awful performers making a mockery of that beautiful music! Is it just me but when the 70-76 period is ever brought up to EJ he just kind of shies away from giving thoughtful succinct answers about the book of work and it's performers. To me EJ, Bernie, Davey, Dee, Nigel, Ray Cooper and Gus Dudgeon are the Elton John Band! Honorable mention to Caleb Quay.
Thanks for the great comments, Brad. The words “silly, awful“ or a perfect way to describe that show. I’ve come to realize that there are fans who love Elton the celebrity; and fans who love his great music. The former are the types that show up at concerts dressed in feathers and crazy glasses; the latter are the types that show up to the concerts to listen to the music and wish the others would stop dancing in the aisles. Elton has two very distinct fan groups. It’s very much the same for most famous music artists. When it comes to most artists I’ve always been all about the music. Thanks for your great comments. I couldn’t agree more.
I've been playing guitar in musical theater pit orchestras as a part-time gig for about 25 years now. Over the past few years I've noticed audience members whooping and cheering anytime a singer holds out a note for more than 2 measures (really???). Even Broadway shows are turning into American Idol performances - it's no longer about the show or the music; it's about who can perform the best vocal acrobatics these days. Long gone are the days where an artist (like early-70s Elton) can sit at a piano and keep an audience entertained for hours. These days you need dancers, light shows, prerecorded tracks, and a dozen video screens to keep our ADHD audience members' attention. All this stuff went through my head when I watched these performances on PBS a few weeks ago. Honestly I felt that Metallica were the only ones that at least came close to being faithful to the original songs they were covering (and they did as best as a 4-piece metal band could do with those songs). Overall though, my reaction to the show was "meh". And I'm equally confused by Elton's duets with Dua Lipa and others...Elton doesn't need to "stay relevant" in that way...the guy's already a legend. Sometimes I think it's not a bad thing for an artist to call it a day and let his legacy speak for itself. OK, rant over. Another great video, brother!
I agree with most of this, but I have to disagree with the position that " Long gone are the days where an artist (like early-70s Elton) can sit at a piano and keep an audience entertained for hours"-- the best concert I've ever seen was Leonard Cohen on his last tour in 2009-- the guy had the entire Chicago Theatre, over 3000 of us-- completely spellbound for almost 2 hours. The guy strummed a guitar a couple times and did his little keyboard riff on "Tower of Song," and there were no pyrotechnics, musical or otherwise. I'd put Elton and Bernie up there with Cohen as legends, and I think many of us would want to see an Elton performance sans the American Idol treatment.
Wow! Such great comments! You said things I wish I thought of saying when I made the video. I love what you said about singers on Broadway “holding a note more than two seconds“. It’s so true that people are now excited by the most unremarkable talent. Everything is X Factor or American idol. There is great music out there but you have to dig for it just like you said. Thank you for the great comments!
I think too many toss aside Elton's later work for his work of the 70's. Granted, he will never repeat that era in popularity, and his work during that era is absolutely timeless - but there have been many, many highs since, even through the doldrums Geffen period of the late 80's. Many rank LEATHER JACKETS as his lowpoint, but it still had "Paris," "Slow Rivers," "Hoop of Fire," "Go It Alone" ...
Are his albums hit or miss since his classic period? That is debatable, honestly. There are obvious lowpoints, but every artist has their ups and downs. Elton has bounced back so many times, you can never really count him out. Even in his classic period there was the mediocre CARIBOU and ROCK OF THE WESTIES, and in the 2000's Elton delivered the classics SONGS FROM THE WEST COAST and PEACHTREE ROAD.
I think the problem with others performing Elton's songs is that it's hard to top the originals. I would say that it has only been done a handful of times - Sinead O'Connor's "Sacrifice" comes immediately to mind. I think Elton's songs have become so ingrained in our brains that it's hard to hear other versions. That said, with a couple of exceptions, I agree with you on the performances at the Gershwin Prize awards. I think Brandi Carlile and Annie Lennox did the best, and Charlie Puth was okay. Everyone else did seem to make it about them, especially Garth. I would have loved to hear more of the lesser known songs, the deep cuts. I really think that is where a cover would shine. We really don't need to hear his hits ruined - like I said, It's hard to imagine anyone topping Elton's originals on those.
Thanks for the great comments! After 1976 I generally like 1-3 songs off each album until The Union. I’m sad to say I haven’t liked a single song he’s released since Captain and The Kid. I really like songs from the West Coast and I think that’s his greatest album. Post 1976. I know that a lot of people like a lot of his later stuff; but to me, it just pales in comparison, both compositionally and lyrically. For instance, I can’t think of a single song after 1976 that you could compare with tracks like“come down in Time, goodbye, yellow brick Road, someone saved my life tonight, ticking, tonight”. He’s definitely written some good songs but he’s never touched the greatest of his 1970s work again. A lot of his material since the lion king has sounded the same to me almost like he’s rewriting the same songs over and over again. I don’t know I just don’t share that magic anymore. But I know some people dig it. I’m always just speaking for myself; I don’t want to take away any joy others get from his later music. Thanks for the great comments!
Well-stated. Tonight and Ticking are in my top 10, with Levon being #1.
Amazing video Jon.
You’re not wrong nor did you miss anything. RIP Elton John Band 1970-1975. Im even ok with Westin’s and Blue Moves. London 77….great show.
After - the music and the overall vibe….I’ll pass.
Again excellent video Jon.
That was supposed to say Westies……
Thanks for watching! Yes, I love those last two albums! I don’t love them as much as the previous ones; but they are still when Elton is in his zone. And they have charms of their own. Thanks for the kind words!
I completely agree with you Jon most of the performances were awful I especially hated the performance of Benny and The Jets
Me too! When he started doing that jazz rendition of Bennie and the Jets, I thought I was going to die. Everyone that performed on the show seem to have no sense of how important and special that music was; and still is. It was all about flash, and all about. “look at me”. So disappointing. So sad. Thank you for the great comments!
Yes the 1970s records had a vibe and a magic that’s not show business . It meant so much and it’s not a joke . I also remember in 1975 Evil Kinevil jumped a bunch of London red double decker buses ! Incredible event of the time . This took place at Wembley Stadium and I think Elton performed the Captain Fantastic lp there the same year . Without Dee and Nigel ?
I love that you recall, Evel Knievel! That was such a big part of my childhood and Americana. I didn’t know he was popular in Britain as well. How interesting how pop culture affects different parts of the world. Thanks for watching.
I really haven't cared too much for Elton John's music since Rock of the Westies. I wouldn't want him or any musician to feel they had to stay trapped in a genre; he grew in a musical direction I don't really like. I still listen to my favorite Elton John music, my kid grew up listening to it and some became his music, too. I'm remembering a bit from an early interview of Elton John, where he said something about really wanting to be famous, and that's what drove the over-the-top costumes and behavior. This Gershwin Award show perhaps played to that diva-esque person that Elton John is, the persona that is so flashy that Bernie, Davey, Nigel, Dee, and all the others are overlooked. Perhaps the show wasn't intended to showcase the music of Elton John, but the persona of Elton John.
Hi Holly. Thank you for the excellent and very insightful comments. You really nailed it. You said things that I felt but couldn’t find a way to say 😊. Thank you. I want to encourage you to take another listen to “blue moves“. If you like “rock of the Westies“ I think he will really find some gems in that album. It took me a few listens to figure it out, but now I consider it his last great masterpiece. If you remove the instrumental songs, it really is one of his greatest albums, compositionally and lyrically. I was so shocked when “a single Man“ came out. It was just void of any of that magic that had colored his earlier albums. For me, that album was the end. There have been some great tracks sprinkled through the years since then, but never has he touched that greatness again. Thanks again for the great comments!
@@JonBlackstoneYes, I will take another listen to "Blue Moves". I haven't listened to it since it came out and I didn't really care for it. I didn't even buy it after listening to someone else's copy. However, with 40+ years of (hopefully) growth, I might have a different opinion. Thanks for encouraging me to give it another chance.
I stopped my deep dive after Rocknof the Westies. I try and appreciate BLUE Moves and I d I do love the collab with Luciano pavorotti (sp)
It's good to have you give us a sounding board for the work, Joe.
Agree with your comments they could have had much better artists covering the great Elton material but this show is typical of the stupid times we live in. But to be fair it seems like Elton and Bernie approve of this crap show so I guess I will just listen to the old records and enjoy them as they still are great.
Thank you for these great comments. I think you encapsulated it in your sentence “stupid times we live in”. Only true music fans understand how people like you and I feel about this. To watch the audience at the tribute so excited about what they were witnessing, was so strange to me. Watching all these people so thrilled about some thing that was turning my stomach. I guess we weren’t born for these times? As one of the other viewers commented, there is a lot great music out there; but that’s not what’s being pushed by the major record labels. You have to dig for it to find it, but thank God it’s out there. Nothing about this “tribute“ felt inspired or remarkable. Thank you again for your great comments!
You didn't ruffle my feathers. It's more important to Elton to be accepted by the celebrities of today. Unfortunately, that's how he's going to be remembered by me. I love his 70s catalog minus Victim of love, but there's not much after that. He could have been remembered almost right next to the Beatles as far as the music is concerned. I'm going to remember him as a self absorbed egomaniac. It's more important to him to be accepted by the celebrities of today it seems. His fans from the past aren't that important. I had no desire to see his farewell concert either. It's more production than music.
Very well put! I completely agree with you. He could have been remembered as The Beatles of the 70s if he hadn’t become such a clown. He’ll never be respected as he should be because he’s ruined his own legacy. Thanks for the great comment. Thanks for watching!
Agree 💯!
And I have to repeat myself: brilliant video!
I thought Metallica did "their" thing... though I found Lars ' s drumming quite "invasive" and therefore annoying and disrupting the song altogether...
Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts. This is been an interesting experiment; to speak, so honestly about this “tribute”. It seems like a lot of people agree with my assessment. Thanks for watching!
I agree that the 1970s was Elton John's peak performance and song writing decade. If I had to choose my 5 favorite albums of all time, Goodbye Yellow Brick Road is always the first one that comes to mind. The other 4 would be The Beatles Abby Road, Aqualung by Jethro Tull, Sheer Heart Attack by Queen and All the World's a Stage by Rush. There are likely hundreds of other albums that I could include in my top 5 but Goodbye Yellow Brick Road will always be my #1 choice.
Hey there thanks for the great comments! I can’t argue with your top five list. Those are all incredible albums. I always have a tough time choosing a favorite Beatles album though. I tend to bounce between Revolver, the White album, and Abbey Road. however, after the 2017 remix of Sergeant Peppers; I’ve grown to love that album in a new way. That album always sounded very murky to me in the past; because of the complicated way they had to record it. The new mix has just brought incredible life and brilliance to that album. Anyway, I’m rambling now. Just wanted to say thanks for the great comments!
@@JonBlackstone It's a pleasure chatting with a fellow Elton John fanatic. I also meant to comment about the Here and There album. I remember buying it in September of 1976 only 2 months after I saw Elton in concert in Pontiac Michigan. I was blown away how powerful the opening songs of Funeral for a Friend/Love Lies Bleeding sounded. I was disappointed that they only included the first 5 songs of the New York and London concerts. Especially with John Lennon making a guest appearance at the New York show. They finally rereleased it about 20 years later with the full concerts. If they had done that when it was first released in the mid 70's, I think it would have been as big a seller as two other successful live albums at the time, Wings Over America and Frampton Comes Alive.
@@canadianfortrump4057 I couldn’t agree with you more about the here and there album! Both of the live albums you mentioned were so exciting and Elton’s could’ve been equally so if it had been done right. You probably remember at the time that the album was considered kind of a throwaway; it was considered a contractual obligation album. I fell in love with that album the moment it came out; and I continue to thrill to it to this day. Thanks for the great comments again. I can tell you and I are like two peas in a pod. I also appreciate that you’re a Trump fan. I happen to be an American Poilievre fan! If you’re ever in the Seattle area, contact me, I’d love to have coffee with you.
@@canadianfortrump4057 by the way have you watched my episode about the Elton John band? All the tracks I play are from the here and there album. In fact, I’m about to re-release the episode in high definition for the first time. I’m happy to give you the link so you can watch it before I release it. The Elton John Band 1970-75 - A Celebration of Musical Excellence
ruclips.net/video/C2Lus__hGts/видео.html
@@JonBlackstone Thanks Jon, I watched the whole episode and it was great. You must be a top notch musician yourself if you've worked with Dee Murray. If you produce any videos about The Beatles and Rolling Stones I'd be interested in seeing those as well. Keep up the good work!!
You just said everything I feel about The Gershwin awards and the Rocket Man Movie, too much "Celebrity", too much " Broadway". The only good performance was by Brandi Carlile. Elton's music is so IMPORTANT and SPECIAL to me, most of the artist's did not do it justice. I really agree with your analysis, The Rocket Man Movie a fantasy??? dance numbers???? I must have walked into the wrong movie, where was the Elton John Band members, it was too self centered. The only part of the movie I liked is when he met Bernie for the first time.
I couldn’t agree more! Watching Gus Dudgeon playing back Love Lies Bleeding reveals how important this music is to so many people. But Elton seems to be last person to understand how important his music was. Everything he does these days only makes people take him less seriously. I honestly don’t think he understands why his 70s music will live forever; otherwise he wouldn’t cheapen it by giving it a Broadway treatment in the movie and in this Gershwin show. Mainly I feel sorry for Davey and Nigel. Even though they could never admit it I know they are embarrassed by who Elton is today. Everytime he presents one of those classic songs as a joke it’s like a slap in the face to Dee, Davey, Nigel, Paul Buckmaster and Gus Dudgeon. Thanks for your comments!
By the way I have a job at Wembley Stadium tomorrow morning into the day . Don’t feel excited about it and didn’t think of it until a minute ago. The Capital Summer Ball with all kinds of pop bands . I wonder who ?
You are not wrong at all. I watched this event as well and felt the same. I too was disappointed with the snubbing of Nigel. Very odd.
It seems that a lot of people feel the same way. I didn’t know what people would think of my comments, but most people are on the same page. I appreciate you letting me know your own feelings. Thank you for watching!
Hi Jon, No, Thank you!
Yes,I always notice
the photos that you use. There were some really early ones that were brilliant this time. Last night I watched the live performance from Hammersmith Odeon London 1974 did not realise that that was available on You tube, absolutely fantastic.
Can't remember if I was there or not on that night but did attend , those concerts. initially I'd seen a clip of white Christmas from the same concert which was hilarious.
I know what you mean about the feelings I feel exactly the same.❤❤❤
I’m so glad they filmed that Hammersmith show! It’s really the only decent concert footage from that era. I wish they would release it with a remixed soundtrack so that we could enjoy it at home.
Sorry: you would NOT hear lennon-McCartney songs interpreted like that! Not very appealing! Great songs interpreted by not very great musicians. Jon, spot on again! You have shared with me so many things I really never knew I missed, and for your sharing, I Thank You!
Thank you again for the great comments! I really appreciate hearing from you!
Hi Jon
This was embarrassing. It makes me sick to see what's become of Elton. The Elton that we admired has been ruined by his desire to be cool.
I couldn’t agree more! The people that he collaborate with now are so below him it’s just ridiculous. What in the world is he doing with Britney Spears and Dua Lipa?!! It seems like a pathetic desire to remain relevant to a generation, who wouldn’t know good music if it hit them over the head. It’s not their fault; it’s the music industry that is turned into a garbage factory. It’s just sad that Hilton has decided to associate himself with such lowbrow stuff. Thanks for the great comments!
I absolutely agree with you about Rocket Man´s movie. For me it´s a bunch of garbage. I was suposed to watch a movie about Elton´s and Bernie´s life, not a Broadway´s Theater
I couldn’t agree more. The thing that was so strange was they didn’t use the original recordings; which reveals Elton doesn’t understand that his band’s work on those recordings was a major part of what made those songs so important. Instead of hearing those incredible recordings we were forced to listen to unremarkable remakes sung by an unremarkable singer while people danced around. I don’t know a single person who liked that movie. It was torture to sit through. Who wants to waste 2 hours suffering through that? Thanks for your great comments!
Wow! First, I always enjoy your programs, Jon, but in this case, I disagree with your comments about this show, which I thought was fabulous. Moreover, I think, at 77, that Elton sounds great and I literally was moved to tears by his beautiful rendition of “Mona Lisas and Mad Hatters.” I also love a lot of his post 1990 stuff when he was finally clean and sober, which saved his life. The songs, “The One,” “The Bridge,” “Made in England,” “Believe” and so many others are fabulous. Getting back to the Gershwin show, I thought there should have been more focus on the band, especially Nigel. I love Davey, but I thought he put himself out front a little too much, but that is total nitpicking. Reading your comments and of the many others who agreed with you, I thought I was hearing about a totally different show because I absolutely loved the one I saw. The Elton John fans I know through social media absolutely loved the show as well. And Jacob Lusk did the best cover of “Bennie and the Jets” that I have ever heard. Then the cherry on top, Elton’s wonderful rendition of “Your Song” with Bernie at the piano melted my heart. Elton’s voice is still fabulous, in my opinion, as is his playing. I love the lower timbre. It is more powerful and resonant and, unlike some other icons like Paul McCartney, Billy Joel and Sting, to me, Elton’s voice remains strong and vibrant while those I mentioned have trouble sustaining many notes. So while I love your stuff, Jon, I strongly disagree with your assessment of the Gershwin tribute and of Elton and Bernie’s work post 1975.
Hi Lillian, thanks for commenting! As I said, in the video, I know some people only came to know Elton John with the lion King; and for those people the change in his voice and style of his music might not have the same effect as it does for those who experienced him in the 1970s. As you can tell by the comments, most viewers did not like this show or the presentation of the songs. In fact,l yours is only one of three comments I received from people who enjoyed it. I think it’s really important to recognize that Elton is not the same artist that he once was. At the time of his golden age, he was influenced by people like Leon Russell, Ray Charles, the band, Bob Dylan, the Rolling Stones, the Beatles, I could go on and on. Those were the artist that inspired Elton in the 1970s. The music that inspires Elton today are people like Dua Lipa, Britney Spears, the British boy band “blue” and a host of modern artists, who I think are mediocre at best. I firmly believe it’s his greatest fault that he continues to celebrate music that is so far below his great catalog. I think it’s clear there are two kinds of fans; those who love Elton the person; and those who love Elton solely for his music. I just don’t relate to who he is anymore; that’s why I had no interest in his last tour. I am strictly s fan of Elton when he was a serious singer, songwriter in league with the great songwriters of the 20th century. The Elton of today is more like a modernist Liberace; as opposed to the legendary artist he was in the 70s. His 70s music is what people will remember centuries from now which is made obvious by the fact that every song in the final tour and Gershwin show were from his 70s catalog (with few exceptions). I understand some people like his music after 1976; but it’s clearly his 70s music that is his legacy and will stand the test of time. Having said all that I’m happy for those who can enjoy his entire catalog. I just wish the Gershwin show had been more reflective of his artistry as opposed to his flamboyant personality and that of the young pop stars he admires so much. Thanks for watching!
You're not crazy, it all seemed like they were acting. I don't care that most of them were flamboyant or anything but they need to sing the songs properly at least. The only one I liked was the metallica performance. And obviously elton's performance.
Thanks for letting me know. And thank you for watching!
Jon, you’re really spot on, mostly terrible, all magic is gone in those performances, more show than magic
Thanks so much for the comments! I confess it surprised me how many people seem to agree with my feelings about the show. In fact, I’ve only had a couple people that seem to enjoy it. Thanks a lot for watching!
This is a random question, related to Elton but not this particular video. Have you thought of doing a video review of the Sgt Zippo album? I only heard about it recently. I had no idea there was an "unreleased first album" in the archives, which saw the light of day two years ago. I'm really fascinated by this. I think it's an excellent album, at least for its time in 1967. But Elton's manager had incredible foresight to see that the style of music was too much of a trend, and told Elton to go back and record something more original. I'm not a huge fan of Empty Sky, but you can hear the seeds of Elton's 70's heyday in that album. Anyway, I'd love to hear your thoughts about the Sgt Zippo album, and what might have been if it had been released in 1967.
Thanks for your question! I confess I don’t like anything Elton recorded before Empty Sky; and I only enjoy a few tracks from that album. The stuff from the Zippo album (and other tracks from that time) have a very corny, immature, 60s psychedelic style I don’t care for. All those old tracks in the Jewels box set are unlistenable to me. I was shocked he and Bernie released those tracks as they’ve always talked about how embarrassing their early songs were. I appreciate the question!
I completely agree, watched the evening celebration, not good.
It seems like based on the comments everyone agrees. I’m surprised I was afraid people we’re gonna disown me! Thank you so much for the kind words!
Here's the greatest thing about Elton john. Every single one of his singles has a b side that has never, never, never ever been released on an album. I would love to see a compilation of all these b size. However maybe not. This just goes to show you that someone who really loves music can put another song on the flip side of the singles. Remember flip sides? There are a lot of boneheads like celebrities or whatever they come out with one song not even a song for the flip side because it's downloaded on whatever. I miss real media. Looks like it's making a comeback. Even audio cassettes are coming back. So keep rolling with what you got thank you.
Also - can you imagine how all that money can ruin a person ? He was my idol in 76 or so . When he came out-radio dropped him . I waited 4 yrs for 21 at 33, then he was ok again . After that ,I kept A Single Man for years - just thru it out lately- he's a grouchy old lady now .
“Grouchy old lady”. You made my day. Thanks for watching!
Hi Jon, another fabulous video! I completely agree with you. It's very interesting to see this. I thought the same about the film. I was upset that it was not true to life. I can't see the point otherwise.
And as for what do you think when you think about Elton John? glasses!😮😖
It does look as if This did devalue Elton and Bernie. I do hope that the Disney documentary will not follow this theme😢
I love your passion and sentiment❤🥰
I love what you wrote! I’m so glad you noticed the comment by Nicki Minaj. When you look at the musical stars of today it’s really quite pathetic. To hear Nicki Minaj refer to her music as “iconic” just reveals how out of touch today’s pop stars are. I could go on and on!
Joni was having a dig at Elton's character in her new lyrics to "I'm Still Standing". He knew that, for sure, and took it in good spirits (or appeared to). At least it was something unexpected (although not particularly outstanding). I agree with everything you say, though. Elton doesn't seem to have a clue what made him great, and, yes, his celebrity has indeed taken over from the rich musical legacy of his early years. His voice is really hard to listen to these days (and has increasingly been so for several decades). Peachtree Rd and Captain And The Kid are both decent later albums, and the AI versions i have made with his younger seventies voice, makes the world of difference. It is worth trying that out if you haven't already. Yes, i found the younger artists tributes quite cringe inducing, and everything, including Elton's own musical contribution, fails to scratch the surface of what made those songs great initially.
I really appreciate what you wrote. You covered some things that I left out. I do like a few of his more recent albums, even though his voice has changed so much. It’s mainly because of the strength of the songs. The last album I really enjoyed was “songs from the West Coast “. I do like a few songs from “captain in the kid“. I find this difficult to say, but I do not like a single song from any albums he’s released since then. There’s something about his music today that sounds uninspired to me. It almost sounds like he’s on autopilot as a songwriter. I just don’t feel any spark or imagination in his new material. But I have to say it’s the change in his voice that makes him so hard for me to listen to now. There’s just nothing left of that beautiful voice he once had. I would be curious to listen to some of the AI versions you’ve created if you send me a link. Thank you so much for watching!
Jon, could not agree with you more. What a tragedy to celebrate such an amazing body of work in such a terrible way. Thankfully I g lot to see Elton a few times in the 70’s (also saw in the 80’s, 90’s and 00’s) but nothing matched the 70’s work. The artists at this show were horrible. I so appreciate your other videos on Elton and the band showing how great they were.
Thank you Mike! I only got to see him once in the 1970s; and it was with the later band. But I did get to see the original lineup on the 1984 tour. I’m really thankful I got to see them. But more than anything I’m so thankful I got to grow up when such incredible music was being released. I will treasure those recordings forever. Thanks for the great comments and thank you for watching!
Hello there Jon. I feel the same way. In fact I'll go a step further. I know that Elton John is still alive, but he has changed so much, in EVERY WAY, that I feel like he died a long time ago. Remember back in the 70's when he said he didn't want to end up like Elvis doing shows in Las Vegas. Elton John made me cringe with those Las Vegas shows that he did. And I think it tarnished his career. I don't understand his lack of shame and self consciousness over going on stage and singing with his horrible voice that is torturous to listen to. If I were in his shoes i would have retired immediately after wining the Oscar for "Can you feel the love tonight." I wonder what Elton's reaction would have been if back in the 70's some Mystic would have shown him himself singing live with that horrible voice, overweight in his 50s 60s and 70s. I think he would not have believed it. It seems to me that Elton John has some kind of psychological disorder when it comes to getting attention. He will do almost anything for attention --- EVEN LIE !!!! Look at how he lied all throughout that awful Rocket man movie. He lied about his mother, he made his stepfather who, was good to him look like some lowlife. Dick James' family was furious over the dishonest way Dick James was portrayed in that horrible movie. He lied about the nature of his relationship with his wife Renata. He made her look like an idiot, and he deservedly got sued over it. Worst of all he lied to his fans and insulted our intelligence. Remember the absurd scene in the movie when he was deciding to change his name and he saw a poster of John Lennon and that's it my last will be John! Every E.J. fan knows he took Long John Baldry's name for his last name. How insulting to his fans! Elton John will do anything for attention. I liked him as a person in the 70's -- I dislike him now. I have no respect for him! I still love listening to his 70s catalogue, but I feel like he died a long time ago.
Take care Jon.
I have to say your comments echo my feelings so perfectly I could have written the same thing. In fact, you did a better job of expressing my distain for who he has become today. I didn’t want to be too harsh and scare people away; but the truth is I feel exactly the same way you do. And I know exactly what you’re talking about in each different scenario you mentioned. As a young fan, I can’t tell you how shocked I was when I listened to “a single Man”. For me that’s when something died within hum. Even though he has done some excellent work since then, he lost something that he never fully retrieved. I believe a lot of it has to do with his obsession with his sexuality. I also think it’s connected with his partner David becoming his manager. As soon as that happened, literally everything Elton says and does is saturated in his sexuality. I have nothing against that whatsoever. But when an artist focuses all their attention on something other than their art, then that great artistic spirit suffers. Elton has not been solely focused on his art for a long long time. And his never ending obsession with young pop (mediocre) music stars has been a great detriment to him. I don’t know if it’s a desperate desire to remain relevant? Heaven knows his work in the 70s was so fantastic there’s no way he won’t be remembered. I would say his behavior over the past 20 years has probably lessened the chances he will be remembered. It’s certainly made it more difficult to take him seriously. But like you, I absolutely love his music from that great golden era. And I do believe that his best work will be rediscovered and celebrated centuries from now. Thanks so much for the great comments!
I was hoping the movie would have focussed on how he writes and how he coped - or didn’t - with the astronomical rise of his stardom (definitely with his issues with being gay and addiction) over the whole Hollywood thing. Also felt that there needed to be much more abiut the role of the band and Bernie and even his management - more like a documentary in some ways
I agree with you. Some thing that’s always frustrated me about Elton is that he constantly says he doesn’t like to focus on the past and always likes to look ahead. On the contrary, I wish he would focus on the past. Maybe then he might remember some thing about the great artist he once was. To focus on what’s ahead isn’t exactly a wise idea these days. Thank you so much for watching!
I did enjoy the Joni Mitchell performance, and like what she changed, but yeah not what we needed for a tribute in a show that was also shining a light on Bernie, only Bernies original chorus getting sung out in that moment. Had she not adjusted the words, would the cover have worked for you? A very interesting cover, and I did like it, but don't disagree with your concerns. I was also not on board with most of the other performances. I liked Brandi's performance, which may have been the only one that did anything for me. Thank goodness he performed himself towards the end though. Couple of little slip ups here and there, but that was still a nice moment.
How do you feel about all the covers that have been done in albums like Two Rooms, Revamp, and the other one, whatever it was. Goodbye Yellow Brick Road too. I don't think anyone's been able to cover him very well at all. He's always struggled writing for other people, and I don't think it's because he's chuned up a terrible song, it's just that most of his songs seem to need him at the helm, especially early on.
Like you, I hated my first viewing of Rocketman, but it did grow on me a bit, the moment I knew what I was getting. However have only seen it about 3 times, and had I been in love with it it would have been seen by me many more times.
Thanks so much for watching! I would’ve been fine if Joni sang the correct lyrics. It’s not that I didn’t like her version musically; I just found it totally inappropriate to write her own lyrics. The show is supposed to be honoring Elton and Bernie and she turned it into some thing that focused of the spotlight on herself. I just don’t think that’s cool. I don’t care for any of the cover albums that have been put out. To me the recordings he did it in the 70s are so iconic and so special that it’s pointless to do cover versions of those songs. I feel the same way about the Beatles. Those recordings were so unique, and so special that a Cover Version is just pointless. I wish I could agree with you on the movie; I found it so distasteful, I almost walked out. And after it was over, I wish I had walked out. I just don’t like who he is as an person anymore. He seems obsessed with his celebrity status, and the LGBT movement more than his legacy as a musician. The same thing happened to John Lennon. Once he became an activist his music became uninteresting for me. To be honest I’ve never cared much about the people who make the much as I care about their music. Anyway thanks for the great comments!
This is so depressing, people change as they age-usually for the worse .
I heartily agree. Thanks for watching!
I was just glad to still see Joni singing ... But as for the rest of the jokers it was a bad joke. I hope Elton got a laugh out of the theatrics .. we were the lucky ones to see Elton s music back in the 70's , and to watch this ficasso was a painfully waste if time...we can feel we were the lucky ones to have witness his music firsthand in our lives of those times when his music enveloped around and was such a part of real musical history being made. So sad music is not made the way it used to be .. and Elton seemed exactly the way you portrayed him so I wouldn't feel to badly Jon ! ( That was then and this is him now ) Our blooming music of those times have definitely wilted
Thanks for the great comments! I wish Alton would stop focusing so much on trying to remain relevant. An artist with his catalog will never have to worry about being relevant. It’s certainly not worth stooping to the level of collaborating with Britney Spears and Dua Lipa. It seems to me Elton is his own worst enemy.
I'm sorry, but I prefer not to see or hear anything from Elton John and Bernie Taupin post Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy. It's when they were young, successful and talented and I was young also. Those are the memories I hold on to -- their music brings back those memories. It's pretty much how I feel about all musicians when they get old. They've long since lost their talent and I don't feel any obligation to pretend I'm still a fan of whatever stuff they're churning out. They have every right to do what they want to do but I don't want any part of it.
I've thought about it a lot and hated that Gershwin concert so much 🤣 One of my versions is that Elton hates his '70s version because he competed with everyone and couldn't beat himself from 1970 to 1977. For example, how can you spend all your money and time creating the worst quality videos of every song on the Fox album without saving the live version of “60 Years On” in normal quality😵 He wants us to be excited by the way he sings now and say, oh Elton you are so much better singer and you play so much better now than in the 70s 🤣And Berny wants us to love Sacrifice😅
Wow I can tell you’ve been noticing the same stuff that I have. The “video album” for The Fox is awful; and no matter how many times I hear Bernie say they’re doing their “best work” today it can’t change the fact that their 70s material is clearly their best. Thanks for the great comments. We could talk for hours. 😎
Ur not crazy. This show blew chunks.
Thanks for letting me know. I particularly enjoyed your use of the phrase “blew chunks”. Thanks for watching!
i agree.
Thank you for letting me know. I really appreciate it. Thanks for watching!
Elton in the 70’s was so much different than all the years after. His voice was edgy and tough. Even in his soft high note songs he had an edge to him that was all rock n roll. His piano playing and writing was more inventive and organic. This award show was more drag show than honoring the greatness of Bernie’s lyrics and Elton’s musicianship. Quite a shame….but as you say John, EJ and BT appeared happy with it.
The 1970s were very very special in many many ways and now at 57 I’m a very grumpy geezer or do I just think a lot of new stuff is rubbish ? Monty Python was classic , Evil Kinevil was classic with the 1974 snake river canyon , the sex pistols , Elton and yeah Dee Murray was such a great bass player , not sure what I like from today’s music ? Saw Elton live at Watford in 2022 and it was a fantastic gig and he didn’t stop . He did some remixes with piano and backing tracks that were classy
Wow, I had forgotten about Evel Knievel, jumping the snake river canyon! Thanks for bringing back. Such a fun memory. And thank you for your great comments!
@@JonBlackstone yeah Snake River canyon is in my memory forever . Then he jumped in a steam powered rocket ? I mean what ? Then parachutes down? Really ?
I agree with you. I've been a fan of Elton's for about 50 years now. I hate what they did to those songs and I hated the Elton John movie. I don't know what's going on with Elton. I started questioning his judgment when he raved about Brittany Spears's horrible remake (or sampling?) of Tiny Dancer. It's a monstrosity, IMO.
Several years ago, I saw video of Lady Gaga and Elton performing some of his songs together and I loved it. They sang and played well and honoured the songs. I thought that was a beautiful tribute.
You put that very well. I showed a photo of Elton with Britney, but I couldn’t bring myself to mention the atrocity of their “collaboration“. As I mentioned in my video, he talked about the boy band “Blue” and raved about how brilliant they were. That was sort of a turning point for me. I realized that Elton is a fan of pop music regardless of how bad it is. That served him well in the 70s because popular music was largely excellent at the time. He was influenced by incredible artists who were also popular artists. He continues to be influenced by pop artists; and unfortunately today’s pop artists are absolutely awful. He also seems to be an LGBT activist these days. Remember when John Lennon became a peace and antiwar activist? It did not serve his music well (some time in New York city, mind games). The same has happened with Elton. Whenever an artist becomes an activist the cause becomes the core of their artistic output. I think it’s been deadly for every artist who ever became an activist of any movement. Thankfully John Lennon abandoned that and put out a few redeeming albums near the end of his career. I don’t see that happening with Elton. Another thing that was detrimental for him was when his partner David became his manager. Since then I’ve noticed that everything Elton does is saturated in his new “cause”. I have nothing against the cause; I just don’t want to hear about it constantly. It’s boring, and in my view unnecessary. Anyway, I’m rambling now. Just wanted to. Thank you for your great comments!
@@JonBlackstone Well said. I agree with it all.
Spot on! While I think the talent is still there, he seems more concerned about being relevant than creating great music. For someone with his genius ability, it is sad that he sees the music as secondary. I'm glad I didn't stumble across this "event". It looks truly cringe worthy.
I didn't watch this show, but the clips you provide are the ick of most award shows and I'm glad I didn't watch it. It doesn't seem like the show was about honoring the body of work created by Bernie & Elton, plus the musicians in the EJ band. It seemed like just another award show. I appreciate the Monty Python clips!
So glad you enjoyed the Monty python!
Oh wow, Jon. Everything you said. I was especially irritated that EJ didn't even mention Davey and Nigel. Nigel was sitting back there looking useless. It was such a disappointing show! I had wanted to see the farewell tour, but after hearing EJ singing lately, I am glad I didn't. I will just enjoy listening to the old albums instead. Concerning the movie, I really didn't like it at all, for the same reasons you said. I did wonder about a movie Davey was supposed to be planning which would have more focus the band. Do you know anything about that?
Hi Martha! Thanks for the great comments! Obviously, you know I feel the same way as you do. I’ve been hearing the same reports that Davey’s son is directing a documentary about the band titled “pillars of Hercules“. It’s my understanding that it’s about the band as much as it is about Elton. I’m very excited about it but I haven’t heard anything within a year. Hopefully we will see that movie one day and the Elton John band will get some of the appreciation. It’s so much deserved. Good to hear from you!
Thing is it wasn’t just me it was all kids in England. Evil Kinevil was a huge thing , like a real life super hero . Another thing is Elton played Wembley in 1975 and I have read he played a lot of the Captain Fantastic lp . I have friends older than me and they loved seeing Chaka Khan Rufus that day , soul music was huge in London. Apparently this was the day when Joe Walsh joined the Eagles ? Or jammed with them or ? I’m working at Wembley today ha ha I wonder . Back to 1975 I remember walking down the high street with my mum and grandmother and we went into a couple of record shops . There were Captain Fantastic posters everywhere, I remember thing who is this ? What is this ?
I think Elton never really wanted to make art exclusively. It has always been important to him that music simply brings people joy and in this context it can also be simple.
And he was/is someone who always wants to try new things.
Well, the award really was garbage!
I also stopped listening to Elton's new music at some point, but after such a long time I no longer expected him to pick up where he left off.
We are also dealing here with a celebrity who has been on stage for almost 55 years. There's hardly anyone you can compare him to, because there are very few. This is a life! And life is always changing, otherwise we'd all be robots!
🎯
Thanks for watching!
After 1974 I think Elton changed big time. Maybe the drugs and alcohol or big ego or whatever. I thinks it's a crying shame he didn't celebrate the band that launched his star back in the day. I really don't pay any attention to garbage music of today and this show is embarrassing to watch. The movie Rocket Man I did turn it off after 10 mins. Your not the only one who thinks this is ridiculous. These millionaire stars are in there own little world it seems.
I think you stated that very well. It seems to me the biggest problem with Elton is that his highest priority seems to be his status as a gay entertainer. I think his partner David has a lot to do with that being that he’s his manager. It seems like everything Alton does is saturated in his own sexuality. I can’t think of any other classic artist that acts that way. None of us have any problem with his sexuality; but when it’s infused in every aspect of everything he does, it’s just become so tiring. I think that’s more important to Alton than his art or anything else. I also think that’s why his music isn’t taken as seriously as it should be. Anyway, thank you for the great comments!
Type in Elton John land / Bennie and the jets You will then see my tour of Eltons childhood homes . ... Also that’s my Bennie cover .
Well its really a new low the Elton 'Click' trotting out soul less versions of great songs, Elton John has really thrown his legacy down the gutter. Awful stuff.
I couldn’t agree more. And I appreciate you letting me know you’re on the same side. Thank you for watching!
Holy Christ! I had no idea about this gawdawful tragedy. But this is what the suits wanted - their new hopeful $tar$ getting as much pub as they could. So they got them on tv, you did a video about it and I watched that and responded to it. Remember, any pub is good pub... Jon, I like to say that Elton was my first musical love - he got me into actual music and away from The Partridge Family. As far as the industry goes, I read somewhere back iin the day that the beginning of the end for rock music was the wholly unexpected and tremendously surprising ultra-mega success of Frampton Comes Alive. If you had to pick one point out of a number of them spread out over a few years, that is the wakeup call to the suits that not only can they make money in the business of rock music, but they can make a s__tload of money. Enter targeted marketing techniques and the subsequent dividing up of rock into sub-categories along with bands that fit a subcategory. Think of what would happen today if an unsigned band presented Abbey Road to a bunch of labels. They'd be told that they were unmarketable because they have no audience that can clearly be targeted and subsequently laughed out of the building.
I agree with every word you said. I have also heard the Frampton album was when the corporations realized what a cash cow music can be. It’s all been downhill from there. Thankfully they can’t take away the great music from the past!
I was going to see the artist Bernie in Denver, tomorrow at a fancy gallery, but am afraid it will be too hoity toity for me. I dunno. The prints are 1200 to start. You know, same as rent. I garnered the RSVP and I love thos guy's work. With respect, I'll leave it for the rich people.
Thanks for watching! I love your use of “hoity toity” to describe gallery event. When I was in Nashville I attended several events like that with famous people and celebrities. I came to the conclusion that famous artists, actors and politicians are no better than anyone else. The fact they’re talented or powerful doesn’t mean they’re particularly bright, intelligent, wise or interesting. I’d much rather spend an evening with family and friends. As a Nashville record label friend said after hanging around Madonna backstage at the Grammys; “her sh*t smells like everyone else’s”. Thanks again!
Jon, sadly this is part and parcel, why I have lost touch with Elton's latest stuff, such as the Lockdown Sessions and the Broadway stuff. I hated the Rocketman movie, it was more of a caricature of Elton, ironically a criticism levied about Elton's work by the "serious" rock and roll crowd since after MAtW. You are not crazy, this was just sad tbh.
Thanks for the great comments. Obviously I agree with everything you said. I used to be frustrated because it seem like Elton never got the respect that he deserved for his great work in the 1970s. But over time I’ve come to realize that it’s his own fault. it’s pretty hard to look back on his stellar work in the 1970s and see it performed by someone in a Donald Duck suit. I know it’s fun for Elton; but it’s going to the point where I just can’t take it anymore. The Gershwin show was just a debacle.
Regarding Rocketman the movie: It was the dumbest thing ever, making a movie about a iconic singer, but it sounds nothing like him, imagine if the Elvis or Queen movie sounded like that. They RUINED what could have been a great biopic, instead it sounded like a Broadway play.
I couldn’t agree more! You said it better than I did. Why they took that approach to the music is beyond my wildest imagination. It did nothing to cement Elton’s legacy; if anything it turned people off. I have not met one fan that thought that movie was good. I’ll tell you. I’m getting a lot of comments on this video and it’s really nice to know that people seem to feel the same way I do. Thank you so much for your comments!